3. WHAT IS LIVE STREAMING?
MEANING
to broadcast video and sound of an event over
the internet as it happens.
4. MEMBERSHIP GOALS BASED ON 1% RULE OF
ADULTS 18 PLUS BY PLACE , 2016 CENSUS
Dryden’s membership is 1% of its adult population.
5. LIVESTREAMING: THREE TIERS OF
GROWTH
TIER ONE - Locality for a potential club
TIER TWO - Locality for a small satellite
TIER THREE – Locality for an individual
6. MEMBERSHIP GOALS
BY LOCATION WITHIN
DRYDEN ORBIT
Red Lake 31 216 km
Fort Francis 62 188 km
Atikokan 22 206 km
Ear Falls 8 164 km
Machin Twp 8 45 km
Ignace 8 107 km
Emo 8 222
km
Rainy River 6 282 km
Villages 4 up to 359 km
TOTAL 157
DISTANCE
TO DRYDEN
The area on the above map is about the size of England & Scotland combined. The
population of the area is about 70,000 vs. 57,000,000 for Eng. & Scotland.
8. LIVE STREAMING VS VIDEO CONFERENCING
Examples
Go-to-Meeting
Zoom
WebEx
Adobe Connect
Examples
BoxCast
Panopto
Livestream (VIMEO)
Ustream
Slingstudio
Facebook Live
YouTube Live
Periscope (Twitter)
(often in combination)
9. LIVE STREAMING VS VIDEO CONFERENCING
Key Advantages
Higher quality video
Simple to connect
Scalable to audience size
Scalable to upgrade quality and
features
Key Advantages
Two way real time communication
10. LIVE STREAMING VS VIDEO CONFERENCING
Advantages
Broadcast in HD quality
(1920x1080p)
Audience size is unlimited
“Near” real time
No software to download or
connect
View on multiple platforms
Simple connect with a URL
No registration needed
Has archiving ability
Professional quality possible
Advantages
Enable two-way online interaction
Real time communication
Good for face to face conversations
Near-zero audio and video delay.
Document integration
Can use desk-top, lap top,
phone with camera
11. LIVE STREAMING VS VIDEO CONFERENCING
Disadvantages
Requires more hardware
Higher start-up costs
No good for face-to-face
meetings
Disadvantages
Limited quality video and audio (640x480p)
Video & audio quality degrade with increase
in number of participants
Difficult to login in
Need to register and get number to
call in so more labour intensive
No long term storage
12. EQUIPMENT FOR LIVESTREAMING -
Camera Tripod Switcher
Canon-Canon XA35 Magnus VT 4000 Roland
($2,800.00) CDN ($200.00) CDN V-1 HD ($1,300) CDN
13. THE ENCODER
HD video streaming
Rugged bullet-proof plastic
Automatically records the
video it encodes
Streams directly to Club
Website
Serves video to any-sized
audience
Captures highlights and
offers social promotion tools
within the BoxCast
Dashboard
($399.00)CDN
EQUIPMENT FOR LIVE STREAMING
15. EQUIPMENT FOR LIVE STREAMING
VIDEO CAMERAS
Beginners Intermediate Advanced
Camera:
Canon Vixia
HF R800
($290.00) CDN
Camera:
Canon VIXIA
HF G20
($1,050.00)CDN
Camera:
Canon XA35
($2,800.00)CDN
Camera:
Canon XA11
($1,700.00)CDN
Intermediate Plus
16. ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT FOR LIVE STREAMING
SPLITTER BOX CABLES GAFFER TAPE HEAD-
PHONES
CONVERTERS CARRYING CASE RECORDER
Sound
cable
Insert PowerPoint Leaves no residue on floor
Keep back-up copy
Take to
Satellite location
17. LIVESTREAMING – QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER
Storage
Viewer capacity
Hardware vs. Software
Simulcasting – sending to multiple destinations
Picture quality
Customer support
Where to send stream
Analytics
Price
Software
18. LIVE STREAMING – COST OPTIONS
USING BOXCAST
Service agreement levels
Standard Plan - $1,600/year CDN
• 1080p HD Video
• Embedded Video Player
• Facebook Live, YouTube Live,
Periscope/Twitter
• Live DVR
• 1 Month Video Storage
• Basic Analytics*(only # of viewers)
• Phone, Email, Chat Support
Advanced Plan - $2,000/year CDN
Standard Features
12 Months Video Storage (vs. 1 Month)
Downloads/Exports
Highlight Clips
Enhanced Analytics* (has data by
community)
Donations
Bulk Scheduling
Live Agent Onboarding Support
19. LIVE STREAMING – COST OPTIONS
