NewBase 22 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1718 by Khaled Al Awadi (AutoRe...
Working at the Speed of Night - Vicky Hoyt, Flatiron West, Inc.
1. Working at The Speed of Night
Work Zone Awareness
Presented by: Vicky Hoyt
Date: July 11,2012
1
2. Working at The Speed of Night
Objectives
All Participants will be able to:
1)Define the Work Zone and its Hazards
2) List What is Currently Being Done to Improve
Conditions
3)Name at Least 1 Community Action You and/ or
Your Company Can Be Committed to Improve the
Working Conditions
2
3. Working at The Speed of Night
Work Zone Awareness
A WORK ZONE is a traffic way area that includes
Highway & street construction or utility work activities.
It differs from the “construction jobsite” in that the work
zone is in a roadway that has passing traffic.
3
4. Working at The Speed of Night
Dangers in The Work Zone
OSHA has identified two major categories of hazards found
at work zones: internal hazards and external hazards.
What Are Some Common Internal Hazards?
What Are The External Hazards of the Work Zone?
4
5. Working at The Speed of Night
Dangers in The Work Zone at Night
High Accident Frequency
Struck By Accidents
Productivity Losses
Confusion in Work Flow
Poor Efficiency
Lighting Problems at
Night :
Not enough light
Angle of light plant
Setting up light plant
Impaired/reduced visibility
5
6. Working at The Speed of Night
Dangers in The Work Zone
In California, the traffic congestion and citizens demand freeway closure work
to be performed primarily at night (McGowen, 2006).
.
6
7. Working at The Speed of Night
Contractors Best Practice Measures:
Traffic Control Devices- Follow MUTCD
Good, Glare-Free Illumination – Adequate & Not Blinding
Visibility of Workers- BE SEEN
Work Vehicle Visibility- BE SEEN
Train Supervisors & Crews in Work Zone Awareness
Use Barrier Methods
7
8. Partial Freeway Closure with Attenuators
Protecting the Work Zone
PARTIAL CLOSURE
SINGLE LANE OF TRAFFIC
8
9. Working at The Speed of Night
Partial Freeway Closure with Ideal Work Zone Protection
PARTIAL CLOSURE
SINGLE LANE OF TRAFFIC
9
11. Working at The Speed of Night
Improving Working Conditions and Incident
Statistics
1 Work Zone Fatality Occurs every 7 hours
The number of fatalities and injuries of the traveling
public in work zones is worse than the occupational
incidents, even among what OSHA calls “High
Hazard” industries
4 out of 5 Fatalities are Public Drivers
11
13. Working at The Speed of Night
Solutions To Take Safety to the Next Level for All
Stakeholders:
CalTrans+ AGC+ CHP = Good Work Zone Solutions
Improve Specifications in the latest revisions(increase
buffer zone, mandate barrier protection)
Expand work Windows
Cozeep Presence + Increase Ticket Enforcement
Possible Speed Reduction in Night Work Zones
13
14. Working at The Speed of Night
Get The Workforce & Public Involved through specific
awareness campaigns
Los Angeles Times
Carmagaddon
14
15. Working at The Speed of Night
MAKE CHANGES TO THE SPEED LAWS!
Lowering the Speed Limit in Work Zones Throughout
California between 11 PM & 3 AM
It takes less than one minute longer to travel
through a two-mile work zone at 45 miles per
hour than at 65 miles per hour.
49 seconds to be exact!
PETITION to Change the Law
15
16. Working at The Speed of Night
Review
1)Name OSHA’s Two Workzone Hazard Categories:
_______________, __________________
2) Name One Measure that Would Help Protected
workers from External Hazards: ________________
3)What Part of the Community Effort Can you make
the most Impact? 1) Speak up at Cal Trans Meetings
2) Participate in Awareness Training
3) Participate via social network
4) Sign a Speed Reduction Petition
16
17. Working at The Speed of Night
Work Zone safety is a community problem that requires a
culture change effort involving all the stakeholders
17
18. Working at The Speed of Night
Outreach Details
State/Agency: California
Campaign Name: "Slow for the Cone Zone"
Description:
The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) introduced its "Slow for the Cone Zone" safety campaign
at a news conference in 2000. Hoping to reduce accidents in highway construction and maintenance zones,
Caltrans targeted audiences in the San Francisco Bay Area and central coast of California with a clear message
to slow down, stay alert and use great caution in the cone zone. The centerpiece of the campaign is a
commercial, featuring a distracted driver slamming his automobile into a piece of highway construction equipment.
