Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...CPWF Mekong
3rd Mekong Forum on Water, Food & Energy. Presentation from Session 19: Advancing Sustainability in the Mekong Region: the role of Assessment Tools, Standards and Safeguards.
Robert Hiett Three Rivers Regional Commission Deputy Executive Director
Georgia Regional Rural Transit Presentation. Presented to the Transit Governance and Funding Commission on November 13, 2017.
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...CPWF Mekong
3rd Mekong Forum on Water, Food & Energy. Presentation from Session 19: Advancing Sustainability in the Mekong Region: the role of Assessment Tools, Standards and Safeguards.
Robert Hiett Three Rivers Regional Commission Deputy Executive Director
Georgia Regional Rural Transit Presentation. Presented to the Transit Governance and Funding Commission on November 13, 2017.
Healthcare is a major part of every country's development platform. By healthcare we are in fact protecting the most important driver of development. Healthcare systems are primarily safe guarding the development core engine and are the best means of sustainable development.
Decentralization in Health Care – is there evidence for it?
Guest lecture at School of Public Health, National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy
by Axel Hoffmann, PhD
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute
A process to assess the condition of South Africa's transport fixed infrastru...Tristan Wiggill
A presentation by Kevin Wall, Chris Rust and Kenny Kistan, delivered during the 2016 Southern African Road Transport Conference in Pretoria, South Africa.
Untapped potential of U-CLTS in tackling the emerging challenges of urban san...IRC
Following an introduction to the differences between the urban and rural, the Kalyani case study from Nadia District, Calcutta, India is explored. This is the first example of the succesful application of the Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) approach in an urban context. It shows how this behaviour change approach can help users move up the sanitation technology ladder. Presente by Kamal Kar, CLTS Foundation at the Round Table Discussion on Urban Sanitation in line with ULCTS, 1 July 2015 at The Hague, The Netherlands
Healthcare is a major part of every country's development platform. By healthcare we are in fact protecting the most important driver of development. Healthcare systems are primarily safe guarding the development core engine and are the best means of sustainable development.
Decentralization in Health Care – is there evidence for it?
Guest lecture at School of Public Health, National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy
by Axel Hoffmann, PhD
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute
A process to assess the condition of South Africa's transport fixed infrastru...Tristan Wiggill
A presentation by Kevin Wall, Chris Rust and Kenny Kistan, delivered during the 2016 Southern African Road Transport Conference in Pretoria, South Africa.
Untapped potential of U-CLTS in tackling the emerging challenges of urban san...IRC
Following an introduction to the differences between the urban and rural, the Kalyani case study from Nadia District, Calcutta, India is explored. This is the first example of the succesful application of the Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) approach in an urban context. It shows how this behaviour change approach can help users move up the sanitation technology ladder. Presente by Kamal Kar, CLTS Foundation at the Round Table Discussion on Urban Sanitation in line with ULCTS, 1 July 2015 at The Hague, The Netherlands
A single ombudsman for UK public servicesJane Tinkler
Presentation to the IPPR seminar on 'Citizen redress in a consumer democracy' 27 January 2014. With Jane Martin (Local Government Ombudsman) and Steve Reed MP.
Assessing impact of metro stations integrating commercial landuse & trans...Vivek Agnihotri
The study had been done as a dissertation for the academic requirement to be fulfilled for Master in City Planning (Department of Architecture & Regional Planning | Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur) in the year of 2015.
Similar to The Potholed Road to De-centralization: An explorative study of Service Delivery in Karachi (20)
Ayesha Khan's presentation on 'A Public Interest Litigation Case to Address Obstetric Fistula in Sindhat' at a Consultation on Maternal Health Petition hosted by the Collective for Social Science Research on 30 November 2018.
Ayesha Khan's presentation at a session on Gender Justice and Women's Rights in the International Policy Conference: The Social Economy of Gender, hosted by the Punjab Commission on the Status of Women (PCSW) in Lahore on 29th November 2018.
Haris Gazdar's presentation at a session on Decent Work and Informal Economy for Women in Pakistan in the International Policy Conference: The Social Economy of Gender, hosted by the Punjab Commission on the Status of Women (PCSW) in Lahore on 28th November 2018. This session was chaired by Khawar Mumtaz who is currently the Chairperson on the National Commission on the Status of Women (NCSW).
