BMP Training Module 4
Extended Dry Detention Basin
and Infiltration Practices
Sponsored by: MARC
Presenters:
Andy Sauer, P.E. (CDM)
Brenda Macke, P.E. (CDM)
February 20, 2009
Agenda


Lecture 1: Review of Module 1

Review Module 1 and WQv definition

Overview of Extended Dry Detention Basin (EDDB)



10-Minute Break



Lecture 2: Extended Dry Detention Basin (EDDB)






Design Example
Design Activity

10-Minute Break
Lecture 3: Infiltration BMPs

Infiltration Basins

Infiltration Trenches

Porous Pavement
Lecture 1 Overview


Review watershed planning and BMP value rating process
(Module 1)



Overview of extended dry detention basins (EDDB)
Best Management Practice
(BMP)






Best – State of the Practice
 No definitive answer
 Past experience, testing, research,
 Unique to site
Management – Responsible Parties

Improve water quality, meet NPDES Phase II
 Jurisdictional specific

Meet specific requirements of a regional
Practice – Action or Implementation

Practice = defined to carry out, apply, or to
do or perform often.
Basic BMP Principles


Plan for stormwater management






Mimic natural hydrology





Sustainable and “be green”
Provide a level of service
Improve water quality
Increase initial abstraction
Promote infiltration, retention & ET

“Treat” the stormwater runoff



Natural processes
Treatment trains
BMP Evaluation Process
PLAN
MIMIC
TREAT
Extended detention
(40 hours) to
increase treatment
and decrease peak
flows
TREAT

Detention and Treatment


Structural BMPs
detain runoff


Extended Detention
Basins
• Wet
• Dry







Extended Detention
Wetlands
Infiltration basins

Typically used as
larger, centralized
facilities
TREAT

Example site
l
ne
n
ha

C
in
Ma
Design Documents
e
i dg
Br

– APWA 5600
– BMP Manual
– Watershed
Master Plans

Grass Swale

Streambank
Biostabilization
Culvert

Roa
d

w ay

Commercial
Building
BioFilters
Dry
Detention
Structural BMP Consideration










Pollutant removal efficiency
Water quality volume
Site suitability
Tributary area
Dimensions (depth, length-width ratio)
Outlet
Emergency spillway
Maintenance easement
Routine and non-routine maintenance
an
Qu

er

er

Aesthetics/Amenity

y
tit

W
at

at
W

Qu
ali
ty

BMP Evaluation
General Rule
BMP Manual
DRAFT – In Progress
BMP Manual
Level of Service


Reduce Volume
• Infiltration
• Evapotranspiration (ET)



Remove total suspended solids (TSS)
• Settling



Temperature Reduction
• Urban heat island



Remove oils and Floatables
• Screening and netting
Value Rating System –
Based on BMP Goals
Condensed Table 5

Value Ratings

BMP
Vegetation
Rain Garden
Infiltration Practices
Bioretention
Pervious or Porous Pavement
Extended Detention Wetland
Media Filtration Practices
Wetland Swale
Bio-Swale
Extended Wet Detention
Native Vegetation Swale
Extended Dry Detention Basin
Turf Grass Swale



Median
Expected
Effluent
EMC TSS

Water
Quality
Value

Volume
Reduction

Temperature
Reduction

Oils/Floatables
Reduction

Overall
Value

N/A
< 10
< 10
< 10
10 - 20
< 10
< 10
10 - 20
10 - 20
10 - 20
10 - 20
20 - 50
10 - 20

5.25
4
4
4
3
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
3

2
2
2
1.5
1.5
2
0
1.5
1.5
2
1
1
0

1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
-1
0
0
0

1
2
2
2
2
1
2
2
2
1
0
1
0

9.25
9.0
9.0
8.5
7.5
7.0
6.0
6.5
6.5
5.0
4.0
4.0
3.0

BMP value table is based on the 4 goals of
BMPs
Post Development BMP
Selection
Value Ratings

BMP
Vegetation
Rain Garden
Infiltration Practices
Bioretention
Pervious or Porous Pavement
Extended Detention Wetland
Media Filtration Practices
Wetland Swale
Bio-Swale
Extended Wet Detention
Native Vegetation Swale
Extended Dry Detention Basin
Turf Grass Swale

Median
Expected
Effluent
EMC TSS
N/A
< 10
< 10
< 10
10 - 20
< 10
< 10
10 - 20
10 - 20
10 - 20
10 - 20
20 - 50
10 - 20

Water
Quality
Value
5.25
4
4
4
3
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
3

Volume
Reduction
2
2
2
1.5
1.5
2
0
1.5
1.5
2
1
1
0

Temperature
Reduction
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
-1
0
0
0

Oils/Floatables
Reduction
1
2
2
2
2
1
2
2
2
1
0
1
0

Overall
Value
9.25
9.0
9.0
8.5
7.5
7.0
6.0
6.5
6.5
5.0
4.0
4.0
3.0
BMP Selection Flowchart
Level Of Service

BMP Value Rating

Water Quality
Volume/sizing

Placement,
maintenance
Water Quality Volume (WQv)


Water Quality Volume
(WQv): The storage needed
to capture and treat 90% of
the average annual storm
runoff volume



Water Quality Storm: The
storm event that produces ≤
90% volume of all daily
storms in a year



Extended dry detention
basin design and infiltration
system design is based on
the WQv

WQv
Kansas City Water Quality
Storm
Young and McEnroe
(http://kcmetro.apwa.net)

Daily Precipitation (in)

2.
7

2.
5

2.
3

1.
9
2.
1

1.
5
1.
7

1.
1
1.
3

0.
5
0.
7
0.
9

45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
0.
1
0.
3

Water Quality
Storm = 1.37 in

# of days > or=

2003 Kansas City Precip events
Why Use the WQv to size
BMP?


Retain runoff long enough to get
water quality benefits





Infiltrate
Maintain vegetation

Reducing erosive flows from
smaller runoff events


Less applicable
Water Quality Volume
Calculation


Two methods


Short-Cut Method
•
•



Sites < 10 acres
Only 1 predominant cover type

Small Storm Hydrology Method
•

Larger or more heterogeneous drainage
areas
WQv Short-cut Example


Given


Tributary area (ATributary) = 2.5 acres



%impervious = 80%

WQv = 1.37in * [0.05 + (0.009 * 80%)] = 1.06 in


Multiply by ATributary to get volume
1.06 * 1ft/12in * 2.5 acres = 0.22 ac-ft



If only 50% impervious WQv = 0.14 ac-ft
WQv Calculation


Small Storm Hydrology Method
WQv = P*Weighted Rv





Weighted Rv = Σ(Rvi*Aci)/Total area (ac)
Rvi = Volumetric runoff coefficient for
impervious cover type (table)
Aci = Area of impervious cover type i (ac)
Rv Table
BMP MANUAL SECTION 6, TABLE 5
VOLUMETRIC COEFFICIENTS FOR URBAN RUNOFF FOR
DIRECTLY CONNECTED IMPERVIOUS AREAS
(CLAYTOR AND SCHUELER 1996)

Flat roofs and
Rainfall large unpaved
(inches)
parking lots

Pitched roofs and
large impervious
areas
(large parking lots)

Small
impervious
areas and
narrow
streets

Silty
soils
HSG-B

Clayey
soils HSGC and D

0.75

0.82

0.97

0.66

0.11

0.20

1.00

0.84

0.97

0.70

0.11

0.21

1.25

0.86

0.98

0.74

0.13

0.22

1.37

0.87

0.98

0.75

0.14

0.23

1.50

0.88

0.99

0.77

0.15

0.24

Note: a reduction factor may be applied to the Rv values for disconnected
surfaces, consult the BMP manual hydrology section
WQv Small Storm Example


Given: ATributary = 26 ac
Cover Type

0.87

1.6

Parking lots

0.98

8.8

Narrow streets

0.75

3.3

Silty soil



Area (acres)

