SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 46
Case Study: Multiple Categories Sourcing
Project Review, Shanghai, Oct. 25th 2013
Dragon Sourcing - 龙
ęŗYour Tailored Sourcing Approach to LCC Sourcing
Time schedule for all categories
-The time schedule is finalized according to the last conference call on 30-Sep.
Today
Process before
audit
Finalized audit
week
National Holiday
2Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
No. Category 22-Jul 29-Jul 5-Aug 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec
1 Engineering
service
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8
2 Construction
service
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17 W18 W19
3 Pipelines W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15
4 Tank W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11
5 Automation W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11
6 Utilities-
Electrical parts
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17
Utilities-
Mechanical parts
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14
7 Part of production
line
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12
Introduction of DS team for this project
Vivian Xu
client Account Manager
In charge of construction service
and part of production line
Richard Laub DS CEO
Olivier Levy
DS Managing Director
Vivian Xu
client Account Manager
Cardboard Packaging Capex
Sara Deng Category
Buying Engineering
Vivian Xu
client Account Manager
Burke Gu Buying
Analyst
William Gu Category
Buying Engineer
In charge of utilities mechanical,
electrical and automation
In charge of pipelines and
tank
3Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Agenda
4Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- On going
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Steps Approach
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8
22-Jul 29-Jul 5-Aug 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep
1 Collect detailed technical information
2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to include in the RFI process
3
Develop the RFI ā€“ jointly with client ā€“ to include all key supplier qualification
criteria (e.g.: financial, related experience , company certificate, CV of the
main persons of the project)
4
Administration and chasing for completion of an NDA with suppliers that have
been preselected
5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as
6
Analyze responses based on qualitative criteria and using a balance score
card and recommend suppliers which client needs to take through a formal
qualification process
7
Carry out interview with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist:
ā€¢Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification interview
ā€¢Option 2: client carries out qualification interview
ā€¢Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by
client interview with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing
8 Support contract negotiations between client and qualified suppliers
Time schedule for engineering service
-The whole process is on schedule, 6 suppliers visited by client with DS
MilestonesAudit weekProcess before audit5
Today
Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Indentified suppliersā€™ status for engineering service
6 suppliers were visited from Sep.4th to Sep.11th
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
Intend to
respond
RFI
received
Selected
for
interview
Negotiate
contract
NDA sent
Number of suppliers initially identified
25
Number of suppliers NDA sent
25
Number of supplier decline to sign
8
Number of suppliers intend to sign
0
Number of suppliers signed
15
Number of suppliers RFI sent
15
Number of suppliers internal checking
2
-2 suppliers donā€™t agree
the items in the NDA
-2 supplier think the
NDA is too complicated,
-4 suppliers give up the
project finally
Number of suppliers intend to respond
14
Number of suppliers RFI received
14
Number of suppliers decline to respond
1
Number of suppliers strong recommend to interview
4
Number of suppliers can be interviewed
6
Number of suppliers finally select to interview
6
6Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Score card analysis for engineering service company after adjusted by client
Average 67
5 suppliers client already
interviewed before the
project
6 suppliers client
visited with DS
7Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
# Country Supplier
Name
Company
Background
Project
related
Company
Qualification
Cooperation Total Rank by
client
adjusted
score card
Rank by
original
score card
30% 40% 20% 10% max score
100
1 Local Supplier 1 30 39 17 10 96 1 1
2 Foreign Suppleir 2 29 37 15 10 91 2 2
3 Local Suppleir 3 22 36 14 10 82 3 3
4 Foreign Suppleir 4 27 28 13 10 78 4 4
5 Foreign Suppleir 5 19 32 16 9 75 5 5
6 Foreign Suppleir 6 16 37 12 10 75 5 6
7 Foreign Suppleir 7 19 37 9 10 75 5 6
8 Foreign Suppleir 8 26 35 4 9 73 6 6
9 Foreign Suppleir 9 19 34 8 10 71 7 7
10 Foreign Suppleir 10 20 37 6 7 70 8 9
11 Foreign Suppleir 11 30 22 6 9 67 9 9
12 Foreign Suppleir 12 13 35 9 10 67 9 10
13 Local Suppleir 13 26 20 13 7 65 10 8
14 Foreign Suppleir 14 19 22 6 10 57 11 13
15 Local Suppleir 15 19 27 3 7 56 12 12
16 Foreign Suppleir 16 22 20 7 7 55 13 11
17 Local Suppleir 17 19 21 7 4 50 14 14
18 Local Suppleir 18 15 13 8 7 42 15 15
19 Foreign Suppleir 19 13 12 5 5 34 16 16
Audit results for 6 engineering service suppliers
8Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Date Time Supplier to be
visited
Agenda Recommended level after
audit
Attendee
4-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank
No.8)
Visit project site XXX
Afternoon Visit supplier office and do interview
5-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank
No.10)
Visit supplier office and do interview
Afternoon Visit project site
6-Sep-13 Morning xxx
(Rank No.5)
Visit supplier office and do interview
Afternoon Visit project site
9-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank
No.13)
Visit supplier office and do interview XXX
Afternoon
Visit project site
10-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank
No.14)
Visit supplier office and do interview XXX
Afternoon Visit project site)
11-Sep-13 Morning xxx
(Rank No.1)
Visit supplier office and do interview
Visit project site
Afternoon
Immediate next steps
Actions
9Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. client will inform DS the audit results for the
engineering service and DS will prepare thank
you lettter to the suppliers who have not been
selected
client/DS 11-
Oct
Agenda
10Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- On going
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Steps Approach
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17 W18 W19 W20
22- 29- 5- 12- 19- 26- 2- 9- 16- 23- 30-
Jul Jul Aug Aug Aug Aug Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep
7-Oct
14- 21- 28-
Oct Oct Oct
4-Nov
11- 18- 25-
Nov Nov
Nov
2-Dec
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l i
d
a
y
2
Identify list of potential suppliers around
Shanghai to include in the RFI process
3
Develop the RFI ā€“ jointly with client ā€“ to include all
key supplier qualification criteria (e.g.: financial,
related experience , company certificate, CV of the
main persons of the project)
4
Administration and chasing for completion of
an NDA with suppliers that have been
preselected
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high
a return rate as
6
Analyze responses based on qualitative criteria
and using a balance score card and
recommend suppliers which client needs to take
through a formal qualification process
7
Carry out interview with pre-selected suppliers.
3 options exist:
ā€¢Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out
qualification interview
ā€¢Option 2: client carries out qualification interview
ā€¢Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial
qualification process followed by client interview
with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing
Time schedule for construction service
-Next week we will contact the supplier who declined the project before due to the
location problem and continue the RFI administration and NDA process
Toda
yProcess before audit Original audit week MilestonesDays base approach11Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Indentified suppliersā€™ status for construction service
-6 RFIs are received so far including 2 EPCM company xxx and xxx
Number of suppliers initially identified
Construction company: 34
Number of suppliers NDA sent
13
Number of suppliers pending to sent NDA
6
Number of suppliers decline the project
15
Number of suppliers signed
6
Number of suppliers intend to sign
0
Number of suppliers internal checking
1
Number of supplier decline to sign
6
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
Intend to
respond
RFI
received
Selected
for
interview
Negotiate
contract
NDA sent
Number of suppliers initially identified
EOCM company: 17
Number of suppliers RFI sent
6
Number of suppliers RFI intend to respond
5
Number of suppliers RFI received
5
Number of suppliers RFI received
2 (xxx , xxx)
Number of suppliers RFI not intend to respond
1
Remark:
Double check with these supplier if they
are interested in the project
12Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Score card analysis for construction service company
-7 suppliersā€™ RFI are analyzed by score card, the average score is 76 points, 3
suppliersā€™ score are over 80 points, 1 supplierā€™s score is over 90 points
Remark:
Supplier No.5 and
No.6 are EPCM
companies
Average 76
92
84 83 81
66 66
58
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Cooperation
Company
Qualification
Project related
Company
Background
Total
13Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
# Country Supplier Name Company
Background
Project
related
Company
Qualification
Cooperation Total Rank by
score card
30% 40% 20% 10% max score 100
1 Local Supplier 1 28 36 18 10 92 1
2 Local Supplier 2 26 33 18 7 84 2
3 Local Supplier 3 20 34 20 9 83 3
4 Local Supplier 4 20 36 18 7 81 4
5 Local Supplier 5 19 25 13 10 66 5
6 foreign Supplier 6 16 24 16 10 66 5
7 Local Supplier 7 23 16 12 7 58 7
Suppliers recommend to interview according to the score card and filled RFI
- 4 suppliers are recommended to the interview stage
14Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Country Supplier
name
City Province Score card
ranking
Strength weakness
China Xxx Shanghai Shanghai 1 -Good company capability
-Big construction group in China
-Has a lot of experience in food industry
-Full certificate
-Has experience in Hangzhou
but not in Xiaoshan
China xxx Hangzhou Zhejiang 2 -Good company capability
