SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 58
Aristotle University, Department of Mathematics Master in Web Science supported by Municipality of Veria Stochastic Modeling of Web Evolution S. Amarantidis, I. Antoniou,  M. Vafopoulos Mathematics Department  Aristotle University of Thessaloniki       SMTDA 2010 Chania, Crete, Greece
Contents What is the Web? What are the issues and problems? The Web as a Complex System Query-Web Models Stochastic Models and the Web 2
What is the Web? Internet ≠ Web  Web: a system of interlinked hypertext documents (html) with unique addresses (URI) accessed via the Internet (http) 3
Web milestones 4 1992: Tim Berners-Lee presents  the idea in CERN 1993: Dertouzos (MIT) and Metakides (EU) create W3C  appointing TBL as director
Why the Web is so successful? Is based on architecture (HTTP, URI, HTML) which is:  simple, free or cheap, open source, extensible tolerant networked  fun & powerful universal 5
Why is so successful? New experience of exploring & editing huge amount of information, people, abilities anytime, from anywhere The biggest human system with no central authority and control but with log data (Yotta* Bytes/sec) Has not yet revealed its full potential… *10248 6
We knew the Web was big...  1 trillion unique URIs(Google blog 7/25/2008) 2 billion users Google: 300 million searches/day US: 15 billion searches/month 72% of the Web population are active on at least 1 social network … 7 Source blog.usaseopros.com/2009/04/15/google-searches-per-day-reaches-293-million-in-march-2009/
Web: the new continent Facebook: 400 million active users 50% of our active users log on to Facebook in any given day 35 million users update their status each day 60 million status updates posted each day 3 billion photos uploaded to the site each month Twitter: 75 million active users 141 employees  Youtube: 350 million daily visitors Flickr: 35 million daily visitors 8
Web: the new continent Online advertising spending in the UK has overtaken television expenditure for the first time [4 billion Euros/year] (30/9/2009, BBC) In US, spending on digital marketing will overtake that of print for the first time in 2010 Amazon.com: 50 million daily visitors 60 billion dollars market capitalization 24.000 employess 9
Web generations 10
Web: What are the issues and related problems? Safe surfing (navigating) Find relevant and credible information  (example: research) Create successful e-business Reduce tax evasion Enable local economic development Communicate with friends, colleagues, customers, citizens, voters,… 11
Need to study the Web The Web is the largest human information construct in history. The Web is transforming society… It is time to study it  systematically as stand- alone socio-technical artifact 12
How to study the Web? Analyze the interplay among the: Structure Function Evolution the Web as a highly inter-connected                         large complex system 13
 Web Modeling understand  measure and  model its evolution  in order to optimize its social benefit through effective policies  14
What is the Structure of the Web The Web as a Graph:  Nodes: the websites (URI)   more than 1 trillion Links: the hyperlinks     5 links per page (average)  Weights: link assessment  The WWW graph is  a Directed Evolving Graph 15 2 0.5   1.2 3   0.2 1  2.1 4
Statistical Analysis of Graphs:The degree distribution  P(k) = P(d ≤ k) is the distribution function of the random variable d that counts the degree of  a randomly chosen node.
 Statistical Analysis of the Web Graph four major findings: power law degree distribution       (self-similarity) internet traffic: Faloutsos Web links: Barabasi small world property       (the diameter is much smaller than the order of the graph)       easy communication many dense bipartite subgraphs on-line property       (the number of nodes and edges changes with time)
Distribution of links on the World-Wide Web          P(k)∼ k−γ power law a, Outgoing links (URLs found on an HTML document); b, Incoming links Web.c,  Average of the shortest path between two documents as a function of system size [Barabasi,ea 1999]
Small World Property Social Communication Networks Watts-Strogatz(1998) Short average path lengths and high clustering.  WWW Average Distance (Shortest Path) between 2 Documents: <ℓ> = 0.35 + 2.06 log(n) <ℓ> = 18.6, n = 8 x 108  (1999) <ℓ> = 18.9, n = 109  (2009) two randomly chosen documents on the web are on average  19 clicks away from each other. (Small World)
Web dynamics Search (PageRank, HITS, Markov matrices) Traffic  Evolution graph generators Games mechanism design (auctions) Queries-search engine-Web  20
Search The Hyperlink Matrix The page rank vector π, is an eigenvector of the Hyperlink Markov matrix M,  For the eigenvalue 1.  π is a stationary distribution Mπ = π π = (π(κ)), π(κ) = the pagerank of the web page κ dimΜ = the number of the web pages                 that can be crawled by search engines.
Basis of Google’s Algorithm If the Μarkovmatrix M is ergodic,      the stationary distribution vector ρ is unique. If the Μarkovmatrix Μ is mixing, then π is calculated as the limit   for every initial probability distribution ρ. The 2ndeigenvalueοf M estimates       the speed of Convergence
Internet Traffic Prigogine and Herman 1971  Stochastic model of vehicular traffic dynamics   based on statistical physics   between the macroscopic “fluid dynamics” model            and the individual vehicle model (1st order SDE) f0 is the "desired" velocity distribution function  x and v are the position and velocity of the "vehicles“    is the average velocity c is the concentration of the "vehicles“ P is the probability of "passing" in the sense of increase of flow,  T is the relaxation time.
Adaptation of the Prigogine - Hermann Model  for the Internet Traffic [Antoniou, Ivanov 2002,2003] Vehicles = the Information Packages Statistics of Information Packages: Log-Normal Distribution
The Origin of Power Law in Network Structure and Network Traffic Kolmogorov 1941, The local structure of the turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large Reynolds numbers, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 30, 301. The origin of Self-Similar Stochastic Processes  Model of the homogeneous fragmentation Applying a variant the central limit theorem, Kolmogorov found that  the logarithms of the grain sizes are normally distributed Before Fractals and Modern scale-free models,  Wavelet Analysis of data [Antoniou, Ivanov 2002]
Evolution: Graph Generators Erdős-Rényi (ER)model [Erdős, Rényi ‘60] Small-world model [Watts, Strogatz ‘98] Preferential Attachment [Barabási, Albert ‘99] EdgeCopying models [Kumar et al.’99], [Kleinberg et al.’99], Forest Fire model [Leskovec, Faloutsos ‘05] Kroneckergraphs [Leskovec, Chakrabarti, Kleinberg, Faloutsos ‘07] Optimization-based models [Carlson,Doyle,’00] [Fabrikant et al. ’02] 26
 Evolution: Game theoretic models   Stageman (2004) Information Goods and Advertising: An Economic Model of the Internet ZsoltKatona and MiklosSarvary (2007) Network Formation and the Structure of the Commercial World Wide Web Kumar (2009), Why do Consumers Contribute to Connected Goods 27
Evolution: Queries- Search Engine -Web Kouroupas, Koutsoupias, Papadimitriou, SideriKKPS 2005 Economic-inspired model (utility) Explains scale-free behavior In the Web three types of entities exist: Documents-i.e. web pages, created by authors [n]  Users [m] Topics [k] k≤m≤n 28
