SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Download to read offline
Water use throughout the
 livestock value chain

               FAO-IFAD
Karen Frenken, Marisha Shibuya,
Rudolph Cleveringa, Melvyn Kay
 IFAD, IADG Meeting, Livestock Week, May 3rd, 2010
Overview of WLVC
• Background: WWDR and awareness
  raising
• Rationale for WLVC: Coverage of
  livestock, Water scarcity and GHG (CO2,
  NOx, CH4)
• Model of Quadrants
• Open questions for research
Background
• WWDR: Risks and Uncertainties
• Drivers: population change, urban/rural
  distribution, lifestyle choices, climate
  change
• Awareness: when to do what, where and
  how for whom
Regional meat consumption
Where are the poor livestock raisers
            (Thornton et al, 2002)
Rationale
• WWDR III, Comprehensive Assessment
  and Long Shadow: open issues
• New FAO study: GHG from the Dairy
  Sector
• New US Dairy Study (forthcoming)

 Integral life cycle view emerging
 Water community still dispersed by sectors
(From: Ceres, 2009)
Water-related risk and uncertainty
                                                                           Water along the livestock value chain




                                                                                                                                      Risks & Uncertainties from Livestock Value Chain
Risks & Uncertainties to Livestock Value Chain




                                                 Drivers of Change
                                                 Climate, economics,
                                                 demographics, etc.


                                                                                  Recycling        Production
                                                                                                                       Impact
                                                   •Water Quantity                                                   Acidification,
                                                   (scarcity, floods)                                               eutrophication,
                                                   •Water Quality                                                   water-use, etc.
                                                                                Consumption        Transformation
                                                   •Allocation Conflicts




                                                                                     Water Use/Consumption
                                                                                               .
Water use in production
      Global net evapotranspiration for agriculture 7,137 km3



             Blue water 22%            Irrigated pasture/feed 17%


                                                                    Irrigated crops 83%


                              Rainfed crops 47%




Green water 78%                                      Rainfed pasture 53%
Water Consumption at the
                      Slaughterhouse
 Data from Danish & Norwegian slaughterhouses

                Water                                                 COD           Nitrogen      Phosphorus Suspended
Per tonne of consumption          Wastewater BOD emission           emission        emission       emission    solids
carcase           (l)                 (l)        (kg)                 (kg)             (g)            (g)     emission
                                                                                                                 (g)

Cattle           1623-9000        1623-9000           1.8-28           4-40        172-1840        24.8-260       11.2-15.9
Pig              1600-8300        1600-6000          2.14-10         3.22-10       180-2100         20-233        0.12-5.1
Sheep            5556-8333        5556-8333            8.89                           1556            500
Poultry         5070-67400       5070-67400          2.43-43           4-41        560-4652        26.2-700        48-700

 Source: European Commission (May 2005), Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control: Reference Document on Best Available
 Techniques in the Slaughterhouses and Animal By-products Industries, viewed 30 April 2010 at
 ftp://ftp.jrc.es/pub/eippcb/doc/sa_bref_0505.pdf
UK Food Waste at the
       Consumer Stage
8.3 million tonnes per year of food and drink waste in UK households
                     (2/3 avoidable, edible foods)




                              Source: WRAP (2009) Household Food and Drink Waste in the UK, p.6
Water for livestock
Water along the livestock value chain



           Recycling    Production



          Consumption   Transformation
Feedback required
• What are the main gaps in the “model”?
• Where are the data by context, timeline
  and quadrants?
• Where are the linkages in research with
  consumer organizations, environment and
  private sector?
• R.cleveringa@ifad.org
  karen.frenken@fao.org
Thank you




Karen Frenken, Marisha Shibuya, Rudolph Cleveringa, Melvyn Kay

More Related Content

What's hot

WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
Laura Kelm
 
Science Forum Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
Science Forum  Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...Science Forum  Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
Science Forum Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
WorldFish
 
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious ResourceRobb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
Contract Cities
 
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT NewsSt. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
Victoria Molina
 
Drought in California
Drought in CaliforniaDrought in California
Drought in California
todspedding
 
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles CountyWRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
Contract Cities
 
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
WaterWeUpTo
 
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_PosterJordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
Blaise Pezold
 
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of HaitiCryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
Pari Doll
 

What's hot (20)

How understanding field to stream sediment
How understanding field to stream sedimentHow understanding field to stream sediment
How understanding field to stream sediment
 
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
 
Science Forum Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
Science Forum  Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...Science Forum  Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
Science Forum Day 2 - Diaa Al Kenawy - Integrated agric-aquaculture, science...
 
