Becoming Better Advocates for Your Health
Tuesday, July 22, 2014
2:00pm – 3:00pm
2
Speakers Today
Sonia Millsom, MPH
Vice President, Client Strategy
Leana Wen, MD, MSc
Director, Patient-Centered Care Research
Department of Emergency Medicine
The George Washington University
2 stories
 #1: Jerry
 #2: May
The problem
 Rising cost
 Unnecessary tests
 Growing disconnect
 More tests… but fewer answers
Pressures and consequences
 Lots of patients, little time
 “Defensive medicine”
 Overreliance on technology
 Medical training
 Misapplication of checklists
 “More is better”
Misdiagnosis
 100,000 deaths from medical errors per year
 Most medical errors are errors in diagnosis
 80%+ of diagnoses are made based on history
 10 seconds before the doctor interrupts
 What does this mean for diagnosis?
What can be done
 Healthcare system needs to be reformed
 Who is the system?
 We cannot wait
 “All medicine is personal”
The big question…
 How do we do this?
The patient’s
perspective
The provider’s
response &
responsibility
#1. Establish an active
partnership
 Set expectations
 Partner in your
decision-making
 Ask to share in the
thought process
 Set expectations
 Be transparent
 Involve patients in
decision-making
 Don’t assume
 Explain your thought
process
Patients Providers
#2. Focus on the diagnosis
 Know why it’s
important
 Ask for:
◦ Most likely dx
◦ Other possibilities
 Assure your doctor,
OK not to be 100%
sure
 Explain why it’s
important
 Provide every pt with:
◦ Working dx
◦ Differential dx
 It’s OK not to be 100%
sure
Patients Providers
#3. Listen
 Tell a good story
◦ Story, not symptoms
◦ Begin at the beginning
◦ Use your own voice
 Come prepared
◦ Write it down
◦ Practice
◦ Bring an advocate
 Really listen
◦ “No questions asked”
◦ “With our whole being”
◦ Beyond the chief
complaint
◦ Will save time
 Encourage preparation
Patients Providers
#4. Understand every test
ordered
 Ask about dx before
tests are done
 Understand why a test
is being ordered
◦ What is it looking for?
◦ What are risks?
◦ What are alternatives?
◦ What happens if neg?
 Explain dx
 Ask yourself, for every
test:
◦ How will it change
management?
◦ Do I need it?
◦ How do I explain
risks/benefits?
Patients Providers
Will patient-centered care have an impact?
 Reduce:
◦ Unnecessary tests
◦ Cost
◦ Misdiagnoses
 Improve:
◦ Patient experience
◦ Physician happiness
◦ Healthcare system
 Right thing to do for our patients
Conclusions
 Lots of pressures leading to less-than-ideal
healthcare system
 We can make a difference, today
 Healthcare reform starts with all of us
 Final follow-up
Leana Wen, MD MSc
George Washington University
www.DrLeanaWen.com
www.whendoctorsdontlisten.com
@DrLeanaWen
Best Doctors, July 2014
16
Nearly one-third of the $2.7 trillion spent
each year on healthcare in the U.S. is
considered to be wasted dollars, according to
the landmark report “Diagnostic Errors: The Next
Frontier for Patient Safety.”
Cost Implication of Diagnostic Errors
“Healthcare System Wastes Up to $800 Billion a Year,” Reuters, Oct. 26, 2009.
Institute of Medicine. Best Care at Lower Cost: The Path to Continuously Learning Health Care in America. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2013.
Under-diagnosis, over-diagnosis and misdiagnosis contribute to wasted
healthcare dollars.
17
Survey of Patient Experience with Preventable Medical Errors
Has a preventable medical
error been made in your own
care, or that of a family
member?
Did the error have serious,
minor or no health
consequences?
34%
1%
65%
Yes
No
Don’t
Know 3%
10%
21%
Serious health
consequences
Minor health
consequences
No health
consequences
Kaiser Family Foundation – 2004 - National Survey on Consumers’ Experiences with Patient Safety and Quality Information
18
Challenges Facing Employers
Reduce direct and
indirect costs associated
with workplace health
challenges, including
short- and long-term
disability
Develop ongoing strategy
that fit current channels of
communication and strategy
Reduce costs
associated with absence
due to illness, estimated
at 2-3x more than drug
claims
Reduce risk of
misdiagnosis,
unwarranted surgery,
unnecessary drugs
and associated costs
Improve employee
attraction, satisfaction
and retention
19
Diagnostic Accuracy and the Triple Aim
Minimize the costs of
unnecessary
hospitalizations,
medications, treatments
and surgeries
Improve diagnostic and
treatment accuracy through
expert reviews of complex
and critical care cases
Provide virtual access to world-renowned medical experts to
confirm optimal clinical pathway
Better Member Experience
20
Best Doctors gave her confidence in her medical decision and
enabled her to become an empowered healthcare consumer.
“You are at risk for developing breast cancer.”
The Impact of an Expert Second Opinion
Let’s wait,
watch and see
what happens.
Try a hormone
therapy to
reduce your risk
of developing
breast cancer.
Remove the
breasts to prevent
the development
of breast cancer
A. 13% B. 45% C. 75%
WHAT’S THE CHANCE THAT
YOUR TREATMENT PLAN
NEEDS CORRECTING
FIND OUT…
IT MATTERS
22
Questions?
www.bestdoctors.com

