SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
The no conclusion intervention
    for couples in conflict
    Dialogical conference Leuven
            march 8 2013
          Lieven Migerode
Migerode, L. & Hooghe, A., (2012). “I love you” How to             Migerode, L. (2012). The no conclusion intervention for
                                                                   couples in conflict. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. Doi:
understand love in couple therapy. Exploring love in context.      10,111/jmft,12.004
Journal of Family Therapy, 34, 371-386. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-
6427.2011.00557.x




                                                lieven.migerode@uzleuven.be



12/03/2013                                     Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven                                                2
Change the other                                                                      Change the other
Anxiety reduction        REACTION                                REACTION             Anxiety reduction




      How do I participate in the impasse                         How do I participate in the impasse
      Looking in the mirror, feel.                                Looking in the mirror, feel.
      Own changes, risk taking.                                   Own changes, risk taking.
                                                 ACTION



                                                                       Speaking and listening
         Speaking and listening                  DIFFERENCE


          Validating (of risk taking)       Love/Bonding over               Validating (of risk taking)

                                            difference

       Falling and getting up                                        Falling and getting up
                                             Love/growth

                                                      Figure 7                                            3
•   Love is at the core of couples
•   Couples are constituted in dialogue
•   You are always different/unique
•   When stuck couples get dua=logical
    – Twice monological
    – Seemingly devide tensions over the partners
• One hour time: lets get do-a-logical
• We can only see well with the
  heart. The essence is invisible
  for the eyes.(The little prince,
  de Saint Exupéry, 1943,).




                           Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
Love
                                                                    Always circular

     Give opposing force
     Knowing and Mystery
     •…


     Stability and Change
     • growth…

     Autonomy and Bonding
     •…


Migerode,L. & Hooghe, A. (In press). How to understand love in couple therapy. Journal of Family Therapy.
How to visualise opposing forces?




closeness   distance                      closeness

                                                          distance




                Lieven Migerode, Context UZLeuven, IFTA
                             march 2011.
No conclusion intervention exercise:



         •Both partners , seperately,
         •name down two areas of difference that lead to conflict.

Step 1
         •Seperately, qualify the conflicting differences either as trivial or important
         •Important = touching on ‘who you are’
         •Important= touching on ‘who your are as a couple’

Step 2   •Important=touching on ‘how the world is’
         •Trivial= neither of the above applies.




         •Exchange the areas of difference
         •Ask question to understand what is named
         •Qualify the areas your partner chose

Step 3   •Four kinds of differences ensue: Trivial-Trivial; trivial-Important; Important-Trivial, Important-Important




                                      Lieven Migerode, Context UZLeuven, IFTA
                                                   march 2011.
Trivial- Important
                                                     Decide not to come to a conclusion
                                                             Make ample time.
                Trivial-Trivial
                                                               Explain Trivial/

                 Take 5’ time                   Listen as good as you can, show understanding
                                                             Explain Important, ,
                   Solve it!
                                                Listen as good as you can, show understanding
             Use cultural methods
                                                                  Put aside
                Life is to short
                                                                 Let it Rise.
                                                                Start all over




             No conclusion intervention
                      Migerode




             Important– Trvial                              Important-Important
     Decide not to come to a conclusion
             Make ample time.                        Decide not to come to a conclusion
               Explain Trivial/                              Make ample time.
Listen as good as you can, show understanding                Explain important/
             Explain Important ,                Listen as good as you can, show understanding
Listen as good as you can, show understanding               Explain Important, ,
                  Put aside                     Listen as good as you can, show understanding
                 Let it Rise.                                     Put aside
                Start all over                                   Let it Rise.
Cultureel geleerde ‘oplossingen’.
                                                   terug

12/03/2013      Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven           10
Therapist actions
• Help partners to make choices
• Help partners to stay with choices
• Help partners to stick to outline
• Help partners to change their choices if
  necesarry
• Help partners to show what they understand
• Ask : Is there more you want to explain?
• Ask : Is there more you want to know?
• Solved


                        Trivial/Trivial   Trivial/Important




                                             Important
                      Important/Trivial
                                            /Important



                                                    •
                                                    • Dis-solved
Figure 6
Love absent in MFT.

