The document discusses budget processes and prioritization of public expenditures in Malawi, focusing on financing the Farm Input Subsidy Programme (FISP). It notes that while the FISP has been successful in achieving food security, financing it presents major challenges due to budget constraints and competing needs. The budget process involves determining available resources and allocating funds between priority areas like agriculture, education, and health. However, a large portion of funds are already committed to non-discretionary spending. The FISP receives a significant portion of agricultural funds but faces issues like budget overruns and unpaid bills. Improving efficiency, targeting, and sustainability of the FISP is needed through measures like increasing farmer contributions and piloting flexible
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Financial and Operating Plan - A Tool for Strategic Municipal Investment and ...Ravikant Joshi
This PPT delivered in a course organised by Administrative Staff College of India - Hyderabad explains Financial and Operating Plan and how to prepare it and used it as a tool for strategic municipal investment and financial planning
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Capital Investment Plan for Local GovernmentRavikant Joshi
PPT presented in Training of Trainers Workshops on Strengthening The Financial Foundation of Local Government Based on Local Government Financial Management Series of UN-HABITAT during June 4- 15 2007 - Nadi, Fiji
www.fao.org/climatechange/epic
This presentation was prepared to provide a general overview of Climate-Smart Agriculture (CSA) and the EPIC programme. After providing a definition of CSA, the presentation focuses on Sustainable Land Management and the role of climate finance to support CSA. It concludes with a description of the FAO-EC project on CSA.
During the webinar, the speakers promoted a set of training materials that is freely available for those interested in learning more about the implementation of NDCs in the agriculture sector in Africa.
More info about the webinar: https://ccafs.cgiar.org/implementing-ndcs-agriculture-sector-across-africa-what-directions-capacity-building#.XxaxH_gzbfZ
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Financial and Operating Plan - A Tool for Strategic Municipal Investment and ...Ravikant Joshi
This PPT delivered in a course organised by Administrative Staff College of India - Hyderabad explains Financial and Operating Plan and how to prepare it and used it as a tool for strategic municipal investment and financial planning
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop organized by the Strengthening National Comprehensive Agricultural Public Expenditure in Sub-Saharan Africa Program
Dar es Salaam, June 2013
Accra, Ghana, April 13-14, 2011
Capital Investment Plan for Local GovernmentRavikant Joshi
PPT presented in Training of Trainers Workshops on Strengthening The Financial Foundation of Local Government Based on Local Government Financial Management Series of UN-HABITAT during June 4- 15 2007 - Nadi, Fiji
www.fao.org/climatechange/epic
This presentation was prepared to provide a general overview of Climate-Smart Agriculture (CSA) and the EPIC programme. After providing a definition of CSA, the presentation focuses on Sustainable Land Management and the role of climate finance to support CSA. It concludes with a description of the FAO-EC project on CSA.
Even though the ink is hardly dry on the 2013 CAP reform, thoughts are turning already to the prospects for the next reform. In this presentation I discuss the likely economic context for agriculture in the coming years and some of the main issues - direct payments, market crises and risk management, greening, soil health and climate policy - likely to be on the agenda for the next CAP reform. However, those seeking reform will have to address a widespread sense of 'reform fatigue'.
Sustainable FP Financing and Agenda 2030 : Emerging Approaches and ToolsJoachim Chijide
Presentation made by Dr Joachim Chijide on Sustainable Family Planning Financing and Agenda 2030 : Emerging Approaches and Tools at the 2nd Sexual and Reproductive Health Community of Practice (SeRHCoP) Webinar, 23rd September 2021
COVID 19 Response for Recovery and Resilience of Agriculture & Food SystemsFrancois Stepman
Vanessa Adams, VP Strategic Partnerships, Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA)
5 May 2020. Webinar German Agribusiness alliance: Making food systems resilient to Covid 19.
Financing for Development :Unlocking Investment Opportunities: Financial Solu...Linah Tembo
Smallholder in Zimbabwe have less access to technical knowledge, markets, credit, and inputs such as improved seeds, fertilisers and equipment. Agriculture is a key sector in the economy.Private sector investment is essential to revive its agricultural sector and economy through
o Addressing issues in the enabling environment and specific government policies that limit the flow of financial services to small holders
o Using Blended finance co-investments and performance-based incentive structures to mitigate risks
o Providing funding to increase investments in agriculture to raise productivity, improve quality of agricultural products, and lead to better post-harvest practices
o Increasing financial inclusion
DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION FOR ZIMASSETInnocent Bayai
Funding for development has been more outward looking ie ODA but this source has not been enough to spur economic growth in Zimbabwe. New paradigm in the funding of a new sustainable development policy (ZIMASSET) is the gist of this presentation.
