This paper evaluates the effect of home-owning on business. There are both positive and negative spillovers from home-owning. The positive spillover is that owners are more stable and they build better amenities, which attracts business. The negative one arises through the NIMBY effect. Both impacts vary with the distance between residence and business, neighborhood income levels, and business types. The aim of this paper is to firstly identify the distance at which the positive effect exceeds the negative one or vice versa. Secondly, I want to find whether the net impact differs for higher or lower residential income groups. Finally, I investigate the impacts for different industries. I employ a K-means clustering method to study the spatial effect with distance by clustering the business first and then drawing donut rings of residents around business clusters. The major endogeneity concern might be the reverse causation. I incorporate multiple identification strategies to cross check the results: fixed effects (FE), first difference (FD) and Instrumental Variable methods (IV). Using American Community Survey (ACS) and Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics (LEHD) Work Area Characteristics (WAC) panel data from 2009 to 2014, I conclude that home-owning only decreases the job counts of adjacent distances of within .3 miles and benefits the business in 3-5 miles. Negative impacts are only identified in higher income groups while the lower income groups benefit business development. Service industries like Retail, Art and Professional Services are welcomed in higher income groups while Manufacturing, Real Estate and Car Rental and Leasing are welcomed in lower income groups.
Location analysis for the expansion of national and public kindergarten겨울 정
Through analyzing geographical big data, the study identified suitable locations to expand national and public kindergartens in Seoul. Data on population, birth rates, income levels, and existing kindergarten locations and densities were analyzed at the dong level and overlaid to determine high priority areas. Two specific locations in Gangseo-gu were identified as suitable sites. While the analysis provides guidance, additional criteria may be needed for areas with high need but no available buildings, like Sanggye-dong. The results can help reduce regional bias and inform Seoul's kindergarten expansion planning and budgeting.
Expert workshop on the creation and uses of combined environmental and economic performance datasets at the micro-level - 10-11 July 2018 - OECD, Paris
Edward Galasso is a seasoned project manager with over 20 years of experience managing multimillion-dollar projects across telecommunications, engineering, and construction industries. He has extensive experience in project operations management, engineering support, profit and loss management, finance and budget management, administrative and human resource management, and account management. Galasso's resume highlights his roles and responsibilities in leading fiber optic cable construction projects, managing engineering teams, negotiating contracts, and overseeing day-to-day operations. He holds an MBA and certifications in project management.
Business-IT Alignment:Getting IT AND Keeping IT - Kappelman & PettitLeon Kappelman
Aligning IT with the business is about knowing your customer, the business. In IT we call this "knowing their requirements." Based on research sponsored by the Society for Information Management's Enterprise Architecture Working Group, this presentation provides performance measures to determine and improve your capabilities to do Requirements Analysis: specifically to assess your capabilities to effectively do Systems Analysis and Design and Enterprise Architecture. A software development capabilities measure is also provided.
Location Behaviors by Univ. of Michigan - Flint professor, Sy Banerjee at #Mo...Kimberly-Clark
What is all the debate on privacy about? Learn about the data that is publicly available and legal – without any hacking. By tapping into Foursquare and Twitter data, Sy Banerjee has found fascinating concrete behaviors only theorized by mobile panels at other conferences. This academic study focuses on a) What environmental aspects cause people to use the phone differently? b) What different types of user segments emerge in displaying more or less “mobile” shopping behaviors? c) How can users in each segment be characterized?
This document provides a summary of Donna S. Nielsen's professional experience and qualifications. She has over 30 years of experience in quality assurance, manufacturing, development and research in the microelectronics and semiconductor industry. Her most recent role is as Senior Manager of Supplier Quality Engineering and Material Quality Lab at GLOBALFOUNDRIES. She has also held various management roles at IBM and Motorola in areas including quality assurance, materials engineering, and process development.
Using ROI Methodology to Document the Benefits of King County GISGreg Babinski
Greg Babinski presented on a study conducted to document the return on investment (ROI) of the King County GIS program. The study found that between 1992-2010, King County GIS generated $775 million in net benefits from increased productivity across county agencies. The study used interviews and surveys of GIS users to compare productivity "with and without" GIS. Future steps include publishing results, refining the methodology, and encouraging more ROI studies to help justify further GIS development.
Location analysis for the expansion of national and public kindergarten겨울 정
Through analyzing geographical big data, the study identified suitable locations to expand national and public kindergartens in Seoul. Data on population, birth rates, income levels, and existing kindergarten locations and densities were analyzed at the dong level and overlaid to determine high priority areas. Two specific locations in Gangseo-gu were identified as suitable sites. While the analysis provides guidance, additional criteria may be needed for areas with high need but no available buildings, like Sanggye-dong. The results can help reduce regional bias and inform Seoul's kindergarten expansion planning and budgeting.
Expert workshop on the creation and uses of combined environmental and economic performance datasets at the micro-level - 10-11 July 2018 - OECD, Paris
Edward Galasso is a seasoned project manager with over 20 years of experience managing multimillion-dollar projects across telecommunications, engineering, and construction industries. He has extensive experience in project operations management, engineering support, profit and loss management, finance and budget management, administrative and human resource management, and account management. Galasso's resume highlights his roles and responsibilities in leading fiber optic cable construction projects, managing engineering teams, negotiating contracts, and overseeing day-to-day operations. He holds an MBA and certifications in project management.
