Dr. Efthymios Constantinides  Assistant Professor Marketing / e-Media School of Management and Governance  NIKOS / UNIVERSITY OF TWENTE [email_address] Social Media as Marketing Tools:  Valuable for SME’s? March 17, 2011   School of Management & Governance
AGENDA Introduction Web 2.0 and Social Media What is Social Media Marketing SMEs experiences from the field
Social Media research in UT / MB / NIKOS SOMERE:  a junior research center (BS / M&G) Master Research on Web 2.0 / Social Media  3 PhDs  Own research: User behavior in online social enviroments, Social market segments, influence of social media on buying behavior.  Ex. Adoption and Market Segments of SNS users in NL; Use of Social Media by WVO 5/6 children and effect on choice of HE study and University Bottom line: How marketers can effectively engage the Internet and the Social Media as Marketing Tools
 
What is Web 2.0 and Social Media?
 
 
What is Social Media Marketing? The Definitive End of Push Marketing!
The power of the Social Media
The Internet and the Social Media are changing the marketing practice
Marketing  Is Changing   Declining Effects of  Traditional Marketing Model Increasing  Customer Power Decreasing  Customer Trust
1. The importance of the Marketing model is declining
 
 
2. The buying / decision making process is changing
Traditional Marketing Marketing in Web 1.0 environment Marketing in Web 2.0 environment The way customers make decisions is changing: Model of Customer Behavior  (  Kotler et al. Marketing Management, 2009) © E. Constantinides
Customer Empowerment
Customers become Brand Ambassadors
 
… but also Brand Detractors
 
And it can get even worst!
Example  1: Kryptonite bicycle locks Example  2: AOL Example  3: United Airlines
Customer trust to business declines:  The new influencers are the peers 84% of Americans influenced by online customer reviews ( Opinion research Co , April 2009)   Bizrate survey (2007): 59% of users consider customer reviews to be more reliable than those from experts Study of Deloitte Touche USA: 62% of the US consumers read consumer-generated online reviews and 98% of them find these reviews reliable enough 80% of these consumers say that reading these reviews has affected their buying intentions  85% of consumers will recommend a company with which they have a trusted relationship (Carlson Marketing)
Source: Constantinides and Fountain, 2008 Web  2.0 Dimensions SOCIAL MEDIA Social Effects Enabling Technologies Blogs Social Networking Sites Online Communities Forums/Bulletin Boards Content aggregators Empowerment Participation Openness Networking Conversation Community Democratization / User control Open Source RSS Wikis Widgets Mashups AJAX
Weblogs   SNS   Online communities   Forums   Content aggregators    © E. Constantinides
Social Media Marketing
Turning the Social Media Threat in a Strategic Opportunity: The (E-)Marketing Strategy Product/ service   Marketing/ E-Marketing Organization Web 1.0 Web site   Web 2.0 Social Media Level 1 Level 3 Level 2 Level 4
Social Media as Marketing Tools:  Generic approaches © E. Constantinides ACTIVE PASSIVE Marketing Strategy Listening In PR / Direct Marketing /CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Social  Media HOW SOCIAL IS YOUR BRAND? Web logs MobileCrunch Direct2Dell Mashable Toyota Communities  / Microblogs Wecando Threadless Twittorati NIKE Heinz   NOKIA Dell Social Networks H&M  Hyves AA McDonalds  Hyves XXX LEGO Forums /  B. Boards Epinions Reviewcenter AmericanExp KLM BookScanner Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring BizReport BuzzCupture DELL RSS Grolsch MyMuesli Innocentive
Online customer intelligence
A few cases How SMEs can harness the Social Media:  Examples from the field
Social Media as MarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities  / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums /  B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
Social Media as PR tool : KLM
 
