SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 47
MAT 308
Test 1 Chapters 6 & 7(170 Total Points)
Show All Work!
Name:_______________
1. Find the value of Zsuch that 0.0500 of the area under the
curve lies to the right of the Z (5 points).
2. Find the value of Zsuch that 0.2000 of the area under the
curve lies to the left of the Z (5 points).
3. The random variable X has a normal distribution with a mean
of 100 and a standard deviation of 25(5 points each).
a. Find probability that X is between 85 & 120
b. Find probability that X is greater than 130
c. Find probability that X is less than 75
d. Find probability that X is between 95 & 105
e. Find probability that X is less than 100
4. Suppose the random variable X has a population mean of 50
and a standard deviation of 10. Calculate the mean and the
standard deviation of the sample mean for each of the following
sample sizes (5 points each).
a. n=25
b. n=40
c. n=55
d. n=65
e. What happens to the size of the standard deviation of the
sample mean as the sample size increases?
5. A national report stated that 72% of trucks sold were
extended cab. John took a random sample of 200 trucks. What is
the probability that less than 116 trucks were extended cab?(10
points)
6. Find the Z-score for (5 points each):
a. Area of .9870 to its left
b. Area of 0.035 to its right
c. Area represents the 40th percentile
d. Area between –Z and Z is 0.90
e. Area to left of –Z and the right of Z totals 0.20
7. Calculate the standard score (Z-Score)(5 points each).
a. μ = 95 and σ = 15; x = 110
b. μ = 110 and σ = 12.5; x = 70
c. μ = 100 and σ = 22; x = 115
8. With a standard normal distribution find (5 points each):
a. area between -1.00 and 1.00
b. area less than 2.45
c. area more than -2.05
d. area less than -.55 and more than .85
9. Body temperatures of adults are normally distributed with a
mean of 98.6˚ and a standard deviation of 0.45˚.What is the
probability that a healthy adult will have a temperature that
differs from the mean by more than 2.00˚?(10 points)
10. The heights of women are normally distributed with a mean
of 63.6 inches and a standard deviation 2.8 inches. With a
sample size of 35 women find (5 points each):
a. Probability that an individual woman is more than 71.5
inches tall
b. Probability that the sample of women are less than 65.5
inches tall
c. Probability that the sample of women are between 56.5
and 71.5 inches tall
d. Probability that the sample of women are less than 64 inches
or greater than 72 inches tall
11. In one region, the September energy consumption levels for
single-family homes are found to be normally distributed with a
mean of 1150 kw and a standard deviation of 228kw. If 50
different homes are randomly selected, find the probability that
their mean energy consumption level for September is greater
than 1175kw (10 points).
COLLEGE LITERATURE: A JOURNAL OF CRITICAL
LITERARY STUDIES 44.4 Fall 2017
Print ISSN 0093-3139 E-ISSN 1542-4286
© Johns Hopkins University Press and West Chester University
2017
TRANSNATIONALISM AND ANTI-GLOBALISM
JOHANNES VOELZ
The recent resurgence of nationalism in the United States finds
expression in a whole vocabulary, made up of slogans, rallying
cries, and buzzwords. Most prominent among them may be
“Make
America Great Again” and “America First,” but there is another
buzzword—anti-globalism—which is particularly suggestive of
the
conundrum transnationalism faces in the Age of Trump. The
term
anti-globalism results from an act of rhetorical appropriation
and
resignification, and as I want to suggest, the idea of
transnationalism
plays an important role in this repackaging effort.
Anti-globalism recalls the anti-globalization movement of the
1990s and early 2000s, but this resonance brings out the
differences
rather than similarities between the two: where anti-
globalization
was concerned with a critique of the economic system, anti-
global-
ism attacks what is perceived as a larger ideology of globalism
that
allegedly promotes free trade as well as cultural and racial
mixing.
From the view of the leftist anti-globalization movement,
globaliza-
tion was driven by the institutions that backed the Washington
Con-
sensus (such as the International Monetary Fund, the World
Bank,
and the US Treasury), global corporations that exploited the
waning
sovereignty of nation-states, and national governments that
colluded
with the forces of global capital, for instance by entering into
inter-
national free trade agreements, such as the North American Free
522 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017
Trade Agreement. The targets of that earlier movement were
there-
fore the profiteers and structures of economic globalization.
This economic understanding of globalization opened up a space
for alternative conceptions of globalization that could compete
with
the economic version. It is no coincidence, therefore, that it was
also
in the late 1990s and early 2000s that the academic field of
Amer-
ican Studies turned to the transnational as an emerging
paradigm.
American Studies entered its transnational phase by engaging in
profound soul-searching about the possibilities of altering the
object
of study seemingly prescribed by the field’s name (see, for
instance,
Janice Radway’s 1998 Presidential Address at the American
Studies
Association, titled “What’s in a Name?”). Although rather
diverse
manifestos appeared in quick succession, there emerged a
consensus
that sticking to the nation form was a sign of ideological
backward-
ness, whereas transcending the nation held out the potential for
pro-
gressive change. From the get-go, transnational American
Studies
aimed to transcend the nation on two different conceptual
planes:
first, on the level of methodology, where transnationalism in
essence
meant adopting a particular perspective; second, on the level of
the
object of study, where transnationalism referred to phenomena
that
went beyond the limits of the nation. This blending of method
and
object of study meant in effect that the transnational wasn’t
some-
thing one could neutrally observe, describe, and chart. Rather,
studying the transnational meant affirming the transnational.
This
is because the approval for the new method jumped over, as it
were,
to an approval of the phenomena studied. If, in other words, the
transnational perspective of scholars was greeted as the
successful
overcoming of critical parochialism, then phenomena
embodying
the transnational were themselves to be commended. This valua-
tion guided the choice of what was to be studied: Preferred
objects
included oppositional social movements that traversed national
boundaries, aesthetic forms that traveled beyond the confines of
the
nation, and ideas that circulated in similarly unbounded ways
(clearly,
this list is not meant to be comprehensive). In short,
transnational
American Studies provided the opportunity to salvage a
“globaliza-
tion from below” (to use a phrase popular with the anti-
globalization
movement), and to favorably contrast it to both nationalism and
eco-
nomic globalization (or “globalization from above”).
One of the problems faced—but rarely addressed—by propo-
nents of transnationalism emerged from this differentiation of
eco-
nomic and cultural globalization. Did the idea that these two
forms
of globalization are principally different really hold up? Didn’t
both
Johannes Voelz | CRITICAL FORUM 523
visions of globalization rely on some of the very same images:
flows
(of goods, people, ideas) as something natural, borders and
bound-
aries as artificial? Wasn’t there, in fact, a deep affinity between
the
longing for cultural transnationalism and the ideology of
economic
globalization, despite the political differences that seemed to
keep
them both neatly separated? I have argued elsewhere that
conceptu-
ally (though not politically) transnational American Studies is
indeed
indebted to economic globalization, and that it is nonetheless
advis-
able to pursue the project of transnationalism, albeit in a self-
re-
flexive manner (Voelz 2011). But rather than revisiting this
debate
at this point, suffice it to say that the question of
transnationalism’s
oppositional purity emerged from the somewhat tenuous
conceptual
framework shared by the anti-globalization movement and
transna-
tional Americanists: globalization, according to this framework,
had
an economic and a cultural aspect, which were to be seen as
opposed
to one another.
Quite some time has passed since the early 2000s. By now, aca-
demic transnationalism in American literary and cultural stud-
ies has been solidly institutionalized. Think only of the Journal
of
Transnational American Studies, the recent Cambridge
Companion to
Transnational American Literature, edited by Yogita Goyal
(2017), or
the founding of the “Obama Institute for Transnational
American
Studies” at the University of Mainz, Germany. Meanwhile, pre-
dictably, the hype that initially attended the “transnational turn”
has faded rather quickly. The anti-globalization movement, on
the
other hand, has largely run out steam, mostly because center-
left
parties across North America and Europe failed to support it;
they
embraced neoliberal reforms instead, a decision which has cost
many
of them a good share of their votes. (One could add that the
move-
ment only petered out after the demise of Occupy, or that, in
fact,
it has survived in places like Spain, where Podemos has
managed
to transform the protest against neoliberal globalization into
party
politics—but these are nuances that don’t change the big
picture.)
Along with the overall decline of anti-globalization came the
rise of
anti-globalism (itself a movement of transnational scope), and
thus
the seemingly miraculous transformation of a left-wing into a
right-
wing movement.
How in the world could that happen? In moving the critique
of globalization across the political spectrum, anti-globalists
have
rejected the foundational premise of anti-globalization and
academic
transnationalism: they refuse to differentiate between two
differ-
ent kinds of globalization, be they “from below and from
above,”
524 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017
“cultural and economic,” or simply “good and bad.” As London-
based
blogger Jacob Stringer has aptly summarized it on
opendemocracy.
net: “[Anti-]Globalisation refers to certain processes in the
interests
of corporate trade. [Anti-]Globalism refers to a global outlook,
bor-
ders too open, a feared mingling of cultures, implied dangerous
liai-
sons with aliens” (March 26, 2017). Anti-globalists, in other
words,
have tied the critique of economic globalization to xenophobia,
rac-
ism, and a disdain for global elites, and have thus
conceptualized
economic and cultural globalization as hanging together.
Anti-globalists’ longing for cultural isolationism, it must be
admitted, has rendered the economic dimension of anti-
globalism
strikingly toothless. It is as if they offered cultural anti-
globalism as
a solution to the problems caused by global capitalism: their
implied
economic platform seems to be limited to the call for
protectionism
(the economic dimension of “America First!”) and the hope for
more
high-paying manufacturing jobs. In Strangers in Their Own
Land,
sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild (2016) has recently shown
just
how deeply the Tea Party members and Trump supporters she
inter-
viewed in Louisiana are invested in the free market, and how
much
they detest the welfare state. Their critique of economic
globaliza-
tion spares multinational corporations (even if these
corporations,
like the petrochemical companies in Louisiana, ruin the
environ-
ment and cause a virtual cancer epidemic) because they are seen
as
the older siblings of small businesses run by local
entrepreneurs.
Though the anti-globalists’ mix of economic and cultural anti-
glo-
balism may be rife with logical faults and moral deficiencies,
their
triumph should not be simply dismissed as racist and
xenophobic
(though it is that, too). Instead, their rise should prompt
scholars
of transnationalism to reflect on the involvement of the idea of
the
transnational in the political struggle that divides the United
States
and, increasingly, other countries in which right-wing populism
has taken hold. In this context, it becomes newly significant
that
transnational Americanists have tended to politically identify
with
the transnational formations they study and that they have thus,
as
described earlier, conflated method and object of study. As a
result
of this conflation, academic transnationalism has come to
embody
the idea of globalism targeted by the anti-globalist agenda.
Econom-
ically, transnationalism encapsulates the privileged status of a
global
elite (here, transnationalism refers to the scholars) and
culturally, it
raises fears of migration, hybridity, and the demise of white
hege-
mony (here, transnationalism refers to the phenomena studied).
Seen in this light, the idea of globalism embodied by
transnational
Johannes Voelz | CRITICAL FORUM 525
American Studies becomes a tailor-made point of attack for
what
John Judis, in The Populist Explosion (2016), has described as
the tri-
angular scapegoating of right-wing populism. Right-wing
populism
is triangular in that it claims to defend “the people” against two
per-
ceived enemies: the elites (situated above) and undeserving
“others”
(situated below).
The challenge of anti-globalism, then, is not only that it rejects
transnationalism’s starting premise of the two kinds of
globaliza-
tion, but, more crucially, that it brings to light the degree to
which
transnationalism is itself involved in the divisive struggle
currently
rocking the United States. This challenge, I think, can be seen
as
a welcome opportunity to generate a new kind of knowledge
from
within transnational American Studies. It calls for an approach
that
is more self-reflexive than the identificatory stance taken by
many
scholars of transnationalism so far. Rather than starting from
the
presumption that studying transnational formations means
helping
to fight the good fight, transnational American Studies could
begin to
chart how the transnational itself has become a currency, or
capital,
in the struggle for symbolic advantages in a starkly divided
society.
This isn’t to devalue the study of transnational formations, but
rather to come to realize that embracing and valuing the
transna-
tional is a maneuver that helps secure symbolically
advantageous
positions. This is the case both in the academic field of
American
Studies, which has long been organized around a moral
economy of
political engagement, and in the larger public sphere of the
United
States. The idea (taken from Bourdieu) is not that we
consciously
try to amass as much symbolic capital as possible—as if we
were
rational-choice actors in the field of symbolic capital—but
instead
that trying to carve out for ourselves a recognized position in
the
field of transnational American Studies is what it means to
“have
an investment in the game” (Bourdieu and Wacquant 1992, 98).
The same goes for the other side of the divide: the embrace of
anti-globalism speaks to the specific value of the ideas and
princi-
ples captured by the term transnationalism in the broader
political
discourse of the United States. Here, too, the currency of the
idea
of transnationalism has a particular valuation. The fact that we
may
think of this value as “negative” when used by anti-globalists
begins
to suggest that taking stock of transnationalism as a currency
helps
us capture its political existence. I am suggesting, in other
words,
to incorporate a self-reflexive and relational sociology of the
trans-
national into the program of transnational American literary and
cultural studies.
526 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017
One of the welcome ramifications of such an extension of
Amer-
icanist transnationalism, it seems to me, would be to overcome
the
harmful dualism of nation and trans-nation. Ultimately, this
dualism
suggests that by turning to the transnational, we will have to
learn
to stop worrying about the nation-state. But Trump’s rise to
power
should make it apparent that American Studies needs to be able
to provide explanations of what goes on inside the United
States.
The truly surprising suggestion to be taken away from the rise
of
anti-globalism is this: a self-reflexively and relationally
revamped
transnational American Studies may provide a necessary tool for
coming to terms with the nationalist resurgence.
WORKS CITED
Bourdieu, Pierre, and Loïc Wacquant. 1992. An Invitation to
Reflexive Sociol-
ogy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Goyal, Yogita, ed. 2017. The Cambridge Companion to
Transnational American
Literature. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hochschild, Arlie Russell. 2016. Strangers in their Own Land:
Anger and
Mourning on the American Right. New York: The New Press.
Judis, John. 2016. The Populist Explosion: How the Great
Recession Transformed
American and European Politics. New York: Columbia Global
Reports.
Ebook.
Radway, Janice. 1999. “What’s in a Name? Presidential Address
to the
American Studies Association, 20 November, 1998.” American
Quarterly
51.1: 1–32.
Stringer, Jacob. “Why did anti-globalisation fail and anti-
globalism suc-
ceed?” Open Democracy. March 26, 2017. Opendemocracy.net.
Last vis-
ited: May 28, 2017.
Voelz, Johannes. 2011. “Utopias of Transnationalism and the
Neoliberal
State.” In Re-Framing the Transnational Turn in American
Studies, edited
by Winfried Fluck, Donald E. Pease, and John Carlos Rowe.
Hanover,
NH: University Press of New England.
JOHANNES VOELZ is Heisenberg-Professor of American
Studies,
Democracy, and Aesthetics at Goethe-University Frankfurt,
Ger-
many. He is the author of Transcendental Resistance: The New
Amer-
icanists and Emerson’s Challenge (UP New England, 2010) and
The
Poetics of Insecurity: American Fiction and the Uses of Threat
(Cambridge
UP, forthcoming 2017).
Reproduced with permission of copyright owner.
Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Listen
Plum Print
The assumption of this article is that the "second great
transformation" proposed by global actors parallels the one
advanced