Business-IT Alignment:Getting IT AND Keeping IT - Kappelman & PettitLeon Kappelman
Aligning IT with the business is about knowing your customer, the business. In IT we call this "knowing their requirements." Based on research sponsored by the Society for Information Management's Enterprise Architecture Working Group, this presentation provides performance measures to determine and improve your capabilities to do Requirements Analysis: specifically to assess your capabilities to effectively do Systems Analysis and Design and Enterprise Architecture. A software development capabilities measure is also provided.
Location Behaviors by Univ. of Michigan - Flint professor, Sy Banerjee at #Mo...Kimberly-Clark
What is all the debate on privacy about? Learn about the data that is publicly available and legal – without any hacking. By tapping into Foursquare and Twitter data, Sy Banerjee has found fascinating concrete behaviors only theorized by mobile panels at other conferences. This academic study focuses on a) What environmental aspects cause people to use the phone differently? b) What different types of user segments emerge in displaying more or less “mobile” shopping behaviors? c) How can users in each segment be characterized?
This document provides a summary of Donna S. Nielsen's professional experience and qualifications. She has over 30 years of experience in quality assurance, manufacturing, development and research in the microelectronics and semiconductor industry. Her most recent role is as Senior Manager of Supplier Quality Engineering and Material Quality Lab at GLOBALFOUNDRIES. She has also held various management roles at IBM and Motorola in areas including quality assurance, materials engineering, and process development.
Using ROI Methodology to Document the Benefits of King County GISGreg Babinski
Greg Babinski presented on a study conducted to document the return on investment (ROI) of the King County GIS program. The study found that between 1992-2010, King County GIS generated $775 million in net benefits from increased productivity across county agencies. The study used interviews and surveys of GIS users to compare productivity "with and without" GIS. Future steps include publishing results, refining the methodology, and encouraging more ROI studies to help justify further GIS development.
This document summarizes trends in technology for cities and counties in 2013. It outlines the top "Ins" and "Outs" for general technology, technical areas, and areas of focus for city and county CIOs. Some key trends include a shift to cloud-based solutions, big data and predictive analytics, mobility, and consumerization of technology. Budgets are expected to increase most for overall IT department budgets and decrease most for staff training and travel budgets. CIOs need to manage expectations around new technologies and ensure their relevance through governance and professionalization of their roles.
Technology, Data Capture, & the Mechanical ContractorNathan C. Wood
There’s an ever increasing amount of data being collected on jobsites through the use of drones, laser scanning, and integrated Building Information Modeling (BIM). These tools provide innumerable data, but you need to know how to dissect that information in order to leverage it. This seminar will explore the different technologies available today, and how mechanical contractors are utilizing them to improve their bottom line. Prepare to learn different strategies for capturing and analyzing performance data across projects and identify struggling projects before they become a bigger issue. This seminar will conclude with a roundtable discussion about the current challenges with sharing data between the other project players like the General Contractor, Engineer, or Owner.
Examples of Modelling & Forecasting - Andrew Jamieson, Andrew HermannAndy Dunne
ARO Break Out Group 2 / Modelling & Forecasting - East of England Forecasting Model and West Midlands IPM. These presentations were given on Wednesday 27th January 2010.
Business Value of Agile Methods: Using ROI & Real OptionsDavid Rico
The document provides background on agile methods and their business value compared to traditional project management approaches. It discusses how agile methods can help address issues like cost overruns, defects, and project failures seen in many traditional projects. The document summarizes research showing that agile projects have significantly better outcomes in terms of costs, quality, and success rates compared to traditional approaches.
Speaking Danish in Japan: Good practice lessons to learn and emulate
(Morten Meyerhoff Nielsen – http://www.flickr.com/photos/40451858@N04/6993025986/in/pool-1909773@N24/)
Business Value of Agile Methods: Its Leadership ConsiderationsDavid Rico
Agile methods provide benefits over traditional approaches such as lower costs, fewer defects, and higher success rates. Studies show that agile projects have lower costs by 61% on average and 93% fewer defects. Agile adoption is widespread, with 80% of organizations using some agile practices. The number of certified scrum masters has doubled in two years, yet there remains a shortage of qualified agile practitioners. Agile is used successfully across many industries, including highly regulated domains.
C2ER 2009 - Data-Driven Responses to a Rapidly Changing Economychrisaberle
A presentation discussing various data and analysis tools and how they can be applied to address the broad range of issues facing communies in this challenging economy. We discuss how to define and evaluate various green projects, how to turn layoffs into opportunities for regional innovation, and how cluster analysis and business intelligence can be combined to create a powerful tool for identifying and supporting areas of entrepreneurial growth.
Digital Employee Experience Breakfast - 13th March SydneySquiz
A great digital employee experience provides many benefits such as improved productivity, higher employee retention rates and technology that adapts to each workforce. However, making this a reality is easier said than done.
This presentation covers:
How increasing employee digital literacy helps organisations to remain competitive, up skill their workforce for the future and incorporate new technologies into the organisation
The benefits of allowing employees to choose the way they work with technology, resulting in employee acquisition, satisfaction and retention
How the digital employee experience impacts the customer experience
The importance of a digital workplace to foster employee collaboration and engagement, make searching for people and files easy, while integrating with existing internal systems
1. The document discusses different definitions of fast growth firms and their implications. It finds that employment-based and productivity-based definitions capture different populations with different economic contributions.
2. It analyzes the regional and industry spillover effects of fast growth firms on other firms' employment growth and productivity growth. It finds both positive and negative externalities depending on the industry, region, and firm characteristics.
3. Geographic externalities, including the concentration of fast growth firms within postcodes and their "gravity force", mirror the findings for industry externalities - negative impacts on employment but positive impacts on productivity.
