The Game Changer
THE GAME CHANGER
The global recession has taken its toll on the majority of Romanian
citizens. People have been affected in a variety of ways, they have
been forced to face a new reality that demands they change their
behaviour in order to maintain, or at least minimize any decline in their
standard of living.
At the same time, the rapid growth of internet usage has provided
these people with the tools that are necessary to implement this new
behaviour, through a combination of easier access and sharing of
information, through time saving, easier access to jobs and learning
resources or through cheaper communications. For many people the
internet and mobile communications are now an indispensable part of
their daily life.
At the convergence of these technological, social and economic
developments a new type of consumer is being born. In Romania, for
some this process is happening rapidly, whilst for others it is much
slower, but the game is changing.
Our “Game Changer” study explores these developments and looks
at how brands need to adapt to demonstrate that they remain relevant
to the consumer.
The Methodology
Following the same methodology as
Initiative’s international “Game Changer”
study, we actively sought the opinion of
612 Romanian citizens using a synergy
of CATI and CAWI data collection tools
in order to learn the current level of
consumer confidence in the present
economic climate and to understand
how the crisis, combined with
developments in technology are leading
to a fundamental change in consumer
behaviour. The study covered people
aged between 21 and 45 years old,
living in urban areas who are financially
independent and is statistically
representative of this segment of the
population.
The Game Changer study has so
far been conducted in seven other
countries: UK, Germany, France, Spain,
Italy, US and China. When referring to
the general average figures from those
countries the term “international figures”
will be used, unless otherwise specified.
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT OF THE
RECESSION IS FAR GREATER THAN THE
ACTUAL IMPACT
Romanians generally have a very negative opinion regarding the
economic situation within their country and tend to be pessimistic
about the future.
Currently 86% think that the current economic situation is worse than
6 months ago, with 54% considering their own household situation
has worsened during this time. Their expectations for the future are
low, with three quarters of them expecting the situation to worsen in
the coming 6 months and 53% expect the situation within their own
household to also worsen.
This is in direct contrast to our international survey, where 70% of
respondents felt that the economic crisis had stabilized and were more
optimistic about the future, however 60% had been directly impacted
by the economic downturn.
When it comes to the current reality in Romania, the biggest impact of
the recession has been in the form of reductions in household income,
with almost a third of respondents (31%) saying that they have received
a decrease in salary, 14% have had bonuses cancelled and 14% have
seen a decline in the value of their homes. At the same time 12% of
respondents have lost their jobs in the last 6 months alone.
As in the international survey, we have split the respondents into 4
distinct segments that classify how people are managing in the current
situation:
“Confidently Secure” (5%) – People who consider themselves as
not having been impacted by the downturn at all and are carrying on
life as normal. They have not had to adapt to a lower standard of living
and have the financial resources to comfortably see them through the
current times.
“Live for Today” (16%) – They have not given up their standard of
living and have carried on as before, but have a general feeling of
nervousness and insecurity about the future. They do not have the
financial resources to maintain these standards should their income
decrease, and they would have to quickly think of solutions and
strategies to cope with any change in their financial situation.
“Hurt but Optimistic” (37%) – Have been directly impacted by the
recession, and have had to adapt to their new situation by cutting
back on their expenditure. Living at a slightly lower standard than they
had before, but still feeling optimistic that things will improve soon.
“Feeling the Brunt” (42%) – Directly and strongly impacted by the
recession. They have drastically cut back on their spending, sometimes
even in basic areas. They are not optimistic that the situation is going to
change anytime soon. This segment represents the major divergence
from our international study, where only 24% of respondents fell into
this segment.
It should also be noted that this is happening at a time where politically,
the government are being given a vote of no-confidence by 91% of
respondents, with more than half of them having increased their level
of distrust in the past 6 months.
• 42% of Romanians are
“Feeling the Brunt” of the
recession, almost double the
number in the international
survey
• 86% consider things to have
got worse in the last 6 months
• They are not positive about
the future, 75% expect things
to get worse in the next 6
months
CONSUMERS ARE DRIVING THE SHIFT
IN MEDIA CONSUMPTION
situation, with 70% of them checking the latest developments on a
daily basis. This is far higher than internationally where only 45% said
they followed the economic situation on a daily basis.
Television is still the most popular way of doing this with the internet
being second. As with the international survey, over 80% mention
television as one of their three primary sources of information.
However significantly more (56%), cite television as the primary source
in Romania compared to only 41% internationally, with the internet
being the primary source for 26% of Romanians, very similar to the
international figure of 27%.