 the KKPS model The Search Engine recommends Documents to the Users  A User obtains satisfaction (Utility) after presented with some Documents by a Search Engine Users choose and endorse those that have the highest Utility for them, and then Search Engines make better recommendations based on these endorsements 29
 Documents  For each topic t ≤ kthere is a Document vector Dt of length n(relevance of Document d for Topic t) For Dtthe value 0 is very probable so that about k - 1 of every k entries are 0 30
 User-Query There are Users that can be thought as simple Queries asked by individuals.  For each topic t there is a User vector Rtof length m, (relevance of User-Query i for Topic t) with about m/k non-zero entries 31
 User-Query the number of Documents proposed by the Search Engine is fixed and denoted by α the number of endorsements per User-Query is also fixed and denoted by b b ≤ α ≤ n 32
 the algorithm  Step 1: A User-Query,for a specific Topic, isentered in the Search Engine Step 2: The Search Engine recommends αrelevant Documents. The listing order is defined by a rule. In the very first operation of the Search Engine the Documents the rule is random listing according to some probability distribution Step 3: Among the α recommended Documents, bareendorsed on the basis of highest Utility. In this way, the bipartite graph S= ([m], [n], L) of Document endorsements is formed. Compute the in-degree of the Documents from the endorsements  33
the algorithm  Step 4: Repeat Step 1 for another Topic. Step 5: Repeat Step 2. The rule for Documents listing is the decreasing in-degree for the specific User-Query computed in Step 3. Step 6: Repeat Step 3. Step 7: Repeat Steps 4, 5, 6 for a number of iterations necessary for statistical convergence (“that is, until very few changes are observed in the www state” )   34
 utility  35
36
 results of statistical experimentsKKPS  for a wide range of values of the parameters m, n, k, a, b, the in-degree of the documents is power-law distributed the price of anarchy (efficiency of algorithm) improved radically during the first 2-3 iterations and later the improvement had a slower rate 37
  results of statistical experimentsKKPS   When the number of topics k increases the efficiency of the algorithm increases When a increases (the number of recommended documents by the search engine) the efficiency of the algorithm also increases Increasing b (number of endorsed documents per user) causes the efficiency of the algorithm to decrease 38
results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos  we extend the investigation in two directions: for Uniform, Poisson and Normal initial random distribution of Documents in-degree (Step 2) and  for different values of α, b and k 39
  results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos    in the case α=b the validity of the power law becomes less significant as bincreases b: number of endorsed documents per user  a: the number of recommended documents by the search engine  40
  results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos    an increase in the number of Topics k, results faster decay of the power law exponent  41
Power law for the case b≤α
efficiency of the search algorithm  α=b efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of topics k increases [confirmation of KKPS results]
efficiency of the search algorithm  in the case b≤α efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of recommended Documents by the Search Engine α increases [confirmation of KKPS results]
efficiency of the search algorithm  b≤α efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of bof endorsed Documents per User-Query increases [KKPS results  not confirmed]
 Discussion of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos  α=b: all recommended Documents are endorsed according to the highest in-degree criterion  Utility is useful only in terms of establishing compatibility between Utility Matrix and the Users-Queries and Documents bipartite graph 46
Discussion of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos  origin of the power law distribution of the in-degree of Documents, two mechanisms are identified in the KKPS model: Users-Queries endorse a small fraction of Documents presented (b) Assuming a small fraction of poly-topic Documents, the algorithm creates a high number of endorsements for them The above mechanisms are not exhaustive for the real Web graph.       Indexing algorithms, crawler’s design, Documents structure and evolution should be examined as       possible additional mechanisms contributing to       the manifestation of the power law distribution 47
Discussion on the Endorsement Mechanism “The endorsement mechanism does not need to be specified, as soon as it is observable by the Search Engine. For example, endorsing a Document may entail clicking it, or pointing a hyperlink to it.”  This KKPS hypothesis does not take into account the fundamental difference between clicking a link (browsing) and creating a hyperlink.  48
 discussion Web traffic is observable by the website owner or administrator through the corresponding log file and by third parties authorized (like search engine cookies which can trace clicking behavior or malicious  49
 discussion  On the contrary, creating a hyperlink results in a more “permanent” link between two Documents which is observable by all Users-Queries and Search Engines.  Therefore, the KKPS algorithm actually examines the Web traffic and not the hyperlink structure of Documents which is the basis of the in-degree Search engine’s algorithm  50
 discussion  Web traffic as well as Web content editing, are not taken into account in the algorithms of Search engines based on the in-degree (i.e. Pagerank).  These algorithms were built for Web 1.0 where Web content update and traffic monetization were not so significant 51
 discussion   In the present Web 2.0 era with rapid change, the Web graph, content and traffic should be taken into account in efficient search algorithms.  Therefore, birth-death processes for Documents and links and Web traffic should be introduced in Web models, combined with content update (Web 2.0) and semantic markup (Web 3.0) for Documents.  52
 discussion  The discrimination between Users and Queries could facilitate extensions of the KKPS model:  teleportation           (a direct visit to a Document which avoids Search Engines) different types of Users and  relevance feedback between Documents and Queries  53
 discussion   KKPS: Utility is defined to be time invariant linear function of R and D which by construction is not affecting the www state when α=b not take into account the dynamic interdependence of the Utility on the www state. In reality, the evolution of the www state will change both R and D A future extension of KKPS model should account for user behavior by incorporating Web browsing and editing preferences 54
 discussion   useful to offer deeper insight in the Web’s economic aspects in the KKPS model: valuation mechanisms for Web traffic and link structures and  monetizing the search procedure (sponsored search, digital goods, excludable, anti-rival goods etc)  55
Stochastic Models and the Web Webmetrics: statistical models for the Web function, structure & evolution in order to evaluate individual, business and public policies 56
Master in web science is based on Web assessment, mathematical modeling and operation combined with business applications and societal transformations in the knowledge society. Web science studies, apart from Academic, Research and Training careers offer remarkable opportunities in Business. 57 WS.01 lecture 1: Web history Michalis Vafopoulos
Master in web science 58 Michalis Vafopoulos

