SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Inexplicable Persistence
of EFM – Is the Law to Blame?
Julie D. Cantor, MD, JD
UCLA School of Law
Overview
• A Word on Systems
• The Story of EFM
• The Status Quo
• Explanations - Is the Law to Blame?
• Your Thoughts
• Closing Thoughts
What is EFM?
What is intermittent auscultation?
The Story of EFM
EFM: Solve Two Problems
1. Screening test for severe asphyxia
2. Allow for recognition of early asphyxia
On CP: Flawed Hypothesis
“Many lay people, and clinicians too, have come to
believe that birth abnormalities explain a variety of
neurologic and cognitive disorders in children.
In fact, there is little evidence to support this belief.”
- Paneth, NEJM 1986
On CP: Flawed Hypothesis
“The majority of cases of CP appear to be caused by
developmental defects, migrational defects, infections, toxins,
antepartum ischemic or asphyxial episodes in the fetus, and
other causes. Unfortunately, the prevalence of CP has not
decreased since the advent of FHR monitoring. . . . The hope that
FHR monitoring will abolish CP has proved to be an
unmeasurable and unrealistic goal.”
- Parer, AJOG 2000
Additional Concerns
• As a screening test (fetal death/CP), 99.8% false + rate
• Interpretation of the data is:
• subjective, difficult to standardize, poorly reproducible
• inter- and intra-observer variation
• Mobility, comfort measures
• Focus on machine, not patient
• Belief: Can prevent all perinatal mortality & neuro injury
• Abnormal pattern may reflect pre-existing condition
On EFM:
• Pseudodisease
• To prevent, intervene
• Dramatic increases in
• Rates of section
• M&M
• Cost of care
• Law suits
• Insurance costs
• No effect on incidence of CP
Rising Cesarean Rate
Status Quo
Prevalence of Use
• 85% of deliveries using continuous EFM
• #1 OB procedure
• 3.4 million US women at low risk screened annually
Structured IA is equivalent to continuous EFM in
screening for fetal compromise in low-risk patients.
An admission tracing of electronic FHR in low-risk
pregnancy increases intervention without improved neonatal
outcomes . . . routine admission tracings should not be
used to determine monitoring technique.
“the method of choice for the
monitoring of the fetus during normal
labour is intermittent auscultation”
“IA is the preferred method for monitoring the FHR
during labor for women at term who at the onset of
labor are low risk for developing fetal acidemia.”
“Given that the available data do not show a clear
benefit for the use of electronic fetal monitoring
over intermittent auscultation, either option is
acceptable in a patient without complications.”
“ineffective, but
nonetheless persistent”
- Michael Greene, MD
Mass. General Hospital
“Routine intrapartum EFM is not recommended for
low risk women. There is insufficient evidence
regarding its routine use in high risk pregnancies.”
“[T]he USPSTF believes that updating its 1996 recommendation
would have limited potential impact on clinical practice.
The USPSTF will not update its 1996 recommendation.”
Explanations
(Is the law to blame?)
Explanations
• No problem
• Psychology
• Economics
• Education
• Law
Your Thoughts
“The story of electronic fetal monitoring also
illustrates the need for proper randomized
clinical trials before new forms of technology are
introduced that may become the standard of
practice without clearly demonstrated benefit.”
The Inexplicable Persistence of EFM – Is the Law to Blame?

More Related Content

What's hot

Genetic testing
Genetic testingGenetic testing
Genetic testing
Shaells Joshi
 
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleelAntenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
pmjaleelvld
 
Safe prevention of primary cesarean section
Safe prevention of primary cesarean sectionSafe prevention of primary cesarean section
Safe prevention of primary cesarean section
Melinda Weiss
 
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPTACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
Asha Reddy
 
Prenatal diagnosis
Prenatal diagnosisPrenatal diagnosis
Prenatal diagnosis
das nelaturi
 
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERSPRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
Dikshat Pruthi
 
prenatal diagnosis
prenatal diagnosis prenatal diagnosis
prenatal diagnosis
ployswift
 
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune DeficiencyNewborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
Dr. Allen Cherer
 
Reflections on Cesarean Section Rates
Reflections on Cesarean Section RatesReflections on Cesarean Section Rates
Reflections on Cesarean Section Rates
Dr. Allen Cherer
 
NIPT inservice talk May 2015
NIPT inservice talk May 2015NIPT inservice talk May 2015
NIPT inservice talk May 2015
Kathryn Murray
 
Gene screen technology
Gene screen technologyGene screen technology
Gene screen technology
Miriya Johnson
 
Newborn screening kuwait
Newborn screening kuwaitNewborn screening kuwait
Newborn screening kuwait
Newborn Screening KW
 
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick MeadePre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
FADsupport
 
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
t7260678
 
Seminar prenatal genetic screening
Seminar prenatal genetic screeningSeminar prenatal genetic screening
Seminar prenatal genetic screening
Sreelasya Kakarla
 
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
Yahya Noori, Ph.D
 
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosisGenetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
Aftab Siddiqui
 
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issuesPrenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
Rupa Rupagal
 
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
DrDilip86
 
Evidence based Infertility Management
Evidence based Infertility ManagementEvidence based Infertility Management
Evidence based Infertility Management
Priya Bhave.
 

