SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
To what extent should magazines be held
responsible for the social ramifications of
     the representations they offer?
‘shout’ is a young teen magazine, aimed at stereotypical girls. There
        are elements of portraying a more rebellious teenager..
                                                                           The masthead ‘shout’ has
                                                                           connotations of making a
                                                                           stand and going against the
                                                                           rules; implying that’s what
                                                                           they think teen girls should
Cover line ‘8 steps to
                                                                           do
kissable lips!’ is an
article that shouldn’t
be on young teen’s
magazines




  Having Taylor Momsen as the
  main image who is known for
  becoming a rebellious teen,                                                   Representation of
  being part of a rock band. She                                                boys – article on
  is pictured wearing heavy                                                     them
  make up, and young girls
  reading this would see her as a
  role model, and it is possible
  they would copy this, making
  them grow up too fast
Cosmo girl is a teen version of Cosmopolitan, perhaps a watered down
 magazine of what the regular Cosmopolitan content would have, but          ‘girl’ looks like it has
 still there are elements which aren’t suitable for teens to be consuming   been written with a
                                                                            pencil connoting the
                                                                            target audience –
                                                                            younger girls
 This cover line
 concentrates on
 the appearance of                                                           Megan Fox is the main
 girls, and their                                                            image, globally seen as a
 perception on the                                                           beautiful actress and
 term ‘hot’ – how                                                            personality, which
 girls reading this                                                          young girls would aspire
 should look                                                                 to look like and see her
                                                                             as an influential role
                                                                             model. ‘Beauty’ is said to
                                                                             be what she talks about
                                                                             with the magazine,
                                                                             connoting the young
Cover line ‘I caught                                                         girls reading this would
him cheating’ isn’t                                                          follow what she says
suitable for the                                                             about the subject
target audience of
this magazine,
promoting the
wrong sort of
content for a teen
magazine
Seventeen is the
                              Kendall and Kylie
   name of the
                              Jenner are the main
   magazine, telling us
                              image, widely known
   the age of the target
                              as being part of the
   audience
                              good looking
                              Kardashian family,
                              girls a teenager
                              would idolize and feel
Cover line ‘Ways to Look      they have to look
Pretty’ feeding the wrong     good to be successful
ideas into a teens mind,
implying your looks is all
you need to focus on,
which is not what a teen
                                ‘Get everything you
should be
                                want this year; Great
                                Body’ this cover line
‘Mega Confidence’ also          states and decides for
implies if you have a great     the reader that
body, you will have             everything they want
confidence, suggesting          is a great body,
that the reader (teen)          displaying the wrong
should be getting a great       image for a teen and
body, if you don’t – you        implying its what
won’t have confidence           they should want, not
which is not a good             giving them the
message to send out to          option
young girls
Company is perhaps
aimed at the older end
of young teens,              Whitney Port the
including higher end         cover girl is a
fashion and celebrity        popular star of
gossip                       The Hills and The
                             City, so represents
                             fashion and
  Make-up and                beauty in herself –
  Style are also             connoting young
  used as cover              girls reading this
  lines, relating to         thinks that’s what
  beauty and                 they should look
  fashion and                like too, beauty
  stereotypically            makes you famous
  what girls should
  be interested in

  Ibiza is the main
  headline, connoting    ‘Fashion’ and ‘Beauty’ are
  again an older         words used here and
  young teen, as they    frequently all over
  would be more          magazines, constantly
  interested in the      injecting the idea that these
  idea of going to       are the most important
  Ibiza, known for       things to concentrate on and
  partying               without them you won’t
                         succeed
Tulisa is the cover girl in
Bliss is the name of        teen magazine Bliss,
this magazine, it has       who has recently been
connotations of this        named the sexiest girl in
magazine being              the world, and is
‘bliss’ and the             currently a judge of The
content inside is the       X Factor, meaning
definition of ‘bliss’. It   young girls would feel
is aimed at the             they need to look like
younger teens, with         her
the content of music
                            This cover line touches on the
and stories                 representation of boys, although
                            not intended for them to read, but
                            how they imply first of all that the
                            reader (a young teen, who this
                            magazine is aimed at) will have a
                            boyfriend and secondly that they
                            should resemble the appearance of
                            Justin Bieber. This makes the
                            reader feel that number one;
                            should they have a boyfriend/why
                            haven’t they already and number
‘Mad for Fash’              two; why doesn’t he look like
                            Justin Bieber. This magazine
stereotyping girls          implies their boyfriend should
to fashion, it’s            look like him which isn’t a good
                            representation for girls’
what they should            expectations of boys.
be ‘mad’ about