by those who resisted laissezțfaire capitalism in the 19th
century. Both
dispute the unilateral imposition of a new planetary order and
endeavor to modify the rhythm and direction of economic
processes
presented as either fact or fate. In doing so, they effectively
place the
question of the political institution of this order on the agenda. I
look
briefly at the familiar underside of globalism and then move on
to
develop a tentative typology of initiatives that set the tone for a
politics
of globalization. These include radical and viral direct action,
the
improvement of the terms of exchange between industrialized
and
developing countries, the expansion of the public sphere outside
national borders through global networks, the accountability of
multilateral organizations, and the advancement of democracy at
a
supranational level. Participants in these initiatives take politics
beyond
the liberalțdemocratic format of elections and partisan
competition
within the nationțstate. They exercise an informal supranational
citizenship that reclaims—and at the same time reformulates—
the
banners of social justice, solidarity, and internationalism as part
of the
public agenda.
Ever since the market ceased to be a taboo and globalization
became
a dominant cognitive framework, the Left seems to have
confined itself
to a principled commitment toward the dispossessed and a
continual
call for measures to ameliorate inequality. Outside the
mainstream,
globaliphobic groups—an expression I use as shorthand to
designate
the naysayer as well as Beck's "black," "green," and "red"
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 1 of 36
protectionists[ 1]—offer more militant, yet scarcely innovative
responses. They conceive globalization as a purely negative
phenomenon, little more than old capitalism dressed in new
clothes.
For them, especially the red and black globaliphobes, the
assault on
sovereignty spearheaded by governments and multilateral
agencies in
the name of international trade strengthens the hand of the
business
and financial community, compromises the autonomy of
domestic
political decisions, and reinforces the submissive status of less
developed countries to the dictates of the major industrial
nations.
Globaliphobes are quite right about this, but they also think
about the
phenomenon from a reductionist perspective that confuses
globalization with what Beck calls "globalism," that is, "the
ideology of
rule by the world market, the ideology of neoliberalism."[ 3] In
doing
so, they neglect the range of contending forces set into motion
by the
process of globalization itself. The paradoxical effect of this
confusion
is that their diagnostic converges with that of the neoliberal
right: both
conceive globalization as a victory of liberalism, except that
each
assigns opposite values to it.
Yet the hegemony of the market and free trade is not quite the
same
as the victory of liberalism tout court. When one looks at the
efforts to
recast the rules and the institutional design of the international
order
that has been emerging from the ruins of the Berlin wall, the
thesis of a
liberal end of history proves to be somewhat premature.
Globalism
undermines Westphalian sovereignty and deepens inequality,
but also
has at least a potential for political innovation as the resistance
to
globalism opens the doors for an expansion of collective action
beyond its conventional enclosure within national borders.
Notwithstanding the unipolarity of the international order, the
wide
array of new global warriors that rally around the banner of the
World
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 2 of 36
Social Forum—"another world is possible"—are assembling a
politics
that seeks to move the current setting beyond mere globalism.
This
intervention examines some of the symptoms of this move.
Every age of great changes brings along an underside.
Nineteenthț
century industrialization unleashed a productive power on a
scale
unknown before while it simultaneously destroyed traditional
communities, virtually wiped out the cottage industry of artisan
production, and created a new urban underclass. Industrial
society
also saw the emergence of efforts to resist and modify the
capitalist
reorganization of the world. Globalization, with its remarkable
time–
space compression and its impact on our perception of
distance,[ 4]
presents us with an underside too. It has three salient aspects:
the
deepening gap between rich and poor countries, the creation of
a
mobile elite and an increasingly confined mass, and the
resurrection of
more rigid and less liberal models of identity as a defensive
reaction to
the dislocations brought upon by globalization under the guise
of
globalism.
The first point has been discussed profusely.[ 5] For the purpose
of
our argument, it suffices to point out that one does not need to
be an
orthodox communist or a Rousseauțstyle egalitarian to
understand
that a minimum threshold of equality is required to shore up
governance and level the field for participants in the public
sphere.
The second aspect addresses a sociological issue. While moral
indignation in the face of human suffering is not enough to
reorient the
global patterns of development towards greater social justice
and
solidarity, the persistence of exclusion confirms the coexistence
of two
worlds or lifețexperiences concerning globalization. These
typically
show themselves, and converge, in one place, border crossings,
and
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 3 of 36
around one issue, mobility. Advocates of globalism extol the
virtues of
the free transit of capitals, goods, services, and people. Without
it,
globalization faces a real and perhaps unsurpassable limit. That
is why
the World Trade Organization (WTO) insists on this free
passage.
However, migratory controls to stop the entry of those fleeing
from
poverty or persecution multiply. The freedom of the market, say
Zincone and Agnew, entails a schizophrenic logic—positive for
capital
and negative for labor.[ 6] The UN reports something similar:
"The
collapse of space, time and borders may be creating a global
village,
but not everyone can be a citizen. The global professional elite
now
face low borders, but billions of others find borders as high as
ever."[
7] Bauman builds on this to identify a novel socioțpolitical
division
developing in the global order. If distance has ceased to be an
obstacle only for the rich—since for the poor it never was more
than a
shackle—this creates a new type of division between the haves
and
the haves not. The former are tourists who travel because they
can
and want to do so, while the latter are vagabonds, people who
move
because the world around them is unbearable, more of a prison
than a
home.[ 8] While the vagabond is the nightmare of the tourist, he
says,
they share something in that they are both "radicalized"
consumers—
they are embarked in a continual pursuit of satisfaction fueled
by
desire rather than by the object of desire—only that the former
is a
"defective" one. Thus, they are not mutually exclusive
categories, both
because tourists might become vagabonds and because one
might
occupy the position of the tourist in some domains and of the
vagabond in others.
The third salient aspect of globalization arises from the
exponential
increase in the pace of political, technological, economic, or
cultural
change. Its impact is undecidable. It can be lived as an opening
up of
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 4 of 36
possibilities for emancipatory projects or as a threat to identity
and to
the certainties of a more familiar world. When the latter gains
the
upper hand, people might turn to aggressive forms of
nationalism,
religious orthodoxy, tribalism, or messianic leaders—none of
which are
likely to enhance toleration—with the expectation of restoring
certainty. This is not entirely new. The industrial revolution
also
undermined the referents of everyday life without offering
cultural
responses, at least not at the beginning. Marx and Engels
describe the
distinctive traits of the dislocations brought upon by capitalism
in a
wellțknown passage of the Manifesto. They say:
Constant revolutionizing of production, uninterrupted
disturbance of
all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation
distinguish
the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. All fixed, fastțfrozen
relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices
and
opinions, are swept away, all newțformed ones become
antiquated
before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is
holy is
profaned.
Nationalism helped to counteract this "uninterrupted
disturbance" that
undermined identities and governmentality. Kahler argues that
in the
19th century, especially after the expansion of the franchise, the
emergence of mass nationalism had a political function, for it
enabled
states to forge strong links with the citizenry and to ensure their
loyalty
in an age of democracy. Later, anticommunism and the promise
of
economic prosperity replaced nationalism as a political
programmed.[
9] Globalism has nothing comparable to offer, or rather, as
Debray
remarks, it seems to offer no other mystique than the prospect
of
economic growth.[10] The latter is certainly desirable, at least
if one
expects some form of income distribution as its side effect, but
it is
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 5 of 36
probably not enough to sway those whose livelihood and
identity are
threatened by the rapid reorganization of labor markets and
trade
patterns. As suggested, the danger here is the possible appeal of
projects that offer certainty at the expense of toleration. The
strong
and often violent revival of nationalism and the aggressive
affirmation
of ethnic identities illustrate an uncanny hardening of territorial
and
cultural frontiers in a global setting where the role of borders is
supposed to have waned. This is complicated further by the rise
of
religious radicalism and by the religious coding of the global
terrorism
that became notorious after the events of 9/11. Since then, those
hitherto known as freedom fighters became the security
nightmare of
the West. Much to the chagrin of those advocating the end of
history
in the aftermath of the Cold War, the enduring presence of such
radicalism shows that the liberal worldțview is not without
rivals.
Interestingly, Debray describes religious radicalism—but not
religious
terrorism—as a defensive response to the loss of a sense of
belonging, or better still, to the dislocation of cultural referents
in the
wake of globalism. He argues that when people feel lost the list
of
"believers" usually grows. That is why he says that sometimes
religion
(but we could also say "nationalism" or "ethnic intolerance,"
which are
similar in this respect) turns out to be not the opium of the
people but
the vitamin of the weak.[11]
Globalism therefore revolutionizes the certainties of the past
and
inserts entire populations into a more open, changing and
diverse
world, often enhancing the array of options of how and where to
live
their lives. Bauman's tourists embody this freedom of choice
and
movement, so dear to liberal thought. Yet it also reminds us of a
possible trade off between these new possibilities and the
relative
security that accompanied identities in a more parochial world.
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 6 of 36
Bauman captures this disorientation when he speaks of
globalization
as the perception of "things getting out of hand."[12] The
question
here is not simply the fear of turning into vagabonds or
remaining
trapped forever in that position; it refers instead to the demand
for
certainty, a desire for more rigid codes that function as
navigational
maps for living in a world in constant flux. This is what Debray
had in
mind when he described religion as a vitamin of the weak. This
vitamin, however, is not sought by the casualties of globalism
alone,
but also by the champions of globalism who must now face the
flip
side of cheap airfares, cheap weapons, and cheap digital
communications being available to its opponents too. In an
international scene dominated by a neoțHobbesian concern for
security—terrorism, AIDS, drugs or immigration—the trade off
between a rapidly changing world and the demand for
certainty—both
in the center and in the periphery of global capitalism—
reinforces our
suspicion about a facile endorsement of a liberal telos of
history. It
does so if only because it reveals that not everyone sees
capitalism—
which Milton Friedman famously characterized as a general
freedom
to choose—and political liberalism as universally valid goods,
and
because sometimes the very advocates of those values easily
override
them by imposing illegal tariffs on imports or by engaging in
wars of
aggression in the name of prosperity and security.
Yet to accept this underside as a necessary consequence of
globalization is to submit to the naturalist fallacy of globalism,
which
presents the unilateral imposition of a world order modeled
around the
Washington Consensus as our destiny instead of as an act of
political
institution. Arguably, one could say that the war on terrorism
unleashed after 9/11 reactivates its political origin. It is the true
index
of globalization, or if one prefers, an implicit acknowledgement
that
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 7 of 36
globalism seeks to hegemonize globalization but can neither
control
nor exhaust it. However, it is the disagreement with and
resistance to
the current state of things that reactivates it explicitly.
What type of resistance? Another parallel with the 19th century
can
help to clarify this. Simplifying things a bit, the range of
responses of
those excluded from the benefits of the industrial revolution
oscillated
between two perspectives. One was the destruction of machines
advocated by the Luddites in the revolts of the 1810s and 1820s
in the
North of England—mainly the Midlands, Yorkshire, and
Lancashire.
Theirs was a mode of direct action motivated by near starvation
and
the desperation stemming from it, but also by a desire to restore
the
working conditions of earlier times, which presupposed that a
return to
the prețindustrial economy of smallțscale producers and artisans
was
a viable alternative. Marx and the International Working Men's
Association or First International exemplified the other
position. For
them there was little or no room for nostalgia since capitalism
was
here to stay, so the political task of the day was not to destroy
machines but to organize the resistance of the dispossessed
through
trade unions and other movements. Their aim was to transform
capitalism from within in order to build a more just and
fraternal
society. In the celebrated opening lines of the Manifesto, their
socialist
and internationalist project was the specter haunting Europe—or
rather, the European ruling classes. Polanyi sees the alternative
in
similar, yet less revolutionary terms, as he claims that by the
1830s "
[E]ither machines had to be demolished, as the Luddites had
tried to
do, or a regular labor market had to be created. Thus was
mankind
forced into the paths of a utopian experiment."[13]
Today we face a similar challenge and a new specter, one
haunting the
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 8 of 36
neoliberal efforts to reduce globalization to globalism. While
globaliphobes—in many ways the latterțday Luddites—see
globalization as the ruse of capitalism and call for a return to
the stateț
centered and protectionist policies of the past, others have
chosen to
become global warriors to transform the current state of affairs.
Like
their socialist predecessors in the industrial age, the more lucid
critics
of the global condition are not against globalization or trade per
se.
Just like those who opposed Gulf War II were not always
pacifists, in
the sense that many did not pose a moral injunction to war as
such but
only to a war that lacked the moral and political legitimacy of a
UN
resolution, these critics are not necessarily opposed to
globalization
but rather to globalism.[14] They do not stand in awe for the
momentum it has gathered nor delude themselves about the
eventual
disappearance of its negative effects either. They partake in the
global
fray to modify the course of globalization from within. Global
warriors
aim to bring about what Zincone and Agnew, in a felicitous play
of
words with the title of Polanyi's celebrated study of
industrialization,
call the political phase of the "second great transformation."[15]
We can read the latter as a move from globalism to
globalization,
which amounts to an effort to politicize economic processes
currently
mystified as either fact or fate. I propose a tentative typology of
the
initiatives undertaken by globalțminded actors. It functions as a
provisional guideline to differentiate forms of collective action
that
seek to modify the course of globalization. Their common trait
is the
resistance to the Washington Consensus of the 1990s—captured
in
ATTAC's slogan "The World is not for Sale"—in order to
transform
globalism from within and below. Their actions extend the
political field
—and by implication, the scope of citizenship—beyond the
enclosure
of the nationțstate. As in any classification, the boundaries
between
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 9 of 36
the various groupings are somewhat porous, as initiatives tend
to
overlap and to appear conjointly. I will distinguish six types,
the first
two being common to political activism more generally.
The lingering perception of the antițglobalization (i.e. antiț
globalism)
movement consists of a string of cities—Seattle, Prague,
Gothenburg,
Genoa—accompanied by images of sitțins, smashed windows,
street
violence, police barricades, and people being arrested. It also
includes
iconic referents like the destruction of a McDonald's restaurant
in
France led by José Bové and the Confédération Paysanne to
protest
against the use of genetically modified foods. This imagery is
prevalent partly because streetțbased politics tends to be more
salient
and thus the media picks on it as newsworthy. They are also the
ones