Women's agricultural work and nutrition (WWN) - survey findings and implications. This presentation was given by Haris Gazdar at a Consultation on Rights and Wellbeing of Women Agricultural Workers in Beach Luxury Hotel, Karachi.
Ayesha Khan's presentation on "Policies and Affirmative Action for Achieving Gender Equity," at the World Bank workshop Pakistan@100 Initiative at Lahore University of Management Sciences.
Haris Gazdar's presentation at a Special Event of the Second Committee of United Nations General Assembly on 'Measuring women’s work and implications for poverty analysis in South Asia.' The session was moderated by Ms. Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka (Under-Secretary-General, Executive Director of UN Women). The panelists included Ms. Kinnon Scott (Senior Economist, Development Research Group, World Bank), Dr. Shahra Razavi (Chief, Research amd Data Section, UN Women), Dr. Agnes Quizumbing (Senior Research Fellow, International Food and Policy Research Institute), Dr. Magdalena Sepulveda (Previous Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty and Human Rights, Mexico), and Mr. Haris Gazdar.
Haris Gazdar's presentation at a seminar on 'The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)- Pakistan’s Maternal, Child Health and Nutrition Challenges: Issues and Progress' organised by Agha Khan University, November 2017
Presentation by Haris Gazdar at the Seminar on 'Food security, hunger & nutrition' hosted by the Planning & Development Department, Sindh and EU PFM-SPP
Presentation by Haris Gazdar at the Seminar on 'Food security, hunger & nutrition' hosted by the Planning & Development Department, Sindh and EU PFM-SPP
Haris Gazdar speaks about a new LANSA Working Paper that explores the trade-offs between work and care on the nutrition outcomes for children in Pakistan
PIDE 2014 conference paper 'Synergy or Trade-Off between Agricultural Growth and Nutrition: Women's Work and Care' presented in a Technical Session on 'Poverty Reduction and Development'.
SECUREX UK FOR SECURITY SERVICES AND MOBILE PATROLsecurexukweb
At Securex UK Ltd we are dedicated to providing top-rated security solutions tailored to your specific needs. With a team of highly trained professionals and cutting-edge technology, we prioritize your safety and peace of mind.
Our commitment to excellence extends beyond traditional security measures. We understand the dynamic nature of security challenges, and our personalized approach ensures that every client receives a bespoke protection plan.
BEst VASHIKARAN SPECIALIST 9463629203 in UK Baba ji Love Marriage problem sol...gitapress3
TOP No AsTro 1 black magic SpecialiSt UK baba ji +91-9463629203 VashIkaRan blaCk maGiC specialist in uSA Uk England Luxembourg CanAdA America BEst VASHIKARAN SPECIALIST 9463629203 in UK Baba ji Love Marriage problem solution Uk USA america england LonDon Divorce problem solution astroloGer
Office Business Furnishings | Office EquipmentOFWD
OFWD is Edmonton’s Newest and most cost-effective source for Office Furnishings. Conveniently located on 170 street and 114 Avenue in Edmonton’s West End. We take pride in servicing a client base of over 500 corporations throughout the Edmonton and Alberta area. OFWD is in the business of satisfying the home or corporate office environment needs of our clients, from individual pieces of furniture for the home user to the implementation of complete turn-key projects on much larger scales. We supply only quality products from reputable manufacturers. It is our intention to continue to earn the trust of our clients by dealing with honesty and integrity and by providing service and after sales follow-up second to none.
How Does Littering Affect the Environment.ClenliDirect
Read this PPT now to gain in-depth insights into how to fight litter and safeguard our landscapes from its negative impacts.
Visit-https://clenlidirect.com/cleaning-equipment/litter-picker-grabber-equipment.html
DOJO Training Center - Empowering Workforce ExcellenceHimanshu
The document delves into DOJO training, an immersive offline training concept designed to educate both new hires and existing staff. This method follows an organized eight-step process within a simulated work setting. The steps encompass safety protocols, behavioral coaching, product familiarity, production guidelines, and procedural understanding. Trainees acquire skills through hands-on simulations and rehearsal prior to transitioning to actual shop floor duties under supervision. The primary aim is to minimize accidents and defects by ensuring employees undergo comprehensive training, preparing them effectively for their job roles.
