How                      uses
to ignite WOM
with help from
Paul Freher                    Brandon Murphy
Buffalo Wild Wings                  22squared
pfreher@buffalowildwings.com       @brmurphy




          WOMMA Summit 11.19.10
But, we are...
Kinda small
Not ubiquitous
Have low(er) awareness levels
Fast Growth Over Past 6 Years
800

                            Number of Restaurants
672


544


 416


288


160
       2004   2005   2006     2007   2008    2009           2010 YTD
                                            End of Year Restaurant Counts
We’re a WOM Brand.
WOM has been key to our growth and success.
Buffalo Wild Wings...




   WINGS   BEER    SPORTS
Buffalo Wild Wings...

                 Social Experience


                        WINGS




                          BEER
        SPORTS
Buffalo Wild Wings...


              A place of...
              Camaraderie
              Banter
              Competition
              Connection
WE TARGET




SPORTS
Marketing facilitates
the social experience for sports fans
Awareness   Consideration      Decision/Use   Retention/Loyalty   Fan/Join




                            Advocacy Loop
Moles that extend the game...
                 Awareness   Consideration                           Decision/Use   Retention/Loyalty   Fan/Join




                                   Website, games and
                                   Buffalo Circle Program

  National
 Television
 Campaign




Program
integration
(Jimmy Kimmel,
ESPN)




                             Digital campaigns and applications




                                                                  Advocacy Loop
An experience that encourages interaction
                 Awareness   Consideration                                                       Decision/Use                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Retention/Loyalty   Fan/Join


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               In-store events - draft
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               parties and challenges

                                   Website, games and
                                   Buffalo Circle Program

  National
 Television
 Campaign                                                           *A limited number of leagues will be sponsored. You must hold your draft party at a participating Buffalo Wild Wings location to be eligible. 8 or more participants must be present at the draft party to be eligible. At participating
                                                                     restaurants only. ©2007 Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. All rights reserved. Copyright ©2007 SportsLine.com, Inc. All rights reserved. SportsLine is a registered service mark of SportsLine.com, Inc. CBS ”eye device” is a registered
                                                                     trademark of CBS Broadcasting, Inc. ©2007 DIRECTV, Inc. DIRECTV and the Cyclone Design logo are registered trademarks of DIRECTV, Inc.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                CHALLENGE




Program
integration
(Jimmy Kimmel,                                                                    POP Materials
ESPN)




                             Digital campaigns and applications




                                                                                                                                                                   Mobile Invitation Campaign




                                                                  Advocacy Loop
A community that engages advocates
                 Awareness   Consideration                                                       Decision/Use                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Retention/Loyalty     Fan/Join


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               In-store events - draft
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               parties and challenges

                                   Website, games and
                                   Buffalo Circle Program
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Facebook apps
  National
 Television
 Campaign                                                           *A limited number of leagues will be sponsored. You must hold your draft party at a participating Buffalo Wild Wings location to be eligible. 8 or more participants must be present at the draft party to be eligible. At participating
                                                                     restaurants only. ©2007 Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. All rights reserved. Copyright ©2007 SportsLine.com, Inc. All rights reserved. SportsLine is a registered service mark of SportsLine.com, Inc. CBS ”eye device” is a registered
                                                                     trademark of CBS Broadcasting, Inc. ©2007 DIRECTV, Inc. DIRECTV and the Cyclone Design logo are registered trademarks of DIRECTV, Inc.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                CHALLENGE




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Celebrity
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            engagements on
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Facebook




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Facebook Community,

Program
integration                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Brackets and
(Jimmy Kimmel,                                                                    POP Materials                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Fantasy
ESPN)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     League Play




                             Digital campaigns and applications




                                                                                                                                                                   Mobile Invitation Campaign




                                                                  Advocacy Loop
Our Strategy:

     Extend the social
     experience outside of
     the restaurant
Be strategic,
1   not just experimental
    What role does Facebook play for you in the
    context of other communications?
    Does it extend your value proposition, or is
    it another channel?
    With whom are you trying to develop a
    relationship?
Listen to what they
2   want to talk about

