2. âFeatured Scientistsâ
James Valentine
Simon Conway-Morris
Paul Chien
Jonathan Wells
Richard Sternberg
Douglas Axe
Paul Nelson
Stephen Meyer
3. CHARLES DARWIN
âConsequently, if my theory be true, it is
indisputable that before the lowest Silurian
stratum was deposited, long periods
elapsed, as long as, or probably far longer
than, the whole interval from the Silurian
age to the present day; and that during
these vast, yet quite unknown periods of
time, the world swarmed with living
creatures. To the question why we do not
ďŹnd records of these vast primordial
periods, I can give no satisfactory answer.â
5. DUANE T. GISH (1974)
âIn the Cambrian geological strata there occurs a sudden, great
outburst of fossils of animals on a highly developed level of
complexity. In the Cambrian rocks are found billions of fossils of
animals so complex that the evolutionists estimate they would have
required one and a half billion years to evolve. Trilobites, brachiopods,
sponges, corals, jellyďŹsh, in fact every one of the major invertebrate
forms of life are found in the Cambrian. What is found in rocks
supposedly older than the Cambrian, that is in the so-called pre-
Cambrian rocks? Not a single indisputable fossil! Certainly it can be
said without fear of contradiction, the evolutionary predecessors of
the Cambrian fauna have never been found.â
6. PANDAS AND PEOPLE
â[S]ome organisms appear with
adaptational packages intact at the
Cambrian boundary where multicellular
life ďŹrst âďŹowers,â with no evidence
whatsoever of fossil ancestors⌠only an
intelligent designer has the ability to
coordinate the design requirements of
multifunctional adaptational
packages.â (71-72)
40. ⢠Noice-caps, deserted land
masses
⢠Oxygen at 63% of modern,
carbon dioxide at ~16 times
pre-industrial levels
⢠Surface
temperature at 7
degrees C above present
⢠Sealevel at 30 - 90m above
present
⢠Warm shallow seas at
continental edges
⢠Presence of lagerstätten
46. MICHAEL DENTON
âAn irreducible gap in phenotypic space
[i.e. morphology] cannot be taken to
imply that there is a similar gap in
genotypic space [i.e. genetics].â
47.
48.
49. SOME KEY IDEAS
Cambrian Explosion â the geologically sudden appearance of many of
the Metazoan phyla.
Metazoan â multicellular organisms
50. PHYLUM
Morphological branch of the tree of life
Group of organisms sharing a âmajor body planâ
Number of extant phyla differ depending on source, but generally
taken to be in the low to mid thirties.
Therefore, we should be careful of âessentializingâ them.
56. FOUR QUESTIONS
1. Was there a Pre-Cambrian fauna?
2. What (if anything) happened in the Cambrian?
3. Is the âexplosionâ a real event or an artifact of preservation?
4. How did it happen?
58. RICHARD DAWKINS
âEvolution makes the strong
prediction that if a single fossil turned
up in the wrong geological stratum,
the theory would be blown out of
the water. When challenged by a
zealous Popperian to say how
evolution could ever be falsiďŹed, J.B.S.
Haldane famously growled: 'Fossil
rabbits in the Precambrian.â No such
anachronistic fossils have ever been
authentically found...â
117. JONATHAN WELLS
âWhy donât textbooks discuss the Cambrian
explosion, in which all major animal groups
appear together in the fossil record fully formed
instead of branching from a common ancestor â
thus contradicting the evolutionary tree of life?â
Reply: Fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and
mammals all are post-Cambrian - arenât these
âmajor groupsâ?
Wells: âFish DID make their ďŹrst appearance in
the Cambrian explosion.â
118. âHere we describe a recently discovered craniate-like
chordate, Haikouella lanceolata, ⌠These ďŹndings indicate that
Haikouella probably represents a very early craniate-like
chordate that lived near the beginning of the Cambrian
periodâ
Jun-Yuan Chen, Di-Ying Huang and Chia-Wei Li, âAn early Cambrian craniate-
like chordate,â Nature 402 (1999), 518-522.
126. âThe Cambrian explosion gave rise to
most of the animal phyla alive today, as
well as some that are now extinct.â (p. 39).
