ENRICHMENT 3
THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE:
ARTICLE CONTRIBUTION &
CRITERION A & B
ASSESSMENT REMINDERS!

Class Participation                  =     30%

Journal Entries                        =     30%
[5% for writing the number of assigned entries,
25% for the 3 journal entries picked by you from
 the compulsory list]

Quizzes & tests                      =     30%

Article contribution                 =     10%
ARTICLE CONTRIBUTION: 10 % not 5 %

PURPOSE:

• To share knowledge with friends

• To build the knowledge trove to enable a
  variety of examples that may be useful for
  oral presentations or for answering
  prescribed titles.
Information to be included in the Article
Contribution section to show its relevance
to TOK …
•   Which AoK (s) does the article relate to?

•   What WoK(s) is/ are involved?

•   What linking questions are involved?

• Explain in what way this article is relevant
    to TOK.
 Assessment of the suitability of the article will be
 based on the answers to the questions asked.
Academic Honesty


Make sure the article has:

1. the name of the newspaper or magazine
2. the date of publication
3. If it is the magazine, make sure the volume
   number is also stated.
EXAMPLES ! EXAMPLES!   EXAMPLES!
Theory of Knowledge: Presentation Structure

         Real-Life Situation                                                          Other Real-Life
                                                                                        Situation



                                WOKs
                                perception, language,                                                   Other Real-Life
                                emotions, logic, faith,                                                   Situation
                                practice, authority,
                                acquaintance, instinct,
                   extraction




What is it about                introspection,
the RLS that                    empathy, conscience
strikes/bothers
you?
                                AoKs                     Linking questions:

                                Math, Nat. Science,      belief      certainty
                                Soc.Science, History,    culture     evidence
                                Arts, Religion,Ethics    explanation interpretation
                                                         intuition   technology
                                                         truth      values




                                                        progression
          Knowledge Issue                                                             Knowledge Issue(s)
            (recognized)                                                                 (developed)
Fast food outlet sued for making people fat
& Man loses millions, sues casino

Which AoK(s) does this article mainly relate to?
social science

Which WoKs are involved?
perception, logic

What linking questions are involved?
truth, explanation, certainty

In what way is this article relevant to TOK?
It shows how logic is misused to justify someone’s
perceived rights even when the case is ‘without merit’.
Blocking file-sharing websites a futile effort

Which AoK does this article mainly relate to?
social science

Which WoKs are involved?
perception, logic, emotion

Which linking questions are involved?
belief, interpretation, value, culture

In what way is this article relevant to TOK?
The article deals with the emotion of fear that and that
the entertainment world needs some kind of protection
when it is rather unfounded in reality. The article seems to
suggest that emotions and perception affects our ability to
evaluate/ interpret a situation accurately.
Is this the Round Table?
Which AoK does the article mainly relate to?
History

Which WoKs does it involve?
logic, authority, perception

Which linking questions does it involve?
belief, evidence, interpretation

In what way would this article be relevant to TOK?
It deals with a historical finding of a structure that historians (the
authority) claim to be King Arthur’s round table based on logical
deductions.
In pairs, give answers to the same set of
questions for the article, ‘Japanese scientist
unveils ‘thinking’ robot.
UNDERSTANDING

TOK ESSAY CRITERIA
UNDERSTANDING EXAM CRITERION A [10 marks]

1. The essay consistently maintains as its focus knowledge issues
   that are relevant to the prescribed title.

2. Effective links and comparisons between areas of knowledge
   and/ or ways of knowing are elaborated so that the essay
   demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the knowledge
   issues under consideration.
ESSAY: HOW IMPORTANT ARE THE OPINIONS OF
EXPERTS IN THE SEARCH FOR KNOWLEDGE?
Knowledge Issues: [what bothers you? What questions arise
in your mind?]

1. Under what circumstances would expert opinion be
   important ?

2. Are there instances when expert opinions are not needed
   or are irrelevant?

3. How much can we trust expert opinions?

4. Are they always accurate or tell the truth?
UNDERSTANDING EXAM CRITERION B [10 marks]

1. The essay shows much evidence of independent thinking
   about the knowledge issues related to the prescribed title.

2. The student has shaped the essay in a way that shows both
   a personal, reflective exploration of the prescribed title and
   significant self-awareness as a knower.