Case 1: Blendtec
Will it Blend? Facts Before October 2006, Blendtec had spent more than a decade selling blenders to the commercial market (restaurants and so on) but had little name recognition with mainstream consumers.   “ Will It Blend” became a viral phenomenon generating 100 mil views, presence in mass media, about 700.000 fans and national distribution, sales up by 600% since the launch of the videos
Case 2: Red Scarf Equestrian
Joanna Wiseberg
Facts Red Scarf Equestrian   is an  one woman  Toronto-based business making stylish handbags and other luxury goods for horse lovers.  Problem: Niche of a Niche, need to go global, the market in Canada is too small Two years after launch Ms. Wiseberg was invited to showcase her goods at elite places like the Cannes Film Festival, The Monaco Grand Prix and a luxury goods conference in China (NYT 29 Sept. 2010) Business strategy: LinkedIn. Joining groups related to her field and participating in discussions. She is now member of more than a dozen groups including Luxury and Lifestyle Professionals, Luxury Addict Groups, Woman 2 Woman Business, and Horse Lovers of the Business World Source: NYT 29 Sept. 2010
Case 3: The Dessert Gallery Facebook Experiment Utpal  M.  Dholakia  and  Emily Durham  HBR March 2010
We began by e-mailing a survey to 13,270 customers from DG’s mailing list to gather store evaluations and data on shopping behavior; 689 people responded. Then, we launched the Facebook page and invited everyone on the mailing list to become a fan. DG updated its page several times a week with pictures of goodies, news about contests and promotions, links to favorable reviews, and introductions to DG employees. Three months later, we resurveyed customers, this time receiving 1,067 responses from DG’s Facebook fans, Facebook users who did not become fans, and customers not on Facebook. We analyzed the data sets separately and then compared participants in the first survey with those in the second who had become DG fans. As it turned out, Facebook changed customer behavior for the better. People who had replied to both surveys and had become fans ended up being DG’s best customers: Though they spent about the same amount of money per visit, they increased their store visits per month after becoming Facebook fans and generated more positive word of mouth than nonfans. They went to DG 20% more often than nonfans and gave the store the highest share of their overall dining-out dollars. They were the most likely to recommend DG to friends and had the highest average Net Promoter Score—75, compared with 53 for Facebook users who were not fans and 66 for customers not on Facebook. DG fans also reported significantly greater emotional attachment to DG—3.4 on a four-point scale, compared with 3.0 for other customers. Additionally, fans were the most likely to say they chose DG over other establishments whenever possible.
 
Social Media and CRM / customer service
 
 
 
 
Social Media as MarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities  / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums /  B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
What my students did Soocial.com Distimo.com
 
© E. ConstantinidesGeneral Introduction to the University of Twente
Social Media as MarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities  / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums /  B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
 
 
 
Social Media as MarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities  / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums /  B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
Seth Haber
Conclusions Declining Effects of Traditional Marketing Increasing Customer Power, transparency, alternatives customer generated content / Decreasing Customer Trust Social Media: New Tools of Marketing for SMEs Listen to customer voice PR, Advertising Reach the New Influencers Mass Customization Distributed co-creation
Thank you [email_address]

Social Media as Marketing Tools: Valuable for SMEs?

