The document discusses strategies for reducing alarm fatigue in healthcare facilities. It notes that the large number of medical devices with alarms can lead to clinicians becoming desensitized to alarms. This is a patient safety issue, as alarms are sometimes ignored as a result. The document recommends several approaches facilities can take to reduce nuisance alarms and distinguish important alarms, such as using silent alarms, adjusting alarm settings, and integrating bed alarms with nurse call systems. The goal is to improve patient safety and care by reducing unnecessary alarms while still using alarms as important safety alerts.
Overview of critical factors affecting medical user interfaces in intensive c...hiij
This paper provides a comprehensive overview of cri
tical factors, which affect on-screen user interfac
es of
medical devices in Intensive Care Unit (ICU). A lit
erature survey with relevant research publications
has
led to selection of thirty eight critical factors i
n ICU. The critical factors identified are categori
zed into
various groups based on three major aspects – syste
m evaluation parameters, constituents of patient
management and user interface design. Physicians’ s
urvey, in which five physicians are involved, is us
ed to
categorize the identified critical factors into rel
ated groups. In the process, fourteen critical fact
ors are
mainly selected, which affect on-screen user interf
ace design of medical devices. The applicability of
such
factors is demonstrated with the help of a case stu
dy of head-injury patient admitted in ICU. The crit
ical
factors identified are definitely useful to device
manufacturers, user interface designers, ICU
administrators and physicians for improved device d
esign, ICU resource management and patient care.
Overview of critical factors affecting medical user interfaces in intensive c...hiij
This paper provides a comprehensive overview of cri
tical factors, which affect on-screen user interfac
es of
medical devices in Intensive Care Unit (ICU). A lit
erature survey with relevant research publications
has
led to selection of thirty eight critical factors i
n ICU. The critical factors identified are categori
zed into
various groups based on three major aspects – syste
m evaluation parameters, constituents of patient
management and user interface design. Physicians’ s
urvey, in which five physicians are involved, is us
ed to
categorize the identified critical factors into rel
ated groups. In the process, fourteen critical fact
ors are
mainly selected, which affect on-screen user interf
ace design of medical devices. The applicability of
such
factors is demonstrated with the help of a case stu
dy of head-injury patient admitted in ICU. The crit
ical
factors identified are definitely useful to device
manufacturers, user interface designers, ICU
administrators and physicians for improved device d
esign, ICU resource management and patient care.
Each month, join us as we highlight and discuss hot topics ranging from the future of higher education to wearable technology, best productivity hacks and secrets to hiring top talent. Upload your SlideShares, and share your expertise with the world!
Not sure what to share on SlideShare?
SlideShares that inform, inspire and educate attract the most views. Beyond that, ideas for what you can upload are limitless. We’ve selected a few popular examples to get your creative juices flowing.
Are You a Caregiver? Here Are 7 Tech Tools That Could Make Your Life Easier b...Pinta Partners
Being a caregiver is both a noble duty and a demanding journey, often filled with varied demands and complexities. Fortunately, the advent of technology has ushered in a new era in caregiving, presenting innovative solutions that mitigate the burdens and improve the quality of care.
Read more on: https://joellandau.com/are-you-a-caregiver-here-are-7-tech-tools-that-could-make-your-life-easier/
Fall preventionApplying the evidence By Kathleen Fowier, MS.docxnealwaters20034
Fall prevention:
Applying the evidence By Kathleen Fowier, MSN, RN, CMSRN Quality Improvement Manager
UPMC St. Margaret, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
As told to Janet Boivin, BSN, RN
S u c c e s s f u l fall pre
vention program s use m u lti
m odal interventions, such as detailed
fall risk assessments, fre q u e n t m o n ito rin g by
staff, and a p p ro p ria te use o f equipm en t. Healthcare
facilities typically im p le m e n t best practices in b un
dles, m aking it often d iffic u lt to determ ine which in
terventions are the m ost effective.
UPMC St. M argaret Hospital in Pittsburgh, Penn
sylvania jo in e d the Pennsylvania Hospital Engage
m ent N etw ork (PA HEN) in A pril 2012 to reduce
falls w ith injury. This set us on a path th a t resulted
in a 75% reduction in falls w ith serious injuries.
(See graph.) Here is how we accom plished this
reduction.
Analysis: Role of data and best practices
A fte r jo in in g PA HEN, we fo rm e d a m ultidisciplinary
team tasked w ith review ing and investigating all fall
events, extracting and analyzing data, and evaluat
ing best practices im p le m e n te d as a result o f root
cause analysis.