Flat roofs

WQv = ∑

Rv

0.14

12.3

( 0.87 ×1.6 + 0.98 × 8.8 + 0.75 × 3.3 + 0.14 ×12.3) ×1.37 = 0.749in
Rvi × Aci
×P =
Total Area
26
Multiply by ATributary to get volume
Overview of Extended Dry
Detention Basin
Extended Dry Detention
Basin (EDDB)
Why the term “Extended”
Detention?
Extended: Designed to release the WQv over a period of 40 hours




Allows time for more particles and associated pollutants to
settle out
Reduces the downstream velocity and erosive conditions
More closely imitates natural release rates and duration
Geomorphic Effects of
Uncontrolled Urban Runoff
Exceedance Frequency for
Detention
1000

Developed
Uncontrolled

7-yr
2/yr

6/yr

100

Flow

20/yr

10

Undeveloped

1

0.1
§

·
q·
more frequent than 1-yr

B
1-yr

2-yr

Storm Return Interval

Ú
10-yr

100-yr
y·
40-Hour Drawdown Impacts
1000

Developed
Uncontrolled
100

Flow

0.80 psf
Developed
Controlled
10

0.26 psf

•10-year control
•1-year control
•WQv – extended
detention with 40 hr
drawdown

1

Undeveloped

0.1
0.01

0.1
more frequent than 1-yr

1

1-yr

2-yr

Storm Return Interval

10

10-yr

100

100-yr
March 2008 Manual
Extended Detention


Water Quality (40-hr)


Pollutant removal through
• Settling
• Biological uptake (more for
wetland)
• Detain and promote
infiltration



Stream Sustainability (40-hr)




Mimic undeveloped
conditions for full range of
hydrology
Can meet flood control
objectives
EDDB Major Components
EDDB Inlet/Forebay

Forebay
EDDB Inlet/Forebay




Traps sediment and trash and slows inflow velocities
Forebay (optional) should be at least 10% of WQv and
separated from the main basin by an acceptable barrier.
Use energy dissipaters at inlets to reduce scour potential
EDDB Pilot Channel

Pilot Channel
EDDB Pilot Channel


Conveys low flows
to the outlet



Recommend lining
with riprap

Olathe, KS
EDDB Main Basin
Main Basin
EDDB Main Basin


Designed to hold the WQv
with a depth of 2 to 5 ft



Does not maintain a
permanent pool



Shallow basins with larger
surface area have higher
performance



Basin bottom should be at
least 2 ft above the wet
season water table



For KC Metro, can be used for
limited passive recreation
such as trails
EDDB Outlet Structure

Outlet
EDDB Outlet Structure


Release the WQv over a
period of 40 hr



Protected by well screens,
trash racks or grates



Located as far from inlet as
possible



Various outlet structure
types


Single Orifice



Perforated Riser or Plate



V-notch Weir

Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
EDDB Outfall

Outfall
EDDB Outfall and Emergency
Spillway


Used to convey
flood flows safely
without overtopping
the basin



Required unless
main outlet is
designed to pass
1% design storm

Olathe, KS
EDDB Maintenance Access

Maintenance
Access
EDDB Vegetation




Function of facility
determines
vegetation selection
Vegetation types




Native grasses
(preferred)
Turf
EDDB Vegetation
Buffalo Grass
Woodland Sedge

Big Bluestem

USDA-NRCS PLANTS
Database / Hitchcock, A.S.
Robert H. Mohlenbrock @
USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database
Jennifer Anderson @ USDANRCS PLANTS Database
EDDB Site Selection


Soil permeability will
impact performance



Clay soils with low
depths to bedrock pose
siting limitations



Basin bottom must be
at least 1-2 ft above wet
season groundwater
table



Backfilling with high
permeable soil should
be considered
EDDB Site Selection


Off-line, outside of
stream corridor



Can be located within
larger flood control
facilities



Not on fill sites or steep
slopes (unless
enhanced)



Olathe, KS

Flood Control Volume
Use fences and
landscaping to impede
WQv
access
Incorporating Flood Control
Benefits

x-section 100-yr pool

slotted weir for
control of WQv

outlet pipe sized to
control 100-yr outflow

WQv
EDDB Advantages


Relatively easy to construct
and inexpensive



Settling of suspended
solids



Flood control via peak
discharge attenuation



Control of channel erosion
by reducing downstream
flow velocities
California Stormwater Quality Association



Recreational benefits
(mainly trails)
EDDB Disadvantages


Not as aesthetically
pleasing as other
BMPs



Not effective at
removal of soluble
pollutants



Difficult to identify
sites with sufficient
infiltration capacity
Questions?
10 minute break
Lecture 2: EDDB Design
Example and Activity



Water quality storage volume
Outlet structure










Orifice
Perforated riser or plate
V-notch weir

Trash rack
Basin shape
Forebay (Optional)
Side Slopes
Vegetation
Design Example




Design an EDDB for a 26-acre commercial development.
Size the EDDB to capture the WQv.
Size an outlet structure to release the WQv over 40
hours.
Step 1: Calculate Water
Quality Storage Volume WQv
Two methods


Short-Cut Method
•
•



Sites  10 acres
Only 1 predominant cover type

Small Storm Hydrology Method
•

Larger or more heterogeneous drainage
areas

As tributary area is 26 acres, Small Storm
Hydrology Method will be used.
Equation: WQv
Small Storm Hydrology Method
WQv = (P)*(Weighted Rv)
Weighted Rv = Σ(Rvi*Aci)/Total area (ac)
•
•

Rvi = Volumetric runoff coefficient for cover type (Table
7)
Aci = Area of cover type i (ac)
Rv Table
TABLE 7
VOLUMETRIC COEFFICIENTS FOR URBAN RUNOFF FOR
DIRECTLY CONNECTED IMPERVIOUS AREAS
(CLAYTOR AND SCHUELER 1996)

Rainfall
(inches)

Flat roofs and
large unpaved
parking lots

Pitched roofs and
large impervious
areas
(large parking lots)

Small
impervious
areas and
narrow
streets

Silty
soils
HSG-B

Clayey soils
HSG-C and
D

0.75

0.82

0.97

0.66

0.11

0.20

1.00

0.84

0.97

0.70

0.11

0.21

1.25

0.86

0.98

0.74

0.13

0.22

1.37

0.87

0.98

0.75

0.14

0.23

1.50

0.88

0.99

0.77

0.15

0.24

Note: a reduction factor may be applied to the Rv values for disconnected
surfaces, consult the BMP hydrology section
Water Quality Control
Volume
Cover Type

Rv

Area (acres)

Flat roofs

0.87

1.6

Parking lots

0.98

8.8

Narrow streets

0.75

3.3

Silty soil

0.14

12.3

Rvi × Aci
WQv = ∑
×P =
Total Area

∑ ( .87 ×1.6 + .98 × 8.8 + .75 × 3.3 + .14 ×12.3) ×1.37 = 0.749in
26
Water Quality Storage
Volume



Convert WQv from inches to ac-ft by converting
inches to feet and multiplying by the tributary area
Add 20 percent to account for silt and sediment
deposition

= (0.749)*(1ft/12in)*26ac
= 1.62*1.20
Step 2: Determine Outlet
Structure

Single Orifice

V-notch Weir

Perforated Riser or Plate
Outlet Structure




Outlet sized to release
WQv (ac-ft) within 40
hours
Locate outlet as far away
from inlet as possible





Avoid short-circuiting

The facility must bypass
1% storm event
Provide at least 1ft of
freeboard above WQV
stage
Option 1: Single Orifice Outlet
Single Orifice Outlet
i.

Depth of water quality volume at outlet (ZWQ)


ii.

Dependent on site conditions – designer determined

Average head of WQv over invert of orifice, HWQ (ft)

HWQ = 0.5*ZWQ
iii.