  • 1.
    Dr. Efthymios Constantinides Assistant Professor Marketing / e-Media School of Management and Governance NIKOS / UNIVERSITY OF TWENTE [email_address] Social Media as Marketing Tools:  Valuable for SME’s? March 17, 2011 School of Management & Governance
  • 2.
    AGENDA Introduction Web2.0 and Social Media What is Social Media Marketing SMEs experiences from the field
  • 3.
    Social Media researchin UT / MB / NIKOS SOMERE: a junior research center (BS / M&G) Master Research on Web 2.0 / Social Media 3 PhDs Own research: User behavior in online social enviroments, Social market segments, influence of social media on buying behavior. Ex. Adoption and Market Segments of SNS users in NL; Use of Social Media by WVO 5/6 children and effect on choice of HE study and University Bottom line: How marketers can effectively engage the Internet and the Social Media as Marketing Tools
  • 4.
  • 5.
    What is Web2.0 and Social Media?
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    What is SocialMedia Marketing? The Definitive End of Push Marketing!
  • 9.
    The power ofthe Social Media
  • 10.
    The Internet andthe Social Media are changing the marketing practice
  • 11.
    Marketing IsChanging Declining Effects of Traditional Marketing Model Increasing Customer Power Decreasing Customer Trust
  • 12.
    1. The importanceof the Marketing model is declining
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    2. The buying/ decision making process is changing
  • 16.
    Traditional Marketing Marketingin Web 1.0 environment Marketing in Web 2.0 environment The way customers make decisions is changing: Model of Customer Behavior ( Kotler et al. Marketing Management, 2009) © E. Constantinides
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    … but alsoBrand Detractors
  • 21.
  • 22.
    And it canget even worst!
  • 23.
    Example 1:Kryptonite bicycle locks Example 2: AOL Example 3: United Airlines
  • 24.
    Customer trust tobusiness declines: The new influencers are the peers 84% of Americans influenced by online customer reviews ( Opinion research Co , April 2009) Bizrate survey (2007): 59% of users consider customer reviews to be more reliable than those from experts Study of Deloitte Touche USA: 62% of the US consumers read consumer-generated online reviews and 98% of them find these reviews reliable enough 80% of these consumers say that reading these reviews has affected their buying intentions 85% of consumers will recommend a company with which they have a trusted relationship (Carlson Marketing)
  • 25.
    Source: Constantinides andFountain, 2008 Web 2.0 Dimensions SOCIAL MEDIA Social Effects Enabling Technologies Blogs Social Networking Sites Online Communities Forums/Bulletin Boards Content aggregators Empowerment Participation Openness Networking Conversation Community Democratization / User control Open Source RSS Wikis Widgets Mashups AJAX
  • 26.
    Weblogs SNS  Online communities  Forums  Content aggregators  © E. Constantinides
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Turning the SocialMedia Threat in a Strategic Opportunity: The (E-)Marketing Strategy Product/ service Marketing/ E-Marketing Organization Web 1.0 Web site Web 2.0 Social Media Level 1 Level 3 Level 2 Level 4
  • 29.
    Social Media asMarketing Tools: Generic approaches © E. Constantinides ACTIVE PASSIVE Marketing Strategy Listening In PR / Direct Marketing /CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Social Media HOW SOCIAL IS YOUR BRAND? Web logs MobileCrunch Direct2Dell Mashable Toyota Communities / Microblogs Wecando Threadless Twittorati NIKE Heinz NOKIA Dell Social Networks H&M Hyves AA McDonalds Hyves XXX LEGO Forums / B. Boards Epinions Reviewcenter AmericanExp KLM BookScanner Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring BizReport BuzzCupture DELL RSS Grolsch MyMuesli Innocentive
  • 30.
  • 31.
    A few casesHow SMEs can harness the Social Media: Examples from the field
  • 32.
    Social Media asMarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums / B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
  • 33.
    Social Media asPR tool : KLM
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
    Will it Blend?Facts Before October 2006, Blendtec had spent more than a decade selling blenders to the commercial market (restaurants and so on) but had little name recognition with mainstream consumers. “ Will It Blend” became a viral phenomenon generating 100 mil views, presence in mass media, about 700.000 fans and national distribution, sales up by 600% since the launch of the videos
  • 37.
    Case 2: RedScarf Equestrian
  • 38.
  • 39.
    Facts Red ScarfEquestrian is an one woman Toronto-based business making stylish handbags and other luxury goods for horse lovers. Problem: Niche of a Niche, need to go global, the market in Canada is too small Two years after launch Ms. Wiseberg was invited to showcase her goods at elite places like the Cannes Film Festival, The Monaco Grand Prix and a luxury goods conference in China (NYT 29 Sept. 2010) Business strategy: LinkedIn. Joining groups related to her field and participating in discussions. She is now member of more than a dozen groups including Luxury and Lifestyle Professionals, Luxury Addict Groups, Woman 2 Woman Business, and Horse Lovers of the Business World Source: NYT 29 Sept. 2010
  • 40.
    Case 3: TheDessert Gallery Facebook Experiment Utpal M. Dholakia and Emily Durham HBR March 2010
  • 41.
    We began bye-mailing a survey to 13,270 customers from DG’s mailing list to gather store evaluations and data on shopping behavior; 689 people responded. Then, we launched the Facebook page and invited everyone on the mailing list to become a fan. DG updated its page several times a week with pictures of goodies, news about contests and promotions, links to favorable reviews, and introductions to DG employees. Three months later, we resurveyed customers, this time receiving 1,067 responses from DG’s Facebook fans, Facebook users who did not become fans, and customers not on Facebook. We analyzed the data sets separately and then compared participants in the first survey with those in the second who had become DG fans. As it turned out, Facebook changed customer behavior for the better. People who had replied to both surveys and had become fans ended up being DG’s best customers: Though they spent about the same amount of money per visit, they increased their store visits per month after becoming Facebook fans and generated more positive word of mouth than nonfans. They went to DG 20% more often than nonfans and gave the store the highest share of their overall dining-out dollars. They were the most likely to recommend DG to friends and had the highest average Net Promoter Score—75, compared with 53 for Facebook users who were not fans and 66 for customers not on Facebook. DG fans also reported significantly greater emotional attachment to DG—3.4 on a four-point scale, compared with 3.0 for other customers. Additionally, fans were the most likely to say they chose DG over other establishments whenever possible.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Social Media andCRM / customer service
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Social Media asMarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums / B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
  • 49.
    What my studentsdid Soocial.com Distimo.com
  • 50.
  • 51.
    © E. ConstantinidesGeneralIntroduction to the University of Twente
  • 52.
    Social Media asMarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums / B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
  • 53.
  • 54.
  • 55.
  • 56.
    Social Media asMarketingTools: Generic approaches ACTIVE © E. Constantinides PASSIVE Marketing Objective Listening In PR / Direct Marketing/ CS Reach the Influencers Personalize Experience Tapping Creativity Application Type Web logs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Communities / Microblogs XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Social Networks XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX Forums / B. Boards XXX XXX XXX Content Aggregators / V.O.C. Monitoring XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX
  • 57.
  • 58.
    Conclusions Declining Effectsof Traditional Marketing Increasing Customer Power, transparency, alternatives customer generated content / Decreasing Customer Trust Social Media: New Tools of Marketing for SMEs Listen to customer voice PR, Advertising Reach the New Influencers Mass Customization Distributed co-creation
  • 59.