The Local-Mobile Opportunity: Presented by 15milesKatie Fellenz
The 3rd webinar in a series presented by Local Search experts, 15miles. Learn how-to take your business mobile and optimize your business for local search.
This document summarizes discussions from a workshop regarding the development of parcels D2 and D3 in Union Square, Somerville. The workshop addressed program, massing, and design principles. For program, a balanced mix of uses including jobs, housing, retail, and open space was proposed. Massing concepts explored stepping back taller portions from streets and the T station. Design principles focused on activating streets, carving out shared public spaces, and relating to the surrounding context.
Joseph D. Legris is a mechanical engineering student at Roger Williams University with a 3.54 GPA. He has experience in mechanical engineering projects including designing a medical device for pain distraction and an autonomous robot. He also has work experience in park maintenance and concrete construction. Currently, he is a research assistant designing a two degree of freedom system and presenting results at multiple conferences.
This document provides an overview of getting started in tech. It discusses how technology is disrupting many industries and creating demand for technical skills. Common first jobs in tech like front-end development, back-end development, and QA testing are outlined. The document also discusses career trajectories in tech and "coding plus" roles like product manager, growth hacker, and data scientist. Tips are provided on learning skills, building a portfolio, networking, and preparing for technical interviews to break into a tech career. Thinkful's coding bootcamp is presented as an option to gain skills through flexible mentorship-driven learning.
The document discusses an Internet of Everything (IoE) Value Index report for Mexico. Some key findings include:
- IoE is expected to create $14.4 trillion in global value from 2013-2022, with Mexico realizing $87.5 billion of that potential value in 2013.
- However, Mexico captured only around 52% of its potential IoE value in 2013, leaving $41 billion "on the table".
- The largest opportunities for capturing more IoE value in Mexico involve improving customer experience, supply chain/logistics efficiency, and innovation.
Eric Gries, CEO of Lucid Imagination, discusses the growth of the enterprise search market and the evolution of open source search tools Lucene and Solr. He introduces LucidWorks Enterprise, a commercial distribution of Solr that aims to make search easier to implement and scale through features like smart defaults, REST APIs, and integrated document updating. LucidWorks Enterprise is intended to provide the power of Solr with a well-organized package, more client libraries, and search innovations like click scoring, all at the lowest cost of scaling a search solution.
This document discusses smart analytics and big data. It begins by defining the 5 V's of big data: volume, velocity, variety, veracity, and value. It then discusses how analytics can provide competitive advantages for organizations and how the percentage of organizations realizing this advantage has increased significantly in recent years. The rest of the document discusses IBM's work in areas like smarter cities, smart service systems, and T-shaped professionals who have expertise across multiple domains. It provides examples of the large amounts of data being generated and concludes with a discussion of modeling holistic service systems at different levels from an individual to the entire planet.
What happened in Tech M&A during the first quarter of 2019? How has the rapid market recovery impacted valuations? Are private equity deals still soaring? Who are the new buyers making waves? Listen in as Corum Group gives the most in-depth look available at Q1 of 2019 for mergers and across all six technology sectors and 30 subsectors. Plus, we’ll get a special report on succession planning for tech company owners and executives, and a report from a special series of M&A conferences across Europe.
Gary Jones has over 40 years of experience developing and supporting mainframe applications. He has extensive experience in COBOL, CICS, DB2, JCL, and other mainframe technologies. His experience includes roles at JPMorgan Chase, Washington Mutual, First Interstate Bank, and Harrah's Hotels and Casinos, where he managed projects, provided 24/7 support, and mentored other employees. He is self-motivated and able to work independently or as part of a team of any size.
This document summarizes trends in technology for cities and counties in 2013. It outlines the top "Ins" and "Outs" for general technology, technical areas, and areas of focus for city and county CIOs. Some key trends include a shift to cloud-based solutions, big data and predictive analytics, mobility, and consumerization of technology. Budgets are expected to increase most for overall IT department budgets and decrease most for staff training and travel budgets. CIOs need to manage expectations around new technologies and ensure their relevance through governance and professionalization of their roles.
Technology, Data Capture, & the Mechanical ContractorNathan C. Wood
There’s an ever increasing amount of data being collected on jobsites through the use of drones, laser scanning, and integrated Building Information Modeling (BIM). These tools provide innumerable data, but you need to know how to dissect that information in order to leverage it. This seminar will explore the different technologies available today, and how mechanical contractors are utilizing them to improve their bottom line. Prepare to learn different strategies for capturing and analyzing performance data across projects and identify struggling projects before they become a bigger issue. This seminar will conclude with a roundtable discussion about the current challenges with sharing data between the other project players like the General Contractor, Engineer, or Owner.
Examples of Modelling & Forecasting - Andrew Jamieson, Andrew HermannAndy Dunne
ARO Break Out Group 2 / Modelling & Forecasting - East of England Forecasting Model and West Midlands IPM. These presentations were given on Wednesday 27th January 2010.
Business Value of Agile Methods: Using ROI & Real OptionsDavid Rico
The document provides background on agile methods and their business value compared to traditional project management approaches. It discusses how agile methods can help address issues like cost overruns, defects, and project failures seen in many traditional projects. The document summarizes research showing that agile projects have significantly better outcomes in terms of costs, quality, and success rates compared to traditional approaches.
