SlideShare a Scribd company logo
8 s Contract Management / April 2004
This article is an extract from
Managing Complex Outsource
Projects by Gregory A. Garrett,
published by CCH Inc.,
Chicago 2004.
As more and more companies and
organizations conduct work on a multi-
national or global basis, the need to
define project management (PM) “best
practices” and leverage project man-
agement expertise globally becomes
greater. What organizations want is
to develop PM methodologies, based
upon proven processes to ensure
repeatable and measurable results,
which meet or exceed their customers
demanding expectations.
Many companies or organizations
have developed internal PM expertise,
typically within their professional
services department or supply chain
management organizations. Likewise,
many companies have taken the time
to develop PM best practices databases
to facilitate knowledge transfer within
their organizations. Most companies
hope to repeat project best practices,
if they were proven successful some-
where else in the organization.
According to the Center for Business
Practices (CBP), the research arm of
PM Solutions and a U.S.-based project
management firm, consistency and
resource problems top the list of con-
cerns facing project managers. These
results come from CBP’s 2003 survey
of 1,000 project professionals and
senior-level executives from such
industries as manufacturing, health
care, and information technology. CBP’s
survey found the largest project man-
agement challenge was developing a
consistent approach to managing pro-
jects (23.9 percent of the respondents).
Following close behind was the concern
over resource allocation (19.7 percent)
and managing too many projects or
the wrong projects (16.9 percent).
GREGORY A. GARRETT, CPCM, PMP,
is vice president and general manager,
U.S. federal government programs for
Lucent Technologies in Herndon, Virginia.
He is a member of NCMA’s Washington,
D.C., Chapter and received the Project
Management Excellence Award from
the Project Management Institute.
Send comments on this article to
cm@ncmahq.org.
A b o u t t h e A u t h o r
As projects are becoming increasingly complex,
professional project management is vital to
achieving successful results in both the public
and private business sectors.
BY GREGORY A. GARRETT
Global Project
Management:
Best Practices
Global Project
Management:
Best Practices
April 2004 / Contract Management s 9
The CBP survey also found that
companies implementing PM improve-
ments spent an average of $712,000 on
them annually, with most commonly
implemented improvements including:
s Software tools (77.9 percent),
s Methodology development
(69.1 percent), and
s Staff training (69.1 percent).
The survey also included other
insights in the area of project types,
project activities, and other areas,
such as
s Project complexity—51.7 percent
of the projects surveyed were con-
sidered complex or highly complex.
s Project management office (PMO)—
44.6 percent of the companies
surveyed had established a PMO
or PM Center of Excellence.
s Project portfolio management
(PPM)—Most companies surveyed
still had a low level of project
portfolio management maturity.
s Project performance measurements—
The metrics most commonly used by
the companies surveyed to assess value
are measured by improvements in
delivery dates (78.9 percent), bottom-
line economics (65.8 percent), and
product or service quality (57.9 percent).1
PM Methodology and Structure
The following best practices have
all been proven effective by numerous
organizations involved in managing
projects on a multi-national and/or
global business scale.
Methodology
Many large multi-national organizations
and companies have created a network
of project managers geographically
distributed in numerous countries
worldwide. The goal of most large
multi-national organizations and
companies is to meet or exceed their
customer’s business needs through
successful project results. Many com-
panies, including ABB, AT&T, Bechtel,
EDS, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Lucent
Technologies, NCR, Sun Microsystems,
USAA, and others; have developed
or have had outside consultants help
them create a high-level project
management methodology. Such PM
methodologies are usually composed
of standardized project management
processes, based upon industry best
practices and specific and tailored
processes proven successful for the
respective company.
A global project management
methodology should be a dynamic set
of processes that evolve as the industry
and company change to meet or exceed
its customers’ needs. Unfortunately,
some companies develop or purchase
a global PM methodology, but do not
take the time and effort to keep it
current and accurate. As a result,
some companies invest a lot of money
in the one-time development of such
methodologies, but do not truly reap
the long-term benefits. It is important
to remember that project management
methodologies, processes, best prac-
tices, and numerous tools and
techniques exist only as a means
to an end—meeting or exceeding
a customer’s needs, while achieving
desired company or organization
performance targets.
For a global project management
methodology to be truly successful
it must be (1) widely distributed
throughout the organization,
typically through multi-media (Web-
based, CD-ROM, and paper copies,
etc.), (2) widely acknowledged at all
levels of the organization, and (3)
routinely practiced by the project
management community within
the respective organization. The
International Standards Organization
(ISO) Standards for Project
Management 10006 provides a good
standardized outline of what process-
es and practices should be included
within global PM methodology.
Support Structure
In order to truly make project man-
agement globally successful within
an organization, there must be an
appropriate support structure. Clearly,
the level of support varies, based upon
numerous factors including the level
of PM maturity, project complexity,
degree of outsourcing, geographic
distribution, and project importance,
etc. The following items are usually
vital to ensure an appropriate project
management support structure exists
to successfully manage complex
outsourced projects worldwide.
s Executive sponsorship—A knowl-
edgeable, experienced, certified
project management executive,
who serves as a champion of the
project management discipline
within the company and externally.
s Global project management office
(GPMO)—A small but effective
team of highly experienced, trained,
and certified project management
professionals, who ensure the pro-
ject managers in the field have all
the resources, tools, training, and
support they need to get the job
done, including a global project
management methodology.
s Regional and/or local country
project management office (PMO)—
In addition, to the GPMO, there
should be a small but highly respon-
sive regional and/or local country
PMO to help support the local pro-
ject managers with more local- and
country-specific project needs, local
laws and regulations, customs, and
team mobilization support.
s Web-based PM best practices
(knowledge management)—As
much as possible, the best practices
from projects worldwide should be
documented and made easily avail-
able and key-word searchable to
all organization project managers.
s Project management networking—
Every available means should be
used to facilitate the networking
of project managers to share
expertise, including teleconferences,
video conferences, net-meetings,
shared electronic databases, Web
portals, and appropriate face-to-
face meetings.
10 s Contract Management / April 2004
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
Project
Name
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3
Project
Manager
Status
(Green,
Yellow, Red)
Project Net
Present
Value
(Revenue)
Project
Margin
Customer
Name
Project
Resource
(Hdct)
Customer
Strategic
Objective
Comments/
Key Notes
Key Projects Portfolio
Table 1.
s Accurate and real-time project-level
data—The organization should offer
an enterprisewide, globally accessi-
ble (24/7/365) information system,
which provides real-time status on
the placement of orders, for pur-
chasing products and services, and
the status of engineering, construc-
tion, manufacturing, shipping
installation, and testing.
Case Study #1
With more than 35,000 employees
in 100 countries, Sun Microsystems
(Sun) is performing project manage-
ment on a truly global scale. Within
Sun’s Services organization, Sun
Professional Services has the responsi-
bility for developing internal project
management expertise. Sun
Professional Services has a network
of about 500 project management
professionals. Project management
expertise with Sun Professional
Services is organized around its
