AF Bagger Line – No. 1 Bad Actor
Total Production 2004 to 2006  = 10.3 Million Bags
Lost Production due to Equipment Breakdown
Lost Production due to Equipment Breakdown
Lost Production due to Equipment Breakdown 1600 Hours of Equipment Breakdowns 2004 – 2006 Equivalent of 1.25 Million Bags Production 2004 - 2006 46 Hours of Equipment Breakdowns/Month on Average $X.XX Million in lost profit
Maintenance Costs 2000 - 2006 YTD
Maintenance Costs 2000 – 2006 YTD
Maintenance Costs 2000 – 2006 YTD Over $1.7 Million in Maintenance Costs over Six Years Capital Project Scope in 2000 = $750K 37% Maintenance Cost/Capital Cost Annually Demand, Downtime and Maintenance Spend are all Increasing !
ACTION PLAN Operations : Jim Robinson, Randy Knowles, Operators Maintenance:  John Derrenbacher, Matt Clemens Engineering:  Tom Friedl, Drew Mummert Management:  Ron Pollock AF Bagger Bad Actor Focus Team
Bad Actor Focus Team Downtime Pareto Analysis
Bad Actor Focus Team Action Plan – Palletizer Engage Manufacturer – Premier Tech to evaluate machine (Jan-07) Develop Maintenance Project to address top recommendations Improved Photo-eyes Rebuild Pallet Dispenser Program Upgrade Improved Pacing Conveyor Belt Improved Bag Flattener Belt Adjustment Implement formal PM Program and Operator Performed Inspections
Bad Actor Focus Team Action Plan – Bagger Engage Sewing Head manufacturer – Fischbein to evaluate machine and train maintenance and operations (Feb-07) Address outstanding equipment issues and downtime causes Frequent bearing failures on in-feed belt pulleys Salt spillage from Bag Spout on pre-charge Bent Belt-Lifting mechanism shafts Bag Magazine Vacuum Plate/ Grippers and Vacuum Break Valve Hopper/Spout lifting mechanism wear (Winkle Bearings) Individual Gripper Arm and Conveyor Belt adjustments Implement formal PM Program and Operator Performed Inspections
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Sewing Heads Discovered no two heads were set to same stitch length (critical parameter for line speed synchronization) – established 2.5 SPI as standard Elected to have Fischbein resume Sewing Head service rather than McCain Industrial Considering new Fischbein short-stroke design sewing head for trial operation Training on set-up and troubleshooting by Bob Jenkins of Fischbein for mechanics and electricians Testing slower sewing station line speed (50-55 FPM)
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements In-Feed Belt Bearings Old style shielded bearing, typical failure mode – salt contamination New style sealed bearing with Teflon-impregnated fiberglass seal
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements  :  Salt Spout Hopper Redesign Separating the hopper from the spout reduces the load and wear on the lift mechanism and “winkle bearings”, an expensive  and time consuming rebuild
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements  :  Salt Spout Redesign
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Salt Spout Re-design Original Spout leaks salt on pre-charge, contaminating all moving machine components New Spout designed to hold salt on pre-charge with closely machined tolerances
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Salt Dust Collection No previous dust collection to capture dust generated during fill sequence New dust collection system installed over bag corners
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Conveyor Lift Shafts Original shafts unable to support load, causing sprocket misalignment and wear New shafts extend through both sprockets, providing maximum support
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Bag Magazine Vacuum Plate Original plate fastened incorrectly, clamps out of alignment to compensate New plate – clamps aligned for maximum gripping surface. Added vacuum break valve
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Bag Pusher Original pusher failed and re-welded numerous times New pusher
Bad Actor Focus Team Improvements Flattener Belt Adjuster Original mechanism failed repeatedly at the pinion gear New adjusting mechanism – 40 Roller Chain and sprockets
Bad Actor Focus Team Results

Af Bagger

  • 1.
