SlideShare a Scribd company logo
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
ISSN(e): 2415-2331, ISSN(p): 2415-5241
Vol. 5, Issue. 10, pp: 100-105, 2019
URL: https://arpgweb.com/journal/journal/11
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32861/ijwpds.510.100.105
Academic Research Publishing
Group
100
Original Research Open Access
Unseen Contributor to the Tensions in Georgia
Vladimir Liparteliani
Department of International Relations and Journalism, Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland
Abstract
The purpose of the research is to examine importance of Georgia‘s current relations with its neighboring Russia and
Azerbaijan and to estimate risks that deterioration of these relations can bring to Georgia‘s economy. Of particular
interest is to understand who stands behind the tensions happened in Georgia in the run-up to the tourist season of
2019 or at least to figure out possible motives behind the events. Interdependence of the states is analyzed through
historical review of their relations and estimation of their current mutual interests. Considering risks and aspirations
of the sides in the tensions, the motives behind are suggested. The data received depicts that none of these tensions
were initiated by Georgia following its interests, on the contrary, its ruling party‘s most visible achievement had
been the ability to maintain positive and beneficial relations with both Russia and Azerbaijan. Thus, the Georgian
government considered to be a victim in this case. The paper concludes that Georgian government is unable to react
on provocations in a timely fashion due to absence of agreement in the ruling party and being quite fragile for
outside forces that try to influence the country‘s political processes. Unless Georgia manages to build more
interdependent or less dependent relations with superpowers, it will be unable to avoid repetition of such
manipulations.
Keywords: Tensions in Georgia; Protests in the caucasus; Azerbaijan and georgia‘s relations; Russia‘s influence in the
caucasus.
CC BY: Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
1. Introduction
One of the main priority directions for Georgia‘s economy is development of tourism sector, which is closely
linked to neighboring countries and based on improved relations with them. According to recent statistics some of
the most important players in this field for Georgia are Russian and Azerbaijani tourists. Collectively they make up
for more than one-third part of the total tourists who visited Georgia in 2018. However, as the 2019 summer season
was approaching, the high season for tourism in Georgia, relations with both neighbors suddenly soured. The crisis
created a real threat for the whole tourism industry, and when buttressed with an already difficult economic situation
and currency crisis in Georgia, its impact was felt across many segments of the economy. According to National
Bank, due to sanctions imposed by Russia, Georgia will suffer losses of approximately 300 million dollars in 2019
(Forbes, 2019). Furthermore, parallel deterioration of relations with Azerbaijan may only aggravate the situation.
This research will analyze importance and perspectives of relations with both neighbors Russia and Azerbaijan
and evaluate risks associated with the current tensions and estimate what impact they can have on Georgia, and
discuss the possible motives behind the events of 2019. The research will contribute to understanding of the role of
economic and cultural ties between these three states for Georgia‘s stability. The results of this analyses play
important role in determination of the right position for Georgia‘s external policy decision makers as it clearly
depicts the weak points of the state‘s foreign agenda. The research will also be useful in attempt to clarify Russia‘s
foreign policy‘s agenda towards Georgia and tools it uses to influence the South Caucasian state.
2. Methodology
In order to evaluate both risks and importance of the current tensions between Georgia with its neighboring
Russia and Azerbaijan, it is necessary to determine roles of these states as they impact Georgia‘s much needed
stability—both geopolitically and in terms of economics. Hence the sense of relations between neighbors should be
understood through historical analyses and close ties, and what current factors are able to provide mutual benefits for
these countries, and what synergies they provide for each other. On the basis of the risk‘s significance it appears to
be able to further describe whose interests may stand behind the tensions.
2.1. Tourism – Country’s Priority
The previous government, of the United National Movement, UNM, place a high priority on tourism a
mechanism for economic growth. The same emphasis was continued successfully by the Georgian Dream party in
the wake of the 2012 Georgian parliamentary elections.
Regardless of the strong criticism towards the current government in terms of a claimed increased level of
corruption than compared with the period of the UNM (Saertashoriso gamchirvaleba – saqartvelo, 2019), recorded
criminal violation total (32.263 in 2011 vs. 58.412 in 2018) (Geostat, 2019a), and accusations of informal ruling, the
fact that tourism sector has done significant progress is undisputed with two fold increase after 2011 (Gnta, 2019).
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
101
However it is worth mentioning that the commitment to work towards the creation of a ―Touristic Paradise‖ –
and Georgia being a preferred destination was endorsed during the Saakashvili‘s period and the first massive wave
of investments was made at that time. The influx of investment served as a first step in bringing Georgia to a new
level.
The concept was most clear: Georgia needed money and investments in order to develop infrastructure whereas
on the other hand, it would bring in tourists who were supposed to boost economy growth. The exact same program
has been followed by the Georgian Dream but its efforts were even more successful than its predecessor.
Thanks to more or less normalized relations with Russian government than compared with the National
Movement, the flow of Russian tourists has drastically increased. Not only in touristic sphere improvement can be
positively mentioned, but Georgia‘s export indicators in terms of exports to the Russian Federation have also
undergone enormous growth and now represent the lion‘s share of total export (Geostat, 2019b).
On the other hand, relations that the new Georgian government, represented by Georgian Dream, has managed
to develop with the European Union should be mentioned as they have been raised economic indicators to a new
level. Reforms and the proposed Association Agreement, as represented DCFTA, were supposed to, and finally have
contributed to the economic development of the country (Modebadze, 2019).
The most visible achievement has been a free visa regime with the EU, which has become a symbol of country‘s
European success. Collectively improved relations could be called exemplary, and this also includes relations with
Azerbaijan and Turkey: no-visa regime and a constant touristic flow from other close countries, Iran and Armenia,
and buttressed with closer cooperation on all levels with the EU.
However, steady improvement does not mean ideal relations with Russia. Georgia had been benefiting from all
its neighbors, including Russia (I do not touch upon the issue of the breakaway regions of South Ossetia and
Abkhazia, and this lack of detail is intentional as it is beyond the scope of this paper) – especially in terms of
economic, political and cultural affairs. Thus, all these other considerations started appeared as something
unrealistic, and very transitory for Georgia, which has always been in at least difficult or even in hostile relations,
with at least one of its neighbors.
2.2. Relations with partners: Azerbaijan and Russia
In this section Georgia‘s relations with Azerbaijan and Russia and shared points for mutually beneficial
cooperation will be discussed on the basis of economic, cultural and political relations. The aim is to demonstrate
how closely tied these three countries are. Thus, to estimate and reduce potential risks that add to tensions between
Georgia and its neighbors.
2.2.1. Azerbaijan
Georgia and Azerbaijan though being of different cultural heritage, predominately Christianity on one side and
Turkic-Muslim identity on the other, has influenced one another in many ways. At times it has even created common
cultural crossovers. To list all cultural links between these two nations would be impossible within the scope of this
article but the most prominent will be further discussed.
A substantial number of Azerbaijani intellectuals, poets and writers who lived at the end of the 19th
century were
working in Tbilisi. They were active in circulating many progressive ideas and thus facilitating cultural cooperation
between two countries. Publishing newspapers and magazines in the mother tongue in the second half of the 19th
century had a positive impact on the Azerbaijani‘s cultural development (Kakachia and Shiriyev, 2019).
For instance, in 1878 in Gori, at the Transcaucasia Teacher Seminary an Azerbaijani (Tatar) Department was
established, known for its prominent graduate, playwright and contributor to purity of Azeri language Mirza Fatali
Akhundov (2000), reveals much. It represented a brilliant example of a common cultural past and such work served
as a masterpiece of an author with a disputable identity. Kurban Said published his novel in more than 30 languages
«Ali and Nino: a love story» (Azer, 2019). «The novel is frequently cited in the news when ethnic conflicts break out
in the Caucasus and Foreign Policy magazine listed it as one of ―The foreign-policy books you should be reading to
get ready for election season‖ (Eurasia, 2019).
The novel serves as a symbol of good neighborly relations between two countries and a statute of Ali and Nino
in Batumi is considered to be one of modern landmarks of the city being very popular among tourists particularly
from Azerbaijan.
Not only cultural ties, dating back, are strengthening these countries relations, but some very important recent
regional projects, such as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) and Baku-Supsa oil pipelines. The Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum
(BTE) gas line can also be included on this list, creating strong and deep economic and political ties between
Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey. This also supports interests of the West as a corridor East-West serves as an
alternative route for bringing Caspian oil and gas to Europe. Notably that Azerbaijan supplied 90 percent of
Georgia‘s gas demand at the lowest rates among SOCAR‘s clients prices (Mendyk, 2019).
