The New Peer Review: Digital Scholarship in a World of Traditional Pubs
•Download as PPTX, PDF•
1 like•577 views
Presentation during NAEPSDP 2015 in San Diego, California
Recommended
Recommended
More Related Content
Viewers also liked
Viewers also liked (18)
Similar to The New Peer Review: Digital Scholarship in a World of Traditional Pubs
Similar to The New Peer Review: Digital Scholarship in a World of Traditional Pubs (20)
More from Jamie Seger
More from Jamie Seger (11)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
The New Peer Review: Digital Scholarship in a World of Traditional Pubs
- 1. THE NEW PEER REVIEW: Digital Scholarship in a World of Traditional Pubs Jamie Seger @JamieMSeger Eric Stafne @estafne Paul Hill @4Hpro Amanda Christensen @famfinpro Jerry Thomas @jeroldthomasosu NAEPSDP 2015
- 3. loosely defined as: Employing digital, networked, and open approaches to demonstrate specialism in a field.
- 4. Digital scholarship work is mostly centered on the curation and preservation of digital artifacts or the digitization of content.
- 5. “The PDF online is shoving paper down wire. You’re bringing paperthink to new media… and it’s not going to work.” - Alan November, Who Owns the Learning?
- 7. “The Wall”: Peer Review, Evaluation, & Reporting
- 9. “[The] disconnect between emerging practice and the evaluation of that practice discourages scholars at all levels from engaging with the new capacities.” - American Historical Association Guidelines for Digital Scholarship
- 10. Responsibilities of Depts. & Scholars 1. How are your department and your institution responding to the opportunities and challenges presented by the emerging digital environment?
- 11. Responsibilities of Depts. & Scholars 2. How is your department planning to evaluate work presented as part of hiring, promotion, tenure, or other review in a digital medium?
- 12. Responsibilities of Depts. & Scholars 3. Do your hiring plans include positions that involve research, teaching, and scholarly communication employing the use of digital media?
- 13. Traditional Pubs vs. Digital Content
- 14. How is your organization addressing digital scholarship?
- 15. Collaboration on Digital Scholarship Eric Stafne - Mississippi Tamara Meredith - Wyoming Jeff Piestrak - New York Alda Noris - Alaska Amanda Christensen - Utah Paul Hill - Utah Jamie Seger - Ohio
- 17. Next Tweetup TODAY @ 11:00am 2pm ET | 1pm CT | 12pm MT | 11am PT + December 17th (every 1st and 3rd of the month) twubs.com/edtechln #EdTechLN
- 18. Thanks Continue the digital scholarship conversation at: extedtechs.org search.twitter.com: #EdTechLN Jamie Seger @JamieMSeger Eric Stafne @estafne Paul Hill @4Hpro Amanda Christensen @famfinpro Jerry Thomas @jeroldthomasosu
Editor's Notes
- Introduction of digital versus traditional scholarship Provide Jamie’s handout
- Ask: who would like to provide an example of digitized content? What does that mean? Examples: blog posts or a post series, infographics, podcasts, interactive media, videos.
- · Many of the current attempts to gain recognition for digital scholarship focus on making it behave like traditional scholarship. · Promotion committees can play a significant role in exploring alternative methods by recognizing new forms of scholarship, as well as positively encouraging them either through guidelines or specific projects.
- Talk about the differences between how traditional pubs and digital are consumed (Eric?)
- [JAMIE COVER]
- share and describe osue peer review flowchart [JAMIE COVER] Ask: for other examples of peer review processes in other states / orgs? How is the process being adapted?
- Share AHA Guidelines for Digital Scholarship doc. [JAMIE INTRODUCE AND ERIC COVER]
- Responsibilities of Depts and Scholars questions from AHA guidelines
- Responsibilities of Depts and Scholars questions from AHA guidelines
- Responsibilities of Depts and Scholars questions from AHA guidelines
- [PAUL COVER] Ask: what is the value your org places on a traditional pub vs. digitally created content? What is the reality and what is the perception?
- [PAUL COVER] allow them to drive this conversation - have a discussion about how their org is or isn’t addressing digital scholarship.
- [PAUL COVER] Provide examples of who is working together in the EdTechLN to share resources (show list with contact info?) and move forward in a collaborative effort. Need to add a couple more examples here of how people are tackling digital scholarship issues
- Share Eric’s digital scholarship series on the EdTechLN blog [ERIC WILL COVER]
- [PAUL COVER]