SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 29
Product Design & Development
Redesign of a Reebok Edge Series Cross Trainer
Foot Plate Linkage
Student Name Tony Ponsonby
Student Number 02968984
Unit Name Product Design And Development
Unit Code 64ET7004 1112 9
Assignment Code 2CWK30
Stage 1
Completion
Completion
Initial
Material
Selection
Initial
FEA
CES Material
Selection
Aesthetics
Of Design User
Interface
Further
FEA
Loading
Types
Final
Design
Environment
Impact
Drawings
& Renders
Motion
Simulation
Design
Selection
3D
Refinement
British
Standards
Which direction now?
Proposed Design
Initial FEA
Acetal
• 120kg load
• Young's modulus 3.54GPa
• Tensile strength 73.3MPa
• Yield strength 59.3MPa
Possible New Linkage Materials
PC – polycarbonate
ABS - acrylonitrile butadiene styrene
HDPE - high density polyethylene
PEEK – polyetheretherketone
Acetal – POM
Initial FEA
Acetal
120kg load Young's modulus 3.54GPa
UTS 73.3MPa Yield strength 59.3MPa
Results
Max Principle stress - 55.53MPa
Von-Mises stress – 72.82MPa
Deflection - 7.47mm
Conclusion - Stronger more rigid material required
Data from CES software
Material Selection
Properties of Plastic
Material Selection
Criteria
• High Young's Modulus >14GPA
• High Tensile strength >50MPA
• Low cost <£8/kg
• Opaque
• Good Processability
• Recyclable?
Material Selection
Material Selection
SPS Syndiotactic Polystyrene 40% Glass Fiber
Density 1360-1380 kg/m^3
Price 2.58-3.86 GBP/kg
Tradenames
Edgetek; Schulatec; Questra; Xarec
Composition overview
Polystyrene homopolymer
(CH2CH(C6H5))n of regular syndiotactic
stereochemistry with impact modification.
With reinforcing filler.
Thermoplastic : semi-crystalline
Mechanical properties
Young's modulus 10-15.2 GPa
Yield strength 110-147 MPa
Tensile strength 96.5-140 MPa
Compressive strength 92.6-134 MPa
Flexural strength 161-231 MPa
Elongation 0.7-2.04 % strain
Melting point 240-260 °C
Optical properties
Transparency Opaque
Recycle False
Downcycle True
Combust for energy recovery True
Landfill True
Typical uses
Specialized components for automotive,
electrical, electronic, and
consumer/industrial products, such as
connectors and microwave oven parts
Data from CES
Design to Standards
BS EN 957 Stationary training equipment —
Part 1: 2005 General safety requirements and
test methods
Part 9: 2003 Elliptical trainers, additional
specific safety requirements and test
Methods
BSEN 15312:2007 Free access multi-sports
equipment
Design to Standards
FOOT PLATE SIZE
BS EN 957 Part 9: 2003 clause 5.5 requires that ‘ the foot platforms have a
non slip surface of at least 300mm x 100mm and a friction actor of more
than 0.5 when tested to ISO5904’
MOTION
Design to Standards
FOOT PLATE GRIP DESIGN
Design to Standards
BS EN 957 Part 9: 2003 clause 5.5 requires that ‘The footplatform shall have a
guard with at least 30mm height along the inside edge and the front edge’
Design to Standards
Trainer Classification as BS EN 957-1:2005
Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
Design to Standards
Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
Design to Standards
Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
Design to Standards
Classification H - 250KG Loading
Design to Standards
Classification H - 250KG Loading
Design to Standards
Classification S - 400KG Loading
Design to Standards
Classification S - 100KG Loading
Conclusion
SPS is suitable for H classification trainers
SPS not suitable for S classification
trainers
The design could be used for S
classification using a material with a
Young’s Modulus >24GPa
Yield Strength > 150MPa
PP66 with 30% carbon fiber is
suitable for H classification trainers
Shape Optimization
CURVATURE OF SHAPE
INITIAL
PROPOSAL
REFINED
DESIGN
Exploded View
Eco Audit Report
Product Name Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage
Product Life (years) 3
Energy and CO2 Footprint Summary:
Energy Details...
CO2 Details...
Phase Energy (MJ) Energy (%) CO2 (kg) CO2 (%)
Material 176 81.2 12.2 80.0
Manufacture 36.8 17.0 2.76 18.2
Transport 3.59 1.7 0.255 1.7
Use 0 0.0 0 0.0
Disposal 0.321 0.1 0.0225 0.1
Total (for first life) 216 100 15.2 100
End of life potential -171 -11.8
Environmental Report
Downcycle at EOL
Criteria
– Component weight 1.6kg
– Manufactured in China &
transported to
Manchester
– Re-engineered at end of
life
– 15.2kg CO2 required for
a 1.6kg?
– Combustion only returns
10MJ but adds 2.6kg CO2
emissions
Tooling
Design Benefits
Original Design New Design
Number of parts 80 16
Manufacturer assembled components 24 6
User assembled components 56 10
Weight 6.03kg 3.18kg
Cross trainer Classification H H&S
Recycle
Steel Yes -
ABS Downcycle/Combust -
SPS - Downcycle/Combust
Future Work
• Rapid prototype
• Physical testing as designated by BS EN957-1;2005
– Load test as per as per clause 5.3.1 in accordance with
clause 6.4
– Fatigue / Cyclic loading as per clause 5.7 in accordance
with clause 6.7
– Friction factor test as per clause 5.5 in accordance with
clause ISO 5904
Redesigned using SPS Syndiotactic
Polystyrene 40% Glass Fiber
Reduces user-assembled components by 64
Reduces weight by 2.85kg
Designed for class H (home use) Elliptical
Trainers as per BS EN 957–1:2005Redesign of a Reebok Edge Series
Elliptical Trainer Foot Plate Linkage
Product Design & Development
Tony Ponsonby 14/12/2011