Development and upgrading of Georgia‘s transport infrastructure to bring it compliance with European
standards is a priority direction for Georgia‘s Foreign Policy Strategy, thus the Baku-Tbilisi-Kars railway project is
of highest importance. It is going to link two countries with centralized European railway network and that is a high
priority for the Black and Caspian Sea regions (Web, 2019).
Additionally, Azerbaijanis living in Georgia represent the biggest ethnic minority in the country and account for
7% of the population (Nplg, 2019). Majority inhabits the Kvemo Kartli region, known also as Borchali among
Azerbaijanis, where they make up roughly half of the citizenry with 45,1 % (Mikadze, 2019).
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
102
This fact should be very carefully evaluated, as without closer understanding, local demands could work against
Georgia‘s territorial integrity interests and vice versa. If potential issues could be addressed property, it could be
beneficial to the state, provided that it follows the path of a consistent and level policy.
Moreover, concurrently, there are about 10,000 ethnic Georgians called Ingiloys living in north-western
Azerbaijan. The main difference between them and Georgians in Georgia is religious affiliation, while some of them
are still Christians, many follow Islam.
In spite of potential conflicts and differences, Georgia remains a popular destination. It is becoming more and
more attractive for Azerbaijanis. Firstly, they visit the Black Sea region and health resorts during summer holidays.
They also come to Georgia during other times to access medical treatments, mainly based on better service and value
for the money. Just over one in five tourists to Georgia comes from Azerbaijan (20, 4 %) from the total amount of
visitors who came to Georgia during the first quarter of 2019 (Geostat, 2019c), which is the second highest
numbers.
Stated above is a prime example of interdependence between Azerbaijan and Georgia culturally, economically
and politically, which must be used by both states for mutual benefit and they must be aware of how third parties
may at times try intervene in such mutually win-win situations.
2.2.2. Russia
Discussions of relations of these two countries bring forth more questions than they can provide us with answers
and this topic is highly debatable. What these countries have common is greater than their differences. From the
very beginning of the relations, in end of the 18th
century, the uniting force proved to be Orthodox Christianity and
the belief that Russia would assume the role of protector. Generally, the way Russia is presenting to Georgia itself
today has not been dramatically changed since earlier periods of history.
Georgian policy towards Russian bears ambivalent character due to Georgia‘s attempts to recover control over
the defector breakaway regions Abkhazia and South Ossetia after mass expulsions of ethnic Georgians from these
region, and on the other hand, the importance of cooperation in economic and socio-cultural issues.
The current ruling party of the Georgian Dream has drastically improved relations with Russia (in comparison
with Saakashvili‘s period) and it has managed to gain benefits, including being able to sell greater quantities of wine
and mineral water to the Russian market. A positive attitude by most Russians makes Georgia one of top most
popular tourist destinations for its citizens (Russiatourism, 2019).
The factor is very important as the popularity of the destination had only been growing until the June 2019. It is
worth mentioning that Georgia has been able to become one of the leading destinations for Russian tourism in spite
of political crises between the states and absence of official diplomatic relations. The important step towards that
helped in the tendency was the implementation of visa-free regime for Russian citizens. This policy was introduced
by President Saakashvili in 2012 (Regnum, 2019).
Nonetheless, all such measures were implemented under the shadow of demands by many Georgians to address
the problem of the ―occupied territories‖ and to address the need to bring about an urgent resolution to the issue.
The government has also been absolutely clear in its position with regard to the country‘s territory integrity,
however, in spite of lack of progress, has somehow managed to balance it with closer collaboration. Although,
modern Russia today still has an image of an empire and is often associated by many Georgians as a country wishing
to seize their lands, the government has used a rational approach to balance its position. It has been successful, at
least until recently, to accomplish both goals at once: oppose occupation and gain benefits from trade and tourism.
However, some consider this as one of the few advantages that has been achieved since the Georgian Dream
party has been in control. There are still many question marks in terms of potential closer cooperation, for example
Giga Otkhozoria and Archil Tatunashvili‘s issues (Agenda, 2019a).
2.3. Tensions and their Meaning
2.3.1. Georgia-Azerbaijan
In spite of the fact that just over a third, (35%) of the 480 kilometer border between Georgia and Azerbaijan has
remained un-delineated for decades, a significant diplomatic dispute has resulted and has led to negative political
statements by various purported stakeholder and public protests on both sides. The difficultness of the issue is that
border is dividing historic complex called David Gareji in Georgia or Keshishdag in Azerbaijan.
This debatable border delimitation happened in 28 January 1922 and remains bone of contention until today for
these two countries. The Soviet Government made decisions according to their politically expedient interests at that
moment, thus trying to 1) make it extremely difficult to undone that decision of border delimitation 2) make the
republics‘ future as much as possible dependent on Moscow in many cases. Today the issue is also complicated by
the fact that each of these two possesses and recognizes different facts and sources with regard to history of the
complex. Georgian side considers it as a part of its culture, while Azerbaijan‘s side counts it is a monument of
Albanian culture.
Although many attempts were used to finally find solution, for example Georgian side suggested to swap the
complex in exchange for some other territories, no agreement has been made yet unfortunately (Sainformacio
analitikuri portali, 2019). The reasons for impossibility for this exchange to become true is that it could give
precedent for the Karabakh issue. If Azerbaijan gives the territory to Georgia on the basis of the last‘s claims to
control the complex as it is a part of Georgian culture and religion, then it would mean that Armenian‘s claims on
Karabakh do have a legal and justified reasons.
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
103
It would also jeopardize the concept of Azerbaijan state as the multicultural one that incorporates peoples and
lands of different ethnicities and unite them under one common governmental idea. The brilliant example for it is
Turkey, closest ally of Azerbaijan. Thus this exchange would serve as a time-bomb as there are enough premises in
Azerbaijan for possible separatism by other ethnic groups living within the country today.
Normally peaceful situation on the Georgian-Azerbaijan border abruptly flared up when Georgian President
Salome Zurabishvili was visiting complex in April 2019. She had called for an effort to finalize the delimitation
talks. Later, on the eve of Orthodox Easter, Azerbaijani border guards restricted access to part of the complex, hence
causing resentment from Georgian worshippers, especially monks and tour guides.
Additionally, the entry to the medieval monastery of Udabno was blocked, where amazing Georgian frescos of
utmost importance for Georgians are maintained. These events caused serious concerns from Georgian Church
Officials. Heated by the events, both Georgians and Azerbaijanis started to debate and argue in online message
boards, thus causing even greater dissonance.
Relatively peaceful rallies were held by Georgian side both along the border near David Gareji and in from of
the Azerbaijani Embassy in Tbilisi (Civil, 2019). Several days after the two countries foreign ministers agreed to
reopen access but the tension had still been existing and in several weeks finally converted in harassing Azerbaijani
boarder guard by Georgian activists and grabbling a pistol from him (YouTube, 2019a). Although both governments
reacted on these particular episodes similarly with condemnation, they hold completely different positions over the
border demarcation issue (Eurasia, 2019).
Due to the above discussed importance of the border issue for both sides, it now appears that is premature to
predict any significant changes and final resolutions at the moment. The repercussions, if one of sides attempts to
solve the problem unilaterally, will be too grave and not worthy for any of the stakeholder.
All this should be discussed in light to the above discussed economic, cultural and social interdependence, and
most importantly, perspectives for future cooperation, however, if emotions are allowed to prevail, irrational
behavior and decisions may prevail. Hence, we can clearly observe that neither Georgia nor Azerbaijan can benefit
from escalation of this border issue, rather than possible third parties.
2.3.2. Georgia-Russia
Understanding the problems faced by these countries relations is essential in looking at larger geopolitical
issues. Few expected the issues that resulted over the unresolved border delineation, and this brought about tense
relations over David Gareji and its ownership. However, in light of what has been mentioned and gradually
improving relations within the last seven years, pundits and laypersons can at least can easily observe the
consequences, particularly on the Georgian economy.
The main sticking point for deterioration in relations was, as Russian side is treating it, the breakout of anti-
Russian protests in Tbilisi, however from the very beginning protest were first described as anti-governmental with
the aim of overthrowing the legally elected Georgian government.
Only later did the protests start to contain anti-occupational direction, albeit rather symbolic. Protesters accused
the government in allowing Russian MP Sergey Gavrilov to chair the general assembly of the Interparliamentary
Assembly on Orthodoxy (IAO) (RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty, 2019). The position of protesters was based on the
fact that Mr. Gavrilov was officially representing the country which, many in Georgia, describes as an occupier.
Consequently he had to leave Georgia urgently and proceedings were disrupted. The second event what