Themes: "Slow for the Cone Zone" - Theme aimed at danger to driver of car in cone zones. Ease up and stay
alert when passing a coned off area.
Audio PSAs: Slow for the Cone Zone Radio Commercial consists of the message to be alert and slow for the
cone zone. A car was crashed into a front-end loader for the commercial and to kick off the campaign. The crash
sound is heard in the commercial.
Video PSAs: The centerpiece of the campaign is a commercial, featuring a distracted driver slamming his
automobile into a piece of highway construction equipment. As glass shatters and metal distorts, viewers are
reminded of the dangers they face when they ignore the orange cones that outline a work zone. As if a further
warning were needed, the narrator dramatically reminds motorists, "Slow for the Cone Zone".
Materials: Slow for The Cone Zone Billboard consists of the message " Slow For The Cone Zone" and Caltrans
logo seen with cones. Graphics include Orange cones and the phrase "Slow For The Cone Zone." Web site and
signage on the back of trucks.
Website: http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/conezone/
18
19. Working at The Speed of Night- References
Axley, S. R. (2000). Communicating change: Questions to consider. Industrial Management, 42(4), 18–22.
Department of Labor Statistics, (2009) Census of fatality statistics, summary.
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cfoi.nr0.htm
Curwen, T. (2011) In the Carmageddon drama, L.A. drivers had to know their roles. July 16, 2011 edition, Los Angeles
Times
FARS, (2009)National Work Zone Safety Information Clearinghouse Work Zone Fatalities,
http://www.workzonesafety.org/crash_data/, based on information from National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS).
Flatiron (2011). Baldwin Park Project Incident Journals.
Gonzales, J. (2010) Interview at California Hospital, Oct, 2010, Los Angeles Ca.
Nastasi, B. & Schensul, S. (2005). Contributions of qualitative research to the validity of intervention research.
[Electronic version]. Journal of School Psychology, 43, 177-195.
Hammersley, M. & Atkinson, P. (1995). Ethnography: Principals and practice. NY, New York: Routledge.
Marsella, A. J. (1998). Toward a “global community psychology”: Meeting the needs of a changing world. American
Psychologist, 53(12), 1282-1291.
Mathis, (2002). Street-smart behavior based safety: It’s time for the theory to get real. Industrial Health and Safety
News. Retrieved on January 4, 2008 from web site: http://www.proactsafety.com/articles.htm
McClelland, K. (2000). Functionalism. Retrieved from http://web.grinnell.edu/courses/soc/s00/soc111-
01/IntroTheories/Functionalism.html
19
20. Working at The Speed of Night
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S., (1991) Motivational interviewing: Preparing people to change behaviour. New York:
Guilford Press.
Melton, G.,(1992). The law is a good thing (Psychology is, too): Human rights in psychological jurisprudence. Law and
Human Behavior, 16, 381-389.
Mathis, (2002). Street-smart behavior based safety: It’s time for the theory to get real. Industrial Health and Safety
News. Retrieved on January 4, 2008 from web site: http://www.proactsafety.com/articles.htm
McClelland, K. (2000). Functionalism. Retrieved from http://web.grinnell.edu/courses/soc/s00/soc111-
01/IntroTheories/Functionalism.html
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S., (1991) Motivational interviewing: Preparing people to change behaviour. New York:
Guilford Press.
Melton, G.,(1992). The law is a good thing (Psychology is, too): Human rights in psychological jurisprudence. Law and
Human Behavior, 16, 381-389.
O’Neil, P., (2004). The ethics of problem definition. Canadian Psychology, 46(1), 13-20.
Sahlins, M. (1976). Culture and practical reason, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
U.S. Department of Energy,(2002). Temporary losses of highway capacity and Impacts on Performance. Oak Ridge
National Laboratory.
U.S. Department of Transportation, (2001).Federal Highway Administration, Moving Ahead: The American Public
Speaks on Roadways and Transportation Communities. FHWA-OP-01-017. Washington, D.C.
20
21. Working at The Speed of Night- Refrences
U.S. Department of Transportation, (2002). Federal Highway Administration, A Snapshot of Peak Summer Work Zone
Activity Reported on State Road Closure and Construction Websites. Washington, D.C.
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics (2003-2008). Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries,
http://www.workzonesafety.org/files/documents/crash_data/worker_fatalities_2003-2007.pdf
U.S. Department of Transportation, (2004). Federal Highway Administration, Characteristics of Today's Work Zones,
presentation at TRB Annual Meeting by Gerald Ullman (Texas Transportation Institute) on preliminary study
results. Washington, D.C.