What's hot (20)

Genetic testing
Genetic testingGenetic testing
Genetic testing
 
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleelAntenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
Antenatal / prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders / diseases . Dr. jaleel
 
Safe prevention of primary cesarean section
Safe prevention of primary cesarean sectionSafe prevention of primary cesarean section
Safe prevention of primary cesarean section
 
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPTACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
ACOG : Recommendations for NIPT
 
Prenatal diagnosis
Prenatal diagnosisPrenatal diagnosis
Prenatal diagnosis
 
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERSPRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
PRENATAL DIAGONOSIS OF GENETIC DISORDERS
 
prenatal diagnosis
prenatal diagnosis prenatal diagnosis
prenatal diagnosis
 
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune DeficiencyNewborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
Newborn Screening and Severe Combined Immune Deficiency
 
Reflections on Cesarean Section Rates
Reflections on Cesarean Section RatesReflections on Cesarean Section Rates
Reflections on Cesarean Section Rates
 
NIPT inservice talk May 2015
NIPT inservice talk May 2015NIPT inservice talk May 2015
NIPT inservice talk May 2015
 
Gene screen technology
Gene screen technologyGene screen technology
Gene screen technology
 
Newborn screening kuwait
Newborn screening kuwaitNewborn screening kuwait
Newborn screening kuwait
 
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick MeadePre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis - Nick Meade
 
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
What is-genetic-testing-powerpoint1562
 
Seminar prenatal genetic screening
Seminar prenatal genetic screeningSeminar prenatal genetic screening
Seminar prenatal genetic screening
 
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
Genetic Screening Counseling Prenatal Testing MPH 23 2-15
 
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosisGenetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
Genetic counseling & prenatal diagnosis
 
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issuesPrenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
Prenatal diagnosis, gene manipulation and their ethical issues
 
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
Genetic counselling & Prenatal Diagnosis
 
Evidence based Infertility Management
Evidence based Infertility ManagementEvidence based Infertility Management
Evidence based Infertility Management
 

Similar to The Inexplicable Persistence of EFM – Is the Law to Blame?

ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONSART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
Aboubakr Elnashar
 
Us e fetal
Us e fetalUs e fetal
Us e fetal
gisa_legal
 
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptxprenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
MMridhunaManoharan
 
Prenatal screening.pptx
Prenatal screening.pptxPrenatal screening.pptx
Prenatal screening.pptx
divya kumar
 
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptxFETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
ChristabelAguinede
 
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.GouravGenetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
Gourav Thakre
 
Journal club
Journal clubJournal club
Journal club
Arsla Memon
 
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 20141  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
Tariq Mohammed
 
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 20141  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
Tariq Mohammed
 
IVF for fertile couples
IVF for fertile couplesIVF for fertile couples
IVF for fertile couples
Hesham Al-Inany
 
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy LossOverview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Dr.Laxmi Agrawal Shrikhande
 
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetalPrenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
Jegon Varakala
 
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1 Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
Praveen Ganji
 
USMLE GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic Proce...
USMLE   GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic  Proce...USMLE   GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic  Proce...
USMLE GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic Proce...
AHMED ASHOUR
 
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Mahmoud Abdel-Aleem
 
Ivf necessary element in gynaecology
Ivf necessary element in gynaecologyIvf necessary element in gynaecology
Ivf necessary element in gynaecology
drhemantzaveri
 
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdfEVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
ssuser781459
 
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL CouplesImpact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
CONSULTANT IN OBGYN, ODISHA ,INDIA
 
Future of IVF : scoping view
Future of IVF : scoping viewFuture of IVF : scoping view
Future of IVF : scoping view
Hesham Al-Inany
 
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS           Prof. Aboubakr ElnasharART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS           Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
Aboubakr Elnashar
 

Similar to The Inexplicable Persistence of EFM – Is the Law to Blame? (20)

ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONSART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS
 
Us e fetal
Us e fetalUs e fetal
Us e fetal
 
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptxprenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
prenatal diagnosis.ppt..pptx
 
Prenatal screening.pptx
Prenatal screening.pptxPrenatal screening.pptx
Prenatal screening.pptx
 
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptxFETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
FETAL SURVEILLANCE.pptx
 
