Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
205540 demonstration of a 10 year, long term project plan
1. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Demonstration of a 10 Year, Long Term
Forecasting Model using Primavera Resource
Loaded Projects
Patrick O’Connell
Project Control Group Lead
Georgia Transmission Corporation
patrick.oconnell@gatrans.com
2. GTC 10 Year LTFM
• There are more slides in this presentation with notes
and procedures
• Not all will be discussed as we will go demo as much
as we can
• Contact me if desired
3. GTC 10 Year LTFM
• GTC - owned by 39 Electric Membership
Cooperatives (EMCs) in Georgia
• Build, operate and maintain Transmission Lines and
Substations
• Not only for the EMC’s but also for the ITS
• ITS – shared transmission system in Georgia with 4
members: GTC, GPC, MEAG and Dalton
4. GTC 10 Year LTFM
• Why this methodology?
• The purpose of the LTFM
is to provide an aligned
cost (EPIS & Cashflow) &
man-hour forecasting tool
• Target audience
• Finance
• Functional Managers
5. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Definitions
• EPIS – Electric Plant In Service
• Depreciation begins
• Affects members as we plan to recover cost for their stations
and lines
• LTFM – Long Term Forecasting Model
• EPIS
• Cashflow
• Capacity planning / Workforce planning
• Cashflow vs EPIS
• Paying the bills vs how we pay off paying the bills
6. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Tools
• TPOP
• Planning tool
• Project attributes
• “Real” projects based on customer need
• P6 v7
• TPOP projects
• “Ghost” projects
• Access
• Query data from multiple data sources
• Excel
• Input/output
• Calculators
• Charts
7. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Tools
• Effect of “Ghost” projects
8. GTC 10 Year LTFM
P6
• Schedules created from standard templates
• Resource loaded
• Expense codes for invoices and payments
• Consistent across all projects
• Project schedule has all cost – BAC, AC, ETC, EAC
• Roles assigned in template
• Standard by project type / activity
• Many departments and job titles
9. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Types of Ghost Projects
• Nine types (well, 14 after considerations)
• Complexity / Size
• New / Mod Subs and New / Mod T/Ls
• Advanced Land Purchase
• Cost average across all for each type
• All expense codes
• All roles – input from team members
• Last 5 years of project history used
• Provision for non standard (like a $30M SS or TL)
• Excluded some as non repeating
• Also, reimbursable projects
10. GTC 10 Year LTFM
What are we doing?
• We have real data that goes out 2-3 years for some
load growth projects and long term projects that
extend for 5-6 year but we don’t plan at the project
level, really that far out.
• We add Ghost projects to match a projection and from
this we get EPIS by project types (accounting need)
and workforce planning by job title.
11. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Predictor Tool (Excel Spreadsheet)
• Sources of Data
• TPOP, Primavera and Formal Projection
• Calculator
• Compares TPOP, Primavera and a prediction to
determine the number of projects to add or remove by
project type
• Graph
• Visual aid as the predictor is adjusted
• It is bottom up estimating
13. GTC 10 Year LTFM
MS Access Queries
• Count (number of projects by type)
• TPOP EPIS
• P6 EPIS
• How many do we need to add (delete)
• Cost
• TPOP EPIS
• P6 EPIS
• As projects are added the cost impacts are telling
14. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Spread Cost
• Each template spreads cost/MH based on activity
duration and cost curves
• Cost Curves
• Construction is back loaded
• Land
• T/L – modified bell curve
• S/S – last period
• Man-hours are linear
15. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Cost by EPS Sheet
• Sanity Check
• Visual check to see if an EPS node does not look “right”
• Useful first step if the chart looks like it has a spike
16. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Project Cost by EPS Sheet
• Error Check
• Step two if you think there might be a bad project
• Easy to sort and group by the same format as the previous
• Example:
• South looks like it has too much
• Drill to South node
• Spy projects and look for outlier(s)
21. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Roles Tab
• List of roles with history
• Class of project
• Direct vs OH
• Number of people supporting the role
• This is how you have charged your time NOT the
place to estimate
22. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Selected Resources Tab
• Pruning
• Who are good candidates to describe the role?
• Selected are those who have worked full years,
consistently on projects
• Exclude
• Started mid year
• Part time
• Re-tasked to other assignments
23. GTC 10 Year LTFM
Role History Tab
• Summarized data by role
• Sanity check
24. GTC 10 Year LTFM
EPS Structure and Activity Counts
25. GTC 10 Year LTFM
LTFM EPS “Years”
• Note 2013 - 2014 have no data by choice
• See how we are extending into the future to capture the
impact of front end activities on the target years
27. GTC 10 Year LTFM
LTFM EPS “Years”
• Note 2013 - 2014 have no data by choice
• See how we are extending into the future to capture the
impact of front end activities on the target years
28. GTC 10 Year LTFM
OH Impact
• No OH shown
• May be flat or steady but is (somewhat) independent of
capital growth
• Ability to predict future year OH rates