that instill most fear in the hearts of governments, business
leaders,
and multilateral agencies more accustomed to the logic of
expert
committees than to mass mobilizations, although at times they
embarrass and even undermine the strategic planning of other
global
protesters too. That is why some might argue that many activist
groups lack a strategic political compass. This is correct, but it
is not
the full story, as they range from strict globaliphobes to those
with a
clearer agenda for transforming globalism. Examples of those
who do
have such an agenda are those who participate in the World
Social
Forum of Porto Alegre, in the more recent European Social
Forum,
which gathered nearly 60,000 people when launched in Florence
in
November 2002, as well in other initiatives I will mention
shortly.[16]
Leading organizations associated with direct action include the
Ruckus Society, Global Exchange, and an array of anarchist
groups like
the Black Bloc.[17] One could also mention the "glocal"
dimension of
resistance, like the international support for local struggles
against
privatized utility companies in Third World countries. Here one
can
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 10 of 36
think of solidarity campaigns for the Bolivian Water Wars of
2000
against a subsidiary of Bechtel Corporation in Cochabamba, or
for the
Soweto Electricity Crisis Committee set up to resist rate
increases of
privatized state utilities in South Africa.[18]
Advocates of direct action—who can be violent or nonțviolent
in their
expression of discontent with the order of things—are the
generic
equivalent of the "dangerous classes" of 19thțcentury
conservative
discourse. Yet most movements and protests have a radical wing
or
radical strands among their ranks. Luddites shunned negotiation
or
accommodation within the system, and promoted the destruction
of
machines instead of proposing an alternative to the brutal
exploitation
of early capitalism. They ultimately failed, but theirs proved to
be a
productive failure, for cotton merchants and politicians got the
message about the perils of excessive greed. New social
movements
have been perhaps less destructive of private property, although
the
cathartic dimension of destruction should not be overlooked in
mass
protests. Yet they also appealed to radical direct action to
advance
their cause—the antinuclear protests in Germany during the
1970s and
the guerrilla tactics of Greenpeace are typical examples. One
can
agree or not with these "hot" actions, which are often
accompanied by
more protests and slogans than by strategic proposals, but they
play
an important role. They provide an initial momentum for
resistances to
globalism and for the globalization of resistances, and therefore
contribute to give visibility to the political phase of the "second
great
transformation." As Wallach says, sometimes direct action helps
to cut
through the arrogance of the international bureaucracy.[19]
Experts of
multilateral agencies often refuse to give any serious thought to
proposals of advocacy groups or stall them in the paper chase of
countless committees. As theorists of realpolitik have shown, a
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 11 of 36
capacity for disruption—which is a de facto veto power—serves
as a
bargaining tool, in this case helping global warriors to get their
case
heard.
The analogical model of these initiatives is the propagation of
digital
viruses over the Web: once they start to circulate, whoever
created
them loses track of how they propagate and cannot control who
will
get infected or when they will be contained. Chain letters are a
less
damaging example of such dissemination. Terrorist cells are a
more
threatening illustration. Viral action coincides with what
Deleuze and
Guattari designate as a "rhizome," a mode of organization that
lacks an
"arborescent" or treețlike central structure connecting and
directing
its parts.[20] A rhizome links people and individuals, and
facilitates
further links—independent initiatives generated by other groups
and
individuals—without the usual hierarchies or infrastructure of
more
conventional social and political organizations. The range of
viral
actions is quite broad. While it is not confined to the "cool"
medium of
cyberspace, the latter provides interesting examples. Some
consist of
gathering funds for relief operations or clicking on websites
like The
Hunger Site (www.thehungersite.org) to donate a cup of food, a
percentage of a mammogram, or to save a square foot of
rainforest—
all of this free of cost for those who do so. Others include
organizing
independent boycotts of firms employing child labor or sharing
information and other resources for sponsoring initiatives or
organizing
protests. Among the latter, one could mention the efforts of
MoveOn
(www.moveon.org, which has an ețmail list with 1.8 million
members)
to organize an internet protest against the war on Iraq, or to
disseminate information linking the war with the "Project for a
New
American Century" and its goal of positioning the US as the
unconditioned pole of the new world order.[21]
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 12 of 36
The strategic matrix for this mode of action in cyberspace is
electronic
civil disobedience (ECD). It was posed in the midț1990s by the
Critical
Art Ensemble as a way to match the dețcentralized and deț
territorialized nature of contemporary capitalism, particularly
financial
capital. Like all forms of radical direct action, it eschews
electoral
and/or party politics. If the streets were the privileged sites of
traditional civil disobedience, the nonțphysical cyberspace is
the
milieu where ECD takes place. The rhizomatic structure of viral
direct
action is clearly at work here, for instead of aiming for a mass
movement of public objectors, it favors a dețcentralized flow of
particularized microțorganizations. "Hacktivism," the
recombinant
encounter of technologyțsavvy hackers and traditional political
activists, is one of its modalities. In December 1997, the
Anonymous
Digital Coalition called people to block access to websites of
Mexican
financial institutions by repeatedly reloading them to protest the
massacre of indigenous people in Acteal, Chiapas, by
proțgovernment
paramilitary groups. The Electronic Disturbance Theatre, a proț
Zapatista group, developed the FloodNet software to engage in
acts of
ECD: in 1998, they flooded the then President Ernesto Zedillo's
webpage with the list of people killed in Acteal. In December
2000, the
Electrohippies group organized a virtual "sitțin" of some
450,000
people to overload the WTO servers, and more recently, Our
World
Our Say staged a 30,000 person virtual march on the US
Embassy in
London to protest George W. Bush's visit to the United
Kingdom in
November 2003.[22]
In addition to the obvious difficulty to measure their degree of
success, whether in the "cool" medium of cyberspace or as "hot"
spaces of street actions, a possible disadvantage of this type of
initiatives is their inbuilt difficulty to generate consensus or to
develop
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 13 of 36
and pursue what Gramsci would call a "counterțhegemonic
project."
However, this might not be such a bad thing. Viral direct action
can
function both as an obstacle for largețscale institutional
transformations and as an alternative to resourcețheavy projects.
Instead of aiming to articulate a wide array of forces to
reinstitute the
political order or communal space as a whole, the rhizome setup
of
viral action connects a myriad of local and global initiatives—in
cyber
or physical space—without a master plan or a central command
structure. Groups and individuals can participate and share
resources
on their own terms quickly, visibly, and costțeffectively by
setting up
transient virtual communities of action that provide adțhoc
modes of
participation for people who are neither militants nor committed
activists. It is a postțhegemony mode of political action, or at
least a
mode of intervention that does not fit strictly within the logic of
hegemony.
This is precisely what makes viral initiatives so useful. Despite
appearances to the contrary, those who stay away from politics
are not
necessarily apolitical. Many still want to change the world, but
not all
the time, for they do not conform to Rousseau's idealized image
of
virtuous citizens who rush to assemblies when called. They
might be
unhappy with the available political options yet lack the time,
the
resources, or the inclination to build institutional alternatives.
This is
not so much a proof of depoliticization as it is an indication that
dispersed people or loosely organized groups rarely count as
political
stakeholders. In a way, they live citizenship as functional
denizens. The
rhizomețstructure of viral direct action can contribute to
counteract
this experience of disenfranchisement. Signing a petition over
the
web, refusing to buy tuna cans that lack the dolphințfriendly
label,
participating in boycotts of products imported from countries
with
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 14 of 36
repressive regimes, joining a virtual sitțin, or taking to the
streets to
join forces with those who oppose wars of aggression, enables
people
to support a cause and intervene in the public sphere without the
usual risks and the costs—not to mention the complex
logistics—
associated with collective action. Here "the public sphere"
might be a
misnomer, for viral action is often a crossover between the
public and
the private. It engenders fleeting, adțhoc publics that appear
whenever and wherever private individuals decide to act, even
if they
only connect with others in the virtual communities resulting
from the
circulation of a pamphlet or forwarded ețmails for a particular
action.
More institutionalțoriented interventions include the campaigns
to
condone the debt of poor countries or to allocate 0.7% of the
GDP of
developed countries to international aid. One of the more
ambitious
initiative to foster equality is the Tobin Tax Initiative
(www.tobintax.org)
supported by a wide array of networks and organizations such as
ATTAC, Global Exchange, the AFLțCIO, or DebtChannel.org.
The Tobin
tax, named after the Nobel laureate economist who first
suggested it,
aims to discourage the ubiquitous crossțborder financial flows
carried
out by currency speculators—estimated at 1.8 trillion US dollars
daily
—by imposing a sales tax of 0.1 to 0.3% on each trade. Such a
tax
would generate estimated revenues ranging from $100 to $300
billion
yearly. As the main financial markets are located in
industrialized
countries, this would amount to a net transfer of resources to
the
developing world. These funds could be earmarked for poverty
eradication, disease prevention, and environmental programs.
This is …
Authors:
Source:
Document Type:
Subject Terms:
Author-Supplied
Keywords:
NAICS/Industry
Codes:
Abstract:
Globalisation, Globalism and
Cosmopolitanism as an Educational Ideal.
Papastephanou, Marianna
Educational Philosophy & Theory. Aug2005, Vol. 37 Issue 4,
p533-551. 19p.
Article
*EDUCATION & globalization
*GLOBAL method of teaching
*TEACHING
*COSMOPOLITANISM
*EDUCATIONAL ideologies
*PHILOSOPHY of education
*EDUCATION
antagonism
Bauman
Dewey
Giddens
globalisation
hybridity
identity
Kristeva
nation-state
923110 Administration of Education Programs
611699 All Other Miscellaneous Schools and Instruction
611710 Educational Support Services
In this paper, I discuss globalisation as an empirical reality that
is in a
complex relation to its corresponding discourse and in a critical
distance
from the cosmopolitan ideal. I argue that failure to grasp the
distinctions
between globalisation, globalism, and cosmopolitanism derives
from
mistaken identifications of the Is with the Ought and leads to
naïve and
ethnocentric glorifications of the potentialities of globalisation.
Conversely,
drawing the appropriate distinctions helps us articulate a more
critical
1
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 1 of 2
Author Affiliations:
ISSN:
DOI:
Accession
Number:
Publisher Logo:
approach to contemporary cultural phenomena, and reconsider
the current
place and potential role of education within the context of
global affairs.
From this perspective, the antagonistic impulses cultivated by
globalisation
and some globalist discourse are singled out and targeted via a
radicalization of educational orientations. The final suggestion
of the article
concerns the vision of a more cosmopolitically sensitive
education.
[ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
Copyright of Educational Philosophy & Theory is the property
of Routledge
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or
posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However,
users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.
This abstract
may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the
copy.
Users should refer to the original published version of the
material for the
full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
University of Cyprus
0013-1857
10.1111/j.1469-5812.2005.00139.x
17715367
1
Plum Print
4/5/20, 10:08 PM
Page 2 of 2
5
Week 1 Assignment Two
Importance of Becoming a Global Citizen
Student’s Name
GEN499 General Education Capstone
Professor’s Name
1
Date
Note: This assignment should be written in the correct format
per APA guidelines. Please click on the Writing Center tab at
the left-hand toolbar of the course. You will then click on the
“Writing a Paper” tab, which goes over the basics of writing an
essay. For information on how to write in-text citations in APA
format, click on the “Citing Within Your Paper” link under the
Writing Center & Library tab. This paper needs to consist of
750 – 1,000 words (excluding the title and reference page).
Start your paper with the title of this assignment:
Importance of Becoming a Global Citizen
The introduction paragraph of this paper should inform the
reader of the topic you are writing about while providing
background information and the purpose or importance of
addressing this topic of global citizenship. You should prepare
the reader by stating the concepts you are about to address
further in your paper. Typically a good introduction paragraph
is made up of 5 – 7 sentences.
Short Title of First Prompt (i.e. Distinction between
“Globalism” and “Globalization”)
After viewing the required video “Globalization at a
Crossroads”, you need write a paragraph of 5 – 7 sentences
addressing the distinction between “globalism” and
“globalization” It’s important to cite the video per APA
guidelines within this paragraph.
Short Title of Second Prompt
Write a paragraph (about 5 sentences) describing how being a
global citizen in the world of advanced technology can be
beneficial to your success in meeting your persona, academic,
and professional goals.
Short Title of Third Prompt
After reading the article by Reysen and Katzarska-Miller,
you need to write a paragraph of 5 – 7 sentences explaining why
there has been a disagreement between theorists about the
definition of global citizenship. Within the article, the authors
address how specific schools of thought define global
citizenship. It would be a good idea to paraphrase this
information in your own words and cite the article per APA
guidelines. Also, within this paragraph, you should provide your
own definition of global citizenship after reading what other
ideas are from the article.
Short Title of Fourth Prompt
Note: Based on the article, you need to write two paragraphs: a
paragraph on each of the two outcomes of global citizenship you
chose (intergroup empathy, valuing diversity, social justice,
environmental sustainability, intergroup helping, and the level
of responsibility to act for the betterment of this world).
Name of First Outcome Addressed (i.e. Valuing Diversity)
Within this paragraph you need to explain why this outcome is
important in becoming a global citizen. It’s a good idea to first
define the outcome in your own words and then provide a
thorough explanation on why it’s important for your own
development as a global citizen.
Name of Second Outcome Addressed (i.e. Social Justice)
Same instructions as the first paragraph above.
Short Title for Fifth Prompt
First Personal Example on (Name First Outcome)
You need to write a short paragraph describing a personal
experience that has corresponds to the first outcome you
addressed in the third prompt and has assisted or resulted in
your development as a global citizen.
Second Personal Example on (Name of Second Outcome)
You need to write a short paragraph describing a personal
experience that has corresponds to the second outcome you
addressed in the third prompt and has assisted or resulted in
your development as a global citizen.
Short Title of Sixth Prompt
You need to write a 5 – 7 sentence paragraph that identifies two
specific education courses and explains how each of those
courses assisted or influenced your development in becoming a
global citizen.
Conclusion
In this paragraph, you need to summarize the main points of this
assignment and include a description of why this topic is
important to address when it comes to the development of
global citizenship. Typically a good conclusion paragraph
consists of 5 – 7 sentences. Keep in mind that you should not
share new information in the conclusion paragraph. This means
that there should not be any in-text citations. You are basically
summarizing what you have written.
References
Note: References are written below in the correct format per
APA guidelines. In addition to these two required resources,
you must locate another scholarly source from the Ashford
University Library that applies to this topic and can be used to
support your perspective.
Reysen, S., & Katzarska-Miller, I. (2013). A model of global
citizenship: Antecedents and outcomes. International Journal of
Psychology, 48(5), 858-870.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00207594.2012.701749
Stucke, K. (Writer). (2009). Globalization at a crossroads
[Series episode]. In M. Stucke & Claudin, C. (Executive
Producers), Global issues.
https://fod.infobase.com/OnDemandEmbed.aspx?token=39350&
wID=100753&plt=FOD&loid=0&w=640&h=480&fWidth=660&
fHeight=530

