SlideShare a Scribd company logo
(r e s e a r c h ) 
PUTTING LEININGER’S NURSING THEORY 
“CULTURE CARE DIVERSITY AND 
UNIVERSALITY” INTO OPERATION IN THE 
CURRICULUM - PART 1 
L de Villiers and D van der Wal 
ABSTRACT 
The culturally diverse South African society necessitates inclusion o f transcultural 
nursing in the curriculum. This article focuses on research regarding the putting o f 
Leininger's nursing theory into operation in the curriculum to provide a scientific 
base for the inclusion o f such nursing. The research process and results are 
discussed. 
OPSOMMING 
Die multikulturele aard van die Suid-Afrikaanse samelewing noodsaak insluiting 
van transkulturek verpleegkunde by die kurrikulum, gegrondop 'n verpleegteorie. 
Hierdie artikel is gerig op navorsing ten einde Leininger se verpleegteorie in die 
kurrikulum te operasion^iseer. Die navorsingsproses en resultate word deur die 
outeur bespreek 
INTRODUCTION 
The culturally diverse South African society 
necessitates a new perspective on nursing 
education and curriculum development. There 
is increasing need for transcultural nursing in 
the curriculum to enable graduates to render 
congruent cultural nursing care. Successful 
health care delivery based on primary health 
care, is dependent on congruent cultural 
nursing care (Sekgobela 1986:30; MacDonald 
1987:32); Burrows (1983:478) regards an 
ethnocentric curriculum as a form of 
institutionalized racism resulting in 
inadequate nursing care. 
Man is acknowledged as a cultural being in the 
philosophies of many nursing schools. Chater 
(1975:429) argues that a philosophy is rarely 
reflected in all phases of the curriculum 
although a nursing theory guides all phases of, 
and provides a scientific base for, the 
curriculum (Aggleton & Chalmers 1989:24, 
Brower & Baker 1976:686). 
With reference to transcultural nursing. Brink 
(1990:523) says “cultural diversity remains 
elusive without a tJteoretical framework Farr 
(1978:294-299) recommends that man as a 
culmral being be acknowledged in nursing 
school philosophies and that inclusion of 
cultural content in the curriculum be based on 
an appropriate nursing theory. 
IMPLICATIONS OF LEININGER’S 
NURSING THEORY FOR THE 
CURRICULUM 
The focus of this theory is to discover care 
diversities and universalities in order to provide 
culturally congruent care (Leininger 1991 a: 11 & 
Leininger 1991 b:39). Putting Leininger’s 
nursing theoiy into operation therefore can be 
instrumental in preparing the nursing student to 
deliver congruent cultural care. The existing 
ethnocentric curriculum, based mainly on 
Euro-American values, thus will make way for 
a curriculum which reflects not only a 
biomedical, but also a sociocultural perspective 
on health related matters. Because a nursing 
theory influences all phases of the curriculum, 
the use of Leininger’s nursing theory should 
result in bnnging congruent cultural nursing 
education to a multicultural student population 
LEININGER’S NURSING THEORY 
IN OPERATION IN THE 
CURRICULUM 
Operation o f this nursing theory was 
accomplished by research involving 
theoretical reflection 
Research question 
The research question on which the study was 
based, is: 
How can Leininger's Nursing Theory 
"Culture Care Diversity and Universality " be 
operationalized in the curriculum? 
Aim 
The aim of the study was to gain insight into 
culturally congruent nursing education by 
means of an exploratory study. Mouton and 
Marais (1992:45) regard willingness to 
explore new ideas and suggestions as essential 
for a good exploratory study. 
Goal 
The goal was to promote culturally congruent 
care through formulation of guidelines for the 
operating of Leininger’s nursing theory, in 
order to include transcultural nursing in the 
curriculum. 
Objectives 
The objectives were: 
• to analyze and evaluate Leininger’s 
nursing theory. 
• to operationalize Leininger’s nursing 
theory in the curriculum. 
Research design and method 
A flexible, non-empirical, exploratory 
research design involving the method of 
theoretical reflection, was utilized. Steyn 
(1981:34) explains this method as the 
gathering and systematic critique of data by 
means of deductive and inductive thought 
processes. Such a study, according to 
Engelbrecht (1989:61), is interpretative-theoretical 
in nature. 
Data were gathered by means of a literature 
study. According to Mouton and Marais 
(1992:45) a literature study can be applied 
successfully to an exploratory study. Expert 
publications regarding the relationship 
between culture and the cuniculum, as well as 
culturally congruent care, were subjected to 
analysis and critique Data gathering and 
analysis were done simultaneously A 
conceptual framework (Figure 1) and data 
56 Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Dcsember 1995
reduction plan (Table 1) were developed to 
guide data gathering and analysis. 
RESEARCH PROCESS 
The research was completed in four phases: 
Phase 1 
Phase one comprised description, analysis and 
evaluation of Leininger’s nursing theory and 
included three steps: 
Step 1 Description of Leininger’s nursing 
theory. 
Step 2 Development of a conceptual 
framework for analysis and 
evaluation of the theory (Table 2). 
Step 3 Analysis and evaluation of the theory 
by means of the conceptual 
framework developed in step 2. 
Analysis and evaluation of the nursing theory 
resulted in insight into its strengths as an 
appropriate theoretical framework for the 
inclusion of anthropological concepts and 
transcultural nursing in the curriculum. 
Leininger describes cultural and social 
structure dimensions which influence man’s 
perception of health, sickness and care, as well 
as nursing’s unique position relative to the 
professional and generic health care systems. 
Culturally congruent care is provided by a 
creative combination of the professional and 
generic health care systems. This is achieved 
through three modes of nursing care 
judgement, decisions and actions namely:- a) 
culture care preservation b) maintenance, 
accommodation negotiation and c) 
repatterning restructuring, in order to 
preserve, adapt and restructure care values, 
lifeways and practices (Leininger 
1991b;37-38 & 41-44; Stasiak 1991:1%). 
Leininger’s nursing theory provides an 
abstract theoretical framework for the 
establishment of transcultural nursing in the 
curriculum but a concrete frame of reference 
also is required to guide structuring of this 
component of the curriculum and to facilitate 
implementation of acquired concepts by the 
student. This understanding led to the second 
phase of research which was exploration of 
Chrisman’s expansionist approach 
Phase 2 
Durmg phase two, a literature study was 
undertaken to explore Chrisman’s 
expansionist approach (1990:2-3), the author 
suggests that this humanist approach 
complements Leininger’s nursing theory 
Whereas Leininger’s nursing theory is 
abstract and focuses on transcultural nursing 
as a formal field of study, the expansionist 
approach is a client centrcd one, through 
which the client can be approached (Chrisman 
1991a:2-5) Within the context of this study, 
the expansionist approach can be used to: 
OIIRECnVE PHASE FORMATIVE PHASE 
Educational philoaophy Curriculum davelopment model 
Situation analysie Transcultural nursing content 
Terminology Guttural issues 
Programme objectivM Clinical competence 
LEININGER'S NURSING THEORY 
FUNCTIONAL PHASE 
Educational strat»giM 
Rgure 1 Concaptual framework for data gathmlng, analysis and presentation 
• organize transcultural nursing curriculum 
content and identify associated clinical 
competence according to the principles of 
congruent cultural care (ie knowledge, 
respect and negotiation). 
• include both the biomedical and socio­cultural 
perspectives on health matters in 
the curriculum, therefore putting an end to 
ethnocentrism in nursing education. 
• ensure congruent cultural care by using the 
nursing process within the cultural context 
during clinical teaching 
Phase 3 
Phase three comprised the putting of 
Leininger’s nursing theory into operation in 
the curriculum. This phase was completed in 
three steps 
Step 1 A literature study regarding the merit 
of curriculum development based on 
a nursing theory and implications of a 
nursing theory for the curriculum was 
done 
Step 2 Development and description of a 
conceptual framework for data 
gathenng, -analysis and -presentation. 
(Figure 1), as well as a data reduction 
plan (Table 1) was drawn up. 
Step 3 Data gathering and atulysis by means 
of the conceptual framework (Figure 
I) and data reduction plan (Table 1) 
was carried out. 
Phase 4 
Phase four involved the formulation of 
guidelines for including transcultural nursing 
in the curriculum. 
RESULTS 
The study resulted in the formulation of such 
guidelines and a brief overview of these 
guidelines is presented (Sec Table 3). 
General 
Nursing theory as a foundation for curriculum 
development has implications for the 
directive, formative and functional phases of 
the curriculum. 
Directive phase 
An analysis of the situation is undertaken to 
determine the social characteristics and health 
Table 1 Data reduction 
CATEGORY CODE 
Directive phase 1 Educational philoeophy 
2 Situation analysts 
3 Terminology 
4 Programme o b fe c tn^ 
Formative phase 5 Curricukjm development model 
6 Transcultural nursing content 
7 Cuttural issues 
e Q in ical competence 
Functional phase 0 Educational strategies 
Curationis, Vol 18 No. 1, Dcsember 1995 57
related needs of the main cultures served by 