happened was an ill-timed and insulting speech of TV host Giorgi Gabunia, who personally addressed Vladimir
Putting with highly offensive language; it is worth mentioning that this all happened within the background of two
weeks of going protests (YouTube, 2019b).
As the result, Russia considered Georgia to be dangerous for its citizens and banned all direct flights to the
country. It also prohibited Russian tour agencies from booking travels to the country (Agenda, 2019b), thus seriously
harming the Georgian tourism sector.
Tbilisi is now on the list of European cities with hardly any Russian tourists (CNN Travel, 2019). There were
also attempts by Duma to impose tough economic sanctions on Georgia after the insulting speech, however Russia‘s
President did not support the parliamentary call.
It does not appear as if all what has transpired was happenstance, not by chance but rather a series of events that
were planned.
In retrospect it is difficult to imagine that members of the ruling party did not know that Russian MP was going
to visit Georgia and chair the assembly. It appears they could not or did not want stop Mr. Gavrilov from coming to
the country. But rather used this as something of a false flag for political gain.
Nonetheless, such efforts backfired in the final analysis, having a negative impact, not only for Georgia but the
United National Movement. It is the Georgian economy that has been weakened and society further divided, and
many are more confused as to the political orientation of the country and who actually stands behind such events.
As for the Russian Federation, it becomes a story of ―I hate to tell you so but I told you so, as Georgia is
unpredictable and not a reliable or trusted party, too emotional.
Russian has been able to prove its cool political standing in face of provocations, not pushing all Georgians for
the actions of a provocation. Many Georgians now see Russia as a more reliable partner and having greater patience.
Russia now has more levers to wake up pro-Russian supporters in Georgia, and it has still not used its main trump –
ban for all Georgian import as it would have more economic consequences.
It is worth mentioning that Vladimir Putin‘s ―gesture of goodwill‖ in not imposing economic sanction after the
insulting speech by G. Gabunia will bring Russia a huge geopolitical advantage. Moreover, the possible cancelation
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
104
of visa regime for Georgians, currently being actively discussed in media (Новости and Новости, 2019), is now
being used by Russians as a ―carrot,‖ and such proactive actions only activates pro-Russian sentiments among
Georgians – thus setting the stage for the greater support by the population for what they perceived as practical
Russian policy.
On the other hand, the actions of Georgian opposition in this case can be estimated as a serious miscalculation
and almost a complete failure. We can assert with certainty that the Gabunia‘s speech was not spontaneous and
based on heated emotion, it was delivered with the clear intention of worsening relations between countries, hence
Georgian Dream, pro-Russians and Russia‗s government and destabilise an already difficult situation. If Putin would
had taken stricter measures and economic sanctions it would play into the hands of opposition. However Russia did
not do it—and this event was used as a way of actually improving Georgian-Russian relations.
3. Results
We can clearly see how important for Georgia having positive peaceful relations with Russia and Azerbaijan,
and not only in terms of maintaining the priority role of tourism in the country‘s economic development strategy. It
is particularly crucial, as the states maintain good perspectives and opportunities for improving relations in the
future. Taken together, due to good economic, cultural and political basis, many barriers can be overcome. However
we should not ignore that problems still exists on both sides. It is clear that under the circumstances that Georgia
currently does not possess any leverage needed to bring about a quick resolution of these issues. However, it is
definitely not in its interests to exacerbate situations, either with Russia or Azerbaijan. Hence, it is becoming clear
that third parties, with others in the shadows, have an agenda in intervening into Georgia‘s relations with its
neighbors, or that some force, domestic or international, desires for one of these neighbors to position itself to dictate
the terms and conditions to impact Georgia‘s policy direction.
4. Conclusion
Analyzing the given information, and in light of how events moved so quickly, it is clear that Georgia did not
initiated any actions in the neighborhood itself, but rather it found itself as being hold hostage. This was because of
government inability to sufficiently react in time to provocations in a timely fashion. It is clear that outside forces,
regardless of the true motivations, want to influence Georgia from near and far.
The ruling Georgian Dream party has not demonstrated any certain leverage in building its foreign policy basing
on National interests. But rather it maintains a defensive position and only reacts. It is clear that based on the
country‘s economic dependence on its neighbors that Georgia may at times be doomed to be manipulated, at least
until it will be able manage to build less dependent relations or more interdependent with its neighbors (as for
example with Azerbaijan).
The most important task at hand is to achieve such a status and without damage being inflicted to the national
economic as well as its cultural and political interests. This will be a challenge for the country for now and into the
foreseeable future.
References
Agenda, g. (2019a). Gov‘t puts 33 people on Otkhozoria-Tatunashvili list. Available:
http://agenda.ge/en/news/2018/1360
Agenda, g. (2019b). Putin bans flights to Georgia, orders return of Russian citizens to homeland. Available:
http://agenda.ge/en/news/2019/1659
Azer, c. (2019). 12.3 ali and nino covers - 37 languages. Available:
http://azer.com/aiweb/an_covers/123_ali_nino_cover.html
Civil, g. (2019). New rally at david gareji monastery | civil.Ge. Available: https://civil.ge/archives/306959
CNN Travel (2019). 20 beautiful European cities with hardly any tourists. Available:
https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/beautiful-european-cities-few-tourists/index.html
Eurasia, R. (2019). Ali and nino‘s enduring mystique – analysis. Available:
https://www.eurasiareview.com/24032012-ali-and-nino%E2%80%99s-enduring-mystique-analysis/
Forbes, G. (2019). Rusuli agrzalvis gavlena - negatiuri da pozitiuri prognozebi. Available:
https://forbes.ge/news/6695/rusuli-akrZalvis-gavlena
Geostat, g. (2019a). Siskhlis samartlis statistika – saqartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available:
https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/132/siskhlis-samartlis-statistika
Geostat, g. (2019b). Sagareo vacroba – saqartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available:
https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/35/sagareo-vachroba
Geostat, g. (2019c). Utskho vizitorebis statistika – sakartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available:
https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/102/utskhoel-vizitorta-statistika
Gnta, g. (2019). kvlevebi | saqartvelos turizmis erovnuli administratsia. Available:
https://gnta.ge/ge/%E1%83%A1%E1%83%A2%E1%83%90%E1%83%A2%E1%83%98%E1%83%A1%E
1%83%A2%E1%83%98%E1%83%99%E1%83%90/
Kakachia, K. and Shiriyev, Z. (2019). The foundations and challenges of the strategic alliance. Available:
www.researchgate.net
Mendyk, B. (2019). Bringing russian and iranian gas to the georgian market: Technically challenging, economically
unfeasible and politically costly? : Available:
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
105
https://www.academia.edu/35919412/Bartosz_Mendyk_Bringing_Russian_and_Iranian_Gas_to_the_Georg
ian_Market_Technically_Challenging_economically_Unfeasible_and_Politically_Costly_
Mikadze, Z. (2019). Kvemo kartli | sakhelmtsifo rtsmunebulis administratsia, kvemo kartli. Available:
http://kvemokartli.gov.ge/region
Mirza Fatali Akhundov (2000). Alphabet reformer before his time. Azerbaijan International, 8(1): Available:
http://azeri.org/Azeri/az_latin/latin_articles/latin_text/latin_81/eng_81/81_akhundov.html
Modebadze, Z. (2019). DCFTA-ს 1 tseli shedegebis mimokhilva.| EUGeorgia. Available:
http://eugeorgia.info/ka/article/343/dcfta-s-1-weli-shedegebis-mimoxilva/
Nplg, g. g. (2019). Ethnosebi saqartveloshi: azerbaijanelebi. Available: http://www.nplg.gov.ge/gsdl/cgi-
bin/library.exe?e=d-00000-00---off-0civil2--00-1----0-10-0---0---0prompt-10---4-------0-1l--10-ka-50---20-
about---00-3-1-00-0-0-01-1-0utfZz-8-00&a=d&cl=CL1.32&d=HASH01539272c0a61b8f8dfb8ff9.8
RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty (2019). Furious anti-russia protesters in tbilisi demand speaker's resignation, clash
with police. Available: https://www.rferl.org/a/anti-russia-protesters-in-tbilisi-demand-speaker-s-
resignation/30011083.html
Regnum, r. (2019). Available: https://regnum.ru/news/polit/1504531.html
Russiatourism, r. (2019). Viborochnaya statisticheskaya informacia, raschitanaya v sootvetstvii s Oficialnoi
statisticheskoi metodologiei ocenki chisla v‘ezdnix I viezdnix turisticheskikh poezdok – Rosturizm.
Available: https://www.russiatourism.ru/contents/statistika/statisticheskie-pokazateli-vzaimnykh-poezdok-
grazhdan-rossiyskoy-federatsii-i-grazhdan-inostrannykh-gosudarstv/vyborochnaya-statisticheskaya-
informatsiya-rasschitannaya-v-sootvetstvii-s-ofitsialnoy-statisticheskoy-metodologiey-otsenki-chisla-
vezdnykh-i-vyezdnykh-turistskikh-poezdok/
Saertashoriso gamchirvaleba – saqartvelo (2019). Erovnuli aghkmis indeksi. Available:
https://www.transparency.ge/ge/corruption/cpi
Sainformacio analitikuri portali (2019). Azerbaijanma davit garejis sadavo teritoris gacvlaze uari tqva. Available:
https://for.ge/view/36121/azerbaijanma-daviT-garejis-sadavo-teritoris-gacvlaze-uari-Tqva.html
Web, a. o. (2019). Ministry of foreign affairs of georgia - აზერბაიჯანის რესპუბლიკა (eng). Available:
https://web.archive.org/web/20070927063947/http://www.mfa.gov.ge/index.php?sec_id=334&lang_id=EN
G
YouTube (2019a). Georgian nationalists stormed david gareja (keşikçidağ) monastry in Azerbaijan's territory.
Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYp5RV1iypg
YouTube (2019b). Expletive-laden putin rant on georgian tv leads to channel going off air - BBC News. Available:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=re4dkJ3Iaks
Новости, Р. and Новости, Р. (2019). V MID ne iskluchili otmeni viz dlia grazhdan Gruzi‘i. Available:
https://ria.ru/20190718/1556631952.html