Newspapers rank lower than internet as a primary source of information,
with only 20% of respondents considering them a top three primary
Implications for Marketers
The financial pressures of the recession are increasing consumers
need to be in control of their own financial situation, fuelling the
growth in platforms and resources that allow them to do this. As
this increases, brands will need to engage consumers on their
own terms and through a wider array of touch points.
• 70% of Romanians check the
news regarding the recession
at least once a day
• Television is still the primary
source of information
• Internet allows consumers to
explore multiple sources of
information
• Newspapers are still key
sources of information, but
via their online editions
source, but only 4% of them would consider it their primary source
of information. The percentage being slightly higher for generalist
newspapers and lower for financial newspapers.
Whilst printed media rank lowly in terms of being a primary source of
information, 69% of respondents read online editions of newspapers
and magazines, with over half of them reading for the specific purpose
of keeping up to date with the latest economic developments. This
is very important for consumers as the internet provides them with
a platform to read many different views and opinions on the same
subject, allowing them to formulate their own opinion from multiple
sources without feeling that they may have been unduly influenced by
any biased reporting.
This is reflected by 60% of respondents saying they consider the
internet a reliable source of information about the recession, higher
than for all other media, and only speaking with friends and family
(75%) or the advice of experts (66%) are considered to be a more
reliable source.
CHANGING CONSUMER VALUES
CANNOT BE IGNORED
As a result of the economic crisis, the trust that consumers give to
institutions and corporations has been redistributed. A polarization
occurs between “heroes” and “villains”, with a positive or negative
view depending on how that institution or corporation has impacted
upon the respondents own wellbeing and quality of life.
As mentioned previously, Government and politicians are given
the least degree of trust by consumers. However, this has been
constantly visible in the Public Opinion Barometer since 1989 and is
not necessarily a result of the current crisis. The level of no-confidence
and distrust in government institutions in Romania is almost identical
to the levels seen for Western Europe and China, where it is a direct
consequence of the recession.
Other notable “villains” are Advertising, not trusted by 48% of
consumers (although it is usually the first place that they receive
information about products), the Media where 47% say they distrust
articles and comments in the media (mostly due to them being
perceived as biased), and Banks and Financial Institutions where 46%
of respondents do not trust them.
Generally, the level of trust in major industries and large corporations
has declined in the past 6 months by over 25%, with the highest
decrease being for banks where the level of distrust increased by 37%.
Romanians’ “heroes” are their own Friends and Families (trusted
by 71% of respondents), the Internet in general (with 52% of the
Romanians having trust in it) and in Supermarkets (44%). Supermarkets
are becoming trustworthy as their discounts and special offers are
perceived as being a positive response to the crisis and helping relieve
the financial pressures that consumers currently face.
When it comes to respondents trust in a company, “credibility” and
“competence” are the key qualities for respondents, with an equal
number of respondents (38%) claiming it was one of the three most
important qualities. “Security” was third with 33%. This reflects a need
for companies and brands to ensure they deliver on what they claim
they do.
Interestingly, for respondents the qualities of “being popular”, “well
known”, and “established” were unimportant, with less than 5%
of respondents claiming they were a key quality for building trust.
Traditionally these qualities would be exploited by marketers as they
are considered be an important influence in a consumers trust in a
company.
When it comes to building trust, the internet plays a key role. 31%
of respondents claim company websites reassure them about the
trustworthiness of the company, with 30% claiming professional
websites & 30% saying search engines provide this reassurance.
Advertising, although considered a villain above is also reassuring to
28% of respondents.
Implications for Marketers
There is a need for a new approach to brand communication, one
which is more focused on credibility, competency and security (in the
form of stability), ensuring that the brand delivers on the consumer’s
expectations. It is no longer enough for brands to rely on being well
known and established to convince consumers. Understanding
that the consumers are part of a larger community and being able
to influence the influencers means that brands have to enter the
online arena with relevant content and genuine interactivity.
• Trust in institutions and
government continues to
decline
• Friends and family remain
the most trusted sources of
information
• Consumers are re-evaluating
their understanding of trust
• “Credibility” & “Competence”
are now the most important
qualities
INTERNET AND MOBILE PHONE ARE THE
ESSENTIALS FOR EVERYDAY LIFE
platform. 87% of respondents consider it essential or important. This
differs significantly from the international survey where only 56% of
respondents considered mobile phones to be so important. Despite
mobile phones being so important for respondents, the economic
situation has led to 22% of respondents saying that they have cut their
expenditure in this area over the past six months.