More Related Content

What's hot

Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative Thinking
Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative ThinkingFigures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative Thinking
Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative ThinkingBernhard Rieder
 
Top 10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology
 Top  10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology Top  10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology
Top 10 Read articles in Web & semantic technologydannyijwest
 
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And Utilising
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And UtilisingExploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And Utilising
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And UtilisingOwen Sacco
 
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.Bernhard Rieder
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)IJERD Editor
 
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...Bernhard Rieder
 
Streaming Graph Processing and Analytics
Streaming Graph Processing and AnalyticsStreaming Graph Processing and Analytics
Streaming Graph Processing and AnalyticsM. Tamer Özsu
 
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric Diversification
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric DiversificationOn Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric Diversification
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric DiversificationBernhard Rieder
 
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of Life
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of LifeVisually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of Life
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of LifeHarish Vaidyanathan
 
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...Waqas Tariq
 
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?Bernhard Rieder
 
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...Gabriela Agustini
 
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephi
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephiInteractive visualization and exploration of network data with gephi
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephiBernhard Rieder
 

What's hot (20)

Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative Thinking
Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative ThinkingFigures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative Thinking
Figures of the Many - Quantitative Concepts for Qualitative Thinking
 
Top 10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology
 Top  10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology Top  10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology
Top 10 Read articles in Web & semantic technology
 
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And Utilising
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And UtilisingExploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And Utilising
Exploiting Semantic Web Techniques For Representing And Utilising
 
GI Management Transformation: from geometry to databased relationships
GI Management Transformation: from geometry to databased relationshipsGI Management Transformation: from geometry to databased relationships
GI Management Transformation: from geometry to databased relationships
 
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.
Engines of Order. Social Media and the Rise of Algorithmic Knowing.
 