More Related Content

What's hot

Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent InterestsRussia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
Russian Council
 
China russia adnd;
China russia adnd;China russia adnd;
China russia adnd;
Saqib Nazir
 
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
Russian Council
 
Cadgat7 political relations
Cadgat7 political relationsCadgat7 political relations
Cadgat7 political relations
Bellamar Inc.
 
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia RelationsA Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
Russian Council
 
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
Egor Kuroptev
 
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
Russian Council
 
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
Russian Council
 
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
Chris Helweg
 
Policy statewatch20 en
Policy statewatch20 enPolicy statewatch20 en
Policy statewatch20 en
IDIS Viitorul
 
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
Russian Council
 
The russia china partnership
The russia china partnershipThe russia china partnership
The russia china partnership
Lester Lim
 
The Age of Putin - Global Implications
The Age of Putin - Global ImplicationsThe Age of Putin - Global Implications
The Age of Putin - Global Implications
Stephen Richardson
 
Transformation of the Modern International Conflicts
Transformation of the Modern International ConflictsTransformation of the Modern International Conflicts
Transformation of the Modern International Conflicts
ijtsrd
 
Managing differences report
Managing differences reportManaging differences report
Managing differences report
Russian Council
 
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump AdministrationComparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
ijtsrd
 
Four Scenarios for European Integration
Four Scenarios for European IntegrationFour Scenarios for European Integration
Four Scenarios for European Integration
Russian Council
 
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
David Vicent
 
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
paulussilas
 
Asia Society US-China21_English
Asia Society US-China21_EnglishAsia Society US-China21_English
Asia Society US-China21_English
Faiysal AliKhan
 

What's hot (20)

Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent InterestsRussia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
Russia—EU Relations at a Crossroads. Common and Divergent Interests
 
China russia adnd;
China russia adnd;China russia adnd;
China russia adnd;
 
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
Russia and Europe: Somewhat Different, Somewhat the Same?
 
Cadgat7 political relations
Cadgat7 political relationsCadgat7 political relations
Cadgat7 political relations
 
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia RelationsA Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
A Roadmap for U.S.-Russia Relations
 
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
Alternative "enemies" 2020. Kremlin's campaign in Georgia.
 
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
Cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Arab Republic of Egypt: Op...
 
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
Current state of Russia’s relations with Japan and prospects for their develo...
 
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
Newsbud Exclusive – “From the Atlantic to the Pacific”: Vladimir Putin & the ...
 
Policy statewatch20 en
Policy statewatch20 enPolicy statewatch20 en
Policy statewatch20 en
 
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
Theses on Russia’s Foreign Policy and Global Positioning (2017–2024)
 
The russia china partnership
The russia china partnershipThe russia china partnership
The russia china partnership
 
The Age of Putin - Global Implications
The Age of Putin - Global ImplicationsThe Age of Putin - Global Implications
The Age of Putin - Global Implications
 
Transformation of the Modern International Conflicts
Transformation of the Modern International ConflictsTransformation of the Modern International Conflicts
Transformation of the Modern International Conflicts
 
Managing differences report
Managing differences reportManaging differences report
Managing differences report
 
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump AdministrationComparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
Comparative Analysis of US China Relations during Trump Administration
 
Four Scenarios for European Integration
Four Scenarios for European IntegrationFour Scenarios for European Integration
Four Scenarios for European Integration
 
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
Resort-oriented tourism development and local tourism networks – a case study...
 
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
Prof. Dr. Paul Ade Silva, Editor of JAMMO, Interviews Khalil Charles, Deputy ...
 
Asia Society US-China21_English
Asia Society US-China21_EnglishAsia Society US-China21_English
Asia Society US-China21_English
 

Similar to Unseen Contributor to the Tensions in Georgia

Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
ijtsrd
 
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian ChallengeRussia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
Russian Council
 
Diplomacy
DiplomacyDiplomacy
Diplomacy
Anano Phagava
 
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
Russian Council
 
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
Azer Dilanchiev
 
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics
 
Regional Determinants of Central Asian Development
Regional Determinants of Central Asian DevelopmentRegional Determinants of Central Asian Development
Regional Determinants of Central Asian Development
ijtsrd
 
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC ReportProspects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
Russian Council
 
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
giorgi lomidze
 
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
Nicolae Arnaut
 
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS tiesA Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
The Economist Media Businesses
 
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
ijtsrd
 
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
ijtsrd
 
Vasty - trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
Vasty -  trade.pptx trading between ghana and russiaVasty -  trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
Vasty - trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
ClementNana
 
International relations
International relationsInternational relations
International relations
JitendraKumar1102
 
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgiaRemittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
Azer Dilanchiev
 
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptxTHE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
JizzaxAKM
 
Russia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
Russia–European Union: Potential for PartnershipRussia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
Russia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
Russian Council
 
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom RelationsThe Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
Russian Council
 
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 ModelRussian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
Russian Council
 

Similar to Unseen Contributor to the Tensions in Georgia (20)

Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
Economic Ties of Georgia with Central Asian Countries and Future Cooperation ...
 
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian ChallengeRussia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
Russia and the Visegrad Group: The Ukrainian Challenge
 
Diplomacy
DiplomacyDiplomacy
Diplomacy
 
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
Russian–Chinese Dialogue: The 2016 Model: Report No. 25/2016
 
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
The economic factors affecting emigration process in georgia the economic fac...
 
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
Trading with the Enemy: The Impact of Conflict on Trade Transactions in Non-C...
 