Case study
This case study illustrates our fall team in action
An 80-year-old fem ale p a tie n t w ith im paired cognitive
function and m u ltip le risk factors— including an
unsteady gait, im paired vision, and m u ltiple
m edications— was assessed as a high fall risk when
a d m itte d to our facility.
The nursing staff im plem ented a bed alarm to alert
them when the p a tie n t was g e ttin g up w ith o u t using
the call light. They also m oved her closer to the nurse's
station and used purposeful rounding to anticipate and
attend to her needs. The average response tim e fo r
alerts w ith this p a tie n t was a rapid 10 seconds. D espite
these steps, the patient's bed alarm sounded several
tim es to alert staff, who fou n d her standing beside
the bed.
The nurses reached o u t to the fall team fo r support.
The team reviewed th e bed-alarm
settings (three sensitivity settings— low,
m edium , and high) and sim ulated alarm
tim e studies w ith the nursing staff. Their
efforts revealed m isperceptions in
em ployee understanding o f bed-alarm
settings. For example, the staff th o u g h t
the bed alarm w ould alert them th a t the
p a tie n t was o ff the p e rim e te r o f the
mattress no m atter what the sensitivity
setting.
The fall team used sim ulated bed-alarm
scenarios to educate the staff and help
to change practice. The nursing staff
learned it's not enough to sim ply engage
the alarm; the alarm also needs to be at the
a p p ropriate setting. The staff began using more
sensitive settings fo r patients w ith im pulsive behaviors.
We learned an im p o rta n t lesson: How well em ployees
understand facility equipm ent, its variations, and how
to use it are im p o rta n t considerations when analyzing
p a tie .
Fall preventionApplying the evidence By Kathleen Fowier, MS.docxmglenn3
Fall prevention:
Applying the evidence By Kathleen Fowier, MSN, RN, CMSRN Quality Improvement Manager
UPMC St. Margaret, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
As told to Janet Boivin, BSN, RN
S u c c e s s f u l fall pre
vention program s use m u lti
m odal interventions, such as detailed
fall risk assessments, fre q u e n t m o n ito rin g by
staff, and a p p ro p ria te use o f equipm en t. Healthcare
facilities typically im p le m e n t best practices in b un
dles, m aking it often d iffic u lt to determ ine which in
terventions are the m ost effective.
UPMC St. M argaret Hospital in Pittsburgh, Penn
sylvania jo in e d the Pennsylvania Hospital Engage
m ent N etw ork (PA HEN) in A pril 2012 to reduce
falls w ith injury. This set us on a path th a t resulted
in a 75% reduction in falls w ith serious injuries.
(See graph.) Here is how we accom plished this
reduction.
Analysis: Role of data and best practices
A fte r jo in in g PA HEN, we fo rm e d a m ultidisciplinary
team tasked w ith review ing and investigating all fall
events, extracting and analyzing data, and evaluat
ing best practices im p le m e n te d as a result o f root
cause analysis.
Case study
This case study illustrates our fall team in action
An 80-year-old fem ale p a tie n t w ith im paired cognitive
function and m u ltip le risk factors— including an
unsteady gait, im paired vision, and m u ltiple
m edications— was assessed as a high fall risk when
a d m itte d to our facility.
The nursing staff im plem ented a bed alarm to alert
them when the p a tie n t was g e ttin g up w ith o u t using
the call light. They also m oved her closer to the nurse's
station and used purposeful rounding to anticipate and
attend to her needs. The average response tim e fo r
alerts w ith this p a tie n t was a rapid 10 seconds. D espite
these steps, the patient's bed alarm sounded several
tim es to alert staff, who fou n d her standing beside
the bed.
The nurses reached o u t to the fall team fo r support.
The team reviewed th e bed-alarm
settings (three sensitivity settings— low,
m edium , and high) and sim ulated alarm
tim e studies w ith the nursing staff. Their
efforts revealed m isperceptions in
em ployee understanding o f bed-alarm
settings. For example, the staff th o u g h t
the bed alarm w ould alert them th a t the
p a tie n t was o ff the p e rim e te r o f the
mattress no m atter what the sensitivity
setting.
The fall team used sim ulated bed-alarm
scenarios to educate the staff and help
to change practice. The nursing staff
learned it's not enough to sim ply engage
the alarm; the alarm also needs to be at the
a p p ropriate setting. The staff began using more
sensitive settings fo r patients w ith im pulsive behaviors.
