The Great Depression lasted from 1929 to 1939, and was the worst economic downturn in the history of the industrialized world. It began after the stock market crash of October 1929, which sent Wall Street into a panic and wiped out millions of investors.
3. Ch. 25: Great Depression and
New Deal, 1929–1941
FDR promise vigorous action because of:
widespread suffering
crisis of capitalism
New Deal:
= experimentation
maintain existing economy/society
Goal = save capitalism
Many helped by New Deal:
even if depression continue until WWII
6. I. Hard Times, 1929–1933
GNP drop by 50%
Profits fall from $10 to $1 billion
100,000 businesses close
Early 1933: unemployed = 25%:
millions more only part-time
Industrial wages cut by ⅓
Millions suffer:
hunger, malnutrition
inadequate heat, poor housing
Illness
Starvation a real threat
7. I. Hard Times, 1929–33 (cont.)
Families evicted
Homeless form “Hoovervilles”
Men seek work on railways and roads
Couples delay marriage and parenthood
Farm crisis (1920s) deepen with:
overproduction and low prices
drought and insects
debt and foreclosures
Many migrate
9. Hard Times, 1929–33 (cont.)
Industrial workers
- rise in standard of living in 1920’s
- every urban American had a job
- workers spent on consumer goods
- depression – less money to spend –
sales dropped – factories closed
- One third of industrial workers
became unemployed
- Wages fell by one-third
10. II. Marginal Workers
Blacks suffer more than whites
unemployment = 50% (1932)
Whites take jobs from blacks and
Hispanics:
USA deport 82,000 Hispanics (1929-35)
½ million more leave because of coercion
Women suffer low pay/segregation:
plus claim they take jobs from men
11. II. Marginal Worker (cont)
Idea that men should be breadwinners
and women homemakers
mixed impact on women:
women in low-wage manufacturing jobs
were laid off before men
domestic workers especially hard hit.
12. But
number of women working outside the
home rose
“women’s jobs” were not as hard hit as
“men’s jobs”
13. III. Middle Class
Professional and white-collar workers did
not fare as badly as industrial workers
and farmers.
Middle class families “Make do” with less.
Slogan: “Use it up, wear it out, make it
do, or do without.”
Fall in income mitigated by falling cost of
consumer products, especially food
Men blamed themselves for their
“failures”.
Human toll of depression visible
everywhere.
16. Read on your own.
IV. Hoover’s Limited Solutions
(pp. 683-685)
V. Protest and Social Unrest
(p. 685)
VI. Bonus Army (1932)
(pp. 685-686)
17. VII. FDR, the 1932 Election, and
Launching the New Deal
Advocate direct relief and USG activity
Win presidency and majorities in Congress
Banking crisis
Risky loans in 1920’s
“Bank runs” threaten full collapse
Promise “war” on Depression
First break-through – Banking bill: saved
US banking system.
People again keen to deposit money.
20. VIII. First Hundred Days (1933)
Federal government took on dramatically new
roles.
Flood of legislation.
Emergency Banking Relief Act:
reopen solvent banks
reorganize insolvent ones
First fireside chat assure people banks safe
Show New Deal’s conservatism
FDR and Brain Trust lack coherent plan
To spur economic recovery, experiment with:
central planning
direct relief
21. IX. National Industrial Recovery
Act (1933)
Respond to “destructive competition” that
worsened industrial problems
Rather co-operation
Establish fixed prices and wages.
Theory: if wages and prices were fixed,
consumer spending will increase.
Industries will be able to rehire workers.
22. Guaranteed workers the right to strike.
HOWEVER
Big businesses dominate code-writing
Not deliver economic recovery
Court found that NRA extended federal
power beyond it constitutional power.
23. X. Agricultural Adjustment Act
(1933)
Pay farmers to cut production:
Less overproduction should raise prices
Implication:
farmers destroyed cattle and crops
Food destruction confused many.
They could not understand the economic
theory behind the waste of food.
Favour landowners but disastrous for
many tenants and sharecroppers
They go to cities
24. Subsidies helped many farmers
AAA also unconstitutional however
popular amongst farmers.
Subsidies continue into 21st century.
25. XI. Relief Programs (1933)
Prefer “work relief” to dole
Civilian Conservation Corps:
jobs for young men (2.5 million)
Public Works Administration:
Major construction projects
spur recovery and development via
infrastructure
cut unemployment and business failures
raise farm prices, wages/salaries
FDR and New Deal very popular
33. XII. Opposition to New Deal
As economy improve, businesses and
conservatives increase opposition
Oppose:
- regulation
- taxes
- deficit spending on relief and public
works
On the one hand:
Business leaders thus fought the new
deal;
34. On the other hand:
Populists claim FDR favours big
business.
Government paid too little attention to
needs of the common people.