Regional Determinants of Central Asian Development
Regional Determinants of Central Asian DevelopmentRegional Determinants of Central Asian Development
Regional Determinants of Central Asian Development
 
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC ReportProspects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
Prospects for Russian-Chinese Cooperation in Central Asia. RIAC Report
 
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH, CASE STUD...
 
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
PartnerstwoWschodnie_EN (1)
 
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS tiesA Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
A Common Wealth: Building Gulf-CIS ties
 
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
 
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
Research on Trade Competitiveness and Trade Potential of Sino Russian Agricul...
 
Vasty - trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
Vasty -  trade.pptx trading between ghana and russiaVasty -  trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
Vasty - trade.pptx trading between ghana and russia
 
International relations
International relationsInternational relations
International relations
 
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgiaRemittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
Remittance inflow and economic growth the case of georgia
 
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptxTHE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FOREIGN TRADE EXPORT AND ECONOMIC..pptx
 
Russia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
Russia–European Union: Potential for PartnershipRussia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
Russia–European Union: Potential for Partnership
 
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom RelationsThe Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
The Current State of Russia-United Kingdom Relations
 
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 ModelRussian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
Russian-Chinese Dialogue: The 2015 Model
 

More from International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies

From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of GeorgiaMulticultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies
 

More from International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies (20)

From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
From Growth Poles and Clusters to Business Ecosystems Dynamics: The ILDI Coun...
 
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
Challenges of Participatory Development in West Africa: A Study of Nigeria’s ...
 
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
Evaluating the Programs and Procedures of Project Planning and Management: th...
 
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
Conservation Agriculture: An Agroecological Approach to Adapting and Mitigati...
 
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
Dynamics in Academic Achievement of Female Education in Jima Arjo Woreda and ...
 
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
Economic Loss of Timber Caused by Over Stumps and Defects in Community Forest...
 
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
Stakeholders’ Perspective of Role of Policy and Legislation in Achieving Medi...
 
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
Agricultural Informatics as a Branch of Study in Information Sciences and Tec...
 
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
Problems and Prospects of Subsistence Agriculture among Peasant Farmers in Ru...
 
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 in Oil Exporting Countries: An Analytical Re...
 
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
COVID-19 Induced Changes on Lifestyles Education and Socio-Economic Activitie...
 
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
Geopolitics of Religion: How Does Religion Influence International Relations ...
 
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
Lexico-semantic Features as Creative/Stylistic Strategies in Joseph Edoki’s T...
 
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
Female Suicide Bombers in Boko Haram Insurgency: Victims or Perpetrators?
 
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
The Graphic Communication Actor: Generating Visual Rhetoric for Development I...
 
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
Niger Delta Crises and the Way Forward: A Study of the Mood System in Helon H...
 
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of GeorgiaMulticultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
Multicultural Inevitability: Case of Georgia
 
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
Developments on Helix Theory: Exploring a Micro-Evolutionary Repositioning in...
 
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
Dynamic Relationship Between Global Oil Price and the Eswatini’s Exchange Rat...
 
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
Water-Demand Growth Modelling in Puerto Ayora’s Water Distribution Network Us...
 

Recently uploaded

NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSONNEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
SHAMIN EABENSON
 
FACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVEFACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVE
aditigupta1117
 
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to CareLGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
VITASAuthor
 
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
DR Jag Mohan Prajapati
 
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CT
PET CT  beginners Guide  covers some of the underrepresented topics  in PET CTPET CT  beginners Guide  covers some of the underrepresented topics  in PET CT
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CT
MiadAlsulami
 
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
rightmanforbloodline
 
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdfU Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
Jokerwigs arts and craft
 
Letter to MREC - application to conduct study
Letter to MREC - application to conduct studyLetter to MREC - application to conduct study
Letter to MREC - application to conduct study
Azreen Aj
 
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in itHypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
Vishal kr Thakur
 
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
nirahealhty
 
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
Canadian Cancer Survivor Network
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
Robert Cole
 
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdfchatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
marynayjun112024
 
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGYTime line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
DianaRodriguez639773
 
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
gjsma0ep
 
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
nktiacc3
 
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdfMBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
bkling
 
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure andGIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
MuzafarBohio
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Chandrima Spa Ajman
 
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine LectureProfessional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
DIVYANSHU740006
 

Recently uploaded (20)

NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSONNEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
NEEDLE STICK INJURY - JOURNAL CLUB PRESENTATION - DR SHAMIN EABENSON
 
FACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVEFACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVE
 
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to CareLGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to Care
 
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
DELIRIUM BY DR JAGMOHAN PRAJAPATI.......
 
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CT
PET CT  beginners Guide  covers some of the underrepresented topics  in PET CTPET CT  beginners Guide  covers some of the underrepresented topics  in PET CT
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CT
 
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
TEST BANK FOR Health Assessment in Nursing 7th Edition by Weber Chapters 1 - ...
 
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdfU Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
U Part Wigs_ A Natural Look with Minimal Effort Jokerwigs.in.pdf
 
Letter to MREC - application to conduct study
Letter to MREC - application to conduct studyLetter to MREC - application to conduct study
Letter to MREC - application to conduct study
 
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in itHypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
Hypotension and role of physiotherapy in it
 
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
Can coffee help me lose weight? Yes, 25,422 users in the USA use it for that ...
 
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
 
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdfDRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference  version  2.4.pdf
DRAFT Ventilator Rapid Reference version 2.4.pdf
 
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdfchatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
chatgptfornlp-230314021506-2f03f614.pdf. 21506-2f03f614.pdf
 
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGYTime line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
Time line.ppQAWSDRFTGYUIOPÑLKIUYTREWASDFTGY
 
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(EUR毕业证)鹿特丹伊拉斯姆斯大学毕业证如何办理
 
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
 
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdfMBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
 
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure andGIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
GIT BS.pptx about human body their structure and
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
 
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine LectureProfessional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
Professional Secrecy: Forensic Medicine Lecture
 

