I have covered details around Mobile Marketing, and structured my presentation
1) Landscape
2) Dollar Flow in the AD Ecosystem
3) Traditional VAS Marketing Methods for Feature Phones
4) Mobile Marketing
5) Automation of Campaigns based on Data - Machine Learning
6) Investor Interests in the Space
7) Traditional Cookie Data from Traditional Browsers
4. * Includes: Ad Networks, SSPs, Private Exchanges, and Ad Rep Firms
** Includes: Media Agencies, Creative Agencies, Trading Desks
*** Includes: Ad Exchanges and DSPs
This slide represents Display, Video, Mobile – based on Rare Crowds Analysis of
Advertising Ecosystem Impression / Dollar
Flow
Note: Ad Servers, Yield Management Systems,
Analytics, DMPs, etc… Take out about 8-10%
of spend in total as they pass through the
ecosystem
20%
ADVERTISER AUDIENCE
Agency*
*
Keeps
5-25%
Large
Publisher
(Direct
Reserved
“Premium
”)
Keeps
75-95%
Large
pub
(Remnant)
Keeps
40-80%
Publisher
Aggregat
or*
Keep
10-80%
(May include
multiple
vendors)
Small-
Med
Publishers
Keeps
20-60%
65%
25%
5%
20%
25%
25%
FLOW OF ADVERTISING
IMPRESSIONS (US)
Percent impressions
40%
35%
40%
35%
Ad spend
100%
Exchang
es, DSPs
***
Keeps
10-20%
(may
include
multiple
vendors)
FLOW OF AD SPEND (US)
Percent Dollars Captured (in
yellow)
25%
5%
PerImpressionPriceDrops
4
5. Communication Platforms for VAS Promotions
VAS
PROMOTIO
N
PLATFORMS
SMS
Out Bound
Dialing
EOCN/USS
D
CELL INFO
PLC Cross
Promotion
IVRS
SELF CARE
START-
STOP
RETAIL/ Go
to Market
6. Most Popular Communication Platform
Advantages – Cost effective , Fast n Easy & Reliable
Perception – Considered intrusive, irrelevant
Can be leveraged by
Base Segmentation
Vernacularisation
Timelines
Over 65% customers prefer to read promo SMS on Sunday/Holidays; Weekdays are not
proffered especially Monday & Tuesday
Customers would also prefer Promo SMS after 5 PM
SMS
7. Tagging Promotions on Activation and Deactivation messages across related / unrelated
product categories
Behtar Zindagi 55678 IVR be promoted as a tag promo on Deactivation message of “Mitti Ke rang”
Behtar Zindagi promo can be tagged with on MT Charging SMS of Talk to Me
Tagged promo on Activation Confirmation of a related / untelated VAS category across other VAS
Content providers.
Behtar Zindagi Can be tagged on LAPU Conf SMS on IFFCO Base
Explore possibilities of tagging promo on HT Song Change Confirmation SMS to Rural base
Tagged Promo on Service messages - Roaming ; Users usually read sms received during travelling
and a far likely to try a service
AFC from Altuist can be promoted on Drop over message on Raat Baki IVR of Hungama
Friend Locator is likely to get better conversion if tagged with PLC content of Friends Chat.