-Big construction group in China
-Has a lot of experience in food industry
-Full certificate
-English skill is not good
China xxx Qidong Jiangsu 3 -Acceptable company capability
-Full certificate
-Good English skill
-Middle size construction
company
China xxx Shanghai Shanghai 4 -Acceptable company back ground
-Full certificate
-Has a lot of experience in food industry
-English skill is not good
-Middle size construction
company
Immediate next steps
Actions
15Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Re-contact the suppliers reject the project before
and collect NDA and RFI
DS 14-Nov
2. RFI analysis and recommend suppliers for audit DS 22-Nov
3. Finalize suppliers for aduit client/DS 25-Nov
Agenda
16Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- On going
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Demand analysis
17Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Tube TT straight length 4m / DN 65 Tube TT curve 90Ā° / DN 65 Tube TT tee standard / DN 65
Material: AISI 304, Weight: 56.95kg, Quantity: 800m Material: AISI 304, Weight: 12.67kg, Quantity: 300pcs Material: AISI 304, Weight: 18.41kg,Quantity: 150pcs
Tube TT straight length 4m / DN 150 Tube TT curve 90Ā° / DN 150 Tube TT tee standard / DN 150b
Material: AISI 304, Weight: 27.57kg, Quantity: 800m Material: AISI 304, Weight: 34.18kg, Quantity: 300pcs Material: AISI 304, Weight: 48.38kg, Quantity: 150pcs
Steps Approach
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15
12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l i
d
a
y
2
Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-
screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers
based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per
category with these criteria to be provided by client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to
include all key supplier qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a
return rate as possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card and
recommend suppliers which client needs to the
RFQ process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process
8
Analyze RFQ responses by score card and
recommend suppliers with client for audit
9
Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3
options exist:
Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification
audits
Option 2: client carries out qualification audits
Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial
qualification process followed by client audit with
suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing
Time schedule for pipelines
Next week we will push the suppliers who havenā€™t replied the RFI and provide the RFI analysis
result by score card
TodaProcess before audit 18 Original audit week MilestonesCurrent audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for pipelines
-284 supplier identified initially, 90/284 suppliers go to pre-screening process, 36/90
suppliers who meet all criteria go to the RFI process, 14/36 suppliers have replied RFI
Number of suppliers initially identified
284
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
265
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
19
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
0
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
90
No. of suppliers declined the project
169
No. of suppliers need to double check
6
No. of suppliers RFI sent
36
No. of suppliers intend to respond
36
No. of suppliers not intend to respond
0
No. of suppliers need to further contact
0
No. of suppliers RFI received by DS
14
No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive
22
19Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
Actions
29Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for
RFQ process and NDA process
DS 31-Oct
2. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 11-Nov
3. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for
audit
DS 15-Nov
Agenda
21Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- On going
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Demand analysis
22Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Vessel 6.25 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 12.5 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 35 mĀ³
No pictures
Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: N/A,
Height: 5,310mm, Out diameter: 2,110 mm , 2~10pcs
Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 2,700kg,
Height; 5,635mm, Out diameter: 2,600 mm, 2~10pcs
Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 4,500kg
Height; 7,755mm, Out diameter: 3,000 mm, 2~10pcs
Vessel 35 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 120 mĀ³
Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 5,500kg
Height; 7,755mm, Out diameter: 3,000 mm, 2~10pcs
Material: AISI 304/304L, Weight: 12,000kg
Height; 12,000mm, Out diameter: 3,800 mm, 2~10pcs
Time schedule for tank
Pre-screening process has completed, next week we will start RFI administration process
Steps Approach
W1 W2
16-Sep 23-Sep
W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11
30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l
i
d
a
y
2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1)
maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to
be provided by client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key
supplier qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as
possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers
which client needs to the RFQ process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process
8
Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers
with client for audit
9
Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist:
Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option
2: client carries out qualification audits
Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process
followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon
Sourcing
Toda
y23 Original audit week MilestonesProcess before audit Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for tank
-83 suppliers identified, 51/83 go to the pre-screening process, 39/83 suppliers are selected
to the RFI process, 21/39 suppliers have replied RFI, 16/39 suppliers are pending to receive
Number of suppliers initially identified
83
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
78
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
5
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
0
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
51
No. of suppliers eliminated
27
No. of suppliers need to double check
0
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
Donā€™t produce what client need
No. of suppliers RFI sent
39
No. of suppliers intend to respond
37
No. of suppliers not intend to respond
2
No. of suppliers RFI received by DS
21
No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive
16
24Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps
25Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Actions Responsible Deadline Remarks
4. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 15-Nov
5. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers
for audit
DS 20-Nov
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
1. Administrate RFI process DS 31-Oct
2. Develop and finalize score card template DS 31-Oct
3. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ
process and NDA process
DS 4-Nov
Agenda
26Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- On going
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
8. Q & A
Time schedule for automation
We will continue telephone pre-screening process next week and develop RFI template
Steps Approach
W1 W2
16-Sep 23-Sep
W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11
30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l
i
d
a
y
2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1)
maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to
be provided by client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key
supplier qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as
possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers
which client needs to the RFQ process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process
8
Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers
with client for audit
9
Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist:
Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option
2: client carries out qualification audits
Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process
followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon
Sourcing
Toda
y27 Original audit week MilestonesProcess before audit Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for automation
-70 suppliers identified so far including the 13 utilities suppliers, 36/70 suppliers go to
the pre-screening process
Number of suppliers initially identified
Utilities: 13 Automation: 57
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
Utilities: 13 Automation: 57
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
0
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
0
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
Utilities: 12 Automation: 25
No. of suppliers eliminated
Utilities: 1 Automation: 32
No. of suppliers need to double check
0
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
ļƒ˜Utilities:
-7 suppliers only do electrical related
-3 suppliers only do mechanical related
-3 supplier do whole process
ļƒ˜Automation:
-4 suppliers only do utilities related
-3 suppliers do production or process related
-17 suppliers do whole process
28Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps
Actions
29Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Telephone pre-screening
process
DS 31-Oct
2. Prepare RFI-RFQ template and validate RFI-RFQ
template
client/DS 31-Oct
3. Administrate RFI process DS 31-Oct
4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 5-Nov
5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for
RFQ process and NDA process
DS 7-Nov
6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 15-Nov
7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for
audit
DS 20-Nov
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
Agenda
30Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- Not started yet
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Demand analysis-utility (electrical parts)
31Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
MV switchgear LV switchboard transformer
UPS Diesel Generator
Step
s
Approach
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13
12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-
Nov
W14 W15 W16 W17
11- 18- 25-
Nov Nov
Nov