Unseen Contributor to the Tensions in Georgia

  • 1. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies ISSN(e): 2415-2331, ISSN(p): 2415-5241 Vol. 5, Issue. 10, pp: 100-105, 2019 URL: https://arpgweb.com/journal/journal/11 DOI: https://doi.org/10.32861/ijwpds.510.100.105 Academic Research Publishing Group 100 Original Research Open Access Unseen Contributor to the Tensions in Georgia Vladimir Liparteliani Department of International Relations and Journalism, Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland Abstract The purpose of the research is to examine importance of Georgia‘s current relations with its neighboring Russia and Azerbaijan and to estimate risks that deterioration of these relations can bring to Georgia‘s economy. Of particular interest is to understand who stands behind the tensions happened in Georgia in the run-up to the tourist season of 2019 or at least to figure out possible motives behind the events. Interdependence of the states is analyzed through historical review of their relations and estimation of their current mutual interests. Considering risks and aspirations of the sides in the tensions, the motives behind are suggested. The data received depicts that none of these tensions were initiated by Georgia following its interests, on the contrary, its ruling party‘s most visible achievement had been the ability to maintain positive and beneficial relations with both Russia and Azerbaijan. Thus, the Georgian government considered to be a victim in this case. The paper concludes that Georgian government is unable to react on provocations in a timely fashion due to absence of agreement in the ruling party and being quite fragile for outside forces that try to influence the country‘s political processes. Unless Georgia manages to build more interdependent or less dependent relations with superpowers, it will be unable to avoid repetition of such manipulations. Keywords: Tensions in Georgia; Protests in the caucasus; Azerbaijan and georgia‘s relations; Russia‘s influence in the caucasus. CC BY: Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 1. Introduction One of the main priority directions for Georgia‘s economy is development of tourism sector, which is closely linked to neighboring countries and based on improved relations with them. According to recent statistics some of the most important players in this field for Georgia are Russian and Azerbaijani tourists. Collectively they make up for more than one-third part of the total tourists who visited Georgia in 2018. However, as the 2019 summer season was approaching, the high season for tourism in Georgia, relations with both neighbors suddenly soured. The crisis created a real threat for the whole tourism industry, and when buttressed with an already difficult economic situation and currency crisis in Georgia, its impact was felt across many segments of the economy. According to National Bank, due to sanctions imposed by Russia, Georgia will suffer losses of approximately 300 million dollars in 2019 (Forbes, 2019). Furthermore, parallel deterioration of relations with Azerbaijan may only aggravate the situation. This research will analyze importance and perspectives of relations with both neighbors Russia and Azerbaijan and evaluate risks associated with the current tensions and estimate what impact they can have on Georgia, and discuss the possible motives behind the events of 2019. The research will contribute to understanding of the role of economic and cultural ties between these three states for Georgia‘s stability. The results of this analyses play important role in determination of the right position for Georgia‘s external policy decision makers as it clearly depicts the weak points of the state‘s foreign agenda. The research will also be useful in attempt to clarify Russia‘s foreign policy‘s agenda towards Georgia and tools it uses to influence the South Caucasian state. 2. Methodology In order to evaluate both risks and importance of the current tensions between Georgia with its neighboring Russia and Azerbaijan, it is necessary to determine roles of these states as they impact Georgia‘s much needed stability—both geopolitically and in terms of economics. Hence the sense of relations between neighbors should be understood through historical analyses and close ties, and what current factors are able to provide mutual benefits for these countries, and what synergies they provide for each other. On the basis of the risk‘s significance it appears to be able to further describe whose interests may stand behind the tensions. 2.1. Tourism – Country’s Priority The previous government, of the United National Movement, UNM, place a high priority on tourism a mechanism for economic growth. The same emphasis was continued successfully by the Georgian Dream party in the wake of the 2012 Georgian parliamentary elections. Regardless of the strong criticism towards the current government in terms of a claimed increased level of corruption than compared with the period of the UNM (Saertashoriso gamchirvaleba – saqartvelo, 2019), recorded criminal violation total (32.263 in 2011 vs. 58.412 in 2018) (Geostat, 2019a), and accusations of informal ruling, the fact that tourism sector has done significant progress is undisputed with two fold increase after 2011 (Gnta, 2019).
  • 2. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies 101 However it is worth mentioning that the commitment to work towards the creation of a ―Touristic Paradise‖ – and Georgia being a preferred destination was endorsed during the Saakashvili‘s period and the first massive wave of investments was made at that time. The influx of investment served as a first step in bringing Georgia to a new level. The concept was most clear: Georgia needed money and investments in order to develop infrastructure whereas on the other hand, it would bring in tourists who were supposed to boost economy growth. The exact same program has been followed by the Georgian Dream but its efforts were even more successful than its predecessor. Thanks to more or less normalized relations with Russian government than compared with the National Movement, the flow of Russian tourists has drastically increased. Not only in touristic sphere improvement can be positively mentioned, but Georgia‘s export indicators in terms of exports to the Russian Federation have also undergone enormous growth and now represent the lion‘s share of total export (Geostat, 2019b). On the other hand, relations that the new Georgian government, represented by Georgian Dream, has managed to develop with the European Union should be mentioned as they have been raised economic indicators to a new level. Reforms and the proposed Association Agreement, as represented DCFTA, were supposed to, and finally have contributed to the economic development of the country (Modebadze, 2019). The most visible achievement has been a free visa regime with the EU, which has become a symbol of country‘s European success. Collectively improved relations could be called exemplary, and this also includes relations with Azerbaijan and Turkey: no-visa regime and a constant touristic flow from other close countries, Iran and Armenia, and buttressed with closer cooperation on all levels with the EU. However, steady improvement does not mean ideal relations with Russia. Georgia had been benefiting from all its neighbors, including Russia (I do not touch upon the issue of the breakaway regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and this lack of detail is intentional as it is beyond the scope of this paper) – especially in terms of economic, political and cultural affairs. Thus, all these other considerations started appeared as something unrealistic, and very transitory for Georgia, which has always been in at least difficult or even in hostile relations, with at least one of its neighbors. 2.2. Relations with partners: Azerbaijan and Russia In this section Georgia‘s relations with Azerbaijan and Russia and shared points for mutually beneficial cooperation will be discussed on the basis of economic, cultural and political relations. The aim is to demonstrate how closely tied these three countries are. Thus, to estimate and reduce potential risks that add to tensions between Georgia and its neighbors. 2.2.1. Azerbaijan Georgia and Azerbaijan though being of different cultural heritage, predominately Christianity on one side and Turkic-Muslim identity on the other, has influenced one another in many ways. At times it has even created common cultural crossovers. To list all cultural links between these two nations would be impossible within the scope of this article but the most prominent will be further discussed. A substantial number of Azerbaijani intellectuals, poets and writers who lived at the end of the 19th century were working in Tbilisi. They were active in circulating many progressive ideas and thus facilitating cultural cooperation between two countries. Publishing newspapers and magazines in the mother tongue in the second half of the 19th century had a positive impact on the Azerbaijani‘s cultural development (Kakachia and Shiriyev, 2019). For instance, in 1878 in Gori, at the Transcaucasia Teacher Seminary an Azerbaijani (Tatar) Department was established, known for its prominent graduate, playwright and contributor to purity of Azeri language Mirza Fatali Akhundov (2000), reveals much. It represented a brilliant example of a common cultural past and such work served as a masterpiece of an author with a disputable identity. Kurban Said published his novel in more than 30 languages «Ali and Nino: a love story» (Azer, 2019). «The novel is frequently cited in the news when ethnic conflicts break out in the Caucasus and Foreign Policy magazine listed it as one of ―The foreign-policy books you should be reading to get ready for election season‖ (Eurasia, 2019). The novel serves as a symbol of good neighborly relations between two countries and a statute of Ali and Nino in Batumi is considered to be one of modern landmarks of the city being very popular among tourists particularly from Azerbaijan. Not only cultural ties, dating back, are strengthening these countries relations, but some very important recent regional projects, such as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) and Baku-Supsa oil pipelines. The Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum (BTE) gas line can also be included on this list, creating strong and deep economic and political ties between Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey. This also supports interests of the West as a corridor East-West serves as an alternative route for bringing Caspian oil and gas to Europe. Notably that Azerbaijan supplied 90 percent of Georgia‘s gas demand at the lowest rates among SOCAR‘s clients prices (Mendyk, 2019). Development and upgrading of Georgia‘s transport infrastructure to bring it compliance with European standards is a priority direction for Georgia‘s Foreign Policy Strategy, thus the Baku-Tbilisi-Kars railway project is of highest importance. It is going to link two countries with centralized European railway network and that is a high priority for the Black and Caspian Sea regions (Web, 2019). Additionally, Azerbaijanis living in Georgia represent the biggest ethnic minority in the country and account for 7% of the population (Nplg, 2019). Majority inhabits the Kvemo Kartli region, known also as Borchali among Azerbaijanis, where they make up roughly half of the citizenry with 45,1 % (Mikadze, 2019).