PLC Cross
Promotion
8. POP Material in the rural market. Nearest Grain/ Vegetable Markets.
Incentivize Retailer on activation of VAS through PEF/SEF
POP Material at IFFCO Retailers for VAS Targeted at Rural base
POP Material at Youth Hangouts for Youth centered VAS
Festive gatherings, Religious gatherings, Agro Fests or and related events attended by rural folk
Branding on Public transport
Branding on Public carriers
POP at Weekly Bazaars
Celeb Endorsements on radio and RJ mentions
Radio Contests
Cinema Advertising / Brand
Branding on Transport used by FOS and Incentive on conversion
Buzz on Social Media through Celeb endorsements, Winners of Various Contests
RETAIL/ Go
to Market
9. Telco/VAS Marketing Plan:
Gratifications
Operator Subscriber Base of UPU
Airtel 18,055,029
Airtel Rural Base in UPU 9,930,266
Avg Price point @ Rs15, Total Revenue/ Month
72,300 1,084,500
Activity Conversion Number/day
USSD Promotions,4 hrs/ 30,000 300
Cell info, 1 week/ 2,40,000 1,000
SMS push of Toll number - 1 lacs sms for 1K calls 100
Ground Activity - 10
OBD from Airtel End: 300,000 => 4000 Subs 1,000
Monthly Subscription 72,300
Total Airtel Revenue 1,084,500
Company Share @ 36% - Earning 0
Gratification Cost 10% of Handygo share 0
Company Share 0
Projected Subscriber Monthly Projected Revenue (INR)
289200 2,892,000
Airtel Share Share @ 66% 1,908,720
Company Share @ 36% - Earning 983,280
Gratification Cost 10% of Handygo share 98,328
Company Share 884,952
Operator Subscriber Base of UPU Rural Base in UP
1st Month
Penetration
2nd Month
Penetration
3rd month
penetration
4th month
penetration
5th month
penetration 6th month penetration
Airtel 18,055,029 9930265.95 29791 49651 69512 99303 129093 158884
Avg Price point @ Rs20 595816 993027 1390237 1986053 2581869 3177685
10. Mobile Marketing Non Feature
Phones
The Telco managed mobile Marketing –
SMS - Short Codes
Outbound Dialer – Long Codes
USSD – Customer Self Care Portal - *121#
Cell-id based Broadcasts
IVRs
Missed Call Alerts
In Message Advertisement
An Example – Behtar Zindagi
11. Mobile Marketing
Mobile Website / Native App strategy
Location Based Marketing
Permissions / Preferences
12. Appstore Optimization : ASO
Keyword optimization (KWO)
Keyword Optimization (also known as keyword research) is the act of
researching, analyzing and selecting the best keywords to target and drive
qualified users from app stores to your app. App store optimization tool provider
Sensor Tower also breaks keyword optimization down into three parts: relevance,
Difficulty Score and Traffic Score.[16]
Conversion rate optimization (CRO)
Conversion rate optimization involves all metadata available and publicly
accessible in the app stores, like icons, screenshots, description and update
texts.[17][18] This part of app store optimization is responsible to convert the traffic
acquired through keyword optimization into app downloads.
Location labs Appstore Optimization Slides
13. The Keys to Mobile Marketing
Usability
Do you have a mobile optimized site?
Do you have a native mobile app?
How many steps from search to purchase?
Trust
Do you have a user rating?
Are people talking about your brand online?
Personalization
Are you finding you customer at the right time?
Are you reaching your customer in the right place?
Are you targeting your customer with the right message?
16. WOWOKAY, SO HOW AM I GOING TO DO THAT ?
DO WE HAVE A DEDICATED MAN SITTING BEHIND AND OBSERVING LIKE WE ARE
DOING IN THIS VIDEO?
17. Challenges
Location – Where am I ? Office or Home or my shop ?
Personality/ Personas – If I love to camp or play football ? Which Segment?
How do you know my existing products, my brands and what needs
replacement ?
How do you know if I look for expensive brand or a less priced ?
How do you know that I would love to fly as a second alternative ?
How come an app knows that I could make payment through my mobile?
What happens to my privacy ?
18. How is a mobile marketer going to
make all these rules?
Should I map the Customer Journey ?
Event based Rule engine should do ?
How many such rules would be required to monetize the moments of
truth ?
Is it feasible ? YES
Lets Make some Rules - Exercise
19. Mobile Market Automation Aspects
Segmentation
PUSH
In App Campaigns
A/B Testing
Analytics & Data
20. Automated A/B Testing
Experimenting Options Available w.r.t every touch points with the
customer in terms of
Message
Content
UI elements
Run the experiments on consumer segments to target based on
Location, device type, app version, traffic source, and in-app
behaviors.
Add your own Attributes and events specific to the particular brand
app
Running concurrent experiments on the Fly
21. Event-Based Triggers
• Behvior Triggers
• Add to Card
• Card Abandonment
• Checked a Product /discount
items
• Has Shared socially with friends
• Life cycle Based
• New User
• Repeat Customer
• About to Churn
• Calendar Events
• Real Life Event
• Instant Gratification
• Entering a Mall/Shop
27. Ecommerce Marketing Tracker
Marketing Spend:
Visitors to the website/ Mobile /channel
Orders / channel
Orders / Customer: How many orders does a customer submit, who was first
attracted through this channel. This KPI is influenced by other factors as well, but
gives you an initial feeling for the customer quality. It is up to you how you define
“lifetime” (1m/6m/1y). In a later version I will go into CLV management more
deeply.
Revenue/ channel
Discounts Needed/ Channel
28. Are these KPI Useful ? What do I do now?
Basket Size (Basket): How much revenue did this channel generate per order. It helps you to
understand the economic value of the customers that you attract through the different marketing
channels.