the nursing school. This analysis should be 
based on the seven social and cultural 
structural dimensions described by Leininger 
namely; cultural values and lifeways, as well 
as technological, religiousphilosophical, 
kinshipsocial, politicalMegal, economic and 
educational factors. 
The philosophy of the nursing school needs 
acknowledge man as a cultural being. The 
inclusion of transcultural nursing in the 
curriculum, should be based on Leininger’s 
nursing theory “Culture Care Diversity and 
Universality”, and be complemented by 
Chrisman’s expansionist approach. 
Leininger’s deflnitions of culture, man, health, 
nursing and environment may be included in 
the terminology which serves as a frame of 
reference for curriculum development and its 
implementation, as applicable to transcultural 
nursing. 
Culture is regarded as the main concept and 
the others as subconcepts. Chrisman’s 
definitions of sickness, disease and illness, are 
appropriate and will result in insight into the 
universal nature of sickness and its causation 
in terms ofthe biomedical versus sociocultural 
perspectives. 
The Programme Objectives for the Education 
and Training of a Nurse (General, Psychiatric, 
Community) and Midwife [South African 
Nursing Council 1988:Paragraph(6X2)],should 
reflect the aim of developing the student’s ability 
to render culturally congruent care. 
The curriculum therefore must provide for 
personal and professional development of the 
student so that, by completion of the course of 
study, the student will: 
• show respect for the dignity and 
uniqueness of man in his social-cultural 
and religious context and approaches and 
understand him as a psychological, 
physical, social and cultural being within 
this context [South African Nursing 
Council 1988: Paragraph (6X2Xm)]. 
• be able to promote community 
involvement within a multicultural context 
at any point along the healthdisease 
continuum in all stages of the life cycle 
[South African Nursing Council 1988: 
Paragraph (6X2Xm)]. 
Formative phase 
Inclusion of transcultural nursing content is 
achieved by a combination of curriculum 
development models. A course in 
anthropology is followed by transcultural 
nursing units o f instruction in close 
association with related nursing subjects. For 
instance, cultural diversities and universalities 
regarding pain-experience and its alleviation 
should form part of the pain module. 
Table 2 Analysis and evaluation of Leininger’s nursing theory 
S T R U C TU R E CRITERIA P R O C E S S C R IT ER IA 
Historical development. Semantic integrity and congruence with eatablished 
general knowlikJge: 
Established general knowledge about man and 
health. 
Correspondence with a paradigm in nursing and 
between the theory and It's undertying 
phik>-sophical assumptions. 
Level of abstractkxi of concepts. 
Clarity and consistency of principles, concepts and 
propositions. 
Parsimony. 
Philosophk^i assumptions Coherence: 
Relationship to other nursing theories. 
Logical flow from philo-sophk»U assumptions to 
propositions. 
Symmetry and beauty. 
Principles and propositions Pragmatkss 
Utility. 
Contribution to nursing. 
Metaparadigm concepts 
The integrated approach is followed during 
clinical teaching to enable the student to apply 
principles of congruent cultural care while 
attending to the client holistically. The 
principles of congruent cultural care are 
knowledge, respect and negotiation 
(Chrisman 1991 b:36). 
The anthropology course should include units 
on:- 
a) Culture 
• Cultural concepts. 
• The seven cultural and social structure 
dimensions o f Leininger. These 
dimensions are cultural uni versals, but also 
culturally diverse in nature. 
b) The relationship between culture 
and health 
• Cultural factors affecting health. 
• Perceptions of health and sickness. 
• Sickness behaviour, including pathways to 
health and treatment strategies 
The transcultural nursing units of instruction 
include; 
a) A comparative study of at least two of 
the main cultures in the region served by 
the nursing school, by means of 
Leininger’s seven cultural and social 
structure dimensions. This is followed by 
units related to specific nursing subjects 
For instance 
- Ethical issues within cultural context, in 
the Ethos and Professional Practice 
module. 
• Cultural beliefs and practices associated 
with pregnancy and labour, in the 
midwifery modules. 
b) Subject content to promote self know­ledge 
in the student. Self knowledge 
includes knowledge regarding personal 
and professional values the nurae brings 
to the health care situation and which may 
lead to stereotyping of and prejudice 
towards clients. 
c) Subject content related to cultural issues 
are included in the curriculum in order to 
promote moral development of the 
student. Examples of cultural issues are 
human rights within the cultural context 
and the effect ethnocentrism has on the 
quality of nursing care (Leininger 
1991a: 13; Mattson 1987:207). 
One of the principles of cultural congruent 
care (namely negotiation) implies clinical 
competence. Clinical competence assumes 
integration of knowledge, attitudes and skills 
needed to function as a registered nurse 
(Mallik 1988:11). Negotiation is a social skill 
which includes listening to the client’s view, 
explaining the professional view, comparing 
the two viewpoints and arriving at a 
compromise for a workable and safe care plan 
(Chrisman 1990;13-14). Such compromise 
implies social, communication and higher 
cognitive skills on the nurse’s part. Listening 
and explaining are communication skills. 
Comparing involves critical analytical 
thought processes and compromising implies 
social skills Within the transcultural nursing 
context, these skills are used to develop a 
negotiated nursing care plan according to 
Leininger’s three modes of nursing le 
58 Curationis, Vol 18 No. 1, Desembcr 1995
Table 3 Including transculturai nursing In the curriculum: Planning quide 
AC-nVITY 
DIRECTIVE PHASE 
1 SmJATION ANALYSIS 
A titajalion analysn hae bwn ImplafTwnted by maans of Leininger's 
s«v«n cultural and tocial itructura dimansions, namaly: 
- Technological lacton 
• Raligious and philoaophical factors 
- Kinwip and aocial lactors 
• Cultiral valuas and ways ol living 
• Politicai and lagal tadois 
- Economical (actors 
• Educational tactcis 
2 EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY 
Acknowrladgamart has baan givan to Man as oJtutal baings 
Tha intantion to approacti ttia patent holiaticelly wiithin tha cuRural 
ccnMKl haa baan statad 
3 TERM NO LO Q Y 
Tha tallowing oorKapts. as dafinad by Lainingar, ars indudad in tha 
tarminology: 
-Cullurs 
• Man 
■Haalth 
-Nursing 
-Environment 
Tha tallowing ooncapts as dsAnad tiy Chhsman. a n included in the 
temiinalogy 
- Sickness 
-Illness 
-Disease 
4 PROGRAMME OBJECTIVES 
The prograirme cbiectives include the following irtentiora: 
- To develop the sludert's ability to approach and underetand the 
patient as a oitural being 
• To prorrxM comrunity development within the cultural corteM 
FORMATIVE PHASE 
5 CURRICULUM D EVELOPMENT PHAS E 
Currictium development model: 
A basic anthropology course is included in the curriculum 
- Tranacultural nursing units of instruction thei builds upon the 
anthropology course, are included at strategic pants throughout the 
cumoium 
- Transculturai nursing is integrated into clinical teaching progrannmes 
• S U B JE C T CONTENT 
The basic anthropology course corsists at. 
■ CiJtml oorxsepts 
- Ovsrvtew of the seven aJtural and social structure dimensions of 
Lemnger as cultural umysrsals 
- Cultural factors ttut influence health 
- Percaptions regarding health and dissasa 
- Sickneaa behaviour, including pathways to haalth arvj treatmert 
strategies 
The tranacultural unils of inatrucbon include; 
- A connparativs study of at least two cultures by means ct the seven 
cultural arxl social structure dirrwnsions 
- Subiect content related to seH-^nowledge 
- Cultural ssuas 
7 C LINICAL COMP ETEN CE 
The following clinical skills are included 
Social skills 
- Socncultural asseasmant 
- Negotiation 
- Aaeei smart of community needs 
- Conflict managemert 
Commurvcatkxi witNn the cultural cortext 
Higher cognitivs skills 
- Critical analitical thought proceesas 
- Protasaional |udgemer« 
- DeciSKn making whith regard to cullurs cars prasarvAion. 
accommodation or reatructunng 
Negotiation as an rtegration of the abovs skills 
COMPLETED 
FUNCTIONAL PHASE 
• EDUCATKM4AL STTtATEQIEB 
The educttiorwl strategies provide lor the lolkMing 
Devetopment of a knowledge base 
Utiliiation of the Meraturs as a aource of knowledge 
ExpenerVial learning 
Development of reepect 
Role modelling 
Utiliabon of human and material resources 
Expenertial leamng 
FaciMation of meaninglul mulb-cultural learning expenerxses 
CtmKal leaching is based on the pnnciples of expanerxaal learning 
Trarvcullural nunmg is applied to the nursing process 
Mullx:iitural ecucatxin. taking into account individual differences 
among studens with regard to the folkiwing 
- Learning styles 
- Perceptions regarding molivatxn, achievement and reward 
- Strategies th« requwe group and indrvidual work, ars aftemated 
REQUIRE FURTHER 
ATTENTION 
judgment, decision making and actions. The 
nursing student also lias to develop skills to 
perform a political function in the assessment 
of community health needs and priorities, 
communicating this information to politicians, 
as well as conflict management should health 
care be regarded by the community as 
incongruent to their needs or priorities (Adlem 