Internet was considered the second most important technology, being
considered essential or important for 79% of respondents – despite
being ranked second, this is still higher than for the international
survey, where 75% of respondents considered the internet essential.
Landlines are considered far less a priority than mobile phones, with
only 49% of respondents considering them essential, and 21% saying
they would be the first thing to cut if they were forced to reduce their
spend on communication and technology.
Printed media is considered non-essential with over half of
respondents considering newspapers (51%) and magazines (54%)
to be unimportant or totally unimportant. If forced to make cuts in
spending in this area, newspapers would be the first thing to go for
31% of consumers & magazines first for 20%.
• Mobile phones are far more
important for Romanians than
for consumers in other countries
• Internet is now an essential part
of life
• The importance of magazines
& newspapers is continuing to
decline
Implications for Marketers
The Internet has become an indispensable tool for life with implications
that are no longer rational but also emotional. The work-personal life-
rest cycle is becoming more the work-Internet-rest cycle, giving brands
the opportunity to follow their consumers in places and at moments
that were previously unreachable. What needs to be understood
though is that the Internet as a mediun is very different from classical
media, which requires a specific approach and customized content.
MOST CONSUMERS HAVE REASSESSED
THEIR PURCHASING BEHAVIOUR BASED
ON NEEDS, RATHER THAN WANTS
Consumers have re-evaluated their spending patterns across all
goods & services, as they balance their purchase decisions based
upon their needs as opposed to their wants. This is reflected in
over half of respondents saying that they have changed their
shopping habits in the last six months and now shop in stores with
lower prices, and 66% of them actively look for special offers and
promotions.
In this regard, there are three identifiable trends in consumers
purchasing behaviour :
• “Positive adaptation”, where the consumer decided to continue
buying the same brands in a similar or lower quantity. This is
the easiest or the most necessary way to adapt to their needs.
• “Negative adaptation”, where a consumer switched from a
brand to a cheaper alternative brand or a retailer own label
brand, or purchased products on promotion or special offer.
This reflects products or services that are a necessity, but
where the brand itself is a want.
• 59% of respondents have
changed their shopping
habits in the past 6 months,
compared to 70% in the
international survey
• A re-evaluation of needsA
versus wants is affecting
many categories
• Brand loyalty skewed towards
more personal products
• “Renunciation”, in this case a consumer gave up buying both
the brand and the product as they are seen as wants and so
not essential items.
“Positive adaptation” can be seen in categories that are more
personal for consumers and where they are less willing to
compromise on their brand choice. For example Personal Hygiene,
where 75% of consumers continue buying the same brands, and
Fresh Fruit and Vegetables (70%) but also Alcohol and Coffee, both
with 59% of the consumers buying the same brand. For these
categories consumers remained loyal to their preferred brands and
continued buying them.
Although remaining loyal to their brands in these categories the
quantitypurchasedwassignificantlylower,whilst75%ofconsumers
said they would continue to purchase the same Personal Hygiene
brands, only 59% of them said they would buy the same quantity
as before. Whilst just over half would purchase the same quantity
of fresh fruit and vegetables and fresh meat, with only 47% buying
the same amount of coffee as before.
“Negative adaption” occurs for products that have a less personal
impact directly on the consumers themselves. Household hygiene
products and pet food are examples of the segments where
this occurs, with 59% switching to cheaper brands or buying on
promotion for household hygiene products and 37% switching their
pet food brands.
Purchases of retailer own label brands are still relatively small, the
leading categories for purchasing own label brands occurs for
non-alcoholic beverages (16%), household hygiene (14%) and for
skincare (11%) .
Unsurprisingly “renunciation”, is more likely for those categories
requiring a higher level of expenditure. 24% of consumers have
stopped purchasing products in the personal technology category
and 18% have stopped purchasing home electronics. At the same
time, 65% say that they have cut back some or all of their spending
on holidays, and less than 10% intend to purchase a car or home
in the next 6 months.
A direct consequence of the economic crisis has been the
rationalization of buying patterns where the cost to benefit ratio is
of far more importance than any emotional attachment to a brand
or product. Allegiance to a brand – something that is considered
more of an emotional bond – has become a strictly rational decision
Implications for Marketers
Consumers have been quick to adapt to their new financial situation
and to rethink their buying patterns. In the short term marketers
can benefit from buying behaviour driven through offers and
promotions, in the longer term they will need to provide consumers
with information and advice that satisfies their needs, whilst at the
same time building brand equity at a time when consumer priorities
are changing.
related to the brand’s (perceived) capacity to deliver on specific
needs in a way that alternative brands could not.