  • 3. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies 102 This fact should be very carefully evaluated, as without closer understanding, local demands could work against Georgia‘s territorial integrity interests and vice versa. If potential issues could be addressed property, it could be beneficial to the state, provided that it follows the path of a consistent and level policy. Moreover, concurrently, there are about 10,000 ethnic Georgians called Ingiloys living in north-western Azerbaijan. The main difference between them and Georgians in Georgia is religious affiliation, while some of them are still Christians, many follow Islam. In spite of potential conflicts and differences, Georgia remains a popular destination. It is becoming more and more attractive for Azerbaijanis. Firstly, they visit the Black Sea region and health resorts during summer holidays. They also come to Georgia during other times to access medical treatments, mainly based on better service and value for the money. Just over one in five tourists to Georgia comes from Azerbaijan (20, 4 %) from the total amount of visitors who came to Georgia during the first quarter of 2019 (Geostat, 2019c), which is the second highest numbers. Stated above is a prime example of interdependence between Azerbaijan and Georgia culturally, economically and politically, which must be used by both states for mutual benefit and they must be aware of how third parties may at times try intervene in such mutually win-win situations. 2.2.2. Russia Discussions of relations of these two countries bring forth more questions than they can provide us with answers and this topic is highly debatable. What these countries have common is greater than their differences. From the very beginning of the relations, in end of the 18th century, the uniting force proved to be Orthodox Christianity and the belief that Russia would assume the role of protector. Generally, the way Russia is presenting to Georgia itself today has not been dramatically changed since earlier periods of history. Georgian policy towards Russian bears ambivalent character due to Georgia‘s attempts to recover control over the defector breakaway regions Abkhazia and South Ossetia after mass expulsions of ethnic Georgians from these region, and on the other hand, the importance of cooperation in economic and socio-cultural issues. The current ruling party of the Georgian Dream has drastically improved relations with Russia (in comparison with Saakashvili‘s period) and it has managed to gain benefits, including being able to sell greater quantities of wine and mineral water to the Russian market. A positive attitude by most Russians makes Georgia one of top most popular tourist destinations for its citizens (Russiatourism, 2019). The factor is very important as the popularity of the destination had only been growing until the June 2019. It is worth mentioning that Georgia has been able to become one of the leading destinations for Russian tourism in spite of political crises between the states and absence of official diplomatic relations. The important step towards that helped in the tendency was the implementation of visa-free regime for Russian citizens. This policy was introduced by President Saakashvili in 2012 (Regnum, 2019). Nonetheless, all such measures were implemented under the shadow of demands by many Georgians to address the problem of the ―occupied territories‖ and to address the need to bring about an urgent resolution to the issue. The government has also been absolutely clear in its position with regard to the country‘s territory integrity, however, in spite of lack of progress, has somehow managed to balance it with closer collaboration. Although, modern Russia today still has an image of an empire and is often associated by many Georgians as a country wishing to seize their lands, the government has used a rational approach to balance its position. It has been successful, at least until recently, to accomplish both goals at once: oppose occupation and gain benefits from trade and tourism. However, some consider this as one of the few advantages that has been achieved since the Georgian Dream party has been in control. There are still many question marks in terms of potential closer cooperation, for example Giga Otkhozoria and Archil Tatunashvili‘s issues (Agenda, 2019a). 2.3. Tensions and their Meaning 2.3.1. Georgia-Azerbaijan In spite of the fact that just over a third, (35%) of the 480 kilometer border between Georgia and Azerbaijan has remained un-delineated for decades, a significant diplomatic dispute has resulted and has led to negative political statements by various purported stakeholder and public protests on both sides. The difficultness of the issue is that border is dividing historic complex called David Gareji in Georgia or Keshishdag in Azerbaijan. This debatable border delimitation happened in 28 January 1922 and remains bone of contention until today for these two countries. The Soviet Government made decisions according to their politically expedient interests at that moment, thus trying to 1) make it extremely difficult to undone that decision of border delimitation 2) make the republics‘ future as much as possible dependent on Moscow in many cases. Today the issue is also complicated by the fact that each of these two possesses and recognizes different facts and sources with regard to history of the complex. Georgian side considers it as a part of its culture, while Azerbaijan‘s side counts it is a monument of Albanian culture. Although many attempts were used to finally find solution, for example Georgian side suggested to swap the complex in exchange for some other territories, no agreement has been made yet unfortunately (Sainformacio analitikuri portali, 2019). The reasons for impossibility for this exchange to become true is that it could give precedent for the Karabakh issue. If Azerbaijan gives the territory to Georgia on the basis of the last‘s claims to control the complex as it is a part of Georgian culture and religion, then it would mean that Armenian‘s claims on Karabakh do have a legal and justified reasons.
  • 4. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies 103 It would also jeopardize the concept of Azerbaijan state as the multicultural one that incorporates peoples and lands of different ethnicities and unite them under one common governmental idea. The brilliant example for it is Turkey, closest ally of Azerbaijan. Thus this exchange would serve as a time-bomb as there are enough premises in Azerbaijan for possible separatism by other ethnic groups living within the country today. Normally peaceful situation on the Georgian-Azerbaijan border abruptly flared up when Georgian President Salome Zurabishvili was visiting complex in April 2019. She had called for an effort to finalize the delimitation talks. Later, on the eve of Orthodox Easter, Azerbaijani border guards restricted access to part of the complex, hence causing resentment from Georgian worshippers, especially monks and tour guides. Additionally, the entry to the medieval monastery of Udabno was blocked, where amazing Georgian frescos of utmost importance for Georgians are maintained. These events caused serious concerns from Georgian Church Officials. Heated by the events, both Georgians and Azerbaijanis started to debate and argue in online message boards, thus causing even greater dissonance. Relatively peaceful rallies were held by Georgian side both along the border near David Gareji and in from of the Azerbaijani Embassy in Tbilisi (Civil, 2019). Several days after the two countries foreign ministers agreed to reopen access but the tension had still been existing and in several weeks finally converted in harassing Azerbaijani boarder guard by Georgian activists and grabbling a pistol from him (YouTube, 2019a). Although both governments reacted on these particular episodes similarly with condemnation, they hold completely different positions over the border demarcation issue (Eurasia, 2019). Due to the above discussed importance of the border issue for both sides, it now appears that is premature to predict any significant changes and final resolutions at the moment. The repercussions, if one of sides attempts to solve the problem unilaterally, will be too grave and not worthy for any of the stakeholder. All this should be discussed in light to the above discussed economic, cultural and social interdependence, and most importantly, perspectives for future cooperation, however, if emotions are allowed to prevail, irrational behavior and decisions may prevail. Hence, we can clearly observe that neither Georgia nor Azerbaijan can benefit from escalation of this border issue, rather than possible third parties. 