U.S. Department of Transportation, (2008). Federal Highway Administration, Our Nation's Highways 2008, Publication
No. FHWA-PL-08-021 Washington D.C.
21
Editor's Notes
This is a community IssueThe Stakeholders come from a variety of perspectives.As I present the material keep on open mind there are competing issues at stake…as you will see.Flatirons passion for work zone safety really came about after a seris of incidents. We took a hard look at our training and realized…even though of our traffic control people were certified that we really didn’t have a focused “work zone awareness” training.We started a western region steering committee that went to work to gather evidence based best practices and eventually put together an A really good awareness training.
Define “work zone”From the 1st warning sign to the “end construction” signDifferent from a CONSTRUCTION JOB SITEWork zones are dangerous places, but the need for highway repair and additional road work continues to grow as highway congestion continues to get worse. Between 1985 and 2006, vehicle miles traveled increased by nearly 100 percent, while highway lane miles only increased 5 percent during the same period (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2008). Add to the need for more highway work, a mounting frustration among the nations' driving public, and the danger grows.
Open Discussion- Capture on paperFor later inclusion
The number of fatalities and injuries of the traveling public is worse than the occupational incidents, even among what OSHA calls “High Hazard” industries45% are during the night. Caltrans admits a preference to schedule work at night as a way of increasing the amount of work that can be performed in a shift. Traffic volumes are lower and more lanes can be closed, allowing greater production and less complaints from the public. Contractors are accustomed to meeting their customers’ demands and have adapted with little question to Caltrans requests. Nevertheless, the incidents of confused and intoxicated drivers go up at night, increasing the risks for both the public and the workers (Mc Gowen, 2006). In 2006, federal government officials from The Federal Highway Administration (FHA) surveyed the publicand found the top three complaints of the public involved how the contractor completed the work, citing needs for: (1) more durable paving materials, (2) repairs during non-rush hours, and (3) reducing repair time (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2001).The FHA has been actively involved in responding to public concerns by taking a functionalist approach. The agency has been developing ways to speed the completion of projects through design-build strategies, standardization of traffic control methods, material designs, and engineering innovations implemented early in the project development process (McClelland,2000). At the same time they have addressed safety concerns by increasing communications through awareness campaigns, public announcements, and driver education programs. They have opened education clearing houses that provide free educational materials to contractors regarding safety devices to keep the work zone safe for all (FARS, 2009 ).
An operational plan should be developed for night work, to address risks associated with worker exposure to traffic, work vehicles and equipment. Workers (especially those inexperienced in night work) should be trained in procedures to avoid hazards associated with lowered visibility.
Looking at Protective Options- Distribute handouts
Caltrans admits a preference to schedule work at night as a way of increasing the amount of work that can be performed in a shift. Traffic volumes are lower and more lanes can be closed, allowing greater production and less complaints from the public. Contractors are accustomed to meeting their customers’ demands and have adapted with little question to Caltrans requests. Nevertheless, the incidents of confused and intoxicated drivers go up at night, increasing the risks for both the public and the workers (Mc Gowen, 2006
EVEN INCREASED USE OF MESSAGE BOARDS DURING DAYTIME HOURS
Work zones are dangerous places, but the need for highway repair and additional road work continues to grow as highway congestion continues to get worse. Between 1985 and 2006, vehicle miles traveled increased by nearly 100 percent, while highway lane miles only increased 5 percent during the same period (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2008). Add to the need for more highway work, a mounting frustration among the nations' driving public, and the danger grows. In 2006, federal government officials from The Federal Highway Administration (FHA) surveyed the publicand found the top three complaints of the public involved how the contractor completed the work, citing needs for: (1) more durable paving materials, (2) repairs during non-rush hours, and (3) reducing repair time (U.S. Department of Transportation, 2001).The FHA has been actively involved in responding to public concerns by taking a functionalist approach. The agency has been developing ways to speed the completion of projects through design-build strategies, standardization of traffic control methods, material designs, and engineering innovations implemented early in the project development process (McClelland,2000). At the same time they have addressed safety concerns by increasing communications through awareness campaigns, public announcements, and driver education programs. They have opened education clearing houses that provide free educational materials to contractors regarding safety devices to keep the work zone safe for all (FARS, 2009 ). Criteria #2: an analysis of the problem using one of the social change theories studied in the course.