CATEGORY PURCHASE CHANGES (%)
5
10
14
10
3
8
11
5
2
24
10
17
1
9
20
11
4
12
10
12
3
5
20
10
5
6
15
13
15
12
2
23
25
20
15
9
5
5
7
5
7
16
11
6
5
5
9
4
1
4
14
11
4
4
1
1
3
1
7
5
4
9
8
7
4
4
9
18
1
19
18
24
16
18
26
12
7
19
12
30
20
33
16
7
19
8
7
12
5
4
59
52
33
47
51
34
40
23
29
14
31
39
27
27
28
13
12
8
Personal Hygiene
Fresh Fruits & Vegetables
Alcohol
Coffee
Fresh Meat
Non-alcoholic Beverages
Skincare
Confectionery
Snacks
Clothing & Accessories
Grooming Products
Milk & Diary Products
OTC Medication
Home DIY
Household Hygiene
Furniture & Home Décor
Home Electronics
Personal Technology
Buy the same brands in the same quantity
Buy the same brands in a lower quantity
Switched to a cheaper branded product
Buy whichever brand has the best offer
Buy more retailer own brands
Stopped purchasing this category
THE RECESSION DRIVES INTERNET USAGE
FOR SHOPPING AND PRICE COMPARISON
The growth in internet usage in Romania has led to consumers using
it in many different ways, however it has not reached a stage where
a significant level of purchases are actually made online. Personal
technology and home appliances and electronics are the leading
categories for online purchases, but of the 38% of consumers who
say they use the internet to help when purchasing personal technology
only 63% of them actually purchase the products online. In the case
of home appliances and electronics, of the 37% who use the internet
to research purchases, only a third of them purchase online. In other
categories the level of online purchases falls well below 10%.
The strength of the internet is in its ability to allow people to search
for information about products and services before actually making a
purchase. Over half of respondents (55%) use it as a tool to find more
detailed information about products and services, an increase of 34%
over those saying they used it for this purpose 6 months ago.
52% of respondents say that they use the internet to specifically
search other customers experiences with the products and services
that they are intending to buy, a third of them read product review
sites and almost half of respondents use price comparison websites
– an increase of 21% in the last six months and a reflection of the
continued growth in these type of sites in Romania.
• Online purchases are still
relatively low in Romania
• Internet provides the platform
for searching out information
before purchasing
• Other customer experiences
are important in making
purchase decisions
• Price comparison websites
continue to grow in popularity
as an effective strategy in
cutting costs.
Implications for Marketers
The recession has increased the
opportunities for marketers to be
present on online platforms, either
interacting with the consumers or
pro-actively meeting their needs for
information. There are a wide variety
of ways for marketers to connect
with consumers in the online
environment, and a very wide range
of activities in which consumers
can engage online in order to find
the best deals, bargains, special
offers and discounts that marketers
should be involved in.
THE CURRENT CRISIS IS A NEW PARADIGM
The economic downturn has been a game changer in terms of
consumer behaviour, with the growth and usage of the internet
providing a catalyst for this change. We have observed a number of
fundamental changes:
• Careful reassessment of their needs versus wants to ensure they
maximize their purchase power in an environment where their
income has stayed the same or is diminishing.
• Internet is now an essential part of everyday life, being considered
more important than television
• At the same time, internet is playing an ever greater role in influencing
purchase decisions, through a variety of sources including other
customer reviews, product and price comparison websites, etc.
• A change in the perception of trust, with the key qualities now
“credibility” and “competence”.
This change is not temporary, 54% have changed their behaviour and
will maintain at least some of these changes even after the recession
is over.
The new game is on! Are you playing?
• Roughly half of the
Romanians have adopted
various new behaviours
as response to the
recession and they are
expected to totally or
partially keep them after
the crisis is over
About Initiative
Initiative (www.initiative.com) is a media
communications company that transforms media
exchanges into marketing results through a
commitment to performance.
Initiative believes that all marketing should be
performance-driven. Data, analytics, insight and
innovation are central to all our services, and we hold
ourselves fully accountable to client business goals.
This commitment to performance is the heart of
Initiative’s unique process and culture. Owned by
the Interpublic Group, Initiative is part of media
management group Mediabrands and a partner
of Magna, IPG’s centralized media negotiation
entity. Initiative employs more than 2500 talented
professionals, working in 91 offices across 70
markets, worldwide.
