SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
FactCheck 2.0 Making health and medical news accurate (kinda) in a 24/7 news cycle Nancy Shute DCHealth2.0 May 20, 2010
Long ago, the news  was fact-checked.
Now, the news  is Oprah-checked.
Most people get  their news  from TV and the Internet.
 
 
 
Which is more trustworthy?
Health news outlets  can build trust by: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
 
We need to tell people  what we do to get it right. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Questions? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)
So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)
So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)Thomas Ho
 
Social Media: Patients And Providers
Social Media: Patients And ProvidersSocial Media: Patients And Providers
Social Media: Patients And Providersjmbhan
 
Social Media Final
Social Media FinalSocial Media Final
Social Media FinalEric Newman
 
The Evolution of the Online Physician Profile
The Evolution of the Online Physician ProfileThe Evolution of the Online Physician Profile
The Evolution of the Online Physician Profile@chrisboyer LLC
 
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach YouMarie Ennis-O'Connor
 
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient RelationshipsNicole Stagg
 
How Clinicians Use Social Media in Healthcare
How Clinicians Use Social Media in HealthcareHow Clinicians Use Social Media in Healthcare
How Clinicians Use Social Media in HealthcareRemo-tito Aguilar
 
Hospital Social Media
Hospital Social MediaHospital Social Media
Hospital Social MediaEd Bennett
 
Virginia Telehealth Network Summit
Virginia Telehealth Network SummitVirginia Telehealth Network Summit
Virginia Telehealth Network SummitMark Ryan
 
Social Media and the Patient's Role
Social Media and the Patient's RoleSocial Media and the Patient's Role
Social Media and the Patient's RoleAndrew Guvetis
 
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and Opportunities
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and OpportunitiesSocial Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and Opportunities
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and OpportunitiesLee Aase
 
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012laucyn
 
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care Environment
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care EnvironmentSocial Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care Environment
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care EnvironmentLee Aase
 
Hospitals & Social Media
Hospitals & Social MediaHospitals & Social Media
Hospitals & Social MediaEd Bennett
 
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionals
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare ProfessionalsSocial Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionals
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionalsdata brackets
 
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care Practitioners
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care PractitionersSocial Media Guidelines For Health Care Practitioners
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care PractitionersMarie Ennis-O'Connor
 
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCare
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCareWhich platform? Decision tree - MultiCare
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCareJenRittenhouse
 
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practices
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practicesEmory Healthcare and Twitter best practices
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practiceslesliebrea
 
Social Media & Free Clinics
Social Media & Free ClinicsSocial Media & Free Clinics
Social Media & Free ClinicsMike Sevilla
 

What's hot (20)

So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)
So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)
So much Web 2.0...it's about time! (healthcare edition)
 
Social Media: Patients And Providers
Social Media: Patients And ProvidersSocial Media: Patients And Providers
Social Media: Patients And Providers
 
Social Media Final
Social Media FinalSocial Media Final
Social Media Final
 
The Evolution of the Online Physician Profile
The Evolution of the Online Physician ProfileThe Evolution of the Online Physician Profile
The Evolution of the Online Physician Profile
 
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You
3 Healthcare Users Who Get Pinterest Right...And What They Can Teach You
 
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships
22 Reasons Why Social Media is the Future of Patient Relationships
 
How Clinicians Use Social Media in Healthcare
How Clinicians Use Social Media in HealthcareHow Clinicians Use Social Media in Healthcare
How Clinicians Use Social Media in Healthcare
 
Hospital Social Media
Hospital Social MediaHospital Social Media
Hospital Social Media
 
Virginia Telehealth Network Summit
Virginia Telehealth Network SummitVirginia Telehealth Network Summit
Virginia Telehealth Network Summit
 
Social Media and the Patient's Role
Social Media and the Patient's RoleSocial Media and the Patient's Role
Social Media and the Patient's Role
 
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and Opportunities
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and OpportunitiesSocial Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and Opportunities
Social Media and Your Hospital: Impacts and Opportunities
 
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012
Dr matthew katz_médias_sociaux_19_avril_2012
 
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care Environment
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care EnvironmentSocial Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care Environment
Social Media: Its Impact in a Changing Health Care Environment
 
Hospitals & Social Media
Hospitals & Social MediaHospitals & Social Media
Hospitals & Social Media
 
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionals
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare ProfessionalsSocial Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionals
Social Media Compliance for Healthcare Professionals
 
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care Practitioners
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care PractitionersSocial Media Guidelines For Health Care Practitioners
Social Media Guidelines For Health Care Practitioners
 
Telehealth & Social Media
Telehealth & Social MediaTelehealth & Social Media
Telehealth & Social Media
 
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCare
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCareWhich platform? Decision tree - MultiCare
Which platform? Decision tree - MultiCare
 
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practices
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practicesEmory Healthcare and Twitter best practices
Emory Healthcare and Twitter best practices
 
Social Media & Free Clinics
Social Media & Free ClinicsSocial Media & Free Clinics
Social Media & Free Clinics
 

