1. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 1
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
LECTURE 4
Exercise: How to make your own alloy?
Lecturers: Dr. ir. Pedro Rivera
Prof. dr. ir. Sybrand van der Zwaag
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
New Building, office 1.36
p.rivera@lr.tudelft.nl, phone 00 3115 2784559
2. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 2
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Objective of this lecture:
Provide critical examples of alloy design.
TRIP steel and TRIP-Ti alloys.
3. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 3
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
LECTURE OUTLINE
1. The design of P TRIP steel.
2. The design of Ti alloys with TRIP effect.
3. Review of student projects and setting timetable.
4. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 4
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
LECTURE OUTLINE
1. The design of P TRIP steel.
2. The design of Ti alloys with TRIP effect.
3. Review of student projects and setting timetable.
5. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 5
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
P Influences
Reviewed in Lecture 2
1. For avoiding phosphide precipitation, P content should be
lower than 0.3%.
2. For casting limitations and segregation, P content should
be lower than 0.3%.
3. From the peritectic reaction, segregation is minimised if P
content is APPROXIMATELY larger than 0.25%.
4. P content should be as large
6. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 6
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Principles of P Alloy Optimisation
1. The amount of plasticity depends on the volume of
martensite induced and the magnitude of the martensite
transformation strain.
2. Residual austenite is no more than 4 vol%.
3. The formation of ferrite and bainite enriches or depletes
alloying elements in the remaining austenite, improving its
stability (chemical stabilization).
4. The formation also decreases austenite grain size (grain
size stabilization).
7. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 7
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Non-equilibrium regimes
1. LE: Local equilibrium or orthoequilibrium. All alloying
elements redistribute.
2. PE: Paraequilibrium. Only interstitial atoms redistribute.
3. NE: Non-equilibrium. No atom redistribution between
matrix and product (same chemical composition).
PE
LE
NE
NPLE
XE
NPLE=non partition
local equilibrium
8. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 8
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Phase Transformations in TRIP steels
1. It is required to know if the ferrite decomposition is under
LE or NPLE.
2. Bainitic decomposition is assumed to be NPLE.
3. Martensitic decomposition is under NE.
9. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 9
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Ferrite decomposition (1/3)
1. Ferrite increases carbon
concentration in austenite.
Why we want this?
2. It decreases grain size of
residual austenite.
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
C, mass %
T,
K
a + q
g
g + q
g + a
liquid
d + g
d
liquid + g
A
B
E
J
H
N
G
S K
P
Q
C
(a)
Fe-C-1.5Mn-0.4Si
10. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 10
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Ferrite decomposition (2/3)
1. Ferrite increases
carbon
concentration in
austenite. Why we
want this?
2. It decreases grain
size of residual
austenite.
0
20
40
60
80
950 1000 1050 1100 1150
T, K
Ferrite,
mass
%
0.25P
0.05P
0.15P
(a)
11. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 11
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Ferrite decomposition (3/3)
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
P, mass %
Ferrite,
mass
%
(b)
Due to phosphide
Due to cementite
Max. ferrite amount
If the combined effects
of phosphide and
cementite formation are
accounted, it is required
that P0.25
12. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 12
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
C in austenite
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
950 1000 1050 1100 1150
T, K
C,
mass
%
0.25P
0.05P
0.15P
(a)
Intercritical annealing temperature -------------------------
C enrichment chemically
stabilises metastable
austenite as it decreases
Ms temperature.
P increases carbon
solubility in austenite
13. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 13
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Si in Austenite and Ferrite
0.4
0.42
0.44
0.46
0.48
0.5
920 970 1020 1070 1120
T, K
Si
in
ferrite,
mass
%
0.3
0.32
0.34
0.36
0.38
0.4
Si
in
austenite,
mass
%
in austenite
in ferrite
0.25P
0.15P
0.05P
(b)
P redistributes Si. This slows
down the kinetics of
cementite formation.
The intercritical annealing
temperature should be
lower than 1030 K.
14. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 14
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Mn in Austenite and Ferrite
0.72
0.76
0.8
0.84
920 970 1020 1070 1120
T, K
Mn
in
ferrite,
mass
%
1.5
2.5
3.5
4.5
Mn
in
austenite,
mass
%
austenite
ferrite
0.25P
0.15P
0.05P
(c)
The intercritical temperature
has to be in the range
970<T<1030 for maximising
the partitioning of Mn, and
thus improve the
metastability of austenite by
lowering the Ms.
15. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 15
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
P in Austenite and Ferrite
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
950 1000 1050 1100 1150
T, K
P
in
ferrite,
mass
%
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
P
in
austenite,
mass
%
0.25P
0.15P
0.05P
ferrite
austenite
(d)
P concentration increases P
content in austenite and
ferrite.
Intercritical T increases
austenite P content,
stabilising metastable
austenite.
T must be maximised.
16. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 16
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Influence of Metastability
20
40
60
80
100
950 975 1000 1025 1050
T, K
Ferrite,
mass
%
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
C
in
austenite,
mass
%
Fe-0.2C-0.15P-1.5Mn-0.4Si
full equilibrium
paraequilibrium
The choice of PE or NPLE
makes no significant
difference in the results.
At T>1000 K C
concentration and amount
of ferrite are slightly
overestimated.
17. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 17
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
CONCLUSIONS REACHED SO FAR:
• Annealing temperature between 1030 and 1040 K
• P content between 0.15 and 0.25 wt%
18. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 18
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Bainitic decomposition (1/4)
• Austenite grain size reduction
• Possible cementite precipitation (retained austenite C decrease)
• C composition of the Retained Austenite
19. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 19
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Bainitic decomposition (2/4)
• Austenite grain size
reduction
Can be determined from
previous experimental work.
Is essential for
micromechanical behaviour.
Grains should be of a lower
size.
20. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 20
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Bainitic decomposition (3/4)
• Possible cementite precipitation (retained austenite C
decrease)
No prior experience on this regard
It is undesirable
Hot deformation at high temperature recommended (e.g.
in Si-Mn TRIP steels)
21. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 21
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Bainitic decomposition (4/4)
Bainite and austenite
compositions can be
determined by
extrapolation in the
appropriate metastable
phase diagram.
From this composition
of martensite may be
determined.
Carbon concentration
Temperature
austenite
austenite
+
ferrite
G
S
P
Q P1 P2
ferrite
/
a
a
x q
/
a
a
x g
/ a
xg
g
T
22. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 22
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Martensitic Decomposition of Austenite
• Ultimately,
austenitemartensite
transformation is wanted.
• Ms can be related to the critical
temperature T0 at which ferrite
and martensite have the same
Gibbs energy.
• Using this concepts, for the
calculated austenite
composition, Fe-1.29C-0.12P-
0.6Si-2.29Mn, Ms ranges
between 252 to 292 K
depending on grain size.
840
844
848
852
856
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
P, mass %
T
0
,
K
23. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 23
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
LECTURE OUTLINE
1. The design of P TRIP steel.
2. The design of Ti alloys with TRIP effect.
3. Review of student projects and setting timetable.
24. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 24
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Ti-Systems with TRIP Effect
How can the TRIP effect be achieved in Ti-alloys?
1. Take the alloy to the +a phase.
2. Quench to room temperature retaining phase.
3. Stress induce martensitic transformation at room
temperature.
25. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 25
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Motivation
26. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 26
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
What is required for TRIP in Ti-
Alloys?
1. Have a system with a+ high temperature phase.
2. Have the ability to retain phase at room temperature.
3. Control the Ms temperature around room temperature.
4. Avoid (control) undesired precipitate phases.
5. Control retained phases hardness at room temperature.
27. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 27
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Some Previous Work (1/5)
1. TRIP effect has been reported in some Ti-alloys:
Ti-Al-Sn, Ti-V-Fe-Al, Ti-Ta, Ti-Mo
2. The conditions for the presence of martensite have been
recorded.
28. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 28
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Some Previous Work (2/5)
3. Some phase diagrams and heat treatment schemes have
been determined.
29. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 29
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Some Previous Work (3/5)
4. Some mechanical properties have already been recorded.
Ti-40wt% Ta
30. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 30
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Some Previous Work (4/5)
Ti-40wt% Ta
31. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 31
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Some Previous Work (5/5)
32. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 32
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
LECTURE OUTLINE
1. The design of P TRIP steel.
2. The design of Ti alloys with TRIP effect.
3. Review of student projects and setting timetable.
33. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 33
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Evaluation Method and Project
Weighted evaluation measuring three aspects:
- Understanding of the lectures
and reading material
- Knowledge of the theory
- Skills for alloy design Aid for using software and
critical decision process
Oral examination
34. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 34
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Suggested projects
1. Controlling the microstructure in TRIP steels.
A thermodynamical analysis will be performed in order to
link the phases present in a commercial TRIP steel.
• Retained austenite and its grain size
• Martensite
• Ferrite
• Bainite
• Cementite
• Precipitate phases.
OBJECTIVE: Excel strength-ductility properties by
controlling the alloying elements in each phase.
Determine optimum rolling schemes and composition.
35. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 35
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Suggested projects
2. Design of Ti alloys with TRIP effects.
Investigate the ranges of binary and ternary systems that
have the required a+ fields and their sizes. Tailor
volume fractions and electron to atom ratios for
inducing martensite transformation.
Determine also optimum heat treatment schemes.
OBJECTIVE: Quantify the most feasible options for Ti-
alloys with TRIP effects.
36. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 36
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
Suggested projects
3. Precipitation sequences in Al 2024 T3 and minimisation of
its softening.
Taking the commercial alloy composition and heat
treatment, reproduce its expected precipitation sequences
and suggest modifications in its composition and heat
treatment scheme to avoid undesirable softening after
aircraft long term use.
OBJECTIVE: Optimise strength-ageing behaviour in
commercial Al 2024 T3.
37. Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
17th of Februaryr 2004 37
Fundamentals of Advanced Materials
BIBLIOGRAPHY
J.J. Wang and S. van der Zwaag; Theoretical study of P containing TRIP
steels. Z. Metallkd 92 (2001) 1299-1311
Q. Y. Sun, S. J. Song, R. H. Zhu and H. C. Gu, Journal of Materials Science
37, 2543 (2002) “Toughening of Titanium Alloys by Twinning and Martensite
Transformation”
J. D. Cotton, J. F. Bingert, P. S. Dunn and R. A. Patterson, Metallurgical and
Materials Transactions A 25A, 461 (1994) “Microstructure and Mechanical
Properties of Ti-40wt Pct Ta
O. M. Ivasishin and R. V. Teliovich, J. Phys. IV 11 (Pr4), 165 (2001)
“Transformation Plasticity in Titatnium Alpha Double Prime Martensite”