    It’s their platform, you’re a guest.
Look for shared passions
Football and Basketball
Teams and rivalries
Wings and beer
Escape from real life
Sauces and flavors
Fandom and competitive spirit
Look for         Listen
engagement       everywhere
insights:        you can:

Content type     Your Facebook page
Post frequency   Their Facebook pages
Time of day      Twitter activity
Day of week      Other brand’s
                 Facebook pages
3 Have a goal
  and establish some
  important benchmarks


                         http://www.flickr.com/photos/villasams/
1991435

Fan Growth

      143298

        Aug 09          Aug 10

     Increase organic impressions
    Increase average feedback rate
       Improve active fan ratio
     Optimize paid & organic likes
    Gain more coupon redemptions
    Get more fan-generated content
Celebrate
milestones
by thanking
your fans.
Celebrate milestones
by thanking your fans.
4




                      http://www.mayforth.com/talk_to_me/ttm_opener.htm




Have a conversation strategy,
not a marketing strategy or a “CRM strategy.”
It’s more like an ARM strategy (Advocate
Relationship Management).
Conversation Math

Word
      + Assets + Time + Topic = Interactions
Count




                   http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/22/facebook-edgerank/
Word Count

7000   6,404
                          Avg. Interactions
5600

4200

2800
                  1,580
1400
                               629         432        355
  0
       <10 (11)   10-19 (7)   20-29 (5)   30-39 (3)   >=40 (2)
Post Type

6000   5841
                       Avg. Interactions
4500


3000
               2021
1500                                995         769     910
                       530
   0
        Text   Photo   Text Link   Photo Link   Video   Poll
Best Time


  2:00 PM -4:00 PM
80/20 Rule
              People        Brand




                                    Misc.
Sports   Wings         Trivia
                                    Humor




    Content                          Calendar
5 Post like a friend,
    not a brand


Today’s a great day to try
    some delicious wings
 from Buffalo Wild Wings.

         Brand                           Friend



                       we call it the art of un-copywriting.
Be Timely
Ask a question
Invite passionate debate
Be funny
Don’t Edit
6 Recognize
  your fans’ awesomeness
7 Good content
  helps drive good conversation.

  Use engagement assets from websites and
  microsites as a means to spark and create
  conversation on Facebook.
7 Good content
    helps drive good conversation.




Fantasy
Pick ’em




                                     Influencer content
Videos


Polls




Analysis
8 Leverage POEM
   to drive growth of your fan base.




 PAID                 OWNED            EARNED
Combine the efficiency of marketplace ads
   with the effectiveness of homepage units.

ROS Units                Homepage Units




       Helps to increase and sustain your
       baseline of likes during off-times.
9 De ne Success
  Know when you’ve done well.


                                           Before: 1 post
                                           generated an
                                           average of
                                           75-100
                                           comments

                                           After: 1 post
                                           generated an
                                           average of
                                           1,500-3,000
                                           comments
                        Listen & Learned
                        Engaged & Activated
Fan Growth
Average Impressions/Month

1400000


1200000


1000000


800000


600000
          Dec 09   Jan 10   Feb 10   March 10   April 10   May 10   June 10   July 10   Aug 10
10 De ne Value
    Know that it’s making a difference.



 BWW Facebook fans visit more often and
 spend an average of $616 more per year
 than our typical customer.
10 De ne Value
    Know that it’s making a difference.