    AF Bagger Line– No. 1 Bad Actor
  • 2.
    Total Production 2004to 2006 = 10.3 Million Bags
  • 3.
    Lost Production dueto Equipment Breakdown
  • 4.
    Lost Production dueto Equipment Breakdown
  • 5.
    Lost Production dueto Equipment Breakdown 1600 Hours of Equipment Breakdowns 2004 – 2006 Equivalent of 1.25 Million Bags Production 2004 - 2006 46 Hours of Equipment Breakdowns/Month on Average $X.XX Million in lost profit
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Maintenance Costs 2000– 2006 YTD Over $1.7 Million in Maintenance Costs over Six Years Capital Project Scope in 2000 = $750K 37% Maintenance Cost/Capital Cost Annually Demand, Downtime and Maintenance Spend are all Increasing !
  • 9.
    ACTION PLAN Operations: Jim Robinson, Randy Knowles, Operators Maintenance: John Derrenbacher, Matt Clemens Engineering: Tom Friedl, Drew Mummert Management: Ron Pollock AF Bagger Bad Actor Focus Team
  • 10.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Downtime Pareto Analysis
  • 11.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Action Plan – Palletizer Engage Manufacturer – Premier Tech to evaluate machine (Jan-07) Develop Maintenance Project to address top recommendations Improved Photo-eyes Rebuild Pallet Dispenser Program Upgrade Improved Pacing Conveyor Belt Improved Bag Flattener Belt Adjustment Implement formal PM Program and Operator Performed Inspections
  • 12.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Action Plan – Bagger Engage Sewing Head manufacturer – Fischbein to evaluate machine and train maintenance and operations (Feb-07) Address outstanding equipment issues and downtime causes Frequent bearing failures on in-feed belt pulleys Salt spillage from Bag Spout on pre-charge Bent Belt-Lifting mechanism shafts Bag Magazine Vacuum Plate/ Grippers and Vacuum Break Valve Hopper/Spout lifting mechanism wear (Winkle Bearings) Individual Gripper Arm and Conveyor Belt adjustments Implement formal PM Program and Operator Performed Inspections
  • 13.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Sewing Heads Discovered no two heads were set to same stitch length (critical parameter for line speed synchronization) – established 2.5 SPI as standard Elected to have Fischbein resume Sewing Head service rather than McCain Industrial Considering new Fischbein short-stroke design sewing head for trial operation Training on set-up and troubleshooting by Bob Jenkins of Fischbein for mechanics and electricians Testing slower sewing station line speed (50-55 FPM)
  • 14.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements In-Feed Belt Bearings Old style shielded bearing, typical failure mode – salt contamination New style sealed bearing with Teflon-impregnated fiberglass seal
  • 15.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements : Salt Spout Hopper Redesign Separating the hopper from the spout reduces the load and wear on the lift mechanism and “winkle bearings”, an expensive and time consuming rebuild
  • 16.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements : Salt Spout Redesign
  • 17.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Salt Spout Re-design Original Spout leaks salt on pre-charge, contaminating all moving machine components New Spout designed to hold salt on pre-charge with closely machined tolerances
  • 18.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Salt Dust Collection No previous dust collection to capture dust generated during fill sequence New dust collection system installed over bag corners
  • 19.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Conveyor Lift Shafts Original shafts unable to support load, causing sprocket misalignment and wear New shafts extend through both sprockets, providing maximum support
  • 20.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Bag Magazine Vacuum Plate Original plate fastened incorrectly, clamps out of alignment to compensate New plate – clamps aligned for maximum gripping surface. Added vacuum break valve
  • 21.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Bag Pusher Original pusher failed and re-welded numerous times New pusher
  • 22.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Improvements Flattener Belt Adjuster Original mechanism failed repeatedly at the pinion gear New adjusting mechanism – 40 Roller Chain and sprockets
  • 23.
    Bad Actor FocusTeam Results