More Related Content

Similar to MAT 308 Test 1 Chapters 6 & 7(170 Total Points)Show All Work!.docx

Essays On Science Fiction
Essays On Science FictionEssays On Science Fiction
Essays On Science Fictionnenid1simut3
 
Essays On Science Fiction.pdf
Essays On Science Fiction.pdfEssays On Science Fiction.pdf
Essays On Science Fiction.pdfMichelle Montoya
 
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docxpaynetawnya
 
Global Warming Essay
Global Warming EssayGlobal Warming Essay
Global Warming EssayDenise Snow
 
Essay Economic Problem. Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...
Essay Economic Problem.  Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...Essay Economic Problem.  Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...
Essay Economic Problem. Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...Claire Flanagan
 
Good Compare And Contrast Essay
Good Compare And Contrast EssayGood Compare And Contrast Essay
Good Compare And Contrast EssayKathy Murray
 
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing ArgumentsArts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing ArgumentsUWAStudySmarter
 
Globalization Pros And Cons Essay
Globalization Pros And Cons EssayGlobalization Pros And Cons Essay
Globalization Pros And Cons EssayLauren Smith
 
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdf
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdfEssay On Health Care Reform.pdf
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdfVicki Ardon
 
Examples Of Definition Essays
Examples Of Definition EssaysExamples Of Definition Essays
Examples Of Definition EssaysShannon Green
 
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright B.docx
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright  B.docxReview of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright  B.docx
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright B.docxmichael591
 
Future of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- EssayFuture of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- EssaySnowPea Guh
 
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay Telegraph
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay  TelegraphEssay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay  Telegraph
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay TelegraphFrances Armijo
 
Hofstede and globe the ecological fallacy
Hofstede and globe  the ecological fallacyHofstede and globe  the ecological fallacy
Hofstede and globe the ecological fallacyBrendan McSweeney
 
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdf
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdfPersonal Descriptive Essay Example.pdf
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdfJessica Spyrakis
 
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay  Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay  Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...Lisa Phon
 

Similar to MAT 308 Test 1 Chapters 6 & 7(170 Total Points)Show All Work!.docx (20)

Essays On Science Fiction
Essays On Science FictionEssays On Science Fiction
Essays On Science Fiction
 
Essays On Science Fiction.pdf
Essays On Science Fiction.pdfEssays On Science Fiction.pdf
Essays On Science Fiction.pdf
 
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx
1. The formula for a regression equation based on a sample size of.docx
 
Global Warming Essay
Global Warming EssayGlobal Warming Essay
Global Warming Essay
 
Essay Economic Problem. Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...
Essay Economic Problem.  Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...Essay Economic Problem.  Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...
Essay Economic Problem. Economic problem essay. The Basic Economic Problem. ...
 