Data Power
Data PowerData Power
Data Power
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
 
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...
Analyzing Social Media with Digital Methods. Possibilities, Requirements, and...
 
Ongoing Research in Data Studies
Ongoing Research in Data StudiesOngoing Research in Data Studies
Ongoing Research in Data Studies
 
Streaming Graph Processing and Analytics
Streaming Graph Processing and AnalyticsStreaming Graph Processing and Analytics
Streaming Graph Processing and Analytics
 
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric Diversification
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric DiversificationOn Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric Diversification
On Digital Markets, Data, and Concentric Diversification
 
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of Life
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of LifeVisually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of Life
Visually Exploring Social Participation in Encyclopedia of Life
 
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...
Integrating Web Services With Geospatial Data Mining Disaster Management for ...
 
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?
From Algorithms to Diagrams: How to Study Platforms?
 
Linked data migrational framework
Linked data migrational frameworkLinked data migrational framework
Linked data migrational framework
 
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...
Subgraph Frequencies: Mapping the Empirical and Extremal Geography of Large G...
 
Homelessness Data Discussion
Homelessness Data DiscussionHomelessness Data Discussion
Homelessness Data Discussion
 
Community Data Program Submitted letter to Open Government Partneship
Community Data Program Submitted letter to Open Government PartneshipCommunity Data Program Submitted letter to Open Government Partneship
Community Data Program Submitted letter to Open Government Partneship
 
Critical Data Studies in the Academy
Critical Data Studies in the AcademyCritical Data Studies in the Academy
Critical Data Studies in the Academy
 
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephi
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephiInteractive visualization and exploration of network data with gephi
Interactive visualization and exploration of network data with gephi
 

Similar to 2010 06-08 chania stochastic web modelling - copy

AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...
AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...
AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...ijcsit
 
On the Navigability of Social Tagging Systems
On the Navigability of Social Tagging SystemsOn the Navigability of Social Tagging Systems
On the Navigability of Social Tagging SystemsMarkus Strohmaier
 
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data sets
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data setsMeasurement and modeling of the web and related data sets
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data setsMark J. Feldman
 
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008Emanuele Della Valle
 
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Enrico Motta
 
Open System Interconnection Model Essay
Open System Interconnection Model EssayOpen System Interconnection Model Essay
Open System Interconnection Model EssayJessica Deakin
 
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operations
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operationsData Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operations
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operationsVincenzo Gulisano
 
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networks
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula NetworksSub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networks
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networksijceronline
 
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3SMCFrance
 
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...CSCJournals
 
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...IJCNCJournal
 
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technology
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic TechnologyJune 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technology
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technologydannyijwest
 
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...Nurhazman Abdul Aziz
 
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1 50+ Abst
Ncct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1   50+ AbstNcct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1   50+ Abst
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1 50+ Abstncct
 
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATA
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATAMINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATA
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATAcscpconf
 
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data csandit
 
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered DesignUsability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design@cristobalcobo
 

Similar to 2010 06-08 chania stochastic web modelling - copy (20)

AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...
AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...
AN APPROACH TO EXTRACTING DISTRIBUTED DATA FROM THE INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENT OF...
 
On the Navigability of Social Tagging Systems
On the Navigability of Social Tagging SystemsOn the Navigability of Social Tagging Systems
On the Navigability of Social Tagging Systems
 
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data sets
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data setsMeasurement and modeling of the web and related data sets
Measurement and modeling of the web and related data sets
 
ICT AND URBAN PLANNING. By Antonio Caperna
ICT AND URBAN PLANNING. By Antonio CapernaICT AND URBAN PLANNING. By Antonio Caperna
ICT AND URBAN PLANNING. By Antonio Caperna
 
Network Science: Theory, Modeling and Applications
Network Science: Theory, Modeling and ApplicationsNetwork Science: Theory, Modeling and Applications
Network Science: Theory, Modeling and Applications
 
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008
A First Step Towards Stream Reasoning at FIS 2008
 
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
 
Open System Interconnection Model Essay
Open System Interconnection Model EssayOpen System Interconnection Model Essay
Open System Interconnection Model Essay
 
CyberDefPos_Scott
CyberDefPos_ScottCyberDefPos_Scott
CyberDefPos_Scott
 
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operations
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operationsData Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operations
Data Streaming (in a Nutshell) ... and Spark's window operations
 
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networks
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula NetworksSub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networks
Sub-Graph Finding Information over Nebula Networks
 
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3
Franck Rebillard, Professeur Université Paris 3
 
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...
The Design of a Simulation for the Modeling and Analysis of Public Transporta...
 