1993:17). 
Functional phase 
Educational strategies applicable to 
transculturai nursing are divided into 
approaches aimed at the: 
• development of a transculturai nursing 
knowledge base. 
• development of respect 
• provision of meaningful multicultural 
learning experiences. 
• provision for individual differences among 
students. 
Educational strategies for the development of 
a transculturai nursing knowledge base should 
not be aimed at teaching lists of cultural 
ch a rac teristic s which could lead to 
stereotyping of clients (Germain 1992:3). 
Stern (1985:177) regards literature and 
personal experience as appropriate sources for 
gaining transculturai nursing knowledge. 
Personal experience can be attained by guest 
speakers, discussions and culture days (Brink 
1990:523, Capers 1992:27; Woolfolk 
1990:486-487). 
Development of respcct can be achieved by 
strategies such as modelling and utilization of 
human and matenal resources, as well as 
simulation (Stem 1985:182-183). Examples 
could be observation of the life history of a 
person of another culture or a Culture Game, 
simulating culture shock (Stern 
1985:182-183, Leimnger 1994:220). 
Leininger (1991a:5) regards experential 
learning as appropriate for transculturai 
nursing. Kolb’s experential learning cycle 
(personal experience, reflective observation, 
abstract conceptualisation and active 
experimenUtion) provides a theoretical base 
for multicultural learning expenences. this in 
turn provides for cognitive and afl"ective 
dimensions of learning (Kolb in Holbert & 
Thomas 1988:30-31). It can be applied to 
discussions and clinical teaching. Clinical 
teaching also should be implemented within 
the cultural context. Anderson (1987:9) 
writes: “ihe clinical encounter is a social 
process in which each party brings a set o f 
expectations and beliefs about the problem at 
hand The critical issue here is that both the 
perspectives o f the nurse and the patient and 
his or her family art legitimate " Gagnon 
(1983:128) states that clinical placements 
should provide the student with the 
opportunity to encounter culturally diverse 
groups in addition to focus on clinical 
Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Desembcr 1995 59
specialities. The nursing process should be 
implemented within the cultural context which 
implies sociocultural assessment, a negotiated 
nursing care plan and implementation as well 
as evaluation, according to the biomedical and 
sociocultural perspective (Chrisman 
1990:11-13). 
Individual differences among culturally 
diverse students include differences in 
learning styles, as well as diverse perspectives 
regarding achievement, motivation and 
reward. Inclusion of transcultural nursing in 
the curriculum implies multicultural 
education, taking into consideration cultural 
pluralism, rather than imposing 
Euro-American values on a culturally diverse 
student population (Slavin 1986:508; Slavin 
1991:451; Woolfolk 1990:527). 
LIMITATIONS 
The interpretative nature of this study might 
have resulted in some degree of bias. Although 
nursing theory influences all phases of the 
curriculum, the evaluation phase was not 
included in the study, because it is considered 
as a separate research project. 
Despite the limitations, the study contributes 
to a thorough exploration of the relationship 
between Leininger’s nursing theory and the 
curriculum and provides the basis for further 
research in order to establish transcultural 
nursing as a formal field of study in South 
Africa. 
RECOMMENDATIONS 
Continuing education 
Personnel development regarding 
transcultural nursing should be provided for 
lecturers and nursing practitioners responsible 
for accompaniment of students. 
Research 
It is recommended that research is undertaken 
into student evaluation within the transcultural 
nursing context, to enable lecturers to monitor 
the student’s progress towards cultural 
congruent care. Research into the 
characteristics and health carc needs of the 
main cultures of the various regions, in order 
to ensure relevant curricula, is needed. 
Curriculum development 
It is recommended that: 
• curriculum evaluation be undertaken, 
guided by the guidelines in this study. 
• curriculum development be undertaken 
within a regional context due to cultural 
diversity between the various regions 
• transcultural nursing be included in the 
curriculum according to the guidelines 
(Table 3) formulated for the inclusion of 
transcultural nursing. 
CONCLUSION 
This study focused on the putting of 
Leininger’s nursing theory into operation 
within the curriculum in order to include 
transcultural nursing. This was achieved by 
means of a non-empirical exploratory study. 
Inclusion of transcultural nursing in the 
curriculum will result into culturally 
congruent care and the provision of 
multicultural education to students. 
REFERENCES 
Adlcm, W .U . (1993). Makro-ptruptutU tvalutnng van 
gtiauBmdtatm- g*l**rahtdt mtt bttondtrt vtrwysing 
no vtrpUtgomkrwys OngqwUtscerd UNISA. 
Agglcton, P. !l Chalmers, H (19«9). Next y etr't modeU 
Nursing Titmt. 85. 51. 24-27 
Andcnon, J.M. (19S7). The culniral context of caring 
Canadian Cnhcal Can Nursing Journal, 4, 4. 7-13 
Brink, P J . (1990). Cultural divcraity in nursmg How much 
can we tolerate In: Current issuts in nursing, edited by 
J.C McCloakey and H.K Grace, third edition, St 
Louu Moaby, 1990. pp 521-527 
Brower, HT .F. & Baker, B J . (1976). Using the 
Adaptation Model in a practitioner cumcuhim. Nursing 
Outlook.lA, 11,6*6-687 
Burrmrs, A. (19(3) Patioit-centered nunuig care in a 
mulu-racial society the relevance of ethnographic 
penpectives ui nuning curricula Journal t^Advanctd 
Nursing. - its 
Capers. C.F. (1992). Teaching cultural content a nursmg 
mpoative Hohsac Nurse Practct. 6.3. 19-28 
Chater, S.S. (1975). A conceptual framework for 
curriculum development Nursing Outlook, 23. 7, 
428^33 
Chrisman, NJ. (1990). Expanding nursing praOiCt with 
culture-stnsilivt oart: a nrw approach to transcultural 
nursing Unpublished University of Washmgton 
Chrisman, NJ. (1991a) CuhunI systems In Canar 
nursing; a ccmpnhtnsnt ttxiboot, edited by S Baird. 
R McCorkle and M Grant. Philadelphia W B 
Saundffs, 1991,45-54 
Chrisman. NJ.0991b). Culture-sensitive nursing care In: 
Mtdical-surgical nursii^: pathophysiologic concepts, 
edited by M.L Patnck, S L Woods. R F Craven. J S 
Rokosky and P.M Bruno. Second edition, 
Philadelphia LippincoO. 1991. 34-47 
D* Villiers. L. (1994) Operastonahsenng van Ltmngtr 
St V tr p lttg tto n t "Culture Care Diversity and 
Universality" in die kurrikulum. M A Cut 
Verhandehng. Universiteit van Suid-Afnka 
Engelbrecht, C.S. (1989) Benaderings en metodes ui 
opvoedkundige navorsing In Navorsing in die 
OfK’oeckunde, saamgestel deur J.J Booyse. Pretons 
UNISA, 1989, 42-70 
Farr, R R (1978) The incorporation <4cultural divtrsily 
into nursing aimcula D Ed thesis, Brigham Young 
University 
Gagnon, AJ. (19S3) Transcultural nursng ncludingitin 
the curriculim Nursing and Health Care. Much 1983, 
127-131 
Germain, C.F. (1992) Cultural care a bndge between 
sickness, illness and disease Holistic Nurse Practice. 
6, 3. 1-9 
Holbert, C.M. A Thomas, KJ. (19H) Toward whole 
brain education in nursing Nurse Educator, 13. 1, 
30-34 
L.eininger, M.M. (1991a) Celebration o f nursing: a 
transcultural human care ethos with ethical 
considerations. Keynote centennial adtkess for one 
hundred veers cfmirsing in South Afhca Unpublished 
UNISA 
Ldnlnger,M.M. (1991b). (Editor) Culture C a v Diversity 
andVniversality: athtoryafnumng New York: NLN. 
Leialnger, M.M. (1994). Teaching and learning 
transcultural nursing In: Nursing education An 
international perspective, edited by T G. Mashaba and 
H.IL. Bnnk. Kenwyn Juta, 207-225. 
MacDonald, J. 09(7). Preparing to woik in a mulucultural 
tocMy Canadian Nurse. 83,8.31-32. 
Mallik. M (1988) A canng curncukim. Semor Nurse, 8. 
9/10.9-11 
Mattson, S. (1987) The need for cultural concepts in 
nursuig currKula Journal cfNursing Education, 26.5. 
206-208 
Mouton, J. A Marala, R C . (1 9 « ) Btmese begrippe: 
metodologie vir die geesUswetentkappe Heniene 
uitgawe derde druk Pretoria: RGN 
Parae, R.R 0987), Nursing sdenoi. Mcfor paradigms, 
timmes end crittques Philadelphia: Saunders 
Sekaobek, M.J. (19W) Conmunity participation The 
hemt of community health NursmgRSA. 1.9,30-31 
Slavin, R.E. (1986) Educational peycholo^: theory into 
practice Second edition Englewood ClifT: Prentice 
Hall 
Slavin, R.E. (1991) Educational psychology: theory into 
practice Third ediuon Boston Allyn It Bacoa 
Staslak. D.B. (1991). Culture Care Theory with Mexican 
Americans in an urban context In: Culture Care 
Diversity and Universalily: a theory o f nursing, edited 
by MM. Lemu^a. New York: NLN, 1991,179-202 
Stem, P.N. (1985) Teaching transcultural nursuig in 
Louiaiaiu Health Care for Women Intemaaoncl, 6. 
1/3, 175-186 
Steyn, CJLA. (1981) Educantulus 3. Navorsingsmetodtek 
in die opvoedkunde Pretoria: Universiteit van 
Suid-Afrika 
South African Nursing Caundi, RegulaUcns Relating to 
the Approval of and Muumum Requiremenu for the 
Education and Training of a Nurse (Genval. Psychiatric 
and Cammuruty)and Midwife Leaduig to Registrauon 
R425 (As amended) Pretoria: Govemmenl Printa, 
1988 
Woolfolk. A.E. (1990) Educational psychology Fourth 
Edibon Englewood Clifis Prenuce Hall 
L de Villiers 
M.A.CUR. (Unisa) 
Snr Tutor 
Ann Latsky Nursing College 
D van der Wal 
M.A.CUR. (Unisa) 
Lecturer 
UNISA 
60 Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Dcs<anbcr 1995