Nature’s Paradise Glamorous And Sustainable Designs For Your Outdoor Living S...Landscape Express
Create a harmonious blend of luxury and sustainability in your outdoor living space with eco-friendly kitchens, enchanting water features, and lush plant landscaping. Embrace energy-efficient appliances, solar lighting, rainwater harvesting, and native plants to enhance beauty while reducing environmental impact. Transform your space into a glamorous, eco-conscious retreat for relaxation and social gatherings.
In the competitive realm of online business, visibility is key, and search engine optimization (SEO) serves as the cornerstone of digital prominence. As the demand for effective SEO solutions continues to soar, finding the best SEO company in Perth becomes imperative. Enter Simba Squad – a dynamic force dedicated to propelling your business to new heights of success.
Looking for the Reliable Logistics Solutions in India? Discover unparalleled efficiency and reliability with our top-rated logistics services. We specialize in streamlining supply chains, ensuring timely deliveries, and providing cutting-edge tracking solutions. Our platform caters to businesses of all sizes, offering customizable logistics solutions to meet your unique needs. With a focus on innovation and customer satisfaction, we are your trusted partner in navigating the complexities of logistics in India. Choose us for seamless, cost-effective, and scalable logistics solutions. Experience the best in Indian logistics with our expert team by your side.
Top Best Astrologer +91-9463629203 LoVe Problem SolUtion specialist In InDia ...gitapress3
Top Best Astrologer +91-9463629203 LoVe Problem SolUtion specialist In InDia Love ProBlem asTroloGer +91-9463629203 love problem solution astrologer
best love problem solution astrologer
online love problem solution astrologer
love problem solution astrologer in india
love problem solution astrologer in kolkata
love problem solution astrologer near me
love problem solution astrologer in ludhiana
love problem solution astrologer acharya ji
love problem solution astrologer in delhi
love problem solution astrologer amritsar
astrologer love problem solution
astrologer for love problem
astrology love problem solution
love solution astrologer
love problem solution specialist astrologer
love problem solution by astrologer
astrology love problem solution baba ji
love problem solve astrologer
love problem solution usa
love problem solution expert astrologer
astrologer for love marriage problem solution
love problem solution astrologer in mumbai
love problem solution muslim astrologer
love marriage specialist astrologer problem solution
famous love astrologer
love problem solution astrologer specialist
love problem solution astrologer baba ji
What Are the Latest Trends in Endpoint Security for 2024?VRS Technologies
In this PDF, Discover the top 2024 endpoint security trends, including zero trust, AI integration, XDR, cloud security, and enhanced mobile protection. VRS Technologies LLC supplies the top level Endpoint Security Service Dubai. For More Info Contact us: +971 56 7029840 Visit us: https://www.vrstech.com/endpoint-security-solutions.html
Learn about Inspect Edge, the leading platform for efficient inspections, featuring the advanced NSPIRE Inspection Application for seamless property assessments. Discover how the NSPIRE Inspection Application by Inspect Edge revolutionizes property inspections with advanced features and seamless integration.
Best Catering Event Planner Miso-Hungry.pptxMiso Hungry
Miso-Hungry, led by Executive Chef Emilio Molina, is Islamorada's premier catering event planner. We specialize in sustainable, farm-fresh cuisine, using local ingredients to create unforgettable dishes. As a FollowTheFoodHMI branded company, we bring our culinary expertise across the U.S., connecting communities through exceptional food and personalized event planning. Let us showcase our family's passion and make your event extraordinary.
Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxamilabibi1
Islamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docxIslamabad No 1 Amil Baba In Pakistan amil baba kala ilm.docx
Earth moving equipment refers to heavy-duty machines used in construction, mining, agriculture, and other industries to move large amounts of earth, soil, and other materials. These machines include excavators, bulldozers, loaders, and backhoes, which are essential for tasks such as digging, grading, and leveling land.
