The document summarizes the findings of the STRIPE (Strengthening the Right to Information for People and the Environment) regional meeting held in Jakarta, Indonesia from April 29th to May 1st. The meeting brought together communities from Indonesia and Thailand impacted by air and water pollution to file freedom of information requests and evaluate environmental information disclosure practices. Key findings included extensive legal provisions for the right to information, but limited proactive disclosure of pollution information. Communities faced barriers like mute refusals and varying response times to requests. The outcomes of the meeting were increased use of freedom of information laws, identification of gaps in regulation and practice, and capacity building for stakeholders.
PANEL 3: Post-2020 Global Chemicals Supply Chains – What will be the drivers for market supply and demand and will chemicals product safety emerge a winner or loser? - Mihai Scumpieru, Manager, Mitsubishi Electric Europe B.V. Vice Chair, Japan Business Council in Europe
Dr. Dorothy Stewart from the EPA presented an overview of Ireland's environmental strategy and research program. The key points were:
1) The EPA's 2016-2020 strategy aims to address knowledge gaps and solutions to environmental problems through research.
2) The EPA funds environmental research through various programs, with €30.9 million allocated from 2014-2020. Research themes include water, climate, health and biodiversity.
3) Upcoming in 2017 is an annual call for research proposals on topics like air quality, water quality, and citizen science projects. Research aims to inform policy and drive sustainable behavior change.
The document summarizes the role and responsibilities of the Environmental Commissioner of Ontario (ECO), an independent officer of the Legislative Assembly. The ECO monitors and reports on environmental decision-making by government ministries. The ECO oversees Ontario's Environmental Bill of Rights (EBR) and ensures public participation in environmentally significant government decisions. The ECO produces annual reports evaluating decisions, applications for review, and emerging environmental issues in the province.
An example of an assessment performed for a client that sought to understand the environmental, social and economic context for a set of packaging systems. All client-specific information has been removed due to confidentiality.
Presentation on Interacting with EPA Research, A two-way Process given by Marc Kierans, EPA Research at School of BEES Research Day, University College Cork, Friday 9th June 2017
1) The document discusses a project assessing Irish farmers' knowledge of greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture and identifying effective ways to encourage adoption of emission-reducing practices.
2) Surveys found farmers have little knowledge of emissions and are willing to use a decision support tool. The most popular mitigation techniques were extending grazing seasons for dairy and improving livestock growth for beef.
3) The project will test promoting the most popular techniques immediately while providing more information on less known options, and evaluate focus groups to identify the best way to introduce the Carbon Navigator tool to farmers.
John F Ryan, Director, European Commission presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference, Dublin on the European Environment and Health Priorities
PANEL 3: Post-2020 Global Chemicals Supply Chains – What will be the drivers for market supply and demand and will chemicals product safety emerge a winner or loser? - Mihai Scumpieru, Manager, Mitsubishi Electric Europe B.V. Vice Chair, Japan Business Council in Europe
Dr. Dorothy Stewart from the EPA presented an overview of Ireland's environmental strategy and research program. The key points were:
1) The EPA's 2016-2020 strategy aims to address knowledge gaps and solutions to environmental problems through research.
2) The EPA funds environmental research through various programs, with €30.9 million allocated from 2014-2020. Research themes include water, climate, health and biodiversity.
3) Upcoming in 2017 is an annual call for research proposals on topics like air quality, water quality, and citizen science projects. Research aims to inform policy and drive sustainable behavior change.
The document summarizes the role and responsibilities of the Environmental Commissioner of Ontario (ECO), an independent officer of the Legislative Assembly. The ECO monitors and reports on environmental decision-making by government ministries. The ECO oversees Ontario's Environmental Bill of Rights (EBR) and ensures public participation in environmentally significant government decisions. The ECO produces annual reports evaluating decisions, applications for review, and emerging environmental issues in the province.
An example of an assessment performed for a client that sought to understand the environmental, social and economic context for a set of packaging systems. All client-specific information has been removed due to confidentiality.
Presentation on Interacting with EPA Research, A two-way Process given by Marc Kierans, EPA Research at School of BEES Research Day, University College Cork, Friday 9th June 2017
1) The document discusses a project assessing Irish farmers' knowledge of greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture and identifying effective ways to encourage adoption of emission-reducing practices.
2) Surveys found farmers have little knowledge of emissions and are willing to use a decision support tool. The most popular mitigation techniques were extending grazing seasons for dairy and improving livestock growth for beef.
3) The project will test promoting the most popular techniques immediately while providing more information on less known options, and evaluate focus groups to identify the best way to introduce the Carbon Navigator tool to farmers.
John F Ryan, Director, European Commission presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference, Dublin on the European Environment and Health Priorities
The EPA Research Programme funds environmental research projects in Ireland. It has provided over €170 million for research since 2000. In 2017, the EPA provided funding through various calls including the Green Enterprise Scheme and an EPA/HSE tender. The EPA collaborates with other agencies on funding, including the Irish Research Council, Science Foundation Ireland, and EU programmes like Horizon 2020. Researchers can interact with the EPA by submitting proposals, providing ideas, attending events, and staying updated through the EPA's newsletters and social media.
The EPA Research programme addresses knowledge gaps and emerging environmental problems. It is responsible for environmental research management in Ireland, funding over 800 researchers and 33 institutions in 2016. The programme focuses on themes like resource efficiency, water, climate and socioeconomics. Annual competitive calls provide desk studies, medium and large projects, and fellowships. The 2017 call deadline is July 3rd and focuses on impacts, research integrity and gender. Partnerships support excellent science, industrial leadership and societal challenges like climate action and sustainable development.
NHS England is committed to five high impact digital changes in primary care by 2018: allowing patients to book appointments and order prescriptions online, access test results electronically, monitor long-term conditions remotely, control personal health records, and engage with professionals via text/email. NHS England also aims to make general practice paper-free by 2018 through initiatives like scanning historical paper records and receiving digital discharge summaries. Over 30 million patients in England will benefit from improved digital access and local transformational changes through the rollout of digital primary care programs.
Deirdre Garvey, CEO, The Wheel presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference 2017 on addressing engagement challenges for communities and citizens - The Wheel experiences.
Patrick Kenny presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference 2017 on Citizen Science - accessing & gathering Ambient Air Quality data - experiences and innovations.
Transport and mobility - behaviour changeCipr Ciprlps
This document discusses enabling behavior change related to transportation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. It notes that while UK greenhouse gas emissions have fallen overall, emissions from road transportation have increased. It outlines key influences on individual and organizational behavior, including attitudes, norms, costs, and choice architecture. The document advocates starting with defining the specific behaviors and target populations, and applying insights from behavioral science. It presents a framework for planning behavior change projects, including defining target groups, identifying barriers to change, and selecting interventions.
Global data sharing aims to increase cooperation between countries on chemical safety information. The current system results in duplicative testing and inconsistent data formats and property protections between jurisdictions. The vision is for common electronic formats for collecting, exchanging, and publishing data, along with global consortia of data owners that agree all data can be used for any regulatory purpose anywhere. This would ensure information is only prepared and submitted once. Existing OECD instruments provide recommendations around proprietary data protection, exchanging confidential data, and lists of non-confidential data that could form the basis for expanded global cooperation.
