Racial Wealth Inequality: Myths, Realities, and What Can be Done About It Workshop
1. Racial Wealth
Inequality:
Myths, Realities and
What Can be Done
About it
FUNKE ADERONMU
BILL EMERSON NATIONAL HUNGER FELLOW
RESULTS/CONGRESSIONAL HUNGER CENTER
JUNE 6, 2018
2. Intro Hosted by Congressional Hunger Center
Hunger Fellows:
โข Tackle U.S. hunger and poverty at local and
national levels
โข Bridge field experiences with policy work
โข Develop racial justice lens in anti-hunger and
anti-poverty work
โข Build leadership capacity
Field Placement - DC Greens
Policy Placement - RESULTS Educational Fund
24th Class Emerson National Hunger
Fellow
โa social justice program that trains,
inspires, and sustains leaders. Fellows
gain field experience fighting hunger
and poverty through placements in
community based organizations across
the country, and policy
experience through placements in
Washington, D.C. โ
4. Understanding
Wealth
Wealth is...
THE FOUNDATION OF ECONOMIC WELLBEING
"Parental wealth, in addition to parent income,
plays an important role in college attendance and
graduation...Parental wealth is also a critical
determinant of where children live and the quality
of schools they attend. It can affect the kind of job
they have, if and when they marry, and whether
they own their homes."
- Christina Gibson-Davis, professor of public policy at Duke;
Christine Percheski, professor of sociology at Northwestern
5. Wealth and Race
in America
In 2016, white
families on average
had 7 times more
wealth than black
families and 5
times more wealth
than Hispanic
families
- Urban Institute, "Nine Charts About Wealth Inequality in
America."
12. About the AAPI
Community
โขWhile AAPI incomes may
be high overall, there's a
lot of variation in wealth
and economic wellbeing
once you dig deeper
(disaggregate the data)
โขThus, wealth inequality
also negatively impacts
AAPI households
14. How Did We
Get Here?
The History
Behind the
Racial
Wealth Gap
"the racial wealth divide is
the natural byproduct of an
endless series of policy
choices that have boosted
the ability of white
Americans to build long-
term wealth, while blocking
communities of color from
doing the same."
- Prosperity Now, "Running in Place: Why the Racial
Wealth Divide Keeps Black and Latino Families From
Achieving Economic Security"
15. Policies that
Created Racial
Wealth
Inequality
1865
Land Reversals
(1865) and
Land Seizures
(1865-Present
Day)
1934
National
Housing Act
1935
Social Security
Act
1938
Fair Labor
Standards Act
1944
G.I. Bill
1970s-
Present
Subprime
Loans (1970s-
Present Day
1971-Present
"War on
Drugs" (1971-
Present Day)
- Bread For the World Racial Wealth Gap
Simulation Policy Packet
16. Housing and Racial
Wealth Inequality
Housing is a major source of wealth for many
middle class Americans and remains a common
path to wealth building
Where you live has implications for health,
education, job access and security outcomes
that all affect overall economic well being
The history of housing policy in the U.S. has
been one where federal policies provided white
Americans opportunities to build wealth while
excluding Americans of color, particularly blacks
from doing the same.
19. Racial Wealth Inequality
and the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs
Act
Benefits mainly go to high-income households. Given
our nation's history of racial economic discrimination,
white families will largely benefit more than families
of color
The law primarily benefits holders of existing wealth
rather than creators of new wealth. This will likely
exacerbate racial wealth inequality
Due to limits on state and local deductions, state
gov'ts will increase fines and fees to gain revenue. This
is regressive and disproportionately impacts low-
income individuals and people of color
Cuts to public sector and public employment due to
tax law will impose burden on black workers and black
communities
21. What Will it Take to Close the Racial
Wealth Gap?
Myths About Closing Racial Wealth Gap
More educational attainment by blacks will close the gap
Homeownership disparities drives racial wealth gap
Buying and banking black will close the gap
Black families saving more will close the gap
Greater financial literacy in the black community will close the gap
Entrepreneurship will close the gap
Emulating โmodel minoritiesโ will close the gap
Improved โsoft skillsโ and โpersonal responsibilityโ will close racial wealth gap
The rise of black celebrities proves the racial wealth gap is closing
Black family disorganization is a cause of the racial wealth gap
22. What Will it
Take to Close
the Racial
Wealth Gap?
"Addressing racial wealth
inequality will require a major
redistributive effort or another
major public policy
intervention to build black [and
brown] American wealth."
23. What Will it Take to
Close the Racial
Wealth Gap?
โขAsses ways in which current federal
policies continue to perpetuate
racial wealth inequality
โขFix upside-down tax incentives that
primarily benefit the wealthy, to
ensure low-income and households
of color receive support to build
wealth
โขUse progressive taxation to address
the distorting influence of
concentrated wealth at the top
24. What Will it Take to Close the Racial
Wealth Gap?
โขThere is no single policy that can fully address the racial wealth divide
โขWe need a multifaceted approach
Policyโ IASP Audit: Reduction of Black-White Wealth Gapโ
Student Loan Forgiveness for Low-Income Familiesโ 7 percentโ
Student Loan Forgiveness for Low-Wealth Familiesโ 37 percentโ
Student Loan Forgiveness for Everyoneโ WORSEโ
Equalize Homeownership Ratesโ 31 percentโ
Equalize College Graduation Ratesโ 1-3 percentโ
End Income Inequalityโ 9-11 percentโ
Universal Savings Accounts at birth, with additional depositsโ 20-80 percentโ
25. Whatโs Your
Role in Tackling
Racial Wealth
Inequality?
โข Racial Wealth Divide Simulation
โข Available at
bread.org/simulation
Educate yourself!
โข Join advocacy organizations
likeโฆRESULTS!
Get Involved!
26. What is RESULTS?
RESULTS is movement of passionate, committed everyday people.
Together they use their voices to influence political decisions that will
bring an end to poverty.
Grassroots Advocacy Model:
Influencing policy through Relationship Building and Storytelling
28. Storytelling
Experts on Poverty program
Media trainings
โWithout SNAP, Iโd be on the cusp of
homelessness. With SNAP, Iโm on the cusp
of law school.โ - Asia Bijan Thompson,
RESULTS Expert on Poverty
29. RESULTS
International
Conference!
July 14-17th | Washington, DC
Speakers include: World Bank
President, Members of Congress,
City Officials, Activists, Writers and
more!
15+ workshops and plenaries
including a session on Running for
Office
Connect with peers and anti-poverty
advocates from across the country
Lobby Day on Capitol Hill
Register at: resultsconference.org
SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE!
Demonstrate links between wealth and housing, education, health, etc. Take graphics from AmeriCorps presentation.
Demonstrate links between wealth and housing, education, health, etc. Take graphics from AmeriCorps presentation.
Draw from AmeriCorps presentation
Whatโs the state of wealth inequality in America?
Perhaps set the frame for understanding that wealthy inequality in America is very much tied to racial economic inequality
A history of policies that have created a legacy of inequality dating back to slaveryย
Pick policies that relate to factors driving the wealth inequality; look into bread for the world racial simulation policy packet and summarize laws
Insert graphic from opportunity starts at home campaign about links between housing and other outcomes
Include time for thoughts/initial reactions after video
How the tax code subsidizes wealth building by the wealthy (Upside Down)ย
Impact of 2017 tax lawย
"Blacks cannot close the racial wealth gap by changing their individual behavior...if the structural sources of racial inequality remain unchanged."
List recommendations from Prosperity Nowโs ever growing gap report
Draw information from AmeriCorps presentation
Why relationship building and storytelling?