SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
INDIVIDUAL STUDIES
BY PARTICIPANTS AT THE
. INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF SEISMOLOGY
AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING
Vol. 16
October 1980
Interna tional Institute
of Seismology and Earthquake Engineering
Building Research Institute, Ministry of Construction
1 To t eho ro , Oha-machi. Tsukuba-gun,
IBARAlO PREFECTURE, J APAN
ELASTO - PLASTIC FOUNDATION
by
Fabian Ed. CEVALLOS larco
(For the Earthquake Engineering Course, 1979-1980)
ABSTRACT
This paper is an effort in analyzing the response of s
mall buildings having an elasto-plastic behavior. It's founded
that a relationship between the ratio building-stiffness/founda
tion-stiffness and the maximum shear force acting on the build
ing exists.
Some devices for obtaining the elasto-plastic behavior
are proposed and it suggests the possibility of designing the
appropriate device for the kind of earthquake expected.
1.- INTRODUCTION
Since the begining of the earthquake engineering subje
ct, the attitude of the researchers was pointed out in two ways;
the first one, how to design a building strong enough to resist
the earthquake shock and the second one, how to avoid or decre
ase the earthquake imput. Nowdays, the first field got a huge
development, but the second is still growing up. This study is
involved in the second area, where one of the solutions is an
elasto-plastic foundation.
In 1960ths. Dr Matsushita and Dr. Izumi presented so
me devices for decreasing the earthquake imput, all of them sho
wn a non-linear relationship between a restoring force and the
displacement (f). In 1974 they presented to the Fifth World Can
ference on Earthquake Engineering some devices for tall buildi
ngs
Private Consultant, calle Alemania 0381 Quito - ECUADOR
** Tokyo University Professor and Research Engineer of Inter
national Institute of Seismology and Earth. Eng. (Japan/74)
-205-
ructed with foundation devices able to decrease the imput acc~
lerations caused by earthquakes, and a few years ago a nuclear
power plant is projected by Koeberg S.A. in Africa with an el
as to-plastic foundation system composed by rubber and sleek s
;,
teel (3).
2.- MODEL USED
In order to pointed out the possible relationship bet
ween the variables involved in the problem, a two degree of
freedom system model was used (figure 1).
In the model; the mass number one, m
l
, represents the
first story and the foundation device; the stiffness number 0
ne, k
l
, is the stiffness of the device which transmit the gro
und movement to the structure and has an elasto-plastic behav
ior; the mass number two, m
2
, is the building's mass and the
stiffness number two, k2' is the stiffness of the building.
The ground motion exitation was imput to the model by
the accelerograms of three earthquakes: San Fernando earthqua
ke (recorded in Pacoima dam, S - 74W component), El Centro (N-
S component) and Miyagi-oki earthquake (recorded in the basem
ent number two of the Sumitomo Bank Building, E - W component).
The analysis was carried out in a digital computer, b~
sically using a program already performed by Dr. Yamazaki for
a non-linear systems.
3.- DAMPING FOUNDATION DEVICES
Some systems were analyzed before one was chosen as th
e most appropriate, but they could be divided in the following
groups:
3.1.- Hanging type:
Fundamentally, this one consists of hanging the struc_
ture so that it could work as a pendulum (figure 2), from the
physical pOint of view, the stiffness (k
l
) of the device is gi
ven by the formula:
• Research Engineer of I.I.S.E.E. (1980)
-206-
r
k1 = _-=-P_...:.x'--_E=---__
s Ln «, r x L
t
Where:
k = stiffness value of the device; other words, restoring force
1
divided by deformation.
P = weight of the structure
~= angle between the cable and the horizontal plane
E = Young's modulus
~ = allowable stress in the cable
t
L = length of the cable
where,
In the practical field if steel is used, for example,
2 r.- 2
E= 2100000 kg/ cm, U = 1400 kg/ cm , 0< = 900
(in the mo
t
st favorable case) and L= 100 cm.; kl becomes 15 x P, this is a
high value for kl because instead of decrease the imput it will
work as an amplifier.
3.2.- Sledding type:
Mainly this type consists of defining one level of imp
ut force by the friction angle between the building and the ear
th (figure 3). Nevertheless the behavior of this model is inte
resting, the analysis by computer is difficult.