Good Compare And Contrast Essay
Good Compare And Contrast EssayGood Compare And Contrast Essay
Good Compare And Contrast Essay
 
What is globalization
What is globalizationWhat is globalization
What is globalization
 
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing ArgumentsArts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
 
Globalization Pros And Cons Essay
Globalization Pros And Cons EssayGlobalization Pros And Cons Essay
Globalization Pros And Cons Essay
 
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdf
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdfEssay On Health Care Reform.pdf
Essay On Health Care Reform.pdf
 
Text 9 2012 general
Text 9 2012 generalText 9 2012 general
Text 9 2012 general
 
Text 9 2012 general
Text 9 2012 generalText 9 2012 general
Text 9 2012 general
 
Examples Of Definition Essays
Examples Of Definition EssaysExamples Of Definition Essays
Examples Of Definition Essays
 
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright B.docx
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright  B.docxReview of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright  B.docx
Review of International Studies (2007), 33, 3–24 Copyright B.docx
 
Future of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- EssayFuture of Modernization- Essay
Future of Modernization- Essay
 
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay Telegraph
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay  TelegraphEssay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay  Telegraph
Essay On Climate Change. Climate Change Essay Telegraph
 
Hofstede and globe the ecological fallacy
Hofstede and globe  the ecological fallacyHofstede and globe  the ecological fallacy
Hofstede and globe the ecological fallacy
 
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdf
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdfPersonal Descriptive Essay Example.pdf
Personal Descriptive Essay Example.pdf
 
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay  Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay  Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...
Essay On Non Violence. Violence Essay Essay on Violence for Students and Chi...
 
Counterterrorism Model Effectiveness
Counterterrorism Model EffectivenessCounterterrorism Model Effectiveness
Counterterrorism Model Effectiveness
 

More from tienboileau

MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docx
MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docxMAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docx
MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docxtienboileau
 
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docx
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docxMasters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docx
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docxtienboileau
 
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docx
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docxMartin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docx
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docxtienboileau
 
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docx
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docxMass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docx
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docxtienboileau
 
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docx
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docxMarys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docx
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docxtienboileau
 
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docx
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docxMasaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docx
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docxtienboileau
 
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docx
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docxMatthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docx
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docxtienboileau
 
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docxMBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docxtienboileau
 
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docx
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docxmax 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docx
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docxtienboileau
 
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project This capsto.docx
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project  This capsto.docxMBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project  This capsto.docx
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project This capsto.docxtienboileau
 
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric  .docxMBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric  .docx
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric .docxtienboileau
 
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docx
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docxMary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docx
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docxtienboileau
 
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docx
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docxMaryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docx
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docxtienboileau
 
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docx
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docxMartha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docx
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docxtienboileau
 
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docx
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docxMaterials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docx
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docxtienboileau
 
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docx
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docxMasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docx
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docxtienboileau
 
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docx
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docxMATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docx
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docxtienboileau
 
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docx
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docxMaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docx
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docxtienboileau
 
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docx
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docxMaster75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docx
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docxtienboileau
 
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docx
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docxMarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docx
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docxtienboileau
 

More from tienboileau (20)

MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docx
MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docxMAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docx
MAT308Chapter 10 Test (75 Points)Show You Work!(1) The mean .docx
 
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docx
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docxMasters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docx
Masters level forum Compare and contrast what President Woodrow .docx
 
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docx
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docxMartin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docx
Martin Wolf MARCH 24 2020 The coronavirus seeks only t.docx
 
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docx
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docxMass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docx
Mass movementChoose oneA.  happens only when the slope .docx
 
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docx
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docxMarys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docx
Marys one year old daughter is due to be given the Measles, Mum.docx
 
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docx
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docxMasaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docx
Masaccio, Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, 1426-27.docx
 
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docx
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docxMatthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docx
Matthew Shepard Was Killed Due To His Sexual Orientation. Defend, Ch.docx
 
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docxMBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 665 Final Project Milestone Three Guidelines and Rubric .docx
 
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docx
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docxmax 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docx
max 200 words due in 2 hoursSummarize the article by parap.docx
 
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project This capsto.docx
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project  This capsto.docxMBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project  This capsto.docx
MBA 599 – Strategic Management Case Project This capsto.docx
 
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric .docx
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric  .docxMBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric  .docx
MBA 640 Final Project Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric .docx
 
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docx
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docxMary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docx
Mary and Elmer’s fifth child, Melvin, was born 6 weeks prematurely a.docx
 
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docx
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docxMaryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docx
Maryland Technology Consultants is a fictitious company create.docx
 
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docx
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docxMartha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docx
Martha Rogers’ Science of Unitary Human BeingsFOR THE THEORY CRI.docx
 
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docx
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docxMaterials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docx
Materials for Your Works Cited PagesNOTE When you are writing.docx
 
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docx
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docxMasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docx
MasubenPrivate equity firm can be very helpful for a company’s g.docx
 
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docx
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docxMATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docx
MATH 114Discussion Board Forum 2 PromptPlease also pay close a.docx
 
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docx
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docxMaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docx
MaterialsGeology.com (httpsgeology.comrocks) as .docx
 
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docx
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docxMaster75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docx
Master75.18473.416-216.822-62.774-98.972229103.995-200225121Pref.docx
 
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docx
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docxMarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docx
MarketingModes of CommunicationHierarchy of Effect.docx
 

Recently uploaded

Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphThiyagu K
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...christianmathematics
 
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docx
psychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docxpsychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docx
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docxPoojaSen20
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdfQucHHunhnh
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesCeline George
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsTechSoup
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...EduSkills OECD
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAssociation for Project Management
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionMaksud Ahmed
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Shubhangi Sonawane
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfagholdier
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdfQucHHunhnh
 
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfAn Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfSanaAli374401
 
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.MateoGardella
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfAdmir Softic
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxDenish Jangid
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxAreebaZafar22
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxVishalSingh1417
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
 
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docx
psychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docxpsychiatric  nursing HISTORY  COLLECTION  .docx
psychiatric nursing HISTORY COLLECTION .docx
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
 
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfAn Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
 
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
Gardella_Mateo_IntellectualProperty.pdf.
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
 