2-Dec
1 Collect detailed technical
information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l i
d
a
y
2
Identify list of potential suppliers
in China to pre-screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of
the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-
5 screening criteria per category with
these criteria to be provided by client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with
clientā€“ to include all key supplier
qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to
ensure as high a return rate as
possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card
and recommend suppliers which client
needs to the RFQ process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA
process
Analyze RFQ responses by score card
8 and recommend
suppliers with client for audit
9
Carry out audits with pre-selected
suppliers. 3 options exist:
Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out
qualification audits
Option 2: client carries out qualification
audits
Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out
initial qualification process followed by
client audit with suppliers
recommended by Dragon Sourcing
Time schedule for utilities-electrical parts
Next week we will push the suppliers who havenā€™t replied the RFI and provide the RFI
analysis result by score card
Toda
y
Process before audit 32 Original audit week MilestonesCurrent audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for utilities-electrical parts
-223 equipment suppliers and 23 installation suppliers initially identified, 64/223
equipments suppliers have been sent RFI, 37/64 suppliers replied RFI, 19/64 suppliers
are pending to receive
Number of suppliers initially identified
Equipment: 223 Installation: 23
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
Equipment: 223 Installation:23
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
0
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
0
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
Equipment: 87 Installation:8
No. of suppliers eliminated
Equipment: 136 Installation:13
No. of suppliers need to double check
Equipment: 0 Installation:6
No. of suppliers RFI sent
Equipment: 64 Installation: 8
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
-These 37 suppliers are selected according to
the results of the pre-screening process
-18 suppliers belong to group 1: switchgear &
switchboard & transformer suppliers
-6 suppliers belong to group 2: UPS suppliers
-13 suppliers belong to group 3: diesel
generator suppliers
No. of suppliers intend to respond
56
No. of suppliers not intend to respond
8
No. of suppliers need to further contact
0
No. of suppliers RFI received by DS
37
No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive
19
-8 suppliers belong to group 1: switchgear &
switchboard & transformer suppliers
-4 suppliers belong to group 2: UPS suppliers
-7 suppliers belong to group 3: diesel generator
suppliers
33Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps-electrical parts
Actions
34Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for
RFQ process and NDA process
DS 31-Oct
2. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 22-Nov
3. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for
audit
DS 26-Nov
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
Demand analysis-utility (mechanical parts)
35Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Chiller Cooling tower for chillers AHU Compressed air and dryer
-Chiller, (6/11Ā°C) each 2,5 MW cooling capacity, watercooled, 3 pcs
-Chiller, (-5/0Ā°C) each 0,7 MW cooling capacity, watercooled, 2 pcs
-Chiller, (-3/2Ā°C) each 1,0 MW cooling capacity, warehouse, 2 ps
-(30/35Ā°C), each 2 MW capacity- for
chillers
-8 pcs
-airflow 50.000 m3/h
-30 pcs
-compressors (8 bar)
aircooled, each 30 m3/min
capacity
-2 pcs
Pumps for cold and hot water Heat exchanger
-Total 40 pcs -steam/hotwater (60/50Ā°C)
each 1,5 MW heating capacity
-4 pcs
Time schedule for utilities-mechanical parts
Next week we will continue the telephone pre-screening process and start RFI administration
process for some items
Steps Approach
W1 W2 W3 W4 W5
9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct
W6 W7 W8
14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct
W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14
4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l i
d
a
y
2
Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-
screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers
based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per
category with these criteria to be provided by
client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to
include all key supplier qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a
return rate as possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card and
recommend suppliers which client needs to the
RFQ process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process
8
Analyze RFQ responses by score card and
recommend suppliers with client for audit
9 Carry out supplier audit
Toda
36 MilestonesProcess before audit Original audit week Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for utilities-mechanical parts
-409 equipment suppliers identified so far, 336/409 suppliers contacted, 73/409 suppliers
pending to contact, 116/336 suppliers go to pre-screening process, 75/336 suppliers need
further contact, 145/336 suppliers eliminated from the process
Number of suppliers initially identified
Equipment: 409
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
Equipment: 336
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
0
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
Equipment: 73
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
Equipment: 116
No. of suppliers eliminated
Equipment: 145
No. of suppliers need to double check
Equipment: 75
Main reasons are suppliers
canā€™t meet requirements or
donā€™t produce want we want
-Chiller & AHU : 71 suppliers
-Cooling tower: 25 suppliers
-Heat exchange: 9 suppliers
-Pump: 5 suppliers
-Air compressor: 6 suppliers
-Cooling tower: 26 suppliers
-Heat exchange: 4 suppliers
-Pump: 45 suppliers
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
37Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps-mechanical parts
Actions
38Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Telephone pre-screening process for pump
and valve
DS 31-Oct
2. Analyze pre-screening results and finalize list for
RFI process
client/DS 31-Oct
3. Administrate RFI process DS 8-Nov
4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 8-Nov
5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for
RFQ process and NDA process
DS 14-Nov
6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 29-Nov
7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for
audit
DS 4-Dec
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
Agenda
39Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
1. Engineering service- Finished
2. Construction service- On going
3. Pipelines- On going
4. Tank- On going
5. Automation- Not started yet
6. Utilities- On going
7. Part of production line-On going
Demand analysis- equipments for part of the production line
40Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Pump Air Dryer Root type blower
Mixer Refining system Cooling system-tempering machine
Demand analysis- equipments for part of the production line
41Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Pressure vessel Roaster Valves
Demand analysis- part of the production line
Conveyor belt
42Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Demand analysis- part of the production line
In pusher chain
43Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Time schedule for part of production line
We will continue pre-screening process and develop the RFI
Steps Approach
W1 W2 W3
23-Sep 30-Sep 7-
Oct
W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10
11-Nov 18-Nov 25-
Nov
W11 W12
14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec
1 Collect detailed technical information
N
a
t i
o
n
a
l
H
o
l i
d
a
y
2
Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-
screening process
3
Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers
based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per
category with these criteria to be provided by client
4
Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include
all key supplier qualification criteria
5
Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return
rate as possible
6
Analyze RFI responses by score card and
recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ
process
7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process
8
Analyze RFQ responses by score card and
recommend suppliers with client for audit
9 Carry out audit
Toda
44 MilestonesProcess before audit Original audit week Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Status of identified suppliers for part of production line
-248 suppliers have been identified so far, including 198 equipment suppliers and 50
production line suppliers
Number of suppliers initially identified
Equipment: 293 Production line: 50
Supplier
indentified
RFI sent
NDA sent
RFQ
sent
Selected for
audit
Selected for
sample
Negotiate
contract
Telphone
screening
No. of suppliers successfully contacted
Equipment: 63 Production line: 33
No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted
Equipment: 0 Production line: 0
No. of suppliers not contacted yet
Equipment: 230 Production line: 17
No. of suppliers go to pre-screening
Equipment: 63 Production line: 5
No. of suppliers eliminated
Equipment: 0 Production line: 0
No. of suppliers need to double check
Equipment: 0 Production line: 28
Remark:
Supplier number for equipments:
-Air dryer : 41 suppliers
-Tempering machine: 17
suppliers
-Pump: 41 suppliers
-Refining machine: 22 suppliers
-Mixer: 17 suppliers
-Blower: 50 suppliers
-Roaster: 10 suppliers
-Valve: 95 suppliers
45Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Next Steps-mechanical parts
Actions
46Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
Responsible Deadline Remarks
1. Telephone pre-screening
process
DS 31-Oct
2. Analyze pre-screening results and finalize list for
RFI process
client/DS 31-Oct
3. Administrate RFI process DS 15-Nov
4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 15-Nov
5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for
RFQ process and NDA process
DS 19-Nov
6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 29-Nov
7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for
audit
DS 4-Dec
Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule.
The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.