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...
On the development of methodology for planning and cost modeling of a wide ar...
 
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technology
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic TechnologyJune 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technology
June 2023:Top 10 Cited Articles in Web & Semantic Technology
 
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...
Applications of xml, semantic web or linked data in Library/Information Servi...
 
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1 50+ Abst
Ncct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1   50+ AbstNcct   Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1   50+ Abst
Ncct Ieee Software Abstract Collection Volume 1 50+ Abst
 
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATA
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATAMINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATA
MINING FUZZY ASSOCIATION RULES FROM WEB USAGE QUANTITATIVE DATA
 
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data
Mining Fuzzy Association Rules from Web Usage Quantitative Data
 
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered DesignUsability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design
Usability First - Introduction to User-Centered Design
 

More from vafopoulos

publicspending.gr
publicspending.grpublicspending.gr
publicspending.grvafopoulos
 
2011 05-02 linked data intro
2011 05-02 linked data intro2011 05-02 linked data intro
2011 05-02 linked data introvafopoulos
 
2011 05-01 linked data
2011 05-01 linked data2011 05-01 linked data
2011 05-01 linked datavafopoulos
 
Amaxus con webdoc_10773
Amaxus con webdoc_10773Amaxus con webdoc_10773
Amaxus con webdoc_10773vafopoulos
 
Ws13 1(2010-11)
Ws13 1(2010-11)Ws13 1(2010-11)
Ws13 1(2010-11)vafopoulos
 
Ws13 2(2010-11)
Ws13 2(2010-11)Ws13 2(2010-11)
Ws13 2(2010-11)vafopoulos
 
Ws 13-3(2010-11)
Ws 13-3(2010-11)Ws 13-3(2010-11)
Ws 13-3(2010-11)vafopoulos
 
Ws 13-4(2010-11)
Ws 13-4(2010-11)Ws 13-4(2010-11)
Ws 13-4(2010-11)vafopoulos
 
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos finalvafopoulos
 
Presentation gr
Presentation grPresentation gr
Presentation grvafopoulos
 
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janus
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janusVafopoulos is the 2faces of janus
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janusvafopoulos
 
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiouvafopoulos
 
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλες
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλεςκοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλες
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλεςvafopoulos
 
2010 02-24 ws gm logic
2010 02-24 ws gm logic2010 02-24 ws gm logic
2010 02-24 ws gm logicvafopoulos
 
Wiki technologies nov_2008_ye
Wiki technologies nov_2008_yeWiki technologies nov_2008_ye
Wiki technologies nov_2008_yevafopoulos
 
Issue 11834$pdf
Issue 11834$pdfIssue 11834$pdf
Issue 11834$pdfvafopoulos
 
Gget 30 webscience
Gget 30 webscienceGget 30 webscience
Gget 30 websciencevafopoulos
 
Mit csail-tr-2007-034
Mit csail-tr-2007-034Mit csail-tr-2007-034
Mit csail-tr-2007-034vafopoulos
 
Riseptis report 1
Riseptis report 1Riseptis report 1
Riseptis report 1vafopoulos
 

More from vafopoulos (20)

publicspending.gr
publicspending.grpublicspending.gr
publicspending.gr
 
2011 05-02 linked data intro
2011 05-02 linked data intro2011 05-02 linked data intro
2011 05-02 linked data intro
 
2011 05-01 linked data
2011 05-01 linked data2011 05-01 linked data
2011 05-01 linked data
 
D bpedia
D bpediaD bpedia
D bpedia
 
Amaxus con webdoc_10773
Amaxus con webdoc_10773Amaxus con webdoc_10773
Amaxus con webdoc_10773
 
Ws13 1(2010-11)
Ws13 1(2010-11)Ws13 1(2010-11)
Ws13 1(2010-11)
 
Ws13 2(2010-11)
Ws13 2(2010-11)Ws13 2(2010-11)
Ws13 2(2010-11)
 
Ws 13-3(2010-11)
Ws 13-3(2010-11)Ws 13-3(2010-11)
Ws 13-3(2010-11)
 
Ws 13-4(2010-11)
Ws 13-4(2010-11)Ws 13-4(2010-11)
Ws 13-4(2010-11)
 
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final
2010 07 modeling web evolution amarantidis antoniou vafopoulos final
 
Presentation gr
Presentation grPresentation gr
Presentation gr
 
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janus
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janusVafopoulos is the 2faces of janus
Vafopoulos is the 2faces of janus
 
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou
2010 3-24 cryptography stamatiou
 
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλες
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλεςκοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλες
κοινωνια της πληροφοριας ευκαιριες και απειλες
 