Speaking Danish in Japan: Good practice lessons to learn and emulate
(Morten Meyerhoff Nielsen – http://www.flickr.com/photos/40451858@N04/6993025986/in/pool-1909773@N24/)
Business Value of Agile Methods: Its Leadership ConsiderationsDavid Rico
Agile methods provide benefits over traditional approaches such as lower costs, fewer defects, and higher success rates. Studies show that agile projects have lower costs by 61% on average and 93% fewer defects. Agile adoption is widespread, with 80% of organizations using some agile practices. The number of certified scrum masters has doubled in two years, yet there remains a shortage of qualified agile practitioners. Agile is used successfully across many industries, including highly regulated domains.
C2ER 2009 - Data-Driven Responses to a Rapidly Changing Economychrisaberle
A presentation discussing various data and analysis tools and how they can be applied to address the broad range of issues facing communies in this challenging economy. We discuss how to define and evaluate various green projects, how to turn layoffs into opportunities for regional innovation, and how cluster analysis and business intelligence can be combined to create a powerful tool for identifying and supporting areas of entrepreneurial growth.
Digital Employee Experience Breakfast - 13th March SydneySquiz
A great digital employee experience provides many benefits such as improved productivity, higher employee retention rates and technology that adapts to each workforce. However, making this a reality is easier said than done.
This presentation covers:
How increasing employee digital literacy helps organisations to remain competitive, up skill their workforce for the future and incorporate new technologies into the organisation
The benefits of allowing employees to choose the way they work with technology, resulting in employee acquisition, satisfaction and retention
How the digital employee experience impacts the customer experience
The importance of a digital workplace to foster employee collaboration and engagement, make searching for people and files easy, while integrating with existing internal systems
1. The document discusses different definitions of fast growth firms and their implications. It finds that employment-based and productivity-based definitions capture different populations with different economic contributions.
2. It analyzes the regional and industry spillover effects of fast growth firms on other firms' employment growth and productivity growth. It finds both positive and negative externalities depending on the industry, region, and firm characteristics.
3. Geographic externalities, including the concentration of fast growth firms within postcodes and their "gravity force", mirror the findings for industry externalities - negative impacts on employment but positive impacts on productivity.
The Local-Mobile Opportunity: Presented by 15milesKatie Fellenz
The 3rd webinar in a series presented by Local Search experts, 15miles. Learn how-to take your business mobile and optimize your business for local search.
This document summarizes discussions from a workshop regarding the development of parcels D2 and D3 in Union Square, Somerville. The workshop addressed program, massing, and design principles. For program, a balanced mix of uses including jobs, housing, retail, and open space was proposed. Massing concepts explored stepping back taller portions from streets and the T station. Design principles focused on activating streets, carving out shared public spaces, and relating to the surrounding context.
Joseph D. Legris is a mechanical engineering student at Roger Williams University with a 3.54 GPA. He has experience in mechanical engineering projects including designing a medical device for pain distraction and an autonomous robot. He also has work experience in park maintenance and concrete construction. Currently, he is a research assistant designing a two degree of freedom system and presenting results at multiple conferences.
This document provides an overview of getting started in tech. It discusses how technology is disrupting many industries and creating demand for technical skills. Common first jobs in tech like front-end development, back-end development, and QA testing are outlined. The document also discusses career trajectories in tech and "coding plus" roles like product manager, growth hacker, and data scientist. Tips are provided on learning skills, building a portfolio, networking, and preparing for technical interviews to break into a tech career. Thinkful's coding bootcamp is presented as an option to gain skills through flexible mentorship-driven learning.
The document discusses an Internet of Everything (IoE) Value Index report for Mexico. Some key findings include:
- IoE is expected to create $14.4 trillion in global value from 2013-2022, with Mexico realizing $87.5 billion of that potential value in 2013.
- However, Mexico captured only around 52% of its potential IoE value in 2013, leaving $41 billion "on the table".
- The largest opportunities for capturing more IoE value in Mexico involve improving customer experience, supply chain/logistics efficiency, and innovation.
Eric Gries, CEO of Lucid Imagination, discusses the growth of the enterprise search market and the evolution of open source search tools Lucene and Solr. He introduces LucidWorks Enterprise, a commercial distribution of Solr that aims to make search easier to implement and scale through features like smart defaults, REST APIs, and integrated document updating. LucidWorks Enterprise is intended to provide the power of Solr with a well-organized package, more client libraries, and search innovations like click scoring, all at the lowest cost of scaling a search solution.
This document discusses smart analytics and big data. It begins by defining the 5 V's of big data: volume, velocity, variety, veracity, and value. It then discusses how analytics can provide competitive advantages for organizations and how the percentage of organizations realizing this advantage has increased significantly in recent years. The rest of the document discusses IBM's work in areas like smarter cities, smart service systems, and T-shaped professionals who have expertise across multiple domains. It provides examples of the large amounts of data being generated and concludes with a discussion of modeling holistic service systems at different levels from an individual to the entire planet.
What happened in Tech M&A during the first quarter of 2019? How has the rapid market recovery impacted valuations? Are private equity deals still soaring? Who are the new buyers making waves? Listen in as Corum Group gives the most in-depth look available at Q1 of 2019 for mergers and across all six technology sectors and 30 subsectors. Plus, we’ll get a special report on succession planning for tech company owners and executives, and a report from a special series of M&A conferences across Europe.
Gary Jones has over 40 years of experience developing and supporting mainframe applications. He has extensive experience in COBOL, CICS, DB2, JCL, and other mainframe technologies. His experience includes roles at JPMorgan Chase, Washington Mutual, First Interstate Bank, and Harrah's Hotels and Casinos, where he managed projects, provided 24/7 support, and mentored other employees. He is self-motivated and able to work independently or as part of a team of any size.
