This document discusses ear prints and their use in criminal identification and solving crimes. It provides details on ear anatomy and development. Ear prints are 2D impressions of the outer ear that can be left on surfaces. The first successful ear print identification of a criminal was in 1965 in Switzerland. The document then describes a 1983 murder case in Brno, Czech Republic where the murderer was identified through an ear print left on the victim's front door. Jan Holub was convicted based on a match between the ear print from the crime scene and his ear print. His conviction was upheld, and he was executed in 1986.
2. INTRODUCTION TO EAR :
Ear is the organ of hearing and its consist of cartilage & which gives the
original shape & dimension to the ear ,covered with skin.
The ear development of the ear begins shortly after conception and by 38th
day certain features of the ear are visible and recognizable.
On 56th day ear moves towards definite position and the shape of the ear can
actually reorganized on 70th day.
From this day the shape of ear remains fixed and never change from birth
until death.
3. ANATOMY OF HUMAN EAR:
Human ear divided into three part :
1.] Outer ear
2.] Middle ear
3.] Inner ear
1.] OUTER EAR : The auricle or auricula is the visible part of the ear that
resides outside the head .Also called as the pinna.
2.] MIDDLE EAR : It include tympanic cavity and three ossicales. They are
called as Malleus, Incus, Stapes.
3.] INNER EAR : The inner ear sites the bony labyrinth & contains
structures which are key to several sense.
4.
5. WHAT IS EAR PRINT?
Ear print is a two dimensional reproduction of the outer ear that have
touched a specific surface.
The ear print include helix, antihelixes, tragus, anti tragus, ear lobe.
The first ear print identification of a criminal was made in Switzerland 1965
and ear print analysis has also been successfully used to solves crimes in the
UK and the Netherland .
Ear print found on a surface ,where an individual has been listening or
attempts to & verifying whether the premises are occupied or not.
Ear prints mostly present on doors & window which made up of glass
,wood or painted.
6. PROCEDURE OF RECOVERING &
ANALYSIS OF EAR PRINT
For recovering of ear print from crime scene is very important.
The first step is do visual examination of ear print before lifting .
The ear print lift by developing with the powder method and then lifting is
carried out.
If ear print are fresh the powder molecule react with sweat and if they are
old print then powder react with fatty deposited.
For collection of control sample from the suspect ask him to listen three
times at a glass plane in a door ,keeping in mind the pressure exerted at time
the plane must be different.
Three type of pressure exerted for the collection, gentle pressure, normal
pressure and excess pressure.
7. PROCEDURE OF COMPARISION
Comparison procedure divide into four steps :
1.] Analysis
2.] Analysis of control sample
3.] Preparation
4.] Comparison
8. THE MUDERER CRIMINATED BY HIS
AURICKLE PRINT
WHAT :-Zdena Minarikova was found dead in her flat in the afternoon on
July 19th ,1983. She was murdered by Jan Holub. Her hands, legs were
corded up ,First he raped her and then she was murdered. There were wound
on stocking & jugulated around her neck . A deep stab wound was also
found in her chest. A blooded knife was also there. When police search
crime scene they found out nothing was stolen. So it was case of sex
motivated murder. Due to which big scandal raises in Brno.
During crime scene examination the police found Aurickle print on the front
door. Police found that the man who meat her last time killed her. By
comparing ear print and other evidence he sentence to death by Regional
Court of Brno on 10th April 1986 .
9. WHO :-In this case victim was Zdena Minarikova who was divorced
mother of a little girl. She was alone and lives with her daughter in flat at
Brno. The suspect was Jan Holub who was criminal. He sentenced five
years for a criminal assault and black mail. He released from jail before the
few days of murder. And he was the only person who mates Zdena
Minarikova before her death. There was no relationship between victim and
suspect.
Suspect
Victim
10. WHEN:-In Brno, South Morvian Region on 19th July 1983 this murder
was happened in flat of Zdena Minarikova. These occurred in afternoon.
WHERE:-This murder was happened in room of flat of Zdena
Minarikova .Her body was laying down on her bed. Where first she raped
and then she murdered by Jan Holub. It was afternoon of 19th July 1983
when this murder happened.
CRIME SCENE
11. Aurickle print of
crime scene
Aurickle print of
Jan Holub
Comparison of sample & control print
12. EVIDENCE:- There were several evidences police found at crime scene
,which were as follow,
Aurickle Print [Ear Print]
Knife with blood stain
Finger print
Glass containing finger print
Semen spots on body
Cigarette butt
Police got DNA from the blood and semen sample which matched with
DNA of Jan Holub.
The ear print which they found was also matched with Holub ear print.
13. LEGAL OUTCOME:- First court gave judgement that he was mental
defect but the psychologist not found any mental disorder. It further ordered
that judgement was entered for plaintiff [Zdena Minarikova] against the
defendant [Jan Holub].For raped & murder of lady Brno Regional court
sentenced him to death. On the 10th April 1986 Jan Holub was executed.
REFLECTION:-The most interesting thing was just the Aurickle Print [Ear
Print].It was the first time in the Czech criminology history, when Brno
Regional Court had took the Aurickle Print [Ear Print]as evidence. And they
caught evidence criminal. And the case was solved.
BIBLIOGRAPHY:- -Jan Holub www.kriminalistika.eu