Becoming Better Advocates for Your Health

  • 1.
    Becoming Better Advocatesfor Your Health Tuesday, July 22, 2014 2:00pm – 3:00pm
  • 2.
    2 Speakers Today Sonia Millsom,MPH Vice President, Client Strategy Leana Wen, MD, MSc Director, Patient-Centered Care Research Department of Emergency Medicine The George Washington University
  • 3.
    2 stories  #1:Jerry  #2: May
  • 4.
    The problem  Risingcost  Unnecessary tests  Growing disconnect  More tests… but fewer answers
  • 5.
    Pressures and consequences Lots of patients, little time  “Defensive medicine”  Overreliance on technology  Medical training  Misapplication of checklists  “More is better”
  • 6.
    Misdiagnosis  100,000 deathsfrom medical errors per year  Most medical errors are errors in diagnosis  80%+ of diagnoses are made based on history  10 seconds before the doctor interrupts  What does this mean for diagnosis?
  • 7.
    What can bedone  Healthcare system needs to be reformed  Who is the system?  We cannot wait  “All medicine is personal”
  • 8.
    The big question… How do we do this? The patient’s perspective The provider’s response & responsibility
  • 9.
    #1. Establish anactive partnership  Set expectations  Partner in your decision-making  Ask to share in the thought process  Set expectations  Be transparent  Involve patients in decision-making  Don’t assume  Explain your thought process Patients Providers
  • 10.
    #2. Focus onthe diagnosis  Know why it’s important  Ask for: ◦ Most likely dx ◦ Other possibilities  Assure your doctor, OK not to be 100% sure  Explain why it’s important  Provide every pt with: ◦ Working dx ◦ Differential dx  It’s OK not to be 100% sure Patients Providers
  • 11.
    #3. Listen  Tella good story ◦ Story, not symptoms ◦ Begin at the beginning ◦ Use your own voice  Come prepared ◦ Write it down ◦ Practice ◦ Bring an advocate  Really listen ◦ “No questions asked” ◦ “With our whole being” ◦ Beyond the chief complaint ◦ Will save time  Encourage preparation Patients Providers
  • 12.
    #4. Understand everytest ordered  Ask about dx before tests are done  Understand why a test is being ordered ◦ What is it looking for? ◦ What are risks? ◦ What are alternatives? ◦ What happens if neg?  Explain dx  Ask yourself, for every test: ◦ How will it change management? ◦ Do I need it? ◦ How do I explain risks/benefits? Patients Providers
  • 13.
    Will patient-centered carehave an impact?  Reduce: ◦ Unnecessary tests ◦ Cost ◦ Misdiagnoses  Improve: ◦ Patient experience ◦ Physician happiness ◦ Healthcare system  Right thing to do for our patients
  • 14.
    Conclusions  Lots ofpressures leading to less-than-ideal healthcare system  We can make a difference, today  Healthcare reform starts with all of us  Final follow-up
  • 15.
    Leana Wen, MDMSc George Washington University www.DrLeanaWen.com www.whendoctorsdontlisten.com @DrLeanaWen Best Doctors, July 2014
  • 16.
    16 Nearly one-third ofthe $2.7 trillion spent each year on healthcare in the U.S. is considered to be wasted dollars, according to the landmark report “Diagnostic Errors: The Next Frontier for Patient Safety.” Cost Implication of Diagnostic Errors “Healthcare System Wastes Up to $800 Billion a Year,” Reuters, Oct. 26, 2009. Institute of Medicine. Best Care at Lower Cost: The Path to Continuously Learning Health Care in America. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2013. Under-diagnosis, over-diagnosis and misdiagnosis contribute to wasted healthcare dollars.
  • 17.
    17 Survey of PatientExperience with Preventable Medical Errors Has a preventable medical error been made in your own care, or that of a family member? Did the error have serious, minor or no health consequences? 34% 1% 65% Yes No Don’t Know 3% 10% 21% Serious health consequences Minor health consequences No health consequences Kaiser Family Foundation – 2004 - National Survey on Consumers’ Experiences with Patient Safety and Quality Information
  • 18.
    18 Challenges Facing Employers Reducedirect and indirect costs associated with workplace health challenges, including short- and long-term disability Develop ongoing strategy that fit current channels of communication and strategy Reduce costs associated with absence due to illness, estimated at 2-3x more than drug claims Reduce risk of misdiagnosis, unwarranted surgery, unnecessary drugs and associated costs Improve employee attraction, satisfaction and retention
  • 19.
    19 Diagnostic Accuracy andthe Triple Aim Minimize the costs of unnecessary hospitalizations, medications, treatments and surgeries Improve diagnostic and treatment accuracy through expert reviews of complex and critical care cases Provide virtual access to world-renowned medical experts to confirm optimal clinical pathway Better Member Experience
  • 20.
    20 Best Doctors gaveher confidence in her medical decision and enabled her to become an empowered healthcare consumer. “You are at risk for developing breast cancer.” The Impact of an Expert Second Opinion Let’s wait, watch and see what happens. Try a hormone therapy to reduce your risk of developing breast cancer. Remove the breasts to prevent the development of breast cancer
  • 21.
    A. 13% B.45% C. 75% WHAT’S THE CHANCE THAT YOUR TREATMENT PLAN NEEDS CORRECTING FIND OUT… IT MATTERS
  • 22.

Editor's Notes

  • #19 These are the nuts and bolts benefits, but remember, it’s actually about saving lives!
  • #21 Member: Female in her mid 50s has been diagnosed with Pleomorphic Lobular Carcinoma in Situ (LCIS) Case History: Member diagnosis was based on a breast biopsy following a recent abnormal mammogram. She was given three therapeutic options: (1) active surveillance, (2) hormone therapy to reduce chances of breast cancer or (3) bilateral prophylactic mastectomies Best Doctors Expert: Dr. Virgilio Sacchini, Breast Cancer Expert, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, Former Deputy Director of the Breast Department in the European Institute of Oncology Expert Findings: The expert confirmed the diagnosis of LCIS and presented new findings that suggest the member was at increased risk for developing breast cancer and recommended forward progression with surgery