More Related Content

What's hot

Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingTapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015Hermann Zapletal
Ā 
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingDoor Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZ
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZQA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZ
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZKhurram hafeeez
Ā 
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launch
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launchDragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launch
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launchDragon Sourcing
Ā 
AKSHAY BOGS CV
AKSHAY BOGS CVAKSHAY BOGS CV
AKSHAY BOGS CVAKSHAY M
Ā 
Case study on PE film global sourcing
Case study on PE film global sourcingCase study on PE film global sourcing
Case study on PE film global sourcingDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPING
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPINGCurriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPING
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPINGramon carcido
Ā 
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case study
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case studyIron Cast and Machined Components Case study
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case studyDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Vijay konathala Resume
Vijay konathala ResumeVijay konathala Resume
Vijay konathala Resumevijay kumar
Ā 
Steel structural parts case study
Steel structural parts case studySteel structural parts case study
Steel structural parts case studyDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon Sourcing
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon SourcingWind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon Sourcing
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon SourcingDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Case Study-Investment casting sourcing
Case Study-Investment casting sourcingCase Study-Investment casting sourcing
Case Study-Investment casting sourcingJohn William
Ā 
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector Resume
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector ResumeAramco Approved Welding Inspector Resume
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector ResumeRobin Parayil
Ā 
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015Kevin Rhodes
Ā 
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingDecorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 

What's hot (20)

Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingTapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Tapioca Starch Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015
Hermann Zapletal - Resume 2015
Ā 
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingDoor Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Door Hardware Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZ
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZQA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZ
QA_QC PAINTING & COATING INSPECTOR - KHURRAM HAFEEZ
Ā 
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launch
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launchDragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launch
Dragon Sourcing case study Supporting New Factory launch
Ā 
AKSHAY BOGS CV
AKSHAY BOGS CVAKSHAY BOGS CV
AKSHAY BOGS CV
Ā 
Resume_Anjanna
Resume_AnjannaResume_Anjanna
Resume_Anjanna
Ā 
Case study on PE film global sourcing
Case study on PE film global sourcingCase study on PE film global sourcing
Case study on PE film global sourcing
Ā 
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPING
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPINGCurriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPING
Curriculum VITA 2 COMPLETE PIPING
Ā 
kiruba new resume
kiruba new resumekiruba new resume
kiruba new resume
Ā 
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case study
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case studyIron Cast and Machined Components Case study
Iron Cast and Machined Components Case study
Ā 
Vijay konathala Resume
Vijay konathala ResumeVijay konathala Resume
Vijay konathala Resume
Ā 
Steel structural parts case study
Steel structural parts case studySteel structural parts case study
Steel structural parts case study
Ā 
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon Sourcing
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon SourcingWind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon Sourcing
Wind Turbine Components Case Study - Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Case Study-Investment casting sourcing
Case Study-Investment casting sourcingCase Study-Investment casting sourcing
Case Study-Investment casting sourcing
Ā 
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014
Wind Turbine Case Study - June, 2014
Ā 
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector Resume
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector ResumeAramco Approved Welding Inspector Resume
Aramco Approved Welding Inspector Resume
Ā 
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015
Kevin Lee RhodesResume` 2015
Ā 
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingDecorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Luminaire Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Antony_Joy_CV.DOC
Antony_Joy_CV.DOCAntony_Joy_CV.DOC
Antony_Joy_CV.DOC
Ā 

Similar to Case study-Multiple categories sourcing project review

Automotive Steel Component
Automotive Steel ComponentAutomotive Steel Component
Automotive Steel ComponentDragon Sourcing
Ā 
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare Parts
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare PartsChina Case Study MRO Electrical Spare Parts
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare PartsJohn William
Ā 
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€John William
Ā 
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon Sourcing
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon SourcingElectric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon Sourcing
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, Vietnam
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, VietnamStrategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, Vietnam
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, VietnamJohn William
Ā 
Case Study - Desalination Unit Project
Case Study - Desalination Unit ProjectCase Study - Desalination Unit Project
Case Study - Desalination Unit ProjectJohn William
Ā 
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingSubstation Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Toothbrush case study
Toothbrush case studyToothbrush case study
Toothbrush case studyDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...John William
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryStrategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryJohn William
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryStrategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances Market
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances MarketGlobal Sourcing Case study in Appliances Market
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances MarketDragon Sourcing
Ā 
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)John William
Ā 
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformation
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformationCase studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformation
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformationJohn William
Ā 
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformation
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformationCase Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformation
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformationJohn William
Ā 
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic Sourcing
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic SourcingCase Study-Indirect China Strategic Sourcing
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic SourcingJohn William
Ā 
CNC Parts Sourcing Case Study
CNC Parts Sourcing Case StudyCNC Parts Sourcing Case Study
CNC Parts Sourcing Case StudyJohn William
Ā 
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon SourcingCleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
RPWORLD for automotive.pdf
RPWORLD for automotive.pdfRPWORLD for automotive.pdf
RPWORLD for automotive.pdfzhanjim40
Ā 

Similar to Case study-Multiple categories sourcing project review (20)

Automotive Steel Component
Automotive Steel ComponentAutomotive Steel Component
Automotive Steel Component
Ā 
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare Parts
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare PartsChina Case Study MRO Electrical Spare Parts
China Case Study MRO Electrical Spare Parts
Ā 
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€
Case Study-New Plant Building ā€œCapex Sourcing in Chinaā€
Ā 
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon Sourcing
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon SourcingElectric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon Sourcing
Electric Motors and Iron Castings case study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, Vietnam
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, VietnamStrategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, Vietnam
Strategic Sourcing Case Study-White Goods sourcing in China, Turkey, Vietnam
Ā 
Case Study - Desalination Unit Project
Case Study - Desalination Unit ProjectCase Study - Desalination Unit Project
Case Study - Desalination Unit Project
Ā 
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingSubstation Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Substation Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Toothbrush case study
Toothbrush case studyToothbrush case study
Toothbrush case study
Ā 
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...
Case Study-Creating Value with an Outsourced International Purchasing Office ...
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryStrategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Ā 
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine IndustryStrategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Strategic Sourcing Case Study ā€“ Wind Turbine Industry
Ā 
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances Market
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances MarketGlobal Sourcing Case study in Appliances Market
Global Sourcing Case study in Appliances Market
Ā 
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)
Global Sourcing Case Study (Chinese Appliances Market)
Ā 
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformation
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformationCase studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformation
Case studies-Promotional supply optimization, procurement transformation
Ā 
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformation
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformationCase Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformation
Case Studies - Promotional supply optimization; procurement transformation
Ā 
Doc. RMD
Doc. RMDDoc. RMD
Doc. RMD
Ā 
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic Sourcing
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic SourcingCase Study-Indirect China Strategic Sourcing
Case Study-Indirect China Strategic Sourcing
Ā 
CNC Parts Sourcing Case Study
CNC Parts Sourcing Case StudyCNC Parts Sourcing Case Study
CNC Parts Sourcing Case Study
Ā 
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon SourcingCleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Cleaning Sponge Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
RPWORLD for automotive.pdf
RPWORLD for automotive.pdfRPWORLD for automotive.pdf
RPWORLD for automotive.pdf
Ā 