The Role of Beaver in Southwest Montana
The Role of Beaver in Southwest MontanaThe Role of Beaver in Southwest Montana
The Role of Beaver in Southwest Montana
 
Plachy_poster
Plachy_posterPlachy_poster
Plachy_poster
 
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious ResourceRobb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
Robb Whitaker - Water Replenishment District, Water: Our Precious Resource
 
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT NewsSt. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
St. Johns River Water Management Distri...rom Environmental Agencies – WUFT News
 
Drought in California
Drought in CaliforniaDrought in California
Drought in California
 
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles CountyWRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
WRD - The Importance of Groundwater in Southern Los Angeles County
 
Cooperation for sustainability of water & culture_Sandeep Joshi_2013
Cooperation for sustainability of water & culture_Sandeep Joshi_2013Cooperation for sustainability of water & culture_Sandeep Joshi_2013
Cooperation for sustainability of water & culture_Sandeep Joshi_2013
 
NIRPC - Watershed Management
NIRPC - Watershed ManagementNIRPC - Watershed Management
NIRPC - Watershed Management
 
Letter to City of Toronto requesting sewage spill cleanup - August 2018
Letter to City of Toronto requesting sewage spill cleanup - August 2018Letter to City of Toronto requesting sewage spill cleanup - August 2018
Letter to City of Toronto requesting sewage spill cleanup - August 2018
 
1. Water quality and us - Andy Fanning, EPA
1. Water quality and us - Andy Fanning, EPA1. Water quality and us - Andy Fanning, EPA
1. Water quality and us - Andy Fanning, EPA
 
Dr. Eileen Kladivko - Transforming Drainage Project
Dr. Eileen Kladivko - Transforming Drainage ProjectDr. Eileen Kladivko - Transforming Drainage Project
Dr. Eileen Kladivko - Transforming Drainage Project
 
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
Harvesting Nitrogen, Phosphate, and Potassium from Game Day Wastewater for Us...
 
Impact of Agricultural Activities On Karstic Aquifer Integrity And Possible I...
Impact of Agricultural Activities On Karstic Aquifer Integrity And Possible I...Impact of Agricultural Activities On Karstic Aquifer Integrity And Possible I...
Impact of Agricultural Activities On Karstic Aquifer Integrity And Possible I...
 
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_PosterJordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
Jordan_Allen_Phase3_Poster
 
The Basin Focal Projects of the CPWF-an interesting journey
The Basin Focal Projects of the CPWF-an interesting journeyThe Basin Focal Projects of the CPWF-an interesting journey
The Basin Focal Projects of the CPWF-an interesting journey
 
Arthington iwc e flows principles handout
Arthington iwc e flows principles handoutArthington iwc e flows principles handout
Arthington iwc e flows principles handout
 
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of HaitiCryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
Cryptosporidium oocysts in the aquatic environment of Haiti
 

Similar to Water in the livestock value chain

Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATERGroundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
India Water Portal
 
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planningScience forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
WorldFish
 
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
NEXTDC
 
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-PollutionDetermination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
COLLINS KUFFOUR
 

Similar to Water in the livestock value chain (20)

Trade-offs or synergies? Assessment of Ecosystem Services in Multi-purpose Sm...
Trade-offs or synergies? Assessment of Ecosystem Services in Multi-purpose Sm...Trade-offs or synergies? Assessment of Ecosystem Services in Multi-purpose Sm...
Trade-offs or synergies? Assessment of Ecosystem Services in Multi-purpose Sm...
 
Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATERGroundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
Groundwater Quality And Human Health: Sunderrajan Krishnan, CAREWATER
 
Natural Capital Project Presentation
Natural Capital Project PresentationNatural Capital Project Presentation
Natural Capital Project Presentation
 
Land & Water Quality and Biodiversity Monitoring w/r to EIA
Land & Water Quality and Biodiversity Monitoring w/r to EIALand & Water Quality and Biodiversity Monitoring w/r to EIA
Land & Water Quality and Biodiversity Monitoring w/r to EIA
 
Slaughter waste effluents and river catchment watershed contamination in Caga...
Slaughter waste effluents and river catchment watershed contamination in Caga...Slaughter waste effluents and river catchment watershed contamination in Caga...
Slaughter waste effluents and river catchment watershed contamination in Caga...
 
Land Water Ecosystems
Land Water EcosystemsLand Water Ecosystems
Land Water Ecosystems
 
The water : its management and occurence
The water : its management and occurenceThe water : its management and occurence
The water : its management and occurence
 
Economic valuation of Little Rann of Kutch
Economic valuation of Little Rann of KutchEconomic valuation of Little Rann of Kutch
Economic valuation of Little Rann of Kutch
 
Predicting Microbial Pollution Concentrations in UK Rivers in Response to Lan...
Predicting Microbial Pollution Concentrations in UK Rivers in Response to Lan...Predicting Microbial Pollution Concentrations in UK Rivers in Response to Lan...
Predicting Microbial Pollution Concentrations in UK Rivers in Response to Lan...
 
WRI's Aqueduct Global Water Risk Mapping: Data & Methodology
WRI's Aqueduct Global Water Risk Mapping: Data & MethodologyWRI's Aqueduct Global Water Risk Mapping: Data & Methodology
WRI's Aqueduct Global Water Risk Mapping: Data & Methodology
 
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planningScience forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
Science forum Day 2 - Suan Pheng Kam - Integrated aquculture planning
 
To Study the Effect of Municipal Treated Effluent on Groundwater Quality Near...
To Study the Effect of Municipal Treated Effluent on Groundwater Quality Near...To Study the Effect of Municipal Treated Effluent on Groundwater Quality Near...
To Study the Effect of Municipal Treated Effluent on Groundwater Quality Near...
 
Allison - Mitigation aquaculture
Allison - Mitigation aquacultureAllison - Mitigation aquaculture
Allison - Mitigation aquaculture
 
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
Tony Kelly – Future Directions In The Water Industry
 
Suitability Assessment of Shallow Groundwater of a Typical Coastal Aquifers f...
Suitability Assessment of Shallow Groundwater of a Typical Coastal Aquifers f...Suitability Assessment of Shallow Groundwater of a Typical Coastal Aquifers f...
Suitability Assessment of Shallow Groundwater of a Typical Coastal Aquifers f...
 
H012615560
H012615560H012615560
H012615560
 
water pollution
water pollutionwater pollution
water pollution
 
Resource utilization and managing conflict in the pastoral community of Ethio...
Resource utilization and managing conflict in the pastoral community of Ethio...Resource utilization and managing conflict in the pastoral community of Ethio...
Resource utilization and managing conflict in the pastoral community of Ethio...
 
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-PollutionDetermination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
Determination-Of-Sources-Of-Water-Pollution
 
Sean McMahon - Farmer-led Efforts to Improve Water Quality
Sean McMahon - Farmer-led Efforts to Improve Water QualitySean McMahon - Farmer-led Efforts to Improve Water Quality
Sean McMahon - Farmer-led Efforts to Improve Water Quality
 

More from copppldsecretariat

More from copppldsecretariat (20)

Recognising local innovation in livestock-keeping – a path to empowering women
Recognising local innovation in livestock-keeping – a path to empowering womenRecognising local innovation in livestock-keeping – a path to empowering women
Recognising local innovation in livestock-keeping – a path to empowering women
 
Watershed Development and Livestock Rearing. Experiences and Learning from th...
Watershed Development and Livestock Rearing. Experiences and Learning from th...Watershed Development and Livestock Rearing. Experiences and Learning from th...
Watershed Development and Livestock Rearing. Experiences and Learning from th...
 
Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Europa
Vétérinaires Sans Frontières EuropaVétérinaires Sans Frontières Europa
Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Europa
 
Impact Assessment of the Community Animal Health System in Mandera West Distr...
Impact Assessment of the Community Animal Health System in Mandera West Distr...Impact Assessment of the Community Animal Health System in Mandera West Distr...
Impact Assessment of the Community Animal Health System in Mandera West Distr...
 
Value Chains, Linking Producers to the Markets
Value Chains, Linking Producers to the MarketsValue Chains, Linking Producers to the Markets
Value Chains, Linking Producers to the Markets
 
Water and Livestock for Rural Livelihoods
Water and Livestock for Rural LivelihoodsWater and Livestock for Rural Livelihoods
Water and Livestock for Rural Livelihoods
 
The Story of Rucibiraro Theresphore: a Farmer’s Inspiring Journey Out of Abso...
The Story of Rucibiraro Theresphore: a Farmer’s Inspiring Journey Out of Abso...The Story of Rucibiraro Theresphore: a Farmer’s Inspiring Journey Out of Abso...
The Story of Rucibiraro Theresphore: a Farmer’s Inspiring Journey Out of Abso...
 
The goat as a tool in poverty alleviation
The goat as a tool in poverty alleviationThe goat as a tool in poverty alleviation
The goat as a tool in poverty alleviation
 
Local Milk Sector in West Africa, Role of RPOs, Small and Medium Farmers in t...
Local Milk Sector in West Africa, Role of RPOs, Small and Medium Farmers in t...Local Milk Sector in West Africa, Role of RPOs, Small and Medium Farmers in t...
Local Milk Sector in West Africa, Role of RPOs, Small and Medium Farmers in t...
 
Strengthening the Backyard Poultry. Experiences of AP Drough Adaptation Initi...
Strengthening the Backyard Poultry. Experiences of AP Drough Adaptation Initi...Strengthening the Backyard Poultry. Experiences of AP Drough Adaptation Initi...
Strengthening the Backyard Poultry. Experiences of AP Drough Adaptation Initi...
 
Community of Practice for Pro-Poor Livestock Development (CoP-PPLD). Strategi...
Community of Practice for Pro-Poor Livestock Development (CoP-PPLD). Strategi...Community of Practice for Pro-Poor Livestock Development (CoP-PPLD). Strategi...
Community of Practice for Pro-Poor Livestock Development (CoP-PPLD). Strategi...
 
Livestock in the New CGIAR Consortium
Livestock in the New CGIAR ConsortiumLivestock in the New CGIAR Consortium
Livestock in the New CGIAR Consortium
 
The State of Food and Agriculture 2009
The State of Food and Agriculture 2009The State of Food and Agriculture 2009
The State of Food and Agriculture 2009
 
Small Ruminant Rearing – Product Markets, Opportunities and Constraints
Small Ruminant Rearing – Product Markets, Opportunities and ConstraintsSmall Ruminant Rearing – Product Markets, Opportunities and Constraints
Small Ruminant Rearing – Product Markets, Opportunities and Constraints
 
Mixed Service of Human and Animal Health in Pastoral Zones: An Innovative and...
Mixed Service of Human and Animal Health in Pastoral Zones: An Innovative and...Mixed Service of Human and Animal Health in Pastoral Zones: An Innovative and...
Mixed Service of Human and Animal Health in Pastoral Zones: An Innovative and...
 
Unpacking the 'Poor Productivity' Myth - Women Resurrecting Poultry Biodivers...
Unpacking the 'Poor Productivity' Myth - Women Resurrecting Poultry Biodivers...Unpacking the 'Poor Productivity' Myth - Women Resurrecting Poultry Biodivers...
Unpacking the 'Poor Productivity' Myth - Women Resurrecting Poultry Biodivers...
 
Development of Village Institutions for Equitable & Sustainable Access to Nat...
Development of Village Institutions for Equitable & Sustainable Access to Nat...Development of Village Institutions for Equitable & Sustainable Access to Nat...
Development of Village Institutions for Equitable & Sustainable Access to Nat...
 