More Related Content

What's hot

PettyMFinalPaper11252014
PettyMFinalPaper11252014PettyMFinalPaper11252014
PettyMFinalPaper11252014
Michelle Petty
 
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text MiningExamining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
Stephen Downing
 
Development and classification
Development and classification Development and classification
Development and classification
Arun Madanan
 
Nursing theories
Nursing theoriesNursing theories
Nursing theories
Mae Aguilar
 
Theory
TheoryTheory
Overview and Future of Nursing Research
Overview and Future of Nursing ResearchOverview and Future of Nursing Research
Overview and Future of Nursing Research
Enoch Snowden
 
Professional Paradigm
Professional ParadigmProfessional Paradigm
Professional Paradigm
Starwindow
 
Historical background of nsg research
Historical background of nsg researchHistorical background of nsg research
Historical background of nsg research
aneez103
 
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Mallika Vhora
 
Theory 1
Theory 1Theory 1
Sesi pembuka adang
Sesi pembuka adangSesi pembuka adang
Sesi pembuka adang
HAJIDINKESDKI
 
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledgeChapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
stanbridge
 
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practicesIntroduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
RushilaLaishram
 
historical development of nursing research
historical development of nursing researchhistorical development of nursing research
historical development of nursing research
Jolly George
 
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowing
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowingNursings fundamental patterns of knowing
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowing
Jijo G John
 
Theories
TheoriesTheories
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-pptEvaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
Maria Poly
 
Ppt (1)
Ppt (1)Ppt (1)
Ppt (1)
anjalatchi
 
Bandura self efficacy ppt
Bandura self efficacy pptBandura self efficacy ppt
Bandura self efficacy ppt
PatriciaBeziRN
 
Introduction to theory By Ritika Soni
Introduction to theory By Ritika SoniIntroduction to theory By Ritika Soni
Introduction to theory By Ritika Soni
Shimla
 

What's hot (20)

PettyMFinalPaper11252014
PettyMFinalPaper11252014PettyMFinalPaper11252014
PettyMFinalPaper11252014
 
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text MiningExamining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
Examining "Borrowed Theory" in Original vs. New Disciplines via Text Mining
 
Development and classification
Development and classification Development and classification
Development and classification
 
Nursing theories
Nursing theoriesNursing theories
Nursing theories
 
Theory
TheoryTheory
Theory
 
Overview and Future of Nursing Research
Overview and Future of Nursing ResearchOverview and Future of Nursing Research
Overview and Future of Nursing Research
 
Professional Paradigm
Professional ParadigmProfessional Paradigm
Professional Paradigm
 
Historical background of nsg research
Historical background of nsg researchHistorical background of nsg research
Historical background of nsg research
 
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
Scope and significance of evidence based research in nursing practice27 5-20
 
Theory 1
Theory 1Theory 1
Theory 1
 
Sesi pembuka adang
Sesi pembuka adangSesi pembuka adang
Sesi pembuka adang
 
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledgeChapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
Chapter 5 components and levels of abstraction in nursing knowledge
 
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practicesIntroduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
Introduction to professional nursing concepts and practices
 
historical development of nursing research
historical development of nursing researchhistorical development of nursing research
historical development of nursing research
 
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowing
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowingNursings fundamental patterns of knowing
Nursings fundamental patterns of knowing
 
Theories
TheoriesTheories
Theories
 
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-pptEvaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
Evaluation of-a-nursing-theory-nursing-theory-ppt
 
Ppt (1)
Ppt (1)Ppt (1)
Ppt (1)
 
Bandura self efficacy ppt
Bandura self efficacy pptBandura self efficacy ppt
Bandura self efficacy ppt
 
