Spatial Multicriteria Approach for Assessing Urban Resilience
•
0 likes•189 views
The document presents a spatial multicriteria approach to identify resilient cities. It involves creating criterion maps to assess factors like accessibility, slope, vulnerability, and seismic hazard. Constraint maps are also used to remove areas with high risks. This is applied to the city of Marsicovetere in Italy as a case study. Different weighting scenarios are defined using pairwise comparison to calculate the most suitable areas for resilient development. The approach aims to help identify resilient cities and inform urban planning and disaster management.
Recommended
Recommended
More Related Content
Viewers also liked
Viewers also liked (16)
More from Vijay Meena
More from Vijay Meena (13)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
Spatial Multicriteria Approach for Assessing Urban Resilience
- 1. Resilient City and Seismic Risk: A Spatial Multicriteria Approach Lucia Tilio, Beniamino Murgante, Francesco Di Trani, Marco Vona, Angelo Masi By: Vijay Meena 2013BPLN037 Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 2. Structure A spatial Multicriteria approach Conclusion and directions Case study of India Facing with disasters Risks Management Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 3. Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 4. Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 5. assessment prevention protection emergency emergency … forecasting Risks Management post- Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 6. Risk Vulnerability Exposure Hazard Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 7. Hazard Global map, Giardini, Gryintal, Shedlock, Zhang, 1999 Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 8. Exposure Population density (people per km2) by country, 2006 Miguel Contreras, lala land, 2007 Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 9. Vulnerability Structural vulnerability Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 10. Vulnerability Structural vulnerability Urbanvulnerability Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 11. to Minimize Urban Vulnerability to Maximize Urban Resilience Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 12. Resilience time Systemstate Se Td Se = Equilibrium State Td = Disaster And then ? Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 13. Resilience Planned preparation Spontaneous adjustments Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 14. Resilience Social aspects Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 15. Resilience Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Urban Resilience is the capacity of individuals, communities, institutions, businesses, and systems within a city to survive, adapt, and grow no matter what kinds of chronic stresses and acute shocks they experience. CHRONIC STRESSES ACUTE SHOCKS Stresses weaken the fabric of a city on a daily or cyclical basis. Examples include: ● high unemployment ● overtaxed or inefficient public ● transportation system ● endemic violence ● chronic food and water shortages. Acute shocks are sudden, sharp events that threaten a city. Examples include: ● earthquakes ● floods ● disease outbreaks ● terrorist attacks Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 16. Resilient CityHuman communities Physical Systems InstitutionsAssociations Organizations Public Buildings Roads Lifelines Strategic Buildings Bridges Citoyens Buildings Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 17. Resilient City Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 18. Resilient City Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 19. Resilient City: how to identify? In Marsicovetere, Basilicata Region, South of Italy Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 20. Marsicovetere (e Villa d’Agri) Important town in the Valley, “Val d’Agri” Seismic Area Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 21. spatial multicriteria model Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 22. a raster model pixels are the decisional alternatives Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 23. criterion maps Accessibility a pixel is as better as it is closer to road network Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 24. criterion maps Slope a pixel is as better as its slope is low Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 25. criterion maps Proximity to urban area a pixel is as better as it is closer to urban area Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 26. criterion maps Proximity to strategic buildings a pixel is as better as it is closer to strategic buildings (e.g. hospitals) Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 27. criterion maps Distance from hydrographic network a pixel is as better as it is further to hydrographic network Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 28. a pixel is as better as it its vulnerability is low criterion maps Structural Vulnerability Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 29. a pixel is as better as it its vulnerability is low criterion maps Structural Vulnerability Marsicovetere Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Villa d’Agri Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 30. a pixel is as better as it its vulnerability is low criterion maps Structural Vulnerability Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 31. a pixel is as better as its seismic hazard is low criterion maps High Seismic Hazard Areas Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 32. constraint maps High Landslide Risk and Flooding Areas a pixel is removed if its landslide and flooding risk is high Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 33. a pixel is removed if soils characteristics are not good constraint maps Seismic Microzonation Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 34. a pixel is removed if it is “occupied” by structures and infrastructures constraint maps Areas physically occupied by buildings and roads Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 35. three scenarios weights definition Pairwise comparison according to Saaty A “neutral” scenario: all criteria have same importance. A “functional” point of view: criteria related to accessibility and built-up areas proximity are more important than others. A “safety” point of view: criteria related to natural risks are more important than others. Facing wth disasters Risks management Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 36. weights definition Pairwise comparison according to Saaty Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 37. resilient city Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 38. conclusions A first approach to resilient city identification Some lack of information The right scale? A map to communicate resilience How to maximize resilience More criteria Facing wth disasters Vulnerability and Resilience Resilient City Spatial Multicriteria Approach Conclusions and directions to diversify alternatives Another multicriteria model? Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 39. India Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 40. India Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 41. India Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com
- 42. Thank You Vijay Meena | School of Planning and Architecture Bhopal | vjspab@gmail.com Vijay M eena SchoolofPlanning and Architecture Bhopal vjspab@ gm ail.com