Securing Community Tenure over Common Lands (SAGP13)
Securing Community Tenure over Common Lands (SAGP13) Securing Community Tenure over Common Lands (SAGP13)
Securing Community Tenure over Common Lands (SAGP13)
 
Backyard Poultry Farming Through Self-Help Groups in West Bengal - Towards Go...
Backyard Poultry Farming Through Self-Help Groups in West Bengal - Towards Go...Backyard Poultry Farming Through Self-Help Groups in West Bengal - Towards Go...
Backyard Poultry Farming Through Self-Help Groups in West Bengal - Towards Go...
 
Making Modern Poultry Markets Work for the Poor - An example of Cooperative D...
Making Modern Poultry Markets Work for the Poor - An example of Cooperative D...Making Modern Poultry Markets Work for the Poor - An example of Cooperative D...
Making Modern Poultry Markets Work for the Poor - An example of Cooperative D...
 

Water in the livestock value chain

  • 1. Water use throughout the livestock value chain FAO-IFAD Karen Frenken, Marisha Shibuya, Rudolph Cleveringa, Melvyn Kay IFAD, IADG Meeting, Livestock Week, May 3rd, 2010
  • 2. Overview of WLVC • Background: WWDR and awareness raising • Rationale for WLVC: Coverage of livestock, Water scarcity and GHG (CO2, NOx, CH4) • Model of Quadrants • Open questions for research
  • 3. Background • WWDR: Risks and Uncertainties • Drivers: population change, urban/rural distribution, lifestyle choices, climate change • Awareness: when to do what, where and how for whom
  • 5. Where are the poor livestock raisers (Thornton et al, 2002)
  • 6. Rationale • WWDR III, Comprehensive Assessment and Long Shadow: open issues • New FAO study: GHG from the Dairy Sector • New US Dairy Study (forthcoming) Integral life cycle view emerging Water community still dispersed by sectors
  • 8. Water-related risk and uncertainty Water along the livestock value chain Risks & Uncertainties from Livestock Value Chain Risks & Uncertainties to Livestock Value Chain Drivers of Change Climate, economics, demographics, etc. Recycling Production Impact •Water Quantity Acidification, (scarcity, floods) eutrophication, •Water Quality water-use, etc. Consumption Transformation •Allocation Conflicts Water Use/Consumption .
  • 9. Water use in production Global net evapotranspiration for agriculture 7,137 km3 Blue water 22% Irrigated pasture/feed 17% Irrigated crops 83% Rainfed crops 47% Green water 78% Rainfed pasture 53%
  • 10. Water Consumption at the Slaughterhouse Data from Danish & Norwegian slaughterhouses Water COD Nitrogen Phosphorus Suspended Per tonne of consumption Wastewater BOD emission emission emission emission solids carcase (l) (l) (kg) (kg) (g) (g) emission (g) Cattle 1623-9000 1623-9000 1.8-28 4-40 172-1840 24.8-260 11.2-15.9 Pig 1600-8300 1600-6000 2.14-10 3.22-10 180-2100 20-233 0.12-5.1 Sheep 5556-8333 5556-8333 8.89 1556 500 Poultry 5070-67400 5070-67400 2.43-43 4-41 560-4652 26.2-700 48-700 Source: European Commission (May 2005), Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control: Reference Document on Best Available Techniques in the Slaughterhouses and Animal By-products Industries, viewed 30 April 2010 at ftp://ftp.jrc.es/pub/eippcb/doc/sa_bref_0505.pdf
  • 11. UK Food Waste at the Consumer Stage 8.3 million tonnes per year of food and drink waste in UK households (2/3 avoidable, edible foods) Source: WRAP (2009) Household Food and Drink Waste in the UK, p.6
  • 12. Water for livestock Water along the livestock value chain Recycling Production Consumption Transformation
  • 13. Feedback required • What are the main gaps in the “model”? • Where are the data by context, timeline and quadrants? • Where are the linkages in research with consumer organizations, environment and private sector? • R.cleveringa@ifad.org karen.frenken@fao.org
  • 14. Thank you Karen Frenken, Marisha Shibuya, Rudolph Cleveringa, Melvyn Kay