•   Love is a noun and a verb, a thing and
    an action, a concept and an organized
    set of behavior, and a subject that
    clinicians generally avoid (Levine, 2007)
•   Love is rarely directly addressed in
    couple therapy and investigated in
    couple research (Riehl-Emde, e.a.
    2003)
•   Love about which is relatively little
    written in couple family therapy
    literature (Grunebaum, 1997)
•   In general psychotherapist have a
    conflicting relationship to love (Willi,
    1997)
•   The lack of attention in the marriage
    therapy literature to romantic love and
    sexual attraction (Roberts, 1992)
                                                               http://www.rein-art.be/
•



                                       Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
Love important for couples

•   Former spouses name ‘the death of love’ as
    primary cause of divorce (Gigy en Kelly, 1992,
    Kayser, 1993; In Berscheid 2010, p 6)
•   Love matters not only because it can make our lives
    better but also because it is a major source of
    misery and pain and can make life worse (Reis &
    Aron, 2008).
•    A love relationship has become the central
    emotional relationship in most people’s lives
    (Johnson, 2008).
•   The couples assessment of their love was the first
    and foremost variable for predicting whether a
    couple belonged to the group with high or low level
    well being= a greater degree of love was associated
    with a greater well being (Riehhl-Emde, 2003).
•   Being in love seems to be me of greater importance
    for the prognosis of marriage the marriage
    happiness and satisfaction (Willi, 1997).
•   The most frequent reason for both marriage and
    divorce is love and the loss of love (Scoresby, 1977
    in Roberts, 1992).

                                                                   http://www.rein-art.be/



                                           Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
Do we know what love is?

•   Because out of the millions, trillions,
    perhaps even centillions of sentences
    written about love , very few can stand
    alone and still strike us a “true”. One of
    those few is “Love is a word”.
    (Bersheid,1995)



•   Love is synthetic rather than
    analytic.(Sternberg 1998)




                                                           http://www.rein-art.be/


                                    Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
Can we then talk about love in
                    therapy?
•    “.Despite the fact that love is one of the
    most polysemous words in English
    language, people generally know what the
    person using the word is trying to
    communicate.” (Bersheid & Meyers, 1996,
    p.171).



•   Theoretically we find support for this in
    the work of Fehr & Russel (1991). They
    propose that love is one of those concepts
    that can best be understood in a
    prototypical way. People ‘know’ if an
    experience matches a concept through its
    resemblance with a model, a prototype.
    (Migerode & Hooghe, in press).                         http://www.rein-art.be/




                                   Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven

More Related Content

Similar to The no conclusion intervention for couples in conflict

The eight habits of highly effective people
The eight  habits of highly effective peopleThe eight  habits of highly effective people
The eight habits of highly effective peopleSeta Wicaksana
 
Empathy In The Workplace
Empathy In The WorkplaceEmpathy In The Workplace
Empathy In The Workplacesuzy629
 
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp Trandolph
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp TrandolphGrief, Loss & Separation Pwp Trandolph
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp TrandolphPJoyceRandolph
 
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptx
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptxFive Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptx
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptxAnneJoiseHerrera
 
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012Rahila Narejo
 
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12htetaft
 
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situations
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situationsThe Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situations
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situationsPortia Tung
 
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptx
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptxCommunication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptx
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptxLisa294081
 
what is Love..............
what is Love.............. what is Love..............
what is Love.............. VisualBee.com
 
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving Conflict
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving ConflictTools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving Conflict
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving ConflictJlindstr
 
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3DANIELLOBERIZ2
 
Empathy: A Keystone Habit
Empathy: A Keystone HabitEmpathy: A Keystone Habit
Empathy: A Keystone Habitptevis
 
Webinar series 3 conflict+
Webinar series 3 conflict+Webinar series 3 conflict+
Webinar series 3 conflict+Jlindstr
 
Cw word choice
Cw word choiceCw word choice
Cw word choicehmfowler
 

Similar to The no conclusion intervention for couples in conflict (20)

The eight habits of highly effective people
The eight  habits of highly effective peopleThe eight  habits of highly effective people
The eight habits of highly effective people
 
Empathy In The Workplace
Empathy In The WorkplaceEmpathy In The Workplace
Empathy In The Workplace
 
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp Trandolph
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp TrandolphGrief, Loss & Separation Pwp Trandolph
Grief, Loss & Separation Pwp Trandolph
 