3.3.- Floating type:
The idea in this type is floating the building in a me
dium where some frequencies could be missed and a medium with
big values of damping ratio will decrease the imput values hig~
ly. From the practical point of view, the floating medium to be
used could be soft soil and some researchers had pointed out th
,',
is fact (4). Therefore the problem to be analized in this type
belongs to the soil-structure interaction.
3.4.- Rolling type:
Basically this type involves rolls, balls or lenses 10
cated between the earth and the foundation (figure 4), with the
characteristic that the shape and the size of the lenses or ba
lIs gave different behavior to the whole structure by providing
the wished foundation's stiffness.
-207-
Some devices and the kl value formula are listed below:
W
k
l
=-----
Z(R-r)
Where:
W= weight of the building
R,r,e,a showed in graphs above.
3.5.- Mixed type:
The combination of two of the types mentioned before
generates the mixed type and this one seems to be the most sui
table to solve the problem. The nuclear power plant projected
in Africa includes a floating-sledding type (figure 5). And t~
is study is related to this type, where the foundation behavi
or is elasto-plastic.
4.- VARIABLES CHOSEN
A floating-sledding type was selected because it is po
ssible for construction. For that purpose a slab foundation mu
st. be done, and over that the lenses will be located and over
the lenses a steell plate with lubricant, then the foundation
of the building will be placed (figure 6).
Since the variables involved in the problem are eight:
stiffness of the device (k
l
), stiffness of the building (k
2
),
mass of the foundation (m
l
), mass of the building (m
Z
)' damping
ratio of the foundation (hI)' damping ratio of the building
(h
2
), sledding level of the foundation or yeilding point of th
e foundation (Q ) and imput accelerations (x); some of them m u
y
st be fixed for the analysis. Therefore a three stories build
ing was considered, in order to avoid the influence of the roc
,I~
king problem (5), with a hundred square meter per floor. The
foundation weight was included in the first floor. In this ma
nner the upper stories weight was rounded in 300 tons.
By keeping the period of the building between 0.2 to
-208-
0.3 seconds the stiffness of the building is in the range betwe
en 150 to 300 tn/ern. The damping ratio of the building was fix
ed in 0.02, considered as the worse case, and fa r the foundati
on it was fixed in 0.001 to assure tha t the only way where the
energy will dissipate in the foundation is throught the pla~
tic deformation beyond the sleeding level. Due to this cons ide
rations, the variables
m 2 ' k2' hI and h2 were fixed. The varia
bles k
l
, m
l
, Q
y
and x were the values used as parameters.
The stiffness of the foundation, k
l
, w a s varying from
the 10% to 80% of the building's stiffness in the following ran
ge:
Name k2 kl ratio Name k2 kl ratio
ROLING 0 150 20 0.13 ROLLING7 2S0 40 0.16
ROLLING 150 40 0.26 ROLLINGS 250 SO 0.32
ROLLING2 150 SO 0.53 ROLLING9 250 120 0.4S
ROLING2A 150 100 0.66 ROLING9A 250 160 0.64
ROLLING3 150 120 0.80 ROLING9B 250 200 0.80
ROLING3A 200 20 0.10 ROLLINGO 300 40 0.13
ROLLING4 200 40 0.20 ROLLINGA 300 80 0.26
ROLLINGS 200 80 0.40 ROLLINGB 300 120 0.40
ROLLING6 200 120 0.60 ROLINGBI 300 180 0.60
ROLING6A 200 160 0.80 ROLINGB2 300 240 0.80
The stiffness of the foundation, k ,
1
are varying mean
while the stiffness of the building is fixed due to the fact
there is more uncertainties about the behavior of the device than
the behavior of the building.
The weight of the foundation was defined by three valu
e s : 50, 100 and 150 tons, in other words, one sixth, one third
and one half of the building weight.
The yeilding point of the foundation (where the plastic
range start) was defined by three values: 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 of
the whole weight over the damping devices.
The maximum imput acceleration given by the three eart~
quakes mentioned before, was adjusted to reach three levels 350
-209-
700 and 1400 gals.
Therefore, the total number, N, of cases analyzed is gi
ven by:
N= earthquakes x imput levels x building stiffness x foun
dation stiffness x building's damping ratio x foundati
on's damping ratio x yeilding point values x building
's masses x foundation's masses.