[Climate Chnage Program Action Plan Paper : Group A]shrdcinfo
The document summarizes the discussions of Group A, which is focused on waste management and recycling issues in relation to climate change. The group is made up of members from various countries and is facilitated by Dr. Woon-su Kim. They identified several challenges with waste management in their countries, including low public participation, increasing waste volumes, and lack of advanced technology/facilities. The group set goals to address these issues and proposed strategies to achieve the goals by certain target years, such as incentivizing public participation, imposing regulations to reduce waste, and exploring public-private partnerships to develop new facilities.
Global data sharing between businesses and regulators can provide many benefits, including sharing workloads and resources, avoiding duplication of data, and better understanding supply chains. However, there are also challenges, such as protecting confidential business information, coordinating differing data needs and formats between countries, and addressing different supply chains. Canada acts as an "international scavenger" of chemical data, implementing approaches to maximize data transparency while respecting confidential business information. Globally, efforts could focus on standardizing data formats, developing tools to facilitate sharing, exploring common data repositories, harmonizing what data is collected and when, and finding solutions to intellectual property issues.
The document discusses Hong Kong's plastic bag levy scheme. It provides background on the need to reduce landfill waste and introduces the "polluter pays" principle. In 2008, the Product Eco-responsibility Ordinance was passed, providing the legal basis for a levy on plastic shopping bags. Since implementation in 2010, the number of plastic bags distributed has reduced by 90%, showing the scheme has been successful in reducing plastic bag use. Civic engagement and public opinion generally supported the levy, though plastic bag manufacturers and retailers opposed it. Reinforcement theory explains how the levy strengthened the desired behavior of reducing plastic bag use.
1) The document discusses transparency of environmental information in Mongolia. There is a national environmental database composed of 22 sectors that is provided to the public through the MEGD website and statistical reports.
2) Mongolia has laws on environmental protection, statistics, and information transparency that provide the legal framework for sharing environmental information. A work group was appointed to oversee transparency.
3) Ensuring transparency of ministry activities, human resources, budgets, and acquisitions is a priority. Information is shared through news boards and reports from provincial environmental organizations.
The document discusses Indonesia's environmental law framework for access to information. It outlines key laws like the Environmental Management & Protection Act of 2009 and air and water pollution control regulations. These establish rights to environmental information and require industry and government to provide information to the public. Challenges in implementation are also summarized, such as information not being accessible to communities and lack of information sharing. The document ends by recommending improved regulations and information sharing, as well as capacity building for both public bodies and communities.
Dokumen tersebut membahas upaya masyarakat sekitar Sungai Ciujung dalam memperjuangkan hak atas informasi publik dan lingkungan hidup yang baik melalui pelatihan keterbukaan informasi, pengajuan permintaan informasi kepada badan publik terkait pencemaran sungai, serta advokasi dan sosialisasi kepada masyarakat hilir sungai.
This document summarizes efforts in China to increase transparency around corporate pollution records and engage the public and companies in addressing environmental issues. It discusses how environmental non-profits launched initiatives like the Green Choice Initiative to request major brands commit not to source from polluting suppliers. It also describes how over 120,000 corporate pollution violation records have been made public online. Several companies are highlighted for their proactive responses, like conducting regular checks on suppliers or pushing suppliers to disclose corrective actions. The document advocates for deeper public participation and cross-sector collaboration to make continued social and environmental progress.
The document summarizes the history and scope of Japan's Pollutant Release and Transfer Register (PRTR) system. It was established in 2001 with 435 reported substances and has expanded to include 562 substances. Facilities must report if they have over 21 employees and handle over 1 ton of a designated substance per year. Data is compiled by local and national governments and disclosed to the public. Top releasing industries include agriculture, manufacturing, and energy. NGOs help promote data use and prioritize substances by risk. Revisions in 2008 increased online disclosure and estimation of non-reported sources. The 2011 earthquake impacted 364 facilities but no significant pollution was detected. Opportunities for improvement include reporting waste handling and maximizing data use.
The document outlines the methodology used by The Access Initiative (TAI) to evaluate countries' compliance with the Aarhus Convention and Principle 10 of the Rio Declaration. TAI conducts legal and case study research across four pillars of access rights - access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. National coalitions in over 40 countries research 18 case studies and analyze laws to produce scores on over 100 indicators. The assessments aim to identify gaps and advocate for reforms to strengthen public environmental rights and participation.
This document provides guidance on selecting case studies for assessing access to information. It recommends choosing 18 total case studies across four pillars: access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. For access to information, it recommends 8 case studies across several mandatory and optional types, including large and small environmental emergencies, air and water quality monitoring systems, facilities-level reporting, and state of the environment reports. It provides guidelines for selecting representative, recent case studies for each type and outlines indicators for assessing each case study.
This document summarizes findings from a study on access to environmental information in Thailand. It discusses constraints to accessing information on air pollution, water pollution, and assessments of relevant laws and policies. Key issues identified include lack of understanding of legal rights, inadequate monitoring data, non-responsive government agencies, and lack of penalties for non-compliance. Recommendations focus on improving legal frameworks, public awareness, digital access to information, and oversight of government responsiveness.
PA Department of Environmental Protection’s Office of Environmental AdvocateMichael Hewitt, GISP
This document discusses Pennsylvania's approach to environmental justice. It defines environmental justice as fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regarding environmental laws, policies, and decisions. Pennsylvania developed its environmental justice policies after a 1996 lawsuit alleging the state's permitting process had disproportionate impacts on minority communities. This led Pennsylvania to create the Office of Environmental Advocate and an Environmental Justice Advisory Board to enhance public participation in environmentally impacted communities. The state identifies environmental justice areas and ensures enhanced public notification, meetings and permit application summaries for projects in these communities.
This document summarizes Theresa O'Donohoe's efforts from 2013-2015 to promote comprehensive public participation in Ireland's national energy transition plans. It details how she helped organize the People's Energy Charter with over 30 supporting organizations to push for community involvement in renewable energy development. It also describes meetings with government officials and participation in Ireland's national energy policy consultation process, though the final policy did not fully incorporate public participation as sought by the Charter.
The EPA Research Programme funds environmental research projects in Ireland. It has provided over €170 million for research since 2000. In 2017, the EPA provided funding through various calls including the Green Enterprise Scheme and an EPA/HSE tender. The EPA collaborates with other agencies on funding, including the Irish Research Council, Science Foundation Ireland, and EU programmes like Horizon 2020. Researchers can interact with the EPA by submitting proposals, providing ideas, attending events, and staying updated through the EPA's newsletters and social media.
The EPA Research programme addresses knowledge gaps and emerging environmental problems. It is responsible for environmental research management in Ireland, funding over 800 researchers and 33 institutions in 2016. The programme focuses on themes like resource efficiency, water, climate and socioeconomics. Annual competitive calls provide desk studies, medium and large projects, and fellowships. The 2017 call deadline is July 3rd and focuses on impacts, research integrity and gender. Partnerships support excellent science, industrial leadership and societal challenges like climate action and sustainable development.
NHS England is committed to five high impact digital changes in primary care by 2018: allowing patients to book appointments and order prescriptions online, access test results electronically, monitor long-term conditions remotely, control personal health records, and engage with professionals via text/email. NHS England also aims to make general practice paper-free by 2018 through initiatives like scanning historical paper records and receiving digital discharge summaries. Over 30 million patients in England will benefit from improved digital access and local transformational changes through the rollout of digital primary care programs.