More Related Content

What's hot

SARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
SARNATH-PROFILE-CAESARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
SARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
Sarnath R
 
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNTSARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
Sarnath R
 
Baja SAE India 2013
Baja SAE India 2013Baja SAE India 2013
Baja SAE India 2013
Utsav Lall
 
Portfolio professional line 2012.english
Portfolio professional line 2012.englishPortfolio professional line 2012.english
Portfolio professional line 2012.english
forestcesar
 

What's hot (20)

128709302.pdf
128709302.pdf128709302.pdf
128709302.pdf
 
SUPRA SAE
SUPRA SAESUPRA SAE
SUPRA SAE
 
SARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
SARNATH-PROFILE-CAESARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
SARNATH-PROFILE-CAE
 
IRJET-Design, Analysis and Weight Optimization of Leaf Spring for Light Weigh...
IRJET-Design, Analysis and Weight Optimization of Leaf Spring for Light Weigh...IRJET-Design, Analysis and Weight Optimization of Leaf Spring for Light Weigh...
IRJET-Design, Analysis and Weight Optimization of Leaf Spring for Light Weigh...
 
Finite element analysis of polymer based automotive connecting rod
Finite element analysis of polymer based automotive connecting rodFinite element analysis of polymer based automotive connecting rod
Finite element analysis of polymer based automotive connecting rod
 
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNTSARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
SARNATH-PROFILE-at LNT
 
2.flat belts &amp; sample problem
2.flat belts &amp; sample problem2.flat belts &amp; sample problem
2.flat belts &amp; sample problem
 
Ijetr042190
Ijetr042190Ijetr042190
Ijetr042190
 
IRJET- Design and Analysis of Hydraulic Continuously Variable Transmission
IRJET- Design and Analysis of Hydraulic Continuously Variable TransmissionIRJET- Design and Analysis of Hydraulic Continuously Variable Transmission
IRJET- Design and Analysis of Hydraulic Continuously Variable Transmission
 
https://irjet.net/archives/V4/i7/IRJET-V4I7551.pdf
https://irjet.net/archives/V4/i7/IRJET-V4I7551.pdfhttps://irjet.net/archives/V4/i7/IRJET-V4I7551.pdf
https://irjet.net/archives/V4/i7/IRJET-V4I7551.pdf
 
SAE 2007-NVC-180
SAE 2007-NVC-180SAE 2007-NVC-180
SAE 2007-NVC-180
 
IRJET- Static Analysis of Pulsar Bike Frame Made Up of Aluminum Alloy 6063
IRJET- Static Analysis of Pulsar Bike Frame Made Up of Aluminum Alloy 6063IRJET- Static Analysis of Pulsar Bike Frame Made Up of Aluminum Alloy 6063
IRJET- Static Analysis of Pulsar Bike Frame Made Up of Aluminum Alloy 6063
 
Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structuresOptimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
 
Design and Optimization of Steering System
Design and Optimization of Steering SystemDesign and Optimization of Steering System
Design and Optimization of Steering System
 
Baja SAE India 2013
Baja SAE India 2013Baja SAE India 2013
Baja SAE India 2013
 
IRJET- Design and Analysis of Different Characteristics of Hollow and Sol...
IRJET-  	  Design and Analysis of Different Characteristics of Hollow and Sol...IRJET-  	  Design and Analysis of Different Characteristics of Hollow and Sol...
IRJET- Design and Analysis of Different Characteristics of Hollow and Sol...
 
Virtual BAJA 2015_(16190)_(Team Prayog)_PRESENTATION
Virtual BAJA 2015_(16190)_(Team Prayog)_PRESENTATION Virtual BAJA 2015_(16190)_(Team Prayog)_PRESENTATION
Virtual BAJA 2015_(16190)_(Team Prayog)_PRESENTATION
 
Ijariie1167
Ijariie1167Ijariie1167
Ijariie1167
 
IRJET- Design Analysis and Optimization of Two-Wheeler Chassis for Weight Red...
IRJET- Design Analysis and Optimization of Two-Wheeler Chassis for Weight Red...IRJET- Design Analysis and Optimization of Two-Wheeler Chassis for Weight Red...
IRJET- Design Analysis and Optimization of Two-Wheeler Chassis for Weight Red...
 
Portfolio professional line 2012.english
Portfolio professional line 2012.englishPortfolio professional line 2012.english
Portfolio professional line 2012.english
 

Viewers also liked

(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
嘉寶 陳
 
Ciencias naturales
Ciencias naturalesCiencias naturales
Ciencias naturales
Evelyn Sagal
 
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan KhamdiyahMakalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
khamdiyah
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Paradoks 1969
Paradoks 1969Paradoks 1969
Paradoks 1969
 
Media pembelajaran
Media pembelajaranMedia pembelajaran
Media pembelajaran
 
Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 1
Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 1Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 1
Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 1
 
Msc Thesis
Msc ThesisMsc Thesis
Msc Thesis
 
(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
(102new)乙三站螺旋式冰水主機控制線路圖102
 
SPL m persamaan linear dengan n bilangan yang tidak diketahui part 2
SPL m persamaan linear dengan n bilangan yang tidak diketahui part 2SPL m persamaan linear dengan n bilangan yang tidak diketahui part 2
SPL m persamaan linear dengan n bilangan yang tidak diketahui part 2
 
Ciencias naturales
Ciencias naturalesCiencias naturales
Ciencias naturales
 
Asthma
AsthmaAsthma
Asthma
 
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan KhamdiyahMakalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
Makalah Sejarah Perkembangan TIK dalam Pendidikan Khamdiyah
 
Law and Justice Chapter 3 power point
Law and Justice Chapter 3 power pointLaw and Justice Chapter 3 power point
Law and Justice Chapter 3 power point
 
MOOCs: searching for a viable business model
MOOCs: searching for a viable business modelMOOCs: searching for a viable business model
MOOCs: searching for a viable business model
 
Let's Get Personal: Creating a Unique Web Experience Each and Every Time
Let's Get Personal: Creating a Unique Web Experience Each and Every TimeLet's Get Personal: Creating a Unique Web Experience Each and Every Time
Let's Get Personal: Creating a Unique Web Experience Each and Every Time
 
Chapter 13 power point
Chapter 13 power pointChapter 13 power point
Chapter 13 power point
 
Law and Justice Chapter 1 power point
Law and Justice Chapter 1 power pointLaw and Justice Chapter 1 power point
Law and Justice Chapter 1 power point
 
MOOCs
MOOCsMOOCs
MOOCs
 

Similar to Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 2

Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structuresOptimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
Mohamed Moanes EzzElarab
 
Final Bachelor thesis Presentation
Final Bachelor thesis PresentationFinal Bachelor thesis Presentation
Final Bachelor thesis Presentation
Mohammed Omer
 
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUEMY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
Chris Yu
 
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUEMY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
Chris Yu
 
Lca avancis for icv
Lca avancis for icvLca avancis for icv
Lca avancis for icv
ICV_eV
 
