From Cognitive Computing
To Wise (or Wisdom) Computing:
A Service Science Perspective
Jim Spohrer, IBM
AAAS Annual Meeting, San Jose, CA USA
February 15, 2015
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
1
Today’s Talk
• Questions
– Smarter, yes; But wiser?
– How can we be sure?
• Progressions
– Tool, assistant, collaborator, ?
– ? = cognitive machine, moral entity
• Occupations
– Cognitive assistants for all occupations
– Smart service systems
– Everyone can afford an executive
secretary and personal coach
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
2
“A service science
perspective considers
the evolving ecology of
service system entities,
their capabilities,
constraints,
rights, and
responsibilities.
Smarter, yes
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
3
Ken Jennings jokingly wrote: “(I for one welcome our new computer overlords)”
But wiser?
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
4
“Wise leaders make decisions only after they figure out
what is good for the organization and society.”
“Practical wisdom is tacit knowledge acquired from experience that enables people to make
prudent judgments and take actions based on the actual situation, guided by values and morals.”
Iwano: Cyber + Reality 1.0 = Reality 2.0
The emerging “cyber-coated reality”
• Reality 1.0
Relationships 
• Reality 2.0
Relationships include
Cyber-relationships:
– “Cogs” for all roles
• People-people
• People-organizations
• People-things
• People-information
– Cogs = cognitive
assistant intermediary
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
5
Source: ResourcesForLife.com
What is “cyber-coated reality” like?
• From Bacteria to “nervous-system-
coated reality”
• From Simple Machines to “cyber-
coated reality”
• Complex Adaptive Systems
– Physical systems
– Chemical systems
– Biological systems
– Social systems
– Socio-technical systems
– Physical symbol systems
– Cognitive systems
– Service systems
• Capabilities & Constraints
• Rights & Responsibilities
– Smart service systems
• AKA “cognitive service systems”
– Wise service systems
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
6
Source teachersparadise.com
Progression
• Tool
• Assistant
• Collaborator
• ?
– Fear: “overlord”
– Design goal: “moral
entity”
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
7
Source Amazon.com
First three items from a discussion with
Paul Maglio (UCMerced) & Don Norman (UCSD)
Brief History
of AI
1956 – Dartmouth Conference
1956 – 1981 Micro-Worlds
1981 – Japanese 5th Generation
1988 – Expert Systems Peak
1990 – AI Winter
1997 – Deep Blue
1997 – 2011 Real-World
2011 – Jeopardy! & SIRI
2013 – Cognitive Systems Institute
2014 – Watson Business Unit
2015 – “Cognition as a Service”
on IBM Bluemix
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
8
Vision: Augment & Scale Expertise
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
9
Cognitive Assistants - Occupations
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
10
Biochemist/Biochemical Engineer
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
11
Occupations = Many Tasks
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
12
Watson Discovery Advisor
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
13
Simonite, T. 2014. Software Mines Science Papers to Make New Discoveries. MIT. November 25, 2014.
URL: http://m.technologyreview.com/news/520461/software-mines-science-papers-to-make-new-discoveries/
User Models
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
14
New Era of Computing:
Cognitive Technologies & Componentry
15
 Natural Language
– Reasoning, Logic & Planning
– Symbolic Processing
– Natural Language Processing
– Ranking of Hypotheses
– Knowledge Representations
– Domain-Specific Ontologies
– Information Storage/Retrieval
– Machine Learning, Reasoning
– Von Neumann Componentry
– OpenPOWER Systems
 Pattern Recognition
– Recognition, Sensing & Acting
– Pattern Processing
– Image & Speech Processing
– Ranking of Hypotheses
– Pattern Representations
– Domain-Specific Neural Nets
– Information Storage/Retrieval
– Machine Learning, Perception
– Neuromorphic Componentry
– TrueNorth & Corelets Systems
AI for IA:
Intelligence
Augmentation
Cognitive Systems
(“Cogs”) that boost
learning,
discovery,
engagement,
transformation, and
long-range planning.