Earthmovers is a leading brand in the industry, known for providing reliable and high-performance earth moving equipment. Their machines are designed to handle the toughest jobs with efficiency and precision, ensuring optimal productivity on any project.
The Jamstack Revolution: Building Dynamic Websites with Static Site Generator...Softradix Technologies
In this infographic, the Jamstack architecture emphasizes pre-rendered content and decoupling the frontend from the backend. It leverages static site generators (SSGs) to create fast-loading HTML files and APIs for dynamic functionality. Benefits include improved performance, enhanced security, scalability, and ease of deployment. Real-world examples include Netlify, Gatsby, and Contentful. https://softradix.com/web-development/
Best steel industrial company LLC in UAEalafnanmetals
AL Afnan Steel Industrial Company LLC is a distinguished steel manufacturer and supplier, celebrated for its high-quality products and outstanding customer service. With a diverse portfolio that includes structural steel, and custom fabrications, AL Afnan meets a wide array of industrial demands. We are dedicated to using advanced technologies and sustainable methods to ensure excellence and reliability in every product, serving both local and international markets with efficiency.
All Trophies at Trophy-World Malaysia | Custom Trophies & Plaques Supplier. Come to our Trophy Shop today and check out all our variety of Trophies available. We have the widest range of Trophies in Malaysia. Our team is always ready to greet your needs and discuss with you on your custom Trophy for your event. Rest assured, you will be with the best Trophy Supplier in Malaysia. The official Trophy Malaysia. Thank you for your support.
The Potholed Road to De-centralization: An explorative study of Service Delivery in Karachi
1. Ammar Khalid (IDEAS) and Kabeer Dawani (CSSR)
THE POTHOLED ROAD TO
DECENTRALIZATION: AN
EXPLORATIVE STUDY OF
SERVICE DELIVERY IN KARACHI
1
Presented at the 10th Annual HSS LUMS Conference, Lahore on
5th March 2016
2. Introduction
• There has been a global trend of countries decentralizing
state responsibilities to lower tiers of government
• Emerging realization that centralized service delivery is
“systematically failing - and especially failing poor
people.” (Ahmed et al, 2005)
• Our work focuses on the relationship of decentralization
and urban service delivery
2
3. Introduction
• Pakistan has urbanized rapidly in recent decades – some
claim that more than half of Pakistan is now urbanized.
• Karachi has grown exponentially over the years, putting
stress on its resources and its ability to deliver services.
• One of the benefits of decentralization, widely cited in
the literature, is the increase in accountability, and
subsequently improved service delivery.
3
4. Literature on Decentralization
• Three types of decentralization:
• Fiscal
• Administrative
• Political
• Proponents of decentralization argue that it results in (Tanzi, 1995)
• Greater accountability
• Allocative efficiency due to proximity to beneficiary
• However, decentralization can face problems (Ahmad et al, 2005)
• Elite capture
• Lack of capacity at the sub-national level
• Misaligned responsibilities
• No consensus on efficiency of decentralization with regards to
service delivery, particularly in Pakistan
4
5. Gaps in the Literature
• Vast literature on decentralization and economic development in
the past decade and a half on Pakistan.
• However, two areas have largely been unexplored in Pakistan
• Service delivery in urban areas
• Within service delivery, there has been an overwhelming focus on social
service delivery (education and health), as opposed to municipal service
delivery (roads, sanitation etc).
• In addition to the gap in the literature, the importance of
assessing municipal service delivery is two-fold:
• Zahid Hasnain (2010) identifies that local government priorities are
heavily tilted towards municipal services
• Deprivations in municipal service delivery contribute to poverty (Cheema
and Mohmand 2004).
5
6. Our research
• Compares service delivery under LGO 2001 to the centralized
governance following its lapse in 2010.
• We decided to focus on four municipal services:
• Water
• Solid Waste
• Roads
• Sewerage
• Exploratory study, not representative of Karachi.
• Interviewed 56 people in early 2014
• For our field research we chose Akhtar Colony
• Akhtar Colony is an ethnically diverse, lower-middle income
settlement adjacent to DHA Phase 1.