2010 02-24 ws gm logic
2010 02-24 ws gm logic2010 02-24 ws gm logic
2010 02-24 ws gm logic
 
Wiki technologies nov_2008_ye
Wiki technologies nov_2008_yeWiki technologies nov_2008_ye
Wiki technologies nov_2008_ye
 
Issue 11834$pdf
Issue 11834$pdfIssue 11834$pdf
Issue 11834$pdf
 
Gget 30 webscience
Gget 30 webscienceGget 30 webscience
Gget 30 webscience
 
Mit csail-tr-2007-034
Mit csail-tr-2007-034Mit csail-tr-2007-034
Mit csail-tr-2007-034
 
Riseptis report 1
Riseptis report 1Riseptis report 1
Riseptis report 1
 

2010 06-08 chania stochastic web modelling - copy

  • 1. Aristotle University, Department of Mathematics Master in Web Science supported by Municipality of Veria Stochastic Modeling of Web Evolution S. Amarantidis, I. Antoniou, M. Vafopoulos Mathematics Department Aristotle University of Thessaloniki SMTDA 2010 Chania, Crete, Greece
  • 2. Contents What is the Web? What are the issues and problems? The Web as a Complex System Query-Web Models Stochastic Models and the Web 2
  • 3. What is the Web? Internet ≠ Web Web: a system of interlinked hypertext documents (html) with unique addresses (URI) accessed via the Internet (http) 3
  • 4. Web milestones 4 1992: Tim Berners-Lee presents the idea in CERN 1993: Dertouzos (MIT) and Metakides (EU) create W3C appointing TBL as director
  • 5. Why the Web is so successful? Is based on architecture (HTTP, URI, HTML) which is: simple, free or cheap, open source, extensible tolerant networked fun & powerful universal 5
  • 6. Why is so successful? New experience of exploring & editing huge amount of information, people, abilities anytime, from anywhere The biggest human system with no central authority and control but with log data (Yotta* Bytes/sec) Has not yet revealed its full potential… *10248 6
  • 7. We knew the Web was big... 1 trillion unique URIs(Google blog 7/25/2008) 2 billion users Google: 300 million searches/day US: 15 billion searches/month 72% of the Web population are active on at least 1 social network … 7 Source blog.usaseopros.com/2009/04/15/google-searches-per-day-reaches-293-million-in-march-2009/
  • 8. Web: the new continent Facebook: 400 million active users 50% of our active users log on to Facebook in any given day 35 million users update their status each day 60 million status updates posted each day 3 billion photos uploaded to the site each month Twitter: 75 million active users 141 employees Youtube: 350 million daily visitors Flickr: 35 million daily visitors 8
  • 9. Web: the new continent Online advertising spending in the UK has overtaken television expenditure for the first time [4 billion Euros/year] (30/9/2009, BBC) In US, spending on digital marketing will overtake that of print for the first time in 2010 Amazon.com: 50 million daily visitors 60 billion dollars market capitalization 24.000 employess 9
  • 11. Web: What are the issues and related problems? Safe surfing (navigating) Find relevant and credible information (example: research) Create successful e-business Reduce tax evasion Enable local economic development Communicate with friends, colleagues, customers, citizens, voters,… 11
  • 12. Need to study the Web The Web is the largest human information construct in history. The Web is transforming society… It is time to study it systematically as stand- alone socio-technical artifact 12
  • 13. How to study the Web? Analyze the interplay among the: Structure Function Evolution the Web as a highly inter-connected large complex system 13
  • 14. Web Modeling understand measure and model its evolution in order to optimize its social benefit through effective policies 14
  • 15. What is the Structure of the Web The Web as a Graph: Nodes: the websites (URI) more than 1 trillion Links: the hyperlinks 5 links per page (average) Weights: link assessment The WWW graph is a Directed Evolving Graph 15 2 0.5 1.2 3 0.2 1 2.1 4
  • 16. Statistical Analysis of Graphs:The degree distribution P(k) = P(d ≤ k) is the distribution function of the random variable d that counts the degree of a randomly chosen node.
  • 17. Statistical Analysis of the Web Graph four major findings: power law degree distribution (self-similarity) internet traffic: Faloutsos Web links: Barabasi small world property (the diameter is much smaller than the order of the graph) easy communication many dense bipartite subgraphs on-line property (the number of nodes and edges changes with time)
  • 18. Distribution of links on the World-Wide Web P(k)∼ k−γ power law a, Outgoing links (URLs found on an HTML document); b, Incoming links Web.c, Average of the shortest path between two documents as a function of system size [Barabasi,ea 1999]
  • 19. Small World Property Social Communication Networks Watts-Strogatz(1998) Short average path lengths and high clustering. WWW Average Distance (Shortest Path) between 2 Documents: <ℓ> = 0.35 + 2.06 log(n) <ℓ> = 18.6, n = 8 x 108 (1999) <ℓ> = 18.9, n = 109 (2009) two randomly chosen documents on the web are on average 19 clicks away from each other. (Small World)
  • 20. Web dynamics Search (PageRank, HITS, Markov matrices) Traffic Evolution graph generators Games mechanism design (auctions) Queries-search engine-Web 20