primary competencies—the Project
Management Performance Model,
project quality activities, Customer
Loyalty Index (CLI), and the Quality
Feedback Loop. All of Sun’s specific
project management methodologies,
processes, and tools are driven by
three principles: (1) customer busi-
ness case, (2) quality, and (3) risk
management.2
Global Project Portfolio
Management
In today’s business environment,
most companies manage numerous
projects. When multiple projects are
related to one another by customers,
technology, products, services, and/or
location, they are usually referred to
as programs. While all programs and
their related projects are important,
to some extent, some are clearly more
important than others. Thus, it is
incumbent upon each organization to
understand which of their numerous
programs and related projects are of
the highest priority, to ensure the top
talent of the organization and the nec-
essary support is provided to those
key projects.
Unfortunately, many organizations
do not do a very good job of effective-
ly managing their respective project
portfolio. Common project portfolio
management problems may include:
s Allowing lower priority projects
to acquire vital materials, products,
or services needed by the higher
priority projects;
s Allowing the internal “who-you-know”
network approach to circumvent a
priority resource allocation program;
s Not placing the best talent on the
highest priority projects, typically
just getting the available talent;
s Failing to rack and stack your
organization’s projects to determine
which are the most important
projects by country, region,
or global basis;
s Not properly or frequently
obtaining status on the organiza-
tion’s key projects;
s Failing to use appropriate perfor-
mance metrics to evaluate cost
control, profitability, on-time deliv-
ery, product and service quality,
and customer satisfaction on the
key projects; and
s Not terminating failing projects.
Table 1 (on page 10) provides a
simple means of helping organizations
prioritize their projects and summa-
rize the key aspects of their portfolio
of projects.
Multi-cultural Awareness Training
As project managers are increasingly
asked by their employers to relocate
to other countries or remotely support
customer’s projects globally, the need
for multi-cultural awareness training
has grown. Likewise, as more organi-
zations outsource supplies on a
multi-national or global basis, the
need for multi-cultural awareness
training continues to grow. Clearly,
both buyers or customers and sellers
12 s Contract Management / April 2004
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
Individual Global Business Competencies
Table 2.
Vision
Global Attitude
• A global mindset
• Ability to work with
a highly diverse team
• A long-term orienta-
tion
Strategy
Leadership
• Motivates employees
to excellence
• Facilitates organiza-
tional change
• Sets high expectations
• Leads by example
Competencies
required to
make it work!
Demonstrated
abilities/actions
Structure
Discipline
• Focuses on process
improvement
• Serves as a team
or force multiplier
• Holds employees
accountable
Implementation
Execution
• Leverages supply-chain
partners
• Skillfully executes
the deployment cycle
• Plans and tracks
performance with
appropriate metrics
i
Adapted from The Global Challenge, by Moran & Riesenberger, New York, McGraw-Hill, 1994.
or suppliers of products and services
projects are expanding the need for
personnel to receive multi-cultural
awareness training, especially to
reflect the diversity of the business
partners engaged in the outsourcing
management environment.
Increasingly companies and other
multi-national organizations are estab-
lishing local country offices staffed with
local country nationals. Yet, many
organizations still require a few key
foreign country nationals to support
their projects. As a result, the foreign
country nationals often require training
in a variety of aspects in order to be
able to successfully conduct business.
Training in often needed in the areas of
s Language development,
s Local culture and customs,
s Support of local country advisors to
understand local business processes
and/or practices,
s Support of interpreters, and
s Document transcription.
Individual Global Business
Competencies
Some people believe that conducting
business on a global basis is an attitude,
not knowledge or information. Stephen
Rhinesmith, author and international
business expert, has stated that a glob-
al mindset is a requirement of a global
business manager who will guide
institutions and organizations into the
future. He defines a mindset as
A predisposition to see the world in a
particular way that sets boundaries and
provides explanations for why things are
they way they are, while at the same time
establishing guidance for ways in which
we should behave. In other words, a mind-
set is a filter through which we look
at the world.
Rhinesmith explains that people with
global mindsets approach the world
in a number of specifics ways. These
individuals
(1) Look for the big picture
and multiple possibilities;
(2) Understand the world is very com-
plex and business is interdependent;
(3) Are process-oriented, understand-
ing that all business follows a
process of inputs, tools and tech-
niques, and outputs;
April 2004 / Contract Management s 13
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
Organizational Global Business Competencies
Table 3.
Core Competencies
1. Global Vision—Where the corporation intends to go,
emphasis is on acceptance
2. Strategic Focus—Competitive advantages of the organization
3. Control—Flow of strategic direction from headquarters
4. Local Autonomy—Degree of freedom allocated to the
subsidiary to change/modify products or services
5. Coordination—Degree of teamwork between subsidiary,
headquarters and third parties
6. Domestic/Subsidiary Relationship—Flow of information-sharing
7. Corporate Culture—Characteristics that unite people
in an organization
8. Management Selection—Strong leadership trait,
team-builder, and results-oriented
9. Employee Selection—Combine country of origin
and corporate management staff
10. Decision Processes—Control and flow of decision-making
11. Information Processes—Control and flow of information
and knowledge
12. Performance-Oriented—Results focused management
and employees
Worldwide Organizational Solutions
Unified, understood, and accepted by all employees
Growth through coordinated centralization and local adaptability
High
High
High
High, shared, and interdependent
Central and unified
Flexibility, best candidate available from any country
Best available candidate
Shared and complex emphasis on the customer and empowering
employees
Shared and complex, real-time data, and accurate information
Shared and understood performance goals and metrics, with pay
tied to performance
i
Adapted from The Global Challenge, by Moran and Riesenberger, New York, McGraw-Hill, 1994
(4) Consider diversity in people as
a real asset and valued resource,
know how to work effectively
in multicultural teams;
(5) Are comfortable with change
and ambiguity; and
(6) Are open to new experiences,
and enjoy a challenge.
While a global mindset or attitude
is vital to successfully manage out-
sourced projects worldwide, there are
several additional factors or compe-
tencies that are essential for success.
Table 2 (on page 12) illustrates the
global business essentials and individ-
ual key competencies of a successful
global business manager/executive.
Organizational Global
Business Competencies
In addition to the individual compe-
tencies required for successful global
business, there are numerous core
organizational competencies required
for a company to successfully manage
complex outsourced projects world-
wide. Table 3 (on page 13) lists the
core organizational competencies
necessary for global business success.
Benchmarking Project
Management Maturity
The challenge facing today’s project-
performing organizations is that each
of the ingredients it takes to deliver
projects successfully requires a sub-
stantial commitment of time and
resources. Given the many initiatives
required to achieve consistent project
success, which initiatives should an
organization undertake first? Project
management maturity models are
designed to provide the framework
that an organization needs to purpose-
fully and progressively develop its
capabilities to consistently deliver
successful projects. Numerous project
management maturity models have
emerged since the mid ‘90s. A recent
estimate suggests there are more than
30 models currently serving the mar-
ket. Most of the models are based on
the Capability Maturity Model devel-
oped by the Software Engineering
Institute at Carnegie Mellon.
In a study first reported in 1998,