More from John William

Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief Study
Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief StudySanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief Study
Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief StudyJohn William
Ā 
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EU
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EUNewsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EU
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EUJohn William
Ā 
Newsletter on PPE
Newsletter on PPENewsletter on PPE
Newsletter on PPEJohn William
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Vietnam
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in VietnamStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Vietnam
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in VietnamJohn William
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Brazil
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in BrazilStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Brazil
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in BrazilJohn William
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Ethiopia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in EthiopiaStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Ethiopia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in EthiopiaJohn William
Ā 
Sourcing Opportunities in Malaysia
Sourcing Opportunities in MalaysiaSourcing Opportunities in Malaysia
Sourcing Opportunities in MalaysiaJohn William
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Pakistan
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in PakistanStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Pakistan
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in PakistanJohn William
Ā 
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South Africa
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South AfricaCase Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South Africa
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South AfricaJohn William
Ā 
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Myanmar
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in MyanmarCase Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Myanmar
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in MyanmarJohn William
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Indonesia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in IndonesiaStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Indonesia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in IndonesiaJohn William
Ā 
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingBattery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon SourcingDecorative Pots Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case Study
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case StudySafety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case Study
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case StudyJohn William
Ā 
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing  FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing John William
Ā 
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingWear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study John William
Ā 
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case Study
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case StudyCotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case Study
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case StudyJohn William
Ā 
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case Study
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case StudyNutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case Study
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case StudyJohn William
Ā 
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon SourcingPressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon SourcingJohn William
Ā 

More from John William (20)

Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief Study
Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief StudySanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief Study
Sanitizer & Disinfectants During COVID 19 ā€“ A Brief Study
Ā 
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EU
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EUNewsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EU
Newsletter on PPE: Classification of PPE and CE Certification Process in EU
Ā 
Newsletter on PPE
Newsletter on PPENewsletter on PPE
Newsletter on PPE
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Vietnam
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in VietnamStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Vietnam
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Vietnam
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Brazil
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in BrazilStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Brazil
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Brazil
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Ethiopia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in EthiopiaStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Ethiopia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Ethiopia
Ā 
Sourcing Opportunities in Malaysia
Sourcing Opportunities in MalaysiaSourcing Opportunities in Malaysia
Sourcing Opportunities in Malaysia
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Pakistan
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in PakistanStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Pakistan
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Pakistan
Ā 
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South Africa
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South AfricaCase Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South Africa
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in South Africa
Ā 
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Myanmar
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in MyanmarCase Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Myanmar
Case Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Myanmar
Ā 
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Indonesia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in IndonesiaStudy on Sourcing Opportunities in Indonesia
Study on Sourcing Opportunities in Indonesia
Ā 
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon SourcingBattery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Battery Sourcing Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon SourcingDecorative Pots Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Decorative Pots Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case Study
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case StudySafety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case Study
Safety Vest, Cotton Bags, College Bags Sourcing Project Case Study
Ā 
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing  FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
FAN Induction Motors Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon SourcingWear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Wear Plate Sourcing Project Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study
Glass Bottles and Glass Jars Sourcing Project Case Study
Ā 
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case Study
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case StudyCotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case Study
Cotton Bags for Luxury Retail Brand Case Study
Ā 
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case Study
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case StudyNutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case Study
Nutrition Product Manufacturers Sourcing in Indonesia Case Study
Ā 
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon SourcingPressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Pressure Vessle and Heat Exchanger Case Study by Dragon Sourcing
Ā 

Recently uploaded

KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA C
KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA CKAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA C
KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA CNiteshKumar82226
Ā 
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL G
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL GSURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL G
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL GNiteshKumar82226
Ā 
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near Me
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near MeCall Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near Me
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near MeIfra Zohaib
Ā 
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...aakahthapa70
Ā 
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALL
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALLNAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALL
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALLNiteshKumar82226
Ā 
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GI
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GIDIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GI
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GINiteshKumar82226
Ā 
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CAL
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CALRAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CAL
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CALNiteshKumar82226
Ā 
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579diyaspanoida
Ā 
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts ServiceCall Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts ServiceLipikasharma29
Ā 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579diyaspanoida
Ā 
Call US PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...
Call US  PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...Call US  PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...
Call US PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...Pooja Nehwal
Ā 
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...Sheetaleventcompany
Ā 
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...aakahthapa70
Ā 
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154NiteshKumar82226
Ā 
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”thapagita
Ā 
Russian Call Girls in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls in Goa By Russi...
Russian Call Girls  in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls  in Goa By Russi...Russian Call Girls  in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls  in Goa By Russi...
Russian Call Girls in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls in Goa By Russi...Goa Call Girls Service Goa escort agency
Ā 
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALL
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALLNASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALL
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALLNiteshKumar82226
Ā 
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe Noida
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe NoidaCall Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe Noida
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe NoidaDelhi Escorts Service
Ā 
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Availablenitugupta1209
Ā 

Recently uploaded (20)

KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA C
KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA CKAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA C
KAKINADA CALL GIRL 92628/71154 KAKINADA C
Ā 
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL G
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL GSURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL G
SURAT CALL GIRL 92628/71154 SURAT CALL G
Ā 
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near Me
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near MeCall Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near Me
Call Girls | šŸ˜šŸ’¦ 03274100048 | Call Girls Near Me
Ā 
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...
Call Girls In {Green Park Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girls...
Ā 
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALL
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALLNAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALL
NAGPUR CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NAGPUR CALL
Ā 
Goa Call Girls šŸ„° +91 9540619990 šŸ“Service Girls In Goa
Goa Call Girls šŸ„° +91 9540619990 šŸ“Service Girls In GoaGoa Call Girls šŸ„° +91 9540619990 šŸ“Service Girls In Goa
Goa Call Girls šŸ„° +91 9540619990 šŸ“Service Girls In Goa
Ā 
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GI
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GIDIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GI
DIGHA CALL GIRL 92628/1154 DIGHA CALL GI
Ā 
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CAL
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CALRAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CAL
RAJKOT CALL GIRLS 92628/71154 RAJKOT CAL
Ā 
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girl Noida Sector 48 Call Me: 8700611579
Ā 
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts ServiceCall Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Naraina (Delhi) +91-9667422720 Escorts Service
Ā 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 24 Call Me: 8700611579
Ā 
Call US PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...
Call US  PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...Call US  PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...
Call US PoojašŸ“ž 9892124323 āœ…Call Girls In Mira Road ( Mumbai ) secure service...
Ā 
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...
Call Girl Rohini ā¤ļø7065000506 Pooja@ Rohini Call Girls Near Me ā¤ļøā™€ļø@ Sexy Cal...
Ā 
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...
Call Girls In {Laxmi Nagar Delhi} 9667938988 Indian Russian High Profile Girl...
Ā 
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154
MYSORE CALL GIRLS ESCORT SER 92628/71154
Ā 
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”
Call Girls In Dwarka Delhi šŸ’ÆCall Us šŸ”9711014705šŸ”
Ā 
Russian Call Girls in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls in Goa By Russi...
Russian Call Girls  in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls  in Goa By Russi...Russian Call Girls  in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls  in Goa By Russi...
Russian Call Girls in Goa %(9316020077)# Russian Call Girls in Goa By Russi...
Ā 
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALL
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALLNASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALL
NASHIK CALL GIRL 92628*71154 NASHIK CALL
Ā 
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe Noida
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe NoidaCall Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe Noida
Call Girls In Sector 85 Noida 9711911712 Escorts ServiCe Noida
Ā 
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available
9811611494,Low Rate Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi 24hrs Available
Ā 