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
halilyldrm13
 
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
halilyldrm13
 

Similar to Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 2 (20)

Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structuresOptimum weight design of ship’s structures
Optimum weight design of ship’s structures
 
Final Bachelor thesis Presentation
Final Bachelor thesis PresentationFinal Bachelor thesis Presentation
Final Bachelor thesis Presentation
 
power 1
power 1power 1
power 1
 
2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Bottasso
2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Bottasso2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Bottasso
2014 Wind Turbine Blade Workshop- Bottasso
 
WMA Presentation at Transportation Research Board Conference 2007
WMA Presentation at Transportation Research Board Conference 2007WMA Presentation at Transportation Research Board Conference 2007
WMA Presentation at Transportation Research Board Conference 2007
 
Senior Design Project Final Presentation
Senior Design Project Final PresentationSenior Design Project Final Presentation
Senior Design Project Final Presentation
 
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUEMY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
 
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUEMY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
MY2017 TAISHAN OPEN MODEL CATALOGUE
 
Engineering case study
Engineering case studyEngineering case study
Engineering case study
 
Diapositivas de la conferencia de Gül Kremer
Diapositivas de la conferencia de Gül KremerDiapositivas de la conferencia de Gül Kremer
Diapositivas de la conferencia de Gül Kremer
 
Design and Performance Analysis of Mechanical Hydro Pneumatic Suspension System
Design and Performance Analysis of Mechanical Hydro Pneumatic Suspension SystemDesign and Performance Analysis of Mechanical Hydro Pneumatic Suspension System
Design and Performance Analysis of Mechanical Hydro Pneumatic Suspension System
 
IRJET- Design, Analysis & Weight Reduction of Piston of Refrigerator Compressor
IRJET- Design, Analysis & Weight Reduction of Piston of Refrigerator CompressorIRJET- Design, Analysis & Weight Reduction of Piston of Refrigerator Compressor
IRJET- Design, Analysis & Weight Reduction of Piston of Refrigerator Compressor
 
Metalerstatning med PP, PA6 og PA66 armeret med lange fibre v. Johnny Bjarnho...
Metalerstatning med PP, PA6 og PA66 armeret med lange fibre v. Johnny Bjarnho...Metalerstatning med PP, PA6 og PA66 armeret med lange fibre v. Johnny Bjarnho...
Metalerstatning med PP, PA6 og PA66 armeret med lange fibre v. Johnny Bjarnho...
 
World Auto Steel General Presentation 20090630
World Auto Steel General Presentation 20090630World Auto Steel General Presentation 20090630
World Auto Steel General Presentation 20090630
 
AmbiCycle Final
AmbiCycle FinalAmbiCycle Final
AmbiCycle Final
 
Lca avancis for icv
Lca avancis for icvLca avancis for icv
Lca avancis for icv
 
Platnium warriors
Platnium warriorsPlatnium warriors
Platnium warriors
 
Platnium warriors
Platnium warriorsPlatnium warriors
Platnium warriors
 
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
 
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
2017_Session_Zhaoqiangsheng.pdf
 