MAT 308 Test 1 Chapters 6 & 7(170 Total Points)Show All Work!.docx

  • 1. MAT 308 Test 1 Chapters 6 & 7(170 Total Points) Show All Work! Name:_______________ 1. Find the value of Zsuch that 0.0500 of the area under the curve lies to the right of the Z (5 points). 2. Find the value of Zsuch that 0.2000 of the area under the curve lies to the left of the Z (5 points). 3. The random variable X has a normal distribution with a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 25(5 points each). a. Find probability that X is between 85 & 120 b. Find probability that X is greater than 130 c. Find probability that X is less than 75 d. Find probability that X is between 95 & 105 e. Find probability that X is less than 100 4. Suppose the random variable X has a population mean of 50 and a standard deviation of 10. Calculate the mean and the standard deviation of the sample mean for each of the following sample sizes (5 points each). a. n=25 b. n=40 c. n=55 d. n=65 e. What happens to the size of the standard deviation of the sample mean as the sample size increases? 5. A national report stated that 72% of trucks sold were extended cab. John took a random sample of 200 trucks. What is the probability that less than 116 trucks were extended cab?(10 points)
  • 2. 6. Find the Z-score for (5 points each): a. Area of .9870 to its left b. Area of 0.035 to its right c. Area represents the 40th percentile d. Area between –Z and Z is 0.90 e. Area to left of –Z and the right of Z totals 0.20 7. Calculate the standard score (Z-Score)(5 points each). a. μ = 95 and σ = 15; x = 110 b. μ = 110 and σ = 12.5; x = 70 c. μ = 100 and σ = 22; x = 115 8. With a standard normal distribution find (5 points each): a. area between -1.00 and 1.00 b. area less than 2.45 c. area more than -2.05 d. area less than -.55 and more than .85 9. Body temperatures of adults are normally distributed with a mean of 98.6˚ and a standard deviation of 0.45˚.What is the probability that a healthy adult will have a temperature that differs from the mean by more than 2.00˚?(10 points) 10. The heights of women are normally distributed with a mean of 63.6 inches and a standard deviation 2.8 inches. With a sample size of 35 women find (5 points each): a. Probability that an individual woman is more than 71.5 inches tall
  • 3. b. Probability that the sample of women are less than 65.5 inches tall c. Probability that the sample of women are between 56.5 and 71.5 inches tall d. Probability that the sample of women are less than 64 inches or greater than 72 inches tall 11. In one region, the September energy consumption levels for single-family homes are found to be normally distributed with a mean of 1150 kw and a standard deviation of 228kw. If 50 different homes are randomly selected, find the probability that their mean energy consumption level for September is greater than 1175kw (10 points). COLLEGE LITERATURE: A JOURNAL OF CRITICAL LITERARY STUDIES 44.4 Fall 2017 Print ISSN 0093-3139 E-ISSN 1542-4286 © Johns Hopkins University Press and West Chester University 2017 TRANSNATIONALISM AND ANTI-GLOBALISM JOHANNES VOELZ The recent resurgence of nationalism in the United States finds expression in a whole vocabulary, made up of slogans, rallying cries, and buzzwords. Most prominent among them may be
  • 4. “Make America Great Again” and “America First,” but there is another buzzword—anti-globalism—which is particularly suggestive of the conundrum transnationalism faces in the Age of Trump. The term anti-globalism results from an act of rhetorical appropriation and resignification, and as I want to suggest, the idea of transnationalism plays an important role in this repackaging effort. Anti-globalism recalls the anti-globalization movement of the 1990s and early 2000s, but this resonance brings out the differences rather than similarities between the two: where anti- globalization was concerned with a critique of the economic system, anti- global- ism attacks what is perceived as a larger ideology of globalism that allegedly promotes free trade as well as cultural and racial mixing. From the view of the leftist anti-globalization movement, globaliza- tion was driven by the institutions that backed the Washington Con- sensus (such as the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and the US Treasury), global corporations that exploited the waning sovereignty of nation-states, and national governments that colluded with the forces of global capital, for instance by entering into inter- national free trade agreements, such as the North American Free
  • 5. 522 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017 Trade Agreement. The targets of that earlier movement were there- fore the profiteers and structures of economic globalization. This economic understanding of globalization opened up a space for alternative conceptions of globalization that could compete with the economic version. It is no coincidence, therefore, that it was also in the late 1990s and early 2000s that the academic field of Amer- ican Studies turned to the transnational as an emerging paradigm. American Studies entered its transnational phase by engaging in profound soul-searching about the possibilities of altering the object of study seemingly prescribed by the field’s name (see, for instance, Janice Radway’s 1998 Presidential Address at the American Studies Association, titled “What’s in a Name?”). Although rather diverse manifestos appeared in quick succession, there emerged a consensus that sticking to the nation form was a sign of ideological backward- ness, whereas transcending the nation held out the potential for pro- gressive change. From the get-go, transnational American Studies
  • 6. aimed to transcend the nation on two different conceptual planes: first, on the level of methodology, where transnationalism in essence meant adopting a particular perspective; second, on the level of the object of study, where transnationalism referred to phenomena that went beyond the limits of the nation. This blending of method and object of study meant in effect that the transnational wasn’t some- thing one could neutrally observe, describe, and chart. Rather, studying the transnational meant affirming the transnational. This is because the approval for the new method jumped over, as it were, to an approval of the phenomena studied. If, in other words, the transnational perspective of scholars was greeted as the successful overcoming of critical parochialism, then phenomena embodying the transnational were themselves to be commended. This valua- tion guided the choice of what was to be studied: Preferred objects included oppositional social movements that traversed national boundaries, aesthetic forms that traveled beyond the confines of the nation, and ideas that circulated in similarly unbounded ways (clearly, this list is not meant to be comprehensive). In short, transnational American Studies provided the opportunity to salvage a “globaliza- tion from below” (to use a phrase popular with the anti- globalization
  • 7. movement), and to favorably contrast it to both nationalism and eco- nomic globalization (or “globalization from above”). One of the problems faced—but rarely addressed—by propo- nents of transnationalism emerged from this differentiation of eco- nomic and cultural globalization. Did the idea that these two forms of globalization are principally different really hold up? Didn’t both Johannes Voelz | CRITICAL FORUM 523 visions of globalization rely on some of the very same images: flows (of goods, people, ideas) as something natural, borders and bound- aries as artificial? Wasn’t there, in fact, a deep affinity between the longing for cultural transnationalism and the ideology of economic globalization, despite the political differences that seemed to keep them both neatly separated? I have argued elsewhere that conceptu- ally (though not politically) transnational American Studies is indeed indebted to economic globalization, and that it is nonetheless advis- able to pursue the project of transnationalism, albeit in a self- re- flexive manner (Voelz 2011). But rather than revisiting this debate
  • 8. at this point, suffice it to say that the question of transnationalism’s oppositional purity emerged from the somewhat tenuous conceptual framework shared by the anti-globalization movement and transna- tional Americanists: globalization, according to this framework, had an economic and a cultural aspect, which were to be seen as opposed to one another. Quite some time has passed since the early 2000s. By now, aca- demic transnationalism in American literary and cultural stud- ies has been solidly institutionalized. Think only of the Journal of Transnational American Studies, the recent Cambridge Companion to Transnational American Literature, edited by Yogita Goyal (2017), or the founding of the “Obama Institute for Transnational American Studies” at the University of Mainz, Germany. Meanwhile, pre- dictably, the hype that initially attended the “transnational turn” has faded rather quickly. The anti-globalization movement, on the other hand, has largely run out steam, mostly because center- left parties across North America and Europe failed to support it; they embraced neoliberal reforms instead, a decision which has cost many of them a good share of their votes. (One could add that the move- ment only petered out after the demise of Occupy, or that, in fact,
  • 9. it has survived in places like Spain, where Podemos has managed to transform the protest against neoliberal globalization into party politics—but these are nuances that don’t change the big picture.) Along with the overall decline of anti-globalization came the rise of anti-globalism (itself a movement of transnational scope), and thus the seemingly miraculous transformation of a left-wing into a right- wing movement. How in the world could that happen? In moving the critique of globalization across the political spectrum, anti-globalists have rejected the foundational premise of anti-globalization and academic transnationalism: they refuse to differentiate between two differ- ent kinds of globalization, be they “from below and from above,” 524 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017 “cultural and economic,” or simply “good and bad.” As London- based blogger Jacob Stringer has aptly summarized it on opendemocracy. net: “[Anti-]Globalisation refers to certain processes in the interests of corporate trade. [Anti-]Globalism refers to a global outlook, bor-
  • 10. ders too open, a feared mingling of cultures, implied dangerous liai- sons with aliens” (March 26, 2017). Anti-globalists, in other words, have tied the critique of economic globalization to xenophobia, rac- ism, and a disdain for global elites, and have thus conceptualized economic and cultural globalization as hanging together. Anti-globalists’ longing for cultural isolationism, it must be admitted, has rendered the economic dimension of anti- globalism strikingly toothless. It is as if they offered cultural anti- globalism as a solution to the problems caused by global capitalism: their implied economic platform seems to be limited to the call for protectionism (the economic dimension of “America First!”) and the hope for more high-paying manufacturing jobs. In Strangers in Their Own Land, sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild (2016) has recently shown just how deeply the Tea Party members and Trump supporters she inter- viewed in Louisiana are invested in the free market, and how much they detest the welfare state. Their critique of economic globaliza- tion spares multinational corporations (even if these corporations, like the petrochemical companies in Louisiana, ruin the environ- ment and cause a virtual cancer epidemic) because they are seen
  • 11. as the older siblings of small businesses run by local entrepreneurs. Though the anti-globalists’ mix of economic and cultural anti- glo- balism may be rife with logical faults and moral deficiencies, their triumph should not be simply dismissed as racist and xenophobic (though it is that, too). Instead, their rise should prompt scholars of transnationalism to reflect on the involvement of the idea of the transnational in the political struggle that divides the United States and, increasingly, other countries in which right-wing populism has taken hold. In this context, it becomes newly significant that transnational Americanists have tended to politically identify with the transnational formations they study and that they have thus, as described earlier, conflated method and object of study. As a result of this conflation, academic transnationalism has come to embody the idea of globalism targeted by the anti-globalist agenda. Econom- ically, transnationalism encapsulates the privileged status of a global elite (here, transnationalism refers to the scholars) and culturally, it raises fears of migration, hybridity, and the demise of white hege- mony (here, transnationalism refers to the phenomena studied).
  • 12. Seen in this light, the idea of globalism embodied by transnational Johannes Voelz | CRITICAL FORUM 525 American Studies becomes a tailor-made point of attack for what John Judis, in The Populist Explosion (2016), has described as the tri- angular scapegoating of right-wing populism. Right-wing populism is triangular in that it claims to defend “the people” against two per- ceived enemies: the elites (situated above) and undeserving “others” (situated below). The challenge of anti-globalism, then, is not only that it rejects transnationalism’s starting premise of the two kinds of globaliza- tion, but, more crucially, that it brings to light the degree to which transnationalism is itself involved in the divisive struggle currently rocking the United States. This challenge, I think, can be seen as a welcome opportunity to generate a new kind of knowledge from within transnational American Studies. It calls for an approach that is more self-reflexive than the identificatory stance taken by many scholars of transnationalism so far. Rather than starting from the
  • 13. presumption that studying transnational formations means helping to fight the good fight, transnational American Studies could begin to chart how the transnational itself has become a currency, or capital, in the struggle for symbolic advantages in a starkly divided society. This isn’t to devalue the study of transnational formations, but rather to come to realize that embracing and valuing the transna- tional is a maneuver that helps secure symbolically advantageous positions. This is the case both in the academic field of American Studies, which has long been organized around a moral economy of political engagement, and in the larger public sphere of the United States. The idea (taken from Bourdieu) is not that we consciously try to amass as much symbolic capital as possible—as if we were rational-choice actors in the field of symbolic capital—but instead that trying to carve out for ourselves a recognized position in the field of transnational American Studies is what it means to “have an investment in the game” (Bourdieu and Wacquant 1992, 98). The same goes for the other side of the divide: the embrace of anti-globalism speaks to the specific value of the ideas and princi- ples captured by the term transnationalism in the broader political
  • 14. discourse of the United States. Here, too, the currency of the idea of transnationalism has a particular valuation. The fact that we may think of this value as “negative” when used by anti-globalists begins to suggest that taking stock of transnationalism as a currency helps us capture its political existence. I am suggesting, in other words, to incorporate a self-reflexive and relational sociology of the trans- national into the program of transnational American literary and cultural studies. 526 COLLEGE LITERATURE | 44.4 Fall 2017 One of the welcome ramifications of such an extension of Amer- icanist transnationalism, it seems to me, would be to overcome the harmful dualism of nation and trans-nation. Ultimately, this dualism suggests that by turning to the transnational, we will have to learn to stop worrying about the nation-state. But Trump’s rise to power should make it apparent that American Studies needs to be able to provide explanations of what goes on inside the United States. The truly surprising suggestion to be taken away from the rise of anti-globalism is this: a self-reflexively and relationally revamped
  • 15. transnational American Studies may provide a necessary tool for coming to terms with the nationalist resurgence. WORKS CITED Bourdieu, Pierre, and Loïc Wacquant. 1992. An Invitation to Reflexive Sociol- ogy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Goyal, Yogita, ed. 2017. The Cambridge Companion to Transnational American Literature. New York: Cambridge University Press. Hochschild, Arlie Russell. 2016. Strangers in their Own Land: Anger and Mourning on the American Right. New York: The New Press. Judis, John. 2016. The Populist Explosion: How the Great Recession Transformed American and European Politics. New York: Columbia Global Reports. Ebook. Radway, Janice. 1999. “What’s in a Name? Presidential Address to the American Studies Association, 20 November, 1998.” American Quarterly 51.1: 1–32. Stringer, Jacob. “Why did anti-globalisation fail and anti- globalism suc- ceed?” Open Democracy. March 26, 2017. Opendemocracy.net. Last vis- ited: May 28, 2017. Voelz, Johannes. 2011. “Utopias of Transnationalism and the
  • 16. Neoliberal State.” In Re-Framing the Transnational Turn in American Studies, edited by Winfried Fluck, Donald E. Pease, and John Carlos Rowe. Hanover, NH: University Press of New England. JOHANNES VOELZ is Heisenberg-Professor of American Studies, Democracy, and Aesthetics at Goethe-University Frankfurt, Ger- many. He is the author of Transcendental Resistance: The New Amer- icanists and Emerson’s Challenge (UP New England, 2010) and The Poetics of Insecurity: American Fiction and the Uses of Threat (Cambridge UP, forthcoming 2017). Reproduced with permission of copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Listen Plum Print The assumption of this article is that the "second great transformation" proposed by global actors parallels the one advanced by those who resisted laissezțfaire capitalism in the 19th century. Both