Similar to Budget processes and prioritization of public expenditure (20)
This presentation was made by Dr. Francesco Cecchi, Assistant Professor, Development Economics Group, Wageningen University, during IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar series on 23 November 2022.
Market Access and Quality Upgrading_Dec12_2022.pdfIFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Dr. Tessa Bold, Associate Professor, Institute of International Economic Studies, Stockholm University, during IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar series on 7 December 2022
The Effect of Extension and Marketing Interventions on Smallholder Farmers: E...IFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Annemie Maertens, Reader in economics, University of Sussex, during the MwAPATA-IFPRI joint seminar series on 9 November 2022
This presentation was made by Ellen Mccullough, Assistant Professor, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Georgia during the MwAPATA-IFPRI Joint seminar series on Wednesday, 19 October 2022
Disentangling food security from subsistence ag malawi t benson_july_2021-minIFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made during the launch of a book titled "Disentangling Food Security from Subsistence Agriculture in Malawi" by Dr. Todd Benson, IFPRI, at IFPRI Malawi brownbag seminar
A New Method for Crowdsourcing 'Farmgate' PricesIFPRIMaSSP
A New Method for Crowdsourcing Farmgate Prices in Malawi
This Presentation was made during a virtual brown bag seminar at IFPRI Malawi on 23 June 2021. The Presentation was made by Dr. Bob Baulch and Mr. Aubrey Jolex
Does connectivity reduce gender gaps in off-farm employment? Evidence from 12...IFPRIMaSSP
At an IFPRI Malawi virtual brown bag seminar held on 19th May 2021, Dr. Eva-Maria Egger, a UNU-Wider Research Fellow, presented a paper that posed the question “Does Connectivity Reduce Gender Gaps in Off-Farm Employment?”.
Urban proximity, demand for land and land prices in malawi (1)IFPRIMaSSP
African cities are growing rapidly This growth can be attributed to the increase in population from natural births within cities and migration of people from rural areas in search of better job opportunities. The increase in urban population has led to an expansion of urban boundaries into peri-urban and rural areas, And the associated increase in demand for land previously not classified as urban has sped up the development of land markets in Sub-Saharan African (SSA) cities. It is in the context of this trend that a spike in global energy and food prices in 2007 and 2008 led to a sharp – albeit temporary – increase in demand by international investors for rural agricultural land in Africa and beyond, stoking fears of a “land grab.”
Understanding the factors that influence cereal legume adoption amongst small...IFPRIMaSSP
This presentation was made by Dr. Tabitha C. Nindi, a Research Fellow at the Malawi University of Science and Technology (MUST), on the 24th of March 2021.
Promoting Participation in Value Chains for Oilseeds and Pulses in Malawi
Budget processes and prioritization of public expenditure
1. BUDGET PROCESSES AND PRIORITIZATION
OF PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
By Anne Conroy, Ministry of Finance and Development
Planning
2. Introduction
• The Farm Inputs Subsidy Programme (FISP) has been successful in terms
of achieving food security at the national level. So Government remains
committed to the FISP.
• This is despite high population growth, declining soil fertility and rapid
rates of environmental degradation.
• Despite these successes, transient food insecurity affects a significant
proportion of the population each year. Last year two million Malawians
needed food aid. Imported food aid is very expensive. The cost of the
humanitarian operation was around US$100 million last year.
• Although Government is committed to the FISP, financing the programme
is a major challenge in the face of budgetary constraints and competing
needs for resources.
3. Introduction cont.
This paper focuses on Budget Process and Prioritization of Public
Expenditure and addresses:
a) Budget Prioritization Process.
b) Budgetary allocations to FISP over time.
c) Specific challenges related to the FISP Budget.
d) The need to improve efficiency and sustainability in the FISP.
e) The need for ownership of the Budget by all stakeholders.