William C. Ibbs and Young-Hoon
Kwak, from the University of
California, developed a benchmark for
project management maturity, as part
of a broader study to determine the
financial and organizational impacts
of project management. This study
employed the Berkeley PM Process
Maturity Model. The sample included
38 companies representing four
targeted industries: engineering and
construction, telecommunications,
information systems, and hi-tech
manufacturing. Each of the participat-
ing companies completed a survey
assessment tool. The researchers
determined that the overall project
management maturity of the 38 com-
panies studied was 3.26 on a 5-point
scale. Ibbs and Kwak also compared
maturity among industries. Using the
average maturity level of all compa-
nies in each of the four industries, the
researchers reported that engineering
and construction (3.36), hi-tech
manufacturing (3.34) and telecommu-
nications (3.30) demonstrated
relatively high project management
maturity compared to information
systems (3.06).
The PM Solution’s Project
Management Maturity Model
The PM Solutions’ Project
Management Maturity Model, devel-
oped by its CEO, Kent Crawford, is
an excellent benchmarking tool. This
model is based on a two-dimensional
framework. The first dimension
reflects the level of maturity. It is
based on the structure of the Software
Engineering Institute’s (SEI)
Capability Maturity Model (CMM).
The SEI-CMM has received wide-
spread acceptance as a standard for
process modeling and assessment
of organizational maturity in several
process areas. The second dimension
depicts the key areas of project man-
agement addressed. This dimension
adopts the structure of the Project
Management Institute’s nine knowl-
edge areas. All of the nine knowledge
areas are further decomposed yielding
a total of 42 key components that
enable a more rigorous and specific
determination of project management
maturity. The structure of this two-
dimensional framework is presented
in Figure 1 (on page 16).
Benchmarking Study Results
Using the Project Management
Maturity Model as a tool, James
Pennypacker (director of Center
for Business Practices) and Dr. Kevin
Grant (assistant professor, University
of Texas San Antonio) conducted
a survey of 123 firms. The survey
results determined that nearly 67
percent of the organizations, compa-
nies with revenues ranging from
below $100 million to more than
$3 billion, were currently operating
at an overall project maturity level
of 2 (out of 5) or below. Further, the
research conducted concludes the
level of project management maturity
is statistically consistent among
industries and companies of
varying size.3
14 s Contract Management / April 2004
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
Project Management Organization Benchmarking Study
Table 4.
Revenue to Hdct. $M (U.S.)
$10M
$15M
$16M
$18M
$20+M
Expense/Revenue %
1.5%
1.0%
0.93%
0.83%
0.75%
Industry Assessment
Below average
Average
Above average
Best-in-class
World-class
16 s Contract Management / April 2004
PM Expense-to-Revenue
Benchmarking Study
The Center for Project Studies
(CPS), a part of Garrett Consulting
Services—a Virginia-based interna-
tional business consulting practice,
conducted a survey of more than 75
companies during 2002. Each compa-
ny surveyed had more than $5 billion
in annual revenue during 2001,
managing numerous large complex
outsourced projects. Based upon a
response rate of more than 32 per-
cent, the following information was
gathered from multi-national compa-
nies in the following industries:
aerospace, defense, engineering,
information technology, construction,
and telecommunications.
Given: A company of more than
$5 billion in annual revenue with
outsourced projects greater than $50
million. Given: A project management
organization performs the following
functions on large complex out-
sourced projects:
(1) project management
s project leadership,
s project planning,
s project scheduling,
s project status,
s project control, and
s project correcting;
(2) Product/service demand planning;
(3) Order management;
(4) Material management;
(5) Supply chain interface; and
(6) Contract administration.
Given: An average employee total
(wrap-rate) expense equals $150,000
USD per year. Table 4 (on page 14)
provides a roughly-right guideline for
staffing large complex outsourced pro-
ject within large companies worldwide.
Recommendations
Based upon research, experience,
and recent discussion with several of
the leading project management con-
sultants who have helped numerous
organizations worldwide improve pro-
ject performance, the following major
actions are suggested.
(1) Ensure top PM talent—Obtain
highly skilled, experienced,
trained, and certified project
management professionals at
all levels of the organization.
(2) Improve information systems—
Provide accurate, real-time,
order-level data by customer
including: plans vs. actual perfor-
mance for cost and schedule/
delivery.
(3) Streamline staff—Reduce support
staffs at all levels by automating
reports, standardizing processes,
driving down decision-making
authority, and outsourcing
support functions.
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
Figure 1.
Level 1
Initial Process
Level 2
Structured Process
and Standards
Level 3
Organizational
Standards and
Institutionalized
Process
Level 4
Managed Process
Level 5
Optimizing Process
SEI Maturity Levels
PMI Knowledge Areas
Each knowledge area is broken down into specific components. Specific components are used
to measure maturity and develop action plans. The number of components associated with
each knowledge area is presented parenthetically following the title of each model.
PM Solutions
Project Management
Maturity Model
Project Integration
Management (5)
Scope Management (6)
Time Management (5)
Cost Management (5)
Quality Management (4)
Project Human Resource
Management (4)
Communications
Management (4)
Risk Management (5)
Procurement
Management (4)
April 2004 / Contract Management s 17
(4) Build high-performance teams—
Motivate leaders to create high
performance teams using the PM
discipline to consistently achieve
customer needs and goals.
(5) Recognize and reward outstanding
performance—Ensure business
leaders actively recognize and
reward project teams when they
achieve excellent results for their
customers and their organization.
(6) Develop project leadership
succession plans—Take the time
to develop project leaders at every
level of the organization. Prepare
appropriate professional develop
plans for all top rated project
managers.
Summary
In today’s world of increased
outsourcing and customers’ high
expections, there is a great need to
develop global project management
best practices. This article provides a
brief summary of many of the proven
effective tools, techniques, and prac-
tices to help projects meet or exceed
both the customers’ and suppliers’
requirements. As projects are becoming
increasingly complex, with the inte-
gration of multiple-parties involving
hardware, software, and professional
services all linked together—profes-
sional project management is vital to
achieving successful results in both
the public and private business
sectors. CM s CMBOK 1.4.6
Endnotes
1. James S. Pennypacker, Center for
Business Practices Survey Results, PM
Network Magazine, (Project Management
Institute, May 2003), 6–7.
2. Marissa Peterson, “Sun Microsystems—
Best Practices,” PM Network Magazine,
(Project Management Institute, January
2003), 24.
3. James S. Pennypacker and Kevin P.
Grant, “Project Management Maturity:
An Industry Benchmark,” Project
Management Journal (Project
Management Institute, March 2003),
4–11.
G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S
It is often said “experience is the best teacher,” and that people learn
more from their mistakes than their successes. This checklist should
help you avoid some of the most common problems that often result
in the failure of complex outsourced projects.
u Who needs roles and responsibilities?
u Begin work without a contract.
u Forget about project progress reports.
u Who needs acceptance criteria?
u Change team members frequently.
u Keep changing requirements.
u Don’t document anything.
u Hire the cheapest subcontractors.
u Select project team leader from whoever is available.
u Who needs a project plan—Just do it!
u Who needs executive support?
u Who cares about a supplier’s past performance?
u Who needs a business case?
u Promise the customer whatever he or she wants.
u Agree to whatever delivery schedule the customer wants.
u Forget about a project kick-off meeting.
u Agree to unlimited liquidated damages.
u Who needs performance-based requirements?
u Forget about earned value.
u Play the lie-and-blame game.
What Not to Do