Average water quality outflow rate, QWQ (cfs)

QWQ = (WQV * 43,560) / (40 * 3,600)
Single Orifice Outlet

= 0.5*3.0ft
= (1.62*43,560)/(40*3600)
Single Orifice Outlet Co
iv. Set orifice coefficient
(Co) depending on orifice
plate thickness
Do must be  or = 4
inches to prevent
clogging
Co = 0.66 if plate
thickness is  Do
Co = 0.80 if plate
thickness is  Do
Single Orifice Outlet
v.

Orifice diameter (Do) must be greater than 4
inches, otherwise use weir or riser

Do = 12 * 2 * QWQ / Co * π *

(

2 * g * HWQ

)
Single Orifice Outlet Sizing

Do=12*2*(0.49/(0.66*π*(2*32.2*1.5)0.5))0.5
Option 2: Perforated Riser or
Plate Outlet

Photo taken by Larry Roesner

Photo taken by Larry Roesner
Perforated Riser or Plate
Outlet



Calculate outlet area per row of
perforations (Ao)

Ao (in2) = WQv / (0.013 * ZWQ2 + 0.22 * ZWQ – 0.1)


Assuming a single column calculate the
diameter of a single perforation for each
row
D1 = (4 * Ao / π)1/2



If D1 is greater than 2 inches add more
columns
nc = 4
Perforated Riser or Plate
Outlet

= 1.62/(0.013*3.02+0.22*3.0–0.1)
= (4*2.4/π)1/2
Perforated Riser or Plate
Outlet


Use number of columns to determine exact
perforation diameter
Dperf = (4 / π * Ao / nc)1/2



Using a 4” center to center vertical spacing and
ZWQ, determine number of rows (nv)
nv = ZWQ / 4
nv = 5
Perforated Riser or Plate
Outlet

= 1.62/(0.013*3.02+0.22*3.0–0.1)
= (4*2.4/π)1/2
= (4/π*2.4/1)1/2
= (ZWQ*12in)/4
Option 3: V-Notch Weir Outlet

Dr. Robert Pitt

Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
V-Notch Weir Outlet Design
i.

Depth of water quality volume at outlet (ZWQ)


ii.

Dependent on site conditions – designer determined

Calculate HWQ over weir notch
HWQ=0.5*ZWQ

iii.

Calculate the average water quality pool outflow
rate QWQ (cfs)
QWQ = (WQv * 43,560)/(40 * 3,600)
V-Notch Weir Outlet Example

= 0.5*3.0ft
= (1.62*43,560)/(40*3600)
V-Notch Weir Outlet Design


Calculate required v-notch weir angle
θ = 2 * (180 / π) * arctan (QWQ/(Cv * HWQ5/2))
CV = V-notch weir coefficient = 2.5



If θ is 20º set θ to 20º



Calculate top width of v-notch weir
(WV)

θ

Wv = 2 * ZWQ * Tan (θ / 2)

Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
V-Notch Weir Outlet Example

= 2*(180/π)*actan(0.49/(2.5*1.5 ))
5/2

= 2*3.0*tan(20º*π/(2*180))


Since θ  20º set θ to 20º

20º
1.1
Step 3: Basin Shape

3W
W

California Stormwater Quality Association
Step 4: Forebay (Optional)


Volume (VolFB) should be at least 10% of WQv



Sides and bottom paved or hardened



Surface area (AFB):
AFB = VolFB / ZFB
Forebay (Optional)
= 0.10*6.23
= 0.62/3.0
EDDB Design Activity
Activity
Design an extended dry detention basin (EDDB) to capture the
WQv from a 52-acre development. Design a single orifice
outlet to release the WQv over 40-hours.
Cover Type

Area (acres)

Commercial Center
Flat Roofs

5

Large Paved Parking Lots

6

Clayey Soils

1

Streets

2

Medium Density Residential
Pitched Roofs

15

Paved Driveways

7

Clayey Soils

11

Streets

5

Totals

52
Activity Solution
Questions?
10 minute break
Lecture 3: Infiltration BMPs




Infiltration basin
Infiltration trench
Pervious pavement
I’Lan Park, Leawood, KS

www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
Infiltration Practices
Advantages


Provides 100% load reduction for captured runoff
volume



Flood control via peak discharge attenuation



Control of channel erosion by reducing
downstream flow velocities
Infiltration Practices
Disadvantages


Sediment can clog an infiltration facility


Tributary area should be stabilized



Not suitable in areas with high water table (12 feet from ground surface)



Soils must have a minimum saturated
hydraulic conductivity



Risk of contaminating groundwater
Caution


Infiltration capacity of soils in the MARC region
is general low (0.5 in/hr)



High water tables are also a common concern
related to these practices



Be very careful in site selection for infiltration
basins or trenches
Infiltration Basin
Vegetated
basin floor

Emergency
Spillway

Pretreatment

Outfall
Backup
Drain

Outlet
Infiltration Basin

WQv
Infiltration Basin Pretreatment




Used to remove as many
of the suspended solids
as possible
Various types





Grit Chambers
Swales with Check Dams
Filter Strips
Sediment Forebays
Pretreatment
Infiltration Basin Floor
•Basin floor should be as level as
possible for even distribution

Vegetated basin
floor
Infiltration Basin
Emergency
Spillway

Outfall
Outlet
Infiltration Basin
Outlet/Overflow Structures




Must pass flood flows
without damaging the
structure
Options



Weir
Overflow pipe

Portland OR
(www.lowimpactdevelopment.org)
Infiltration Basin Backup
Drain



Used to
drain the
basin if
ponding
persists for
more than
72 hours

Backup Drain
Infiltration Basin
Infiltration Basin Key Design
Criteria






Maximum of 2 acre tributary
area
Off line, outside of stream
corridors
Where soil permeability
and water table is suitable
Minimum of 150 ft from
drinking water wells
Minimum 10 ft downgradient
and 100 ft upgradient from
building foundations
Infiltration Basin
Key Design Criteria





Use a length to width
ratio of at least 3:1
Grade basin bottom as
flat as possible
Side slopes not to
exceed 3:1
Install pretreatment
device
(forebay/swale/filter strip)
Design: Infiltration Basin
Depth


Calculate ponding depth (d)
d=f*t


Where:
• f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr)
• t = retention time (hr)




72-hour maximum ponding time (24-hr
recommended)
Depth should be less than 2 feet
Design: Infiltration Basin
Area


Calculate bottom area (A)
A = 12 * V / (f * t),


Where
• V = volume to be infiltrated (ft3)
V = WQv(ac-ft) * 43,560
Design: Infiltration Basin
Example
Size an infiltration basin to treat a WQV of 0.15 ac-ft
over 72 hours, if the surrounding soil percolation
rate is 0.35 in/hr





d = (0.35 * 72) / 12 = 2.1 ft
Set d = 2.0 ft
t = 12 * d / f = 12 * 2.0 / 0.35 = 68 hours
A = (12 * 0.15 * 43560) / (0.35 * 68) = 3,300 ft2
Infiltration Basin Vegetation


Plant native vegetation on side slopes and
bottom of infiltration basin


Can increase infiltration rate



Use plants listed in the BMP Manual Appendix A
“Recommended Plant Materials for BMPs”



Select species that can withstand drought and
long periods of ponding
DO NOT use sod


Infiltration Basin
Maintenance



Inspect at least twice a year
Initially inspect more frequently





Look for sustained ponding

Maintain vegetation
Remove sediment
Infiltration Basin Maintenance


Regular inspections







Stabilize areas of erosion in tributary area
Remove trash and debris at beginning and end of
wet season
Remove dry sediment from basin





Preferably once per month
Assess length of time water is ponded following a
storm

Use light equipment
Wait until sediment Is cracking and readily
separating from bottom

Weed trimming to maintain plants
Infiltration Trench
Infiltration Trench Plan View

Pretreatment

Bypass
Structure
Infiltration
Trench
Overflow

Vegetated
Channel
Infiltration Trench
Pretreatment

Pretreatment
Infiltration Trench
Pretreatment



Pretreatment increases the life of the trench
Remove as much of the suspended solids as
possible