Similar to The effect of home owning on business development micro-level evidence bingbing wang-slides (20)
XP 2024 presentation: A New Look to Leadershipsamililja
Presentation slides from XP2024 conference, Bolzano IT. The slides describe a new view to leadership and combines it with anthro-complexity (aka cynefin).
This presentation by Professor Alex Robson, Deputy Chair of Australia’s Productivity Commission, was made during the discussion “Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations” held at the 77th meeting of the OECD Working Party No. 2 on Competition and Regulation on 10 June 2024. More papers and presentations on the topic can be found at oe.cd/crps.
This presentation was uploaded with the author’s consent.
This presentation, created by Syed Faiz ul Hassan, explores the profound influence of media on public perception and behavior. It delves into the evolution of media from oral traditions to modern digital and social media platforms. Key topics include the role of media in information propagation, socialization, crisis awareness, globalization, and education. The presentation also examines media influence through agenda setting, propaganda, and manipulative techniques used by advertisers and marketers. Furthermore, it highlights the impact of surveillance enabled by media technologies on personal behavior and preferences. Through this comprehensive overview, the presentation aims to shed light on how media shapes collective consciousness and public opinion.
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie WellsRosie Wells
Insight: In a landscape where traditional narrative structures are giving way to fragmented and non-linear forms of storytelling, there lies immense potential for creativity and exploration.
'Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity' is a micro report from Rosie Wells.
Rosie Wells is an Arts & Cultural Strategist uniquely positioned at the intersection of grassroots and mainstream storytelling.
Their work is focused on developing meaningful and lasting connections that can drive social change.
Please download this presentation to enjoy the hyperlinks!
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...Suzanne Lagerweij
This is a workshop about communication and collaboration. We will experience how we can analyze the reasons for resistance to change (exercise 1) and practice how to improve our conversation style and be more in control and effective in the way we communicate (exercise 2).
This session will use Dave Gray’s Empathy Mapping, Argyris’ Ladder of Inference and The Four Rs from Agile Conversations (Squirrel and Fredrick).
Abstract:
Let’s talk about powerful conversations! We all know how to lead a constructive conversation, right? Then why is it so difficult to have those conversations with people at work, especially those in powerful positions that show resistance to change?
Learning to control and direct conversations takes understanding and practice.
We can combine our innate empathy with our analytical skills to gain a deeper understanding of complex situations at work. Join this session to learn how to prepare for difficult conversations and how to improve our agile conversations in order to be more influential without power. We will use Dave Gray’s Empathy Mapping, Argyris’ Ladder of Inference and The Four Rs from Agile Conversations (Squirrel and Fredrick).
In the session you will experience how preparing and reflecting on your conversation can help you be more influential at work. You will learn how to communicate more effectively with the people needed to achieve positive change. You will leave with a self-revised version of a difficult conversation and a practical model to use when you get back to work.
Come learn more on how to become a real influencer!
This presentation by OECD, OECD Secretariat, was made during the discussion “Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations” held at the 77th meeting of the OECD Working Party No. 2 on Competition and Regulation on 10 June 2024. More papers and presentations on the topic can be found at oe.cd/crps.
This presentation was uploaded with the author’s consent.
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
The effect of home owning on business development micro-level evidence bingbing wang-slides
1. 1/52
The Effect of Home-owning on Business
Development: Micro-level Evidence
Bingbing Wang
Lusk Center of Real Estate, University of Southern California
01/04/2018
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
2. 2/52
Introduction
NIMBYism
Protesting Cases
Spring Valley residents in Las Vegas vs. the expansion of
an existing asphalt mixing plant;
Local residents vs. shopping centers in Lake Brandt North
Carolina for natural beauty preservation;
New York upper east side residents vs. subway entrances.
A material impact from home-owning on
business?
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
3. 3/52
Introduction: background
Home-owning impact on unemployment
Blanchflower and Oswald (2013); Oswald (1996 and 1997);
the aggregate and individual level studies (Goss and
Phillips 1997; Green, 2001; Genesove and Mayer, 2001;
Chan, 2001; Engelhardt, 2001; Coulson and Fisher, 2001
and 2009; Munch, 2006 and 2007; Mumford, 2013;
Valletta, 2013);
Mechanism: transaction cost, lock-in effect, job mismatch,
crowding out effect on renters and NIMBY effect.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
4. 4/52
Introduction: micro-level effect of home-owning
Home-owning negative spillovers on
neighboring business:
NIMBYism (Oswald, 2013)
Home-owning positive spillovers on
neighboring business:
1. Stable employees (Coulson and Fisher, 2002);
2. Better amenities (DiPasquale and Glaeser, 1998; Rohe,
Zandt and McCarthy, 2002; Dietz and Haurin, 2003);