Conversion Rate (CR): How many customers per 100 visitors, that came to your site, finally ordered a
product? The Conversion Rate helps you to understand if people that came through this channel only
browsed around, or actually purchased something.
Cost Per Order (CPO): How efficient is this marketing channel? The cost per order tells you how much
you spent to generate one order.
Real Cost Per Order (real CPO): To be able to compare channels on a CPO basis (which channels
generates the cheapest customers), the CPO should be adjusted by certain factors. One big
influencer is the discounts you needed to give to generate an order. E.g. flash sales are usually
relatively cheap to initiate, however you need to give huge discounts. This increases the adjusted
(real) CPO accordingly.
Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): How much revenue does a customer that is generated through this
channel generate for you. This factors in the average basket size, as customers that come through
different channels reorder differently, and spend different amounts.
Return On Marketing Investment Factor (ROMI Factor): How much revenue did you generate per dollar
invest? It helps you to understand the return per marketing channel. It is already adjusted with
discounts to compare the factor cross channel. If you want you can adjust the factor by other
influencers.
29. Exercise – Abandon Cart?
How do I retarget ?
Rules
Time Duration after someone traversed and left
Message Method
Discount
Segment
Timing
31. Last Touch Model
Measure - What was the last touch point the customer interacted ?
What is the conversion % for each last touch point ?
Generally, Email is considered the greater impact for sales conversion
32. First touch Model
Measure – What % of the consumer use which channel as First
touch or the first interaction or the first keyword (in direct search)
What is the impact % table for each touch point in FTM ?
FTM works as a strategy tool for Social Media marketer
34. Customer Credit Sharing
Engagement Factors
Click on Ad
Simply Viewed
In Video Banner Ad
Media Factor
Std Ad
Animated Ad
Size of the Banner Ad
Time Factor
Time span between ads viewing & conversion
Position Factor
Position the offer/ad conversion %
35. Attributions Model -Campaign
Measurements & Results
Which Ad channels drive the best results ?
How are these channels influence each other ?
Which mix of ad/market spend on these channels works best ?
What kind of creative ?
What size, placement & frequency drives the consumer behavior ?
Basically what tactics works best for your business !
36. Custom Credit Rule Examples
What are the customer credit Rules that works best and leads to conversion.
It could be a series of interactions before the moment of truth
Mapping the Offer/Ad Interaction Maps and conversions provides the best
media/campaigns budgets.
40. Analyzing the Cohorts
On Boarding Trend, the orange left arrow, indicates the
product’s effectiveness in its first month of use and its trend
over time, which is nothing less than a metric for user on
boarding effectiveness.
The first cell in each column indicates the monthly active rate
for the cohort’s first month as users. In our hypothetical data
set, that number’s growth varies from 35% to 41% over time.
The product team has done a reasonable job of improving
user on boarding and engaging users when they sign up
Longitudinal Trend, the top red arrow, indicates how the
activity rate changes as users continue to use the product.
The first row is the oldest cohort of users with the most recent
data, the ones who signed up most recently. The bottom row
is the newest cohort. Time flows right in this chart.
41. Cohort Analysis
Average Revenue Per Customer Over Time - Chart monthly revenue
over time to contrast with cohort data
Individual Channel Growth Over Time - Chart all accounts to visualize
trends.
Number of Customers in Each Cohort - Chart number of customers in
each cohort to see how sensitive cohort data is to sample size and also
see the size of the new customer pipeline over time.
Average Monthly Revenue By Cohort - Chart the revenue by cohort to
see if newer customers generate more or less revenue than older
customers. Really good for marketing spend evaluation.
Cohort Comparison - Chart the different cohorts over time to see how
their revenue characteristics compare.
42. Why Deep Linking Matters ?
Links in email/sms not prompting the user to open the native app and
straightway opening a browser
Quite prominently seen in most of the apps
Ecommerce Alerts providing the Access to Purchase, however not
taking directly to Purchase page or CTA landing page
Asking to login on a portal – Ebay and not taking to PDP
ETSY has fixed it and fixed the revenue leakage as well
Marketing links automatically detects the presence of app and auto-
matically takes to either browser or app
Gaming Apps can save the session today, however they can include
the saved sessions in the PN and straightway take it to the that level
In App / PNs directly translate into revenue
TW Cards / Google App Indexing / FB App Link Tags
43. Deep Linking is Context Critical for Mobile Marketing
ADs 2 App
SMS 2 App
QR 2 App
EMAIL 2 App
WEB 2 App
SOCIAL 2 App
App 2 App
Landing Page Optimization Strategy per traffic source.