Grit Chambers
Swales with check dams
Filters strips
Sediment Forebays
Infiltration Trench Bypass 
Overflow





Bypass
Structure
Convey flows over
the WQv around or
over the trench
safely
Prevent erosion

Overflow
Infiltration Trench

Infiltration
Trench
Infiltration Trench





Designed to Infiltrate the WQv within 72 hours (24
hours recommended)
Filled with clean stone 1.5-2.5 inches in diameter
Lined with filter fabric
Under drain can be incorporated
Infiltration Trench Filter
Fabric


Use non-woven filter fabric layer close to the surface
to prevent majority of substrate from getting clogged
with sediment



Line the trench walls and bottom with filter fabric
Infiltration Trench
Monitoring Well





Used to monitor the
infiltration rate
Determine if trench
needs cleaning
4 to 6 inch diameter
PVC
Anchored to bottom of
trench

www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
Outlet
Commercial Area Drainage
Overflow Weir
Riprap covered
outlet
Infiltration Trench Example
Infiltration Trench Example
Portland OR
(www.lowinpactdevelopment.org)
Infiltration Trench Design
Considerations






Tributary area must be less than 5 acres
If runoff comes in as sheet flow orient the trench
perpendicular to the flow
If runoff is channelized orient the channel parallel
to the channel
Don’t use limestone or shale as backfill material
Surrounding soil should be less than 40% clay
Design: Infiltration Trench
Volume


Calculate the volume of the trench (VTR)
VTR = WQv / n



where:



WQv = water quality volume (ft3)
n = void space in trench media (0.4 for clean
stone, 1.5-2.5in diameter)
Design: Infiltration Trench
Area


Calculate bottom area (A)
A = 12 * WQv / (f * t)



where:




WQv = water quality volume (ft3)
f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr)
t = retention time (hr)
Design: Infiltration Trench
Depth


Calculate trench depth (D)
D = VTR / A



where:





VTR = volume of the trench (ft3)
A = area of the trench (ft2)

The depth should be 3 to 8 ft
Infiltration Trench Design
Length


If WQv enters as sheet flow position the
trench perpendicular to the flow



If stormwater enters as channel flow orient
parallel to flow



Maximize the length of the trench for both
flow types
Design: Infiltration Trench
Example


Size an infiltration trench to treat a WQV of 0.15
ac-ft over 48 hours, if the surrounding soil
percolation rate is 0.35 in/hr
VTR = (0.15 ac-ft * 43,560) / 0.4 = 16,335 ft3
A = (12 * 0.15 * 43560) / (0.35 * 48) = 4,667 ft2



Assuming a sheet flow width of 250ft
Ltrench = 250ft
W

= 7,780/250 = 19ft
Infiltration Trench
Maintenance


Regular inspections






Preferably once per month
Assess length of time water is ponded following a
storm (monitoring well)

Stabilize areas of erosion in tributary area
Remove trash and debris at beginning and end of
wet season
Infiltration Trench
Maintenance


If sediment is visible in top layer, remove top
layer of stone, filter fabric and sediment





Wash stone
Reinstall filter fabric and washed stone

If standing water persists for more than a few
days



Remove and clean or replace all stone aggregate
Replace filter fabric
Pervious Pavement
Pervious Pavement

Pervious surface

www.oregon.gov/ODOT/TD/TP_RES/docs/2006_NWTC/2C_Cahill.pdf
Pervious Pavement Types








Permeable
Interlocking
Concrete Pavers
Concrete Grid
Pavers
Pervious Concrete
Pervious Asphalt
Cast-in-Place
Plastic Turf
Reinforcing
Geowebs
Pervious Pavement

www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
Pervious Pavement


Design to infiltrate the WQv

I’lan Park, Leawood KS

Concrete Promotions Demo
Pervious Pavement
Advantages
 Reduce flooding potential
 Can be more aesthetically pleasing
Disadvantages
 May cost more
 Can be a more uneven driving surface
Cast-In-Place Concrete
Slabs



Reinforced slab, suitable
for heavy loads
Poured on site

Lenexa, KS

www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
Precast Concrete Grids




Permeable Concrete
pavers with void areas
separating pieces
Higher percentage of
permeable surfaces

www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
Modular Unit Pavers



Pavers themselves are impermeable
Porous material places in gaps between pavers

Concrete Promotions Demo
Geowebs


Traditionally used for soil
stabilization
Pervious Pavement
Considerations








System must be able to sustain traffic load
15% Void space with infiltration rates  12in/hr
Subbase – 36 to 42% voids compacted at 95
proctor
Subbase – ¾ inch clean rock with  2% passing
#200 sieve
A minimum subbase thickness of 8 inches
Use non-woven geotexile fabric between subbase
and soil
Use a uniform grade material to maximize voids
Pervious Pavement Design
Criteria



Only use certified ready-mix companies
Request certified contractor or






Require test placement (4 yd3) to verify mix and
installation procedures

Do not use pervious pavements in areas where
heavy trucks will turn
2:1 impervious to pervious area is good rule of
thumb
Use an underdrain to dewater subbase for events
greater than the water quality event
Design: Pervious Pavement


Design volume (Dv)
DV= WQv / n
where WQv = volume (ft3)
n = void space
Design: Pervious Pavement


Calculate the minimum required surface area
(SAmin) to infiltration the WQv into the soil
SAmin = 12 * WQv / (f * t)
where:
• WQv = water quality volume (ft3)
• f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr)
• t = retention time (hr)
Design: Pervious Pavement
Example
Size a permeable pavement parking area to
capture and infiltrate a WQv 0f 1.37 inches over a 0.5
acre tributary area
 Assume 100% impervious tributary area
 Short-cut Method


WQv = (1.37in)*(0.05+0.009(100%)) = 1.3in
Water quality volume to be infiltrated in 12 hrs into
subsurface soils with infiltration rate of 0.35 in/hr
Design: Pervious Pavement
Example
Using the previous example:

WQv = 1.3in

WQv (1.3 / 12)*0.5*43,560 = 2,360ft3
DV = 2,360 ft3 / 0.4 = 5,899 ft3
SAmin = 12 * 2,360 ft3 / (0.35 in/hr * 12 hrs)= 6,742 ft2
6,742 ft2 / 43,560 = 0.15 ac (  2:1 ratio)
Depth for the WQv = 5,899 ft3 / 6,742 ft2 = 0.88 ft
Pervious Pavement
Maintenance


Stabilize areas of erosion in tributary area



Don’t salt the 1st year



Street sweeping with vacuum truck
 3 times per year


April, July, and November



Inspect underdrain outlets annually



Snow plowing acceptable but need to educate
operators
Pervious Pavement
Resources


Center for Transportation Research and
Education, Iowa State University
• www.ctre.iastate.edu



Concrete Promotions
• www.concretepromotion.com



Univeristy of Missouri – Kansas City
 John Kevern, Ph.D.