N= 3 x 3 x 4 x 5 x I x 1 x 3 x 1 x 3 1620 cases
The output requested to the computer was the following
values: maximum shear coefficient for the building (SCMAX), ma~
imum absolute displacement of the foundation (with respect to
the earth, ABMAX), frequency for the first mode (OME) and the
maximum acceleration imput to the first story (ACMAX).
5.- RESULTS
The results of the computation are shown in the Table 1
and they are listed in the annex number 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. Where
the first column is the value of ACHAX, the second column is
SCMAX, the third column is ABMAX, the fourth is the earthquake
name, the fifth is the maximum acceleration of the earthquake,
the sixth is the type of the building structure and the seventh
is OME's value.
To visualize the relationship between the variables, a
computer program was performed to draw the following graphs:
Ordinate (Y) vs. Abscissa (X)
- maximum shear coefficient vs. stiffness ratio
- maximum .absolute displacement vs. stiffness ratio
- maximum shear coefficient vs. frequency
- maximum acceleration of the first story vs. frequency
The typical graphs obtained are shown in the figure 7
in the annex number 6, where each line represents the same bui!
ding (fixed the stiffness, k2' of the building) with different
kinds of foundation devices (varying the stiffness, k
l
, of the
foundation). Therefore, each cartesian coordinates contains 20
points and 324 graphs were plotted for the analysis.
-210-
6.- CONCLUSIONS
The analysis of the graphs pointec out the following
fdctS:
- the shear coefficient to be applied to the building keeps a
relationship with foundation's stiffness/building's stiffness
ratio, in other form: if the ratio increases, the shear coeffi
cient increases.
- the maximum absolute displacement increases for stiffness ra
tio values below some level.
- for the same conditions, the shear coefficient increases when
the mass ratio ml/m
Z
(foundation's mass/ buildine's mass) also
increases.
- for big earthquakes, the maximum absolute displacement of the
foundation is almost directly proportional to the yeilding poi
nt Q of the elasto-plastic device; then, it is proportional to
y
the frictional angle between the structure and the earth.
- in the case of big earthquakes analyzed (1400 gals) the maxi
mum shear coefficient obtained is independent of the earthquake
imput, but depend on the yeilding point Q of the elasto-plas
y
tic foundation device.
- there is some value of the stiffness ratio where the absolute
displacement and the shear coefficient are in a reasonable valu
es for each kind of earthquake analyzed.
7.- ADVANTAGES
Special buildings, for example, for computer systems or
military purposes, could be constructed with a great safety fa~
tor using an elasto-plastic foundation; even near to the faults
where the accelerations got unexpected values.
After the structural design of the building, the stiff
ness value of the structure must be computed, with this value
the appropriate stiffness of the foundation could be defined
and designed using the formula (a) of the section three.
8.- LIMITATIONS
- the small earthquakes amplified by a factor do not show the
-211-
same characteristics as the big ones. For that analysis another
kind of simulated earthquakes must be applied, for instance, th
e synthetic earthquakes obtained by the multiple source method.
- after the earthquake jacks will be used to return the struc
ture to the original po~ition.
- water, sanitary and gas installations must be provided with a
flexible joint to out-side of the building.
9.- SUGGESTIONS
- a floating-sledding type using clay and sand could be develo
ped, for that purpose some tests will be carried out to analyze
the real behavior of this system.
- a computer program must be developed to analyze the pure sled
ding type.
- using the results showed in the table 1, a formula could be ob
tained to establish the relationship between the variables.
REF ERE N C E S
(£) MATSUSHITA and IZUMI et al. "Study about the process to red!:!.
ce the seismic force on the buildings"; Transaction of the
Architectural Institute of Japan, Vol. N° 122, April-1966
pp. 15-22
,',
(2) MATSUSHITA and IZUHI. "Application of input controlling me_.
chanism to the structural design of a tall building"; Proce
edings of the Fifth W.C.E.E. Rome-1974, Vol. N° 2 pp. 2948-
2955.