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptx
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptxFive Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptx
Five Categories of Oral Language Stance And Behavior.pptx
 
Padmavat ppt
Padmavat ppt Padmavat ppt
Padmavat ppt
 
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012
Narejohr counselling_british council_feb-2012
 
Life & work values
Life & work values Life & work values
Life & work values
 
Person-Centered Therapy
Person-Centered TherapyPerson-Centered Therapy
Person-Centered Therapy
 
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12
Type talk and relationships power point 2 28-12
 
SOCIAL STYLES
SOCIAL STYLESSOCIAL STYLES
SOCIAL STYLES
 
ItsmeKeru
ItsmeKeruItsmeKeru
ItsmeKeru
 
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situations
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situationsThe Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situations
The Emperor's New Clothes - Meaningful interactions in stressful situations
 
what is Love?
what is Love? what is Love?
what is Love?
 
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptx
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptxCommunication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptx
Communication, Conflict Resolution, Bullying and Harassment.pptx
 
what is Love..............
what is Love.............. what is Love..............
what is Love..............
 
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving Conflict
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving ConflictTools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving Conflict
Tools and Techniques for Managing and Resolving Conflict
 
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3
LOSS AND GRIEF- a lesson for grade 7 MAPEH: Health q3
 
Empathy: A Keystone Habit
Empathy: A Keystone HabitEmpathy: A Keystone Habit
Empathy: A Keystone Habit
 
Webinar series 3 conflict+
Webinar series 3 conflict+Webinar series 3 conflict+
Webinar series 3 conflict+
 
Cw word choice
Cw word choiceCw word choice
Cw word choice
 

More from opendialogicalpractices (11)

Diagnosis dialogical space
Diagnosis dialogical spaceDiagnosis dialogical space
Diagnosis dialogical space
 
Karine and rolf presentation070313
Karine and rolf presentation070313Karine and rolf presentation070313
Karine and rolf presentation070313
 
Whitaker
WhitakerWhitaker
Whitaker
 
Marc calmeyn
Marc calmeynMarc calmeyn
Marc calmeyn
 
Jaakko pp leuven2013
Jaakko pp leuven2013Jaakko pp leuven2013
Jaakko pp leuven2013
 
Ivana markova pp + dialogue pp
Ivana markova pp + dialogue ppIvana markova pp + dialogue pp
Ivana markova pp + dialogue pp
 
Dingens
DingensDingens
Dingens
 
Dijkstra
DijkstraDijkstra
Dijkstra
 
Margreet de pater
Margreet de paterMargreet de pater
Margreet de pater
 
Cornelis en van oenen
Cornelis en van oenenCornelis en van oenen
Cornelis en van oenen
 