Cognition as a Service
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
15
Watson Platform on BlueMix
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
16
CSIG: Cognitive Systems Institute Group
 LinkedIn discussion
 Cognitive-Systems-Institute-6729452
 Web site for resource
sharing
 cognitive-science.info
 Bluemix
 ibm.biz/HackBluemix
 ibm.biz/LearnBluemix
 $0.07 per GB-Hour (*)
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
17
* = check online for current pricing info
Smarter Service Systems Workshop
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
18
National Science Foundation
A feature of a service system is the
participation and cooperation of the customer
in the service and its delivery. A service system
then requires an integration of knowledge and
technologies from a range of disciplines, often
including engineering, computer science, social
science, behavioral science, and cognitive
science, paired with market knowledge to
increase its social benefit.
Nano-Bio-Info-Cogno
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
19
Future Research Directions
• “The CSIG Algorithm”
• Cognitive Assistants for
Policy Maker
– “Debater” is coming
– Objective functions for
other entities
• Wise/Wisdom
Computing Needs:
– Literature review
– Roadmap of steps
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
20
Source http://www.linkedin/group/Cognitive-Systems-Institute-6729452
Literature Review
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
21
Related Work: Steve Omohundro
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
22
Source http://www.parc.com/event/2127/ai-and-robotics-at-an-inflection-point.html
Join ISSIP.org
Professional Development for Smart Service System Innovators
• 2015 Conferences
– HICSS, Honolulu, HI, Jan 5-8
– T Summit, E Lansing, MI, Mar 16-17
– ICSERV,San Jose, CA July 6-8
– Frontiers, San Jose, CA July 9-12
– AHFE HSSE,Las Vegas, NV July 23-27
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
23
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
24
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
25
IBM operates in 170 countries
around the globe
Acquisitions contribute significantly
to IBM’s growth ; ~120 acquisitions in
last decade
Number 1 in patent
generation for more
than two decades
More than 40% of IBMs
workforce does
business away from an
office
5 Nobel Laureates10 time winner of the
President’s National
Medal of Technology &
Innovation – latest for
LASIK laser refractive
surgical techniques
The Smartest Machine On Earth
100 Years of Business &
Innovation in 2011
New Era in IBM’s Leadership
IBM Growth Initiatives
IBM has
~400,000
employees
worldwide
Jim Spohrer, IBM
• Dr. James (“Jim”) C. Spohrer is Director IBM Global University
Programs and leads IBM’s Cognitive Systems Institute. The
Cognitive Systems Institute works to align cognitive systems
researchers in academics, government, and industry globally to
improve productivity and creativity of problem-solving
professionals, transforming learning, discovery, and sustainable
development. IBM University Programs works to align IBM and
universities globally for innovation amplification and T-shaped
skills. Jim co-founded IBM’s first Service Research group, ISSIP
Service Science community, and was founding CTO of IBM’s
Venture Capital Relations Group in Silicon Valley. He was awarded
Apple Computers’ Distinguished Engineer Scientist and
Technology title for his work on next generation learning
platforms. Jim has a Yale PhD in Computer Science/Artificial
Intelligence and MIT BS in Physics. His research priorities include
service science, cognitive systems for smart holistic service
systems, especially universities and cities. With over ninety
publications and nine patents, he is also a PICMET Fellow and a
winner of the S-D Logic award.