Case study-Multiple categories sourcing project review

  • 1. Case Study: Multiple Categories Sourcing Project Review, Shanghai, Oct. 25th 2013 Dragon Sourcing - 龙 ęŗYour Tailored Sourcing Approach to LCC Sourcing
  • 2. Time schedule for all categories -The time schedule is finalized according to the last conference call on 30-Sep. Today Process before audit Finalized audit week National Holiday 2Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. No. Category 22-Jul 29-Jul 5-Aug 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec 1 Engineering service W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 2 Construction service W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17 W18 W19 3 Pipelines W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 4 Tank W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 5 Automation W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 6 Utilities- Electrical parts W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17 Utilities- Mechanical parts W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 7 Part of production line W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12
  • 3. Introduction of DS team for this project Vivian Xu client Account Manager In charge of construction service and part of production line Richard Laub DS CEO Olivier Levy DS Managing Director Vivian Xu client Account Manager Cardboard Packaging Capex Sara Deng Category Buying Engineering Vivian Xu client Account Manager Burke Gu Buying Analyst William Gu Category Buying Engineer In charge of utilities mechanical, electrical and automation In charge of pipelines and tank 3Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 4. Agenda 4Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- On going 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 5. Steps Approach W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 22-Jul 29-Jul 5-Aug 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 1 Collect detailed technical information 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to include in the RFI process 3 Develop the RFI ā€“ jointly with client ā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria (e.g.: financial, related experience , company certificate, CV of the main persons of the project) 4 Administration and chasing for completion of an NDA with suppliers that have been preselected 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as 6 Analyze responses based on qualitative criteria and using a balance score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to take through a formal qualification process 7 Carry out interview with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: ā€¢Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification interview ā€¢Option 2: client carries out qualification interview ā€¢Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client interview with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing 8 Support contract negotiations between client and qualified suppliers Time schedule for engineering service -The whole process is on schedule, 6 suppliers visited by client with DS MilestonesAudit weekProcess before audit5 Today Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 6. Indentified suppliersā€™ status for engineering service 6 suppliers were visited from Sep.4th to Sep.11th Supplier indentified RFI sent Intend to respond RFI received Selected for interview Negotiate contract NDA sent Number of suppliers initially identified 25 Number of suppliers NDA sent 25 Number of supplier decline to sign 8 Number of suppliers intend to sign 0 Number of suppliers signed 15 Number of suppliers RFI sent 15 Number of suppliers internal checking 2 -2 suppliers donā€™t agree the items in the NDA -2 supplier think the NDA is too complicated, -4 suppliers give up the project finally Number of suppliers intend to respond 14 Number of suppliers RFI received 14 Number of suppliers decline to respond 1 Number of suppliers strong recommend to interview 4 Number of suppliers can be interviewed 6 Number of suppliers finally select to interview 6 6Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 7. Score card analysis for engineering service company after adjusted by client Average 67 5 suppliers client already interviewed before the project 6 suppliers client visited with DS 7Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. # Country Supplier Name Company Background Project related Company Qualification Cooperation Total Rank by client adjusted score card Rank by original score card 30% 40% 20% 10% max score 100 1 Local Supplier 1 30 39 17 10 96 1 1 2 Foreign Suppleir 2 29 37 15 10 91 2 2 3 Local Suppleir 3 22 36 14 10 82 3 3 4 Foreign Suppleir 4 27 28 13 10 78 4 4 5 Foreign Suppleir 5 19 32 16 9 75 5 5 6 Foreign Suppleir 6 16 37 12 10 75 5 6 7 Foreign Suppleir 7 19 37 9 10 75 5 6 8 Foreign Suppleir 8 26 35 4 9 73 6 6 9 Foreign Suppleir 9 19 34 8 10 71 7 7 10 Foreign Suppleir 10 20 37 6 7 70 8 9 11 Foreign Suppleir 11 30 22 6 9 67 9 9 12 Foreign Suppleir 12 13 35 9 10 67 9 10 13 Local Suppleir 13 26 20 13 7 65 10 8 14 Foreign Suppleir 14 19 22 6 10 57 11 13 15 Local Suppleir 15 19 27 3 7 56 12 12 16 Foreign Suppleir 16 22 20 7 7 55 13 11 17 Local Suppleir 17 19 21 7 4 50 14 14 18 Local Suppleir 18 15 13 8 7 42 15 15 19 Foreign Suppleir 19 13 12 5 5 34 16 16
  • 8. Audit results for 6 engineering service suppliers 8Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Date Time Supplier to be visited Agenda Recommended level after audit Attendee 4-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.8) Visit project site XXX Afternoon Visit supplier office and do interview 5-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.10) Visit supplier office and do interview Afternoon Visit project site 6-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.5) Visit supplier office and do interview Afternoon Visit project site 9-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.13) Visit supplier office and do interview XXX Afternoon Visit project site 10-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.14) Visit supplier office and do interview XXX Afternoon Visit project site) 11-Sep-13 Morning xxx (Rank No.1) Visit supplier office and do interview Visit project site Afternoon
  • 9. Immediate next steps Actions 9Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. client will inform DS the audit results for the engineering service and DS will prepare thank you lettter to the suppliers who have not been selected client/DS 11- Oct
  • 10. Agenda 10Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- On going 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 11. Steps Approach W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16 W17 W18 W19 W20 22- 29- 5- 12- 19- 26- 2- 9- 16- 23- 30- Jul Jul Aug Aug Aug Aug Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep 7-Oct 14- 21- 28- Oct Oct Oct 4-Nov 11- 18- 25- Nov Nov Nov 2-Dec 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers around Shanghai to include in the RFI process 3 Develop the RFI ā€“ jointly with client ā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria (e.g.: financial, related experience , company certificate, CV of the main persons of the project) 4 Administration and chasing for completion of an NDA with suppliers that have been preselected 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as 6 Analyze responses based on qualitative criteria and using a balance score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to take through a formal qualification process 7 Carry out interview with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: ā€¢Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification interview ā€¢Option 2: client carries out qualification interview ā€¢Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client interview with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing Time schedule for construction service -Next week we will contact the supplier who declined the project before due to the location problem and continue the RFI administration and NDA process Toda yProcess before audit Original audit week MilestonesDays base approach11Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 12. Indentified suppliersā€™ status for construction service -6 RFIs are received so far including 2 EPCM company xxx and xxx Number of suppliers initially identified Construction company: 34 Number of suppliers NDA sent 13 Number of suppliers pending to sent NDA 6 Number of suppliers decline the project 15 Number of suppliers signed 6 Number of suppliers intend to sign 0 Number of suppliers internal checking 1 Number of supplier decline to sign 6 Supplier indentified RFI sent Intend to respond RFI received Selected for interview Negotiate contract NDA sent Number of suppliers initially identified EOCM company: 17 Number of suppliers RFI sent 6 Number of suppliers RFI intend to respond 5 Number of suppliers RFI received 5 Number of suppliers RFI received 2 (xxx , xxx) Number of suppliers RFI not intend to respond 1 Remark: Double check with these supplier if they are interested in the project 12Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 13. Score card analysis for construction service company -7 suppliersā€™ RFI are analyzed by score card, the average score is 76 points, 3 suppliersā€™ score are over 80 points, 1 supplierā€™s score is over 90 points Remark: Supplier No.5 and No.6 are EPCM companies Average 76 92 84 83 81 66 66 58 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Cooperation Company Qualification Project related Company Background Total 13Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. # Country Supplier Name Company Background Project related Company Qualification Cooperation Total Rank by score card 30% 40% 20% 10% max score 100 1 Local Supplier 1 28 36 18 10 92 1 2 Local Supplier 2 26 33 18 7 84 2 3 Local Supplier 3 20 34 20 9 83 3 4 Local Supplier 4 20 36 18 7 81 4 5 Local Supplier 5 19 25 13 10 66 5 6 foreign Supplier 6 16 24 16 10 66 5 7 Local Supplier 7 23 16 12 7 58 7