Cohorts / Traffic Source would enable to fix the leakages and marketing campaigns
improvement
51. Merging the Old & the New World
Browser Cookie Data Management - DMP
52. Data Management Platform ( DMP
)
A very smart, very fast cookie warehouse with analytical firepower
to crunch, de-duplicate, and integrate your data with any
technology platform you desire
Demdex (now owned by Adobe), RedAril, and Krux are what I
would consider pure-plays, while Lotame, Collective, and Turn
provide services
56. Ad Cookies – Step by Step
A request is sent from the browser to retrieve an ad from the publisher
network.
The publisher network retrieve a number of variables from the publisher -
in some exchanges the publisher chooses which data it wants to share.
Publisher variables include:
Anonymity (if anonymous URL above is not shown)
URL e.g. youtube.com
CookieId (buyers can use this to match the user to a pervious seen user,
e.g. for a remarketing campaign)
Vertical - e.g. Videos > Sport
Blocks - e.g. no Google Chrome ads please
Location - e.g. user is in UK, London
57. Ad Cookie – Step by Step …
The network then sends out a request to the buy-side to find ads
e.g. a request is sent out to the DSPs and Buyer Networks.
This includes the publisher variables that are set in the request
sent to the exchange.
The DSPs and BuyerNetworks then run a query.
SELECT snippet, bid FROM all_advertisers WHERE targeting_url = request_url
Bids are then returned by the buyers within the 120ms threshold.
bidder_A:
Advertiser: amazon.com
CPM: $2.50
bidder_B:
Advertiser: ebay.com
CPM: $0.50
The winning ad is then selected. The ad is sent back to the users
browser. The buyer often pays the second highest price to the buyer.
58. Real Time Bidding
User visits a website: say abcd.com.
Within abcd.com there is a HTTP request to SSP, to fill an ad slot.
On receiving the request for showing the ads, the SSP conducts a
real time auction. To each of the DSPs whose have expressed interest
in this user (some SSPs may be willing to show ads to users from a
specific geo, some may be willing to show ads on a certain website,
a retargeting DSP may be willing to show ads to a predefined set of
users etc.)
The SSP sends a bid request. The bid request looks like this:
[ "auction_id": 1234abcd,
"geo": "Bangalore, India",
"ad_width": 728,
"ad_height": 90,
"website": "abcd.com",
"id": ssp1234
]
59. Real Time Bidding – Demand Side
.. On receiving the bid request, each DSP needs to send a bid
response. DSPs typically calculate bid response based on the
parameters in bid request (geo, banner size, etc) and the user profile
that DSP has stored for user id dsp1234 (Remeber that ssp1234 was
mapped to dsp1234 in cookie mapping stage, and data provided by
DMPs is stored against the key dsp1234)
Bid response looks like this:
["auction_id": 1234abcd,
"bid_value": 12.34
"adTag": "<script type='text/javascript'>
document.write ("<script type='text/javascript'
src='dsp.com/showad'");
document.write ("</script>");
</script>"
]
60. Real Time Bidding – Awarding the
Inventory
The SSP compares the bid response of each of the DSPs, and
awards the impression to the highest bidder. These auctions are
usually second price auctions: the highest bidder wins and cost to
highest bidder is second highest bid in the auction.
The SSP redirects user browser to the ad tag provided in the bid
response, which renders the ad to the user's browser.
65. Acronyms
Eng. Rate Engagement rate. For promoted tweets on Twitter, engagement rate is calculated by dividing the number of
engagements a promoted tweet receives by the number of impressions.
Follow Rate For promoted tweets on Twitter, follow rate is calculated by dividing the number of follows by the number of
impressions within a campaign.
Form Submits Form submissions on a website. These metrics indicate what percent of form submissions come from each
digital marketing source (e.g. paid search and referral traffic, email campaigns, social media).
Gross Open Rate The number of times an email message is opened, either by the original recipients or by those to
whom the recipient forwarded the message, divided by the total number of delivered messages. Also known as total open
rate.
Like Rate Facebook page like rate. The number of page likes divided by number of impressions per ad.
MQL Marketing-qualified lead. This is a lead that Marketing has vetted and passes on to Sales.
RL Raw lead. This is a lead that has not yet been vetted and accepted by Marketing.
SQL Sales-qualified lead. This is a lead that has been passed on to Sales from Marketing, and accepted by Sales.
Unique Open Rate The number of unique recipients that opened an email message divided by the total number of
delivered email messages. This measure does not count multiple email opens by a single recepient