(~) KOEBERG S.A. Mr. Marc Richli, Spie-Batignolle Paris
(4) BYCROFT "Soil-structure interaction at higher frequency fac
tor"; Abstract journal in earthquake engineering, Vol. N° 7
Dec-1978. Section soil-structure interaction 0.8 - 9 pp.l69
1,
(5) OSAWA, KITAGAhlA and IRIE. "Evaluation of various parameters
on response analysis of earthquake motions, including soil-
building system"; Proceedings of the Sixth W.C.E.E., Vol. 2
New Delhi - 1977, pp. 1461 - 1466
-212-
MODEL USED
W/.@IW$W/~
Figure 1
SLEDDING TYPE
Figure 3
FLOATING SLEDDING
Figure 5
HANGING TYPE
slab
Figure 2
ROLLING TYPE
'~~<>
slab foundation
PB~I!@W~_$A_
Figure 4
ROLLING - SLEDDING
steel plate
wi th
lubricant
lenses
foundation slab
Figure 6
-213-
1 An nex N
0
2
Co n t T A B L E N U 1f B E R
:
"..... ""'i' ',IU
: .".' .. ,!I" 11.'.. IU'"
:!i: 1~ii111 :I.~l
'" .,..., '.'" .''''. -.11" ,,0'"
.:," "'.nfl'
",," .11.'" .1'"'>I."
11,7., 1.>." 'u,.·
.., : .hP ...." ,. "', ,n",n. ,.'" " '''.'' .h" >."1'
flU •••
1".11
HII' ".....,
"'.
.OH'." ...../
."'~,.. :"." .11" '.'h}', 'I'.
".u, · .•• Ufl qUI"
n~u .••, ."'~' .< ••••
.""
• •OOI~
.,., '"n',,' ".'" '''.11
HI," ./":' I,M"
"
'Ib • '~I "~1
".1" .,'0,
'{"." .',,, ., e , ,nll.·t, 1/' .~.'
,"" ~.Hf'
'UI'"
..' " e ,
,....,
,I'" '.'1
."'1 '.""
I".'" 'lel'OI
),., '~l 10" ""..,: ...... ."'.' >."" ,....".1'"
m~,~mm;:.1'" .... ,I". ".'''1 .,,,.,,
.'''' II.UU
100,
.. •.••.n
'H'•..• 'U. 1011.1,
." '•..... ,1.1<
1••••• " HI" 01
[~:~~:!;~j'.n" UII
" "0. :
."U 'I,Hn 111'
"
,.,.
Inlf'"
""." .,.., 11."'" "(I',,
I~". ••••. 11 .,,., " .• ,t>
>U.
,ou'""
".,n ."u '1.'/1.'~I ,.~/O
"
'II"" 'h .• n" ••~.
,,,....
!l!:l~!ij~ll
'·.'.H ,II"
.",......." "
'"
'''.'' .UH ',.OH III .. It~• '~l1UU I' •.•~ ....' Il, •• 1/ 1".0<
:
..,,~ .... :
.'" ".., '0" ••• " "'.~' ."" I!.""
111111!iiil!j
,.n,
H •• "
"" ./:.,·1 .1O~
."..- .1,/ • ....." '.U' '.' ,).ue
'''.'' .,'," "."U
: ."." /.,'"
".111
'" "."'
' .II~
:
:
.1'" ~,.""1 "'G. " ,,, .•• t
.1'" <1."1/ "0"
!ll.l: l~l;~l~
11.'",,,.,, .101> ..... "".1', .H.· "0'"
.HI' I.,,·•• "10 IU •• 'GIll'" "1." .1: •• ".)001
:
".'"HI.H .180,
".·'H "0'. In, ,.~.~ II •• .,
".1'" 11f""
I·~.I .!.~' II.'''' ..... ., ".UIj H{I' 'I
::~:::~~U;;~
, ••• 1
: .1'" ...... "'..,./ .1»' ",10<1
'"
IHo. 'QII'ill ",11'
.. """./ .
".
",.,', .1"/ 1"',00
" '10. ,Oll'.O t.'.' JI •••• •)'1 I."~, HI" tve , 1.111
: .n" I."'" '.'"n.", "'." .10" ,,(,. II •• .nll,..,
"'." ."M 11•••• I."" "0..,... 'G •
.,·u 'ClI'''' ,""
"
I •••.•~
.,.tI '.lIot
'IU'
II e , 'G".u. 1.11'
I.'" UQ.
: "'." .'''' II,.
'.IH' '((f'
II".
lI.ln
... ~..... II e ,
.It") 11.'1 n•.
'."" 0.100
'''.'' '(fl'
".. ".01'I'''.
