JUSTEC2012 @ Naruto University of Education
9:20-9:50 July 7, 2012



    What determines willingness to study abroad in
              teacher training program?



  TOMIDA Eiji, Associate Professor, Ehime University
  Thilla Sivakumaran, Dean of the College of Education, Arkansas State University
  Manabu Sumida, Associate Professor, Ehime University




                                                                                    1
Background and Objectives
• Needs for teachers with international background
   – Many countries demand universities to train teacher candidates
     that can adapt to culturally diverse society
• A new international program
   – March 5th, 2012, University of Louisiana at Monroe (ULM)
     and Ehime University (EU) established a MOU
   – 20 students from each party visit the partner university for
     2 weeks to actively observe classrooms, spend time with
     students, and learn the educational systems abroad
• Objective
   – Explore the factors which
     determine motivation level
     to study abroad in ULM and
     EU with online survey

                                                                      2
Survey Overview
• Objectives
  – Explore potential interests/fears/affordability in students
  – Compare the results between ULM and EU
      • Expected to help us design the joint program between ULM & EU
• Method
  – Online survey after a class with a cell/smart phone
  – 5-point self-rating scales
  – Responded anonymously
• Respondents
  – CEHD at ULM                B1:24, B2:6,     B3:5,   B4:25   (60)
  – Faculty of Education at EU B2:122, B3:38,   B4:1,   M2:2    (163)

                                                                        3
Survey Contents
1.What Motivates students to go abroad
   –Cultural Tour, Speaking in foreign language, Visiting foreign
   schools, Teaching Practice, Developing teaching material, Learning in
   University, Meeting foreign Univ. students, Interaction with foreign school
   students
2.Destination
3.Potential Fears or Barriers
   –Security, Being Alone in a Host Country, Being Away from Family and
   Friends, Food in a Host Country, Cultural Differences , Cost of
   Participation, Language Barrier, Education Outcome, Avoiding Trouble in
   Host Country, Dislike of Travel
4.Language Proficiency
5.Learning Expectations
   –To Experience Different Cultures, To Gain Skills Teaching in a Foreign Language
   –To Improve Foreign Language Skills, To Advance Teaching Methods
   –To Learn About Foreign Education Systems
6.Foreign Experiences
7.Perceived Reasonable Costs for Study Abroad
                                                                                4
1. What motivate students to go abroad

                                                        Learning Meeting Interaction
               Speaking in Visiting          Developing
      Cultural                      Teaching               in a     foreign with foreign
                a foreign foreign             teaching
       Tour language schools Practice material foreign University school
                                                        University Students children


       3.60      3.37      3.55      3.42       3.13      3.18      3.28        3.38
ULM
       (1.55)    (1.44)    (1.33)   (1.28)     (1.37)    (1.46)     (1.55)     (1.52)

       3.61      3.13      3.42
                                      ˅
                                     2.77
                                                 ˅
                                                2.72      3.41
                                                                      ˅
                                                                    3.91
                                                                                 ˅
                                                                                3.91
EU
       (1.28)    (1.36)    (1.37)   (1.46)     (1.36)    (1.40)     (1.29)     (1.17)
                                     **          *                   **         **


                                                                                   5
2. Potential Fears or Barriers
                     Away
                     from                                  Doubting          Dislike
               Being
      Security       Family Food Cultural Cost    Language Education Trouble of
               Alone             Difference                Outcome
                     and                                                     Travel
                     Friends


       3.52   3.40   3.12    2.90   2.53   3.53     3.35     2.72    3.12     1.88
ULM
                             (1.40        (1.35
      (1.38) (1.37) (1.30)         (1.11)       (1.30) (1.40) (1.37) (1.22)
                               )            )
         ˅
       4.06   3.80   3.04
                              ˅
                             3.34
                                     ˅
                                    3.07   3.88
                                                      ˅
                                                    4.39
                                                               ˅ 3.85
                                                             2.07
                                                                  ˅            ˅
                                                                              2.36
EU
                             (1.35        (1.20
      (1.11) (1.35) (1.46)         (1.30)       (0.96) (1.03) (1.28) (1.34)
                               )            )
       **                     *     **              **       **       **       *


                                                                                6
3. Learning Expectations
What do they want to learn as student teachers abroad?