USING BOXCAST
BARE MINIMUM CONFIGURATION
Encoder and Service Agreement - $400.00 + $1,600 = $2,000 CDN
Member’s Camera, tripod, iPhone/laptop, & Club Website
20. LIVE STREAMING – COST OPTIONS USING
BOXCAST
Service Agreement: Advanced $2,000
Encoder BoxCast Standard $ 400
Camera : Canon VIXIA HF G20 $1,050
Tripod : Magnus VT 4000 $ 200
Switcher : Roland V-1 HD $1,300
Ancillary materials $ 450
TOTAL $5,000
LEVEL ONE - START-UP CONFIGURATION
21. LIVE STREAMING – COST OPTIONS USING
BOXCAST
Service Agreement: Standard $2,000
Encoder BoxCast Advanced $400
Camera : Canon XA 11 Pro $1,700
Tripod : Magnus VT 4000 $ 200
Switcher : Roland V-1 HD $1,300
Kenex Pro Splitter $50
Ancillary materials $350
TOTAL $6,000
ADVANCED START-UP CONFIGURATION
22. LIVE STREAMING PAYMENT MODELS
A. Club Administration
a) within current bi-annual levy
b) with increased bi-annual levy
B. Club Member Donations
a) 20 members donate $100 each as alternative to bringing in new member
b) Club pays for Encoder and amount over 2,000 CDN (the exchange rate)
C. Consortium
a) Club, City, District 5550, Church, Two School Boards, Hospital Board, Shaw Cable sign MOUs
to jointly share the cost of the hardware and monthly service costs
D. Charity Foundation Funds*
a) Qualifies if we make it available to the community as a community resource to
enhance a sense of community . * Discussion with Patty Speilmacher
23. ADVANTAGES OF FINANCIAL MODELS
A & B
Equipment ownership issue is clear ,
Operating team limited to club volunteers – size 3 - 5 members
Few issues
No need for MOUs
No need to train community volunteers
No need to negotiate role of Club website
Full control over termination of pilot if goals not being met
Start-up time is minimized
24. ADVANTAGES OF FINANCIAL MODELS
C & D
Has potential to:
Make drydenrotary.org a media hub of community
Open governance of local organizations in new ways
Increase sense of community
Reduces club administrative costs
Increased visibility and knowledge of Rotary within community
25. ISSUES RELATED TO FINANCIAL
MODELS C & D
Many issues need to be resolved:
Ownership of equipment needs to be clear and unambiguous
Cost sharing needs negotiation.
MOU ‘s annual administrative renewal cost in time
Establishment of community fee if model D
Certification and training other community user teams
Work load on Rotarian volunteers
Role of Club website vs other organization’s websites
Start-up time could be delayed
26. LIVESTREAMING – PROMOTION
Press release to traditional news media sources in Northwestern
Ontario
Community Newspapers
Radio – Press release for announcements/Websites
- Arrange for Live interviews
27. LIVESTREAMING – PROMOTION
Hold an in-person Rotary Town Hall in the major communities;
Live Interview for Shaw Cable to Broadcast
Social Media – Facebook
Community Poster Campaign
Flyer insert
Weekly announcements on Dryden Rotary Radio Bingo over CKDR
Word of Mouth – telephone campaign
Rotary International Press release and post for Rotary Voices
28. LIVE STREAMING –AUDIENCE
CATEGORIES
1. Persons of Interest
• Watch to learn about their community
• No interest in joining the club
2. Friends of Rotary
• Want to engage with the ways Rotary supports the local community
• Want to be involved with Rotary activities without the duties of membership
• Is willing to contribute a small fee ($50.00/yr) to support Rotary’s activities
3. Full membership in Satellite location
29. POSSIBLE SOCIAL IMPLICATIONS FOR CLUB
Focus changes from local to regional
Will impact programs to have speakers via livestreaming from satellite locations
Will impact executive to plan for future satellite members on executive & need
for video-conferencing
May impact outreach - need to have club meetings in satellite locations
Could have positive impact on other clubs in region
Would we accept members from elsewhere in Canada?