, .•. ,0 .101'
,.,not .. no, • n••• ~•• n.19' "...•,.ltl' 11 ••
'""....1".11 .,.10 I."H .~""., ' ••• 1 " .. '....,
... •••• 11
.It••
1.'11.
10. '~ll1'~' ...... ",." .) ... ,.,'11 .011'" 10 ••••
.l/" I'to 110.
.nl:'''' II.,,, "'." ./011 I.Itol 111/· aD ••••• ,
.H" ...., .. .nll",
: 'I.u'... ~II .• '~ •• HI 1.11t.
"
'60 •
!,;
II.". •••.1. ,,<1,
.., :
.''''
....,. .1,.,
11'." ,1'1' 1.110/ .. /0'. ','/0
": .n"' 'OUI'.' n.I"
,"L' ...., t.>I" III.
" " e , II.IH "' ..'. .!lot "(,. " •.01
: ."'.' ,... ".1" 11.1'1 .OUI·" 1),'10
HI." ....... ".'"".111
"". 01.1"
... '11.'" .n' I1.H" '.~. H.lt!
"'." .H" ".1'"
".'"... .IH· ..... .11"
: ..,.~~ "./. In. 10.101 Ill." .11 ".UIO
: II ••••
,.. '".''' .IM·
/'."'. " "... '.'e/ 11." .1"
... '''.1' .101' / ...."
" "... .nLlI'U 11,11' 1011.",
..,,, 10./)01 1100
'01'''1 II.U'
.00 "00. OO.u,l. 11,110 1I."" '1.111
.., U'."
.1'" 'o.""
,0'1'<)' , •• 11
"'.1< .I~" ...,.., .n •••••• >.111
.! t , II ..."
.I~<I ••.uu 'OIlIlU ...,.. "".11 ..", flO' 'Ou/." It.I"
: ",." .q,. I1.Uro
".." ""." ....,
:Hl,.. n'.I' ..", n.I'D6 .. ", e . 'Oltto,.
:ll!!!
,.. 'U.'~ .JlI' n.'14 H(n
!!m
'CUlOtt
"I." .111.'
Sf"."
.<111 11.'"1 .".. 'CIIUH ".111
.1'"
,,. 1/'.',0 .1/" U.!lH
" "". 1011.1' .IHI 19,1)1 1111'
;m: '01"" 11.0011
'"
• 11.1'
".
"".n It." •• ......., ...,..
: .Il" •• 00' oJ'." .HI< I.UU lH" lb • ,ol, •• e '.11'
'"
"I.~I .1'0/ 1.11" 1IU ,. lO. .nll"~
'.'" '"
,,,..' .lIlt '.1111 HII. 10. Oft", •• •••n
'"
HI.I) .•• r- 1.'"' "
10. '01101/1 ".lID
'" "~.!' .,1/, •.nu fill' )0 • .nllo". 11.111
~"." 1.11" .ou,," ').11'
'''.'' 'lIfO 110.
In. '.IIt
'" II'." .11" , .1~J1
"
ISO.
'OU'''' '.'" IU.·' .11'/ q(l'
i!~
'O'lIU' f.U'
'" "'.!' ,I'" I.IIU ".11' ••0"
: .h:· 11.100
". 11I.'~ • •• 1.
I.'''' Heh ~:::.ftlU" ".111
", 1'9." .IIf' I •.,,, II., '011"" '.011 -.Q'" 'H('
~.
"111'10 1•• ",
: ."-'
."" ".11'
• '1" ..... ,,,.,, ...:.
'"
'!'.II
'''.'',0"', '.011, ,.,. II.IID "01./1 ,tlH LI111 flO' '~ll"H 11.1
: .1'" ".U' "".11 .t'" H(II .0.".0
'.11.
: .",' '.01' .GU, ••• ".11.
.'''' '1 .e 1t
""." ........
'" "".~ .on •
'Ol~ , •••
II.HI
I~U"u ".11'
• '011
.. ~I'.·· .1'" ' •• IIIt
u." •.••
'e.'n•I·~' '.U· .ft ••••• '
,,, "'.1. .UU "."/9 .. In. Inlll'" 11.)" ... ISI.I • . oj" '.11" IUfO In. IftU ••• ' ",01'
'" ,~I "
~.o.,. III' '00. 'Olll'" 1t.11I '''.1' ."" ".UU HU'
im
tftll"" II ••••
,.. "'." ,'II
'.'''' ".. t.OI! ." .I~ ."O! II.IHI ,,(I' '~'I"" ".nl
,.. ."" .""".. .,1'
101.11"
11.1"
.'''', .n<l"" 'OlllOU
,.. ,,,.',. ••.•• It 1.11" P.1U
'" "'.11 .01., 7.0·/1 1(1'
.m:
1010111
II.'"