Initiative’s comprehensive range of performance-
led communications services include: research
and insight, media planning and buying, digital
communications solutions, content creation, and
evaluation and accountability services.
For more information about the Game Changer
research or Initiative, please contact:
Manuela Ramona Zidaru
Corporate Communications Manager - Initiative
M + (40) 740 084 896
E ramona.zidaru@ro.initiative.com
Initiative Romania
17 Ceasornicului Street
Bucharest - 1, Romania

The game changer 2010

  • 1.
  • 3.
    THE GAME CHANGER Theglobal recession has taken its toll on the majority of Romanian citizens. People have been affected in a variety of ways, they have been forced to face a new reality that demands they change their behaviour in order to maintain, or at least minimize any decline in their standard of living. At the same time, the rapid growth of internet usage has provided these people with the tools that are necessary to implement this new behaviour, through a combination of easier access and sharing of information, through time saving, easier access to jobs and learning resources or through cheaper communications. For many people the internet and mobile communications are now an indispensable part of their daily life. At the convergence of these technological, social and economic developments a new type of consumer is being born. In Romania, for some this process is happening rapidly, whilst for others it is much slower, but the game is changing. Our “Game Changer” study explores these developments and looks at how brands need to adapt to demonstrate that they remain relevant to the consumer. The Methodology Following the same methodology as Initiative’s international “Game Changer” study, we actively sought the opinion of 612 Romanian citizens using a synergy of CATI and CAWI data collection tools in order to learn the current level of consumer confidence in the present economic climate and to understand how the crisis, combined with developments in technology are leading to a fundamental change in consumer behaviour. The study covered people aged between 21 and 45 years old, living in urban areas who are financially independent and is statistically representative of this segment of the population. The Game Changer study has so far been conducted in seven other countries: UK, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, US and China. When referring to the general average figures from those countries the term “international figures” will be used, unless otherwise specified.
  • 4.
    THE PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACTOF THE RECESSION IS FAR GREATER THAN THE ACTUAL IMPACT Romanians generally have a very negative opinion regarding the economic situation within their country and tend to be pessimistic about the future. Currently 86% think that the current economic situation is worse than 6 months ago, with 54% considering their own household situation has worsened during this time. Their expectations for the future are low, with three quarters of them expecting the situation to worsen in the coming 6 months and 53% expect the situation within their own household to also worsen. This is in direct contrast to our international survey, where 70% of respondents felt that the economic crisis had stabilized and were more optimistic about the future, however 60% had been directly impacted by the economic downturn. When it comes to the current reality in Romania, the biggest impact of the recession has been in the form of reductions in household income, with almost a third of respondents (31%) saying that they have received
  • 5.
    a decrease insalary, 14% have had bonuses cancelled and 14% have seen a decline in the value of their homes. At the same time 12% of respondents have lost their jobs in the last 6 months alone. As in the international survey, we have split the respondents into 4 distinct segments that classify how people are managing in the current situation: “Confidently Secure” (5%) – People who consider themselves as not having been impacted by the downturn at all and are carrying on life as normal. They have not had to adapt to a lower standard of living and have the financial resources to comfortably see them through the current times. “Live for Today” (16%) – They have not given up their standard of living and have carried on as before, but have a general feeling of nervousness and insecurity about the future. They do not have the financial resources to maintain these standards should their income decrease, and they would have to quickly think of solutions and strategies to cope with any change in their financial situation. “Hurt but Optimistic” (37%) – Have been directly impacted by the recession, and have had to adapt to their new situation by cutting back on their expenditure. Living at a slightly lower standard than they had before, but still feeling optimistic that things will improve soon. “Feeling the Brunt” (42%) – Directly and strongly impacted by the recession. They have drastically cut back on their spending, sometimes even in basic areas. They are not optimistic that the situation is going to change anytime soon. This segment represents the major divergence from our international study, where only 24% of respondents fell into this segment. It should also be noted that this is happening at a time where politically, the government are being given a vote of no-confidence by 91% of respondents, with more than half of them having increased their level of distrust in the past 6 months. • 42% of Romanians are “Feeling the Brunt” of the recession, almost double the number in the international survey • 86% consider things to have got worse in the last 6 months • They are not positive about the future, 75% expect things to get worse in the next 6 months
  • 6.