Viewers also liked

US Science Journalists Embrace Social Media
US Science Journalists Embrace Social MediaUS Science Journalists Embrace Social Media
US Science Journalists Embrace Social Medianancyshute
 
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good Practice
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good PracticeNYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good Practice
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good PracticeAlexandra Holt
 
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...UNESCO Venice Office
 
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...nancyshute
 
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...Regina Nuzzo
 
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - Newsgames
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - NewsgamesInteractive Journalism - StoryDesign - Newsgames
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - NewsgamesGerald Holubowicz
 
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiences
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiencesSTEM News among underserved and under-represented audiences
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiencesDanielle N. Lee, PhD
 
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Kroll
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David KrollScience Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Kroll
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Krollkroll001
 
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 Workshop
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 WorkshopNABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 Workshop
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 WorkshopDanielle N. Lee, PhD
 
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014Holly Bik
 
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being Online
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being OnlineScience and Social Media: The Importance of Being Online
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being OnlineChristie Wilcox
 
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science Po
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science PoInteractive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science Po
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science PoGerald Holubowicz
 
Social media for science communication campus communicators
Social media for science communication   campus communicatorsSocial media for science communication   campus communicators
Social media for science communication campus communicatorsPaige Jarreau
 
Science Journalism Training
Science Journalism TrainingScience Journalism Training
Science Journalism Trainingwellcome.trust
 
Social media for science communication - URMA Presentation
Social media for science communication - URMA PresentationSocial media for science communication - URMA Presentation
Social media for science communication - URMA PresentationPaige Jarreau
 

Viewers also liked (20)

US Science Journalists Embrace Social Media
US Science Journalists Embrace Social MediaUS Science Journalists Embrace Social Media
US Science Journalists Embrace Social Media
 
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good Practice
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good PracticeNYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good Practice
NYU Journalism Handbook for Students Ethics, Law and Good Practice
 
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...
Mr Fabio Turone - Agency Zoe of scientific and medical information - Science ...
 
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...
How Science Writers Use Social Media, for the UNC Medical & Science Writing B...
 
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...
Writing about P-values in science journalism, for National Association of Sci...
 
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - Newsgames
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - NewsgamesInteractive Journalism - StoryDesign - Newsgames
Interactive Journalism - StoryDesign - Newsgames
 
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiences
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiencesSTEM News among underserved and under-represented audiences
STEM News among underserved and under-represented audiences
 
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Kroll
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David KrollScience Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Kroll
Science Journalism - Henrietta Lacks reporting - NABJ 2013 - David Kroll
 
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 Workshop
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 WorkshopNABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 Workshop
NABJ 2013 Science Journalism 101 Workshop
 
Science Writing: Styles, Audiences, and Tools
Science Writing: Styles, Audiences, and ToolsScience Writing: Styles, Audiences, and Tools
Science Writing: Styles, Audiences, and Tools
 
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014
Social Media for Researchers Workshop at UC Davis - Feb 7, 2014
 
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being Online
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being OnlineScience and Social Media: The Importance of Being Online
Science and Social Media: The Importance of Being Online
 
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science Po
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science PoInteractive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science Po
Interactive Journalism - What is a Story? - Science Po
 
Clinical science 2011
Clinical science 2011Clinical science 2011
Clinical science 2011
 
Social media for science communication campus communicators
Social media for science communication   campus communicatorsSocial media for science communication   campus communicators
Social media for science communication campus communicators
 
Science Journalism Training
Science Journalism TrainingScience Journalism Training
Science Journalism Training
 
Journalism07
Journalism07Journalism07
Journalism07
 
Social media for science communication - URMA Presentation
Social media for science communication - URMA PresentationSocial media for science communication - URMA Presentation
Social media for science communication - URMA Presentation
 
Scientific Writing 101
Scientific Writing 101Scientific Writing 101
Scientific Writing 101
 
Science journalism workshop
Science journalism workshopScience journalism workshop
Science journalism workshop
 

Similar to FactCheck 2.0: Making Health News (Kinda) Accurate in a 24/7 News Cycle

Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare Providers
Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare ProvidersLeveraging Social Media for Healthcare Providers
Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare ProvidersGreenway Health
 
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in Healthcare
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in HealthcarePerficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in Healthcare
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in HealthcarePerficient, Inc.
 
