Patricia Brassil Poole, Head of Partner Management, MBNA, will discuss how the MBNA Etihad Guest Credit Card Program is optimizing email as part of its fully integrated marketing campaign in order to get results.
Five Essential Tools for International SEO - Natalia Witczyk - SearchNorwich 15
The Secret to Email Optimization in MBNA's Etihad Guest Credit Card Program
1. MBNA Etihad Guest
Credit Card Programme
How optimisation of email as part of a fully
integrated marketing campaign gets results.
2.
3. Etihad Guest Credit card brings
together 2 powerful global brands
MBNA Limited and Etihad Guest
4. • One of the UK’s leading credit card providers.
• Voted Credit Card Provider of the Year for the third year
running in the Consumer Moneyfacts Awards 2016.
• Partners with some of the world’s most recognised
Brands in the Airline, Football and Charity Sectors.
• Sponsor of Thames Clippers and TFL.
Who are mbna?
5.
6. • Etihad Airways is one of the fast growing airlines in the history of commercial aviation
• National Airline of the United Arab Emirates (UAE)
• 120 aircraft, 116 destinations , 49 partnerships with other international airlines
• Etihad Guest is the one of the world’s most rewarding Loyalty Programmes
• Brand associated with Prestige, Comfort, Convenience
Who are Etihad?
12. The Etihad Guest Credit Card
• Earns Etihad Guest miles every time customer
spends with their card.
• Two cards on one account, working seamlessly to
help customers earn Etihad Guest Miles faster.
Etihad Guest American
Express® Credit Card 1.5
miles for every £1 you spend on
card purchases using this card.
Etihad Guest Visa Credit
Card 1.5 miles for every £2
you spend on card
purchases using this card.
13. Enjoy flights and upgrades to
thousands of destinations on
Etihad Airways and more than
25 airline partners.
Spend your miles on over
3,500 products at the Etihad
Guest Reward Shop.
Convert miles to cash to
spend at 30 million outlets
worldwide with PointsPay.
Rewarding Customers
14. • 5,000 Welcome Miles
• Competitive interest rates
• Double Etihad Guest Miles when booking Etihad Business flights
• Triple Etihad Guest when booking Etihad First Class Flights
• Fast track to Silver Tier upon completion of a return flight within 12
months of account opening
• No annual fee
Account Benefits
17. Optimise email performance in our integrated campaigns
Objectives
• Better understand the Etihad membership base’s view on the email channel
• Maximise total volume of new accounts from the tactical offer marketing
• Reduce reliance on the more expensive and slower to execute direct mail channel
Challenge
19. Analysed full Etihad Guest marketable database to understand
• Database quality
• Credit worthiness
• Affluence levels
• Channel Propensity
• Frequency of flights with Etihad per annum/Membership tier
Etihad
Client File Duplicates
Removed
(258k)
Data
Warehouse
Suppressions
(186k)
Fail
Credit
Policy Rules
(7k)
Duplicates
Removed
Pass
Suppressions
Match
To Prospect
Database
No Match to
Prospect Database
Pass
Credit Rules
Best Population
Fail Credit
Rules
Fail
Suppressions
Duplicate Files
Good
Population
1. Database analysis
20. 20
Data insight was used to provide accurate credit worthiness
checks and enhance product and channel strategy.
1. Data Usage
23. Demographical Profile
• Age, employment status, affluence levels, family stage etc.
Preferred Channel
• Online is the preferred communication channel.
• A % of members are also heavily inclined toward
traditional media as a supporting channel.
Data cleanse
• Analysis identified a population of customers whose
addresses were out of date.
Frequency of flight /Tier
• A population of the Etihad base did not hold any Etihad
Guest loyalty tier.
1. What we learnt
24. • A refresh was undertaken to create consistency with the Etihad
re-designed website and brand advertising
• There had been a change in brand look and feel and
colour palette
• We wanted to convey that aspirational, sophisticated
cosmopolitan feel of international travel to the marketing
2. Creative Refresh
25. • “See the World” = Creative Theme
• To reflect: the range of destinations, thinking differently, looking at
things from a different perspective
• The headline translated well across all online and offline channels
2. The result
28. Analysis helped us identify an existing product
feature not being heavily promoted which was
likely to appeal to a large % of the target
audience:
Fast track to Silver Tier upon completion of
one return flight with Etihad Airways within 12
months of account opening.
3. Email Messaging
29. • 25% extra miles on every flight
• Lounge access
• Guaranteed Economy seat if booked 48 hours in
advance
• Extra luggage allowance
• Chauffeur Service
3. Silver Tier benefits
30. Split data into those who held a loyalty tier and those who didn’t.
Tested 2 different creatives & Tested different
subject headers:
a) Test -Leading on Etihad Guest Silver tier benefit with 25,000
miles as secondary message.
b) Control –Leading on BAU 25,000 tactical miles.