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Evaluation Q2
Evaluation Q2Evaluation Q2
Evaluation Q2
 
Kim
KimKim
Kim
 
Research
ResearchResearch
Research
 
Signs and signifers pp
Signs and signifers ppSigns and signifers pp
Signs and signifers pp
 
Music magazine research
Music magazine researchMusic magazine research
Music magazine research
 
Natashapres final
Natashapres finalNatashapres final
Natashapres final
 
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
 
Actors, costumes and props
Actors, costumes and propsActors, costumes and props
Actors, costumes and props
 
toe nail
toe nailtoe nail
toe nail
 
Location%2c costumes%2c props%2c actors
Location%2c costumes%2c props%2c actorsLocation%2c costumes%2c props%2c actors
Location%2c costumes%2c props%2c actors
 
Home learning stereotypes
Home learning stereotypesHome learning stereotypes
Home learning stereotypes
 
Signs and signifiers
Signs and signifiersSigns and signifiers
Signs and signifiers
 
Media evaluation
Media evaluationMedia evaluation
Media evaluation
 
How my magazine appeals to the target audience
How my magazine appeals to the target audienceHow my magazine appeals to the target audience
How my magazine appeals to the target audience
 
Question 5 pp
Question 5 ppQuestion 5 pp
Question 5 pp
 
dps analysis
dps analysisdps analysis
dps analysis
 
Q2:
Q2:Q2:
Q2:
 
The evaluation actually this one
The evaluation actually this oneThe evaluation actually this one
The evaluation actually this one
 
Representation
RepresentationRepresentation
Representation
 
2. how does your media product represent particular social groups
2. how does your media product represent particular social groups2. how does your media product represent particular social groups
2. how does your media product represent particular social groups
 

Similar to Task 3 Essay Presentation

Similar to Task 3 Essay Presentation (20)

Pages 11 to 15
Pages 11 to 15Pages 11 to 15
Pages 11 to 15
 
Media: how does your media product represent particular social groups?
Media: how does your media product represent particular social groups?Media: how does your media product represent particular social groups?
Media: how does your media product represent particular social groups?
 
A2 Media G325 Collective identity in youth Case Study Chart
A2 Media G325 Collective identity in youth Case Study ChartA2 Media G325 Collective identity in youth Case Study Chart
A2 Media G325 Collective identity in youth Case Study Chart
 
Question 2
Question 2Question 2
Question 2
 
Analysis of similar style magazine cover
Analysis of similar style magazine coverAnalysis of similar style magazine cover
Analysis of similar style magazine cover
 
Dps 1
Dps 1Dps 1
Dps 1
 
Front cover analysis
Front cover analysisFront cover analysis
Front cover analysis
 
Denotation
DenotationDenotation
Denotation
 
Research into media magazines
Research into media magazinesResearch into media magazines
Research into media magazines
 
Full representation presentation
Full representation presentationFull representation presentation
Full representation presentation
 
Contents page analysis 1
Contents page analysis 1Contents page analysis 1
Contents page analysis 1
 
Front cover analysis cher
Front cover analysis   cherFront cover analysis   cher
Front cover analysis cher
 