2.3.2. Georgia-Russia Understanding the problems faced by these countries relations is essential in looking at larger geopolitical issues. Few expected the issues that resulted over the unresolved border delineation, and this brought about tense relations over David Gareji and its ownership. However, in light of what has been mentioned and gradually improving relations within the last seven years, pundits and laypersons can at least can easily observe the consequences, particularly on the Georgian economy. The main sticking point for deterioration in relations was, as Russian side is treating it, the breakout of anti- Russian protests in Tbilisi, however from the very beginning protest were first described as anti-governmental with the aim of overthrowing the legally elected Georgian government. Only later did the protests start to contain anti-occupational direction, albeit rather symbolic. Protesters accused the government in allowing Russian MP Sergey Gavrilov to chair the general assembly of the Interparliamentary Assembly on Orthodoxy (IAO) (RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty, 2019). The position of protesters was based on the fact that Mr. Gavrilov was officially representing the country which, many in Georgia, describes as an occupier. Consequently he had to leave Georgia urgently and proceedings were disrupted. The second event what happened was an ill-timed and insulting speech of TV host Giorgi Gabunia, who personally addressed Vladimir Putting with highly offensive language; it is worth mentioning that this all happened within the background of two weeks of going protests (YouTube, 2019b). As the result, Russia considered Georgia to be dangerous for its citizens and banned all direct flights to the country. It also prohibited Russian tour agencies from booking travels to the country (Agenda, 2019b), thus seriously harming the Georgian tourism sector. Tbilisi is now on the list of European cities with hardly any Russian tourists (CNN Travel, 2019). There were also attempts by Duma to impose tough economic sanctions on Georgia after the insulting speech, however Russia‘s President did not support the parliamentary call. It does not appear as if all what has transpired was happenstance, not by chance but rather a series of events that were planned. In retrospect it is difficult to imagine that members of the ruling party did not know that Russian MP was going to visit Georgia and chair the assembly. It appears they could not or did not want stop Mr. Gavrilov from coming to the country. But rather used this as something of a false flag for political gain. Nonetheless, such efforts backfired in the final analysis, having a negative impact, not only for Georgia but the United National Movement. It is the Georgian economy that has been weakened and society further divided, and many are more confused as to the political orientation of the country and who actually stands behind such events. As for the Russian Federation, it becomes a story of ―I hate to tell you so but I told you so, as Georgia is unpredictable and not a reliable or trusted party, too emotional. Russian has been able to prove its cool political standing in face of provocations, not pushing all Georgians for the actions of a provocation. Many Georgians now see Russia as a more reliable partner and having greater patience. Russia now has more levers to wake up pro-Russian supporters in Georgia, and it has still not used its main trump – ban for all Georgian import as it would have more economic consequences. It is worth mentioning that Vladimir Putin‘s ―gesture of goodwill‖ in not imposing economic sanction after the insulting speech by G. Gabunia will bring Russia a huge geopolitical advantage. Moreover, the possible cancelation
  • 5. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies 104 of visa regime for Georgians, currently being actively discussed in media (Новости and Новости, 2019), is now being used by Russians as a ―carrot,‖ and such proactive actions only activates pro-Russian sentiments among Georgians – thus setting the stage for the greater support by the population for what they perceived as practical Russian policy. On the other hand, the actions of Georgian opposition in this case can be estimated as a serious miscalculation and almost a complete failure. We can assert with certainty that the Gabunia‘s speech was not spontaneous and based on heated emotion, it was delivered with the clear intention of worsening relations between countries, hence Georgian Dream, pro-Russians and Russia‗s government and destabilise an already difficult situation. If Putin would had taken stricter measures and economic sanctions it would play into the hands of opposition. However Russia did not do it—and this event was used as a way of actually improving Georgian-Russian relations. 3. Results We can clearly see how important for Georgia having positive peaceful relations with Russia and Azerbaijan, and not only in terms of maintaining the priority role of tourism in the country‘s economic development strategy. It is particularly crucial, as the states maintain good perspectives and opportunities for improving relations in the future. Taken together, due to good economic, cultural and political basis, many barriers can be overcome. However we should not ignore that problems still exists on both sides. It is clear that under the circumstances that Georgia currently does not possess any leverage needed to bring about a quick resolution of these issues. However, it is definitely not in its interests to exacerbate situations, either with Russia or Azerbaijan. Hence, it is becoming clear that third parties, with others in the shadows, have an agenda in intervening into Georgia‘s relations with its neighbors, or that some force, domestic or international, desires for one of these neighbors to position itself to dictate the terms and conditions to impact Georgia‘s policy direction. 4. Conclusion Analyzing the given information, and in light of how events moved so quickly, it is clear that Georgia did not initiated any actions in the neighborhood itself, but rather it found itself as being hold hostage. This was because of government inability to sufficiently react in time to provocations in a timely fashion. It is clear that outside forces, regardless of the true motivations, want to influence Georgia from near and far. The ruling Georgian Dream party has not demonstrated any certain leverage in building its foreign policy basing on National interests. But rather it maintains a defensive position and only reacts. It is clear that based on the country‘s economic dependence on its neighbors that Georgia may at times be doomed to be manipulated, at least until it will be able manage to build less dependent relations or more interdependent with its neighbors (as for example with Azerbaijan). The most important task at hand is to achieve such a status and without damage being inflicted to the national economic as well as its cultural and political interests. This will be a challenge for the country for now and into the foreseeable future. References Agenda, g. (2019a). Gov‘t puts 33 people on Otkhozoria-Tatunashvili list. Available: http://agenda.ge/en/news/2018/1360 Agenda, g. (2019b). Putin bans flights to Georgia, orders return of Russian citizens to homeland. Available: http://agenda.ge/en/news/2019/1659 Azer, c. (2019). 12.3 ali and nino covers - 37 languages. Available: http://azer.com/aiweb/an_covers/123_ali_nino_cover.html Civil, g. (2019). New rally at david gareji monastery | civil.Ge. Available: https://civil.ge/archives/306959 CNN Travel (2019). 20 beautiful European cities with hardly any tourists. Available: https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/beautiful-european-cities-few-tourists/index.html Eurasia, R. (2019). Ali and nino‘s enduring mystique – analysis. Available: https://www.eurasiareview.com/24032012-ali-and-nino%E2%80%99s-enduring-mystique-analysis/ Forbes, G. (2019). Rusuli agrzalvis gavlena - negatiuri da pozitiuri prognozebi. Available: https://forbes.ge/news/6695/rusuli-akrZalvis-gavlena Geostat, g. (2019a). Siskhlis samartlis statistika – saqartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available: https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/132/siskhlis-samartlis-statistika Geostat, g. (2019b). Sagareo vacroba – saqartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available: https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/35/sagareo-vachroba Geostat, g. (2019c). Utskho vizitorebis statistika – sakartvelos statistikis erovnuli samsakhuri. Available: https://www.geostat.ge/ka/modules/categories/102/utskhoel-vizitorta-statistika Gnta, g. (2019). kvlevebi | saqartvelos turizmis erovnuli administratsia. Available: https://gnta.ge/ge/%E1%83%A1%E1%83%A2%E1%83%90%E1%83%A2%E1%83%98%E1%83%A1%E 1%83%A2%E1%83%98%E1%83%99%E1%83%90/ Kakachia, K. and Shiriyev, Z. (2019). The foundations and challenges of the strategic alliance. Available: www.researchgate.net Mendyk, B. (2019). Bringing russian and iranian gas to the georgian market: Technically challenging, economically unfeasible and politically costly? : Available:
  • 6. International Journal of World Policy and Development Studies 105 https://www.academia.edu/35919412/Bartosz_Mendyk_Bringing_Russian_and_Iranian_Gas_to_the_Georg ian_Market_Technically_Challenging_economically_Unfeasible_and_Politically_Costly_ Mikadze, Z. (2019). Kvemo kartli | sakhelmtsifo rtsmunebulis administratsia, kvemo kartli. Available: http://kvemokartli.gov.ge/region Mirza Fatali Akhundov (2000). Alphabet reformer before his time. Azerbaijan International, 8(1): Available: http://azeri.org/Azeri/az_latin/latin_articles/latin_text/latin_81/eng_81/81_akhundov.html Modebadze, Z. (2019). DCFTA-ს 1 tseli shedegebis mimokhilva.| EUGeorgia. Available: http://eugeorgia.info/ka/article/343/dcfta-s-1-weli-shedegebis-mimoxilva/ Nplg, g. g. (2019). Ethnosebi saqartveloshi: azerbaijanelebi. Available: http://www.nplg.gov.ge/gsdl/cgi- bin/library.exe?e=d-00000-00---off-0civil2--00-1----0-10-0---0---0prompt-10---4-------0-1l--10-ka-50---20- about---00-3-1-00-0-0-01-1-0utfZz-8-00&a=d&cl=CL1.32&d=HASH01539272c0a61b8f8dfb8ff9.8 RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty (2019). Furious anti-russia protesters in tbilisi demand speaker's resignation, clash with police. Available: https://www.rferl.org/a/anti-russia-protesters-in-tbilisi-demand-speaker-s- resignation/30011083.html Regnum, r. (2019). Available: https://regnum.ru/news/polit/1504531.html Russiatourism, r. (2019). Viborochnaya statisticheskaya informacia, raschitanaya v sootvetstvii s Oficialnoi statisticheskoi metodologiei ocenki chisla v‘ezdnix I viezdnix turisticheskikh poezdok – Rosturizm. Available: https://www.russiatourism.ru/contents/statistika/statisticheskie-pokazateli-vzaimnykh-poezdok- grazhdan-rossiyskoy-federatsii-i-grazhdan-inostrannykh-gosudarstv/vyborochnaya-statisticheskaya- informatsiya-rasschitannaya-v-sootvetstvii-s-ofitsialnoy-statisticheskoy-metodologiey-otsenki-chisla- vezdnykh-i-vyezdnykh-turistskikh-poezdok/ Saertashoriso gamchirvaleba – saqartvelo (2019). Erovnuli aghkmis indeksi. Available: https://www.transparency.ge/ge/corruption/cpi Sainformacio analitikuri portali (2019). Azerbaijanma davit garejis sadavo teritoris gacvlaze uari tqva. Available: https://for.ge/view/36121/azerbaijanma-daviT-garejis-sadavo-teritoris-gacvlaze-uari-Tqva.html Web, a. o. (2019). Ministry of foreign affairs of georgia - აზერბაიჯანის რესპუბლიკა (eng). Available: https://web.archive.org/web/20070927063947/http://www.mfa.gov.ge/index.php?sec_id=334&lang_id=EN G YouTube (2019a). Georgian nationalists stormed david gareja (keşikçidağ) monastry in Azerbaijan's territory. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYp5RV1iypg YouTube (2019b). Expletive-laden putin rant on georgian tv leads to channel going off air - BBC News. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=re4dkJ3Iaks Новости, Р. and Новости, Р. (2019). V MID ne iskluchili otmeni viz dlia grazhdan Gruzi‘i. Available: https://ria.ru/20190718/1556631952.html