Introduction to theory By Ritika Soni
Introduction to theory By Ritika SoniIntroduction to theory By Ritika Soni
Introduction to theory By Ritika Soni
 

Viewers also liked

5分でわかる助成金
5分でわかる助成金5分でわかる助成金
5分でわかる助成金Sugiyama Hiroki
 
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
Ahmed Abdelghany
 
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金Sugiyama Hiroki
 
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金Sugiyama Hiroki
 
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruzVerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
Tom Cruz
 
Doc1
Doc1Doc1
Doc1
28647913
 
Final Presentation
Final PresentationFinal Presentation
Final Presentation
Tom Cruz
 
5分で分かる助成金
5分で分かる助成金5分で分かる助成金
5分で分かる助成金Sugiyama Hiroki
 
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur DiebstahlsaufklärungZulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
André Zimmermann
 
Overlapping Vulnerabilities
Overlapping VulnerabilitiesOverlapping Vulnerabilities
Overlapping Vulnerabilities
Catherine Salgado
 
analysis of effective of training program
analysis of effective of training programanalysis of effective of training program
analysis of effective of training program
Rekha Angel
 
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
Hashers United
 
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
Hashers United
 
Circuit breaker
Circuit breakerCircuit breaker
Circuit breaker
Syafei Yusri
 
Litecoin from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
Litecoin  from genesis to the moon by Charlie LeeLitecoin  from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
Litecoin from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
Hashers United
 
Riesgos fisicos
Riesgos fisicosRiesgos fisicos
Riesgos fisicos
eduarrincon6
 
Leather
LeatherLeather
It all starts here
It all starts hereIt all starts here
It all starts here
SIAAmerica
 
Styles of printing
Styles of printingStyles of printing
Styles of printing
sakshisingh3100
 
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine LeiningerTranscultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
Shelley Cullum
 

Viewers also liked (20)

5分でわかる助成金
5分でわかる助成金5分でわかる助成金
5分でわかる助成金
 
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
How to make companies run after you ver0.7 nov14
 
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
 
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
5分で分かる労働環境向上助成金
 
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruzVerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
VerizonFinalPresentation_TomCruz
 
Doc1
Doc1Doc1
Doc1
 
Final Presentation
Final PresentationFinal Presentation
Final Presentation
 
5分で分かる助成金
5分で分かる助成金5分で分かる助成金
5分で分かる助成金
 
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur DiebstahlsaufklärungZulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
Zulässige Videoüberwachung durch Arbeitgeber zur Diebstahlsaufklärung
 
Overlapping Vulnerabilities
Overlapping VulnerabilitiesOverlapping Vulnerabilities
Overlapping Vulnerabilities
 
analysis of effective of training program
analysis of effective of training programanalysis of effective of training program
analysis of effective of training program
 
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
Building a Cost-effective Mining Rig by Michael Carter (BitsBeTrippin)
 
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
An analysis of bitcoin exchange rates by Jake Smith (University of Houston)
 
Circuit breaker
Circuit breakerCircuit breaker
Circuit breaker
 
Litecoin from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
Litecoin  from genesis to the moon by Charlie LeeLitecoin  from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
Litecoin from genesis to the moon by Charlie Lee
 
Riesgos fisicos
Riesgos fisicosRiesgos fisicos
Riesgos fisicos
 
Leather
LeatherLeather
Leather
 
It all starts here
It all starts hereIt all starts here
It all starts here
 
Styles of printing
Styles of printingStyles of printing
Styles of printing
 
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine LeiningerTranscultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
Transcultural Nursing Powerpoint Presentation/Dr. Madeleine Leininger
 

Similar to 1376 4578-1-sm

The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
sdfghj21
 
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdfMadeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
bkbk37
 
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptxNursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
SikoBikoAreru
 
NURSING THEORIES.pptx
NURSING THEORIES.pptxNURSING THEORIES.pptx
NURSING THEORIES.pptx
APRILGRACETCANASA
 
Dine Nursing Theory
Dine Nursing TheoryDine Nursing Theory
Dine Nursing Theory
KhadiraMohammed
 
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing scienceChapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
stanbridge
 
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing scienceChapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
stanbridge
 
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docxReflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
ringrid1
 
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
Eileen Ziegler
 
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING JULY 2002Leininger .docx
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING  JULY 2002Leininger .docx189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING  JULY 2002Leininger .docx
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING JULY 2002Leininger .docx
aulasnilda
 
WLP WEEK 1.pdf
WLP WEEK 1.pdfWLP WEEK 1.pdf
WLP WEEK 1.pdf
JessamaeCabasan1
 
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppttranscultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
GabrielaCordeiro26
 
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdfMiddle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
bkbk37
 
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
SISTER LISIEUX TRESA
 
Andragogy In Nursing A Literature Review
Andragogy In Nursing  A Literature ReviewAndragogy In Nursing  A Literature Review
Andragogy In Nursing A Literature Review
Sandra Long
 
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdfNursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
bkbk37
 
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdfNursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
bkbk37
 
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdfPortfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
sdfghj21
 
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
stirlingvwriters
 
Curriculum Introduction & Process
Curriculum Introduction & ProcessCurriculum Introduction & Process
Curriculum Introduction & Process
Anamika Ramawat
 

Similar to 1376 4578-1-sm (20)

The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
The Sunrise Model Teaching of Nursing Article Theoretical Framework Discussio...
 
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdfMadeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
Madeleine Culture Care Theory.pdf
 
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptxNursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
Nursing Theory 4 PG.pptx
 
NURSING THEORIES.pptx
NURSING THEORIES.pptxNURSING THEORIES.pptx
NURSING THEORIES.pptx
 
Dine Nursing Theory
Dine Nursing TheoryDine Nursing Theory
Dine Nursing Theory
 
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing scienceChapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
 
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing scienceChapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
Chapter 2 the evolution of nursing science
 
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docxReflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
Reflection as an Educational Strategyin Nursing Professional.docx
 
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01
 
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING JULY 2002Leininger .docx
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING  JULY 2002Leininger .docx189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING  JULY 2002Leininger .docx
189JOURNAL OF TRANSCULTURAL NURSING JULY 2002Leininger .docx
 
WLP WEEK 1.pdf
WLP WEEK 1.pdfWLP WEEK 1.pdf
WLP WEEK 1.pdf
 
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppttranscultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
transcultural_nursing_nur324.ppt
 
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdfMiddle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
Middle Range Nursing Theorist.pdf
 
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
Nursingtheories 130729120009-phpapp01(1)
 
Andragogy In Nursing A Literature Review
Andragogy In Nursing  A Literature ReviewAndragogy In Nursing  A Literature Review
Andragogy In Nursing A Literature Review
 
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdfNursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
 
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdfNursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
Nursing Theories Aacn Essentials Question CC.pdf
 
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdfPortfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
Portfolio My class is NURSING RESEARCH 28358.pdf
 
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
Develop an effective communication style for interacting with current patient...
 
