1. Francesco Sylos Labini Centro Fermi & ISC-CNR Roma http://ricercatorialberi.blogspot.com/ http://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/blog/flabini/ http://ricercatorialberi.blogspot.com Valutazione
2.
3. Valutazione: problema chiave Se una ipotetica commissione che avesse dovuto decidere del finanziamento di un “ progetto ” al tempo T 0 che poi ha portato al “ Nobel ” al tempo T 1 >T 0 , ed avesse applicato un dato criterio (ad esempio metrico) avrebbe preso la decisione giusta?
5. Analisi dei criteri di valutazione da un punto di vista storico Valutazione: problema chiave
6.
7. “ … . Nella ricerca conta solo l' eccellenza: ciò che non è eccellente non lascia traccia nella Storia . ” (Francesco Giavazzi, 22.11.2004, Corriere della Sera)
8. The two papers in Science 2004 and Nature 2005 are the most cited papers on graphene … The Science paper has also been acknowledged as “one of the most cited recent papers in the field of Physics”. 2010 Valutazione: problema chiave
9. A Research Assessment System (or RAS) is a system in which groups of researchers are assessed at intervals. If the assessment is good, the group retains its funding or gets more, while, if the assessment is bad, the group’s funds are reduced or perhaps removed altogether. Research Assessment Exercise
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16. My claim is that the research work of the members of whichever school has the largest number of members will receive the highest valuation. So if school A is in the majority, the members of school A will receive the highest valuation. If school B is in the majority, then the members of school B will receive the highest valuation, and so on. If a Research Assessment System is applied to such a community, what result will it give? (Economics and Research Assessment Systems Donald Gillies, In the press, 2011)