  • 14. Suppliers recommend to interview according to the score card and filled RFI - 4 suppliers are recommended to the interview stage 14Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Country Supplier name City Province Score card ranking Strength weakness China Xxx Shanghai Shanghai 1 -Good company capability -Big construction group in China -Has a lot of experience in food industry -Full certificate -Has experience in Hangzhou but not in Xiaoshan China xxx Hangzhou Zhejiang 2 -Good company capability -Big construction group in China -Has a lot of experience in food industry -Full certificate -English skill is not good China xxx Qidong Jiangsu 3 -Acceptable company capability -Full certificate -Good English skill -Middle size construction company China xxx Shanghai Shanghai 4 -Acceptable company back ground -Full certificate -Has a lot of experience in food industry -English skill is not good -Middle size construction company
  • 15. Immediate next steps Actions 15Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Re-contact the suppliers reject the project before and collect NDA and RFI DS 14-Nov 2. RFI analysis and recommend suppliers for audit DS 22-Nov 3. Finalize suppliers for aduit client/DS 25-Nov
  • 16. Agenda 16Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- On going 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 17. Demand analysis 17Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Tube TT straight length 4m / DN 65 Tube TT curve 90Ā° / DN 65 Tube TT tee standard / DN 65 Material: AISI 304, Weight: 56.95kg, Quantity: 800m Material: AISI 304, Weight: 12.67kg, Quantity: 300pcs Material: AISI 304, Weight: 18.41kg,Quantity: 150pcs Tube TT straight length 4m / DN 150 Tube TT curve 90Ā° / DN 150 Tube TT tee standard / DN 150b Material: AISI 304, Weight: 27.57kg, Quantity: 800m Material: AISI 304, Weight: 34.18kg, Quantity: 300pcs Material: AISI 304, Weight: 48.38kg, Quantity: 150pcs
  • 18. Steps Approach W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre- screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process 8 Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option 2: client carries out qualification audits Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing Time schedule for pipelines Next week we will push the suppliers who havenā€™t replied the RFI and provide the RFI analysis result by score card TodaProcess before audit 18 Original audit week MilestonesCurrent audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 19. Status of identified suppliers for pipelines -284 supplier identified initially, 90/284 suppliers go to pre-screening process, 36/90 suppliers who meet all criteria go to the RFI process, 14/36 suppliers have replied RFI Number of suppliers initially identified 284 Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening No. of suppliers successfully contacted 265 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted 19 No. of suppliers not contacted yet 0 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening 90 No. of suppliers declined the project 169 No. of suppliers need to double check 6 No. of suppliers RFI sent 36 No. of suppliers intend to respond 36 No. of suppliers not intend to respond 0 No. of suppliers need to further contact 0 No. of suppliers RFI received by DS 14 No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive 22 19Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 20. Next Steps Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability. Actions 29Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 31-Oct 2. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 11-Nov 3. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 15-Nov
  • 21. Agenda 21Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- On going 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 22. Demand analysis 22Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Vessel 6.25 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 12.5 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 35 mĀ³ No pictures Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: N/A, Height: 5,310mm, Out diameter: 2,110 mm , 2~10pcs Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 2,700kg, Height; 5,635mm, Out diameter: 2,600 mm, 2~10pcs Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 4,500kg Height; 7,755mm, Out diameter: 3,000 mm, 2~10pcs Vessel 35 mĀ³ with agitator Vessel 120 mĀ³ Material: AISI 304L/304, Weight: 5,500kg Height; 7,755mm, Out diameter: 3,000 mm, 2~10pcs Material: AISI 304/304L, Weight: 12,000kg Height; 12,000mm, Out diameter: 3,800 mm, 2~10pcs
  • 23. Time schedule for tank Pre-screening process has completed, next week we will start RFI administration process Steps Approach W1 W2 16-Sep 23-Sep W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process 8 Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option 2: client carries out qualification audits Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing Toda y23 Original audit week MilestonesProcess before audit Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 24. Status of identified suppliers for tank -83 suppliers identified, 51/83 go to the pre-screening process, 39/83 suppliers are selected to the RFI process, 21/39 suppliers have replied RFI, 16/39 suppliers are pending to receive Number of suppliers initially identified 83 No. of suppliers successfully contacted 78 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted 5 No. of suppliers not contacted yet 0 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening 51 No. of suppliers eliminated 27 No. of suppliers need to double check 0 Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening Donā€™t produce what client need No. of suppliers RFI sent 39 No. of suppliers intend to respond 37 No. of suppliers not intend to respond 2 No. of suppliers RFI received by DS 21 No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive 16 24Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 25. Next Steps 25Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Actions Responsible Deadline Remarks 4. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 15-Nov 5. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 20-Nov Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability. 1. Administrate RFI process DS 31-Oct 2. Develop and finalize score card template DS 31-Oct 3. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 4-Nov
  • 26. Agenda 26Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- On going 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going 8. Q & A
  • 27. Time schedule for automation We will continue telephone pre-screening process next week and develop RFI template Steps Approach W1 W2 16-Sep 23-Sep W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process 8 Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option 2: client carries out qualification audits Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing Toda y27 Original audit week MilestonesProcess before audit Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 28. Status of identified suppliers for automation -70 suppliers identified so far including the 13 utilities suppliers, 36/70 suppliers go to the pre-screening process Number of suppliers initially identified Utilities: 13 Automation: 57 No. of suppliers successfully contacted Utilities: 13 Automation: 57 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted 0 No. of suppliers not contacted yet 0 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening Utilities: 12 Automation: 25 No. of suppliers eliminated Utilities: 1 Automation: 32 No. of suppliers need to double check 0 Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening ļƒ˜Utilities: -7 suppliers only do electrical related -3 suppliers only do mechanical related -3 supplier do whole process ļƒ˜Automation: -4 suppliers only do utilities related -3 suppliers do production or process related -17 suppliers do whole process 28Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 29. Next Steps Actions 29Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Telephone pre-screening process DS 31-Oct 2. Prepare RFI-RFQ template and validate RFI-RFQ template client/DS 31-Oct 3. Administrate RFI process DS 31-Oct 4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 5-Nov 5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 7-Nov 6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 15-Nov 7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 20-Nov Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
  • 30. Agenda 30Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- Not started yet 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 31. Demand analysis-utility (electrical parts) 31Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. MV switchgear LV switchboard transformer UPS Diesel Generator