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
26
Professional Roles
• Director Global University Programs and Cognitive Systems Institute (2014 - )
– http://cognitive-science.info
– Cognitive Assistants for all occupations in smart service systems
• Director IBM Global University Programs (2009 – 2014)
– http://www.ibm.com/university
– 6 R’s - research, readiness, recruiting, revenue, responsibility, regions)
– Universities as “smarter service systems” and startup engines of their regions
• Founding Director of IBM’s first Service Research group (2003 - 2009)
– http://www.service-science.info
– Service Science (short for Service Science Management Engineering Design Arts Public Policy)
– http://www.issip.org
– International Society of Service Innovation Professionals (ISSIP)
• Founding CTO of IBM’s Venture Capital Relations Group (1999-2002)
• Apple Computer’s (Distinguished Engineer Scientist and Technologist) award (90’s)
• Student: Ph.D. Computer Science/Artificial Intelligence from Yale University (80’s)
• Researcher: Dialogue Systems/VERBEX – Speech Recognition Startup (1978-1982)
• Student: B.S. in Physics from MIT (1974-1978)
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
27
28
Measuring Impact (2003-2009)
• SSME: IBM Icon of Progress & IBM Research Outstanding Accomplishment
– Internal 10x return: CBM, IDG, SDM Pricing & Costing, BIW COBRA, SIMPLE, IoFT, Fringe, VCR
• Key was tools to model customers & IBM better
• Also tools to shift routine physical, mental, interactional & identify synergistic new ventures
• Alignment with Smarter Planet & Analytics (instrumented, interconnected, intelligent)
• Alignment with Smarter Cities, Smarter Campus, Smarter Buildings (Holistic Service Systems)
– External: More than $1B in national investments in Service Innovation activities
– External: Increase conferences, journals, and publications
– External: Service Science SIGs in Professional Associations
– External: Course & Program Guidelines for T-shaped Professionals, 500+ institutions
– External: National Service Science Institutions, Books & Case Studies (Open Services Innovation)
– External: International Society of Service Innovation Professionals (ISSIP)
• Service Research, a Portfolio Approach
– 1. Improve existing offerings (value propositions that can move the needle on KPI’s)
– 2. Create new offerings (for old and new customers)
– 3. Improve outcomes insourcing, outsourcing, acquisitions, divestitures (interconnect-fission-fusion)
– 4. For all three of the above, improve customer/partner capabilities (ratchet each other up)
– 5. For all four of the above, increase patents and service IP assets (some donated to open forums)
– 6. For all five of the above, increase publications and body-of-knowledge (professional associations)
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
2/16/2015
© IBM 2015, IBM Upward University
Programs Worldwide accelerating regional
development
29

Wise computing 20150215 v5

  • 1.
    From Cognitive Computing ToWise (or Wisdom) Computing: A Service Science Perspective Jim Spohrer, IBM AAAS Annual Meeting, San Jose, CA USA February 15, 2015 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 1
  • 2.
    Today’s Talk • Questions –Smarter, yes; But wiser? – How can we be sure? • Progressions – Tool, assistant, collaborator, ? – ? = cognitive machine, moral entity • Occupations – Cognitive assistants for all occupations – Smart service systems – Everyone can afford an executive secretary and personal coach 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 2 “A service science perspective considers the evolving ecology of service system entities, their capabilities, constraints, rights, and responsibilities.
  • 3.
    Smarter, yes 2/16/2015 © IBM2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 3 Ken Jennings jokingly wrote: “(I for one welcome our new computer overlords)”
  • 4.
    But wiser? 2/16/2015 © IBM2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 4 “Wise leaders make decisions only after they figure out what is good for the organization and society.” “Practical wisdom is tacit knowledge acquired from experience that enables people to make prudent judgments and take actions based on the actual situation, guided by values and morals.”
  • 5.
    Iwano: Cyber +Reality 1.0 = Reality 2.0 The emerging “cyber-coated reality” • Reality 1.0 Relationships  • Reality 2.0 Relationships include Cyber-relationships: – “Cogs” for all roles • People-people • People-organizations • People-things • People-information – Cogs = cognitive assistant intermediary 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 5 Source: ResourcesForLife.com
  • 6.
    What is “cyber-coatedreality” like? • From Bacteria to “nervous-system- coated reality” • From Simple Machines to “cyber- coated reality” • Complex Adaptive Systems – Physical systems – Chemical systems – Biological systems – Social systems – Socio-technical systems – Physical symbol systems – Cognitive systems – Service systems • Capabilities & Constraints • Rights & Responsibilities – Smart service systems • AKA “cognitive service systems” – Wise service systems 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 6 Source teachersparadise.com
  • 7.
    Progression • Tool • Assistant •Collaborator • ? – Fear: “overlord” – Design goal: “moral entity” 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 7 Source Amazon.com First three items from a discussion with Paul Maglio (UCMerced) & Don Norman (UCSD)
  • 8.