30
3. Approach
31. • Silver Tier Offer drove 20% more clickthroughs.
• Tracking established there were a lot of clicks
on the Silver Tier and Flight upgrade .
3. What we learnt
32. • Moved the campaign duration from 2 month duration to 3 months
• Changed channel sequencing to start with an email early in the campaign to a
large volume, send a highly target DM campaign after 4 week and then have a final
follow up email, which was the last reminder.
4. Integrated Campaign Structure
33. 33
Direct Mail
16th Oct
OCTOBER
SEPTEMBER
Group site, MBNA.co.uk, IBTM, Aggregator & PPC
10th Sept
Display
20th Oct
Email #1
3rd Oct
Follow up
Email #
12th Nov
NOVEMBER
We changed channel sequencing:
1. start with an email early in the campaign
2. send a highly targeted DM campaign after 4 weeks to those most receptive to DM (New
Tech Novices/Traditionalists)
3. issue a final follow up email, which was the last reminder of the special offer
Previously DM was the main focus of the campaign with email the secondary support channel.
4. Channels and timings
34. • We were able to keep response momentum going throughout the 3 month period
• It allowed us to fine tune campaign content as it progressed and add additional promotional opportunities
4. What we learnt
e
d
ee
f
Q3-4 Enhanced Campaign – 9th September until 30th November
10-Sep 17-Sep 24-Sep 01-Oct 08-Oct 15-Oct 22-Oct 29-Oct 05-Nov 12-Nov 19-Nov 26-Nov
e eMail d Direct Mail f Facebook
e
d
Q2-3 Enhanced Campaign – 5th May until 10th July
07-Apr 14-Apr 21-Apr 28-Apr 05-May 12-May 19-May 26-May 02-Jun 09-Jun 16-Jun 23-Jun 30-Jun 07-Jul
e eMail d Direct Mail
35. To help optimise email as part of a fully integrated marketing campaign.
we focussed on 4 key areas:
1. Database analysis
2. Creative refresh
3. Tailored Messaging
4. Modify campaign construct
Recap
MBNA – just voted Consumer Moneyfacts Awards 2016 for the 3rd year running. All awards are fantastic but we are particularly proud of this as it is voted for by our customers!
Partnerships across a wide variety of sectors with some very well known brands e.g. WWF, British Heart Foundation, Manchester United, Liverpool, VAA, Emirates, Etihad
Other sponsorships – at a UK level and locally e.g. Chester Racecourse
Quote from Etihad, which nicely sums up their brand focus
Etihad support the promotion of local culture in the UAE and worldwide, and sponsor cultural and sporting events that are consistent with their values of hospitality, team spirit and helping to bring the world together.
Examples:
The Title Sponsor of the Formula 1 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix
official airline partner of the England Cricket Teams.
Mumbai Indians Cricket Club
New York City Football Club
Not forgetting, Manchester City Football Club
Etihad launched a global advertising campaign in 2015 featuring Nicole Kidman
It was shot on board the new flagship Airbus A380 and in three locations around the world: Abu Dhabi, Marseilles and Prague.
The MBNA and Etihad Guest Credit card partnership commenced in May 2013
Etihad companion card – 2 plastics – American Express
Customer earns Etihad Guest air miles every time they spend with their card.
The Etihad Guest Credit card offers customers access to
Flights and upgrades to thousands of Etihad destinations worldwide
Spending their miles on over 3,500 products at the Etihad Guest Reward Shop
Convert their miles to cash
List of other card benefits
Slides 15-16
Our joint marketing of the Etihad Guest credit card cuts across a wide spectrum of online and offline channels:
Etihad Guest and Airways websites, MBNA website, Email to Etihad Guest members, Moneysupermarket, Display advertising, Search, Direct mail, Social Media, Inserts
We conduct 2 tactical integrated marketing campaigns p.a.
I’m here today to discuss how MBNA with its partner Etihad optimised its email activity as part of these fully integrated marketing campaign to get results.
3 main objectives:
Better understand the Etihad Guest membership base through analysis and insight
Maximise new account volumes
Reduce releance on more expensive and unwieldy Direct Mail channel
Used a 4 pronged approach:
Database analysis
Creative refresh
Tailored Messaging
Modify campaign construct
We analysed the Etihad Guest marketable database to understand:
Database quality
Credit worthiness
Affluence levels
Preferred Marketing Channel
How Frequency of flights with Etihad/Membership tier affects behaviour
We took the full marketable database and:
removed duplicates
Matched to our prospect database
Applied suppressions
Overlaid segmentation models
We matched the Etihad Guest membership file to the Bureau and then used this to assess customer credit worthiness and demographic information.
Matching the population to the Bureau provides the confidence that checks on credit worthiness are accurate. This information can then be used to assess where Prospects fall within current product, line and risk strategies.
Conducting demographic analysis allows for a clear assessment of the prospect pool, which can be used to develop targeted channel strategies and offer what’s best for the customer.