Deirdre Garvey, CEO, The Wheel presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference 2017 on addressing engagement challenges for communities and citizens - The Wheel experiences.
Patrick Kenny presenting at the EPA/HSE Environment & Health Conference 2017 on Citizen Science - accessing & gathering Ambient Air Quality data - experiences and innovations.
Transport and mobility - behaviour changeCipr Ciprlps
This document discusses enabling behavior change related to transportation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. It notes that while UK greenhouse gas emissions have fallen overall, emissions from road transportation have increased. It outlines key influences on individual and organizational behavior, including attitudes, norms, costs, and choice architecture. The document advocates starting with defining the specific behaviors and target populations, and applying insights from behavioral science. It presents a framework for planning behavior change projects, including defining target groups, identifying barriers to change, and selecting interventions.
Global data sharing aims to increase cooperation between countries on chemical safety information. The current system results in duplicative testing and inconsistent data formats and property protections between jurisdictions. The vision is for common electronic formats for collecting, exchanging, and publishing data, along with global consortia of data owners that agree all data can be used for any regulatory purpose anywhere. This would ensure information is only prepared and submitted once. Existing OECD instruments provide recommendations around proprietary data protection, exchanging confidential data, and lists of non-confidential data that could form the basis for expanded global cooperation.
[Climate Chnage Program Action Plan Paper : Group A]shrdcinfo
The document summarizes the discussions of Group A, which is focused on waste management and recycling issues in relation to climate change. The group is made up of members from various countries and is facilitated by Dr. Woon-su Kim. They identified several challenges with waste management in their countries, including low public participation, increasing waste volumes, and lack of advanced technology/facilities. The group set goals to address these issues and proposed strategies to achieve the goals by certain target years, such as incentivizing public participation, imposing regulations to reduce waste, and exploring public-private partnerships to develop new facilities.
Global data sharing between businesses and regulators can provide many benefits, including sharing workloads and resources, avoiding duplication of data, and better understanding supply chains. However, there are also challenges, such as protecting confidential business information, coordinating differing data needs and formats between countries, and addressing different supply chains. Canada acts as an "international scavenger" of chemical data, implementing approaches to maximize data transparency while respecting confidential business information. Globally, efforts could focus on standardizing data formats, developing tools to facilitate sharing, exploring common data repositories, harmonizing what data is collected and when, and finding solutions to intellectual property issues.
The document discusses Hong Kong's plastic bag levy scheme. It provides background on the need to reduce landfill waste and introduces the "polluter pays" principle. In 2008, the Product Eco-responsibility Ordinance was passed, providing the legal basis for a levy on plastic shopping bags. Since implementation in 2010, the number of plastic bags distributed has reduced by 90%, showing the scheme has been successful in reducing plastic bag use. Civic engagement and public opinion generally supported the levy, though plastic bag manufacturers and retailers opposed it. Reinforcement theory explains how the levy strengthened the desired behavior of reducing plastic bag use.
1) The document discusses transparency of environmental information in Mongolia. There is a national environmental database composed of 22 sectors that is provided to the public through the MEGD website and statistical reports.
2) Mongolia has laws on environmental protection, statistics, and information transparency that provide the legal framework for sharing environmental information. A work group was appointed to oversee transparency.
3) Ensuring transparency of ministry activities, human resources, budgets, and acquisitions is a priority. Information is shared through news boards and reports from provincial environmental organizations.
The document discusses Indonesia's environmental law framework for access to information. It outlines key laws like the Environmental Management & Protection Act of 2009 and air and water pollution control regulations. These establish rights to environmental information and require industry and government to provide information to the public. Challenges in implementation are also summarized, such as information not being accessible to communities and lack of information sharing. The document ends by recommending improved regulations and information sharing, as well as capacity building for both public bodies and communities.
Dokumen tersebut membahas upaya masyarakat sekitar Sungai Ciujung dalam memperjuangkan hak atas informasi publik dan lingkungan hidup yang baik melalui pelatihan keterbukaan informasi, pengajuan permintaan informasi kepada badan publik terkait pencemaran sungai, serta advokasi dan sosialisasi kepada masyarakat hilir sungai.
This document summarizes efforts in China to increase transparency around corporate pollution records and engage the public and companies in addressing environmental issues. It discusses how environmental non-profits launched initiatives like the Green Choice Initiative to request major brands commit not to source from polluting suppliers. It also describes how over 120,000 corporate pollution violation records have been made public online. Several companies are highlighted for their proactive responses, like conducting regular checks on suppliers or pushing suppliers to disclose corrective actions. The document advocates for deeper public participation and cross-sector collaboration to make continued social and environmental progress.
The document summarizes the history and scope of Japan's Pollutant Release and Transfer Register (PRTR) system. It was established in 2001 with 435 reported substances and has expanded to include 562 substances. Facilities must report if they have over 21 employees and handle over 1 ton of a designated substance per year. Data is compiled by local and national governments and disclosed to the public. Top releasing industries include agriculture, manufacturing, and energy. NGOs help promote data use and prioritize substances by risk. Revisions in 2008 increased online disclosure and estimation of non-reported sources. The 2011 earthquake impacted 364 facilities but no significant pollution was detected. Opportunities for improvement include reporting waste handling and maximizing data use.
The document outlines the methodology used by The Access Initiative (TAI) to evaluate countries' compliance with the Aarhus Convention and Principle 10 of the Rio Declaration. TAI conducts legal and case study research across four pillars of access rights - access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. National coalitions in over 40 countries research 18 case studies and analyze laws to produce scores on over 100 indicators. The assessments aim to identify gaps and advocate for reforms to strengthen public environmental rights and participation.
This document provides guidance on selecting case studies for assessing access to information. It recommends choosing 18 total case studies across four pillars: access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. For access to information, it recommends 8 case studies across several mandatory and optional types, including large and small environmental emergencies, air and water quality monitoring systems, facilities-level reporting, and state of the environment reports. It provides guidelines for selecting representative, recent case studies for each type and outlines indicators for assessing each case study.
This document summarizes findings from a study on access to environmental information in Thailand. It discusses constraints to accessing information on air pollution, water pollution, and assessments of relevant laws and policies. Key issues identified include lack of understanding of legal rights, inadequate monitoring data, non-responsive government agencies, and lack of penalties for non-compliance. Recommendations focus on improving legal frameworks, public awareness, digital access to information, and oversight of government responsiveness.
PA Department of Environmental Protection’s Office of Environmental AdvocateMichael Hewitt, GISP
This document discusses Pennsylvania's approach to environmental justice. It defines environmental justice as fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regarding environmental laws, policies, and decisions. Pennsylvania developed its environmental justice policies after a 1996 lawsuit alleging the state's permitting process had disproportionate impacts on minority communities. This led Pennsylvania to create the Office of Environmental Advocate and an Environmental Justice Advisory Board to enhance public participation in environmentally impacted communities. The state identifies environmental justice areas and ensures enhanced public notification, meetings and permit application summaries for projects in these communities.
This document summarizes Theresa O'Donohoe's efforts from 2013-2015 to promote comprehensive public participation in Ireland's national energy transition plans. It details how she helped organize the People's Energy Charter with over 30 supporting organizations to push for community involvement in renewable energy development. It also describes meetings with government officials and participation in Ireland's national energy policy consultation process, though the final policy did not fully incorporate public participation as sought by the Charter.