35. XIV. Shaping the Second New
Deal
Pressure on Roosevelt for social justice
Eleanor Roosevelt = key advisor:
put social justice issues at the centre of
the New Deal agenda
lead social justice activists
“Black Cabinet”
Different groups:
Hard hit by depression: New Deal must
give them help and social justice;
36. Those with a “tenuous hold on the middle
class: wanted security and stability;
Those with more to lose: New Deal must
preserve American capitalism.
Result: FDR extends New Deal, so called
“Second New Deal”
- “Greater security for the average man”
- $4 billion (deficit spending) to help poor
39. XV. Emergency Relief
Appropriation Act (1935)
Resettlement Administration:
housing for destitute families
Rural Electrification Administration
Works Progress Administration = 8.5
million jobs
Include actors, writers, musicians, artists:
provide jobs
bring culture
celebrate plain folk (slave narratives)
40. XVI. Social Security Act (1935)
Initiate:
federal pension system
unemployment compensation
aid to dependents
More government responsibility, but
conservative:
funded by taxes on workers and employers
taxes regressive
not including farm labor, domestic service,
public sector
Often exclude people of color and women
41. Despite limitations, the Social Security
Act was highly significant:
government took responsibility for
economic security of aged, temporary
unemployed, dependent children and
people with disabilities
42. XVII. FDR’s Populist Strategies
Criticize big business
Wealth Tax: raise taxes on rich/corps
Slight redistribution of income (Figure
25.2)
1936 election: landslide
Cement Democratic coalition:
unions
urbanities (new immigrants)
Solid South
northern blacks
dominate US Government for next 30 years
44. XVIII. Assessment of New Deal
FDR was passionately hated and loved
He personified the presidency and built
trust
Important role of Eleanor Roosevelt –
social justice and human rights
Historians vary on FDR
Some praise ability to inspire/experiment
Others criticize for not doing more
45. FDR = pragmatist who wanted to
preserve the system
capitalist, not radical:
reduce suffering and
preserve capitalist economy
Strengthen government, especially
presidency
46. XXV. Assessment of New Deal
(cont.)
Government:
more regulation
some responsibility for people’s welfare
stimulate economy
Not end Depression
Stay active so no repeat depressions
Liberal reform, not revolution
Editor's Notes
This 1939 photograph, titled “Mother and Children on the Road,” was taken in Tule Lake, California, by Farm Security Administration photographer Dorothea Lange. The FSA used photos like this one to build public support for New Deal programs to assist migrant workers and the rural poor.
As hard times grew worse, families were evicted from their houses or apartments. In desperation, many moved into shantytowns—called Hoovervilles, after the now-unpopular president—on the outskirts of the nation’s cities. These shacks, photographed in October 1931, are in Seattle’s Hooverville. Despite the squalor of the surroundings, someone has done laundry and hung it to dry in the sun.
As the economic depression deepened, Americans had less money to spend, even on necessities, and manufacturers of consumer goods struggled to sell their products and stay in business. In this 1932 Ladies’ Home Journal advertisement, Armour Foods tried to convince housewives who were making do with less that it was economical—“often as low as 10¢ a serving”—to purchase a whole ham instead of cheaper cuts of meat.
Map 25.1: Presidential Election, 1932.
One factor above all decided the 1932 presidential election: the Great Depression. Roosevelt won 42 states and Hoover 6.
In November 1930, Franklin D. Roosevelt (1882–1945) read the good news. Reelected governor of New York by 735,000 votes, he immediately became a leading contender for the Democratic presidential nomination. Notice Roosevelt’s leg braces, rarely shown because of an unwritten agreement by photographers to shoot him from the waist up.
Under the Agricultural Adjustment Act, farmers received government payments for not planting crops or for destroying crops they had already planted. Some farmers, however, needed help of a different kind. The Resettlement Administration, established by executive order in 1935, was authorized to resettle destitute farm families from areas of soil erosion, flooding, and stream pollution to homestead communities. This poster was done by Ben Shahn.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
Figure 25.1: The Economy Before and After the New Deal, 1929–1941.
The New Deal reduced bank closings, business failures, and unemployment, and it increased farm prices, wages, and salaries. Some of the nation’s most persistent economic problems, however, did not disappear until the advent of the Second World War.
In the 1930s, Senator Huey Long (center) had a mass following and presidential ambitions. But he was assassinated in 1935, the evening this photograph was taken. When Long was shot, he fell into the arms of James O’Connor (left), a political crony. Louisiana governor O. K. Allen (right) seized a pistol and dashed into the corridor in pursuit of the murderer, shouting, “If there’s shooting, I want to be in on it.”
Mary McLeod Bethune, pictured here with her friend and supporter Eleanor Roosevelt, became the first African American woman to head a federal agency as director of the Division of Negro Affairs for the National Youth Administration.
Map 25.3: Presidential Election, 1940.
Roosevelt won an unprecedented third term in the 1940 presidential election. He did not repeat his landslide 1936 victory, in which he won all but two states. But he did capture 38 states in 1940 to Republican Wendell Willkie’s 10.