3. YIMBYism: Yes, in my back yard (Stephens, 2017).
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
5. 5/52
Introduction
Three factors: distance, income, and
industry types
Identify and quantify the home-owning
spatial impact on neighboring business:
At what distance, for which neighborhoods, for what kind of
business, the net impact is positive or negative.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
6. 6/52
Framework
Producer function:
Max
q
πe = pqe − TCe
s.t. qe = f(K, L, M) TCe = vK + wL + r
Incorporating business location:
qe,i = f(K, Zi) TCe,i = vK + ZiPZi
e: establishment e
i: location i
Zi: attributes in location i including labor, land resources,
neighborhood amenity (population and income), tax policy
transportation access, CBD distance, agglomeration
PZi :land, labor, friction cost in location i
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
7. 7/52
Framework
Max
z
πi = p(f(K, Zi)) − Kv − PZi Zi (1)
Max
z
πi = p(f(Zi)) − PZi Zi (2)
Zi(labor stability) = fdistance(Owni)
Zi(neighborhood amenity) = fdistance,income(Owni)
PZi(friction cost) = fdistance,income,industry(Owni)
Max
Own
πi = Fdistance,income,industry(Owni) (3)
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
8. 8/52
Framework: with respect to distance
Max
z
πi = p(f(Zi)) − PZi Zi (2)
∂π
∂D
= p
∂f
∂Z
∂Z
∂D
−
∂PZ
∂D
Z − PZ
∂Z
∂D
(4)
Preferred and nuisance creating:
S1 :
∂f
∂Z
> 0 and PZ > 0
Preferred and not nuisance creating:
S2 :
∂f
∂Z
> 0 and PZ = 0
Not preferred:
S3 :
∂f
∂Z
< 0
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
9. 9/52
Framework: with respect to distance
∂π
∂D
= p
∂f
∂Z
∂Z
∂D
−
∂PZ
∂D
Z − PZ
∂Z
∂D
(4)
NIMBY distance Da :
If D < Da,
∂Pz
∂D
< 0 and PZ > 0
If D >= Da, PZ = 0
Positive spillover distance D0 :
If Da < D < D0,
∂Z
∂D
= 0 and PZ = 0
If D >= D0,
∂Z
∂D
< 0 and PZ = 0
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
10. 10/52
Predictions: distance
∂π
∂D
= p
∂f
∂Z
∂Z
∂D
−
∂PZ
∂D
Z − PZ
∂Z
∂D
(4)
S1 :
If D = 0, PZ = +∞ and π < 0
If 0 < D < Da,
∂π
∂D
> 0
If Da <= D <= D0,
∂π
∂D
= 0 and π(Da) = π(D0) > 0
If D >= D0,
∂π
∂D
< 0 and π > 0
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
14. 14/52
Predictions
1: Home-owning increases the job counts of preferred
business for low income neighborhoods for all distances.
2: Home-owning reduces the job counts of the preferred
but nuisance creating business located at adjacent
distances for high income neighborhoods.
3: Home-owning increases the job counts of preferred
business located at close but not adjacent distances for
high income neighborhoods.
4: Home-owning decreases the job counts of not preferred
business at all distances for both income groups.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
20. 20/52
Methodology: alternative mechanisms
Transportation access:
FE: cluster
Agglomeration:
Employee population density and education
Local policies (tax policy):
CBSA FE
Common economic and local factors:
Space and time FE
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
22. 22/52
Methodology: IV
Instrument: 1) the Federal Housing Administration (FHA)
loan limit of the county where the donut ring resides
divided by the median house price of the donut ring; 2) the
ratio of families with children under 18.
log(JobCountj,t) =α + βOwnj,i,t + Controlsj,i,t + j,t
j: cluster j
i: donut ring i (.3, .3-1, 1-2, 2-3, 3-5, 5-10)
Crosscheck with OLS, FE and FD
Lagged home-ownership rates with OLS, FE, FD and IV
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
23. 23/52
Data
Job counts and employee controls (education)
Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics (LEHD)
Origin-Destination Employment Statistics (LODES) Work
Area Characteristics (WAC): 2009-2014
Ownership rates and residential controls (population,
education, income)
American Community Survey (ACS): 2009-2014
Latitude, longitude and CBSA codes
2010 Decennial Census geocodes
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
24. 24/52
Data: K-means clustering method
arg min
k
i=1 X∈Si
||X − µi||2
Wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-means_clustering
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
27. 27/52
Job clusters
217,778 block groups in 2011/50,138 are job block groups
10,000 job clusters in the U.S.
1) The number of block groups for each cluster varies from
1 to 38 and averages at 5.0138 and the median is 4.
2) The job cluster average land area is 31.79 square miles
with an average radius of 2.008 miles.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
28. 28/52
Cluster and donut rings
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
29. 29/52
Data: summary statistics
Residential features: home-ownership rates
Blkgp .3 .3-1 1-2 2-3 3-5 5-10
Own .6536 .6323 .6529 .6666 .6735 .6845 .6916
(.26) (.20) (.18) (.17) (.16) (.15) (.13)
Obs 1,069,231 54,643 51,790 53,991 53,993 57,168 58,896
Table: Resident characteristics descriptive statistics. Standard errors of the means are
in the parenthesis. The unit is mile. The data is from ACS from 2009 to 2014.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
30. 30/52
Data: summary statistics
Residential features: home-ownership rate change
Blkgp .3 .3-1 1-2 2-3 3-5 5-10
∆ Own -.0059 -.0066 -.0067 -.0063 -.0058 -.0054 -.0048
(.07) (.05) (.05) (.04) (.04) (.03) (.02)
Obs 1,069,231 54,643 51,790 53,991 53,993 57,168 58,896
Table: Resident characteristics descriptive statistics. Standard errors of the means are
in the parenthesis. The unit is mile. The data is from ACS from 2009 to 2014.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
31. 31/52
Data: summary statistics
Job features: the job count
Blkgp Ratio Cluster Ratio
Pooled 661 8859
Downtown 2685 .0089 17255 .2550