6
8. Service Delivery Improvements
• We found that overall service delivery was better under the
decentralized governance setup, as compared to the period
following 2010
• However, for the four public goods that we were examining, the
improvement in service delivery was not uniform. Aslam and
Yilmaz (2011) reach a similar conclusion for rural Pakistan.
8
9. Water - I
• An overwhelming majority of our respondents cited the shortage
of water supply as the most pressing problem in the area
• Till 2008, the provision of water was satisfactory.
• After 2008, however, delivery of water reduced significantly.
• Respondents alleged that because the area did not vote for MQM,
the MQM was diverting water away from the area, towards DHA
and Qayyumabad.
• “KWSB chief engineer Najm-i-Alam Siddiqui said some
mischievous elements carried out valve operation on their own,
adding that tampering with the valve - through which water was
supplied to both Qayyumabad and Akhtar Colony - often caused a
water shortage in Akhtar Colony.” – Dawn report, 06th June 2009.
9
10. Water - II
• Residents protested in 2009 and 2010 – they were suppressed forcibly
by the state
• This goes to show that contestation goes beyond UC level.
• At the time of research, 89% respondents were procuring water
through unofficial means – water tankers and boring, primarily.
10
Source:
Dawn.com
11. Solid Waste
• Area cleaner under the local government set up.
• The UC administration had 4 sweepers designated for the area.
• Following 2010, garbage was predominantly collected by
individuals of Afghan origin employed by the residents. Three
quarters of our respondents resorted to this in the absence of
official collection.
11
12. Roads and Sewerage - I
• Road conditions poor in general, and declined after 2010. Only
one instance of major road development.
• Sewerage pipelines were laid in the area in 2008 by the UC
administration, before which there were open sewers.
• In light of the older sewerage lines proving to be inadequate, in
the run up to the 2013 general elections, the PPP laid a new set
of sewerage lines parallel to the older lines.
• Partisan delivery: These lines were laid only in the areas where
PPP voters resided, i.e. Sectors C, D and E.
12
13. Roads and Sewerage - II
• Political contestation over these two services.
• The PPP laid new sewerage pipelines in the area in the run up to
the 2013 general elections.
• This, however, uprooted the main road that the MQM had re-
laid only a few months prior.
• Respondents reported that MQM workers had subsequently
tried to block these new pipelines by “dumping rocks, blankets
and pillows” into the sewers
13
14. Discussion - I
• We found that, in accordance with the literature, lower tiers of
government did have an efficiency advantage as compared to
higher tiers of government (Nguyen, 2008; Tanzi, 1995)
• The first avenue of complaint was the local UC office.
However, a significant number of complaints were not resolved
because the officials claimed to not have the resources.
• One reason for the lack of funds at the UC officials’ disposal
was because the UC government was formed by a different
party than the one in power at the city level (JI, MQM).
14
15. Discussion - II
• We argue that local governments should be empowered through
fiscal decentralization.
• However, it is crucial that before fiscal decentralization takes
place, local capacity building is undertaken to prevent
mismanagement and high corruption (Fjelstad, 2001; Mehmood
and Sadiq, 2010)
• We found service delivery to be along partisan lines following
2010. This can lead to greater polarization thereby increasing
the risk of political violence (Esteban and Schneider, 2008).
Thus, it is important to strengthen institutions of service
delivery, such as local governments.
15
16. Conclusion and Way Forward
• To conclude, despite delivery being uneven for the four services
under consideration, overall service delivery was better under a
decentralized set up.
• Further avenues of study
• Given that this study is not representative of Karachi as a whole, it will be
important to conduct a city-wide study that assesses service delivery
outcomes.
• Compare service delivery between ethnically heterogeneous and
homogenous areas. Some scholars argue that ethnically heterogeneous
areas are worse off than homogenous areas (Chandra, 2007)
• Elite capture is often cited in the literature as a reason for the failure of
decentralization, particularly in Pakistan’s rural areas. However, this needs
to be explored further for the urban context.
16
17. THANK YOU
Acknowledgements: We would like to thank Husnain Habib
Malik for his immense contribution to the research, without
whom this would not have been possible, and to Dr. Hassan
Javid for his advice throughout the research process.
17