QUESTION 2
QUESTION 2QUESTION 2
QUESTION 2
 
Task 4 media
Task 4 mediaTask 4 media
Task 4 media
 
Cher 1
Cher 1Cher 1
Cher 1
 
Cher 1
Cher 1Cher 1
Cher 1
 
Representations ppt
Representations pptRepresentations ppt
Representations ppt
 
Magazine research
Magazine researchMagazine research
Magazine research
 
Magazine research
Magazine researchMagazine research
Magazine research
 
Question two
Question twoQuestion two
Question two
 

Task 3 Essay Presentation

  • 1. To what extent should magazines be held responsible for the social ramifications of the representations they offer?
  • 2. ‘shout’ is a young teen magazine, aimed at stereotypical girls. There are elements of portraying a more rebellious teenager.. The masthead ‘shout’ has connotations of making a stand and going against the rules; implying that’s what they think teen girls should Cover line ‘8 steps to do kissable lips!’ is an article that shouldn’t be on young teen’s magazines Having Taylor Momsen as the main image who is known for becoming a rebellious teen, Representation of being part of a rock band. She boys – article on is pictured wearing heavy them make up, and young girls reading this would see her as a role model, and it is possible they would copy this, making them grow up too fast
  • 3. Cosmo girl is a teen version of Cosmopolitan, perhaps a watered down magazine of what the regular Cosmopolitan content would have, but ‘girl’ looks like it has still there are elements which aren’t suitable for teens to be consuming been written with a pencil connoting the target audience – younger girls This cover line concentrates on the appearance of Megan Fox is the main girls, and their image, globally seen as a perception on the beautiful actress and term ‘hot’ – how personality, which girls reading this young girls would aspire should look to look like and see her as an influential role model. ‘Beauty’ is said to be what she talks about with the magazine, connoting the young Cover line ‘I caught girls reading this would him cheating’ isn’t follow what she says suitable for the about the subject target audience of this magazine, promoting the wrong sort of content for a teen magazine
  • 4. Seventeen is the Kendall and Kylie name of the Jenner are the main magazine, telling us image, widely known the age of the target as being part of the audience good looking Kardashian family, girls a teenager would idolize and feel Cover line ‘Ways to Look they have to look Pretty’ feeding the wrong good to be successful ideas into a teens mind, implying your looks is all you need to focus on, which is not what a teen ‘Get everything you should be want this year; Great Body’ this cover line ‘Mega Confidence’ also states and decides for implies if you have a great the reader that body, you will have everything they want confidence, suggesting is a great body, that the reader (teen) displaying the wrong should be getting a great image for a teen and body, if you don’t – you implying its what won’t have confidence they should want, not which is not a good giving them the message to send out to option young girls
  • 5. Company is perhaps aimed at the older end of young teens, Whitney Port the including higher end cover girl is a fashion and celebrity popular star of gossip The Hills and The City, so represents fashion and Make-up and beauty in herself – Style are also connoting young used as cover girls reading this lines, relating to thinks that’s what beauty and they should look fashion and like too, beauty stereotypically makes you famous what girls should be interested in Ibiza is the main headline, connoting ‘Fashion’ and ‘Beauty’ are again an older words used here and young teen, as they frequently all over would be more magazines, constantly interested in the injecting the idea that these idea of going to are the most important Ibiza, known for things to concentrate on and partying without them you won’t succeed
  • 6. Tulisa is the cover girl in Bliss is the name of teen magazine Bliss, this magazine, it has who has recently been connotations of this named the sexiest girl in magazine being the world, and is ‘bliss’ and the currently a judge of The content inside is the X Factor, meaning definition of ‘bliss’. It young girls would feel is aimed at the they need to look like younger teens, with her the content of music This cover line touches on the and stories representation of boys, although not intended for them to read, but how they imply first of all that the reader (a young teen, who this magazine is aimed at) will have a boyfriend and secondly that they should resemble the appearance of Justin Bieber. This makes the reader feel that number one; should they have a boyfriend/why haven’t they already and number ‘Mad for Fash’ two; why doesn’t he look like Justin Bieber. This magazine stereotyping girls implies their boyfriend should to fashion, it’s look like him which isn’t a good representation for girls’ what they should expectations of boys. be ‘mad’ about