Suburbs 616 .9110 7592 .7450
High 604 .3980 11394 .5940
Low 698 .6020 6656 .4060
Downtown high 3435 .0225 20353 .1582
Downtown low 2442 .0654 13814 .0976
Suburban high 575 .3753 9826 .4359
Suburban low 643 .5368 5721 .3083
Obs 1070442 59772
Table: Work characteristics descriptive statistics. The data is from LEHD LODES WAC
from 2009 to 2014.Downtown is defined as the block groups adjacent to the CBD, the
total population of which are no more than 5% of the CBSA population. The high
income group is categorized as the block groups with higher median income than the
average median income of the block groups.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
32. 32/52
Data: summary statistics
Job features: job count change
Blkgp Growth Cluster Growth US
Pooled -35 -.0530 569 .0642 .0162
Downtown -253 -.0942 991 .0574
Suburbs -30 -.0487 505 .0665
High -28 -.0464 754 .0662
Low -40 -.0573 398 .0598
Downtown high -244 -.0710 1178 .0579
Downtown low -243 - .0995 773 .0560
Suburban high -26 -.0452 681 .0693
Suburban low -34 -.0529 348 .0608
Obs 1070442 59772
Table: Work characteristics descriptive statistics. The data is from LEHD LODES WAC
from 2009 to 2014 and the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
33. 33/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
.3 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own -.0319 -.1291 -.1187 -.0281 -.0592 -.0570
Std (.0097) (.0521) (.0536) (.0097) (.0284) (.0270)
P .0011 .0132 .0267 .0036 .0375 .0353
Obs 46498 44370 35483 45303 43253 34366
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. The interpretation of the coefficient (.1291) for
within .3 miles for Column (2) is that if ownership rate increase by 1%, then job counts
increase by 12.91%. So if ownership rate increases from 65% to 66%, then job counts
might increase from 1000 to 1012.91. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
34. 34/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
.3-1 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own -.0253 .0775 .0820 -.0327 -.0170 -.0039
Std (.0113) (.0552) (.0657) (.0117) (.0230) (.0258)
P .0255 .1714 .2117 .0053 .4603 .8656
Obs 44013 44012 33749 42971 42970 34156
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
35. 35/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
1-2 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own -.0256 -.0266 -.0588 -.0253 .0102 .0190
Std (.0128) (.0641) (.0690) (.0132) (.0304) (.0302)
P .0454 .6780 .3941 .0547 .7373 .5282
Obs 45666 45665 34887 44835 44834 35690
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
36. 36/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
2-3 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own .0166 -.1722 -.2062 -.0086 .0001 .0586
Std (.0148) (.0674) (.0759) (.0146) (.0288) (.0295)
P .2640 .0106 .0066 .5563 .9984 .0475
Obs 45614 45613 34890 44841 44842 34179
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
37. 37/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
3-5 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own -.0053 -.2247 -.1891 .0035 .1409 .1107
Std (.0172) (.1002) (.0981) (.0174) (.0450) (.0451)
P .7588 .0249 .0540 .8387 .0018 .0142
Obs 48103 48102 36651 47505 45285 36106
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
38. 38/52
Pooled sample result: cluster with distance
5-10 OLS FE FD OLSL FEL FDL
Own .0303 .0966 .0552 .0260 -.0374 -.0083
Std (.0215) (.1855) (.1702) (.0218) (.0709) (.0562)
P .1590 .6023 .7457 .2321 .5977 .8824
Obs 49275 49273 37519 48940 48939 39070
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. Controls include lagged job
counts, residential population, employee education, employee population density,
residential median income, educational levels, ownership rates of other rings, distance
to CBD, cbsa and year fixed effects. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level
and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
39. 39/52
IV for .3, 2-3 and 3-5
.3 FHA First Stage Exogenous IV IVlag
Own .0745 -.0060 -.1086 -.1297
Std (.0047) (.0040) (.0524) (.0566)
P .0000 .1390 .0380 .0220
Obs 35519 35519 37211 37215
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. The instrument is the FHA loan
limit divided by the median house price. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster
level and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
40. 40/52
IV for .3, 2-3 and 3-5
2-3 FHA First Stage Exogenous
Own .0968 -.0096
Std (.0035) (.0044)
P .0000 .0301
Obs 34931 34931
3-5 FHA
Own -.1596 -.0156
Std (.0499) (.0050)
P .0014 .0019
Obs 36712 35519
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. The instrument is the FHA loan
limit divided by the median house price. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster
level and are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
41. 41/52
IV for .3, 2-3 and 3-5
2-3 Child First Stage Exogenous IV
Own .2621 .0189 .0495
Std (.0130) (.0131) (.0470)
P .0000 .1489 .2918
Obs 34944 34944 34944
3-5 Child First Stage Exogenous IV IVlag
Own .2618 .0253 .0832 .1462
Std (.0145) (.0187) (.0660) (.0780)
P .0000 .1773 .2078 .0608
Obs 36716 36716 36716 36716
Table: The dependent variable is the log of job counts. The instrument is the ratio of
families with children under 18. Standard errors are clustered at the cluster level and
are in parentheses. *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
42. 42/52
Result: pooled sample and different income groups
Pooled .3 .3-1 1-2 2-3 3-5 5-10
Own -
OwnLag - +
Income .3 .3-1 1-2 2-3 3-5 5-10
Own -high
OwnLag +low +low
Table: The results for different income groups are from the FE specification and are
consistent across other specifications.