4. Budget Prioritization Process and Allocations to
FISP over time.
• The first step is to determine the total resource envelope for the three year Medium
Term Expenditure Framework – estimating growth, revenue, resources from DPs.
• The Fiscal Framework is updated twice a year in consultation with the IMF.
• There is currently limited “fiscal space” for the FISP. Fiscal space is defined as the
room in the Government’s Budget to provide resources for desired purposes
without jeopardizing the overall macro-economic framework.
• A significant proportion of the Budget is non-discretionary – this includes salaries,
transfers, pensions, and statutory and debt service obligations.
• Funds for Other Recurrent Transactions have been squeezed. Travel costs and
personnel emoluments have increased as a proportion of the budget. This has
reduced resources for generic goods and services – funding agricultural inputs,
drugs and Education materials.
• For example, in 2011/12 Budget, generic goods and services were 9.8 percent of
GDP or 28 percent of total expenditure.
• A significant proportion of aid resources are non-discretionary – tied to specific
purposes.
5. Budget Process and allocation to the FISP
over time
• Efforts by Government to restore macro-economic balance were
compromised by the cash-gate scandal in September 2013.
• This resulted in the suspension of General and Sector Budget Support by
several Development Partners with devastating impacts (Mangani 2013)
• As a consequence, Domestic debt has increased to MK340 Billion and
reported arrears are very high – these are being verified by the Auditor
General.
• The 2014/15 Budget should reflect the priorities of the new Government
and accommodate debt service obligations.
• This is why the Minister of Finance used the Appropriation Bill to roll-over
the current Budget for four months.
• An IMF Mission is currently working with Government to finalize the
macro-economic framework for the new Budget.
6. Budgetary allocations to Agriculture and FISP
• Malawi is committed to agricultural development – agriculture accounted
for 18-21 percent of total expenditure from 2008 -2012.
• Agricultural expenditures are financed by local resources (55 percent) and
external resources (45 percent).
• Donor funding for agriculture is extremely fragmented – 50 percent is
financed off-budget.
• The FISP absorbs 69 percent of MoAFS resources and 51 percent of total
sector spending.
• Non-FISP spending (agricultural research and technology development,
soil and water management and agricultural commercialization are crowded
out.
• The FISP also is very demanding of senior management time in MoAFS,
this limits their ability to follow up on other programmes and may lead to
reduced donor inflows . This is a significant opportunity cost.
7. Problems related to the FISP Budget
• The FISP Budget is always a difficult line item, subject to cost overruns.
This is because all fertilizer is imported. Costs increase if the exchange
rate depreciates.
• In early years of the programme, the amount of fertilizer distributed exceed
the planned amount – leading to significant budgetary overruns.
• It is often difficult for fertilizer importers to access foreign exchange and
open Letters of Credit.
• In 2011/12, the Kwacha was overvalued and importers could not access
foreign exchange. The Minister of Finance Minister had to request DPs to
reprogramme GBS to cover fertilizer imports. There were few problems in
2012/13. But in that year, aid doubled and GBS was MK100 Billion.
• This year, the cash-gate scandal and suspension of GBS has led to
significant unpaid bills on the FISP Programme – which will have to be
accommodated in this year’s budget.
8. Problems related to the FISP Budget
• Budgetary problems were compounded in 2013/14 due to the introduction
of the Farm Inputs Loan Scheme outside the Budget and IMF Framework.
• Despite the suspension of aid, the Ministry of Finance attempted to
maintain allocations to core Ministries (Agriculture, Education and Health).
• However, maintaining the overall Budget Framework requires strict
adherence to the Budget Approved by Parliament and no approval of
expenditure outside the agreed Budget Framework.
• The FISP has always over-run the Budgetary provision, this contributes to
delayed payment of suppliers and has an adverse impact on overall
Budgetary Implementation.
• Budgetary over-runs on the FISP generate arrears and also have major
opportunity costs.