We matched the Etihad Guest membership file to the Bureau and then used this to assess customer credit worthiness and demographic information.
Matching the population to the Bureau provides the confidence that checks on credit worthiness are accurate. This information can then be used to assess where Prospects fall within current product, line and risk strategies.
Conducting demographic analysis allows for a clear assessment of the prospect pool, which can be used to develop targeted channel strategies and offer what’s best for the customer.
True Touch = an external model used to understand prospect preferences for Channel Marketing; this insight can be used to create bespoke marketing strategies for increased response rates amongst potential customers.
Etihad data shows a highly favourable approach to the Internet compared to the general UK population,
While a large proportion of Etihad members use the Internet as a primary source of information, a smaller % of the population are still influenced by traditional media channels and can benefit from DM campaigns.
2 Key Populations: ‘Experienced Netizens’, who are highly comfortable with online channel and ‘New Tech Novices’ segment, which is reflective of an older demographic and suggests a combination of online and direct mail channels would be more successful
True Touch = an external model used to understand prospect preferences for Channel Marketing; this insight can be used to create bespoke marketing strategies for increased response rates amongst potential customers.
Etihad data shows a highly favourable approach to the Internet compared to the general UK population,
While a large proportion of Etihad members use the Internet as a primary source of information, a smaller % of the population are still influenced by traditional media channels and can benefit from DM campaigns.
2 Key Populations: ‘Experienced Netizens’, who are highly comfortable with online channel and ‘New Tech Novices’ segment, which is reflective of an older demographic and suggests a combination of online and direct mail channels would be more successful.
Demographical Profile
financially sound males in full-time employment.
in the older family life stage of their lives
living in sizeable homes in suburban areas.
Preferred Channel
Online is the preferred communication channel.
A combination of online and direct mail channels would be successful for one segment of the population as these customers are also heavily inclined toward more traditional media channels.
Data cleanse
Analysis identified a population of customers whose addresses were out of date. We added an additional 20k records to the DM population by emailing these customers for an update.
Frequency of flight /Tier
We established that a population of the Etihad base did not hold any Etihad Guest loyalty tier , which presented an opportunity to promote an existing feature more heavily
2nd area we looked at – Creative
A refresh was undertaken to create consistency with the Etihad re-designed website and brand advertising
There had been a change in brand look and feel and colour palette
We wanted to convey that aspirational, sophisticated cosmopolitan feel of international travel to the marketing
Creative Theme chosen = See the World
New Email creative looks fresh, clean, uncluttered, less copy heavy
The creative theme also translated well across the other channels e.g. Direct Mail, Social media, Etihad website
Analysis helped us identify an existing product feature not being heavily promoted which was likely to appeal to distinct population of the target audience:
Silver tier feature = Fast track to Silver Tier upon completion of one return flight with Etihad Airways within 12 months of account opening.
Silver Tier membership has a wealth of benefits, which appeal to flyers:
25% extra miles on every flight, Lounge access, Guaranteed Economy seat if booked 48 hours in advance, Extra luggage allowance, Use of a Chauffeur Service
Split data into those who held an Etihad loyalty tier (Silver, Goldand those who didn’t
Tested 2 different creatives
Tested different subject headers:
a) Test -Leading on Etihad Guest Silver tier benefit with 25,000 miles as secondary message
v.
b) Control –Leading on BAU 25,000 tactical miles
Amongst the test population, the Silver Tier creative achieved 20% more clickthroughs.
This was great news, as it is an existing feature
4th changes we made we to the campaign structure.
Moved the intregrated campaign duration from 2 month duration to 3 months
Changed channel sequencing to start with an email early in the campaign to a large volume, send a highly targeted DM campaign after 4s week and then have a final follow up email, which was the last reminder of the offer.
2 changes allowed us to introduce tweaks to marketing and messaging as we went along. The charts show the levels of responsiveness to the 2 tactical camapigns.
While we in 2014 we saw a drop in interest/response across the 2nd half of the campaign, there is momentum throughout.
The spikes in the charts show where we introduced the Emails, the Direct Mail, Social Media
Slide 35:
Recap of 4 areas we worked on:
Database analysis
Creative refresh
Tailored Messaging
Modify campaign construct
Did our work pay off?
The Payment Ninjas say Yes!
For the 3 objectives there are tangible results.
Better understand Etihad Guest membership base
How?
Internet, including EM is preferred communication channel
Silver Tier is an under-promoted USP
Maximise new account volumes
How?
27% more responses and 40% more new accounts through Email channel in 2015 than in 2014
Created a Halo Effect of 70% more accounts in 2015 than in 2014;
Biggest channel improvement was Etihad website with a massive 125% increase followed by MBNA.co.uk
Reduce reliance on expensive slower to execute DM
How?
2014: DM generated 29% of accounts and the online channels 53%.
2015, this changed to 14% DM and the online channels a whopping 79%