."') ',.",., ,~ e , 10., .,~, II .~"
01." .11" ...... ,,{I' .c,'Utl  ..",
'" "1,.' ,"·1"
"."" 1(' UIO • • nuo< 0 ..... ... "'.Il .,.,, 11."11
""' .ou •.•• I. II!
..... •••• ,0 '.101 '00.>1 .'HI 11.1'11 "n. :!::: 101'" •• 11
"".~' .>01' H ••••••
"n. ,DIUI/' OI.n. ... "I.~I ,UI1 Jr."'1 '(1' ...., .~t,.<1' >1.'"
 '.~ ''''.1' ,'~'~ 11,/.11 III'
" UU. Ull' •• '
'::::: '"
;mm
.,." 1t.9119 HI,"
:!::: un,'" It. II!
• I·t> '0" •• 1•
I'd •·.nI· ••• 1111 III'
" lO" • U",~" :tm
... ."" ;;~!:~;Ill"
:;;:~.ftlll""
:::;::.'", 1t.""
I." 1~;~:;~
:i!~1ilillli
IfIl ..
iil!
'Ol'IIAI
lilll!
'"
!iillli It!t! ~:I!!!II!!!
Ino,
l~!!ll!li~1
'"
:::::
... .nlll'"
;m:,~~, .1
'''.AI III .nlll""
::~~:
'" "" '~Ill",'
:::t... ..-.~' ."" 'L'''I .".,. t •• e •
.0 •••••• .111 n.I'" .~,...,
'"
-214-
Con t
n.
,..
.,,.,
..m
,..
""
'"
'"'"'"no
".
'"
'"
'"'"...
."'"
'"nr
n.
'"n,
'"
"'
...
.,
M'
M'
'"
'"...
,..,n
'"'"
'"
'"
'"
III
.,
'"..'"
'"
".
'"...,.,
TAB L E
6>,,"
" •• H
&lO.·~
'U,'.
•,•.u
•••• 0
1J1."
"',11
•~,.1'
....~.10.1'
11I.1t
''',It
IU."
IH.·'•u •••
116.06
UO.l1
......",..,
In•••
''',>I
"'.)1,•••n
,,,.,,
111.U
n"u
•••• '1
" •. t,
".',.t
"".1'
" ••tI
'o6.lI
,m:lln e , ll
......,." ." .•• ••• J.
III.t·
......101.11
'1'.'1
''',11
...,.,
"',1 •
•H.t.
l~~
·m:H
~~:!~
m:~~
:~ii
;lli:j!
.Ion
•HU
.1U'
.HU
,.]116
,llU
.,,,.
•)1"
,Ion
,Hll
.1111
..,..
"".
.11"
,'''!
.1001
,.,10
,I'"
.I"~• 11>-
;01 ••
.110'
.1'10
lun
HIU
'."n
He ••
1.""'.Ull Ile••
HU •
".'fl, .UII
1._. ,UI•
!:~!:~:t:::
~:!!:::~:~
loUU HII •
II,Utl Hlto
....,.. HIn
n.uu "CI'
lUll
Hel'
IUU
U,U
IUU
He ••
Heu
I~U'
Hel'
ne ••
IU.·
ntl.
HII.
HI"
.UI.
HU'
IU"
H, ••
,,,to
,Ut,
.101
,1111
• 1901
.1'",.tol
,lilt
,19.'
."1&
,IU'
,I'"
:m~
.tUf
......>0"
.llIJ
.ilh
."1', •• 11
.".,,tl/f
,'."
."".".1
I.'''' HIU
1•• '" HIIO
'.UU IUIO
~.tl •• lun
I."" lUll
'.HI! HIU
••••n
'.nu
1."11 rUI •
I.n" Hlto
1111"
he ••
".6111 IHII
HI"
"..."'"H'"
I,Mn HCIO
HCOt
•••• " HIIO
H.'''' H'"1.UII ILIII
1.1111 ,un
,un; nm.!:!m :w:
,um Hi!:
!~I!II~)f,IIH IIln
n~~mmn
1,.. .~~,0, I
~iJ;~
~!'l~ill~~::::g~1::~
m~~m~m'~Q. 'O~UIII
.~, 10101
IUQ, 10LI0I 0
un.