Session 1 - OECD_Effective Environmental Information Systems.pdfOECD Environment
This document discusses OECD's work on improving environmental information systems to support waste and plastics management policies. It notes that effective data collection and harmonized indicators are needed as an evidence base for policymaking. However, waste data can be estimated inaccurately and measurement scopes differ between countries. Specific challenges include accounting for illegally dumped or informally managed waste. The document provides lessons from OECD's work, including the need for coordinated data collection, transparent methods, continuity over time, and expanding monitoring progressively. Effective monitoring of plastics requires data on the full value chain from production to environmental impacts.
How are decisions made to authorize industrial operations in Alberta? Who gets to use water and how? How can you get involved in those types of decisions?
The short answer is that Alberta Environment regulates environmental aspects of many industrial activities under the Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act, and water use and activities affecting water under the Water Act.
On February 4th 2010, Cindy Chiasson, the Environmental Law Centre's Executive Director, explained more about these authorizations and how you can have a say in the decision-making process.
1. ICRAF has a long history of policy research but it has become more diffuse in recent years, with research focusing more on documenting policy constraints rather than testing policy options.
2. Common broad policy constraints affecting agroforestry include low policy awareness of agroforestry, issues around land and tree tenure including forest regulations, and lack of recognition of environmental services.
3. Moving forward, ICRAF's policy research would benefit from more strategic thinking at both the program and institutional levels to identify clear policy outcomes and coordinate research efforts accordingly. The Agroforestry Policy Initiative aims to facilitate this but its objectives and pathways for supporting policy reforms require further discussion.
Enforcement of enviornmental legislation, indian scenario in enforment, publi...Vamsi kumar
This document contains summaries of three student papers on environmental topics:
1. Prince Kumar's paper discusses factors affecting international environmental laws such as the identification and severity of problems, statistics, geography, law and order, political pressures, infrastructure, and international cooperation.
2. Tinku's paper examines India's enforcement of environmental legislation, noting that laws need strengthening and proper implementation to protect the environment.
3. Md. Shadab Chaudary's paper focuses on the importance of public awareness for environmental science and sustainable development, the role of various groups in increasing awareness, and suggestions for effective awareness campaigns.
ODDC Context - Open government data for regulation of energy resource industr...Open Data Research Network
Presentation in the first workshop of the Exploring the Emerging Impacts of Open Data in Developing Countries project. Looking at the context of open data, and the research case study planned for 2013 - 2014. See http://www.opendataresearch.org/project/2013/teri
Information Access and NGO Participation: North America and EuropeIwl Pcu
Ruth Greenspan Bell, Resources for the FutureJane Bloom Stewart, New York University. Presentation at the GEF International Waters Conference 2000 (15 slides)
Overview of Presentation:
1) What is public participation and what does it add?
2) Pragmatic reasons for public participation
3)Examples of public participation to achieve environmental goals
4)Summary thoughts about public participation
5) Future directions in the Danube
Information Access and NGO Participation: North America and EuropeIwl Pcu
What is public participation and what does it add? Pragmatic reasons for public participation.
Examples of public participation to achieve environmental goals.Summary thoughts about public participation.Future directions in the Danube
Information Access and NGO Participation: North America and EuropeIwl Pcu
Ruth Greenspan Bell, Resources for the FutureJane Bloom Stewart, New York University. Presentation at the GEF International Waters Conference 2000 (15 slides)
Overview of Presentation:
1) What is public participation and what does it add?
2) Pragmatic reasons for public participation
3)Examples of public participation to achieve environmental goals
4)Summary thoughts about public participation
5) Future directions in the Danube
The document discusses seeking comprehensive public participation in Ireland's national energy transition plans through climate dialogue. It outlines the history of the Transition and People's Energy Charter movements in Ireland which brought together various climate, community, and industry groups starting in 2013 to develop shared principles for energy policy. It describes the Charter's involvement in policy consultations over two years, including hosting workshops and making submissions. The groups had one consistent shared demand of comprehensive public participation in national plans. In late 2015, a new national energy policy was finally launched that included establishing a national energy forum.
Open Government Data Ecosystems: Linking Transparency for Innovation with Tra...Luigi Reggi
Presentation at IFIP EGOV 2016 Conference. September 5, 2016.
Abstract. The rhetoric of open government data (OGD) promises that data transparency will lead to multiple public benefits: economic and social innovation, civic participation, public-private collaboration, and public accountability. In reality much less has been accomplished in practice than advocates have hoped. OGD research to address this gap tends to fall into two streams – one that focuses on data publication and re-use for purposes of innovation, and one that views publication as a stimulus for civic participation and government accountability - with little attention to whether or how these two views interact. In this paper we use an ecosystem perspective to explore this question. Through an exploratory case study we show how two related cycles of influences can flow from open data publication. The first addresses transparency for innovation goals, the second addresses larger issues of data use for public engagement and greater government accountability. Together they help explain the potential and also the barriers to reaching both kinds of goals.
The document discusses access to environmental information and the right to environmental information under EU law. It provides an overview of the key aspects of the Access to Environmental Information Directive, including what environmental information can be requested, who can make requests, the obligations of public authorities to grant access to information and organize environmental information, exceptions to granting access, and avenues for administrative and judicial remedies. It emphasizes that the directive establishes a fundamental right of access to environmental information that should be interpreted broadly in order to increase public awareness and participation in environmental decision making.
This document summarizes efforts to establish a Pollution Release and Transfer Registry (PRTR) system in the Philippines between 2010-2013. It discusses:
- A timeline of key events including developing a draft administrative order for a PRTR, legal reviews, consultations with NGOs, and a commitment from the DENR Secretary to disclose industry reports.
- Details from the draft administrative order describing the PRTR's scope, lead implementing agency, requirements for covered industries, and guidelines for public access to information.
- Campaign strategies used by environmental groups to advocate for the PRTR including highlighting toxic pollution, establishing community water patrols, engaging stakeholders, and an online campaign reinforcing a global initiative.
This poster was presented as part of the East African Learning Landscape Regional Knowledge Exchange, at the African Institute for Capacity Development at Jomo Kenyatta University on June 2-3, 2015.
For more information, see: http://bit.ly/1KtnN0S
This poster provides information on the Ethiopian Learning Landscape Network developed by the Water and Land Resource Centre (WLRC).
Presented by Dr. Gizaw Desta, as part of the East African Learning Landscape Regional Knowledge Exchange, at the African Institute for Capacity Development at Jomo Kenyatta University on June 2-3, 2015.
For more information, see: http://bit.ly/1KtnN0S
This document provides an overview of an open policy survey conducted by a team from several organizations to analyze open educational resources (OER), open data, open heritage, and open science policies around the world. The survey examines the strength and implementation of relevant policies in different countries and jurisdictions, as well as discovery mechanisms and influential models. It includes sample results on OER policies and implementations scores for several countries and provides information on the survey methodology and funding sources.
This document discusses the tragedy of the commons concept introduced by Hardin in 1968. It suggests that when resources are commonly held, individual users will ultimately deplete the finite resources for their own benefit at the cost of the common good. The document then provides an overview of environmental laws and policies in the Philippines, including key milestones like the Pollution Control Law of 1976. It outlines the objectives and mandate of the Environmental Management Bureau as the primary agency for enforcing environmental laws in the country. Finally, it discusses issues and concerns with Philippine environmental institutions like a lack of resources, overlapping mandates between agencies, and the need to strengthen local governments and multi-sectoral partnerships.