Marc calmeyn
Marc calmeynMarc calmeyn
Marc calmeyn
 

The no conclusion intervention for couples in conflict

  • 1. The no conclusion intervention for couples in conflict Dialogical conference Leuven march 8 2013 Lieven Migerode
  • 2. Migerode, L. & Hooghe, A., (2012). “I love you” How to Migerode, L. (2012). The no conclusion intervention for couples in conflict. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. Doi: understand love in couple therapy. Exploring love in context. 10,111/jmft,12.004 Journal of Family Therapy, 34, 371-386. doi: 10.1111/j.1467- 6427.2011.00557.x lieven.migerode@uzleuven.be 12/03/2013 Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven 2
  • 3. Change the other Change the other Anxiety reduction REACTION REACTION Anxiety reduction How do I participate in the impasse How do I participate in the impasse Looking in the mirror, feel. Looking in the mirror, feel. Own changes, risk taking. Own changes, risk taking. ACTION Speaking and listening Speaking and listening DIFFERENCE Validating (of risk taking) Love/Bonding over Validating (of risk taking) difference Falling and getting up Falling and getting up Love/growth Figure 7 3
  • 4. Love is at the core of couples • Couples are constituted in dialogue • You are always different/unique • When stuck couples get dua=logical – Twice monological – Seemingly devide tensions over the partners • One hour time: lets get do-a-logical
  • 5. • We can only see well with the heart. The essence is invisible for the eyes.(The little prince, de Saint Exupéry, 1943,). Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
  • 6. Love Always circular Give opposing force Knowing and Mystery •… Stability and Change • growth… Autonomy and Bonding •… Migerode,L. & Hooghe, A. (In press). How to understand love in couple therapy. Journal of Family Therapy.
  • 7. How to visualise opposing forces? closeness distance closeness distance Lieven Migerode, Context UZLeuven, IFTA march 2011.
  • 8. No conclusion intervention exercise: •Both partners , seperately, •name down two areas of difference that lead to conflict. Step 1 •Seperately, qualify the conflicting differences either as trivial or important •Important = touching on ‘who you are’ •Important= touching on ‘who your are as a couple’ Step 2 •Important=touching on ‘how the world is’ •Trivial= neither of the above applies. •Exchange the areas of difference •Ask question to understand what is named •Qualify the areas your partner chose Step 3 •Four kinds of differences ensue: Trivial-Trivial; trivial-Important; Important-Trivial, Important-Important Lieven Migerode, Context UZLeuven, IFTA march 2011.
  • 9. Trivial- Important Decide not to come to a conclusion Make ample time. Trivial-Trivial Explain Trivial/ Take 5’ time Listen as good as you can, show understanding Explain Important, , Solve it! Listen as good as you can, show understanding Use cultural methods Put aside Life is to short Let it Rise. Start all over No conclusion intervention Migerode Important– Trvial Important-Important Decide not to come to a conclusion Make ample time. Decide not to come to a conclusion Explain Trivial/ Make ample time. Listen as good as you can, show understanding Explain important/ Explain Important , Listen as good as you can, show understanding Listen as good as you can, show understanding Explain Important, , Put aside Listen as good as you can, show understanding Let it Rise. Put aside Start all over Let it Rise.
  • 10. Cultureel geleerde ‘oplossingen’. terug 12/03/2013 Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven 10
  • 11. Therapist actions • Help partners to make choices • Help partners to stay with choices • Help partners to stick to outline • Help partners to change their choices if necesarry • Help partners to show what they understand • Ask : Is there more you want to explain? • Ask : Is there more you want to know?
  • 12. • Solved Trivial/Trivial Trivial/Important Important Important/Trivial /Important • • Dis-solved Figure 6
  • 13. Love absent in MFT. • Love is a noun and a verb, a thing and an action, a concept and an organized set of behavior, and a subject that clinicians generally avoid (Levine, 2007) • Love is rarely directly addressed in couple therapy and investigated in couple research (Riehl-Emde, e.a. 2003) • Love about which is relatively little written in couple family therapy literature (Grunebaum, 1997) • In general psychotherapist have a conflicting relationship to love (Willi, 1997) • The lack of attention in the marriage therapy literature to romantic love and sexual attraction (Roberts, 1992) http://www.rein-art.be/ • Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
  • 14. Love important for couples • Former spouses name ‘the death of love’ as primary cause of divorce (Gigy en Kelly, 1992, Kayser, 1993; In Berscheid 2010, p 6) • Love matters not only because it can make our lives better but also because it is a major source of misery and pain and can make life worse (Reis & Aron, 2008). • A love relationship has become the central emotional relationship in most people’s lives (Johnson, 2008). • The couples assessment of their love was the first and foremost variable for predicting whether a couple belonged to the group with high or low level well being= a greater degree of love was associated with a greater well being (Riehhl-Emde, 2003). • Being in love seems to be me of greater importance for the prognosis of marriage the marriage happiness and satisfaction (Willi, 1997). • The most frequent reason for both marriage and divorce is love and the loss of love (Scoresby, 1977 in Roberts, 1992). http://www.rein-art.be/ Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
  • 15. Do we know what love is? • Because out of the millions, trillions, perhaps even centillions of sentences written about love , very few can stand alone and still strike us a “true”. One of those few is “Love is a word”. (Bersheid,1995) • Love is synthetic rather than analytic.(Sternberg 1998) http://www.rein-art.be/ Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven
  • 16. Can we then talk about love in therapy? • “.Despite the fact that love is one of the most polysemous words in English language, people generally know what the person using the word is trying to communicate.” (Bersheid & Meyers, 1996, p.171). • Theoretically we find support for this in the work of Fehr & Russel (1991). They propose that love is one of those concepts that can best be understood in a prototypical way. People ‘know’ if an experience matches a concept through its resemblance with a model, a prototype. (Migerode & Hooghe, in press). http://www.rein-art.be/ Lieven Migerode Context UZLeuven