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
43. 43/52
Result: .3-1 from high income groups
.3-1 >55 >60 >65 >70 >75
Own -.1191 -.1244 -.1373 -.1045 -.0807
Std (.0737) (.0740) (.0823) (.0926) (.1011)
P .1062 .0930 .0952 .2590 .4248
Obs 17358 15578 13474 11165 9327
.3-1 >80 >85 >90 >95
Own -.1792 -.2125 -.5416 -.6165
Std (.1164) (.1430) (.1767) (.2725)
P .1239 .1376 .0022 .0242
Obs 7242 5018 3174 1300
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
44. 44/52
Result: .3 of lagged ownership rates from low income
groups
.3 <5 <10 <15 <20 <25
Own .2060 .1962 .1241 .0547 .0516
Std (.2045) (.0870) (.0725) (.0611) (.0561)
P .3143 .0244 .0870 .3707 .3580
Obs 1284 3162 5083 7345 9564
.3 <30 <35 <40 <45 <50
Own .0149 -.0171 -.0182 -.0131 -.0293
Std (.0517) (.0469) (.0416) (.0410) (.0371)
P .7736 .7157 .6616 .7485 4292
Obs 11414 13849 16043 17805 21212
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
45. 45/52
Result: 3-5 of lagged ownership rates from low income
groups
3-5 <5 <10 <15 <20 <25
Own .2852 .1821 .1576 .3042 .2443
Std (.3543) (.1539) (.1228) (.1134) (.0990)
P .4215 .2371 .1996 .0074 .0137
Obs 1244 3023 4860 6975 9048
3-5 <30 <35 <40 <45 <50
Own .2430 .2296 .2086 .1938 .1622
Std (.0992) (.0889) (.0832) (.0757) (.0719)
P .0143 .0099 .0122 .0105 .0241
Obs 10832 13153 15210 16974 20224
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
46. 46/52
Summary statistics: industry
NAICS Max Max Location
Total 467929 -
NAICS sector 11 (Agriculture, Forestry,
Fishing and Hunting)
11322 North CA
NAICS sector 21 (Mining, Quarrying,
and Oil and Gas Extraction)
17320 Houston downtown
NAICS sector 22 (Utilities) 11712 LA downtown
NAICS sector 23 (Construction) 12023 Vegas
NAICS sector 31-33 (Manufacturing) 33260 Seattle (Boeing)
NAICS sector 42 (Wholesale Trade) 26227 NYC Manhattan
NAICS sector 44-45 (Retail Trade) 18221 New York
NAICS sector 48-49 (Transportation and
Warehousing)
52392 NYC (JFK airport)
NAICS sector 51 (Information) 47206
Seattle (Microsoft
headquarters)
NAICS sector 52 (Finance and
Insurance)
75889 NYC Manhattan
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
47. 47/52
Summary statistics: industry
NAICS Max Max Location
Total 467929 -
NAICS sector 53 (Real Estate and Rental and
Leasing)
15293 NYC Manhattan
NAICS sector 54 (Professional, Scientific, and
Technical Services)
73292 Chicago
NAICS sector 55 (Management of Companies
and Enterprises)
13630
Arkansas (Walmart home
office)
NAICS sector 56 (Administrative and Support
and Waste Management and Remediation
Services)
26435 Chicago
NAICS sector 61 (Educational Services) 173587 NYC Manhattan (NYU)
NAICS sector 62 (Health Care and Social
Assistance)
54194
Houston (Texas Medical
Center)
NAICS sector 71 (Arts, Entertainment, and
Recreation)
41671 Orlando Disney
NAICS sector 72 (Accommodation and Food
Services)
91530 Vegas
NAICS sector 81 (Other Services [except Public
Administration])
23551 Seattle downtown
NAICS sector 92 (Public Administration) 90563 NYC Lower Manhattan
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
48. 48/52
Summary statistics: industry
Agricultural: North CA Oil: Houston Utility: LA Construction: Vegas
Manufacturing: Seattle Wholesale Trade: NYC Retail Trade: NYC Transportation: JFK
Information: Seattle Finance & Insurance: NYC Real Estate: NYC Professional service: Chicago
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
49. 49/52
Summary statistics: industry
Management of
companies: Arkansas
Admin and support:
Chicago
Educational service:
NYC
Health care: Houston
Arts and entertain:
Orlando
Accommodation and
food: Vegas
Other service: Seattle Public admin: NYC
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
50. 50/52
Result: industry
Positive
Lower Income Higher Income
Manufacturing (+:1-2) Retail Trade (-: .3/+: 3-5)
Real Estate and Car Rental and
Leasing (+:1-2) Arts, Entertainment (+:.3)
Information (+:.3;+: .3-1) Public Administration (+: .3; -: 5-10)
Accommodation and Food Services
(+:.3-1;-: 3-5)
Professional, Scientific, and Technical
Services (-: .3/+: 3-5)
Administrative and Support and Waste
(+: .3-1; -: 2-3)
Negative
Lower Income Higher Income
Management of Companies (3-5) Manufacturing (.3-1)
Wholesale Trade (.3)
Real Estate and Rental and Leasing
(.3; 2-3; 5-10)
Other Services [except Public
Administration] (.3-1; 5-10) Wholesale Trade (.3)
Retail Trade (2-3)
Management of Companies (.3; .3-1;
2-3)
Arts, Entertainment (3-5) Finance and Insurance (.3; 1-2)
Public Administration (.3; 1-2: 3-10) Educational Services (.3; 5-10)
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
51. 51/52
Conclusion
Comfortable distance: 3-5 miles
Friction distance: adjacent distance of .3 or
.3-1 miles from high income groups
The combination of neighborhoods and
industries
High income with service industries like Art and Retail
Low income with job generating industries like
Manufacturing and Real Estate and Car Rental and
Leasing
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro
52. 52/52
Q and A
Thank you!
bingbinw@usc.edu;
bingbingwang123@gmail.com
Bingbing Wang The Effect of Home-owning on Business Development: Micro