What are the advantages and disadvantages of membrane structures.pptx
Slides cecam
1. Let H = 1
2pT M−1p + V(q) = A + B be a Hamiltonian with the
equations of motion
d
dt
q = M−1
p,
d
dt
p = − qV(q). (1)
The integration schemes under study belong to the
one-parameter family of symplectic two-stage splitting
integrators of the form
ψ∆t = ϕB
b∆t ◦ ϕA
∆t/2 ◦ ϕB
(1−2b)∆t ◦ ϕA
∆t/2 ◦ ϕB
b∆t ,
with b ∈ (0, 1/4].
If b = 1/4, ψ∆t = ψVV
∆t/2 ◦ ψVV
∆t/2 (two velocity Verlet integrator
half steps).
The energy error over an I-steps trajectory is
∆(q, p, ∆t) = H(Ψ∆t,I(q, p)) − H(q, p), where
Ψ∆t,I = ψ∆t ◦ ψ∆t ◦ · · · ◦ ψ∆t
I times
.
2. Given a step size ∆t and the highest frequency ˜ω in a
physical system find
b(∆t, ˜ω) ≡ system specific integrator
that minimizes the expectation of the energy error ∆
0 ≤ E(∆) ≤ ρ(h, b) =
h4
(2b2
(1/2 − b)h2
+ 4b2
− 6b + 1)2
8(2 − bh2)(2 − (1/2 − b)h2)(1 − b(1/2 − b)h2)
.
The bound is found from analysis of the harmonic oscillator
and h is a non-dimensional time-step. Then,
b∗
(∆t, ˜ω) = arg min max
0<h<˜h
ρ(h, b),
where ˜h is a function of ∆t and ˜ω.
3. • Toxin-bilayer: coarse-grained non-constrained system
AIA provides the highest acceptance rates in the Metropolis test of
HMC and the most accurate average temperatures in MD,
regardless a choice of the time-step.
10 15 20 25
∆t / number of stages (fs)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AR(%)
VV
BCSS
AIA
Acceptance Rates (HMC)
10 15 20 25
∆t / number of stages (fs)
308
309
310
311
312
Temperature(K)
VV
BCSS
AIA
Target temperature
Temperature (MD)
AIA is at least as good as the best sampling integrator, i.e., it has
the lowest integrated autocorrelation function (IACF) values for the
studied observable, regardless a choice of the time-step, for both MD
and HMC.
20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
∆t x L (ps)
0
10
20
30
40
50
IACFxtime(h)
VV
BCSS
AIA
∆t / nr stages = 10 fs
∆t / nr stages = 15 fs
∆t / nr stages = 20 fs
∆t / nr stages = 22.5 fs
IACF equilibration (HMC)
10 15 20
∆t / number of stages (fs)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
IACFxtime(h)
VV
BCSS
AIA
IACF equilibration (MD)
Remark: BCSS is a specific two-stage splitting scheme presented in Blanes et al., (2014).
4. • Villin protein: atomistic system with hydrogen bonds constrained
AIA provides the highest acceptance rates in the Metropolis test of
HMC and the most accurate average temperatures in MD,
regardless a choice of the time-step.
1 1.5 2 2.5
∆t / number of stages (fs)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AR(%)
VV
BCSS
AIA
Acceptance Rates (HMC)
1 1.5 2 2.5
∆t / number of stages (fs)
298
299
300
301
302
Temperature(K)
VV
BCSS
AIA
Target temperature
Temperature (MD)
AIA needs equal or smaller number of force evaluations to start a
folding process than the best sampling integrator in both MD and
HMC.
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
∆t x L (ps)
0
10
20
30
40
numberofforceevaluations(x10
5
)
VV
BCSS
AIA
∆t / nr stages = 1 fs
∆t / nr stages = 1.5 fs
∆t / nr stages = 2 fs
Force evaluations folding (HMC)
1 1.5 2
∆t / number of stages (fs)
0
10
20
30
40numberofforceevaluations(x10
5
)
VV
BCSS
AIA
Force evaluations folding (MD)
Remark: BCSS is a specific two-stage splitting scheme presented in Blanes et al., (2014).