Social media tactics generate nearly 2.5
times more offline and online brand
conversations than non-social tactics. They
also yield 4X as many influenced purchases.
                        Source: Digital Actions and Their Effect on Advocacy, 22squared and Consumer Insights Inc., 2010.
                                         http://www.slideshare.net/brandonmurphy/the-true-value-of-social-media-4267498
1.    Be strategic, not just experimental
2.    Listen to what they want
3.    Have a goal, set some benchmarks
4.    Develop a conversation strategy
5.    Post like a friend, not like a brand
6.    Recognize your fans’ awesomeness
7.    Use good content to drive conversation
8.    Leverage POEM to grow likes
9.    De ne success, know when you did well
10.   De ne value, and make a difference
THANKS

                   Paul Freher Brandon Murphy
           Buffalo Wild Wings 22squared
pfreher@buffalowildwings.com @brmurphy
Notes
Key Partners   Things we’re exploring

               Facebook Places & Deals
               Facebook Groups


               Things we’ve tested




               Wall Coupon


                        Applications

Becoming a Top Brand on Facebook

  • 1.
    How uses to ignite WOM with help from Paul Freher Brandon Murphy Buffalo Wild Wings 22squared pfreher@buffalowildwings.com @brmurphy WOMMA Summit 11.19.10
  • 4.
    But, we are... Kindasmall Not ubiquitous Have low(er) awareness levels
  • 5.
    Fast Growth OverPast 6 Years 800 Number of Restaurants 672 544 416 288 160 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 YTD End of Year Restaurant Counts
  • 6.
    We’re a WOMBrand. WOM has been key to our growth and success.
  • 7.
    Buffalo Wild Wings... WINGS BEER SPORTS
  • 8.
    Buffalo Wild Wings... Social Experience WINGS BEER SPORTS
  • 9.
    Buffalo Wild Wings... A place of... Camaraderie Banter Competition Connection
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Marketing facilitates the socialexperience for sports fans
  • 12.
    Awareness Consideration Decision/Use Retention/Loyalty Fan/Join Advocacy Loop
  • 13.
    Moles that extendthe game... Awareness Consideration Decision/Use Retention/Loyalty Fan/Join Website, games and Buffalo Circle Program National Television Campaign Program integration (Jimmy Kimmel, ESPN) Digital campaigns and applications Advocacy Loop
  • 14.
    An experience thatencourages interaction Awareness Consideration Decision/Use Retention/Loyalty Fan/Join In-store events - draft parties and challenges Website, games and Buffalo Circle Program National Television Campaign *A limited number of leagues will be sponsored. You must hold your draft party at a participating Buffalo Wild Wings location to be eligible. 8 or more participants must be present at the draft party to be eligible. At participating restaurants only. ©2007 Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. All rights reserved. Copyright ©2007 SportsLine.com, Inc. All rights reserved. SportsLine is a registered service mark of SportsLine.com, Inc. CBS ”eye device” is a registered trademark of CBS Broadcasting, Inc. ©2007 DIRECTV, Inc. DIRECTV and the Cyclone Design logo are registered trademarks of DIRECTV, Inc. CHALLENGE Program integration (Jimmy Kimmel, POP Materials ESPN) Digital campaigns and applications Mobile Invitation Campaign Advocacy Loop
  • 15.
    A community thatengages advocates Awareness Consideration Decision/Use Retention/Loyalty Fan/Join In-store events - draft parties and challenges Website, games and Buffalo Circle Program Facebook apps National Television Campaign *A limited number of leagues will be sponsored. You must hold your draft party at a participating Buffalo Wild Wings location to be eligible. 8 or more participants must be present at the draft party to be eligible. At participating restaurants only. ©2007 Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. All rights reserved. Copyright ©2007 SportsLine.com, Inc. All rights reserved. SportsLine is a registered service mark of SportsLine.com, Inc. CBS ”eye device” is a registered trademark of CBS Broadcasting, Inc. ©2007 DIRECTV, Inc. DIRECTV and the Cyclone Design logo are registered trademarks of DIRECTV, Inc. CHALLENGE Celebrity engagements on Facebook Facebook Community, Program integration Brackets and (Jimmy Kimmel, POP Materials Fantasy ESPN) League Play Digital campaigns and applications Mobile Invitation Campaign Advocacy Loop