  • 21. Search The Hyperlink Matrix The page rank vector π, is an eigenvector of the Hyperlink Markov matrix M, For the eigenvalue 1. π is a stationary distribution Mπ = π π = (π(κ)), π(κ) = the pagerank of the web page κ dimΜ = the number of the web pages that can be crawled by search engines.
  • 22. Basis of Google’s Algorithm If the Μarkovmatrix M is ergodic, the stationary distribution vector ρ is unique. If the Μarkovmatrix Μ is mixing, then π is calculated as the limit for every initial probability distribution ρ. The 2ndeigenvalueοf M estimates the speed of Convergence
  • 23. Internet Traffic Prigogine and Herman 1971 Stochastic model of vehicular traffic dynamics based on statistical physics between the macroscopic “fluid dynamics” model and the individual vehicle model (1st order SDE) f0 is the "desired" velocity distribution function x and v are the position and velocity of the "vehicles“ is the average velocity c is the concentration of the "vehicles“ P is the probability of "passing" in the sense of increase of flow, T is the relaxation time.
  • 24. Adaptation of the Prigogine - Hermann Model for the Internet Traffic [Antoniou, Ivanov 2002,2003] Vehicles = the Information Packages Statistics of Information Packages: Log-Normal Distribution
  • 25. The Origin of Power Law in Network Structure and Network Traffic Kolmogorov 1941, The local structure of the turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large Reynolds numbers, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 30, 301. The origin of Self-Similar Stochastic Processes Model of the homogeneous fragmentation Applying a variant the central limit theorem, Kolmogorov found that the logarithms of the grain sizes are normally distributed Before Fractals and Modern scale-free models, Wavelet Analysis of data [Antoniou, Ivanov 2002]
  • 26. Evolution: Graph Generators Erdős-Rényi (ER)model [Erdős, Rényi ‘60] Small-world model [Watts, Strogatz ‘98] Preferential Attachment [Barabási, Albert ‘99] EdgeCopying models [Kumar et al.’99], [Kleinberg et al.’99], Forest Fire model [Leskovec, Faloutsos ‘05] Kroneckergraphs [Leskovec, Chakrabarti, Kleinberg, Faloutsos ‘07] Optimization-based models [Carlson,Doyle,’00] [Fabrikant et al. ’02] 26
  • 27. Evolution: Game theoretic models Stageman (2004) Information Goods and Advertising: An Economic Model of the Internet ZsoltKatona and MiklosSarvary (2007) Network Formation and the Structure of the Commercial World Wide Web Kumar (2009), Why do Consumers Contribute to Connected Goods 27
  • 28. Evolution: Queries- Search Engine -Web Kouroupas, Koutsoupias, Papadimitriou, SideriKKPS 2005 Economic-inspired model (utility) Explains scale-free behavior In the Web three types of entities exist: Documents-i.e. web pages, created by authors [n] Users [m] Topics [k] k≤m≤n 28
  • 29. the KKPS model The Search Engine recommends Documents to the Users A User obtains satisfaction (Utility) after presented with some Documents by a Search Engine Users choose and endorse those that have the highest Utility for them, and then Search Engines make better recommendations based on these endorsements 29
  • 30. Documents For each topic t ≤ kthere is a Document vector Dt of length n(relevance of Document d for Topic t) For Dtthe value 0 is very probable so that about k - 1 of every k entries are 0 30
  • 31. User-Query There are Users that can be thought as simple Queries asked by individuals. For each topic t there is a User vector Rtof length m, (relevance of User-Query i for Topic t) with about m/k non-zero entries 31
  • 32. User-Query the number of Documents proposed by the Search Engine is fixed and denoted by α the number of endorsements per User-Query is also fixed and denoted by b b ≤ α ≤ n 32
  • 33. the algorithm Step 1: A User-Query,for a specific Topic, isentered in the Search Engine Step 2: The Search Engine recommends αrelevant Documents. The listing order is defined by a rule. In the very first operation of the Search Engine the Documents the rule is random listing according to some probability distribution Step 3: Among the α recommended Documents, bareendorsed on the basis of highest Utility. In this way, the bipartite graph S= ([m], [n], L) of Document endorsements is formed. Compute the in-degree of the Documents from the endorsements 33
  • 34. the algorithm Step 4: Repeat Step 1 for another Topic. Step 5: Repeat Step 2. The rule for Documents listing is the decreasing in-degree for the specific User-Query computed in Step 3. Step 6: Repeat Step 3. Step 7: Repeat Steps 4, 5, 6 for a number of iterations necessary for statistical convergence (“that is, until very few changes are observed in the www state” ) 34
  • 35. utility 35
  • 36. 36
  • 37. results of statistical experimentsKKPS for a wide range of values of the parameters m, n, k, a, b, the in-degree of the documents is power-law distributed the price of anarchy (efficiency of algorithm) improved radically during the first 2-3 iterations and later the improvement had a slower rate 37
  • 38. results of statistical experimentsKKPS When the number of topics k increases the efficiency of the algorithm increases When a increases (the number of recommended documents by the search engine) the efficiency of the algorithm also increases Increasing b (number of endorsed documents per user) causes the efficiency of the algorithm to decrease 38