    Brief History of AI 1956– Dartmouth Conference 1956 – 1981 Micro-Worlds 1981 – Japanese 5th Generation 1988 – Expert Systems Peak 1990 – AI Winter 1997 – Deep Blue 1997 – 2011 Real-World 2011 – Jeopardy! & SIRI 2013 – Cognitive Systems Institute 2014 – Watson Business Unit 2015 – “Cognition as a Service” on IBM Bluemix 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 8
  • 9.
    Vision: Augment &Scale Expertise 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 9
  • 10.
    Cognitive Assistants -Occupations 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 10
  • 11.
    Biochemist/Biochemical Engineer 2/16/2015 © IBM2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 11
  • 12.
    Occupations = ManyTasks 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 12
  • 13.
    Watson Discovery Advisor 2/16/2015 ©IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 13 Simonite, T. 2014. Software Mines Science Papers to Make New Discoveries. MIT. November 25, 2014. URL: http://m.technologyreview.com/news/520461/software-mines-science-papers-to-make-new-discoveries/
  • 14.
    User Models 2/16/2015 © IBM2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 14
  • 15.
    New Era ofComputing: Cognitive Technologies & Componentry 15  Natural Language – Reasoning, Logic & Planning – Symbolic Processing – Natural Language Processing – Ranking of Hypotheses – Knowledge Representations – Domain-Specific Ontologies – Information Storage/Retrieval – Machine Learning, Reasoning – Von Neumann Componentry – OpenPOWER Systems  Pattern Recognition – Recognition, Sensing & Acting – Pattern Processing – Image & Speech Processing – Ranking of Hypotheses – Pattern Representations – Domain-Specific Neural Nets – Information Storage/Retrieval – Machine Learning, Perception – Neuromorphic Componentry – TrueNorth & Corelets Systems AI for IA: Intelligence Augmentation Cognitive Systems (“Cogs”) that boost learning, discovery, engagement, transformation, and long-range planning. Cognition as a Service 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 15
  • 16.
    Watson Platform onBlueMix 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 16
  • 17.
    CSIG: Cognitive SystemsInstitute Group  LinkedIn discussion  Cognitive-Systems-Institute-6729452  Web site for resource sharing  cognitive-science.info  Bluemix  ibm.biz/HackBluemix  ibm.biz/LearnBluemix  $0.07 per GB-Hour (*) 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 17 * = check online for current pricing info
  • 18.
    Smarter Service SystemsWorkshop 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 18
  • 19.
    National Science Foundation Afeature of a service system is the participation and cooperation of the customer in the service and its delivery. A service system then requires an integration of knowledge and technologies from a range of disciplines, often including engineering, computer science, social science, behavioral science, and cognitive science, paired with market knowledge to increase its social benefit. Nano-Bio-Info-Cogno 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 19
  • 20.
    Future Research Directions •“The CSIG Algorithm” • Cognitive Assistants for Policy Maker – “Debater” is coming – Objective functions for other entities • Wise/Wisdom Computing Needs: – Literature review – Roadmap of steps 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 20 Source http://www.linkedin/group/Cognitive-Systems-Institute-6729452
  • 21.
    Literature Review 2/16/2015 © IBM2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 21
  • 22.
    Related Work: SteveOmohundro 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 22 Source http://www.parc.com/event/2127/ai-and-robotics-at-an-inflection-point.html
  • 23.
    Join ISSIP.org Professional Developmentfor Smart Service System Innovators • 2015 Conferences – HICSS, Honolulu, HI, Jan 5-8 – T Summit, E Lansing, MI, Mar 16-17 – ICSERV,San Jose, CA July 6-8 – Frontiers, San Jose, CA July 9-12 – AHFE HSSE,Las Vegas, NV July 23-27 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 23
  • 24.
    2/16/2015 © IBM 2015,IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 24
  • 25.