Product Design of Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage 2

  • 1. Product Design & Development Redesign of a Reebok Edge Series Cross Trainer Foot Plate Linkage Student Name Tony Ponsonby Student Number 02968984 Unit Name Product Design And Development Unit Code 64ET7004 1112 9 Assignment Code 2CWK30
  • 2. Stage 1 Completion Completion Initial Material Selection Initial FEA CES Material Selection Aesthetics Of Design User Interface Further FEA Loading Types Final Design Environment Impact Drawings & Renders Motion Simulation Design Selection 3D Refinement British Standards Which direction now?
  • 4. Initial FEA Acetal • 120kg load • Young's modulus 3.54GPa • Tensile strength 73.3MPa • Yield strength 59.3MPa Possible New Linkage Materials PC – polycarbonate ABS - acrylonitrile butadiene styrene HDPE - high density polyethylene PEEK – polyetheretherketone Acetal – POM
  • 5. Initial FEA Acetal 120kg load Young's modulus 3.54GPa UTS 73.3MPa Yield strength 59.3MPa Results Max Principle stress - 55.53MPa Von-Mises stress – 72.82MPa Deflection - 7.47mm Conclusion - Stronger more rigid material required
  • 6. Data from CES software Material Selection Properties of Plastic
  • 7. Material Selection Criteria • High Young's Modulus >14GPA • High Tensile strength >50MPA • Low cost <£8/kg • Opaque • Good Processability • Recyclable?
  • 9. Material Selection SPS Syndiotactic Polystyrene 40% Glass Fiber Density 1360-1380 kg/m^3 Price 2.58-3.86 GBP/kg Tradenames Edgetek; Schulatec; Questra; Xarec Composition overview Polystyrene homopolymer (CH2CH(C6H5))n of regular syndiotactic stereochemistry with impact modification. With reinforcing filler. Thermoplastic : semi-crystalline Mechanical properties Young's modulus 10-15.2 GPa Yield strength 110-147 MPa Tensile strength 96.5-140 MPa Compressive strength 92.6-134 MPa Flexural strength 161-231 MPa Elongation 0.7-2.04 % strain Melting point 240-260 °C Optical properties Transparency Opaque Recycle False Downcycle True Combust for energy recovery True Landfill True Typical uses Specialized components for automotive, electrical, electronic, and consumer/industrial products, such as connectors and microwave oven parts Data from CES
  • 10. Design to Standards BS EN 957 Stationary training equipment — Part 1: 2005 General safety requirements and test methods Part 9: 2003 Elliptical trainers, additional specific safety requirements and test Methods BSEN 15312:2007 Free access multi-sports equipment
  • 11. Design to Standards FOOT PLATE SIZE BS EN 957 Part 9: 2003 clause 5.5 requires that ‘ the foot platforms have a non slip surface of at least 300mm x 100mm and a friction actor of more than 0.5 when tested to ISO5904’
  • 12. MOTION Design to Standards FOOT PLATE GRIP DESIGN
  • 13. Design to Standards BS EN 957 Part 9: 2003 clause 5.5 requires that ‘The footplatform shall have a guard with at least 30mm height along the inside edge and the front edge’
  • 14. Design to Standards Trainer Classification as BS EN 957-1:2005 Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
  • 15. Design to Standards Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
  • 16. Design to Standards Load testing to BS EN 957-9:2003
  • 20. Design to Standards Classification S - 100KG Loading Conclusion SPS is suitable for H classification trainers SPS not suitable for S classification trainers The design could be used for S classification using a material with a Young’s Modulus >24GPa Yield Strength > 150MPa PP66 with 30% carbon fiber is suitable for H classification trainers
  • 23.
  • 25. Eco Audit Report Product Name Reebok Cross Trainer Linkage Product Life (years) 3 Energy and CO2 Footprint Summary: Energy Details... CO2 Details... Phase Energy (MJ) Energy (%) CO2 (kg) CO2 (%) Material 176 81.2 12.2 80.0 Manufacture 36.8 17.0 2.76 18.2 Transport 3.59 1.7 0.255 1.7 Use 0 0.0 0 0.0 Disposal 0.321 0.1 0.0225 0.1 Total (for first life) 216 100 15.2 100 End of life potential -171 -11.8 Environmental Report Downcycle at EOL Criteria – Component weight 1.6kg – Manufactured in China & transported to Manchester – Re-engineered at end of life – 15.2kg CO2 required for a 1.6kg? – Combustion only returns 10MJ but adds 2.6kg CO2 emissions
  • 27. Design Benefits Original Design New Design Number of parts 80 16 Manufacturer assembled components 24 6 User assembled components 56 10 Weight 6.03kg 3.18kg Cross trainer Classification H H&S Recycle Steel Yes - ABS Downcycle/Combust - SPS - Downcycle/Combust
  • 28. Future Work • Rapid prototype • Physical testing as designated by BS EN957-1;2005 – Load test as per as per clause 5.3.1 in accordance with clause 6.4 – Fatigue / Cyclic loading as per clause 5.7 in accordance with clause 6.7 – Friction factor test as per clause 5.5 in accordance with clause ISO 5904
  • 29. Redesigned using SPS Syndiotactic Polystyrene 40% Glass Fiber Reduces user-assembled components by 64 Reduces weight by 2.85kg Designed for class H (home use) Elliptical Trainers as per BS EN 957–1:2005Redesign of a Reebok Edge Series Elliptical Trainer Foot Plate Linkage Product Design & Development Tony Ponsonby 14/12/2011