BMP Subcommittee Update this Guidance
Designer
Review Team

Planning Phase
– Environmental Site
Assessment
– Select Post
Construction BMPs
– Flood Control Study
– Establish Long-term
Maintenance Agreements

Plat
Approval

Planning
Engineering
Parks  Recreation
Environmental Specialists
Attorney

Design Phase
– Erosion and
sedimentation
controls
– Post-construction
BMPs
– Flood control
improvements

Building
Permit
Review Team
Planning
Engineering
Code Compliance
Inspectors

Review Team
Planning
Engineering
Parks  Recreation
Environmental Specialists
Operations  Maintenance

Construction Phase
– Inspect and maintain
BMPs for construction
activities
– Construct Post
Construction BMPs
– Maintain agreements for
post-construction BMPs

Occupancy
Permit
Questions?
Comments.
Thank You

MARC BMP Manual Training Module 4

  • 1.
    BMP Training Module4 Extended Dry Detention Basin and Infiltration Practices Sponsored by: MARC Presenters: Andy Sauer, P.E. (CDM) Brenda Macke, P.E. (CDM) February 20, 2009
  • 2.
    Agenda  Lecture 1: Reviewof Module 1  Review Module 1 and WQv definition  Overview of Extended Dry Detention Basin (EDDB)  10-Minute Break  Lecture 2: Extended Dry Detention Basin (EDDB)     Design Example Design Activity 10-Minute Break Lecture 3: Infiltration BMPs  Infiltration Basins  Infiltration Trenches  Porous Pavement
  • 3.
    Lecture 1 Overview  Reviewwatershed planning and BMP value rating process (Module 1)  Overview of extended dry detention basins (EDDB)
  • 4.
    Best Management Practice (BMP)    Best– State of the Practice  No definitive answer  Past experience, testing, research,  Unique to site Management – Responsible Parties  Improve water quality, meet NPDES Phase II  Jurisdictional specific  Meet specific requirements of a regional Practice – Action or Implementation  Practice = defined to carry out, apply, or to do or perform often.
  • 5.
    Basic BMP Principles  Planfor stormwater management     Mimic natural hydrology    Sustainable and “be green” Provide a level of service Improve water quality Increase initial abstraction Promote infiltration, retention & ET “Treat” the stormwater runoff   Natural processes Treatment trains
  • 6.
    BMP Evaluation Process PLAN MIMIC TREAT Extendeddetention (40 hours) to increase treatment and decrease peak flows
  • 7.
    TREAT Detention and Treatment  StructuralBMPs detain runoff  Extended Detention Basins • Wet • Dry    Extended Detention Wetlands Infiltration basins Typically used as larger, centralized facilities
  • 8.
    TREAT Example site l ne n ha C in Ma Design Documents e idg Br – APWA 5600 – BMP Manual – Watershed Master Plans Grass Swale Streambank Biostabilization Culvert Roa d w ay Commercial Building BioFilters Dry Detention
  • 9.
    Structural BMP Consideration          Pollutantremoval efficiency Water quality volume Site suitability Tributary area Dimensions (depth, length-width ratio) Outlet Emergency spillway Maintenance easement Routine and non-routine maintenance
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    BMP Manual Level ofService  Reduce Volume • Infiltration • Evapotranspiration (ET)  Remove total suspended solids (TSS) • Settling  Temperature Reduction • Urban heat island  Remove oils and Floatables • Screening and netting
  • 13.
    Value Rating System– Based on BMP Goals Condensed Table 5 Value Ratings BMP Vegetation Rain Garden Infiltration Practices Bioretention Pervious or Porous Pavement Extended Detention Wetland Media Filtration Practices Wetland Swale Bio-Swale Extended Wet Detention Native Vegetation Swale Extended Dry Detention Basin Turf Grass Swale  Median Expected Effluent EMC TSS Water Quality Value Volume Reduction Temperature Reduction Oils/Floatables Reduction Overall Value N/A < 10 < 10 < 10 10 - 20 < 10 < 10 10 - 20 10 - 20 10 - 20 10 - 20 20 - 50 10 - 20 5.25 4 4 4 3 4 4 3 3 3 3 2 3 2 2 2 1.5 1.5 2 0 1.5 1.5 2 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 1 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 0 1 0 9.25 9.0 9.0 8.5 7.5 7.0 6.0 6.5 6.5 5.0 4.0 4.0 3.0 BMP value table is based on the 4 goals of BMPs
  • 14.
    Post Development BMP Selection ValueRatings BMP Vegetation Rain Garden Infiltration Practices Bioretention Pervious or Porous Pavement Extended Detention Wetland Media Filtration Practices Wetland Swale Bio-Swale Extended Wet Detention Native Vegetation Swale Extended Dry Detention Basin Turf Grass Swale Median Expected Effluent EMC TSS N/A < 10 < 10 < 10 10 - 20 < 10 < 10 10 - 20 10 - 20 10 - 20 10 - 20 20 - 50 10 - 20 Water Quality Value 5.25 4 4 4 3 4 4 3 3 3 3 2 3 Volume Reduction 2 2 2 1.5 1.5 2 0 1.5 1.5 2 1 1 0 Temperature Reduction 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 Oils/Floatables Reduction 1 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 0 1 0 Overall Value 9.25 9.0 9.0 8.5 7.5 7.0 6.0 6.5 6.5 5.0 4.0 4.0 3.0
  • 15.
    BMP Selection Flowchart LevelOf Service BMP Value Rating Water Quality Volume/sizing Placement, maintenance
  • 16.
    Water Quality Volume(WQv)  Water Quality Volume (WQv): The storage needed to capture and treat 90% of the average annual storm runoff volume  Water Quality Storm: The storm event that produces ≤ 90% volume of all daily storms in a year  Extended dry detention basin design and infiltration system design is based on the WQv WQv
  • 17.
    Kansas City WaterQuality Storm Young and McEnroe (http://kcmetro.apwa.net) Daily Precipitation (in) 2. 7 2. 5 2. 3 1. 9 2. 1 1. 5 1. 7 1. 1 1. 3 0. 5 0. 7 0. 9 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0. 1 0. 3 Water Quality Storm = 1.37 in # of days > or= 2003 Kansas City Precip events
  • 18.
    Why Use theWQv to size BMP?  Retain runoff long enough to get water quality benefits    Infiltrate Maintain vegetation Reducing erosive flows from smaller runoff events  Less applicable
  • 19.
    Water Quality Volume Calculation  Twomethods  Short-Cut Method • •  Sites < 10 acres Only 1 predominant cover type Small Storm Hydrology Method • Larger or more heterogeneous drainage areas
  • 20.
    WQv Short-cut Example  Given  Tributaryarea (ATributary) = 2.5 acres  %impervious = 80% WQv = 1.37in * [0.05 + (0.009 * 80%)] = 1.06 in  Multiply by ATributary to get volume 1.06 * 1ft/12in * 2.5 acres = 0.22 ac-ft  If only 50% impervious WQv = 0.14 ac-ft
  • 21.
    WQv Calculation  Small StormHydrology Method WQv = P*Weighted Rv    Weighted Rv = Σ(Rvi*Aci)/Total area (ac) Rvi = Volumetric runoff coefficient for impervious cover type (table) Aci = Area of impervious cover type i (ac)
  • 22.
    Rv Table BMP MANUALSECTION 6, TABLE 5 VOLUMETRIC COEFFICIENTS FOR URBAN RUNOFF FOR DIRECTLY CONNECTED IMPERVIOUS AREAS (CLAYTOR AND SCHUELER 1996) Flat roofs and Rainfall large unpaved (inches) parking lots Pitched roofs and large impervious areas (large parking lots) Small impervious areas and narrow streets Silty soils HSG-B Clayey soils HSGC and D 0.75 0.82 0.97 0.66 0.11 0.20 1.00 0.84 0.97 0.70 0.11 0.21 1.25 0.86 0.98 0.74 0.13 0.22 1.37 0.87 0.98 0.75 0.14 0.23 1.50 0.88 0.99 0.77 0.15 0.24 Note: a reduction factor may be applied to the Rv values for disconnected surfaces, consult the BMP manual hydrology section
  • 23.
    WQv Small StormExample  Given: ATributary = 26 ac Cover Type 0.87 1.6 Parking lots 0.98 8.8 Narrow streets 0.75 3.3 Silty soil  Area (acres) Flat roofs WQv = ∑ Rv 0.14 12.3 ( 0.87 ×1.6 + 0.98 × 8.8 + 0.75 × 3.3 + 0.14 ×12.3) ×1.37 = 0.749in Rvi × Aci ×P = Total Area 26 Multiply by ATributary to get volume
  • 24.
    Overview of ExtendedDry Detention Basin