  • 17. dispute the unilateral imposition of a new planetary order and endeavor to modify the rhythm and direction of economic processes presented as either fact or fate. In doing so, they effectively place the question of the political institution of this order on the agenda. I look briefly at the familiar underside of globalism and then move on to develop a tentative typology of initiatives that set the tone for a politics of globalization. These include radical and viral direct action, the improvement of the terms of exchange between industrialized and developing countries, the expansion of the public sphere outside national borders through global networks, the accountability of multilateral organizations, and the advancement of democracy at a supranational level. Participants in these initiatives take politics beyond the liberalțdemocratic format of elections and partisan competition within the nationțstate. They exercise an informal supranational citizenship that reclaims—and at the same time reformulates— the banners of social justice, solidarity, and internationalism as part of the public agenda. Ever since the market ceased to be a taboo and globalization became a dominant cognitive framework, the Left seems to have confined itself to a principled commitment toward the dispossessed and a continual
  • 18. call for measures to ameliorate inequality. Outside the mainstream, globaliphobic groups—an expression I use as shorthand to designate the naysayer as well as Beck's "black," "green," and "red" 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 1 of 36 protectionists[ 1]—offer more militant, yet scarcely innovative responses. They conceive globalization as a purely negative phenomenon, little more than old capitalism dressed in new clothes. For them, especially the red and black globaliphobes, the assault on sovereignty spearheaded by governments and multilateral agencies in the name of international trade strengthens the hand of the business and financial community, compromises the autonomy of domestic political decisions, and reinforces the submissive status of less developed countries to the dictates of the major industrial nations. Globaliphobes are quite right about this, but they also think about the phenomenon from a reductionist perspective that confuses globalization with what Beck calls "globalism," that is, "the ideology of rule by the world market, the ideology of neoliberalism."[ 3] In doing so, they neglect the range of contending forces set into motion by the process of globalization itself. The paradoxical effect of this
  • 19. confusion is that their diagnostic converges with that of the neoliberal right: both conceive globalization as a victory of liberalism, except that each assigns opposite values to it. Yet the hegemony of the market and free trade is not quite the same as the victory of liberalism tout court. When one looks at the efforts to recast the rules and the institutional design of the international order that has been emerging from the ruins of the Berlin wall, the thesis of a liberal end of history proves to be somewhat premature. Globalism undermines Westphalian sovereignty and deepens inequality, but also has at least a potential for political innovation as the resistance to globalism opens the doors for an expansion of collective action beyond its conventional enclosure within national borders. Notwithstanding the unipolarity of the international order, the wide array of new global warriors that rally around the banner of the World 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 2 of 36 Social Forum—"another world is possible"—are assembling a politics that seeks to move the current setting beyond mere globalism.
  • 20. This intervention examines some of the symptoms of this move. Every age of great changes brings along an underside. Nineteenthț century industrialization unleashed a productive power on a scale unknown before while it simultaneously destroyed traditional communities, virtually wiped out the cottage industry of artisan production, and created a new urban underclass. Industrial society also saw the emergence of efforts to resist and modify the capitalist reorganization of the world. Globalization, with its remarkable time– space compression and its impact on our perception of distance,[ 4] presents us with an underside too. It has three salient aspects: the deepening gap between rich and poor countries, the creation of a mobile elite and an increasingly confined mass, and the resurrection of more rigid and less liberal models of identity as a defensive reaction to the dislocations brought upon by globalization under the guise of globalism. The first point has been discussed profusely.[ 5] For the purpose of our argument, it suffices to point out that one does not need to be an orthodox communist or a Rousseauțstyle egalitarian to understand that a minimum threshold of equality is required to shore up
  • 21. governance and level the field for participants in the public sphere. The second aspect addresses a sociological issue. While moral indignation in the face of human suffering is not enough to reorient the global patterns of development towards greater social justice and solidarity, the persistence of exclusion confirms the coexistence of two worlds or lifețexperiences concerning globalization. These typically show themselves, and converge, in one place, border crossings, and 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 3 of 36 around one issue, mobility. Advocates of globalism extol the virtues of the free transit of capitals, goods, services, and people. Without it, globalization faces a real and perhaps unsurpassable limit. That is why the World Trade Organization (WTO) insists on this free passage. However, migratory controls to stop the entry of those fleeing from poverty or persecution multiply. The freedom of the market, say Zincone and Agnew, entails a schizophrenic logic—positive for capital and negative for labor.[ 6] The UN reports something similar: "The collapse of space, time and borders may be creating a global village,
  • 22. but not everyone can be a citizen. The global professional elite now face low borders, but billions of others find borders as high as ever."[ 7] Bauman builds on this to identify a novel socioțpolitical division developing in the global order. If distance has ceased to be an obstacle only for the rich—since for the poor it never was more than a shackle—this creates a new type of division between the haves and the haves not. The former are tourists who travel because they can and want to do so, while the latter are vagabonds, people who move because the world around them is unbearable, more of a prison than a home.[ 8] While the vagabond is the nightmare of the tourist, he says, they share something in that they are both "radicalized" consumers— they are embarked in a continual pursuit of satisfaction fueled by desire rather than by the object of desire—only that the former is a "defective" one. Thus, they are not mutually exclusive categories, both because tourists might become vagabonds and because one might occupy the position of the tourist in some domains and of the vagabond in others. The third salient aspect of globalization arises from the exponential increase in the pace of political, technological, economic, or cultural
  • 23. change. Its impact is undecidable. It can be lived as an opening up of 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 4 of 36 possibilities for emancipatory projects or as a threat to identity and to the certainties of a more familiar world. When the latter gains the upper hand, people might turn to aggressive forms of nationalism, religious orthodoxy, tribalism, or messianic leaders—none of which are likely to enhance toleration—with the expectation of restoring certainty. This is not entirely new. The industrial revolution also undermined the referents of everyday life without offering cultural responses, at least not at the beginning. Marx and Engels describe the distinctive traits of the dislocations brought upon by capitalism in a wellțknown passage of the Manifesto. They say: Constant revolutionizing of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. All fixed, fastțfrozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all newțformed ones become antiquated
  • 24. before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned. Nationalism helped to counteract this "uninterrupted disturbance" that undermined identities and governmentality. Kahler argues that in the 19th century, especially after the expansion of the franchise, the emergence of mass nationalism had a political function, for it enabled states to forge strong links with the citizenry and to ensure their loyalty in an age of democracy. Later, anticommunism and the promise of economic prosperity replaced nationalism as a political programmed.[ 9] Globalism has nothing comparable to offer, or rather, as Debray remarks, it seems to offer no other mystique than the prospect of economic growth.[10] The latter is certainly desirable, at least if one expects some form of income distribution as its side effect, but it is 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 5 of 36 probably not enough to sway those whose livelihood and identity are threatened by the rapid reorganization of labor markets and trade patterns. As suggested, the danger here is the possible appeal of
  • 25. projects that offer certainty at the expense of toleration. The strong and often violent revival of nationalism and the aggressive affirmation of ethnic identities illustrate an uncanny hardening of territorial and cultural frontiers in a global setting where the role of borders is supposed to have waned. This is complicated further by the rise of religious radicalism and by the religious coding of the global terrorism that became notorious after the events of 9/11. Since then, those hitherto known as freedom fighters became the security nightmare of the West. Much to the chagrin of those advocating the end of history in the aftermath of the Cold War, the enduring presence of such radicalism shows that the liberal worldțview is not without rivals. Interestingly, Debray describes religious radicalism—but not religious terrorism—as a defensive response to the loss of a sense of belonging, or better still, to the dislocation of cultural referents in the wake of globalism. He argues that when people feel lost the list of "believers" usually grows. That is why he says that sometimes religion (but we could also say "nationalism" or "ethnic intolerance," which are similar in this respect) turns out to be not the opium of the people but the vitamin of the weak.[11] Globalism therefore revolutionizes the certainties of the past and
  • 26. inserts entire populations into a more open, changing and diverse world, often enhancing the array of options of how and where to live their lives. Bauman's tourists embody this freedom of choice and movement, so dear to liberal thought. Yet it also reminds us of a possible trade off between these new possibilities and the relative security that accompanied identities in a more parochial world. 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 6 of 36 Bauman captures this disorientation when he speaks of globalization as the perception of "things getting out of hand."[12] The question here is not simply the fear of turning into vagabonds or remaining trapped forever in that position; it refers instead to the demand for certainty, a desire for more rigid codes that function as navigational maps for living in a world in constant flux. This is what Debray had in mind when he described religion as a vitamin of the weak. This vitamin, however, is not sought by the casualties of globalism alone, but also by the champions of globalism who must now face the flip side of cheap airfares, cheap weapons, and cheap digital communications being available to its opponents too. In an international scene dominated by a neoțHobbesian concern for
  • 27. security—terrorism, AIDS, drugs or immigration—the trade off between a rapidly changing world and the demand for certainty—both in the center and in the periphery of global capitalism— reinforces our suspicion about a facile endorsement of a liberal telos of history. It does so if only because it reveals that not everyone sees capitalism— which Milton Friedman famously characterized as a general freedom to choose—and political liberalism as universally valid goods, and because sometimes the very advocates of those values easily override them by imposing illegal tariffs on imports or by engaging in wars of aggression in the name of prosperity and security. Yet to accept this underside as a necessary consequence of globalization is to submit to the naturalist fallacy of globalism, which presents the unilateral imposition of a world order modeled around the Washington Consensus as our destiny instead of as an act of political institution. Arguably, one could say that the war on terrorism unleashed after 9/11 reactivates its political origin. It is the true index of globalization, or if one prefers, an implicit acknowledgement that 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 7 of 36
  • 28. globalism seeks to hegemonize globalization but can neither control nor exhaust it. However, it is the disagreement with and resistance to the current state of things that reactivates it explicitly. What type of resistance? Another parallel with the 19th century can help to clarify this. Simplifying things a bit, the range of responses of those excluded from the benefits of the industrial revolution oscillated between two perspectives. One was the destruction of machines advocated by the Luddites in the revolts of the 1810s and 1820s in the North of England—mainly the Midlands, Yorkshire, and Lancashire. Theirs was a mode of direct action motivated by near starvation and the desperation stemming from it, but also by a desire to restore the working conditions of earlier times, which presupposed that a return to the prețindustrial economy of smallțscale producers and artisans was a viable alternative. Marx and the International Working Men's Association or First International exemplified the other position. For them there was little or no room for nostalgia since capitalism was here to stay, so the political task of the day was not to destroy machines but to organize the resistance of the dispossessed through trade unions and other movements. Their aim was to transform capitalism from within in order to build a more just and
  • 29. fraternal society. In the celebrated opening lines of the Manifesto, their socialist and internationalist project was the specter haunting Europe—or rather, the European ruling classes. Polanyi sees the alternative in similar, yet less revolutionary terms, as he claims that by the 1830s " [E]ither machines had to be demolished, as the Luddites had tried to do, or a regular labor market had to be created. Thus was mankind forced into the paths of a utopian experiment."[13] Today we face a similar challenge and a new specter, one haunting the 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 8 of 36 neoliberal efforts to reduce globalization to globalism. While globaliphobes—in many ways the latterțday Luddites—see globalization as the ruse of capitalism and call for a return to the stateț centered and protectionist policies of the past, others have chosen to become global warriors to transform the current state of affairs. Like their socialist predecessors in the industrial age, the more lucid critics of the global condition are not against globalization or trade per se. Just like those who opposed Gulf War II were not always pacifists, in
  • 30. the sense that many did not pose a moral injunction to war as such but only to a war that lacked the moral and political legitimacy of a UN resolution, these critics are not necessarily opposed to globalization but rather to globalism.[14] They do not stand in awe for the momentum it has gathered nor delude themselves about the eventual disappearance of its negative effects either. They partake in the global fray to modify the course of globalization from within. Global warriors aim to bring about what Zincone and Agnew, in a felicitous play of words with the title of Polanyi's celebrated study of industrialization, call the political phase of the "second great transformation."[15] We can read the latter as a move from globalism to globalization, which amounts to an effort to politicize economic processes currently mystified as either fact or fate. I propose a tentative typology of the initiatives undertaken by globalțminded actors. It functions as a provisional guideline to differentiate forms of collective action that seek to modify the course of globalization. Their common trait is the resistance to the Washington Consensus of the 1990s—captured in ATTAC's slogan "The World is not for Sale"—in order to transform globalism from within and below. Their actions extend the political field
  • 31. —and by implication, the scope of citizenship—beyond the enclosure of the nationțstate. As in any classification, the boundaries between 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 9 of 36 the various groupings are somewhat porous, as initiatives tend to overlap and to appear conjointly. I will distinguish six types, the first two being common to political activism more generally. The lingering perception of the antițglobalization (i.e. antiț globalism) movement consists of a string of cities—Seattle, Prague, Gothenburg, Genoa—accompanied by images of sitțins, smashed windows, street violence, police barricades, and people being arrested. It also includes iconic referents like the destruction of a McDonald's restaurant in France led by José Bové and the Confédération Paysanne to protest against the use of genetically modified foods. This imagery is prevalent partly because streetțbased politics tends to be more salient and thus the media picks on it as newsworthy. They are also the ones that instill most fear in the hearts of governments, business leaders, and multilateral agencies more accustomed to the logic of