We learned an im p o rta n t lesson: How well em ployees
understand facility equipm ent, its variations, and how
to use it are im p o rta n t considerations when analyzing
p a tie .
The SENSACTION-AAL project addressed one of the main problems for older people: motor disabilities.
By Lorenzo Chiari, Carlo Tacconi. DEIS - Università di Bologna
Disasters and similar emergency situations could actually test you- as a firm owner even as doctor. Most of the time, things might go fairly easy for you.
Why Care Management Systems are Essential for Efficient Healthcare Delivery?.pdfmagePoint
Care Management System is one such technology that emerged relatively recently but has established itself as essential to delivering the best experience. The idea is to fulfill the moral and legal obligation to ensure that everyone associated with the establishment, whether employee, volunteer, student, tradesperson visitor, or resident, is fully protected from any personal, physical, and/or emotional harm, either on the premises or when engaged in activities relating to the establishment.
In an ever-evolving world of technology, personal safety and security have also seen significant advancements. One such innovation that has gained prominence, particularly among seniors and vulnerable individuals, is the personal alarm device. These unassuming small devices are making a big impact when it comes to ensuring the safety and well-being of those who use them.
Reasons to Own a Personal Emergency Response System(PERS)Senior Protection
Mobile Personal Emergency Response System helps seniors stay safe while maintaining independence in their own homes.
This Emergency Pendant offers Automatic fall detection at a time of an emergency with Two-way communication in an emergency.
The advanced Personal Emergency Response system comes with push-button & easy to use a two-way communication system. Quick connect to a trained operator who can contact emergency services to provide immediate assistance, GPS alert & optional fall detection. Know use of mPERS system their features and its benefits for senior protection.
Technology evolutions in disaster medicine - Crisis Response JournalEmily Hough
As medicine is always evolving, it is crucial for disaster medicine to apply technology, not as an exception, but as a necessity, Here is a glimpse of some ideas that might revolutionise disaster medicine in the future
Bay Area Alarm - Persona Response Medical Emergency SystemsCarolyn Steinberg
For anyone involved in helping seniors maintain independent living (friends, family and professionals). This presentation details the benefits of using the Personal Response Medical Emergency System offered by Bay Alarm Medical. I service Santa Clara County, CA and will be happy to personally answer any questions.
Presentation at 2007 Meeting of Indian Health Service in San DiegoNoel Eldridge
This is based on Jim Bagian's "Why Bother" (about patient safety) presentation. Jim was invited but had a conflict so I wen to the national meeting of the Indian Health Service. I think this was maybe a 75 minute presentation. I added some things to make it personal to me like the Jimi Hendrix Experience slide and slide 81 on the "tissue issue" in VA that I helped resolve during my work on hand hygiene improvement. The audience also seemed to like my closing slide.
Presentation at 2007 Meeting of Indian Health Service in San Diego
Alarm Fatigue Best Practices
1. Fall Management Best Practices
Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue
Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 53092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
Fall Practices
The number of medical devices with alarm systems is overwhelming: ECG
(electrocardiograms), ventilators, blood pressure monitors, infusion pumps,
pulse oximeters, central station monitors, bedside telemetry, are only a few of
such devices.
While these alarm-equipped devices are essential to providing safe care to
patients and residents, they create both opportunities and hazards in the
healthcare environment. With similar alarms sounds or false alarms, unintended
consequences including alarm fatigue poses a problem in facilities as the sheer
number of technological devices available increases every year.
Technology – Friendor Foe?
The two main purposes of alarms for medical devices is to alert caregivers about
a possible unsafe situation for their patient or to remind them some type of care
was required. With the flood of these types of products in the market,
caretakers are now inundated with hearing and responding to hundreds of
alarms from just one patient/resident’s room each day. Multiply that by caring
for multiple patients/ residents, and that can equal thousands of different alarm
sounds per day. This can result in clinicians becoming desensitized to the
offending alarms and consequently ignoring them, known as alarm fatigue.
Alarm fatigue is a persistent problem that is predominantly affecting Directors
of Nursing and their staff, including anyone who directly interacts with
patients/ residents. The issue is further complicated when alarms sound alike,
adding to a confusing situation. Various estimates show that more than 85% of
the time the indicated alarm does not require a response from a caretaker, but
they do not know this until after they have responded.
2. Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 530092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
White Paper, By David Lange 2
Fall Management Best Practices – Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue (cont’d)
www.rft.com
A secondary problem is the challenge in creating a home-like setting, which
would help a patient/resident with their recovery. The concept of creating a
home setting would include eliminating the constant barrage of noise, much of
that caused by alarm signals. The design of the physical environment also has a
substantial impact on the caregivers through creating more efficient and
productive work areas and the proper design of settings to mitigate medical
error.
Technology and its ever-changing advancements, is considered a natural part of
the acute and critical care environment. Physiologic monitoring is standard
practice in telemetry, acute, critical, and long-term care settings. The reality is
that technology and physiologic monitors are only as reliable as the clinicians
who use them. Thus, alarms are inherent in the work of caregivers, and are
intended to alert clinicians to deviations from a predetermined “normal”
status. Alarms are important and sometimes life-saving, and can compromise
patient/ resident safety if ignored.
A common goal of patient/resident safety and security providers is to utilize
technology so it allows caregivers and clinicians the ability to efficiently perform
their jobs, to enhance their roles with critical medical device alarms, not hinder.
The ultimate goal is providing the highest level of care.
An Urgent Safety Concern
According to a Boston Globe article, a 60-year old man died in the intensive care unit of a
hospital from a system failure as a result from a delayed response to an alarm signal, and
not from the injuries he sustained to his head from an accident. It took the staff one hour to
respond to a device alarm. As a result, his heart rate increased while his blood oxygen levels
fell to a level where he suffered irreversible brain damageand was eventually removed
from life support. His unanticipated death was a result of the failure to respond to
appropriate alarm signals in a timely manner.
The Joint Commission’s (a national quality control group) Sentinel Event database includes
reports between January 2009 and June 2012 indicating 98 alarm-relatedevents occurred.
Of those events, 80 resulted in death and 13 in permanent loss of function and 5 in
unexpected, additional stay. These injuries resulted from medication errors, ventilator use,
delays in treatment, and falls.1
3. Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 530092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
White Paper, By David Lange 3
Fall Management Best Practices – Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue (cont’d)
Bed and Chair Alarm Effective Practices
Bed and chair alarms may add to alarm fatigue by possibly desensitizing staff to
general alarm sounds, but this is a very small part of the overall problem. Proper
monitoring of bed and chair alarms is vital for a more home-like environment.
By using the most technologically current products, a facility can improve the
overall environment, leading to improved patient/resident care and recovery.
Many bed and chair devices now allow facilities to control and change the
device settings for the best configuration for each patient/resident. The
following can assist with eliminating alarm fatigue:
1. Silent alarms: eliminating audible alarms and utilizing silent, local alarms
can have many benefits. Silent alarms will signal through the system, for
example at a nurse’s station, and will eliminate the need to be within
earshot of the patient/resident. Unnecessary interaction is reduced. Time
saved can be used for actual care work and active interactions with
patients/residents. Silent alarms can also improve environment and
occupant’s satisfaction. Noisy environments add to patients’/residents’
anxiety and make rest and healing more difficult. The use of silent alarms
can greatly improve these conditions, and with satisfied customers and
relatives, the working atmosphere improves.
2. Delay setting: most basic devices are created to alert staff immediately
when the sensor pad detects an absence of weight. In some cases, this can
create nuisance alarms if a patient is simply shifting his/her weight
without actually leaving the bed or chair. By changing a delay setting
(generally anywhere from one to four seconds), the number of nuisance
alarms can be dramatically reduced. Of course, this is totally dependent
on the patient/resident and is not appropriate for all patients/residents.
3. Alarm tone setting: there are two main advantages of changing the actual
sound the control unit makes when egress is detected. The first is to
create a tone that does not sound the same as another medical device in
use. Different devices have different levels of urgency and can create a
difficult situation for staff if they sound alike. By changing the sound of the
4. Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 530092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
White Paper, By David Lange 4
Fall Management Best Practices – Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue (cont’d)
bed alarm they can make it distinctive from other products. The second
possibility is to vary tones for different patients/residents. That way, staff
will know which patient/resident is leaving their bed or chair the instant
they hear the alarm rather than waiting until they begin their search. This
feature does require more diligence on the part of the staff to learn the
corresponding tones.
4. Nurse call integration: facilities can also consider connecting the product
with an existing nurse call systemto create more safeguards for the
patient/resident. This will allow more people to be notified when a
patient/ resident has left their bed or chair without the need for any
audible alarm.