Curriculum Introduction & Process
Curriculum Introduction & ProcessCurriculum Introduction & Process
Curriculum Introduction & Process
 

1376 4578-1-sm

  • 1. (r e s e a r c h ) PUTTING LEININGER’S NURSING THEORY “CULTURE CARE DIVERSITY AND UNIVERSALITY” INTO OPERATION IN THE CURRICULUM - PART 1 L de Villiers and D van der Wal ABSTRACT The culturally diverse South African society necessitates inclusion o f transcultural nursing in the curriculum. This article focuses on research regarding the putting o f Leininger's nursing theory into operation in the curriculum to provide a scientific base for the inclusion o f such nursing. The research process and results are discussed. OPSOMMING Die multikulturele aard van die Suid-Afrikaanse samelewing noodsaak insluiting van transkulturek verpleegkunde by die kurrikulum, gegrondop 'n verpleegteorie. Hierdie artikel is gerig op navorsing ten einde Leininger se verpleegteorie in die kurrikulum te operasion^iseer. Die navorsingsproses en resultate word deur die outeur bespreek INTRODUCTION The culturally diverse South African society necessitates a new perspective on nursing education and curriculum development. There is increasing need for transcultural nursing in the curriculum to enable graduates to render congruent cultural nursing care. Successful health care delivery based on primary health care, is dependent on congruent cultural nursing care (Sekgobela 1986:30; MacDonald 1987:32); Burrows (1983:478) regards an ethnocentric curriculum as a form of institutionalized racism resulting in inadequate nursing care. Man is acknowledged as a cultural being in the philosophies of many nursing schools. Chater (1975:429) argues that a philosophy is rarely reflected in all phases of the curriculum although a nursing theory guides all phases of, and provides a scientific base for, the curriculum (Aggleton & Chalmers 1989:24, Brower & Baker 1976:686). With reference to transcultural nursing. Brink (1990:523) says “cultural diversity remains elusive without a tJteoretical framework Farr (1978:294-299) recommends that man as a culmral being be acknowledged in nursing school philosophies and that inclusion of cultural content in the curriculum be based on an appropriate nursing theory. IMPLICATIONS OF LEININGER’S NURSING THEORY FOR THE CURRICULUM The focus of this theory is to discover care diversities and universalities in order to provide culturally congruent care (Leininger 1991 a: 11 & Leininger 1991 b:39). Putting Leininger’s nursing theoiy into operation therefore can be instrumental in preparing the nursing student to deliver congruent cultural care. The existing ethnocentric curriculum, based mainly on Euro-American values, thus will make way for a curriculum which reflects not only a biomedical, but also a sociocultural perspective on health related matters. Because a nursing theory influences all phases of the curriculum, the use of Leininger’s nursing theory should result in bnnging congruent cultural nursing education to a multicultural student population LEININGER’S NURSING THEORY IN OPERATION IN THE CURRICULUM Operation o f this nursing theory was accomplished by research involving theoretical reflection Research question The research question on which the study was based, is: How can Leininger's Nursing Theory "Culture Care Diversity and Universality " be operationalized in the curriculum? Aim The aim of the study was to gain insight into culturally congruent nursing education by means of an exploratory study. Mouton and Marais (1992:45) regard willingness to explore new ideas and suggestions as essential for a good exploratory study. Goal The goal was to promote culturally congruent care through formulation of guidelines for the operating of Leininger’s nursing theory, in order to include transcultural nursing in the curriculum. Objectives The objectives were: • to analyze and evaluate Leininger’s nursing theory. • to operationalize Leininger’s nursing theory in the curriculum. Research design and method A flexible, non-empirical, exploratory research design involving the method of theoretical reflection, was utilized. Steyn (1981:34) explains this method as the gathering and systematic critique of data by means of deductive and inductive thought processes. Such a study, according to Engelbrecht (1989:61), is interpretative-theoretical in nature. Data were gathered by means of a literature study. According to Mouton and Marais (1992:45) a literature study can be applied successfully to an exploratory study. Expert publications regarding the relationship between culture and the cuniculum, as well as culturally congruent care, were subjected to analysis and critique Data gathering and analysis were done simultaneously A conceptual framework (Figure 1) and data 56 Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Dcsember 1995
  • 2. reduction plan (Table 1) were developed to guide data gathering and analysis. RESEARCH PROCESS The research was completed in four phases: Phase 1 Phase one comprised description, analysis and evaluation of Leininger’s nursing theory and included three steps: Step 1 Description of Leininger’s nursing theory. Step 2 Development of a conceptual framework for analysis and evaluation of the theory (Table 2). Step 3 Analysis and evaluation of the theory by means of the conceptual framework developed in step 2. Analysis and evaluation of the nursing theory resulted in insight into its strengths as an appropriate theoretical framework for the inclusion of anthropological concepts and transcultural nursing in the curriculum. Leininger describes cultural and social structure dimensions which influence man’s perception of health, sickness and care, as well as nursing’s unique position relative to the professional and generic health care systems. Culturally congruent care is provided by a creative combination of the professional and generic health care systems. This is achieved through three modes of nursing care judgement, decisions and actions namely:- a) culture care preservation b) maintenance, accommodation negotiation and c) repatterning restructuring, in order to preserve, adapt and restructure care values, lifeways and practices (Leininger 1991b;37-38 & 41-44; Stasiak 1991:1%). Leininger’s nursing theory provides an abstract theoretical framework for the establishment of transcultural nursing in the curriculum but a concrete frame of reference also is required to guide structuring of this component of the curriculum and to facilitate implementation of acquired concepts by the student. This understanding led to the second phase of research which was exploration of Chrisman’s expansionist approach Phase 2 Durmg phase two, a literature study was undertaken to explore Chrisman’s expansionist approach (1990:2-3), the author suggests that this humanist approach complements Leininger’s nursing theory Whereas Leininger’s nursing theory is abstract and focuses on transcultural nursing as a formal field of study, the expansionist approach is a client centrcd one, through which the client can be approached (Chrisman 1991a:2-5) Within the context of this study, the expansionist approach can be used to: OIIRECnVE PHASE FORMATIVE PHASE Educational philoaophy Curriculum davelopment model Situation analysie Transcultural nursing content Terminology Guttural issues Programme objectivM Clinical competence LEININGER'S NURSING THEORY FUNCTIONAL PHASE Educational strat»giM Rgure 1 Concaptual framework for data gathmlng, analysis and presentation • organize transcultural nursing curriculum content and identify associated clinical competence according to the principles of congruent cultural care (ie knowledge, respect and negotiation). • include both the biomedical and socio­cultural perspectives on health matters in the curriculum, therefore putting an end to ethnocentrism in nursing education. • ensure congruent cultural care by using the nursing process within the cultural context during clinical teaching Phase 3 Phase three comprised the putting of Leininger’s nursing theory into operation in the curriculum. This phase was completed in three steps Step 1 A literature study regarding the merit of curriculum development based on a nursing theory and implications of a nursing theory for the curriculum was done Step 2 Development and description of a conceptual framework for data gathenng, -analysis and -presentation. (Figure 1), as well as a data reduction plan (Table 1) was drawn up. Step 3 Data gathering and atulysis by means of the conceptual framework (Figure I) and data reduction plan (Table 1) was carried out. Phase 4 Phase four involved the formulation of guidelines for including transcultural nursing in the curriculum. RESULTS The study resulted in the formulation of such guidelines and a brief overview of these guidelines is presented (Sec Table 3). General Nursing theory as a foundation for curriculum development has implications for the directive, formative and functional phases of the curriculum. Directive phase An analysis of the situation is undertaken to determine the social characteristics and health Table 1 Data reduction CATEGORY CODE Directive phase 1 Educational philoeophy 2 Situation analysts 3 Terminology 4 Programme o b fe c tn^ Formative phase 5 Curricukjm development model 6 Transcultural nursing content 7 Cuttural issues e Q in ical competence Functional phase 0 Educational strategies Curationis, Vol 18 No. 1, Dcsember 1995 57