  • 39. results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos we extend the investigation in two directions: for Uniform, Poisson and Normal initial random distribution of Documents in-degree (Step 2) and for different values of α, b and k 39
  • 40. results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos in the case α=b the validity of the power law becomes less significant as bincreases b: number of endorsed documents per user a: the number of recommended documents by the search engine 40
  • 41. results of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos an increase in the number of Topics k, results faster decay of the power law exponent 41
  • 42. Power law for the case b≤α
  • 43. efficiency of the search algorithm α=b efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of topics k increases [confirmation of KKPS results]
  • 44. efficiency of the search algorithm in the case b≤α efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of recommended Documents by the Search Engine α increases [confirmation of KKPS results]
  • 45. efficiency of the search algorithm b≤α efficiency of the search algorithm increases when the number of bof endorsed Documents per User-Query increases [KKPS results not confirmed]
  • 46. Discussion of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos α=b: all recommended Documents are endorsed according to the highest in-degree criterion Utility is useful only in terms of establishing compatibility between Utility Matrix and the Users-Queries and Documents bipartite graph 46
  • 47. Discussion of statistical experimentsAmarantidis-Antoniou-Vafopoulos origin of the power law distribution of the in-degree of Documents, two mechanisms are identified in the KKPS model: Users-Queries endorse a small fraction of Documents presented (b) Assuming a small fraction of poly-topic Documents, the algorithm creates a high number of endorsements for them The above mechanisms are not exhaustive for the real Web graph. Indexing algorithms, crawler’s design, Documents structure and evolution should be examined as possible additional mechanisms contributing to the manifestation of the power law distribution 47
  • 48. Discussion on the Endorsement Mechanism “The endorsement mechanism does not need to be specified, as soon as it is observable by the Search Engine. For example, endorsing a Document may entail clicking it, or pointing a hyperlink to it.” This KKPS hypothesis does not take into account the fundamental difference between clicking a link (browsing) and creating a hyperlink. 48
  • 49. discussion Web traffic is observable by the website owner or administrator through the corresponding log file and by third parties authorized (like search engine cookies which can trace clicking behavior or malicious 49
  • 50. discussion On the contrary, creating a hyperlink results in a more “permanent” link between two Documents which is observable by all Users-Queries and Search Engines. Therefore, the KKPS algorithm actually examines the Web traffic and not the hyperlink structure of Documents which is the basis of the in-degree Search engine’s algorithm 50
  • 51. discussion Web traffic as well as Web content editing, are not taken into account in the algorithms of Search engines based on the in-degree (i.e. Pagerank). These algorithms were built for Web 1.0 where Web content update and traffic monetization were not so significant 51
  • 52. discussion In the present Web 2.0 era with rapid change, the Web graph, content and traffic should be taken into account in efficient search algorithms. Therefore, birth-death processes for Documents and links and Web traffic should be introduced in Web models, combined with content update (Web 2.0) and semantic markup (Web 3.0) for Documents. 52
  • 53. discussion The discrimination between Users and Queries could facilitate extensions of the KKPS model: teleportation (a direct visit to a Document which avoids Search Engines) different types of Users and relevance feedback between Documents and Queries 53
  • 54. discussion KKPS: Utility is defined to be time invariant linear function of R and D which by construction is not affecting the www state when α=b not take into account the dynamic interdependence of the Utility on the www state. In reality, the evolution of the www state will change both R and D A future extension of KKPS model should account for user behavior by incorporating Web browsing and editing preferences 54
  • 55. discussion useful to offer deeper insight in the Web’s economic aspects in the KKPS model: valuation mechanisms for Web traffic and link structures and monetizing the search procedure (sponsored search, digital goods, excludable, anti-rival goods etc) 55
  • 56. Stochastic Models and the Web Webmetrics: statistical models for the Web function, structure & evolution in order to evaluate individual, business and public policies 56
  • 57. Master in web science is based on Web assessment, mathematical modeling and operation combined with business applications and societal transformations in the knowledge society. Web science studies, apart from Academic, Research and Training careers offer remarkable opportunities in Business. 57 WS.01 lecture 1: Web history Michalis Vafopoulos
  • 58. Master in web science 58 Michalis Vafopoulos

Editor's Notes

  1. Add people from audience, domingos?