  • 32. Step s Approach W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 12-Aug 19-Aug 26-Aug 2-Sep 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4- Nov W14 W15 W16 W17 11- 18- 25- Nov Nov Nov 2-Dec 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre-screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4- 5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process Analyze RFQ responses by score card 8 and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out audits with pre-selected suppliers. 3 options exist: Option 1: Dragon Sourcing carries out qualification audits Option 2: client carries out qualification audits Option 3: Dragon Sourcing carries out initial qualification process followed by client audit with suppliers recommended by Dragon Sourcing Time schedule for utilities-electrical parts Next week we will push the suppliers who havenā€™t replied the RFI and provide the RFI analysis result by score card Toda y Process before audit 32 Original audit week MilestonesCurrent audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 33. Status of identified suppliers for utilities-electrical parts -223 equipment suppliers and 23 installation suppliers initially identified, 64/223 equipments suppliers have been sent RFI, 37/64 suppliers replied RFI, 19/64 suppliers are pending to receive Number of suppliers initially identified Equipment: 223 Installation: 23 No. of suppliers successfully contacted Equipment: 223 Installation:23 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted 0 No. of suppliers not contacted yet 0 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening Equipment: 87 Installation:8 No. of suppliers eliminated Equipment: 136 Installation:13 No. of suppliers need to double check Equipment: 0 Installation:6 No. of suppliers RFI sent Equipment: 64 Installation: 8 Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening -These 37 suppliers are selected according to the results of the pre-screening process -18 suppliers belong to group 1: switchgear & switchboard & transformer suppliers -6 suppliers belong to group 2: UPS suppliers -13 suppliers belong to group 3: diesel generator suppliers No. of suppliers intend to respond 56 No. of suppliers not intend to respond 8 No. of suppliers need to further contact 0 No. of suppliers RFI received by DS 37 No. of suppliers RFI pending to receive 19 -8 suppliers belong to group 1: switchgear & switchboard & transformer suppliers -4 suppliers belong to group 2: UPS suppliers -7 suppliers belong to group 3: diesel generator suppliers 33Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 34. Next Steps-electrical parts Actions 34Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 31-Oct 2. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 22-Nov 3. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 26-Nov Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
  • 35. Demand analysis-utility (mechanical parts) 35Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Chiller Cooling tower for chillers AHU Compressed air and dryer -Chiller, (6/11Ā°C) each 2,5 MW cooling capacity, watercooled, 3 pcs -Chiller, (-5/0Ā°C) each 0,7 MW cooling capacity, watercooled, 2 pcs -Chiller, (-3/2Ā°C) each 1,0 MW cooling capacity, warehouse, 2 ps -(30/35Ā°C), each 2 MW capacity- for chillers -8 pcs -airflow 50.000 m3/h -30 pcs -compressors (8 bar) aircooled, each 30 m3/min capacity -2 pcs Pumps for cold and hot water Heat exchanger -Total 40 pcs -steam/hotwater (60/50Ā°C) each 1,5 MW heating capacity -4 pcs
  • 36. Time schedule for utilities-mechanical parts Next week we will continue the telephone pre-screening process and start RFI administration process for some items Steps Approach W1 W2 W3 W4 W5 9-Sep 16-Sep 23-Sep 30-Sep 7-Oct W6 W7 W8 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct W9 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 4-Nov 11-Nov 18-Nov 25-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre- screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process 8 Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out supplier audit Toda 36 MilestonesProcess before audit Original audit week Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 37. Status of identified suppliers for utilities-mechanical parts -409 equipment suppliers identified so far, 336/409 suppliers contacted, 73/409 suppliers pending to contact, 116/336 suppliers go to pre-screening process, 75/336 suppliers need further contact, 145/336 suppliers eliminated from the process Number of suppliers initially identified Equipment: 409 No. of suppliers successfully contacted Equipment: 336 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted 0 No. of suppliers not contacted yet Equipment: 73 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening Equipment: 116 No. of suppliers eliminated Equipment: 145 No. of suppliers need to double check Equipment: 75 Main reasons are suppliers canā€™t meet requirements or donā€™t produce want we want -Chiller & AHU : 71 suppliers -Cooling tower: 25 suppliers -Heat exchange: 9 suppliers -Pump: 5 suppliers -Air compressor: 6 suppliers -Cooling tower: 26 suppliers -Heat exchange: 4 suppliers -Pump: 45 suppliers Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening 37Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 38. Next Steps-mechanical parts Actions 38Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Telephone pre-screening process for pump and valve DS 31-Oct 2. Analyze pre-screening results and finalize list for RFI process client/DS 31-Oct 3. Administrate RFI process DS 8-Nov 4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 8-Nov 5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 14-Nov 6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 29-Nov 7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 4-Dec Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.
  • 39. Agenda 39Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. 1. Engineering service- Finished 2. Construction service- On going 3. Pipelines- On going 4. Tank- On going 5. Automation- Not started yet 6. Utilities- On going 7. Part of production line-On going
  • 40. Demand analysis- equipments for part of the production line 40Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Pump Air Dryer Root type blower Mixer Refining system Cooling system-tempering machine
  • 41. Demand analysis- equipments for part of the production line 41Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Pressure vessel Roaster Valves
  • 42. Demand analysis- part of the production line Conveyor belt 42Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 43. Demand analysis- part of the production line In pusher chain 43Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 44. Time schedule for part of production line We will continue pre-screening process and develop the RFI Steps Approach W1 W2 W3 23-Sep 30-Sep 7- Oct W4 W5 W6 W7 W8 W9 W10 11-Nov 18-Nov 25- Nov W11 W12 14-Oct 21-Oct 28-Oct 4-Nov 2-Dec 9-Dec 1 Collect detailed technical information N a t i o n a l H o l i d a y 2 Identify list of potential suppliers in China to pre- screening process 3 Carry out a phone pre-screening of the suppliers based on (1) maximum 4-5 screening criteria per category with these criteria to be provided by client 4 Develop the RFI-RFQ ā€“ jointly with clientā€“ to include all key supplier qualification criteria 5 Administer the RFI process to ensure as high a return rate as possible 6 Analyze RFI responses by score card and recommend suppliers which client needs to the RFQ process 7 Administrate RFQ and NDA process 8 Analyze RFQ responses by score card and recommend suppliers with client for audit 9 Carry out audit Toda 44 MilestonesProcess before audit Original audit week Current audit weekĀ© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 45. Status of identified suppliers for part of production line -248 suppliers have been identified so far, including 198 equipment suppliers and 50 production line suppliers Number of suppliers initially identified Equipment: 293 Production line: 50 Supplier indentified RFI sent NDA sent RFQ sent Selected for audit Selected for sample Negotiate contract Telphone screening No. of suppliers successfully contacted Equipment: 63 Production line: 33 No. of suppliers unsuccessfully contacted Equipment: 0 Production line: 0 No. of suppliers not contacted yet Equipment: 230 Production line: 17 No. of suppliers go to pre-screening Equipment: 63 Production line: 5 No. of suppliers eliminated Equipment: 0 Production line: 0 No. of suppliers need to double check Equipment: 0 Production line: 28 Remark: Supplier number for equipments: -Air dryer : 41 suppliers -Tempering machine: 17 suppliers -Pump: 41 suppliers -Refining machine: 22 suppliers -Mixer: 17 suppliers -Blower: 50 suppliers -Roaster: 10 suppliers -Valve: 95 suppliers 45Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved.
  • 46. Next Steps-mechanical parts Actions 46Ā© 2013 Dragon Sourcing. All rights reserved. Responsible Deadline Remarks 1. Telephone pre-screening process DS 31-Oct 2. Analyze pre-screening results and finalize list for RFI process client/DS 31-Oct 3. Administrate RFI process DS 15-Nov 4. Develop and finalize score card template DS 15-Nov 5. Analyze RFI result and recommend suppliers for RFQ process and NDA process DS 19-Nov 6. Administrate RFQ and NDA process DS 29-Nov 7. Analyze RFQ result and recommend suppliers for audit DS 4-Dec Below are the proposed next steps with responsibilities and deadlines according to the schedule. The deadlines need to be adjusted to take into account the client availability.