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Why the term“Extended” Detention? Extended: Designed to release the WQv over a period of 40 hours    Allows time for more particles and associated pollutants to settle out Reduces the downstream velocity and erosive conditions More closely imitates natural release rates and duration
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
    40-Hour Drawdown Impacts 1000 Developed Uncontrolled 100 Flow 0.80psf Developed Controlled 10 0.26 psf •10-year control •1-year control •WQv – extended detention with 40 hr drawdown 1 Undeveloped 0.1 0.01 0.1 more frequent than 1-yr 1 1-yr 2-yr Storm Return Interval 10 10-yr 100 100-yr
  • 30.
    March 2008 Manual ExtendedDetention  Water Quality (40-hr)  Pollutant removal through • Settling • Biological uptake (more for wetland) • Detain and promote infiltration  Stream Sustainability (40-hr)   Mimic undeveloped conditions for full range of hydrology Can meet flood control objectives
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
    EDDB Inlet/Forebay    Traps sedimentand trash and slows inflow velocities Forebay (optional) should be at least 10% of WQv and separated from the main basin by an acceptable barrier. Use energy dissipaters at inlets to reduce scour potential
  • 34.
  • 35.
    EDDB Pilot Channel  Conveyslow flows to the outlet  Recommend lining with riprap Olathe, KS
  • 36.
  • 37.
    EDDB Main Basin  Designedto hold the WQv with a depth of 2 to 5 ft  Does not maintain a permanent pool  Shallow basins with larger surface area have higher performance  Basin bottom should be at least 2 ft above the wet season water table  For KC Metro, can be used for limited passive recreation such as trails
  • 38.
  • 39.
    EDDB Outlet Structure  Releasethe WQv over a period of 40 hr  Protected by well screens, trash racks or grates  Located as far from inlet as possible  Various outlet structure types  Single Orifice  Perforated Riser or Plate  V-notch Weir Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
  • 40.
  • 41.
    EDDB Outfall andEmergency Spillway  Used to convey flood flows safely without overtopping the basin  Required unless main outlet is designed to pass 1% design storm Olathe, KS
  • 42.
  • 43.
    EDDB Vegetation   Function offacility determines vegetation selection Vegetation types   Native grasses (preferred) Turf
  • 44.
    EDDB Vegetation Buffalo Grass WoodlandSedge Big Bluestem USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database / Hitchcock, A.S. Robert H. Mohlenbrock @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database Jennifer Anderson @ USDANRCS PLANTS Database
  • 45.
    EDDB Site Selection  Soilpermeability will impact performance  Clay soils with low depths to bedrock pose siting limitations  Basin bottom must be at least 1-2 ft above wet season groundwater table  Backfilling with high permeable soil should be considered
  • 46.
    EDDB Site Selection  Off-line,outside of stream corridor  Can be located within larger flood control facilities  Not on fill sites or steep slopes (unless enhanced)  Olathe, KS Flood Control Volume Use fences and landscaping to impede WQv access
  • 47.
    Incorporating Flood Control Benefits x-section100-yr pool slotted weir for control of WQv outlet pipe sized to control 100-yr outflow WQv
  • 48.
    EDDB Advantages  Relatively easyto construct and inexpensive  Settling of suspended solids  Flood control via peak discharge attenuation  Control of channel erosion by reducing downstream flow velocities California Stormwater Quality Association  Recreational benefits (mainly trails)
  • 49.
    EDDB Disadvantages  Not asaesthetically pleasing as other BMPs  Not effective at removal of soluble pollutants  Difficult to identify sites with sufficient infiltration capacity
  • 50.
  • 51.
    Lecture 2: EDDBDesign Example and Activity   Water quality storage volume Outlet structure         Orifice Perforated riser or plate V-notch weir Trash rack Basin shape Forebay (Optional) Side Slopes Vegetation
  • 52.
    Design Example    Design anEDDB for a 26-acre commercial development. Size the EDDB to capture the WQv. Size an outlet structure to release the WQv over 40 hours.
  • 53.
    Step 1: CalculateWater Quality Storage Volume WQv Two methods  Short-Cut Method • •  Sites 10 acres Only 1 predominant cover type Small Storm Hydrology Method • Larger or more heterogeneous drainage areas As tributary area is 26 acres, Small Storm Hydrology Method will be used.
  • 54.
    Equation: WQv Small StormHydrology Method WQv = (P)*(Weighted Rv) Weighted Rv = Σ(Rvi*Aci)/Total area (ac) • • Rvi = Volumetric runoff coefficient for cover type (Table 7) Aci = Area of cover type i (ac)
  • 55.
    Rv Table TABLE 7 VOLUMETRICCOEFFICIENTS FOR URBAN RUNOFF FOR DIRECTLY CONNECTED IMPERVIOUS AREAS (CLAYTOR AND SCHUELER 1996) Rainfall (inches) Flat roofs and large unpaved parking lots Pitched roofs and large impervious areas (large parking lots) Small impervious areas and narrow streets Silty soils HSG-B Clayey soils HSG-C and D 0.75 0.82 0.97 0.66 0.11 0.20 1.00 0.84 0.97 0.70 0.11 0.21 1.25 0.86 0.98 0.74 0.13 0.22 1.37 0.87 0.98 0.75 0.14 0.23 1.50 0.88 0.99 0.77 0.15 0.24 Note: a reduction factor may be applied to the Rv values for disconnected surfaces, consult the BMP hydrology section
  • 56.
    Water Quality Control Volume CoverType Rv Area (acres) Flat roofs 0.87 1.6 Parking lots 0.98 8.8 Narrow streets 0.75 3.3 Silty soil 0.14 12.3 Rvi × Aci WQv = ∑ ×P = Total Area ∑ ( .87 ×1.6 + .98 × 8.8 + .75 × 3.3 + .14 ×12.3) ×1.37 = 0.749in 26
  • 57.
    Water Quality Storage Volume   ConvertWQv from inches to ac-ft by converting inches to feet and multiplying by the tributary area Add 20 percent to account for silt and sediment deposition = (0.749)*(1ft/12in)*26ac = 1.62*1.20
  • 58.
    Step 2: DetermineOutlet Structure Single Orifice V-notch Weir Perforated Riser or Plate
  • 59.
    Outlet Structure   Outlet sizedto release WQv (ac-ft) within 40 hours Locate outlet as far away from inlet as possible    Avoid short-circuiting The facility must bypass 1% storm event Provide at least 1ft of freeboard above WQV stage
  • 60.
    Option 1: SingleOrifice Outlet
  • 61.
    Single Orifice Outlet i. Depthof water quality volume at outlet (ZWQ)  ii. Dependent on site conditions – designer determined Average head of WQv over invert of orifice, HWQ (ft) HWQ = 0.5*ZWQ iii. Average water quality outflow rate, QWQ (cfs) QWQ = (WQV * 43,560) / (40 * 3,600)
  • 62.
    Single Orifice Outlet =0.5*3.0ft = (1.62*43,560)/(40*3600)
  • 63.
    Single Orifice OutletCo iv. Set orifice coefficient (Co) depending on orifice plate thickness Do must be or = 4 inches to prevent clogging Co = 0.66 if plate thickness is Do Co = 0.80 if plate thickness is Do
  • 64.
    Single Orifice Outlet v. Orificediameter (Do) must be greater than 4 inches, otherwise use weir or riser Do = 12 * 2 * QWQ / Co * π * ( 2 * g * HWQ )
  • 65.
    Single Orifice OutletSizing Do=12*2*(0.49/(0.66*π*(2*32.2*1.5)0.5))0.5
  • 66.
    Option 2: PerforatedRiser or Plate Outlet Photo taken by Larry Roesner Photo taken by Larry Roesner
  • 67.
    Perforated Riser orPlate Outlet  Calculate outlet area per row of perforations (Ao) Ao (in2) = WQv / (0.013 * ZWQ2 + 0.22 * ZWQ – 0.1)  Assuming a single column calculate the diameter of a single perforation for each row D1 = (4 * Ao / π)1/2  If D1 is greater than 2 inches add more columns nc = 4
  • 68.
    Perforated Riser orPlate Outlet = 1.62/(0.013*3.02+0.22*3.0–0.1) = (4*2.4/π)1/2
