Workshop on
โ€œ How to reduce
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection
in primary careโ€
Introduction
Dr Aung Pyi Soe
M.B.,B.S (YGN), Dip. Med. Sc (Family Medicine)
Myanmar belief
แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€†แ€ฌแ€ธ = แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›แ€ฝแ€ญ
IV/IM vitamin injection
โ€ข Vitamin B complex ( B1 + B6 + B12)
โ€ข Vitamin B1
โ€ข Vitamin B12
โ€ข Vitamin C
โ€ข Glucose 25%, 50%
โ€ข Glucose + multivitamin infusion
โ€ข Calcium gluconate
โ€ข Amino acid injection
Strange!
โ€ข A lot of such practices are present around us.
But,
โ€ข Nothing was seen in the medical textbooks.
โ€ข Nothing was taught in the medical schools.
Factors promoting vitamin injections
โ€ข Patient factors
โ€ข Doctor factors
โ€ข Health system factors
โ€ข Culture factors
Factors promoting vitamin injections
Patient factor โ€“
โ€ข patient demand โ€“ dependent psychologically on
injection
โ€ข perception on treatment โ€“ will get better by
injection rather than oral, one can see skill of a
doctor
โ€ข Health belief โ€“ I will boost my energy by this
injection
Factors promoting vitamin injections
Doctor factor โ€“
โ€ข Finances โ€“ doctors are underpaid or greedy
โ€ข Poor knowledge on disease management โ€“
do not know what the patient is actually
suffering (failure of continuous professional
development)
Factors promoting vitamin injections
Health system factor โ€“
โ€ข Poor regulation on quacks and drug shops โ€“
more pressure to use injection practice that
cannot be used by non-medical personnel
Culture factor โ€“
โ€ข Family and society pressure โ€“ all the people
are doing
โ€ข Pain culture โ€“ no pain, no gain (will get better
if I receive pain by injection)
Ethical points of view
โ€ข แ€œแ€ฐแ€” แ€€ แ€ฑ แ€ แ€„แ€น แ€ฌแ€ธแ€†แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€œแ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ‚” แ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€•แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹
Autonomy โ‰  Right to demand
Autonomy is right to deny and right to know.
โ€ข แ€œแ€ฐแ€” แ€…แ€ฝแ€ญแ€แ€นแ€ฑ แ€€แ€บแ€”แ€•แ€นแ€ฑ แ€ก แ€„แ€น แ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€•แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹
Beneficence โ‰  making patient satisfied
Beneficence is doing good for the patient.
โ€ข แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€†แ€ฌแ€ธแ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ‚” แ€˜ แ€†แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€€แ€บ แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™ แ€™แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€ แ‹
Non - maleficence โ‰  avoiding death and disability
Non - maleficence is not doing any harm.
Professional points of view
โ€ข Doctors are professionals.
โ€ข Being professional is fulfilling the client needs
with the understanding of the risk and
benefits of any service given in terms of the
best interest for the client.
โ€ข Practicing medicine is not doing a business.
More importantly, people should be able to expect more
from physicians. Patients come to us for genuine answersโ€”if
they wanted a witch doctor, they would have found one. I
think we need to hold ourselves to a higher standard than a
huckster at the carnival. Weโ€™re not here to promise that weโ€™ve
got all the answers. We are here to be honest, and to use the
best knowledge that science has to offer, using genuine
compassion and thought. Letโ€™s leave the quacking to the
quacks. Weโ€™ll stick with real medicine.
Roy Benaroch, pediatrician
Februrary 3,2013
http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2013/02/fetish-vitamin-b12-shots.html
Problem?
โ€ข Is it the problem?
โ€ข Yes, it is.
โ€ข Is it manageable one?
โ€ข Yes, it is.
โ€ข Why wouldnโ€™t we do?
โ€ข Because, we donโ€™t know how.
โ€ข Then, we will together find out the solution.