  • 3. related needs of the main cultures served by the nursing school. This analysis should be based on the seven social and cultural structural dimensions described by Leininger namely; cultural values and lifeways, as well as technological, religiousphilosophical, kinshipsocial, politicalMegal, economic and educational factors. The philosophy of the nursing school needs acknowledge man as a cultural being. The inclusion of transcultural nursing in the curriculum, should be based on Leininger’s nursing theory “Culture Care Diversity and Universality”, and be complemented by Chrisman’s expansionist approach. Leininger’s deflnitions of culture, man, health, nursing and environment may be included in the terminology which serves as a frame of reference for curriculum development and its implementation, as applicable to transcultural nursing. Culture is regarded as the main concept and the others as subconcepts. Chrisman’s definitions of sickness, disease and illness, are appropriate and will result in insight into the universal nature of sickness and its causation in terms ofthe biomedical versus sociocultural perspectives. The Programme Objectives for the Education and Training of a Nurse (General, Psychiatric, Community) and Midwife [South African Nursing Council 1988:Paragraph(6X2)],should reflect the aim of developing the student’s ability to render culturally congruent care. The curriculum therefore must provide for personal and professional development of the student so that, by completion of the course of study, the student will: • show respect for the dignity and uniqueness of man in his social-cultural and religious context and approaches and understand him as a psychological, physical, social and cultural being within this context [South African Nursing Council 1988: Paragraph (6X2Xm)]. • be able to promote community involvement within a multicultural context at any point along the healthdisease continuum in all stages of the life cycle [South African Nursing Council 1988: Paragraph (6X2Xm)]. Formative phase Inclusion of transcultural nursing content is achieved by a combination of curriculum development models. A course in anthropology is followed by transcultural nursing units o f instruction in close association with related nursing subjects. For instance, cultural diversities and universalities regarding pain-experience and its alleviation should form part of the pain module. Table 2 Analysis and evaluation of Leininger’s nursing theory S T R U C TU R E CRITERIA P R O C E S S C R IT ER IA Historical development. Semantic integrity and congruence with eatablished general knowlikJge: Established general knowledge about man and health. Correspondence with a paradigm in nursing and between the theory and It's undertying phik>-sophical assumptions. Level of abstractkxi of concepts. Clarity and consistency of principles, concepts and propositions. Parsimony. Philosophk^i assumptions Coherence: Relationship to other nursing theories. Logical flow from philo-sophk»U assumptions to propositions. Symmetry and beauty. Principles and propositions Pragmatkss Utility. Contribution to nursing. Metaparadigm concepts The integrated approach is followed during clinical teaching to enable the student to apply principles of congruent cultural care while attending to the client holistically. The principles of congruent cultural care are knowledge, respect and negotiation (Chrisman 1991 b:36). The anthropology course should include units on:- a) Culture • Cultural concepts. • The seven cultural and social structure dimensions o f Leininger. These dimensions are cultural uni versals, but also culturally diverse in nature. b) The relationship between culture and health • Cultural factors affecting health. • Perceptions of health and sickness. • Sickness behaviour, including pathways to health and treatment strategies The transcultural nursing units of instruction include; a) A comparative study of at least two of the main cultures in the region served by the nursing school, by means of Leininger’s seven cultural and social structure dimensions. This is followed by units related to specific nursing subjects For instance - Ethical issues within cultural context, in the Ethos and Professional Practice module. • Cultural beliefs and practices associated with pregnancy and labour, in the midwifery modules. b) Subject content to promote self know­ledge in the student. Self knowledge includes knowledge regarding personal and professional values the nurae brings to the health care situation and which may lead to stereotyping of and prejudice towards clients. c) Subject content related to cultural issues are included in the curriculum in order to promote moral development of the student. Examples of cultural issues are human rights within the cultural context and the effect ethnocentrism has on the quality of nursing care (Leininger 1991a: 13; Mattson 1987:207). One of the principles of cultural congruent care (namely negotiation) implies clinical competence. Clinical competence assumes integration of knowledge, attitudes and skills needed to function as a registered nurse (Mallik 1988:11). Negotiation is a social skill which includes listening to the client’s view, explaining the professional view, comparing the two viewpoints and arriving at a compromise for a workable and safe care plan (Chrisman 1990;13-14). Such compromise implies social, communication and higher cognitive skills on the nurse’s part. Listening and explaining are communication skills. Comparing involves critical analytical thought processes and compromising implies social skills Within the transcultural nursing context, these skills are used to develop a negotiated nursing care plan according to Leininger’s three modes of nursing le 58 Curationis, Vol 18 No. 1, Desembcr 1995
  • 4. Table 3 Including transculturai nursing In the curriculum: Planning quide AC-nVITY DIRECTIVE PHASE 1 SmJATION ANALYSIS A titajalion analysn hae bwn ImplafTwnted by maans of Leininger's s«v«n cultural and tocial itructura dimansions, namaly: - Technological lacton • Raligious and philoaophical factors - Kinwip and aocial lactors • Cultiral valuas and ways ol living • Politicai and lagal tadois - Economical (actors • Educational tactcis 2 EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY Acknowrladgamart has baan givan to Man as oJtutal baings Tha intantion to approacti ttia patent holiaticelly wiithin tha cuRural ccnMKl haa baan statad 3 TERM NO LO Q Y Tha tallowing oorKapts. as dafinad by Lainingar, ars indudad in tha tarminology: -Cullurs • Man ■Haalth -Nursing -Environment Tha tallowing ooncapts as dsAnad tiy Chhsman. a n included in the temiinalogy - Sickness -Illness -Disease 4 PROGRAMME OBJECTIVES The prograirme cbiectives include the following irtentiora: - To develop the sludert's ability to approach and underetand the patient as a oitural being • To prorrxM comrunity development within the cultural corteM FORMATIVE PHASE 5 CURRICULUM D EVELOPMENT PHAS E Currictium development model: A basic anthropology course is included in the curriculum - Tranacultural nursing units of instruction thei builds upon the anthropology course, are included at strategic pants throughout the cumoium - Transculturai nursing is integrated into clinical teaching progrannmes • S U B JE C T CONTENT The basic anthropology course corsists at. ■ CiJtml oorxsepts - Ovsrvtew of the seven aJtural and social structure dimensions of Lemnger as cultural umysrsals - Cultural factors ttut influence health - Percaptions regarding health and dissasa - Sickneaa behaviour, including pathways to haalth arvj treatmert strategies The tranacultural unils of inatrucbon include; - A connparativs study of at least two cultures by means ct the seven cultural arxl social structure dirrwnsions - Subiect content related to seH-^nowledge - Cultural ssuas 7 C LINICAL COMP ETEN CE The following clinical skills are included Social skills - Socncultural asseasmant - Negotiation - Aaeei smart of community needs - Conflict managemert Commurvcatkxi witNn the cultural cortext Higher cognitivs skills - Critical analitical thought proceesas - Protasaional |udgemer« - DeciSKn making whith regard to cullurs cars prasarvAion. accommodation or reatructunng Negotiation as an rtegration of the abovs skills COMPLETED FUNCTIONAL PHASE • EDUCATKM4AL STTtATEQIEB The educttiorwl strategies provide lor the lolkMing Devetopment of a knowledge base Utiliiation of the Meraturs as a aource of knowledge ExpenerVial learning Development of reepect Role modelling Utiliabon of human and material resources Expenertial leamng FaciMation of meaninglul mulb-cultural learning expenerxses CtmKal leaching is based on the pnnciples of expanerxaal learning Trarvcullural nunmg is applied to the nursing process Mullx:iitural ecucatxin. taking into account individual differences among studens with regard to the folkiwing - Learning styles - Perceptions regarding molivatxn, achievement and reward - Strategies th« requwe group and indrvidual work, ars aftemated REQUIRE FURTHER ATTENTION judgment, decision making and actions. The nursing student also lias to develop skills to perform a political function in the assessment of community health needs and priorities, communicating this information to politicians, as well as conflict management should health care be regarded by