More Related Content

What's hot

How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
Association for Project Management
 
Project Management
Project ManagementProject Management
Project Management
Nawanan Theera-Ampornpunt
 
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to PracticeAgile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
Glen Alleman
 
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
CollectiveKnowledge
 
PPM Global survey (with outputs)
PPM Global survey (with outputs)PPM Global survey (with outputs)
PPM Global survey (with outputs)
Association for Project Management
 
01 introduction
01  introduction01  introduction
01 introduction
Ala Ibrahim
 
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project ManagementPrograms and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
Bryan Fenech
 
Project Management Survey Research
Project Management Survey ResearchProject Management Survey Research
Project Management Survey Research
David Robins
 
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
International Institute for Learning
 
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
Productivity Intelligence Institute
 
Project Management Essentials
Project Management Essentials Project Management Essentials
Project Management Essentials
SriramITISConsultant
 
Advanced project management ppts
Advanced project management pptsAdvanced project management ppts
Advanced project management pptsAli Ishaqi
 
Reinventing project management antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
Reinventing project management   antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021Reinventing project management   antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
Reinventing project management antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
PMIUKChapter
 
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
Project Controls Expo
 
People in portfolio management
People in portfolio management People in portfolio management
People in portfolio management
Luis Javier Serrano
 
Good governance of the project portfolio
Good governance of the project portfolioGood governance of the project portfolio
Good governance of the project portfolio
Association for Project Management
 
Lessons learned report
Lessons learned reportLessons learned report
Lessons learned reportMarsha Cooper
 
Introduction to Project Portfolio Management
Introduction to Project Portfolio ManagementIntroduction to Project Portfolio Management
Introduction to Project Portfolio Management
Luis Javier Serrano
 
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE EnvironmentUCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
Mark Ritchie
 

What's hot (20)

How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
How can you influence your Board to adopt good governance of project / change...
 
Project Management
Project ManagementProject Management
Project Management
 
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to PracticeAgile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
Agile Program Management: Moving from Principles to Practice
 
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...Insights and Trends:  Current Portfolio,  Programme, and Project  Management ...
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...
 
PPM Global survey (with outputs)
PPM Global survey (with outputs)PPM Global survey (with outputs)
PPM Global survey (with outputs)
 
01 introduction
01  introduction01  introduction
01 introduction
 
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project ManagementPrograms and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
Programs and Portfolios - Multi-project Management
 
Project Management Survey Research
Project Management Survey ResearchProject Management Survey Research
Project Management Survey Research
 
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
Emerging Trends in PMO Governance
 
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
Making the most of your constrained resources optimizing resource allocation ...
 
The Value of Project Portfolio Management
The Value of Project Portfolio ManagementThe Value of Project Portfolio Management
The Value of Project Portfolio Management
 
Project Management Essentials
Project Management Essentials Project Management Essentials
Project Management Essentials
 
Advanced project management ppts
Advanced project management pptsAdvanced project management ppts
Advanced project management ppts
 
Reinventing project management antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
Reinventing project management   antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021Reinventing project management   antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
Reinventing project management antonio nieto-rodriguez. 27th may 2021
 
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
Project Controls Expo, 18th Nov 2014 - "Effective Project Portfolio Managemen...
 