    2/16/2015 © IBM 2015,IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 25 IBM operates in 170 countries around the globe Acquisitions contribute significantly to IBM’s growth ; ~120 acquisitions in last decade Number 1 in patent generation for more than two decades More than 40% of IBMs workforce does business away from an office 5 Nobel Laureates10 time winner of the President’s National Medal of Technology & Innovation – latest for LASIK laser refractive surgical techniques The Smartest Machine On Earth 100 Years of Business & Innovation in 2011 New Era in IBM’s Leadership IBM Growth Initiatives IBM has ~400,000 employees worldwide
  • 26.
    Jim Spohrer, IBM •Dr. James (“Jim”) C. Spohrer is Director IBM Global University Programs and leads IBM’s Cognitive Systems Institute. The Cognitive Systems Institute works to align cognitive systems researchers in academics, government, and industry globally to improve productivity and creativity of problem-solving professionals, transforming learning, discovery, and sustainable development. IBM University Programs works to align IBM and universities globally for innovation amplification and T-shaped skills. Jim co-founded IBM’s first Service Research group, ISSIP Service Science community, and was founding CTO of IBM’s Venture Capital Relations Group in Silicon Valley. He was awarded Apple Computers’ Distinguished Engineer Scientist and Technology title for his work on next generation learning platforms. Jim has a Yale PhD in Computer Science/Artificial Intelligence and MIT BS in Physics. His research priorities include service science, cognitive systems for smart holistic service systems, especially universities and cities. With over ninety publications and nine patents, he is also a PICMET Fellow and a winner of the S-D Logic award. 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 26
  • 27.
    Professional Roles • DirectorGlobal University Programs and Cognitive Systems Institute (2014 - ) – http://cognitive-science.info – Cognitive Assistants for all occupations in smart service systems • Director IBM Global University Programs (2009 – 2014) – http://www.ibm.com/university – 6 R’s - research, readiness, recruiting, revenue, responsibility, regions) – Universities as “smarter service systems” and startup engines of their regions • Founding Director of IBM’s first Service Research group (2003 - 2009) – http://www.service-science.info – Service Science (short for Service Science Management Engineering Design Arts Public Policy) – http://www.issip.org – International Society of Service Innovation Professionals (ISSIP) • Founding CTO of IBM’s Venture Capital Relations Group (1999-2002) • Apple Computer’s (Distinguished Engineer Scientist and Technologist) award (90’s) • Student: Ph.D. Computer Science/Artificial Intelligence from Yale University (80’s) • Researcher: Dialogue Systems/VERBEX – Speech Recognition Startup (1978-1982) • Student: B.S. in Physics from MIT (1974-1978) 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 27
  • 28.
    28 Measuring Impact (2003-2009) •SSME: IBM Icon of Progress & IBM Research Outstanding Accomplishment – Internal 10x return: CBM, IDG, SDM Pricing & Costing, BIW COBRA, SIMPLE, IoFT, Fringe, VCR • Key was tools to model customers & IBM better • Also tools to shift routine physical, mental, interactional & identify synergistic new ventures • Alignment with Smarter Planet & Analytics (instrumented, interconnected, intelligent) • Alignment with Smarter Cities, Smarter Campus, Smarter Buildings (Holistic Service Systems) – External: More than $1B in national investments in Service Innovation activities – External: Increase conferences, journals, and publications – External: Service Science SIGs in Professional Associations – External: Course & Program Guidelines for T-shaped Professionals, 500+ institutions – External: National Service Science Institutions, Books & Case Studies (Open Services Innovation) – External: International Society of Service Innovation Professionals (ISSIP) • Service Research, a Portfolio Approach – 1. Improve existing offerings (value propositions that can move the needle on KPI’s) – 2. Create new offerings (for old and new customers) – 3. Improve outcomes insourcing, outsourcing, acquisitions, divestitures (interconnect-fission-fusion) – 4. For all three of the above, improve customer/partner capabilities (ratchet each other up) – 5. For all four of the above, increase patents and service IP assets (some donated to open forums) – 6. For all five of the above, increase publications and body-of-knowledge (professional associations) 2/16/2015 © IBM 2015, IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development
  • 29.
    2/16/2015 © IBM 2015,IBM Upward University Programs Worldwide accelerating regional development 29