  • 16.
    Our Strategy: Extend the social experience outside of the restaurant
  • 17.
    Be strategic, 1 not just experimental What role does Facebook play for you in the context of other communications? Does it extend your value proposition, or is it another channel? With whom are you trying to develop a relationship?
  • 18.
    Listen to whatthey 2 want to talk about It’s their platform, you’re a guest.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Football and Basketball Teamsand rivalries Wings and beer Escape from real life Sauces and flavors Fandom and competitive spirit
  • 21.
    Look for Listen engagement everywhere insights: you can: Content type Your Facebook page Post frequency Their Facebook pages Time of day Twitter activity Day of week Other brand’s Facebook pages
  • 22.
    3 Have agoal and establish some important benchmarks http://www.flickr.com/photos/villasams/
  • 23.
    1991435 Fan Growth 143298 Aug 09 Aug 10 Increase organic impressions Increase average feedback rate Improve active fan ratio Optimize paid & organic likes Gain more coupon redemptions Get more fan-generated content
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    4 http://www.mayforth.com/talk_to_me/ttm_opener.htm Have a conversation strategy, not a marketing strategy or a “CRM strategy.” It’s more like an ARM strategy (Advocate Relationship Management).
  • 27.
    Conversation Math Word + Assets + Time + Topic = Interactions Count http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/22/facebook-edgerank/
  • 28.
    Word Count 7000 6,404 Avg. Interactions 5600 4200 2800 1,580 1400 629 432 355 0 <10 (11) 10-19 (7) 20-29 (5) 30-39 (3) >=40 (2)
  • 29.
    Post Type 6000 5841 Avg. Interactions 4500 3000 2021 1500 995 769 910 530 0 Text Photo Text Link Photo Link Video Poll
  • 30.
    Best Time 2:00 PM -4:00 PM
  • 31.
    80/20 Rule People Brand Misc. Sports Wings Trivia Humor Content Calendar
  • 32.
    5 Post likea friend, not a brand Today’s a great day to try some delicious wings from Buffalo Wild Wings. Brand Friend we call it the art of un-copywriting.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
    6 Recognize your fans’ awesomeness
  • 40.
    7 Good content helps drive good conversation. Use engagement assets from websites and microsites as a means to spark and create conversation on Facebook.
  • 41.
    7 Good content helps drive good conversation. Fantasy Pick ’em Influencer content
  • 42.
  • 44.
    8 Leverage POEM to drive growth of your fan base. PAID OWNED EARNED
  • 45.
    Combine the efficiencyof marketplace ads with the effectiveness of homepage units. ROS Units Homepage Units Helps to increase and sustain your baseline of likes during off-times.
  • 46.
    9 De neSuccess Know when you’ve done well. Before: 1 post generated an average of 75-100 comments After: 1 post generated an average of 1,500-3,000 comments Listen & Learned Engaged & Activated
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Average Impressions/Month 1400000 1200000 1000000 800000 600000 Dec 09 Jan 10 Feb 10 March 10 April 10 May 10 June 10 July 10 Aug 10
  • 49.
    10 De neValue Know that it’s making a difference. BWW Facebook fans visit more often and spend an average of $616 more per year than our typical customer.
  • 50.
    10 De neValue Know that it’s making a difference. Social media tactics generate nearly 2.5 times more offline and online brand conversations than non-social tactics. They also yield 4X as many influenced purchases. Source: Digital Actions and Their Effect on Advocacy, 22squared and Consumer Insights Inc., 2010. http://www.slideshare.net/brandonmurphy/the-true-value-of-social-media-4267498
  • 51.
    1. Be strategic, not just experimental 2. Listen to what they want 3. Have a goal, set some benchmarks 4. Develop a conversation strategy 5. Post like a friend, not like a brand 6. Recognize your fans’ awesomeness 7. Use good content to drive conversation 8. Leverage POEM to grow likes 9. De ne success, know when you did well 10. De ne value, and make a difference
  • 52.
    THANKS Paul Freher Brandon Murphy Buffalo Wild Wings 22squared pfreher@buffalowildwings.com @brmurphy
  • 53.
    Notes Key Partners Things we’re exploring Facebook Places & Deals Facebook Groups Things we’ve tested Wall Coupon Applications