People in portfolio management
People in portfolio management People in portfolio management
People in portfolio management
 
Good governance of the project portfolio
Good governance of the project portfolioGood governance of the project portfolio
Good governance of the project portfolio
 
Lessons learned report
Lessons learned reportLessons learned report
Lessons learned report
 
Introduction to Project Portfolio Management
Introduction to Project Portfolio ManagementIntroduction to Project Portfolio Management
Introduction to Project Portfolio Management
 
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE EnvironmentUCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
 

Viewers also liked

The Historical Development of the Concept of Life
The Historical Development of the Concept of LifeThe Historical Development of the Concept of Life
The Historical Development of the Concept of Life
Ruwyne Akkean Obediente
 
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
Marileah Mendina
 
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
Junnie Salud
 
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015Gregory A. Garrett
 
Perpetuation
PerpetuationPerpetuation
Perpetuation
Josynda Bacaro
 
Topic 6 origins of life ppt
Topic 6   origins of life pptTopic 6   origins of life ppt
Topic 6 origins of life pptjsanchez17
 
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE
THE ORIGIN OF LIFETHE ORIGIN OF LIFE
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE
Chen Mangkun
 
The origin of life
The origin of lifeThe origin of life
The origin of life
fandjie
 
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
DONBUMACAS
 
Origin of life
Origin of lifeOrigin of life
Origin of lifedamarisb
 
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDEEARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
PRINTDESK by Dan
 
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 34A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
janehbasto
 
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense OrganDetailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
janehbasto
 

Viewers also liked (15)

The Historical Development of the Concept of Life
The Historical Development of the Concept of LifeThe Historical Development of the Concept of Life
The Historical Development of the Concept of Life
 
Intro to Life Science & Biology
Intro to Life Science & BiologyIntro to Life Science & Biology
Intro to Life Science & Biology
 
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
Grade 11 Earth & Life Science Lesson 1
 
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
Detailed Lesson Plan (ENGLISH, MATH, SCIENCE, FILIPINO)
 
Article - CMMM
Article - CMMMArticle - CMMM
Article - CMMM
 
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015
Published Article - Creating a World Class Contracting Organization - Jul 2015
 
Perpetuation
PerpetuationPerpetuation
Perpetuation
 
Topic 6 origins of life ppt
Topic 6   origins of life pptTopic 6   origins of life ppt
Topic 6 origins of life ppt
 
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE
THE ORIGIN OF LIFETHE ORIGIN OF LIFE
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE
 
The origin of life
The origin of lifeThe origin of life
The origin of life
 
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
Don Earth & Life Science Daily Lesson Log (DLL)
 
Origin of life
Origin of lifeOrigin of life
Origin of life
 
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDEEARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
EARTH SCIENCE TEACHING GUIDE
 
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 34A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
4A's Detailed lesson plan in Science 3
 
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense OrganDetailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
Detailed Lesson Plan in Science and Health Grade 3 Sense Organ
 

Similar to Article - Global Project Management

PM-1 Overview.ppt
PM-1 Overview.pptPM-1 Overview.ppt
PM-1 Overview.ppt
natisil1
 
PMO and PPM Best Practices
PMO and PPM Best PracticesPMO and PPM Best Practices
PMO and PPM Best PracticesJeff McClay
 
Project Management Overview
Project Management OverviewProject Management Overview
Project Management Overview
Rockon0017i5
 
1 b. introduction to project management
1 b. introduction to project management1 b. introduction to project management
1 b. introduction to project management
Dr.R. SELVAM
 
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
GP Strategies Corporation
 
PMO Managed Service Introduction
PMO Managed Service IntroductionPMO Managed Service Introduction
PMO Managed Service Introduction
Keith Rackley
 
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”Lviv Startup Club
 
Project Portfolio Management
Project Portfolio ManagementProject Portfolio Management
Project Portfolio Management
Digite Inc
 
La Verne Clark - CV Resume
La Verne Clark - CV ResumeLa Verne Clark - CV Resume
La Verne Clark - CV ResumeLa Verne Clark
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional Profile
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional ProfileCarlos Sousa\'s Professional Profile
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional Profilecarlos-sousa
 
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1James McDermott
 
Implementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
Implementation of Knowledge Management in StarwoodImplementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
Implementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
Yudha Satya Perdana
 
SSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management ServicesSSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Consulting
 
Resume for Blair Pack
Resume for Blair PackResume for Blair Pack
Resume for Blair PackBlair Pack
 
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop PresentationInfo-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
Hilary Carney Badoian
 

Similar to Article - Global Project Management (20)

7 keys
7 keys7 keys
7 keys
 
PM-1 Overview.ppt
PM-1 Overview.pptPM-1 Overview.ppt
PM-1 Overview.ppt
 
Pmce presentation slides
Pmce presentation slidesPmce presentation slides
Pmce presentation slides
 
PMO and PPM Best Practices
PMO and PPM Best PracticesPMO and PPM Best Practices
PMO and PPM Best Practices
 
Project Management Overview
Project Management OverviewProject Management Overview
Project Management Overview
 
1 b. introduction to project management
1 b. introduction to project management1 b. introduction to project management
1 b. introduction to project management
 
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
Best Practices for Managing a Global SuccessFactors Rollout
 
PMO Managed Service Introduction
PMO Managed Service IntroductionPMO Managed Service Introduction
PMO Managed Service Introduction
 
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”
Андрій Татчин “Будуючи ПМО з нуля”
 
Project Portfolio Management
Project Portfolio ManagementProject Portfolio Management
Project Portfolio Management
 
La Verne Clark - CV Resume
La Verne Clark - CV ResumeLa Verne Clark - CV Resume
La Verne Clark - CV Resume
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
 
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional Profile
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional ProfileCarlos Sousa\'s Professional Profile
Carlos Sousa\'s Professional Profile
 
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1
L Holution Srochure B Pervices V1
 
LCesnick
LCesnickLCesnick
LCesnick
 
Implementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
Implementation of Knowledge Management in StarwoodImplementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
Implementation of Knowledge Management in Starwood
 
SSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management ServicesSSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management Services
 
Resume for Blair Pack
Resume for Blair PackResume for Blair Pack
Resume for Blair Pack
 
1 ch1
1 ch11 ch1
1 ch1
 
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop PresentationInfo-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
Info-Tech Research Group & Boardroom Events Value Prop Presentation
 