5. Recorded voice message: there are also two main advantages for using
the recorded voice option. The first: it is often more pleasant than the
alarm sounds, which can create a more home-like environment for
everyone. The second: recording a familiar voice – such as a spouse, child
or sibling – can be helpful to a patient/resident who experiences
confusion. Again, this is also to be used on a case-by-case basis since some
people can be so confused by hearing their spouse’s voice that they begin
to look for them in the room and become agitated. Used in the correct
manner, however, it can be a very effective tool.
6. Integrated floor mats: using a floor mat in combination with a bed or
chair alarm, the system now becomes more like an individualized
wandering systemrather than a simple egress system. This can be another
effective way to eliminate alarm fatigue.
Overall, there are key advantages to understanding the features of any alarm
unit in place and how to configure it to best work for the facility,
patients/residents, families, and visitors. Staff should be aware of what the
visual and audible indicators mean during some type of qualitative in-servicing.
Proper usage depends on everyone who uses the product understanding these
signals.
5. Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 530092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
White Paper, By David Lange 5
Fall Management Best Practices – Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue (cont’d)
Alarm Improvement Initiatives Your Facility Can
Institute
Some facilities concerned about alarm fatigue simply remove as many alarms as
possible, but how will a patient be better served by removing some of the safety
nets currently used? Will a patient’s welfare be improved with fewer safeguards
to help the staff? While addressing alarmfatigue, it’s important to keep the
patient’s safety at the forefront. ECRI has compiled a handbook of suggestions
and recommendations about managing the many alarms that are currently
utilized in today’s healthcare environment.2
Have a process in place for safe alarm management and response
Establish guidelines for alarm settings on alarm-equipped medical
devices used in high-risk areas and high-risk clinical conditions Create
guidelines for customizing alarm settings and limits for each patient or
resident Inventory all alarm-equipped medical devices and identify
default alarm settings and limits Inspect and maintain alarm-equipped
devices to provide for accurate and appropriate alarm settings,
detectability, and proper operation Provide ongoing training and
education of the clinical care team Form a cross-disciplinary team to
address alarm safety and the potential impact of alarm fatigue in all
patient and resident care areas Share your experiences and
information about your organization’s alarm-related incidents, lessons
learned and prevention strategies with appropriate organizations, such as
The Joint Commission and the FDA
Prepare, Plan and Prevent
Medical products with alarms started as simple devices intended for people to
“hear and respond,” but more analytic opportunities continue to be developed.
Key aspects to consider when assessing your alarm management practices:
When are these devices alarming? How long are they alarming?
How is my facility doing compared to an industry average? Are there
patterns that can be learned about the patient/ resident as a result of this
6. Lange Medical,LLC428 Alta Loma DriveThiensville, WI 530092
(800) 278-4293dlange@langemed.com
White Paper, By David Lange 6
Fall Management Best Practices – Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue (cont’d)
information? Is there proper training at your facility? Are
communication channels clearly defined?
Are responses to alarm events selective? Or does everyone react?
Are there metrics in place to track response time?
These questions will help the facilities shift their thinking from a “hear and
7. Fall Management Best Practices
Strategies for Reducing Alarm Fatigue
respond” to a “prepare, plan and prevent” methodology. The information can now
become part of a patient’s/resident’s overall careplan and not only keep them safer
but possibly help their overall recovery and healing. This type of methodology will
also allow staff to be more proactive with fall management protocols rather than
simply reacting to alarms. Also, putting metrics in place for tracking response times
will improve trends and issue areas.
An organizational focus on moving to this type of methodology is likely to yield positive
improvements in critical areas, such as patient/resident safety and satisfaction; clinical
outcomes; relevancy of clinical documentation; effectiveness of the careteam; and
staff morale.
Ironically, alarm systems were created to enhance patient and resident safety yet
have become an urgent patient/resident safety concern. We need to manage our
alarm systems to achieve the highest levels of both sensitivity and specificity. The
goal is to eliminate alarm fatigue and provide a safer health careenvironment.
References
1. Medical Alarm System Information, MedicalAlarmSystem.org, http://www.medicalalarmsystem.org /medical-alert-
alarmsystems.html
2. “Medical device alarm safety in hospitals,” The Joint Commission Sentinel Event Alert – Issue 50,
http://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/18/SEA_50_alarms_4 _5_13_FINAL1.PDF
3.“ECRI Institute’s Alarm Safety Handbook Helps Hospitals Minimize a Top Threat to Patient Safety,” ECRI Institute, https://
www.ecri.org/press/Pages/Alarm-Safety-Handbook-Minimize-Threat-Patient-Safety.aspx