                                      Improve               Learn About
                Skills Teaching in               Advance
      Different                        Foreign                Foreign
                      Foreign                    Teaching
      Cultures                       Language                Education
                    Language                     Methods
                                        Skills                Systems
       4.13            3.45            3.88       3.55         3.68
ULM
       (1.24)         (1.20)          (1.19)     (1.32)       (1.23)
        4.11           3.58            3.89
                                                    ˅
                                                  4.17         3.94
 EU
       (0.98)         (1.01)          (1.01)     (0.98)       (0.95)
                                                  **




                                                                      7
Regression Analysis:
              What determines willingness to go abroad
•   Stepwise procedure was performed for each university’s dataset
     – Objective variable: How much the respondents want to go abroad
     – Explaining variables: Almost all variables in the survey

•   ULM
                                              Estimate         p-value      β
     – Barrier: Language                         .380          .0091*     .351
     – Foreign Experience                        .992          .0096*     .348
         • Adjusted determination coefficient .128

•   EU
                                                   Estimate    p-value     β
     –   Motive: Speaking in foreign language        .868      .002        .215
     –   Motive: Visiting foreign schools          1.352      <.001        .336
     –   Barrier: Dislike of Travel                - .711      .005      - .174
     –   Expectation: Foreign Education System     1.370      <.001        .238
           • Adjusted determination coefficient    .496


                                                                                  8
Discussion
• The different preferences in both students parties
   – What motivates students to go abroad
       • ULM: Practices as a teacher candidate
       • EU: interactions between both parties people
   – Potential Fears or Barriers
       • ULM: Doubting Education Outcome
       • EU: Many fears
           – However, EU students more want to go abroad significantly
   – Expectations in Exchange
       • Both students are highly interested in Experiencing Cultural difference
       • EU students more want to advance teaching method

• Designing exchange programs based on the preferences
• Recruiting student participation based on the preferencess

                                                                              9
Thank you!!
• This study was supported by JSPS Grant-in-Aid
  for Scientific Research (C)
  – Grant number 24530826, TOMIDA Eiji, 2012-2015
  – “Construction of the ability of collaborative public
    talk for teacher training”
     「教員養成のための協同的パブリック・トークの力量形成」