Article - Global Project Management

  • 1. 8 s Contract Management / April 2004 This article is an extract from Managing Complex Outsource Projects by Gregory A. Garrett, published by CCH Inc., Chicago 2004. As more and more companies and organizations conduct work on a multi- national or global basis, the need to define project management (PM) “best practices” and leverage project man- agement expertise globally becomes greater. What organizations want is to develop PM methodologies, based upon proven processes to ensure repeatable and measurable results, which meet or exceed their customers demanding expectations. Many companies or organizations have developed internal PM expertise, typically within their professional services department or supply chain management organizations. Likewise, many companies have taken the time to develop PM best practices databases to facilitate knowledge transfer within their organizations. Most companies hope to repeat project best practices, if they were proven successful some- where else in the organization. According to the Center for Business Practices (CBP), the research arm of PM Solutions and a U.S.-based project management firm, consistency and resource problems top the list of con- cerns facing project managers. These results come from CBP’s 2003 survey of 1,000 project professionals and senior-level executives from such industries as manufacturing, health care, and information technology. CBP’s survey found the largest project man- agement challenge was developing a consistent approach to managing pro- jects (23.9 percent of the respondents). Following close behind was the concern over resource allocation (19.7 percent) and managing too many projects or the wrong projects (16.9 percent). GREGORY A. GARRETT, CPCM, PMP, is vice president and general manager, U.S. federal government programs for Lucent Technologies in Herndon, Virginia. He is a member of NCMA’s Washington, D.C., Chapter and received the Project Management Excellence Award from the Project Management Institute. Send comments on this article to cm@ncmahq.org. A b o u t t h e A u t h o r As projects are becoming increasingly complex, professional project management is vital to achieving successful results in both the public and private business sectors. BY GREGORY A. GARRETT Global Project Management: Best Practices Global Project Management: Best Practices
  • 2. April 2004 / Contract Management s 9 The CBP survey also found that companies implementing PM improve- ments spent an average of $712,000 on them annually, with most commonly implemented improvements including: s Software tools (77.9 percent), s Methodology development (69.1 percent), and s Staff training (69.1 percent). The survey also included other insights in the area of project types, project activities, and other areas, such as s Project complexity—51.7 percent of the projects surveyed were con- sidered complex or highly complex. s Project management office (PMO)— 44.6 percent of the companies surveyed had established a PMO or PM Center of Excellence. s Project portfolio management (PPM)—Most companies surveyed still had a low level of project portfolio management maturity. s Project performance measurements— The metrics most commonly used by the companies surveyed to assess value are measured by improvements in delivery dates (78.9 percent), bottom- line economics (65.8 percent), and product or service quality (57.9 percent).1 PM Methodology and Structure The following best practices have all been proven effective by numerous organizations involved in managing projects on a multi-national and/or global business scale. Methodology Many large multi-national organizations and companies have created a network of project managers geographically distributed in numerous countries worldwide. The goal of most large multi-national organizations and companies is to meet or exceed their customer’s business needs through
  • 3. successful project results. Many com- panies, including ABB, AT&T, Bechtel, EDS, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Lucent Technologies, NCR, Sun Microsystems, USAA, and others; have developed or have had outside consultants help them create a high-level project management methodology. Such PM methodologies are usually composed of standardized project management processes, based upon industry best practices and specific and tailored processes proven successful for the respective company. A global project management methodology should be a dynamic set of processes that evolve as the industry and company change to meet or exceed its customers’ needs. Unfortunately, some companies develop or purchase a global PM methodology, but do not take the time and effort to keep it current and accurate. As a result, some companies invest a lot of money in the one-time development of such methodologies, but do not truly reap the long-term benefits. It is important to remember that project management methodologies, processes, best prac- tices, and numerous tools and techniques exist only as a means to an end—meeting or exceeding a customer’s needs, while achieving desired company or organization performance targets. For a global project management methodology to be truly successful it must be (1) widely distributed throughout the organization, typically through multi-media (Web- based, CD-ROM, and paper copies, etc.), (2) widely acknowledged at all levels of the organization, and (3) routinely practiced by the project management community within the respective organization. The International Standards Organization (ISO) Standards for Project Management 10006 provides a good standardized outline of what process- es and practices should be included within global PM methodology. Support Structure In order to truly make project man- agement globally successful within an organization, there must be an appropriate support structure. Clearly, the level of support varies, based upon numerous factors including the level of PM maturity, project complexity, degree of outsourcing, geographic distribution, and project importance, etc. The following items are usually vital to ensure an appropriate project management support structure exists to successfully manage complex outsourced projects worldwide. s Executive sponsorship—A knowl- edgeable, experienced, certified project management executive, who serves as a champion of the project management discipline within the company and externally. s Global project management office (GPMO)—A small but effective team of highly experienced, trained, and certified project management professionals, who ensure the pro- ject managers in the field have all the resources, tools, training, and support they need to get the job done, including a global project management methodology. s Regional and/or local country project management office (PMO)— In addition, to the GPMO, there should be a small but highly respon- sive regional and/or local country PMO to help support the local pro- ject managers with more local- and country-specific project needs, local laws and regulations, customs, and team mobilization support. s Web-based PM best practices (knowledge management)—As much as possible, the best practices from projects worldwide should be documented and made easily avail- able and key-word searchable to all organization project managers. s Project management networking— Every available means should be used to facilitate the networking of project managers to share expertise, including teleconferences, video conferences, net-meetings, shared electronic databases, Web portals, and appropriate face-to- face meetings. 10 s Contract Management / April 2004 G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S Project Name Project 1 Project 2 Project 3 Project Manager Status (Green, Yellow, Red) Project Net Present Value (Revenue) Project Margin Customer Name Project Resource (Hdct) Customer Strategic Objective Comments/ Key Notes Key Projects Portfolio Table 1.