3. There is serious consideration of different perspectives.

4. Examples chosen are varied and effectively used.
Tok woks

Tok woks

  • 1.
    ENRICHMENT 3 THEORY OFKNOWLEDGE: ARTICLE CONTRIBUTION & CRITERION A & B
  • 2.
    ASSESSMENT REMINDERS! Class Participation = 30% Journal Entries = 30% [5% for writing the number of assigned entries, 25% for the 3 journal entries picked by you from the compulsory list] Quizzes & tests = 30% Article contribution = 10%
  • 3.
    ARTICLE CONTRIBUTION: 10% not 5 % PURPOSE: • To share knowledge with friends • To build the knowledge trove to enable a variety of examples that may be useful for oral presentations or for answering prescribed titles.
  • 4.
    Information to beincluded in the Article Contribution section to show its relevance to TOK … • Which AoK (s) does the article relate to? • What WoK(s) is/ are involved? • What linking questions are involved? • Explain in what way this article is relevant to TOK. Assessment of the suitability of the article will be based on the answers to the questions asked.
  • 5.
    Academic Honesty Make surethe article has: 1. the name of the newspaper or magazine 2. the date of publication 3. If it is the magazine, make sure the volume number is also stated.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Theory of Knowledge:Presentation Structure Real-Life Situation Other Real-Life Situation WOKs perception, language, Other Real-Life emotions, logic, faith, Situation practice, authority, acquaintance, instinct, extraction What is it about introspection, the RLS that empathy, conscience strikes/bothers you? AoKs Linking questions: Math, Nat. Science, belief certainty Soc.Science, History, culture evidence Arts, Religion,Ethics explanation interpretation intuition technology truth values progression Knowledge Issue Knowledge Issue(s) (recognized) (developed)
  • 8.
    Fast food outletsued for making people fat & Man loses millions, sues casino Which AoK(s) does this article mainly relate to? social science Which WoKs are involved? perception, logic What linking questions are involved? truth, explanation, certainty In what way is this article relevant to TOK? It shows how logic is misused to justify someone’s perceived rights even when the case is ‘without merit’.
  • 9.
    Blocking file-sharing websitesa futile effort Which AoK does this article mainly relate to? social science Which WoKs are involved? perception, logic, emotion Which linking questions are involved? belief, interpretation, value, culture In what way is this article relevant to TOK? The article deals with the emotion of fear that and that the entertainment world needs some kind of protection when it is rather unfounded in reality. The article seems to suggest that emotions and perception affects our ability to evaluate/ interpret a situation accurately.
  • 10.
    Is this theRound Table? Which AoK does the article mainly relate to? History Which WoKs does it involve? logic, authority, perception Which linking questions does it involve? belief, evidence, interpretation In what way would this article be relevant to TOK? It deals with a historical finding of a structure that historians (the authority) claim to be King Arthur’s round table based on logical deductions.
  • 11.
    In pairs, giveanswers to the same set of questions for the article, ‘Japanese scientist unveils ‘thinking’ robot.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    UNDERSTANDING EXAM CRITERIONA [10 marks] 1. The essay consistently maintains as its focus knowledge issues that are relevant to the prescribed title. 2. Effective links and comparisons between areas of knowledge and/ or ways of knowing are elaborated so that the essay demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the knowledge issues under consideration.
  • 14.
    ESSAY: HOW IMPORTANTARE THE OPINIONS OF EXPERTS IN THE SEARCH FOR KNOWLEDGE? Knowledge Issues: [what bothers you? What questions arise in your mind?] 1. Under what circumstances would expert opinion be important ? 2. Are there instances when expert opinions are not needed or are irrelevant? 3. How much can we trust expert opinions? 4. Are they always accurate or tell the truth?
  • 15.
    UNDERSTANDING EXAM CRITERIONB [10 marks] 1. The essay shows much evidence of independent thinking about the knowledge issues related to the prescribed title. 2. The student has shaped the essay in a way that shows both a personal, reflective exploration of the prescribed title and significant self-awareness as a knower. 3. There is serious consideration of different perspectives. 4. Examples chosen are varied and effectively used.