Members experiencing a period of convalescence can remain connected to
club in a real way;
30. LIVE STREAMING: ANCILLARY BENEFITS
AND FUTURE POSSIBILITIES FOR DISTRICT &
RI
As a Rotary pioneer Club will have to deal with requests for information and/or
presentations
In rural areas where clubs are now very small (5-12 members) Livestreaming may be
a means to amalgamate entities while permitting the traditional units to meet yet
be part of a larger whole.
In urban areas with multiple clubs could the system be shared over one common
website with options to join the club of choice rather than each having to purchase
equipment and service separately.
With the advanced system where payments for view are possible a club could use
the system as a fund raising vehicle.
To improve membership Rotary international has approved such strategies as eclubs, satellites and corporate memberships. Each time the cost of technology declines new opportunities arise to build a Rotary club in new ways. Such a time is now, the technology is called Livestreaming.
RI President Barry Rassin’s New Year’s message asks us to “Be the Inspiration.” Today, in that spirit, I am asking you to support a pilot Livestreaming initiative at the Rotary Club of Dryden, which will take Dryden to new levels of membership.
Livestreaming is the broadcasting of live video and sound of a club meeting over the internet while it happens.
I started this study by analysing the demographics of communities within Dryden's “orbit.” I found that Dryden Rotary has nearly exactly one per cent of Dryden’s 18 and over, population. In other words adults.
Using the same criteria, I projected a goal of 157 additional members within ten years.
I then divided the communities into 3 Tiers:
Communities which would begin as Satellites but had the potential to become independent clubs.
Communities which would remain as Satellites and
Communities so small and isolated that they might provide just one member.
A map of Communities in Dryden’s orbit shows 4 goups. Three communities currently with a club are in Black, three in Tier One, five in Tier two, and About 20 in Tier 3. The current clubs show their membership numbers on December 10th 2018. Red Lake, Fort Frances, and Atikokan in Red possess the potential to be chartered. Five small places have adult populations near 1000 with the potential of small satellites of 6-8 members. There are another 20 villages plus the First Nations North of this map from which I estimate maybe four members.
When I first discussed this idea with District Governor Elaine, she suggested we could use the District’s Zoom Video Conferencing system. So I made a comparison of the two systems.
This slide shows the basic difference in purpose between the two. Video conferencing is a two-way conversation best for small group meetings while Livestreaming is a one-way out to the audience system best for large groups. The next four slides are a comparison of each systems advantages and disadvantages.
There are many examples of products in both Livestreaming and Video-Conferencing. District 5550 has used both Go-to-Meeting and Zoom platforms. Both are software driven systems. The Livestreaming systems listed here are both hardware and software solutions. The system I recommend is a hardware system called BoxCast.
First, it is important to note that live video is ten times more engaging than a pre-recorded video presentation. The key advantage of Video-conferencing is its ability to be a two-way conversation. It is interactive. The key advantage of Livestreaming is its high-quality picture and sound. The potentially unlimited size of the audience, and the simple way to connect.
Take a moment to read down through these two lists of advantages. You can see that the purpose and advantages are quite different. Research is going on to merge the two systems, something that will likely happen in the coming decade.