9. The need to promote efficiency and
sustainability in the FISP
Sustaining returns to investment in FISP requires continued efforts to promote
efficiency. The conference has highlighted many of the issues:
a) Ensuring productivity gains from high yielding maize and legume seed . There is
need to reassess the optimal balance between seed and fertilizer. – given that
hybrid maize has higher fertilizer use efficiency than local, and that legumes and
other fertility enhancing interventions increase fertilizer use efficiency.
b) There is need to ensure that fertilizer is procured in as cost-effective a manner as
possible. Options include i) launching tenders earlier in the year and ii) adopting
the same process for fertilizer as seed – negotiating a voucher price and allowing
private sector distribute inputs – this works with rather than against incentive
structures.
c) Increase fertilizer use efficiency by i) getting it to farmers on time, ii) targeting
appropriate combinations of nutrients for different soils iii) focus on restoring soil
fertility and organic matter in the soil iv) scale up legumes and agro-forestry v)
complement investments in the FISP with programmes of soil conservation .
10. The need to promote efficiency and
sustainability in the FISP
• Reducing displacement of commercial sales of fertilizer and seed by better
targeting and reducing corruption. The FISP should not be targeted at
ultra-poor land and labour constrained households, or the wealthiest third
of households who could purchase fertilizer on their own.
• Increasing the level of farmers’ contribution. The level of farmer
contribution has declined and is now less than 5 percent. To promote
sustainability, there is need to progressively increase the amount of farmers’
contribution to one third of the cost of fertilizer – as envisaged in the
original programme design.
• The suggestion that flexible input vouchers should be piloted is also
constructive. This would give farmers more choice of inputs – more seed,
Urea rather than basal dressing fertilizer, investment in crops other than
maize if this is what farmers prefer.
11. The need for ownership of the Budget by
all stakeholders
• A budget is a plan. Successful implementation requires commitment by all
stakeholders to cost –effectiveness ,to adhere to budgetary ceilings and not build
arrears , be vigilant about fraud.
• There is also need for greater realism about what Government can provide . This is
a very resource constrained environment where a minority of the population pays
tax.
• We also need to be clear about opportunity costs – an extra MK10 Billion on FISP
could pay the salaries of 20,000 teachers or reduce the shortage of Essential Drugs
in our health centers.
• Sustaining expenditure on the FISP , Social Protection or education and health will
require efforts in the following areas:
a) Domestic Resources Mobilization : we need to finance a higher proportion of
expenditure from revenue. In 2012/13, revenue is estimated at around 24 percent
GDP while expenditure was 40 percent GDP. There is need to promote
efficiencies in revenue collection and to reduce tax evasion.
12. The need for ownership of the Budget by all
stakeholders
b) Improve Public Financial Management – this is essential to restore
confidence by tax payers and donors and ensure that public finances are
managed in a transparent and accountable manner. PFEM reforms must
be implemented by all Ministries, Agencies, Departments and Parastatals.
c) There is need to strive for a better balance between investments in the
productive base of the economy and welfare. We have a gap of US$1
Billion in the Balance of Payments – this puts pressure on the Exchange
Rate. There is need to prioritize and fully finance the National Export
Strategy to generate the growth that is required to finance our welfare
requirements.
d) Strengthen prioritization within the Budget. Ensure that procurement is as
cost-effective as possible. Reduce travel costs and allowances. Reduce
extravagant expenditure. Release resources for critical services for the
population. This is the responsibility of us all.
13. The need for ownership of the Budget by all
stakeholders
e) Strengthen aid effectiveness. This is with a view to reducing fragmentation and
duplication and bringing more resources on-budget. In Agriculture alone there are
more than 150 projects.
f) Continue to promote inclusive dialogue between all stakeholders in development to
improve programme design. Include the Executive, the legislature, citizens, tax-
payers, Development Partners, researchers, farmers organizations the private sector,
civil society and vulnerable populations. This conference has highlighted issues –
few of them are new, many are known. We need to think about how to use existing
information more effectively.
As the Honourable Minister suggested, there is need to move beyond analysis towards
implementing recommendations. Thank you to LUARNAR and IFPRI for
organizing the conference. I hope the outcome will be a restructured FISP to
promote efficiency and sustainability – to serve the Nation better.
Thank you and God Bless