Today is the history
Workshop on
โ€œ How to reduce the unnecessary
IV/IM multivitamin injection
in primary careโ€
Objectives
โ€ข To increase awareness of the problem of
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection among
doctors and public
โ€ข To find out the practical solutions to reduce
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection
โ€ข To collaborate among the GPs in reducing
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection
โ€ข To announce the position statement and
recommendations to reduce unnecessary
IV/IM vitamin injection in primary care
Agenda โ€“ morning session
Time Topics
8:00-8:30am Registration and morning tea
8:30-8:45am Introduction Dr Aung Pyi Soe
8:45-9:30am Keynote lectures
1) Scope of the problem Dr Kyaw Thet Soe
2) Biochemical and nutritional aspects of
IV/IM vitamin injection
Dr Theikdi Oo
9:30-10:30am Discussion from audience
10:30-12:00am Workshop 1
Who and why the patients are received Vit
injection?
Facilitator โ€“ Dr Kyaw Thet Soe
12:00-12:45pm Lunch
Keynote lecture themes
โ€ข IV/IM vitamin injection is the huge but covert
problem in primary care practice that uses up
the health resources โ€“ medications, money,
human, time.
โ€ข This practice is questionably beneficial to the
patient but definitely harmful to individuals
and public in some extent โ€“ in terms of
contents and ways of administration
Workshop (1) objectives
โ€ข to find out what is the patient population that
are receiving the treatment
โ€ข to stratify and classify this population
โ€ข to dig into the idea, concern and expectation
of those patients
Agenda โ€“ afternoon session
Time Topics
12:45-2:15pm Workshop (2)
Various ways to reduce
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin
injection
Facilitator โ€“ Dr Aung Pyi
Soe
2:15-2:30pm Afternoon tea break
2:30-3:30pm Conclusion
Finalizing position
statement and
recommendation
Workshop (2) objectives
โ€ข to brainstorm ways to reduce unnecessary
IV/IM Vit Injection together with advantages
and disadvantages
โ€ข to decide and list the effective ways on the
board to use in reducing unnecessary IV/IM
Vit injection
โ€ข to draft approach to use the various ways to
reduce unnecessary IV/IM Vit injection
โ€ข to present the draft approach and discuss the
practicability and pitfalls
Summarization
โ€ข to write the position statement as a workshop
output
โ€ข to write the recommendation for reduction of
unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection as a
workshop output
โ€ข to plan for future task
THANK YOU

Workshop on IV injection Introduction

  • 1.
    Workshop on โ€œ Howto reduce unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection in primary careโ€ Introduction Dr Aung Pyi Soe M.B.,B.S (YGN), Dip. Med. Sc (Family Medicine)
  • 2.
    Myanmar belief แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€ธ = แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›แ€ฝแ€ญ
  • 3.
    IV/IM vitamin injection โ€ขVitamin B complex ( B1 + B6 + B12) โ€ข Vitamin B1 โ€ข Vitamin B12 โ€ข Vitamin C โ€ข Glucose 25%, 50% โ€ข Glucose + multivitamin infusion โ€ข Calcium gluconate โ€ข Amino acid injection
  • 14.
    Strange! โ€ข A lotof such practices are present around us. But, โ€ข Nothing was seen in the medical textbooks. โ€ข Nothing was taught in the medical schools.
  • 15.
    Factors promoting vitamininjections โ€ข Patient factors โ€ข Doctor factors โ€ข Health system factors โ€ข Culture factors
  • 16.
    Factors promoting vitamininjections Patient factor โ€“ โ€ข patient demand โ€“ dependent psychologically on injection โ€ข perception on treatment โ€“ will get better by injection rather than oral, one can see skill of a doctor โ€ข Health belief โ€“ I will boost my energy by this injection
  • 17.
    Factors promoting vitamininjections Doctor factor โ€“ โ€ข Finances โ€“ doctors are underpaid or greedy โ€ข Poor knowledge on disease management โ€“ do not know what the patient is actually suffering (failure of continuous professional development)
  • 18.
    Factors promoting vitamininjections Health system factor โ€“ โ€ข Poor regulation on quacks and drug shops โ€“ more pressure to use injection practice that cannot be used by non-medical personnel Culture factor โ€“ โ€ข Family and society pressure โ€“ all the people are doing โ€ข Pain culture โ€“ no pain, no gain (will get better if I receive pain by injection)
  • 19.