    CONSUMERS ARE DRIVINGTHE SHIFT IN MEDIA CONSUMPTION situation, with 70% of them checking the latest developments on a daily basis. This is far higher than internationally where only 45% said they followed the economic situation on a daily basis. Television is still the most popular way of doing this with the internet being second. As with the international survey, over 80% mention television as one of their three primary sources of information. However significantly more (56%), cite television as the primary source in Romania compared to only 41% internationally, with the internet being the primary source for 26% of Romanians, very similar to the international figure of 27%. Newspapers rank lower than internet as a primary source of information, with only 20% of respondents considering them a top three primary
  • 7.
    Implications for Marketers Thefinancial pressures of the recession are increasing consumers need to be in control of their own financial situation, fuelling the growth in platforms and resources that allow them to do this. As this increases, brands will need to engage consumers on their own terms and through a wider array of touch points. • 70% of Romanians check the news regarding the recession at least once a day • Television is still the primary source of information • Internet allows consumers to explore multiple sources of information • Newspapers are still key sources of information, but via their online editions source, but only 4% of them would consider it their primary source of information. The percentage being slightly higher for generalist newspapers and lower for financial newspapers. Whilst printed media rank lowly in terms of being a primary source of information, 69% of respondents read online editions of newspapers and magazines, with over half of them reading for the specific purpose of keeping up to date with the latest economic developments. This is very important for consumers as the internet provides them with a platform to read many different views and opinions on the same subject, allowing them to formulate their own opinion from multiple sources without feeling that they may have been unduly influenced by any biased reporting. This is reflected by 60% of respondents saying they consider the internet a reliable source of information about the recession, higher than for all other media, and only speaking with friends and family (75%) or the advice of experts (66%) are considered to be a more reliable source.
  • 8.
    CHANGING CONSUMER VALUES CANNOTBE IGNORED As a result of the economic crisis, the trust that consumers give to institutions and corporations has been redistributed. A polarization occurs between “heroes” and “villains”, with a positive or negative view depending on how that institution or corporation has impacted upon the respondents own wellbeing and quality of life. As mentioned previously, Government and politicians are given the least degree of trust by consumers. However, this has been constantly visible in the Public Opinion Barometer since 1989 and is not necessarily a result of the current crisis. The level of no-confidence and distrust in government institutions in Romania is almost identical to the levels seen for Western Europe and China, where it is a direct consequence of the recession. Other notable “villains” are Advertising, not trusted by 48% of consumers (although it is usually the first place that they receive information about products), the Media where 47% say they distrust articles and comments in the media (mostly due to them being perceived as biased), and Banks and Financial Institutions where 46% of respondents do not trust them. Generally, the level of trust in major industries and large corporations has declined in the past 6 months by over 25%, with the highest decrease being for banks where the level of distrust increased by 37%.
  • 9.
    Romanians’ “heroes” aretheir own Friends and Families (trusted by 71% of respondents), the Internet in general (with 52% of the Romanians having trust in it) and in Supermarkets (44%). Supermarkets are becoming trustworthy as their discounts and special offers are perceived as being a positive response to the crisis and helping relieve the financial pressures that consumers currently face. When it comes to respondents trust in a company, “credibility” and “competence” are the key qualities for respondents, with an equal number of respondents (38%) claiming it was one of the three most important qualities. “Security” was third with 33%. This reflects a need for companies and brands to ensure they deliver on what they claim they do. Interestingly, for respondents the qualities of “being popular”, “well known”, and “established” were unimportant, with less than 5% of respondents claiming they were a key quality for building trust. Traditionally these qualities would be exploited by marketers as they are considered be an important influence in a consumers trust in a company. When it comes to building trust, the internet plays a key role. 31% of respondents claim company websites reassure them about the trustworthiness of the company, with 30% claiming professional websites & 30% saying search engines provide this reassurance. Advertising, although considered a villain above is also reassuring to 28% of respondents. Implications for Marketers There is a need for a new approach to brand communication, one which is more focused on credibility, competency and security (in the form of stability), ensuring that the brand delivers on the consumer’s expectations. It is no longer enough for brands to rely on being well known and established to convince consumers. Understanding that the consumers are part of a larger community and being able to influence the influencers means that brands have to enter the online arena with relevant content and genuine interactivity. • Trust in institutions and government continues to decline • Friends and family remain the most trusted sources of information • Consumers are re-evaluating their understanding of trust • “Credibility” & “Competence” are now the most important qualities
  • 10.