This document provides guidelines for civil society organizations on public policy instruments for sustainable consumption and production. It gives an overview of key areas of focus in food, housing and mobility and describes SCP policy processes from the individual to international levels. The document outlines various policy instruments that can be used for SCP and provides an example of norms and standards. It suggests ways that CSOs can assess, campaign for, participate in and network around policy instruments to increase their effectiveness in supporting SCP goals.
Public Engagement in Estonia – lessons learnt and way forwardOECD Governance
Presentation by Helena Braun, Advisor of Better Regulation Legislative Policy Department, Ministry of Justice, Estonia, at the 7th Expert Meeting on Measuring Regulatory Performance: Embedding Regulatory Policy in Law and Practice, Breakout session 2, Reykjavik, 18-19 June 2015. Further information is available at http://www.oecd.org/gov/regulatory-policy/measuring-regulatory-performance.htm
Similar to Wri stripe regional meeting: Overview of STRIPE Findings (20)
Hacia un Instrumento Regional Iniciativa de Acceso para América Latina y el ...The Access Initiative
Este documento describe el proceso hacia un posible instrumento regional sobre el Principio 10 en América Latina y el Caribe. 15 países han firmado una declaración para iniciar este proceso. Se han realizado varias reuniones donde se acordó un plan de acción y se sumaron más países al proceso. El objetivo final es mejorar el acceso a la información ambiental y la participación ciudadana en la región.
The document outlines the structure and methodology for TAI assessments of public participation. It discusses the four pillars of access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. Case studies are used to evaluate public participation at the project, regulatory, and policy levels across different sectors. Indicators examine relevant laws, the efforts made for participation, and the effectiveness of participation. The assessments involve a mix of prescribed and discretionary case studies totaling at least 18 to provide comprehensive insights into each country's framework and practice of public participation.
TAI Training focuses on four pillars: access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. Capacity building enhances governments' ability to provide access, the public's ability to demand access, and the environment for media and civil society organizations. The TAI assessment structure includes indicators on access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. It also includes poverty case studies and constitutional and general law indicators. The capacity building indicators examine issues like press freedom, equal enforcement of laws for media and CSOs, legal aid, an enabling environment for CSOs, and public school resources on access rights.
The document outlines a three step process for advocacy: 1) identify objectives such as engaging government and influencing policymakers, 2) identify the target audience which includes the general public, policymakers, and NGOs, and 3) create a strategy such as education programs and lobbying government. Some strategies discussed are forming working groups with government and industry and creating partnerships between NGOs, government, and businesses. The document also mentions challenges and opportunities for advocacy like building CSO capacity and growing support for the access movement.
The document discusses The Access Initiative (TAI), a decentralized network of 170 civil society organizations and 49 countries that works to implement Principle 10 of environmental law. TAI conducts assessments of countries' laws and institutions regarding access to information, public participation, and access to justice relating to the environment. The assessments include case studies, indicators, and measures of capacity building. TAI then works with governments and institutions to advocate for reforms to close gaps and promote inclusive, transparent and accountable access. The initiative has grown since its founding and aims to continue assessments, deepen advocacy efforts, and diversify its activities in the future.
TAI Training focuses on access to justice through four pillars: access to information, public participation, access to justice, and capacity building. It assesses countries using indicators in these areas applied to case studies across various sectors. The access to justice assessment includes 33 indicators examining whether forums are impartial, affordable, have capacity to handle claims, and issue timely decisions. Case studies must include at least 4 access to information cases, 6 public participation cases, and 4 access to justice cases, with 2 poverty cases. Priority sectors are chosen based on economic/environmental significance and representation of average impacts.
This document summarizes access to environmental information in Japan. It discusses the Aarhus Net, an NGO network established to implement the Aarhus Convention in Japan. It also describes Japan's Access to Government Information Act at the national and local levels. A survey of Japanese environmental NGOs found most were aware of the information disclosure act but few had used it. The act has some limitations compared to the Aarhus Convention, such as only requiring disclosure from government bodies, not private companies. The document also summarizes a Supreme Court case about disclosure of factory CO2 emissions and a major air pollution case in Nishiyodogawa.
This document discusses Pollutant Release and Transfer Registers (PRTRs) and their benefits. A PRTR is a central database that stores, manages, and validates pollution data provided by industries and governments. It disseminates this information to the public. PRTRs benefit governments by increasing efficiency and capacities, and benefit civil society and industry by empowering the public and involving industries. The document provides examples of PRTR legal frameworks and discusses how PRTR data can be presented through searchable databases, maps, trend graphs, and rankings to facilitate access to environmental information.
The Deputy Minister for Technical Infrastructure and Capacity Building at the Ministry of Environment of the Republic of Indonesia welcomed participants to the regional meeting on strengthening the right to information for people and the environment. The meeting aims to exchange ideas on promoting access to environmental information and discuss solutions. Access to information is important for transparency, economic growth, and sustainable development. The STRIPE project focuses on improving access to information about air and water pollution in Thailand and Indonesia. The Deputy Minister hopes the dialogue will support practices around environmental disclosure in Indonesia. Availability of environmental information to the public is crucial to inform development projects and allow public oversight. Indonesia's laws require public agencies to provide access to information and emphasize the importance of environmental information disclosure. The meeting aims
This document discusses access to information in Japan. It provides details on:
1) Japan's national and local laws governing access to information held by government agencies.
2) The scope of documents covered by the laws, including documents from closed agencies.
3) Exceptions where information can be withheld and recent cases expanding disclosure.
4) Procedures for requesting information, fees, timelines, and appeals process.
5) The role of Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board in reviewing appeals.
This document discusses how to create usable data and actionable information. It explains that data needs to be tailored to different types of users, including analysts, authors, citizens, and decision makers. For analysts, raw data in CSV files is preferred. For authors, providing summary tables and charts allows them to tell stories. Citizens benefit from maps and local information on web pages. Decision makers need integrated stories with data and narratives. The presentation provides tips on keeping data and visualizations simple, including using static maps and charts, and having non-experts write stories integrating the information.
The document announces that the Official Information Commission has agreed to specify that certain types of environmental and health information must be made available to the public according to Section 9(8) of Thailand's Official Information Act of 1997. This was in response to a request from the Thai Environmental Institute and allied organizations. The Commission identified 16 categories of information that state agencies must prepare and make accessible, including reports on environmental impact assessments, pollution levels, health studies, and laws and policies related to the environment and health. State agencies now have 90 days to organize and provide access to this information.
This document discusses access to environmental information in the Philippines. It outlines the country's policy framework for access to information, including provisions in the Philippine Constitution guaranteeing access to official records. It also discusses efforts to increase access to information related to extractive industries through the Philippines' participation in the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative. The document notes challenges to obtaining timely pollution data and proposes establishing a pollution release and transfer registry system. It also suggests creating a natural resource valuation system to assess the economic value of conservation.
This document discusses access to environmental information in Mongolia under the country's Law on Information Transparency and Right to Information. It provides 5 case studies of civil society organizations using the law to obtain environmental data:
1) A coalition requested information from an oil company about its exploration activities but received incomplete responses.
2) An NGO obtained a protected area map after multiple meetings to clarify reasons for disclosure.
3) An NGO created a multilateral council for information sharing between community, companies, and government to prevent conflicts.
4) A movement's request for impact assessments was denied as "state secret."
5) A foundation received no response to requests for spending reports of environmental funds.