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.GouravGenetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
Genetic counselling 7 march13-Dr.Gourav
 
Journal club
Journal clubJournal club
Journal club
 
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 20141  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
 
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 20141  prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
1 prof james bently cervical cancer screening 2014
 
IVF for fertile couples
IVF for fertile couplesIVF for fertile couples
IVF for fertile couples
 
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy LossOverview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
Overview of Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
 
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetalPrenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
Prenatal evaluation and postnatal early outcomes of fetal
 
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1 Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
Perinatal hdn f recovered file 1
 
USMLE GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic Proce...
USMLE   GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic  Proce...USMLE   GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic  Proce...
USMLE GENERAL EMBRYOLOGY 018 Prenatal Diagnostic Prenatal Diagnostic Proce...
 
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
Why to reduce cesarean section rate?
 
Ivf necessary element in gynaecology
Ivf necessary element in gynaecologyIvf necessary element in gynaecology
Ivf necessary element in gynaecology
 
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdfEVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
EVALUATION OF TESTICULAR PAIN.pdf
 
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL CouplesImpact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
Impact Of Genetic Testing For RPL Couples
 
Future of IVF : scoping view
Future of IVF : scoping viewFuture of IVF : scoping view
Future of IVF : scoping view
 
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS           Prof. Aboubakr ElnasharART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS           Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
ART PREGNANCY COMPLICATIONS Prof. Aboubakr Elnashar
 

More from The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health

Helzner lecture 11102020
Helzner lecture 11102020Helzner lecture 11102020
Harris danielle 05282020
Harris danielle 05282020Harris danielle 05282020
Student-Assessed Sex Education Standards
Student-Assessed Sex Education StandardsStudent-Assessed Sex Education Standards
Student-Assessed Sex Education Standards
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Upadhyay 02202020
Upadhyay 02202020Upadhyay 02202020
Papp green melissa-02232020
Papp green melissa-02232020Papp green melissa-02232020
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in IndiaEmpowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion careTelehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Sisson presentation 01-25-2018
Sisson presentation 01-25-2018Sisson presentation 01-25-2018
Mounier 11292017
Mounier 11292017Mounier 11292017
Parra 11292017
Parra 11292017Parra 11292017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Oaks presentation 4-12-17
Oaks presentation 4-12-17Oaks presentation 4-12-17
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health
 
Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017
Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017
Anguyo 10 12-15
Anguyo 10 12-15Anguyo 10 12-15
Maposhere lecture 9-30-15
Maposhere lecture 9-30-15Maposhere lecture 9-30-15

More from The Bixby Center on Population and Reproductive Health (20)

Helzner lecture 11102020
Helzner lecture 11102020Helzner lecture 11102020
Helzner lecture 11102020
 
Harris danielle 05282020
Harris danielle 05282020Harris danielle 05282020
Harris danielle 05282020
 
Student-Assessed Sex Education Standards
Student-Assessed Sex Education StandardsStudent-Assessed Sex Education Standards
Student-Assessed Sex Education Standards
 
Upadhyay 02202020
Upadhyay 02202020Upadhyay 02202020
Upadhyay 02202020
 
Papp green melissa-02232020
Papp green melissa-02232020Papp green melissa-02232020
Papp green melissa-02232020
 
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in IndiaEmpowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
Empowerment with Sex Workers for HIV Prevention in India
 
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
Understanding HPV vaccine hesitancy from a cultural and social perspective: ...
 
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
Gender Discrimination in Sexual & Reproductive Health Rights - the Role of th...
 
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
Introduction to Judge Dingake lecture 4 feb 2019
 
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion careTelehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
Telehealth: The next frontier in abortion care
 
Sisson presentation 01-25-2018
Sisson presentation 01-25-2018Sisson presentation 01-25-2018
Sisson presentation 01-25-2018
 
Mounier 11292017
Mounier 11292017Mounier 11292017
Mounier 11292017
 
Parra 11292017
Parra 11292017Parra 11292017
Parra 11292017
 
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
 
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017Marques lecture 5-30-2017
Marques lecture 5-30-2017
 
Oaks presentation 4-12-17
Oaks presentation 4-12-17Oaks presentation 4-12-17
Oaks presentation 4-12-17
 
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
Creating space presentation 5 18-2017
 
Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017
Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017
Jures hailey lecture_2-21-2017
 
Anguyo 10 12-15
Anguyo 10 12-15Anguyo 10 12-15
Anguyo 10 12-15
 
Maposhere lecture 9-30-15
Maposhere lecture 9-30-15Maposhere lecture 9-30-15
Maposhere lecture 9-30-15
 

Recently uploaded

How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptxHow to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
HajraNaeem15
 
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
สมใจ จันสุกสี
 
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfWalmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
TechSoup
 