  • 69.
    Perforated Riser orPlate Outlet  Use number of columns to determine exact perforation diameter Dperf = (4 / π * Ao / nc)1/2  Using a 4” center to center vertical spacing and ZWQ, determine number of rows (nv) nv = ZWQ / 4 nv = 5
  • 70.
    Perforated Riser orPlate Outlet = 1.62/(0.013*3.02+0.22*3.0–0.1) = (4*2.4/π)1/2 = (4/π*2.4/1)1/2 = (ZWQ*12in)/4
  • 71.
    Option 3: V-NotchWeir Outlet Dr. Robert Pitt Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
  • 72.
    V-Notch Weir OutletDesign i. Depth of water quality volume at outlet (ZWQ)  ii. Dependent on site conditions – designer determined Calculate HWQ over weir notch HWQ=0.5*ZWQ iii. Calculate the average water quality pool outflow rate QWQ (cfs) QWQ = (WQv * 43,560)/(40 * 3,600)
  • 73.
    V-Notch Weir OutletExample = 0.5*3.0ft = (1.62*43,560)/(40*3600)
  • 74.
    V-Notch Weir OutletDesign  Calculate required v-notch weir angle θ = 2 * (180 / π) * arctan (QWQ/(Cv * HWQ5/2)) CV = V-notch weir coefficient = 2.5  If θ is 20º set θ to 20º  Calculate top width of v-notch weir (WV) θ Wv = 2 * ZWQ * Tan (θ / 2) Source: Hubbard Brook LTER
  • 75.
    V-Notch Weir OutletExample = 2*(180/π)*actan(0.49/(2.5*1.5 )) 5/2 = 2*3.0*tan(20º*π/(2*180))  Since θ 20º set θ to 20º 20º 1.1
  • 76.
    Step 3: BasinShape 3W W California Stormwater Quality Association
  • 77.
    Step 4: Forebay(Optional)  Volume (VolFB) should be at least 10% of WQv  Sides and bottom paved or hardened  Surface area (AFB): AFB = VolFB / ZFB
  • 78.
  • 79.
  • 80.
    Activity Design an extendeddry detention basin (EDDB) to capture the WQv from a 52-acre development. Design a single orifice outlet to release the WQv over 40-hours. Cover Type Area (acres) Commercial Center Flat Roofs 5 Large Paved Parking Lots 6 Clayey Soils 1 Streets 2 Medium Density Residential Pitched Roofs 15 Paved Driveways 7 Clayey Soils 11 Streets 5 Totals 52
  • 81.
  • 82.
  • 83.
    Lecture 3: InfiltrationBMPs    Infiltration basin Infiltration trench Pervious pavement I’Lan Park, Leawood, KS www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
  • 84.
    Infiltration Practices Advantages  Provides 100%load reduction for captured runoff volume  Flood control via peak discharge attenuation  Control of channel erosion by reducing downstream flow velocities
  • 85.
    Infiltration Practices Disadvantages  Sediment canclog an infiltration facility  Tributary area should be stabilized  Not suitable in areas with high water table (12 feet from ground surface)  Soils must have a minimum saturated hydraulic conductivity  Risk of contaminating groundwater
  • 86.
    Caution  Infiltration capacity ofsoils in the MARC region is general low (0.5 in/hr)  High water tables are also a common concern related to these practices  Be very careful in site selection for infiltration basins or trenches
  • 87.
  • 88.
  • 89.
    Infiltration Basin Pretreatment   Usedto remove as many of the suspended solids as possible Various types     Grit Chambers Swales with Check Dams Filter Strips Sediment Forebays Pretreatment
  • 90.
    Infiltration Basin Floor •Basinfloor should be as level as possible for even distribution Vegetated basin floor
  • 91.
  • 92.
    Infiltration Basin Outlet/Overflow Structures   Mustpass flood flows without damaging the structure Options   Weir Overflow pipe Portland OR (www.lowimpactdevelopment.org)
  • 93.
    Infiltration Basin Backup Drain  Usedto drain the basin if ponding persists for more than 72 hours Backup Drain
  • 94.
  • 95.
    Infiltration Basin KeyDesign Criteria      Maximum of 2 acre tributary area Off line, outside of stream corridors Where soil permeability and water table is suitable Minimum of 150 ft from drinking water wells Minimum 10 ft downgradient and 100 ft upgradient from building foundations
  • 96.
    Infiltration Basin Key DesignCriteria     Use a length to width ratio of at least 3:1 Grade basin bottom as flat as possible Side slopes not to exceed 3:1 Install pretreatment device (forebay/swale/filter strip)
  • 97.
    Design: Infiltration Basin Depth  Calculateponding depth (d) d=f*t  Where: • f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr) • t = retention time (hr)   72-hour maximum ponding time (24-hr recommended) Depth should be less than 2 feet
  • 98.
    Design: Infiltration Basin Area  Calculatebottom area (A) A = 12 * V / (f * t),  Where • V = volume to be infiltrated (ft3) V = WQv(ac-ft) * 43,560
  • 99.
    Design: Infiltration Basin Example Sizean infiltration basin to treat a WQV of 0.15 ac-ft over 72 hours, if the surrounding soil percolation rate is 0.35 in/hr     d = (0.35 * 72) / 12 = 2.1 ft Set d = 2.0 ft t = 12 * d / f = 12 * 2.0 / 0.35 = 68 hours A = (12 * 0.15 * 43560) / (0.35 * 68) = 3,300 ft2
  • 100.
    Infiltration Basin Vegetation  Plantnative vegetation on side slopes and bottom of infiltration basin  Can increase infiltration rate  Use plants listed in the BMP Manual Appendix A “Recommended Plant Materials for BMPs”  Select species that can withstand drought and long periods of ponding DO NOT use sod 
  • 101.
    Infiltration Basin Maintenance   Inspect atleast twice a year Initially inspect more frequently    Look for sustained ponding Maintain vegetation Remove sediment
  • 102.
    Infiltration Basin Maintenance  Regularinspections      Stabilize areas of erosion in tributary area Remove trash and debris at beginning and end of wet season Remove dry sediment from basin    Preferably once per month Assess length of time water is ponded following a storm Use light equipment Wait until sediment Is cracking and readily separating from bottom Weed trimming to maintain plants
  • 103.
  • 104.
    Infiltration Trench PlanView Pretreatment Bypass Structure Infiltration Trench Overflow Vegetated Channel
  • 105.
  • 106.
    Infiltration Trench Pretreatment   Pretreatment increasesthe life of the trench Remove as much of the suspended solids as possible     Grit Chambers Swales with check dams Filters strips Sediment Forebays
  • 107.
    Infiltration Trench Bypass Overflow   Bypass Structure Convey flows over the WQv around or over the trench safely Prevent erosion Overflow
  • 108.
  • 109.
    Infiltration Trench     Designed toInfiltrate the WQv within 72 hours (24 hours recommended) Filled with clean stone 1.5-2.5 inches in diameter Lined with filter fabric Under drain can be incorporated
  • 110.
    Infiltration Trench Filter Fabric  Usenon-woven filter fabric layer close to the surface to prevent majority of substrate from getting clogged with sediment  Line the trench walls and bottom with filter fabric
  • 111.
    Infiltration Trench Monitoring Well     Usedto monitor the infiltration rate Determine if trench needs cleaning 4 to 6 inch diameter PVC Anchored to bottom of trench www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
  • 112.
  • 113.
  • 114.
  • 115.
    Infiltration Trench Example PortlandOR (www.lowinpactdevelopment.org)
  • 116.
    Infiltration Trench Design Considerations      Tributaryarea must be less than 5 acres If runoff comes in as sheet flow orient the trench perpendicular to the flow If runoff is channelized orient the channel parallel to the channel Don’t use limestone or shale as backfill material Surrounding soil should be less than 40% clay
  • 117.
    Design: Infiltration Trench Volume  Calculatethe volume of the trench (VTR) VTR = WQv / n  where:   WQv = water quality volume (ft3) n = void space in trench media (0.4 for clean stone, 1.5-2.5in diameter)
  • 118.