  • 32. expert committees than to mass mobilizations, although at times they embarrass and even undermine the strategic planning of other global protesters too. That is why some might argue that many activist groups lack a strategic political compass. This is correct, but it is not the full story, as they range from strict globaliphobes to those with a clearer agenda for transforming globalism. Examples of those who do have such an agenda are those who participate in the World Social Forum of Porto Alegre, in the more recent European Social Forum, which gathered nearly 60,000 people when launched in Florence in November 2002, as well in other initiatives I will mention shortly.[16] Leading organizations associated with direct action include the Ruckus Society, Global Exchange, and an array of anarchist groups like the Black Bloc.[17] One could also mention the "glocal" dimension of resistance, like the international support for local struggles against privatized utility companies in Third World countries. Here one can 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 10 of 36 think of solidarity campaigns for the Bolivian Water Wars of 2000
  • 33. against a subsidiary of Bechtel Corporation in Cochabamba, or for the Soweto Electricity Crisis Committee set up to resist rate increases of privatized state utilities in South Africa.[18] Advocates of direct action—who can be violent or nonțviolent in their expression of discontent with the order of things—are the generic equivalent of the "dangerous classes" of 19thțcentury conservative discourse. Yet most movements and protests have a radical wing or radical strands among their ranks. Luddites shunned negotiation or accommodation within the system, and promoted the destruction of machines instead of proposing an alternative to the brutal exploitation of early capitalism. They ultimately failed, but theirs proved to be a productive failure, for cotton merchants and politicians got the message about the perils of excessive greed. New social movements have been perhaps less destructive of private property, although the cathartic dimension of destruction should not be overlooked in mass protests. Yet they also appealed to radical direct action to advance their cause—the antinuclear protests in Germany during the 1970s and the guerrilla tactics of Greenpeace are typical examples. One can agree or not with these "hot" actions, which are often
  • 34. accompanied by more protests and slogans than by strategic proposals, but they play an important role. They provide an initial momentum for resistances to globalism and for the globalization of resistances, and therefore contribute to give visibility to the political phase of the "second great transformation." As Wallach says, sometimes direct action helps to cut through the arrogance of the international bureaucracy.[19] Experts of multilateral agencies often refuse to give any serious thought to proposals of advocacy groups or stall them in the paper chase of countless committees. As theorists of realpolitik have shown, a 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 11 of 36 capacity for disruption—which is a de facto veto power—serves as a bargaining tool, in this case helping global warriors to get their case heard. The analogical model of these initiatives is the propagation of digital viruses over the Web: once they start to circulate, whoever created them loses track of how they propagate and cannot control who will get infected or when they will be contained. Chain letters are a less damaging example of such dissemination. Terrorist cells are a
  • 35. more threatening illustration. Viral action coincides with what Deleuze and Guattari designate as a "rhizome," a mode of organization that lacks an "arborescent" or treețlike central structure connecting and directing its parts.[20] A rhizome links people and individuals, and facilitates further links—independent initiatives generated by other groups and individuals—without the usual hierarchies or infrastructure of more conventional social and political organizations. The range of viral actions is quite broad. While it is not confined to the "cool" medium of cyberspace, the latter provides interesting examples. Some consist of gathering funds for relief operations or clicking on websites like The Hunger Site (www.thehungersite.org) to donate a cup of food, a percentage of a mammogram, or to save a square foot of rainforest— all of this free of cost for those who do so. Others include organizing independent boycotts of firms employing child labor or sharing information and other resources for sponsoring initiatives or organizing protests. Among the latter, one could mention the efforts of MoveOn (www.moveon.org, which has an ețmail list with 1.8 million members) to organize an internet protest against the war on Iraq, or to disseminate information linking the war with the "Project for a New
  • 36. American Century" and its goal of positioning the US as the unconditioned pole of the new world order.[21] 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 12 of 36 The strategic matrix for this mode of action in cyberspace is electronic civil disobedience (ECD). It was posed in the midț1990s by the Critical Art Ensemble as a way to match the dețcentralized and deț territorialized nature of contemporary capitalism, particularly financial capital. Like all forms of radical direct action, it eschews electoral and/or party politics. If the streets were the privileged sites of traditional civil disobedience, the nonțphysical cyberspace is the milieu where ECD takes place. The rhizomatic structure of viral direct action is clearly at work here, for instead of aiming for a mass movement of public objectors, it favors a dețcentralized flow of particularized microțorganizations. "Hacktivism," the recombinant encounter of technologyțsavvy hackers and traditional political activists, is one of its modalities. In December 1997, the Anonymous Digital Coalition called people to block access to websites of Mexican financial institutions by repeatedly reloading them to protest the massacre of indigenous people in Acteal, Chiapas, by proțgovernment paramilitary groups. The Electronic Disturbance Theatre, a proț Zapatista group, developed the FloodNet software to engage in
  • 37. acts of ECD: in 1998, they flooded the then President Ernesto Zedillo's webpage with the list of people killed in Acteal. In December 2000, the Electrohippies group organized a virtual "sitțin" of some 450,000 people to overload the WTO servers, and more recently, Our World Our Say staged a 30,000 person virtual march on the US Embassy in London to protest George W. Bush's visit to the United Kingdom in November 2003.[22] In addition to the obvious difficulty to measure their degree of success, whether in the "cool" medium of cyberspace or as "hot" spaces of street actions, a possible disadvantage of this type of initiatives is their inbuilt difficulty to generate consensus or to develop 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 13 of 36 and pursue what Gramsci would call a "counterțhegemonic project." However, this might not be such a bad thing. Viral direct action can function both as an obstacle for largețscale institutional transformations and as an alternative to resourcețheavy projects. Instead of aiming to articulate a wide array of forces to reinstitute the political order or communal space as a whole, the rhizome setup of viral action connects a myriad of local and global initiatives—in
  • 38. cyber or physical space—without a master plan or a central command structure. Groups and individuals can participate and share resources on their own terms quickly, visibly, and costțeffectively by setting up transient virtual communities of action that provide adțhoc modes of participation for people who are neither militants nor committed activists. It is a postțhegemony mode of political action, or at least a mode of intervention that does not fit strictly within the logic of hegemony. This is precisely what makes viral initiatives so useful. Despite appearances to the contrary, those who stay away from politics are not necessarily apolitical. Many still want to change the world, but not all the time, for they do not conform to Rousseau's idealized image of virtuous citizens who rush to assemblies when called. They might be unhappy with the available political options yet lack the time, the resources, or the inclination to build institutional alternatives. This is not so much a proof of depoliticization as it is an indication that dispersed people or loosely organized groups rarely count as political stakeholders. In a way, they live citizenship as functional denizens. The rhizomețstructure of viral direct action can contribute to counteract this experience of disenfranchisement. Signing a petition over the
  • 39. web, refusing to buy tuna cans that lack the dolphințfriendly label, participating in boycotts of products imported from countries with 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 14 of 36 repressive regimes, joining a virtual sitțin, or taking to the streets to join forces with those who oppose wars of aggression, enables people to support a cause and intervene in the public sphere without the usual risks and the costs—not to mention the complex logistics— associated with collective action. Here "the public sphere" might be a misnomer, for viral action is often a crossover between the public and the private. It engenders fleeting, adțhoc publics that appear whenever and wherever private individuals decide to act, even if they only connect with others in the virtual communities resulting from the circulation of a pamphlet or forwarded ețmails for a particular action. More institutionalțoriented interventions include the campaigns to condone the debt of poor countries or to allocate 0.7% of the GDP of developed countries to international aid. One of the more ambitious initiative to foster equality is the Tobin Tax Initiative
  • 40. (www.tobintax.org) supported by a wide array of networks and organizations such as ATTAC, Global Exchange, the AFLțCIO, or DebtChannel.org. The Tobin tax, named after the Nobel laureate economist who first suggested it, aims to discourage the ubiquitous crossțborder financial flows carried out by currency speculators—estimated at 1.8 trillion US dollars daily —by imposing a sales tax of 0.1 to 0.3% on each trade. Such a tax would generate estimated revenues ranging from $100 to $300 billion yearly. As the main financial markets are located in industrialized countries, this would amount to a net transfer of resources to the developing world. These funds could be earmarked for poverty eradication, disease prevention, and environmental programs. This is … Authors: Source: Document Type: Subject Terms: Author-Supplied Keywords: NAICS/Industry
  • 41. Codes: Abstract: Globalisation, Globalism and Cosmopolitanism as an Educational Ideal. Papastephanou, Marianna Educational Philosophy & Theory. Aug2005, Vol. 37 Issue 4, p533-551. 19p. Article *EDUCATION & globalization *GLOBAL method of teaching *TEACHING *COSMOPOLITANISM *EDUCATIONAL ideologies *PHILOSOPHY of education *EDUCATION antagonism Bauman Dewey Giddens globalisation hybridity identity Kristeva nation-state 923110 Administration of Education Programs 611699 All Other Miscellaneous Schools and Instruction 611710 Educational Support Services
  • 42. In this paper, I discuss globalisation as an empirical reality that is in a complex relation to its corresponding discourse and in a critical distance from the cosmopolitan ideal. I argue that failure to grasp the distinctions between globalisation, globalism, and cosmopolitanism derives from mistaken identifications of the Is with the Ought and leads to naïve and ethnocentric glorifications of the potentialities of globalisation. Conversely, drawing the appropriate distinctions helps us articulate a more critical 1 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 1 of 2 Author Affiliations: ISSN: DOI: Accession Number: Publisher Logo: approach to contemporary cultural phenomena, and reconsider the current
  • 43. place and potential role of education within the context of global affairs. From this perspective, the antagonistic impulses cultivated by globalisation and some globalist discourse are singled out and targeted via a radicalization of educational orientations. The final suggestion of the article concerns the vision of a more cosmopolitically sensitive education. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR] Copyright of Educational Philosophy & Theory is the property of Routledge and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.) University of Cyprus 0013-1857 10.1111/j.1469-5812.2005.00139.x 17715367 1 Plum Print
  • 44. 4/5/20, 10:08 PM Page 2 of 2 5 Week 1 Assignment Two Importance of Becoming a Global Citizen Student’s Name GEN499 General Education Capstone Professor’s Name 1 Date Note: This assignment should be written in the correct format per APA guidelines. Please click on the Writing Center tab at the left-hand toolbar of the course. You will then click on the “Writing a Paper” tab, which goes over the basics of writing an essay. For information on how to write in-text citations in APA format, click on the “Citing Within Your Paper” link under the Writing Center & Library tab. This paper needs to consist of 750 – 1,000 words (excluding the title and reference page). Start your paper with the title of this assignment: Importance of Becoming a Global Citizen The introduction paragraph of this paper should inform the
  • 45. reader of the topic you are writing about while providing background information and the purpose or importance of addressing this topic of global citizenship. You should prepare the reader by stating the concepts you are about to address further in your paper. Typically a good introduction paragraph is made up of 5 – 7 sentences. Short Title of First Prompt (i.e. Distinction between “Globalism” and “Globalization”) After viewing the required video “Globalization at a Crossroads”, you need write a paragraph of 5 – 7 sentences addressing the distinction between “globalism” and “globalization” It’s important to cite the video per APA guidelines within this paragraph. Short Title of Second Prompt Write a paragraph (about 5 sentences) describing how being a global citizen in the world of advanced technology can be beneficial to your success in meeting your persona, academic, and professional goals. Short Title of Third Prompt After reading the article by Reysen and Katzarska-Miller, you need to write a paragraph of 5 – 7 sentences explaining why there has been a disagreement between theorists about the definition of global citizenship. Within the article, the authors address how specific schools of thought define global citizenship. It would be a good idea to paraphrase this information in your own words and cite the article per APA guidelines. Also, within this paragraph, you should provide your own definition of global citizenship after reading what other ideas are from the article. Short Title of Fourth Prompt Note: Based on the article, you need to write two paragraphs: a paragraph on each of the two outcomes of global citizenship you chose (intergroup empathy, valuing diversity, social justice, environmental sustainability, intergroup helping, and the level of responsibility to act for the betterment of this world). Name of First Outcome Addressed (i.e. Valuing Diversity)
  • 46. Within this paragraph you need to explain why this outcome is important in becoming a global citizen. It’s a good idea to first define the outcome in your own words and then provide a thorough explanation on why it’s important for your own development as a global citizen. Name of Second Outcome Addressed (i.e. Social Justice) Same instructions as the first paragraph above. Short Title for Fifth Prompt First Personal Example on (Name First Outcome) You need to write a short paragraph describing a personal experience that has corresponds to the first outcome you addressed in the third prompt and has assisted or resulted in your development as a global citizen. Second Personal Example on (Name of Second Outcome) You need to write a short paragraph describing a personal experience that has corresponds to the second outcome you addressed in the third prompt and has assisted or resulted in your development as a global citizen. Short Title of Sixth Prompt You need to write a 5 – 7 sentence paragraph that identifies two specific education courses and explains how each of those courses assisted or influenced your development in becoming a global citizen. Conclusion In this paragraph, you need to summarize the main points of this assignment and include a description of why this topic is important to address when it comes to the development of global citizenship. Typically a good conclusion paragraph consists of 5 – 7 sentences. Keep in mind that you should not share new information in the conclusion paragraph. This means that there should not be any in-text citations. You are basically summarizing what you have written.
  • 47. References Note: References are written below in the correct format per APA guidelines. In addition to these two required resources, you must locate another scholarly source from the Ashford University Library that applies to this topic and can be used to support your perspective. Reysen, S., & Katzarska-Miller, I. (2013). A model of global citizenship: Antecedents and outcomes. International Journal of Psychology, 48(5), 858-870. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207594.2012.701749 Stucke, K. (Writer). (2009). Globalization at a crossroads [Series episode]. In M. Stucke & Claudin, C. (Executive Producers), Global issues. https://fod.infobase.com/OnDemandEmbed.aspx?token=39350& wID=100753&plt=FOD&loid=0&w=640&h=480&fWidth=660& fHeight=530