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview TrainingBBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
Katrina Pritchard
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
Celine George
 
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRMHow to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
Celine George
 
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptxChapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
Denish Jangid
 
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem studentsRHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
Himanshu Rai
 
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleHow to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
Celine George
 
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdfLiberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
WaniBasim
 
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold MethodHow to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
Celine George
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental DesignDigital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
amberjdewit93
 
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
Diana Rendina
 
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE” .
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE”           .MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE”           .
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE” .
Colégio Santa Teresinha
 
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street NamesThe History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
History of Stoke Newington
 
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
PECB
 

Recently uploaded (20)

How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptxHow to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
 
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
คำศัพท์ คำพื้นฐานการอ่าน ภาษาอังกฤษ ระดับชั้น ม.1
 
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfWalmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
 
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview TrainingBBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
 
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
 
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRMHow to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRM
 
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptxChapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
Chapter wise All Notes of First year Basic Civil Engineering.pptx
 
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem studentsRHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
 
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleHow to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
 
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
 
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdfLiberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
 
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold MethodHow to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold Method
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
 
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental DesignDigital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
Digital Artefact 1 - Tiny Home Environmental Design
 
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
Reimagining Your Library Space: How to Increase the Vibes in Your Library No ...
 
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
Pollock and Snow "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape, Session One: Setting Expec...
 
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE” .
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE”           .MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE”           .
MARY JANE WILSON, A “BOA MÃE” .
 
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street NamesThe History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
 
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
 

The Inexplicable Persistence of EFM – Is the Law to Blame?

  • 1. The Inexplicable Persistence of EFM – Is the Law to Blame? Julie D. Cantor, MD, JD UCLA School of Law
  • 2. Overview • A Word on Systems • The Story of EFM • The Status Quo • Explanations - Is the Law to Blame? • Your Thoughts • Closing Thoughts
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 6.
  • 7. What is intermittent auscultation?
  • 8.
  • 10. EFM: Solve Two Problems 1. Screening test for severe asphyxia 2. Allow for recognition of early asphyxia
  • 11. On CP: Flawed Hypothesis “Many lay people, and clinicians too, have come to believe that birth abnormalities explain a variety of neurologic and cognitive disorders in children. In fact, there is little evidence to support this belief.” - Paneth, NEJM 1986
  • 12.
  • 13. On CP: Flawed Hypothesis “The majority of cases of CP appear to be caused by developmental defects, migrational defects, infections, toxins, antepartum ischemic or asphyxial episodes in the fetus, and other causes. Unfortunately, the prevalence of CP has not decreased since the advent of FHR monitoring. . . . The hope that FHR monitoring will abolish CP has proved to be an unmeasurable and unrealistic goal.” - Parer, AJOG 2000
  • 14. Additional Concerns • As a screening test (fetal death/CP), 99.8% false + rate • Interpretation of the data is: • subjective, difficult to standardize, poorly reproducible • inter- and intra-observer variation • Mobility, comfort measures • Focus on machine, not patient • Belief: Can prevent all perinatal mortality & neuro injury • Abnormal pattern may reflect pre-existing condition
  • 15. On EFM: • Pseudodisease • To prevent, intervene • Dramatic increases in • Rates of section • M&M • Cost of care • Law suits • Insurance costs • No effect on incidence of CP
  • 17.
  • 19. Prevalence of Use • 85% of deliveries using continuous EFM • #1 OB procedure • 3.4 million US women at low risk screened annually
  • 20. Structured IA is equivalent to continuous EFM in screening for fetal compromise in low-risk patients. An admission tracing of electronic FHR in low-risk pregnancy increases intervention without improved neonatal outcomes . . . routine admission tracings should not be used to determine monitoring technique. “the method of choice for the monitoring of the fetus during normal labour is intermittent auscultation”
  • 21. “IA is the preferred method for monitoring the FHR during labor for women at term who at the onset of labor are low risk for developing fetal acidemia.” “Given that the available data do not show a clear benefit for the use of electronic fetal monitoring over intermittent auscultation, either option is acceptable in a patient without complications.”
  • 22. “ineffective, but nonetheless persistent” - Michael Greene, MD Mass. General Hospital
  • 23.
  • 24. “Routine intrapartum EFM is not recommended for low risk women. There is insufficient evidence regarding its routine use in high risk pregnancies.” “[T]he USPSTF believes that updating its 1996 recommendation would have limited potential impact on clinical practice. The USPSTF will not update its 1996 recommendation.”
  • 26. Explanations • No problem • Psychology • Economics • Education • Law
  • 28. “The story of electronic fetal monitoring also illustrates the need for proper randomized clinical trials before new forms of technology are introduced that may become the standard of practice without clearly demonstrated benefit.”