This document discusses recent developments in open environmental information in China. It outlines the legal framework for disclosure, including key laws and measures passed since 2007. It also describes requirements for government agencies and companies to disclose various types of environmental information. The document then reviews progress made, such as the release of air quality data in 74 cities, and discusses observations from a civil society organization's Pollution Information Transparency Index reports, which have found improving disclosure scores but room for further progress.
Have you ever been confused by the myriad of choices offered by AWS for hosting a website or an API?
Lambda, Elastic Beanstalk, Lightsail, Amplify, S3 (and more!) can each host websites + APIs. But which one should we choose?
Which one is cheapest? Which one is fastest? Which one will scale to meet our needs?
Join me in this session as we dive into each AWS hosting service to determine which one is best for your scenario and explain why!
For the full video of this presentation, please visit: https://www.edge-ai-vision.com/2024/06/how-axelera-ai-uses-digital-compute-in-memory-to-deliver-fast-and-energy-efficient-computer-vision-a-presentation-from-axelera-ai/
Bram Verhoef, Head of Machine Learning at Axelera AI, presents the “How Axelera AI Uses Digital Compute-in-memory to Deliver Fast and Energy-efficient Computer Vision” tutorial at the May 2024 Embedded Vision Summit.
As artificial intelligence inference transitions from cloud environments to edge locations, computer vision applications achieve heightened responsiveness, reliability and privacy. This migration, however, introduces the challenge of operating within the stringent confines of resource constraints typical at the edge, including small form factors, low energy budgets and diminished memory and computational capacities. Axelera AI addresses these challenges through an innovative approach of performing digital computations within memory itself. This technique facilitates the realization of high-performance, energy-efficient and cost-effective computer vision capabilities at the thin and thick edge, extending the frontier of what is achievable with current technologies.
In this presentation, Verhoef unveils his company’s pioneering chip technology and demonstrates its capacity to deliver exceptional frames-per-second performance across a range of standard computer vision networks typical of applications in security, surveillance and the industrial sector. This shows that advanced computer vision can be accessible and efficient, even at the very edge of our technological ecosystem.
Skybuffer SAM4U tool for SAP license adoptionTatiana Kojar
Manage and optimize your license adoption and consumption with SAM4U, an SAP free customer software asset management tool.
SAM4U, an SAP complimentary software asset management tool for customers, delivers a detailed and well-structured overview of license inventory and usage with a user-friendly interface. We offer a hosted, cost-effective, and performance-optimized SAM4U setup in the Skybuffer Cloud environment. You retain ownership of the system and data, while we manage the ABAP 7.58 infrastructure, ensuring fixed Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and exceptional services through the SAP Fiori interface.
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...Jason Yip
The typical problem in product engineering is not bad strategy, so much as “no strategy”. This leads to confusion, lack of motivation, and incoherent action. The next time you look for a strategy and find an empty space, instead of waiting for it to be filled, I will show you how to fill it in yourself. If you’re wrong, it forces a correction. If you’re right, it helps create focus. I’ll share how I’ve approached this in the past, both what works and lessons for what didn’t work so well.
Freshworks Rethinks NoSQL for Rapid Scaling & Cost-EfficiencyScyllaDB
Freshworks creates AI-boosted business software that helps employees work more efficiently and effectively. Managing data across multiple RDBMS and NoSQL databases was already a challenge at their current scale. To prepare for 10X growth, they knew it was time to rethink their database strategy. Learn how they architected a solution that would simplify scaling while keeping costs under control.
Dandelion Hashtable: beyond billion requests per second on a commodity serverAntonios Katsarakis
This slide deck presents DLHT, a concurrent in-memory hashtable. Despite efforts to optimize hashtables, that go as far as sacrificing core functionality, state-of-the-art designs still incur multiple memory accesses per request and block request processing in three cases. First, most hashtables block while waiting for data to be retrieved from memory. Second, open-addressing designs, which represent the current state-of-the-art, either cannot free index slots on deletes or must block all requests to do so. Third, index resizes block every request until all objects are copied to the new index. Defying folklore wisdom, DLHT forgoes open-addressing and adopts a fully-featured and memory-aware closed-addressing design based on bounded cache-line-chaining. This design offers lock-free index operations and deletes that free slots instantly, (2) completes most requests with a single memory access, (3) utilizes software prefetching to hide memory latencies, and (4) employs a novel non-blocking and parallel resizing. In a commodity server and a memory-resident workload, DLHT surpasses 1.6B requests per second and provides 3.5x (12x) the throughput of the state-of-the-art closed-addressing (open-addressing) resizable hashtable on Gets (Deletes).
zkStudyClub - LatticeFold: A Lattice-based Folding Scheme and its Application...Alex Pruden
Folding is a recent technique for building efficient recursive SNARKs. Several elegant folding protocols have been proposed, such as Nova, Supernova, Hypernova, Protostar, and others. However, all of them rely on an additively homomorphic commitment scheme based on discrete log, and are therefore not post-quantum secure. In this work we present LatticeFold, the first lattice-based folding protocol based on the Module SIS problem. This folding protocol naturally leads to an efficient recursive lattice-based SNARK and an efficient PCD scheme. LatticeFold supports folding low-degree relations, such as R1CS, as well as high-degree relations, such as CCS. The key challenge is to construct a secure folding protocol that works with the Ajtai commitment scheme. The difficulty, is ensuring that extracted witnesses are low norm through many rounds of folding. We present a novel technique using the sumcheck protocol to ensure that extracted witnesses are always low norm no matter how many rounds of folding are used. Our evaluation of the final proof system suggests that it is as performant as Hypernova, while providing post-quantum security.
Paper Link: https://eprint.iacr.org/2024/257
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned", Igor IvaniukFwdays
At this talk we will discuss DDoS protection tools and best practices, discuss network architectures and what AWS has to offer. Also, we will look into one of the largest DDoS attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure that happened in February 2022. We'll see, what techniques helped to keep the web resources available for Ukrainians and how AWS improved DDoS protection for all customers based on Ukraine experience
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024Northern Engraving
Manufacturing custom quality metal nameplates and badges involves several standard operations. Processes include sheet prep, lithography, screening, coating, punch press and inspection. All decoration is completed in the flat sheet with adhesive and tooling operations following. The possibilities for creating unique durable nameplates are endless. How will you create your brand identity? We can help!
Driving Business Innovation: Latest Generative AI Advancements & Success StorySafe Software
Are you ready to revolutionize how you handle data? Join us for a webinar where we’ll bring you up to speed with the latest advancements in Generative AI technology and discover how leveraging FME with tools from giants like Google Gemini, Amazon, and Microsoft OpenAI can supercharge your workflow efficiency.
During the hour, we’ll take you through:
Guest Speaker Segment with Hannah Barrington: Dive into the world of dynamic real estate marketing with Hannah, the Marketing Manager at Workspace Group. Hear firsthand how their team generates engaging descriptions for thousands of office units by integrating diverse data sources—from PDF floorplans to web pages—using FME transformers, like OpenAIVisionConnector and AnthropicVisionConnector. This use case will show you how GenAI can streamline content creation for marketing across the board.
Ollama Use Case: Learn how Scenario Specialist Dmitri Bagh has utilized Ollama within FME to input data, create custom models, and enhance security protocols. This segment will include demos to illustrate the full capabilities of FME in AI-driven processes.