    Ethical points ofview โ€ข แ€œแ€ฐแ€” แ€€ แ€ฑ แ€ แ€„แ€น แ€ฌแ€ธแ€†แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€œแ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ‚” แ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€•แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹ Autonomy โ‰  Right to demand Autonomy is right to deny and right to know. โ€ข แ€œแ€ฐแ€” แ€…แ€ฝแ€ญแ€แ€นแ€ฑ แ€€แ€บแ€”แ€•แ€นแ€ฑ แ€ก แ€„แ€น แ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€•แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹ Beneficence โ‰  making patient satisfied Beneficence is doing good for the patient. โ€ข แ€ก แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑ แ€†แ€ฌแ€ธแ€‘แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ‚” แ€˜ แ€†แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ญแ€ฏแ€ฌแ€ธแ€€แ€บ แ€ฝแ€ญแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™ แ€™แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€ แ‹ Non - maleficence โ‰  avoiding death and disability Non - maleficence is not doing any harm.
  • 20.
    Professional points ofview โ€ข Doctors are professionals. โ€ข Being professional is fulfilling the client needs with the understanding of the risk and benefits of any service given in terms of the best interest for the client. โ€ข Practicing medicine is not doing a business.
  • 21.
    More importantly, peopleshould be able to expect more from physicians. Patients come to us for genuine answersโ€”if they wanted a witch doctor, they would have found one. I think we need to hold ourselves to a higher standard than a huckster at the carnival. Weโ€™re not here to promise that weโ€™ve got all the answers. We are here to be honest, and to use the best knowledge that science has to offer, using genuine compassion and thought. Letโ€™s leave the quacking to the quacks. Weโ€™ll stick with real medicine. Roy Benaroch, pediatrician Februrary 3,2013 http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2013/02/fetish-vitamin-b12-shots.html
  • 22.
    Problem? โ€ข Is itthe problem? โ€ข Yes, it is. โ€ข Is it manageable one? โ€ข Yes, it is. โ€ข Why wouldnโ€™t we do? โ€ข Because, we donโ€™t know how. โ€ข Then, we will together find out the solution.
  • 23.
    Today is thehistory Workshop on โ€œ How to reduce the unnecessary IV/IM multivitamin injection in primary careโ€
  • 24.
    Objectives โ€ข To increaseawareness of the problem of unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection among doctors and public โ€ข To find out the practical solutions to reduce unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection โ€ข To collaborate among the GPs in reducing unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection โ€ข To announce the position statement and recommendations to reduce unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection in primary care
  • 25.
    Agenda โ€“ morningsession Time Topics 8:00-8:30am Registration and morning tea 8:30-8:45am Introduction Dr Aung Pyi Soe 8:45-9:30am Keynote lectures 1) Scope of the problem Dr Kyaw Thet Soe 2) Biochemical and nutritional aspects of IV/IM vitamin injection Dr Theikdi Oo 9:30-10:30am Discussion from audience 10:30-12:00am Workshop 1 Who and why the patients are received Vit injection? Facilitator โ€“ Dr Kyaw Thet Soe 12:00-12:45pm Lunch
  • 26.
    Keynote lecture themes โ€ขIV/IM vitamin injection is the huge but covert problem in primary care practice that uses up the health resources โ€“ medications, money, human, time. โ€ข This practice is questionably beneficial to the patient but definitely harmful to individuals and public in some extent โ€“ in terms of contents and ways of administration
  • 27.
    Workshop (1) objectives โ€ขto find out what is the patient population that are receiving the treatment โ€ข to stratify and classify this population โ€ข to dig into the idea, concern and expectation of those patients
  • 28.
    Agenda โ€“ afternoonsession Time Topics 12:45-2:15pm Workshop (2) Various ways to reduce unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection Facilitator โ€“ Dr Aung Pyi Soe 2:15-2:30pm Afternoon tea break 2:30-3:30pm Conclusion Finalizing position statement and recommendation
  • 29.
    Workshop (2) objectives โ€ขto brainstorm ways to reduce unnecessary IV/IM Vit Injection together with advantages and disadvantages โ€ข to decide and list the effective ways on the board to use in reducing unnecessary IV/IM Vit injection โ€ข to draft approach to use the various ways to reduce unnecessary IV/IM Vit injection โ€ข to present the draft approach and discuss the practicability and pitfalls
  • 30.
    Summarization โ€ข to writethe position statement as a workshop output โ€ข to write the recommendation for reduction of unnecessary IV/IM vitamin injection as a workshop output โ€ข to plan for future task
  • 31.

Editor's Notes

  • #30ย Group work for obj 1 and 2 โ€“ 45 min Combined for obj 3 and 4 โ€“ 45 min