It is when you take the advantages and compare the disadvantages of video-conferencing that the advantages of Livestreaming appear most clearly. Video-conferencing uses low-quality cameras at 480 p vs the 1080 p of Livestreaming. In video-conferencing as the size of the audience increases the quality decreases. This doesn’t happen in Livestreaming. Also it is fairly complicated to set up a video conference. Each participant has to download the software; be sent a number to login under and login at a particulr time. Someone has to set up the conference and so it is more labour intensive. As you can see, there are a couple of disadvantages to the Livestreaming system, start up costs and the amount of hardware.
Livestreaming has a higher start-up cost because you need equipment to make it work well. You need at least one camera,
A tripod to place it on, and if you have more than one camera a switcher to switch from one camera to another.
And most importantly an Encoder what here is called a BoxCast. An encoder is where the video and audio coming from the camera and microphone are gathered and compressed so it can proceed as HD and good quality sound. The result is a slightly longer delay than in Video-conferencing. It also has to be connected to the Internet to send the data out and to a power source.
Along with the encoder and service plan, you get software which runs a dashboard. This is where the web-editor puts the program onto your website or other Livestreaming portals, such as Youtube Live or Facebook Live. As mentioned, the BoxCast Dashboard or Platform software comes with the BoxCast and Service plan. And as the picture shows it works on a smartphone, tablet or laptop.
As with most technology there is always extra pieces of equipment necessary to tie everything together such as cables, splitters, converters, gaff tape, a carrying container and recorder. Most are low cost items.
Slide Seventeen
Boxcast has two service plans. They are a recurring annual cost just like ClubRunner. Before deciding on which plan to buy one has to consider the many questions listed in this slide.
Although all nine questions are important, three of the most important in my analysis are storage, support and analytics. For Dryden’s pilot to be successful, analytics is the most important aspect of all. Dryden needs to know exactly from which community each viewer originates. The Standard Plan only gives you the total number of viewers; it does not supply the geographic location. The Advanced Plan does supply the data and much more.
Here is a comparison of the Standard and Advanced Plans. As mentioned, the Advanced Plan is needed for the breakout of viewers by the community. It also provides for storage of the presentations beyond one month. Plus, you have live, real-time support if you run into a problem. Also, the fact that payment can be made to see a program may present opportunities to use the system as a fun-raising platform. The difference in cost is $33.00 per month paid annually.
The next three slides show three cost configurations. This one shows the barest possible minimum using a members cameras and tripod without the analytics.
This Level-One configuration has the Advanced Plan, a mid-range camera, and a tripod. The Switcher is optional. So, the cost could be lowered to $3,700.00, however, I am suggesting the Switcher because the PowerPoint slides can be shown separate from the speaker or additional cameras could be added to enhance the production.
Depending on which of the financial proposals are successful and approved it may be possible to finance a really good quality camera with a good quality audio system. It is the enhanced audio which makes this option most attractive. Good video with poor audio is one of the major mistakes in both Livestreaming and Pre-recorded videos.
Of the four financing options presented here, options one and two are likely to be least successful. Although option four is attractive and maybe Dryden Rotary’s final choice, I am with this presentation putting my focus on the creation of a consortium or partnership. As you can see District 5550 can be one of the partners.
There are some reasons why this could be of advantage to the District. If it works in the Dryden orbit, the District has other geographic areas with similar characteristics. The District also has twelve clubs well under the 20 charter threshold, including some even in the single-digit range. Livestreaming may present an opportunity to consolidate clubs while maintaining the unique identities which have formed over the years. Finally, it would provide an opportunity to Livestream the keynote addresses and awards ceremony of the District conference.
Dryden Rotary is going to have to develop a promotion program to get the word out that Livestreaming is occurring. Community newspapers and radio stations are some of the vehicles we could consider.
Most importantly, there is a high degree of congruity between the weekly CKDR broadcast of Dryden Rotary Radio Bingo and the Communities we would target for membership.
In summary, I believe Livestreaming provides three distinct potential audiences; those who may not join but are interested in our speakers and learning more about their community and the region. The spin-off for Rotary could be substantial in the long term. Another, benefit, suggested by DG Elaine is growth in Friends of Rotary something Dryden has not to date promoted. Finally, and most importantly is the ability to grow and attract new members to the Club.