    Design: Infiltration Trench Area  Calculatebottom area (A) A = 12 * WQv / (f * t)  where:    WQv = water quality volume (ft3) f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr) t = retention time (hr)
  • 119.
    Design: Infiltration Trench Depth  Calculatetrench depth (D) D = VTR / A  where:    VTR = volume of the trench (ft3) A = area of the trench (ft2) The depth should be 3 to 8 ft
  • 120.
    Infiltration Trench Design Length  IfWQv enters as sheet flow position the trench perpendicular to the flow  If stormwater enters as channel flow orient parallel to flow  Maximize the length of the trench for both flow types
  • 121.
    Design: Infiltration Trench Example  Sizean infiltration trench to treat a WQV of 0.15 ac-ft over 48 hours, if the surrounding soil percolation rate is 0.35 in/hr VTR = (0.15 ac-ft * 43,560) / 0.4 = 16,335 ft3 A = (12 * 0.15 * 43560) / (0.35 * 48) = 4,667 ft2  Assuming a sheet flow width of 250ft Ltrench = 250ft W = 7,780/250 = 19ft
  • 122.
    Infiltration Trench Maintenance  Regular inspections     Preferablyonce per month Assess length of time water is ponded following a storm (monitoring well) Stabilize areas of erosion in tributary area Remove trash and debris at beginning and end of wet season
  • 123.
    Infiltration Trench Maintenance  If sedimentis visible in top layer, remove top layer of stone, filter fabric and sediment    Wash stone Reinstall filter fabric and washed stone If standing water persists for more than a few days   Remove and clean or replace all stone aggregate Replace filter fabric
  • 124.
  • 125.
  • 126.
    Pervious Pavement Types       Permeable Interlocking ConcretePavers Concrete Grid Pavers Pervious Concrete Pervious Asphalt Cast-in-Place Plastic Turf Reinforcing Geowebs
  • 127.
  • 128.
    Pervious Pavement  Design toinfiltrate the WQv I’lan Park, Leawood KS Concrete Promotions Demo
  • 129.
    Pervious Pavement Advantages  Reduceflooding potential  Can be more aesthetically pleasing Disadvantages  May cost more  Can be a more uneven driving surface
  • 130.
    Cast-In-Place Concrete Slabs   Reinforced slab,suitable for heavy loads Poured on site Lenexa, KS www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
  • 131.
    Precast Concrete Grids   PermeableConcrete pavers with void areas separating pieces Higher percentage of permeable surfaces www.lowimpactdevelopment.org
  • 132.
    Modular Unit Pavers   Paversthemselves are impermeable Porous material places in gaps between pavers Concrete Promotions Demo
  • 133.
  • 134.
    Pervious Pavement Considerations        System mustbe able to sustain traffic load 15% Void space with infiltration rates 12in/hr Subbase – 36 to 42% voids compacted at 95 proctor Subbase – ¾ inch clean rock with 2% passing #200 sieve A minimum subbase thickness of 8 inches Use non-woven geotexile fabric between subbase and soil Use a uniform grade material to maximize voids
  • 135.
    Pervious Pavement Design Criteria   Onlyuse certified ready-mix companies Request certified contractor or     Require test placement (4 yd3) to verify mix and installation procedures Do not use pervious pavements in areas where heavy trucks will turn 2:1 impervious to pervious area is good rule of thumb Use an underdrain to dewater subbase for events greater than the water quality event
  • 136.
    Design: Pervious Pavement  Designvolume (Dv) DV= WQv / n where WQv = volume (ft3) n = void space
  • 137.
    Design: Pervious Pavement  Calculatethe minimum required surface area (SAmin) to infiltration the WQv into the soil SAmin = 12 * WQv / (f * t) where: • WQv = water quality volume (ft3) • f = percolation rate of surrounding soil (in/hr) • t = retention time (hr)
  • 138.
    Design: Pervious Pavement Example Sizea permeable pavement parking area to capture and infiltrate a WQv 0f 1.37 inches over a 0.5 acre tributary area  Assume 100% impervious tributary area  Short-cut Method  WQv = (1.37in)*(0.05+0.009(100%)) = 1.3in Water quality volume to be infiltrated in 12 hrs into subsurface soils with infiltration rate of 0.35 in/hr
  • 139.
    Design: Pervious Pavement Example Usingthe previous example: WQv = 1.3in WQv (1.3 / 12)*0.5*43,560 = 2,360ft3 DV = 2,360 ft3 / 0.4 = 5,899 ft3 SAmin = 12 * 2,360 ft3 / (0.35 in/hr * 12 hrs)= 6,742 ft2 6,742 ft2 / 43,560 = 0.15 ac ( 2:1 ratio) Depth for the WQv = 5,899 ft3 / 6,742 ft2 = 0.88 ft
  • 140.
    Pervious Pavement Maintenance  Stabilize areasof erosion in tributary area  Don’t salt the 1st year  Street sweeping with vacuum truck  3 times per year  April, July, and November  Inspect underdrain outlets annually  Snow plowing acceptable but need to educate operators
  • 141.
    Pervious Pavement Resources  Center forTransportation Research and Education, Iowa State University • www.ctre.iastate.edu  Concrete Promotions • www.concretepromotion.com  Univeristy of Missouri – Kansas City  John Kevern, Ph.D.  BMP Subcommittee Update this Guidance
  • 142.
    Designer Review Team Planning Phase –Environmental Site Assessment – Select Post Construction BMPs – Flood Control Study – Establish Long-term Maintenance Agreements Plat Approval Planning Engineering Parks Recreation Environmental Specialists Attorney Design Phase – Erosion and sedimentation controls – Post-construction BMPs – Flood control improvements Building Permit Review Team Planning Engineering Code Compliance Inspectors Review Team Planning Engineering Parks Recreation Environmental Specialists Operations Maintenance Construction Phase – Inspect and maintain BMPs for construction activities – Construct Post Construction BMPs – Maintain agreements for post-construction BMPs Occupancy Permit
  • 143.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Green to gray?
  • #5 Best Management Practices (BMPs) is a familiar term we use when talking about water quality, NPDES Phase II permits, and education to the public. We all have are own understanding of the term and use it maybe more than we should and too often forget the true meaning and intent of the acronym. The action word in the acronym is PRACTICE. Practice if you go to a dictionary is defined as to carry out, apply, or to do or perform often. Therefore what should w carry out regularly (often) to improvement water quality in our region? This and other BMP manuals often focus on the actions that are BEST not the ones that should be perform regularly. Therefore this primer is a discussion on what we should do regularly to improve water quality. Other items in this manual will focus on specific structural practices that can be implement for a specific site. This section will focus on regular practices that should be consider as key part in a stormwater management program to improve water quality.
  • #17 Add pic of wqv
  • #27 Add a pic or figure of settling cross-section
  • #35 Text for all components
  • #36 Need Better picture
  • #38 Add figure Incorporate flood control volume?
  • #42 Picture
  • #44 Well planted picture
  • #45 Do animation
  • #49 Good eddb pic
  • #50 Need more pictures of properly functioning and poorly functioning EDDB’s
  • #52 PIC
  • #73 Same as single orifice
  • #75 For larger Zwq values the angle is over the table, the angle doesn’t change that much with the range of Cv values
  • #101 Some example plants sp.
  • #111 What is the purpose of lining the trench with fabric?
  • #116 Added diameter
  • #117 Picture Added last 2 bullets
  • #118 Added diameter
  • #119 Added diameter
  • #120 Added diameter
  • #121 Added diameter
  • #133 New Picture
  • #134 Picture?