  • 4. s Accurate and real-time project-level data—The organization should offer an enterprisewide, globally accessi- ble (24/7/365) information system, which provides real-time status on the placement of orders, for pur- chasing products and services, and the status of engineering, construc- tion, manufacturing, shipping installation, and testing. Case Study #1 With more than 35,000 employees in 100 countries, Sun Microsystems (Sun) is performing project manage- ment on a truly global scale. Within Sun’s Services organization, Sun Professional Services has the responsi- bility for developing internal project management expertise. Sun Professional Services has a network of about 500 project management professionals. Project management expertise with Sun Professional Services is organized around its primary competencies—the Project Management Performance Model, project quality activities, Customer Loyalty Index (CLI), and the Quality Feedback Loop. All of Sun’s specific project management methodologies, processes, and tools are driven by three principles: (1) customer busi- ness case, (2) quality, and (3) risk management.2 Global Project Portfolio Management In today’s business environment, most companies manage numerous projects. When multiple projects are related to one another by customers, technology, products, services, and/or location, they are usually referred to as programs. While all programs and their related projects are important, to some extent, some are clearly more important than others. Thus, it is incumbent upon each organization to understand which of their numerous programs and related projects are of the highest priority, to ensure the top talent of the organization and the nec- essary support is provided to those key projects. Unfortunately, many organizations do not do a very good job of effective- ly managing their respective project portfolio. Common project portfolio management problems may include: s Allowing lower priority projects to acquire vital materials, products, or services needed by the higher priority projects; s Allowing the internal “who-you-know” network approach to circumvent a priority resource allocation program; s Not placing the best talent on the highest priority projects, typically just getting the available talent; s Failing to rack and stack your organization’s projects to determine which are the most important projects by country, region, or global basis; s Not properly or frequently obtaining status on the organiza- tion’s key projects; s Failing to use appropriate perfor- mance metrics to evaluate cost control, profitability, on-time deliv- ery, product and service quality, and customer satisfaction on the key projects; and s Not terminating failing projects. Table 1 (on page 10) provides a simple means of helping organizations prioritize their projects and summa- rize the key aspects of their portfolio of projects. Multi-cultural Awareness Training As project managers are increasingly asked by their employers to relocate to other countries or remotely support customer’s projects globally, the need for multi-cultural awareness training has grown. Likewise, as more organi- zations outsource supplies on a multi-national or global basis, the need for multi-cultural awareness training continues to grow. Clearly, both buyers or customers and sellers 12 s Contract Management / April 2004 G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S Individual Global Business Competencies Table 2. Vision Global Attitude • A global mindset • Ability to work with a highly diverse team • A long-term orienta- tion Strategy Leadership • Motivates employees to excellence • Facilitates organiza- tional change • Sets high expectations • Leads by example Competencies required to make it work! Demonstrated abilities/actions Structure Discipline • Focuses on process improvement • Serves as a team or force multiplier • Holds employees accountable Implementation Execution • Leverages supply-chain partners • Skillfully executes the deployment cycle • Plans and tracks performance with appropriate metrics i Adapted from The Global Challenge, by Moran & Riesenberger, New York, McGraw-Hill, 1994.
  • 5. or suppliers of products and services projects are expanding the need for personnel to receive multi-cultural awareness training, especially to reflect the diversity of the business partners engaged in the outsourcing management environment. Increasingly companies and other multi-national organizations are estab- lishing local country offices staffed with local country nationals. Yet, many organizations still require a few key foreign country nationals to support their projects. As a result, the foreign country nationals often require training in a variety of aspects in order to be able to successfully conduct business. Training in often needed in the areas of s Language development, s Local culture and customs, s Support of local country advisors to understand local business processes and/or practices, s Support of interpreters, and s Document transcription. Individual Global Business Competencies Some people believe that conducting business on a global basis is an attitude, not knowledge or information. Stephen Rhinesmith, author and international business expert, has stated that a glob- al mindset is a requirement of a global business manager who will guide institutions and organizations into the future. He defines a mindset as A predisposition to see the world in a particular way that sets boundaries and provides explanations for why things are they way they are, while at the same time establishing guidance for ways in which we should behave. In other words, a mind- set is a filter through which we look at the world. Rhinesmith explains that people with global mindsets approach the world in a number of specifics ways. These individuals (1) Look for the big picture and multiple possibilities; (2) Understand the world is very com- plex and business is interdependent; (3) Are process-oriented, understand- ing that all business follows a process of inputs, tools and tech- niques, and outputs; April 2004 / Contract Management s 13 G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S Organizational Global Business Competencies Table 3. Core Competencies 1. Global Vision—Where the corporation intends to go, emphasis is on acceptance 2. Strategic Focus—Competitive advantages of the organization 3. Control—Flow of strategic direction from headquarters 4. Local Autonomy—Degree of freedom allocated to the subsidiary to change/modify products or services 5. Coordination—Degree of teamwork between subsidiary, headquarters and third parties 6. Domestic/Subsidiary Relationship—Flow of information-sharing 7. Corporate Culture—Characteristics that unite people in an organization 8. Management Selection—Strong leadership trait, team-builder, and results-oriented 9. Employee Selection—Combine country of origin and corporate management staff 10. Decision Processes—Control and flow of decision-making 11. Information Processes—Control and flow of information and knowledge 12. Performance-Oriented—Results focused management and employees Worldwide Organizational Solutions Unified, understood, and accepted by all employees Growth through coordinated centralization and local adaptability High High High High, shared, and interdependent Central and unified Flexibility, best candidate available from any country Best available candidate Shared and complex emphasis on the customer and empowering employees Shared and complex, real-time data, and accurate information Shared and understood performance goals and metrics, with pay tied to performance i Adapted from The Global Challenge, by Moran and Riesenberger, New York, McGraw-Hill, 1994
  • 6. (4) Consider diversity in people as a real asset and valued resource, know how to work effectively in multicultural teams; (5) Are comfortable with change and ambiguity; and (6) Are open to new experiences, and enjoy a challenge. While a global mindset or attitude is vital to successfully manage out- sourced projects worldwide, there are several additional factors or compe- tencies that are essential for success. Table 2 (on page 12) illustrates the global business essentials and individ- ual key competencies of a successful global business manager/executive. Organizational Global Business Competencies In addition to the individual compe- tencies required for successful global business, there are numerous core organizational competencies required for a company to successfully manage complex outsourced projects world- wide. Table 3 (on page 13) lists the core organizational competencies necessary for global business success. Benchmarking Project Management Maturity The challenge facing today’s project- performing organizations is that each of the ingredients it takes to deliver projects successfully requires a sub- stantial commitment of time and resources. Given the many initiatives required to achieve consistent project success, which initiatives should an organization undertake first? Project management maturity models are designed to provide the framework that an organization needs to purpose- fully and progressively develop its capabilities to consistently deliver successful projects. Numerous project management maturity models have emerged since the mid ‘90s. A recent estimate suggests there are more than 30 models currently serving the mar- ket. Most of the models are based on the Capability Maturity Model devel- oped by the Software Engineering Institute at Carnegie Mellon. In a study first reported in 1998, William C. Ibbs