Custom AI Models: Discover how to leverage FME to build personalized AI models using your data. Whether it’s populating a model with local data for added security or integrating public AI tools, find out how FME facilitates a versatile and secure approach to AI.
We’ll wrap up with a live Q&A session where you can engage with our experts on your specific use cases, and learn more about optimizing your data workflows with AI.
This webinar is ideal for professionals seeking to harness the power of AI within their data management systems while ensuring high levels of customization and security. Whether you're a novice or an expert, gain actionable insights and strategies to elevate your data processes. Join us to see how FME and AI can revolutionize how you work with data!
Taking AI to the Next Level in Manufacturing.pdfssuserfac0301
Read Taking AI to the Next Level in Manufacturing to gain insights on AI adoption in the manufacturing industry, such as:
1. How quickly AI is being implemented in manufacturing.
2. Which barriers stand in the way of AI adoption.
3. How data quality and governance form the backbone of AI.
4. Organizational processes and structures that may inhibit effective AI adoption.
6. Ideas and approaches to help build your organization's AI strategy.
Main news related to the CCS TSI 2023 (2023/1695)Jakub Marek
An English 🇬🇧 translation of a presentation to the speech I gave about the main changes brought by CCS TSI 2023 at the biggest Czech conference on Communications and signalling systems on Railways, which was held in Clarion Hotel Olomouc from 7th to 9th November 2023 (konferenceszt.cz). Attended by around 500 participants and 200 on-line followers.
The original Czech 🇨🇿 version of the presentation can be found here: https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/hlavni-novinky-souvisejici-s-ccs-tsi-2023-2023-1695/269688092 .
The videorecording (in Czech) from the presentation is available here: https://youtu.be/WzjJWm4IyPk?si=SImb06tuXGb30BEH .
Discover top-tier mobile app development services, offering innovative solutions for iOS and Android. Enhance your business with custom, user-friendly mobile applications.
How information systems are built or acquired puts information, which is what they should be about, in a secondary place. Our language adapted accordingly, and we no longer talk about information systems but applications. Applications evolved in a way to break data into diverse fragments, tightly coupled with applications and expensive to integrate. The result is technical debt, which is re-paid by taking even bigger "loans", resulting in an ever-increasing technical debt. Software engineering and procurement practices work in sync with market forces to maintain this trend. This talk demonstrates how natural this situation is. The question is: can something be done to reverse the trend?
Fueling AI with Great Data with Airbyte WebinarZilliz
This talk will focus on how to collect data from a variety of sources, leveraging this data for RAG and other GenAI use cases, and finally charting your course to productionalization.
AppSec PNW: Android and iOS Application Security with MobSFAjin Abraham
Mobile Security Framework - MobSF is a free and open source automated mobile application security testing environment designed to help security engineers, researchers, developers, and penetration testers to identify security vulnerabilities, malicious behaviours and privacy concerns in mobile applications using static and dynamic analysis. It supports all the popular mobile application binaries and source code formats built for Android and iOS devices. In addition to automated security assessment, it also offers an interactive testing environment to build and execute scenario based test/fuzz cases against the application.
This talk covers:
Using MobSF for static analysis of mobile applications.
Interactive dynamic security assessment of Android and iOS applications.
Solving Mobile app CTF challenges.
Reverse engineering and runtime analysis of Mobile malware.
How to shift left and integrate MobSF/mobsfscan SAST and DAST in your build pipeline.
AppSec PNW: Android and iOS Application Security with MobSF
Wri stripe regional meeting: Overview of STRIPE Findings
1. Strengthening the right to information for People and the Environment
April 29-May 1
Jakarta Indonesia
STRIPE
REGIONAL MEETING
Carole Excell
Overview of STRIPE
findings
April 29-May 1
Jakarta Indonesia
7. Indonesia Thailand
• Tubanan village, Central
Java
• Tanjung Jati B coal
Steam fired power plant
(AIR)
• Pontang village, Serang,
Banten.
• Indah Kiat Pulp and
Paper (IKPP) (WATER)
• Indonesia Center for
Environmental Law
(ICEL) and coalition
• Community of Nong
Fab
• Community of Clong
Num Hoo
• Both in Map ta Phut
Petrochemical
Industrial estate
• (AIR and WATER)
• Partners – Thailand
Environmental Institute
and coalition
8. Strengthening the right to information for People and the Environment
April 29-May 1
Jakarta Indonesia
Methodology
10. How STRIPE Works
• ID needed info
• ID if legal mandate for collection and release
• ID Availability
• If info not available, file FOI Request
• Monitor and track
• Follow through FOI Request, incl. appeal
• Advocacy strategies created by each partner
and implemented
12. Information was made available
proactively but it was limited in
scope
Thailand:- More information
released on pollution in general
Indonesia:-More information on
environmental performance
Findings- Disclosure of Environmental
Information Proactively
19. • Gaps in the way industry
is regulated were found
– Failure to include
standards on toxic
chemicals
– Limited monitoring
requirements on permits
– Failure to conduct public
hearings for renewal of
permits
– Failure to take action for
breach of standards
Findings
24. Outcomes
An increase in the use of FOI
Law
175 requests were made by
local partners and community
members
A determination of gaps and
deficiencies in national right to
information law and practice as
well as the regulation of
pollution
25. Outcomes
• The first assessment of
proactive release of
information on air and
water pollution (7
categories).
• The community in Serang
got the government to do
an environmental audit of
the IKPP mill
• Enforcement of the right to
information in both the
mediation and appeal
mechanisms.
• Capacity Building for
Government, civil society
and communities
26. • Communities need to have the space to
participate in decision-making to use information
• Pollution control is aided by citizen action and
participation in policy, permitting and
enforcement
• Transparency policies are needed by
Government and Civil society to address
pollution control compliance.
• Proactive release of usable environmental
information is needed in both countries
Lessons Learned
27. "Those of us who understand
the complex concept of the
environment have the burden to
act. We must not tire. We must
not give up. We must persist "
Dr. Wangari Maathai (Nobel
Peace Prize Laureate, 1940-2011)
Editor's Notes
My presentation today is about the findings of the STRIPE Project. I plan to give you a short background to some of the issues the STRIPE project address, take you briefly through the methodology we utilised and then go into our findings from Indonesia and Thailand. We have a report that has been handed out to you that summarises these findings. We have also made 9 recommendations based on these findings are in that are that we can discuss at the end with the recommendations that you will hear from both presenters . STRIPE was conceived based on the result of TAIs research in 2008 that indicated that ( monitoring data, compliance data and the quality of information provided to the public was weak in the 65 case studies that we analysised from all over the world. The research also indicated that companies were continuing to claim confidentiality for data on the pollution they released into the environment and the even where specific systems were designed to release company level data on the environment it was released in forms that are not understandable to the public. STRIPE was thus designed to take advantage of the political opportunity created by using access to information laws in two countries Indonesia and Thailand to try and help ordinary citizens, civil society and communities understand the quality of the air and water in their communities and use that to help make change.
Map Ta Phut is one of the largest industrial estates in the world with close to 200 facilities incluing petroleum, gas and other polluting industries. Over thirty additional industry were proposed to be added. Activists including the Eastern Peoples Network obtained a court order trying to stop this development in line with the new constitution that required the preparation of additional health impact assessments. 11 projects have now got the go ahead by the courts. The government has said in a statement that this delay is expected to last for 10 months after which the projects should go ahead despite information about the health of nearby citizens and pollution of the water and air.