Chart gives 18 âmajor living animal phylaâ
âOne phylum (the sponges) and possibly
two others appeared just before the
Cambria; two worm phyla appeared much
later, in the Carboniferous ⌠and one
[phylum] in the Ordovician.â
Therefore, claim is that 12 of 18 (66%)
phyla appeared in the Cambrian
127.
128. Placozoa
Mesozoa
Platyhelminthes
Extant Phyla without Gnathostomulida
a fossil record Gastrotricha
Acantochephala
12 of 34 Loricifera
Kinorhyncha
35% Pogonophora
Sipuncula
Phoronida
Urochordata
141. STEPHEN MEYER
âIf you can preserve [a pre-Cambrian] embryo, you can preserve an
animal. If those animals were there, we should have found them. And
theyâre not there.â
But:
⢠Special conditions required for preservation
⢠We havenât found pre-Cambrian adult sponges but they must
have existed
⢠Pre-Cambrian specimens create a problem for the âexplosionâ!
142. EXPERIMENTAL TAPHONOMY
âUnder conditions that prevent
autolysis, embryos within the fertilization
envelope can be preserved with good
morphology for sufďŹciently long periods
for mineralization to occur. ... Although
embryos within the fertilization
envelope have high preservation
potential, primary larvae have negligible
preservation potential. Thus the paleo-
embryological record may have strong
biases on developmental stages
preserved.â
Raff EC, Villinski JT, Turner FR, Donoghu PCJ, Raff RA (2006) Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 103(15):5846-5851.
145. CONCLUSION FROM
THE FOSSIL DATA
Metazoans certainly originated signiďŹcantly earlier than 570my.
A date of 700my would not conďŹict with the evidence
currently to hand.
We thus see an approximately 170 million year period for the
evolution of the Cambrian fauna.
A exponential increase in diversity occurs in the Cambrian
(Valentine et al, 1999, Development 126: 851)
146. WHAT ABOUT
GENETIC DATA?
âThe basal animal phyla (Porifera,
Ctenophora and Cnidaria) diverged
between about 1200 â 1500 MYA.
This suggests that at least six animal
phyla originated deep in the
Precambrian, more than 400 million
years earlier than their ďŹrst
appearance in the fossil record.â
147. OTHER ESTIMATES
⢠Bromham et al.(1998): 1,500 mybp
Meyer gives this as 680 my
⢠Ayala, Rzhetsky
& Ayala (1998): 670 mybp for Protostome /
Deuterostome split
Still 130my before the start of the Cambrian
148. REVIEW IN 2005
â[M]olecular data analyzed over the past 3 decades have
found deeper divergences among animals (~800 to 1,200
MYA), with and without the assumption of a global molecular
clock. Recently, two studies have instead reported time
estimates apparently consistent with the fossil record. Here,
we demonstrate that methodological problems in these
studies cast doubt on the accuracy and interpretations of the
results obtained. ... With these results aside, molecular clocks
continue to support a long period of animal evolution before
the Cambrian explosion of fossils.â
149. THREE POINTS
WORTH REMEMBERING
⢠Majorbranches on the Tree of Life (e.g. fungi, bacteria and
other groups) actually pre-date the Cambrian.
⢠All
plants post-date the Cambrian, and ďŹowering plants, by far
the dominant form of land life today, only appeared about 140
mya
⢠None of the animal groups that people think of as major
taxonomic groups, such as mammals, reptiles, birds, or insects,
appeared in the Cambrian.
160. OUR FIVE QUESTIONS
Was there a Pre-Cambrian fauna?
Yes â including multicellular ancestors of Cambrian forms.
What happened in the Cambrian?
A geologically rapid morphological diversiďŹcation
Is the explosion real?
Yes, but it was phenotypic rather than genotypic.
How did it happen?
167. HOW DID IT HAPPEN?
Environmental changes
Opening of new niches
Development of predator/prey systems
Development of visual systems
Ecological feedback
Activation of genetic pathways (see next
week)
Editor's Notes
BAD PEDAGOGY!!!!!
No time scale
No relationships between groups
No names of groups
Pre-cambrian record?
HALDANE
1. Precambrian forms
2. Disparity and Diversity rise together