and Young-Hoon Kwak, from the University of California, developed a benchmark for project management maturity, as part of a broader study to determine the financial and organizational impacts of project management. This study employed the Berkeley PM Process Maturity Model. The sample included 38 companies representing four targeted industries: engineering and construction, telecommunications, information systems, and hi-tech manufacturing. Each of the participat- ing companies completed a survey assessment tool. The researchers determined that the overall project management maturity of the 38 com- panies studied was 3.26 on a 5-point scale. Ibbs and Kwak also compared maturity among industries. Using the average maturity level of all compa- nies in each of the four industries, the researchers reported that engineering and construction (3.36), hi-tech manufacturing (3.34) and telecommu- nications (3.30) demonstrated relatively high project management maturity compared to information systems (3.06). The PM Solution’s Project Management Maturity Model The PM Solutions’ Project Management Maturity Model, devel- oped by its CEO, Kent Crawford, is an excellent benchmarking tool. This model is based on a two-dimensional framework. The first dimension reflects the level of maturity. It is based on the structure of the Software Engineering Institute’s (SEI) Capability Maturity Model (CMM). The SEI-CMM has received wide- spread acceptance as a standard for process modeling and assessment of organizational maturity in several process areas. The second dimension depicts the key areas of project man- agement addressed. This dimension adopts the structure of the Project Management Institute’s nine knowl- edge areas. All of the nine knowledge areas are further decomposed yielding a total of 42 key components that enable a more rigorous and specific determination of project management maturity. The structure of this two- dimensional framework is presented in Figure 1 (on page 16). Benchmarking Study Results Using the Project Management Maturity Model as a tool, James Pennypacker (director of Center for Business Practices) and Dr. Kevin Grant (assistant professor, University of Texas San Antonio) conducted a survey of 123 firms. The survey results determined that nearly 67 percent of the organizations, compa- nies with revenues ranging from below $100 million to more than $3 billion, were currently operating at an overall project maturity level of 2 (out of 5) or below. Further, the research conducted concludes the level of project management maturity is statistically consistent among industries and companies of varying size.3 14 s Contract Management / April 2004 G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S Project Management Organization Benchmarking Study Table 4. Revenue to Hdct. $M (U.S.) $10M $15M $16M $18M $20+M Expense/Revenue % 1.5% 1.0% 0.93% 0.83% 0.75% Industry Assessment Below average Average Above average Best-in-class World-class
  • 7. 16 s Contract Management / April 2004 PM Expense-to-Revenue Benchmarking Study The Center for Project Studies (CPS), a part of Garrett Consulting Services—a Virginia-based interna- tional business consulting practice, conducted a survey of more than 75 companies during 2002. Each compa- ny surveyed had more than $5 billion in annual revenue during 2001, managing numerous large complex outsourced projects. Based upon a response rate of more than 32 per- cent, the following information was gathered from multi-national compa- nies in the following industries: aerospace, defense, engineering, information technology, construction, and telecommunications. Given: A company of more than $5 billion in annual revenue with outsourced projects greater than $50 million. Given: A project management organization performs the following functions on large complex out- sourced projects: (1) project management s project leadership, s project planning, s project scheduling, s project status, s project control, and s project correcting; (2) Product/service demand planning; (3) Order management; (4) Material management; (5) Supply chain interface; and (6) Contract administration. Given: An average employee total (wrap-rate) expense equals $150,000 USD per year. Table 4 (on page 14) provides a roughly-right guideline for staffing large complex outsourced pro- ject within large companies worldwide. Recommendations Based upon research, experience, and recent discussion with several of the leading project management con- sultants who have helped numerous organizations worldwide improve pro- ject performance, the following major actions are suggested. (1) Ensure top PM talent—Obtain highly skilled, experienced, trained, and certified project management professionals at all levels of the organization. (2) Improve information systems— Provide accurate, real-time, order-level data by customer including: plans vs. actual perfor- mance for cost and schedule/ delivery. (3) Streamline staff—Reduce support staffs at all levels by automating reports, standardizing processes, driving down decision-making authority, and outsourcing support functions. G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S Figure 1. Level 1 Initial Process Level 2 Structured Process and Standards Level 3 Organizational Standards and Institutionalized Process Level 4 Managed Process Level 5 Optimizing Process SEI Maturity Levels PMI Knowledge Areas Each knowledge area is broken down into specific components. Specific components are used to measure maturity and develop action plans. The number of components associated with each knowledge area is presented parenthetically following the title of each model. PM Solutions Project Management Maturity Model Project Integration Management (5) Scope Management (6) Time Management (5) Cost Management (5) Quality Management (4) Project Human Resource Management (4) Communications Management (4) Risk Management (5) Procurement Management (4)
  • 8. April 2004 / Contract Management s 17 (4) Build high-performance teams— Motivate leaders to create high performance teams using the PM discipline to consistently achieve customer needs and goals. (5) Recognize and reward outstanding performance—Ensure business leaders actively recognize and reward project teams when they achieve excellent results for their customers and their organization. (6) Develop project leadership succession plans—Take the time to develop project leaders at every level of the organization. Prepare appropriate professional develop plans for all top rated project managers. Summary In today’s world of increased outsourcing and customers’ high expections, there is a great need to develop global project management best practices. This article provides a brief summary of many of the proven effective tools, techniques, and prac- tices to help projects meet or exceed both the customers’ and suppliers’ requirements. As projects are becoming increasingly complex, with the inte- gration of multiple-parties involving hardware, software, and professional services all linked together—profes- sional project management is vital to achieving successful results in both the public and private business sectors. CM s CMBOK 1.4.6 Endnotes 1. James S. Pennypacker, Center for Business Practices Survey Results, PM Network Magazine, (Project Management Institute, May 2003), 6–7. 2. Marissa Peterson, “Sun Microsystems— Best Practices,” PM Network Magazine, (Project Management Institute, January 2003), 24. 3. James S. Pennypacker and Kevin P. Grant, “Project Management Maturity: An Industry Benchmark,” Project Management Journal (Project Management Institute, March 2003), 4–11. G L O B A L P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T : B E S T P R A C T I C E S It is often said “experience is the best teacher,” and that people learn more from their mistakes than their successes. This checklist should help you avoid some of the most common problems that often result in the failure of complex outsourced projects. u Who needs roles and responsibilities? u Begin work without a contract. u Forget about project progress reports. u Who needs acceptance criteria? u Change team members frequently. u Keep changing requirements. u Don’t document anything. u Hire the cheapest subcontractors. u Select project team leader from whoever is available. u Who needs a project plan—Just do it! u Who needs executive support? u Who cares about a supplier’s past performance? u Who needs a business case? u Promise the customer whatever he or she wants. u Agree to whatever delivery schedule the customer wants. u Forget about a project kick-off meeting. u Agree to unlimited liquidated damages. u Who needs performance-based requirements? u Forget about earned value. u Play the lie-and-blame game. What Not to Do