This is Ms. Lee Uk mari a villager who lives near the Map ta Phut estate. We visited her house and she told us that her well was polluted with arsenic by the local health authorities. Local officials also stated that it may be in her blood. She does not know how or when it will be cleaned up. She still uses it for gardening and believes the industries from Map Ta Phut are affecting her health.
This is the Tanjung Jati B Power Plant operates at Tubanan Village, Kembang Sub-District, Jepara Regency, Central Java. It is, close to the northern part of Java Sea in the area of Tubanan village. Where villagers live from agriculture and fishery sector,
This is Bakri a community leader from Tubanen. He is concerned about a little girl in his communities suffering from respiratory illnesses that he believes is caused from the coal fired power plant.
Empower communities to in the target countries to improve their environmental health through improved access to information. (FOI) law in partner country by strengthening domestic constituencies demanding environmental information. (1)to conduct research and analysis in these countries on air and water pollution control systems, identifying deficiencies and gaps in pollution control regulation (2)use FOI laws to push government to proactively release environmental information on air and water quality monitoring data, (3)work with communities and government to build their capacity to properly monitor private sector effluent and emission data (4) Build spaces for government dialogue on these issues and identification and support for key government officials to act as change makers in this process.
Friends of the earth / Legal Aid foundations – indonesia – Dr. Ganniga Sutthiprasid, Lawyer, Office of the Administrative Courts; o Mr. Pairoj Pholphet, Secretary for the Union Civil Liberty; o Mr. Srisuvan Janya, Environmental Committee, Lawyers Council of Thailand; o Mr. Sutthi Atchasai, Coordinator, Eastern People Network.
Ambient conditions – What is the quality of the water in the river or the quality of the air? – How were the standards set- was it transparent? E.g In indonesia preliminary research already reveal that air emission standards are not sufficient – Mercury Point Source _ What chemical/pollutants are entering the air, water or land from companies – In thailand we were told by the Ministy of health of two instances when they had large leaks from facilities that caused injury and death and were not able to get information from companies or government about what gases were released. Enforcement information – We were told that the industrial estate that brings in business is in charge of monitoring and enforcement of industry Non point- what are entering not from direct sources Air Quality indicator -Method for initial pollution monitoring publicly available (including siting of monitors, dispersal modeling) Ongoing reporting of annual releases made available Permit includes publicly available pollution reduction plan Synthesized information on violations of standards Ongoing measurement of water conditions (temp., pH, dissolved oxygen, conductivity, oxidation reduction potential, turbidity)
Problems faced – information needed- This study aims to identify important aspects of effective environmental information systems, identify where those systems are lacking, and make RTI requests to push strategically for access to information. The process of identification will include the following questions: Which information is required under the law? Is information being provided in accordance with the law? Is information being provided in a timely, accurate, understandable manner free of undue influence? The first template helps assess proactive systems for access to environmental information including: Comprehensiveness of parameters monitored (on general environmental conditions and on facility-level data) Process for gathering information, including verification Availability Monitor and Track – costs, response,timelines, appeals etc
Thailand – onsite monitoring – and pollution 2011 Indonesia – PROPER and EIAs Did not address specific monitoring data or discharges or answer health realted issue – use of water ,
This sign says “ good environmental governance” in Thailand and in reporting Nox and Sox the community noted that there are always happy faces all the time. The little proactive information that is released was not trusted by the communities.. Independent audits of data from facilities and rigorous reporting requirements were suggested by community members.
In both countries request were made to 34 public authorities. State owned enterprises had the worst response rate in both countries, this was followed by local government.
Both Indonesian and Thai government authorities took a varied, wide range of time to answer information requests despite having legislated-mandated timeline requirements. Data on response time was collected for 51 requests in Indonesia and 61 requests in Thailand. Overall the number of days it took Indonesian government authorities to send an answer varied from 4 to 27 days. The average number of days for a response was 11.96 days. Despite requiring a response in 15 days, Thailand requesters took between 4 and 90 days to receive a request response, with 31 requests taking longer than 15 days before acknowledgement. The average number of days for a response was 51.90 days
In Indonesia, most of the requests submitted about the two industrial facilities were either denied or resulted in a mute refusal. In Thailand, most requests for information about facilities, in general, and the four factories in particular were granted, although only a small number of requests were submitted about each facility particular information.
In both countries despite having independent review mechanism (Office of Information Commissioners/ Tribunal) requestors catalogued difficulties in the appeal process. Over 80% of the appeals made by requestors in Indonesia were denied, including 96% of the appeals submitted by community members. This included 68 cases where the original FOI request was met with a mute refusal and two cases initially denied. Most petitions submitted for internal review, 42 cases in total, were also denied; including all of the state owned enterprises based appeals. Many of the information was refused on the basis that the information was not their own information ( did not transfer) or that they did not have the information at all In many cases, Thailand requestors who were not satisfied with the information provided did not take additional action. Where appeals were pursued less than half were granted by Thailand’s OIC, including 14 cases where the original FOI request was met with a mute refusal and 6 cases that were originally denied. In many cases in Thailand requesters choose not to continue with the appeal process.
Difficulties in using FOI laws: Community members in both countries indicated difficulties in tracking and following up on responses to requests as well as using the internal review (Indonesia only) and appeal procedures. Response rate to requests: Community members in Indonesia had their information requests responded to with a mute refusal or refused 76% of the time. While the majority of information requests submitted by community members in Thailand were granted, 40% of their requests were refused or had a mute refusal response. Difficulties in understanding information: Community members in both countries documented difficulties in obtaining easily understandable information. In both Indonesia and Thailand, communities found that technical information was often sent in response to a request which was very difficult to understand. Information in Thailand was often provided in verbal form which made it difficult for citizens to share with other community members, interpret or take action. In some cases the answers given were in English instead of Thai or Indonesian. Intermediaries were needed to explain the information in both countries. Location and Cost Obstacles to Information: Costs also played a role in obtaining information. In Indonesia the FOI law permits public bodies to charge for duplication and delivery of information. This made it unreachable for ordinary community members. For examples, a huge volume of EIA documents were only available in hard copy (not electronic) at cost. In Thailand charges can be issued for photocopying or an official’s verification of photocopied pages. In both countries a significant amount of information, relevant to their requests, was only available in main cities (Bangkok and Jakarta). This became a limiting factor in more than one case as community members could not afford the travel costs. Providing Reasons for making a request: The Indonesian FOI law requires a reason is provided for making a request and therefore in several cases, citizens were asked to explain why they needed the information. In Thailand officials asked for a reason for requests even though the law does not require this. In a few other cases, officials called or visited requestor’s homes. Community members documented in both countries that at times they felt uncomfortable contacting officials; they were often not comfortable writing requests or appeals. In some cases, community members reported they felt afraid to file information requests about specific facilities because of possible resultant intimidation if the notice was provided to the company about who made the request for information. In Indonesia, based on the practice of Information Commissioners, it is actually has been determined that the absence of reason shall not be a ground of not processing an information request or a refusal.
Despite its importance Government is not providing usable information to local communities that directly relates to their health and environment Without basic information communities find it difficult to hold companies to account- Governments are not collecting and monitoring to provide needed information to communities FOI laws implementation and enforcement need to be strengthened Transparency policies can be utilised to strengthen coorporate compliance and government capacity to do this must be built systematically.