    INTERNET AND MOBILEPHONE ARE THE ESSENTIALS FOR EVERYDAY LIFE platform. 87% of respondents consider it essential or important. This differs significantly from the international survey where only 56% of respondents considered mobile phones to be so important. Despite mobile phones being so important for respondents, the economic situation has led to 22% of respondents saying that they have cut their expenditure in this area over the past six months. Internet was considered the second most important technology, being considered essential or important for 79% of respondents – despite being ranked second, this is still higher than for the international survey, where 75% of respondents considered the internet essential. Landlines are considered far less a priority than mobile phones, with only 49% of respondents considering them essential, and 21% saying they would be the first thing to cut if they were forced to reduce their spend on communication and technology. Printed media is considered non-essential with over half of respondents considering newspapers (51%) and magazines (54%) to be unimportant or totally unimportant. If forced to make cuts in spending in this area, newspapers would be the first thing to go for 31% of consumers & magazines first for 20%. • Mobile phones are far more important for Romanians than for consumers in other countries • Internet is now an essential part of life • The importance of magazines & newspapers is continuing to decline Implications for Marketers The Internet has become an indispensable tool for life with implications that are no longer rational but also emotional. The work-personal life- rest cycle is becoming more the work-Internet-rest cycle, giving brands the opportunity to follow their consumers in places and at moments that were previously unreachable. What needs to be understood though is that the Internet as a mediun is very different from classical media, which requires a specific approach and customized content.
  • 11.
    MOST CONSUMERS HAVEREASSESSED THEIR PURCHASING BEHAVIOUR BASED ON NEEDS, RATHER THAN WANTS Consumers have re-evaluated their spending patterns across all goods & services, as they balance their purchase decisions based upon their needs as opposed to their wants. This is reflected in over half of respondents saying that they have changed their shopping habits in the last six months and now shop in stores with lower prices, and 66% of them actively look for special offers and promotions. In this regard, there are three identifiable trends in consumers purchasing behaviour : • “Positive adaptation”, where the consumer decided to continue buying the same brands in a similar or lower quantity. This is the easiest or the most necessary way to adapt to their needs. • “Negative adaptation”, where a consumer switched from a brand to a cheaper alternative brand or a retailer own label brand, or purchased products on promotion or special offer. This reflects products or services that are a necessity, but where the brand itself is a want. • 59% of respondents have changed their shopping habits in the past 6 months, compared to 70% in the international survey • A re-evaluation of needsA versus wants is affecting many categories • Brand loyalty skewed towards more personal products
  • 12.
    • “Renunciation”, inthis case a consumer gave up buying both the brand and the product as they are seen as wants and so not essential items. “Positive adaptation” can be seen in categories that are more personal for consumers and where they are less willing to compromise on their brand choice. For example Personal Hygiene, where 75% of consumers continue buying the same brands, and Fresh Fruit and Vegetables (70%) but also Alcohol and Coffee, both with 59% of the consumers buying the same brand. For these categories consumers remained loyal to their preferred brands and continued buying them. Although remaining loyal to their brands in these categories the quantitypurchasedwassignificantlylower,whilst75%ofconsumers said they would continue to purchase the same Personal Hygiene brands, only 59% of them said they would buy the same quantity as before. Whilst just over half would purchase the same quantity of fresh fruit and vegetables and fresh meat, with only 47% buying the same amount of coffee as before. “Negative adaption” occurs for products that have a less personal impact directly on the consumers themselves. Household hygiene products and pet food are examples of the segments where this occurs, with 59% switching to cheaper brands or buying on promotion for household hygiene products and 37% switching their pet food brands. Purchases of retailer own label brands are still relatively small, the leading categories for purchasing own label brands occurs for non-alcoholic beverages (16%), household hygiene (14%) and for skincare (11%) . Unsurprisingly “renunciation”, is more likely for those categories requiring a higher level of expenditure. 24% of consumers have stopped purchasing products in the personal technology category and 18% have stopped purchasing home electronics. At the same time, 65% say that they have cut back some or all of their spending on holidays, and less than 10% intend to purchase a car or home in the next 6 months. A direct consequence of the economic crisis has been the rationalization of buying patterns where the cost to benefit ratio is of far more importance than any emotional attachment to a brand or product. Allegiance to a brand – something that is considered more of an emotional bond – has become a strictly rational decision
  • 13.