the community as incongruent to their needs or priorities (Adlem 1993:17). Functional phase Educational strategies applicable to transculturai nursing are divided into approaches aimed at the: • development of a transculturai nursing knowledge base. • development of respect • provision of meaningful multicultural learning experiences. • provision for individual differences among students. Educational strategies for the development of a transculturai nursing knowledge base should not be aimed at teaching lists of cultural ch a rac teristic s which could lead to stereotyping of clients (Germain 1992:3). Stern (1985:177) regards literature and personal experience as appropriate sources for gaining transculturai nursing knowledge. Personal experience can be attained by guest speakers, discussions and culture days (Brink 1990:523, Capers 1992:27; Woolfolk 1990:486-487). Development of respcct can be achieved by strategies such as modelling and utilization of human and matenal resources, as well as simulation (Stem 1985:182-183). Examples could be observation of the life history of a person of another culture or a Culture Game, simulating culture shock (Stern 1985:182-183, Leimnger 1994:220). Leininger (1991a:5) regards experential learning as appropriate for transculturai nursing. Kolb’s experential learning cycle (personal experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualisation and active experimenUtion) provides a theoretical base for multicultural learning expenences. this in turn provides for cognitive and afl"ective dimensions of learning (Kolb in Holbert & Thomas 1988:30-31). It can be applied to discussions and clinical teaching. Clinical teaching also should be implemented within the cultural context. Anderson (1987:9) writes: “ihe clinical encounter is a social process in which each party brings a set o f expectations and beliefs about the problem at hand The critical issue here is that both the perspectives o f the nurse and the patient and his or her family art legitimate " Gagnon (1983:128) states that clinical placements should provide the student with the opportunity to encounter culturally diverse groups in addition to focus on clinical Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Desembcr 1995 59
  • 5. specialities. The nursing process should be implemented within the cultural context which implies sociocultural assessment, a negotiated nursing care plan and implementation as well as evaluation, according to the biomedical and sociocultural perspective (Chrisman 1990:11-13). Individual differences among culturally diverse students include differences in learning styles, as well as diverse perspectives regarding achievement, motivation and reward. Inclusion of transcultural nursing in the curriculum implies multicultural education, taking into consideration cultural pluralism, rather than imposing Euro-American values on a culturally diverse student population (Slavin 1986:508; Slavin 1991:451; Woolfolk 1990:527). LIMITATIONS The interpretative nature of this study might have resulted in some degree of bias. Although nursing theory influences all phases of the curriculum, the evaluation phase was not included in the study, because it is considered as a separate research project. Despite the limitations, the study contributes to a thorough exploration of the relationship between Leininger’s nursing theory and the curriculum and provides the basis for further research in order to establish transcultural nursing as a formal field of study in South Africa. RECOMMENDATIONS Continuing education Personnel development regarding transcultural nursing should be provided for lecturers and nursing practitioners responsible for accompaniment of students. Research It is recommended that research is undertaken into student evaluation within the transcultural nursing context, to enable lecturers to monitor the student’s progress towards cultural congruent care. Research into the characteristics and health carc needs of the main cultures of the various regions, in order to ensure relevant curricula, is needed. Curriculum development It is recommended that: • curriculum evaluation be undertaken, guided by the guidelines in this study. • curriculum development be undertaken within a regional context due to cultural diversity between the various regions • transcultural nursing be included in the curriculum according to the guidelines (Table 3) formulated for the inclusion of transcultural nursing. CONCLUSION This study focused on the putting of Leininger’s nursing theory into operation within the curriculum in order to include transcultural nursing. This was achieved by means of a non-empirical exploratory study. Inclusion of transcultural nursing in the curriculum will result into culturally congruent care and the provision of multicultural education to students. REFERENCES Adlcm, W .U . (1993). Makro-ptruptutU tvalutnng van gtiauBmdtatm- g*l**rahtdt mtt bttondtrt vtrwysing no vtrpUtgomkrwys OngqwUtscerd UNISA. Agglcton, P. !l Chalmers, H (19«9). Next y etr't modeU Nursing Titmt. 85. 51. 24-27 Andcnon, J.M. (19S7). The culniral context of caring Canadian Cnhcal Can Nursing Journal, 4, 4. 7-13 Brink, P J . (1990). Cultural divcraity in nursmg How much can we tolerate In: Current issuts in nursing, edited by J.C McCloakey and H.K Grace, third edition, St Louu Moaby, 1990. pp 521-527 Brower, HT .F. & Baker, B J . (1976). Using the Adaptation Model in a practitioner cumcuhim. Nursing Outlook.lA, 11,6*6-687 Burrmrs, A. (19(3) Patioit-centered nunuig care in a mulu-racial society the relevance of ethnographic penpectives ui nuning curricula Journal t^Advanctd Nursing. - its Capers. C.F. (1992). Teaching cultural content a nursmg mpoative Hohsac Nurse Practct. 6.3. 19-28 Chater, S.S. (1975). A conceptual framework for curriculum development Nursing Outlook, 23. 7, 428^33 Chrisman, NJ. (1990). Expanding nursing praOiCt with culture-stnsilivt oart: a nrw approach to transcultural nursing Unpublished University of Washmgton Chrisman, NJ. (1991a) CuhunI systems In Canar nursing; a ccmpnhtnsnt ttxiboot, edited by S Baird. R McCorkle and M Grant. Philadelphia W B Saundffs, 1991,45-54 Chrisman. NJ.0991b). Culture-sensitive nursing care In: Mtdical-surgical nursii^: pathophysiologic concepts, edited by M.L Patnck, S L Woods. R F Craven. J S Rokosky and P.M Bruno. Second edition, Philadelphia LippincoO. 1991. 34-47 D* Villiers. L. (1994) Operastonahsenng van Ltmngtr St V tr p lttg tto n t "Culture Care Diversity and Universality" in die kurrikulum. M A Cut Verhandehng. Universiteit van Suid-Afnka Engelbrecht, C.S. (1989) Benaderings en metodes ui opvoedkundige navorsing In Navorsing in die OfK’oeckunde, saamgestel deur J.J Booyse. Pretons UNISA, 1989, 42-70 Farr, R R (1978) The incorporation <4cultural divtrsily into nursing aimcula D Ed thesis, Brigham Young University Gagnon, AJ. (19S3) Transcultural nursng ncludingitin the curriculim Nursing and Health Care. Much 1983, 127-131 Germain, C.F. (1992) Cultural care a bndge between sickness, illness and disease Holistic Nurse Practice. 6, 3. 1-9 Holbert, C.M. A Thomas, KJ. (19H) Toward whole brain education in nursing Nurse Educator, 13. 1, 30-34 L.eininger, M.M. (1991a) Celebration o f nursing: a transcultural human care ethos with ethical considerations. Keynote centennial adtkess for one hundred veers cfmirsing in South Afhca Unpublished UNISA Ldnlnger,M.M. (1991b). (Editor) Culture C a v Diversity andVniversality: athtoryafnumng New York: NLN. Leialnger, M.M. (1994). Teaching and learning transcultural nursing In: Nursing education An international perspective, edited by T G. Mashaba and H.IL. Bnnk. Kenwyn Juta, 207-225. MacDonald, J. 09(7). Preparing to woik in a mulucultural tocMy Canadian Nurse. 83,8.31-32. Mallik. M (1988) A canng curncukim. Semor Nurse, 8. 9/10.9-11 Mattson, S. (1987) The need for cultural concepts in nursuig currKula Journal cfNursing Education, 26.5. 206-208 Mouton, J. A Marala, R C . (1 9 « ) Btmese begrippe: metodologie vir die geesUswetentkappe Heniene uitgawe derde druk Pretoria: RGN Parae, R.R 0987), Nursing sdenoi. Mcfor paradigms, timmes end crittques Philadelphia: Saunders Sekaobek, M.J. (19W) Conmunity participation The hemt of community health NursmgRSA. 1.9,30-31 Slavin, R.E. (1986) Educational peycholo^: theory into practice Second edition Englewood ClifT: Prentice Hall Slavin, R.E. (1991) Educational psychology: theory into practice Third ediuon Boston Allyn It Bacoa Staslak. D.B. (1991). Culture Care Theory with Mexican Americans in an urban context In: Culture Care Diversity and Universalily: a theory o f nursing, edited by MM. Lemu^a. New York: NLN, 1991,179-202 Stem, P.N. (1985) Teaching transcultural nursuig in Louiaiaiu Health Care for Women Intemaaoncl, 6. 1/3, 175-186 Steyn, CJLA. (1981) Educantulus 3. Navorsingsmetodtek in die opvoedkunde Pretoria: Universiteit van Suid-Afrika South African Nursing Caundi, RegulaUcns Relating to the Approval of and Muumum Requiremenu for the Education and Training of a Nurse (Genval. Psychiatric and Cammuruty)and Midwife Leaduig to Registrauon R425 (As amended) Pretoria: Govemmenl Printa, 1988 Woolfolk. A.E. (1990) Educational psychology Fourth Edibon Englewood Clifis Prenuce Hall L de Villiers M.A.CUR. (Unisa) Snr Tutor Ann Latsky Nursing College D van der Wal M.A.CUR. (Unisa) Lecturer UNISA 60 Curationis, Vol 18 No 1, Dcs<anbcr 1995