                                                       10

20120707justec tomida etal_shared

  • 1.
    JUSTEC2012 @ NarutoUniversity of Education 9:20-9:50 July 7, 2012 What determines willingness to study abroad in teacher training program? TOMIDA Eiji, Associate Professor, Ehime University Thilla Sivakumaran, Dean of the College of Education, Arkansas State University Manabu Sumida, Associate Professor, Ehime University 1
  • 2.
    Background and Objectives •Needs for teachers with international background – Many countries demand universities to train teacher candidates that can adapt to culturally diverse society • A new international program – March 5th, 2012, University of Louisiana at Monroe (ULM) and Ehime University (EU) established a MOU – 20 students from each party visit the partner university for 2 weeks to actively observe classrooms, spend time with students, and learn the educational systems abroad • Objective – Explore the factors which determine motivation level to study abroad in ULM and EU with online survey 2
  • 3.
    Survey Overview • Objectives – Explore potential interests/fears/affordability in students – Compare the results between ULM and EU • Expected to help us design the joint program between ULM & EU • Method – Online survey after a class with a cell/smart phone – 5-point self-rating scales – Responded anonymously • Respondents – CEHD at ULM B1:24, B2:6, B3:5, B4:25 (60) – Faculty of Education at EU B2:122, B3:38, B4:1, M2:2 (163) 3
  • 4.
    Survey Contents 1.What Motivatesstudents to go abroad –Cultural Tour, Speaking in foreign language, Visiting foreign schools, Teaching Practice, Developing teaching material, Learning in University, Meeting foreign Univ. students, Interaction with foreign school students 2.Destination 3.Potential Fears or Barriers –Security, Being Alone in a Host Country, Being Away from Family and Friends, Food in a Host Country, Cultural Differences , Cost of Participation, Language Barrier, Education Outcome, Avoiding Trouble in Host Country, Dislike of Travel 4.Language Proficiency 5.Learning Expectations –To Experience Different Cultures, To Gain Skills Teaching in a Foreign Language –To Improve Foreign Language Skills, To Advance Teaching Methods –To Learn About Foreign Education Systems 6.Foreign Experiences 7.Perceived Reasonable Costs for Study Abroad 4
  • 5.
    1. What motivatestudents to go abroad Learning Meeting Interaction Speaking in Visiting Developing Cultural Teaching in a foreign with foreign a foreign foreign teaching Tour language schools Practice material foreign University school University Students children 3.60 3.37 3.55 3.42 3.13 3.18 3.28 3.38 ULM (1.55) (1.44) (1.33) (1.28) (1.37) (1.46) (1.55) (1.52) 3.61 3.13 3.42 ˅ 2.77 ˅ 2.72 3.41 ˅ 3.91 ˅ 3.91 EU (1.28) (1.36) (1.37) (1.46) (1.36) (1.40) (1.29) (1.17) ** * ** ** 5
  • 6.
    2. Potential Fearsor Barriers Away from Doubting Dislike Being Security Family Food Cultural Cost Language Education Trouble of Alone Difference Outcome and Travel Friends 3.52 3.40 3.12 2.90 2.53 3.53 3.35 2.72 3.12 1.88 ULM (1.40 (1.35 (1.38) (1.37) (1.30) (1.11) (1.30) (1.40) (1.37) (1.22) ) ) ˅ 4.06 3.80 3.04 ˅ 3.34 ˅ 3.07 3.88 ˅ 4.39 ˅ 3.85 2.07 ˅ ˅ 2.36 EU (1.35 (1.20 (1.11) (1.35) (1.46) (1.30) (0.96) (1.03) (1.28) (1.34) ) ) ** * ** ** ** ** * 6
  • 7.
    3. Learning Expectations Whatdo they want to learn as student teachers abroad? Improve Learn About Skills Teaching in Advance Different Foreign Foreign Foreign Teaching Cultures Language Education Language Methods Skills Systems 4.13 3.45 3.88 3.55 3.68 ULM (1.24) (1.20) (1.19) (1.32) (1.23) 4.11 3.58 3.89 ˅ 4.17 3.94 EU (0.98) (1.01) (1.01) (0.98) (0.95) ** 7
  • 8.
    Regression Analysis: What determines willingness to go abroad • Stepwise procedure was performed for each university’s dataset – Objective variable: How much the respondents want to go abroad – Explaining variables: Almost all variables in the survey • ULM Estimate p-value β – Barrier: Language .380 .0091* .351 – Foreign Experience .992 .0096* .348 • Adjusted determination coefficient .128 • EU Estimate p-value β – Motive: Speaking in foreign language .868 .002 .215 – Motive: Visiting foreign schools 1.352 <.001 .336 – Barrier: Dislike of Travel - .711 .005 - .174 – Expectation: Foreign Education System 1.370 <.001 .238 • Adjusted determination coefficient .496 8
  • 9.
    Discussion • The differentpreferences in both students parties – What motivates students to go abroad • ULM: Practices as a teacher candidate • EU: interactions between both parties people – Potential Fears or Barriers • ULM: Doubting Education Outcome • EU: Many fears – However, EU students more want to go abroad significantly – Expectations in Exchange • Both students are highly interested in Experiencing Cultural difference • EU students more want to advance teaching method • Designing exchange programs based on the preferences • Recruiting student participation based on the preferencess 9
  • 10.
    Thank you!! • Thisstudy was supported by JSPS Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) – Grant number 24530826, TOMIDA Eiji, 2012-2015 – “Construction of the ability of collaborative public talk for teacher training” 「教員養成のための協同的パブリック・トークの力量形成」 10