Impact and risk assessment of biotechnological alterations on agriculture.Also discusses the biasness towards other similar practices and its disparagement.
Discovery of an Accretion Streamer and a Slow Wide-angle Outflow around FUOri...
Agricultural Biotechnology
1. What is AgriculturalWhat is Agricultural
Biotechnology ?Biotechnology ?
Unmodified DNA
Gene of
Interest
Promoter
Gene
Marker
Gene
Transgenic organism
2. What are the Goals of
Biotech?
Single-genetransfer
Single-genetransfer
GeneGene
silencingsilencing
Multi-genetransfer
Multi-genetransfer
Modifying
gene
expression
Yield
Nutrition
Pest
protection
Rx
Drugs
Hardier
plants
Industrial
products
4. Adoption
of GM Crops
Soybeans – more than 74 %
Corn – about 32 %
Cotton – more than 71 %
Sweet corn – less than 5 %
Potato – dropped due to poor
sales
Why are some popular, others
not ?
5. So, why is biotechnology
in agriculture so
controversial ?
Why are other types of
biotechnology not as
controversial ?
6. Biotechnology, Consumers, &Biotechnology, Consumers, &
the Environmentthe Environment
Some oppose biotech because theySome oppose biotech because they
believe it poses an unacceptablebelieve it poses an unacceptable
environmental riskenvironmental risk
Others believe that it may be theOthers believe that it may be the
solution to some importantsolution to some important
environmental/agricultural problemsenvironmental/agricultural problems
7. Production Issues in AgricultureProduction Issues in Agriculture
Over use of pesticidesOver use of pesticides
Fertilizers leaching into water suppliesFertilizers leaching into water supplies
Soil erosionSoil erosion
Microbial contamination and food safetyMicrobial contamination and food safety
Disposal of animal waste at large facilitiesDisposal of animal waste at large facilities
Poor nutrition and unhealthy foodsPoor nutrition and unhealthy foods
Crops not adapted for diverse environmentsCrops not adapted for diverse environments
8. What are the PotentialWhat are the Potential
Environmental Risks ?Environmental Risks ?
Herbicide resistanceHerbicide resistance
Super weedsSuper weeds
Gene escapeGene escape
Effect on non-targetsEffect on non-targets
Insect resistance &Insect resistance & refugiarefugia
‘‘GMO pollution’ of organic productionGMO pollution’ of organic production
Biodiversity reductionBiodiversity reduction
Antibiotic marker genesAntibiotic marker genes
9. What are the PotentialWhat are the Potential
Environmental Benefits ?Environmental Benefits ?
Insect and disease controlInsect and disease control
Reduced pesticide usageReduced pesticide usage
Effects on non-targetsEffects on non-targets
Increased yieldsIncreased yields
Crops for marginal lands
Reduced animal waste
Reduced soil erosion
Less microbial contamination of foodsLess microbial contamination of foods
10. RiskRisk
AssessmentAssessment
•ScientistsScientists rate nuclear power as fairly safe;rate nuclear power as fairly safe;
lay peoplelay people are horrified by it.are horrified by it.
• ScientistsScientists think X-rays are moderately dangerousthink X-rays are moderately dangerous
lay peoplelay people aren't so worried.aren't so worried.
• ScientistsScientists rate swimming as rather hazardous;rate swimming as rather hazardous;
lay peoplelay people consider it rather harmless.consider it rather harmless.
11. RiskRisk
AssessmentAssessment
• Natural risks are less scary
Nuclear energy vs. radon gas
• Risks imposed on us seem worse
Nuclear energy vs. swimming
•Risks associated with complex technologies
and catastrophes are greater
Nuclear energy vs. car accidents
•Risks with an obvious benefit are less
daunting
Editor's Notes
This slides illustrates the basic concept of we will discuss in this presentation. Agricultural biotechnology means different things to different people.
Many of the current ag biotech crops on the market have been modified with a single gene of interest. This could be a gene that controls the production of a vitamin, an enzyme, or a protein that protects the plant from insect attack.
But to add this new gene, plant scientists have also added two additional genes, a promoter gene and a marker gene. The promoter gene controls when and where in the plant that the gene of interest is used. The marker gene helps scientists and plant breeders know which plants have been modified.
Each of these genes may come from different organisms, the promoter may come from a virus, the gene of interest from a bacteria, and the marker from a plant.
These three genes are inserted randomly into the genetic material of the plant as a unit.
Plant scientists use various biotech techniques to modify plants. They may add a single gene of interest, as they have with many of the products on the market. We soon may see plants that have been modified with traits that are require multiple genes.
Another tools used by plant scientists is gene silencing. Rather than adding traits to a plant, the expression of a particular is shut down.
In the future, rather than simply adding or removing genes, scientists hope to be able to more precisely control gene expression within plants.
The are a large number of products of agricultural biotechnology in the marketplace. I have divided these into two groups. The first group being those agricultural and pharmaceutical products in which the production process and been modified using biotechnology. Although these products are derived through biotechnology, they differ from the other group in that they are produced in a controlled environment. Because of that, environmental issues have not been a concern.
However, the second group represents that agricultural crops that have been modified using biotechnology and grown on commercial farms. With these crops, they have been some environmental concerns that have been raised.
The adoption of biotech agricultural products has been rapid with some crops, slow with others. In the US, soybean and cotton and cotton producers have adopted biotechnology to the greatest extent. With soybeans this has been due to the success of Roundup Ready technology and with cotton it has been Bt cotton and Roundup Ready cotton.
Only about a third of the corn market is using biotech hybrids. This includes Bt corn, Roundup Ready corn, and Liberty Link corn.
Bt sweet corn only represents a small fraction of the sweet corn market. Bt potatoes were on the market for several years, but have been dropped due to diminished markets.
If we ignore biotechnology for a minute and look at agriculture in general, there are many environmental issues that need to be addressed with sustainable solutions.
For example, everyone would agree that we need to eliminate unnecessary and over use of broad-spectrum pesticides. In the past, IPM has helped to do just that.
There have been several concerns raised about potential environmental risks posed by certain biotech crops.
In this slide the risks and the science-based assessments are discussed.
It is important to keep in mind that when risks are identified, then strategies must be developed to managed those risks. For example, if antibiotic marker genes are found to be a risk, then replacing those with other types of marker genes may be the best method to manage the risk. With Bt crops and insect resistance, resistance management plans involving minimum, structured, crops refuges are used to prevent or delay the development of resistance.
There are also many potential environmental benefits that may result from the use of agricultural biotechnology. These may help to address some of the issues confronting production agriculture.