    Implications for Marketers Consumershave been quick to adapt to their new financial situation and to rethink their buying patterns. In the short term marketers can benefit from buying behaviour driven through offers and promotions, in the longer term they will need to provide consumers with information and advice that satisfies their needs, whilst at the same time building brand equity at a time when consumer priorities are changing. related to the brand’s (perceived) capacity to deliver on specific needs in a way that alternative brands could not. CATEGORY PURCHASE CHANGES (%) 5 10 14 10 3 8 11 5 2 24 10 17 1 9 20 11 4 12 10 12 3 5 20 10 5 6 15 13 15 12 2 23 25 20 15 9 5 5 7 5 7 16 11 6 5 5 9 4 1 4 14 11 4 4 1 1 3 1 7 5 4 9 8 7 4 4 9 18 1 19 18 24 16 18 26 12 7 19 12 30 20 33 16 7 19 8 7 12 5 4 59 52 33 47 51 34 40 23 29 14 31 39 27 27 28 13 12 8 Personal Hygiene Fresh Fruits & Vegetables Alcohol Coffee Fresh Meat Non-alcoholic Beverages Skincare Confectionery Snacks Clothing & Accessories Grooming Products Milk & Diary Products OTC Medication Home DIY Household Hygiene Furniture & Home Décor Home Electronics Personal Technology Buy the same brands in the same quantity Buy the same brands in a lower quantity Switched to a cheaper branded product Buy whichever brand has the best offer Buy more retailer own brands Stopped purchasing this category
  • 14.
    THE RECESSION DRIVESINTERNET USAGE FOR SHOPPING AND PRICE COMPARISON The growth in internet usage in Romania has led to consumers using it in many different ways, however it has not reached a stage where a significant level of purchases are actually made online. Personal technology and home appliances and electronics are the leading categories for online purchases, but of the 38% of consumers who say they use the internet to help when purchasing personal technology only 63% of them actually purchase the products online. In the case of home appliances and electronics, of the 37% who use the internet to research purchases, only a third of them purchase online. In other categories the level of online purchases falls well below 10%. The strength of the internet is in its ability to allow people to search for information about products and services before actually making a purchase. Over half of respondents (55%) use it as a tool to find more detailed information about products and services, an increase of 34% over those saying they used it for this purpose 6 months ago. 52% of respondents say that they use the internet to specifically search other customers experiences with the products and services that they are intending to buy, a third of them read product review sites and almost half of respondents use price comparison websites – an increase of 21% in the last six months and a reflection of the continued growth in these type of sites in Romania. • Online purchases are still relatively low in Romania • Internet provides the platform for searching out information before purchasing • Other customer experiences are important in making purchase decisions • Price comparison websites continue to grow in popularity as an effective strategy in cutting costs. Implications for Marketers The recession has increased the opportunities for marketers to be present on online platforms, either interacting with the consumers or pro-actively meeting their needs for information. There are a wide variety of ways for marketers to connect with consumers in the online environment, and a very wide range of activities in which consumers can engage online in order to find the best deals, bargains, special offers and discounts that marketers should be involved in.
  • 15.
    THE CURRENT CRISISIS A NEW PARADIGM The economic downturn has been a game changer in terms of consumer behaviour, with the growth and usage of the internet providing a catalyst for this change. We have observed a number of fundamental changes: • Careful reassessment of their needs versus wants to ensure they maximize their purchase power in an environment where their income has stayed the same or is diminishing. • Internet is now an essential part of everyday life, being considered more important than television • At the same time, internet is playing an ever greater role in influencing purchase decisions, through a variety of sources including other customer reviews, product and price comparison websites, etc. • A change in the perception of trust, with the key qualities now “credibility” and “competence”. This change is not temporary, 54% have changed their behaviour and will maintain at least some of these changes even after the recession is over. The new game is on! Are you playing? • Roughly half of the Romanians have adopted various new behaviours as response to the recession and they are expected to totally or partially keep them after the crisis is over
  • 16.
    About Initiative Initiative (www.initiative.com)is a media communications company that transforms media exchanges into marketing results through a commitment to performance. Initiative believes that all marketing should be performance-driven. Data, analytics, insight and innovation are central to all our services, and we hold ourselves fully accountable to client business goals. This commitment to performance is the heart of Initiative’s unique process and culture. Owned by the Interpublic Group, Initiative is part of media management group Mediabrands and a partner of Magna, IPG’s centralized media negotiation entity. Initiative employs more than 2500 talented professionals, working in 91 offices across 70 markets, worldwide. Initiative’s comprehensive range of performance- led communications services include: research and insight, media planning and buying, digital communications solutions, content creation, and evaluation and accountability services. For more information about the Game Changer research or Initiative, please contact: Manuela Ramona Zidaru Corporate Communications Manager - Initiative M + (40) 740 084 896 E ramona.zidaru@ro.initiative.com Initiative Romania 17 Ceasornicului Street Bucharest - 1, Romania