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 Final
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 FinalCadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 Final
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 FinalJim Walker
 
Social Media in Healthcare
Social Media in HealthcareSocial Media in Healthcare
Social Media in HealthcareWebbed Marketing
 
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11roeyer
 
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11roeyer
 
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumers
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health ConsumersPatients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumers
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumerse-Patient Connections
 
The Power of Social in health and healthcare
The Power of Social in health and healthcareThe Power of Social in health and healthcare
The Power of Social in health and healthcareD3 Consutling
 
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection Final
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection FinalSocial Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection Final
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection FinalStephanie Cannon
 
Social Media and MCR Readmissions
Social Media and MCR ReadmissionsSocial Media and MCR Readmissions
Social Media and MCR ReadmissionsMark Ryan
 
Health 20 And Participatory Health
Health 20 And Participatory HealthHealth 20 And Participatory Health
Health 20 And Participatory HealthMatthew Holt
 
VAFP Social Media Presentation
VAFP Social Media PresentationVAFP Social Media Presentation
VAFP Social Media PresentationMark Ryan
 
Health 2.0 and the UK
Health 2.0 and the UKHealth 2.0 and the UK
Health 2.0 and the UKTim Lloyd
 
NCRP Communicaton 2.0
NCRP Communicaton 2.0NCRP Communicaton 2.0
NCRP Communicaton 2.0Jay Bernhardt
 
Stfm pci 2011
Stfm pci 2011Stfm pci 2011
Stfm pci 2011Mark Ryan
 
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?Gregg Masters
 

Similar to FactCheck 2.0: Making Health News (Kinda) Accurate in a 24/7 News Cycle (20)

Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare Providers
Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare ProvidersLeveraging Social Media for Healthcare Providers
Leveraging Social Media for Healthcare Providers
 
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in Healthcare
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in HealthcarePerficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in Healthcare
Perficient Perspectives: The Evolution of Social Media in Healthcare
 
Public Health 2.0
Public Health 2.0Public Health 2.0
Public Health 2.0
 
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 Final
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 FinalCadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 Final
Cadient Fda Social Media Nov 13 09 Final
 
Social Media in Healthcare
Social Media in HealthcareSocial Media in Healthcare
Social Media in Healthcare
 
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
 
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
Mhc new yearcampaign2011gm 1-11-11
 
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumers
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health ConsumersPatients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumers
Patients Rising: How to Reach Empowered, Digital Health Consumers
 
The Power of Social in health and healthcare
The Power of Social in health and healthcareThe Power of Social in health and healthcare
The Power of Social in health and healthcare
 
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection Final
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection FinalSocial Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection Final
Social Media The Evolving Patient Physician Connection Final
 
Social Media and MCR Readmissions
Social Media and MCR ReadmissionsSocial Media and MCR Readmissions
Social Media and MCR Readmissions
 
091409 U Of Florida
091409 U Of Florida091409 U Of Florida
091409 U Of Florida
 
Health 20 And Participatory Health
Health 20 And Participatory HealthHealth 20 And Participatory Health
Health 20 And Participatory Health
 
VAFP Social Media Presentation
VAFP Social Media PresentationVAFP Social Media Presentation
VAFP Social Media Presentation
 
Dr. Jay Bernhardt
Dr. Jay BernhardtDr. Jay Bernhardt
Dr. Jay Bernhardt
 
Health 2.0 and the UK
Health 2.0 and the UKHealth 2.0 and the UK
Health 2.0 and the UK
 
NCRP Communicaton 2.0
NCRP Communicaton 2.0NCRP Communicaton 2.0
NCRP Communicaton 2.0
 
Phil Baumann
Phil BaumannPhil Baumann
Phil Baumann
 
Stfm pci 2011
Stfm pci 2011Stfm pci 2011
Stfm pci 2011
 
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?
Social Media and Medicine: Fad or Shift?
 

FactCheck 2.0: Making Health News (Kinda) Accurate in a 24/7 News Cycle

Editor's Notes

  1. T
  2. When I was science editor of US News in the 1990s, we had copyeditors and a fact-checking department. All gone now; nobody wants to pay for accuracy. Copyeditors in a city newsroom, 1952, courtesy National Archives.
  3. This is true for health, medicine, and science as well as general news. This means most people are getting health news this way:
  4. Oprah has 8.5 million viewers daily. Monthly uniques to the CDC website in April 2009, during the beginning of the swine flu pandemic:
  5. This story was not reported by US News. It is a press release from the Carnegie Institution that was distributed by the National Science Foundation.
  6. Applied Content was bought on May 18. 2010 by Yahoo for about $100 million. It publishes 2,000 stories a day. The 15 editors can spend about 2 minutes on each story. Contributors make about $5 per story.
  7. Although studies indicate people are skeptical of Internet news sources, self-reinforcing communities make it easy for bad science to flourish online. Calling people stupid for believing junk science isn’t going to help, particularly when the quality of medical reporting in the mainstream media is so bad.
  8. Accurate reporting takes time and money. The public and scientists often disagree on trusted names, like Oprah. Few news organizations have internal standards for quality reporting. Almost none explain how they report and fact check.
  9. The Knight-funded Tracker has been critiquing science journalism since May 2006, and recently added health and medical coverage. It’s mostly inside baseball, but it’s a start.
  10. Former CNN reporter Gary Schwitzer launched Health News Review in 2006, patterning it on Media Doctor Australia. He concluded that TV coverage of health and medicine is so terrible, he no longer rates it. Similar to Annenberg-funded FactCheck.Org, but focused on medical news.
  11. Is it OK to rewrite a press release? Or to run a press release as news? How many sources you do need for a news report on a journal article? Does your news organization have any guidelines for reporters and editors on quality?