1401, .ouu"
U", un'It'"
'.0e , nUI_
1001. uu,o"
H ••• n"u"
un. 101""
"..
n••
IH. oou,on
1>0, •••• , •••
0.101..1.,01'
aGLI""
111. tOu,'"
III1;;;;;;;:
~1:~~~~;,
',UoCo,
10 ••• 101.
,..,
oOo"ltu
'0 •• ,0lllUl
n,.u,lOU,
"",.IOI'UIO
lUO • .au,,,,,
.~••••u
1£00, IDUIU'
uu, ,onlO ••
'O,,'U'
0'"""1'00•• 011""
'0«''''
IOU. '011 •• 01
no, UH'"
.0',.••.110, Inu.l'"
30.0."""
HI, UILUU
IOU ••••
"0, toLU'"
"U.·"we, 1ft", •••
00" ••••
0."•••,
In•• 'CI'U
..",."
'O~'0I1'
..",..••
ii~~lmtm, •••• Olll'"
m: mmU
,m~mm;i
l~l:l!~jlll
mr mgm::::; ::~::::~
jm~~~mm
HUH n E R
•. 1"
'.IIt
".UI
........,..
" .•n
'.'".,.".It •• "
n.".
".,"•••• )1
t ••u
t.'"
11.",
'.UI
',.H,
lim[
II'.It.
t ••, •
H.I"
'.H'
11.011
...".
~i
".U,
'.H'1l •• U
H.n.
..,..
'.1"
".1"
II.IH
".0')U.t1O
11.01'
-215-
"
'"
.•....
'"
."
'"
'"
".."
."
..
.,.
...
...
'"'"
'"on
...
'"
'",,,
,..
'",..
'"
,,,
'"
'"'"
l~no
'"
......."'."/, ...,
1'1.0
,.,.•..
"'.'", ., ,-
, .III."
'10."
'N."
,.....,,,.,'
'''.H.11."
I~·.• I I
1"."
"'."
~U1
'U.U
III."
", .." ..N.H
'....,
'''.'',....,
110 •• '
.' •• H
"'.11,,,.1.
1/,.1>
""."
/I ••••
"~.,,.n."
u~."",./01".)1
'''.''
UO •••
......"<.11
•••• 11
• ••• 11
UI.H
.11 •• 1
'00.1'
"'."
'1<.11
H'.II
"'.11
l·'."
109.11
tlo •• ,
U ••• ,
'10.It
fI~."
,~../.11
'''.''no.tI
1!1~
1
.17'
.,.;',
• "Y'
.10"
.....
.1''''
. "1'
.""
.""
."".,n,
."...IIU
."1'.1"..,,,,
.r •• ,
.lln
.IIH
.,"'• 1110
•/1"
.,,,.
.,,"
.n••
."...101'
.IIH
.1'11
II."lI Illl'
l.lO.' /lil.
'.""
+~m:::::
..1'"...."..11"
'.'/0" ILCI'
'.01"
..-'"•••• 11
,.1011 HCI'
..,,".....,
jj:ru1 :::::
:::HH :::::
H:;m :~:::
:::!~~:~:::
::::::: ;m;
~IIII
.n"
.111'
.1111
.1'"
.11"
.HII
.J"I
.111'
"I1~
.0<1
.'01.
.01"
.111
.1111
.IOH
".0111 'LCI'"
••••• 1
HCU U
!."" He •• 01
".11" ,.110 '"
•• lI'"
<.1'"
II.oOl'H'"''
'.HII
1._'" ILl ••••
Hili U
HO' 01
HIli"
lUll 11
11(11 U
I UfO 11
'U" 01
111~11 ~~;:~~
.HO'
.""
".10"
I.""' ••• to
•••••• Ill""
,."U IHU'I
".lIP
1.""......
~t:;!:m: :H~:!1
II.)HI III II "
::;:r, ILl""
.~:m:nm::
~mmm~;~i
~uml~mg
:::;::: :t:::::
:::J;H :~::::;
mm!m~~2
.<1'1
.611
••• 10
.]111
.,.,.....
.PII
.•ou
.1111
.UI'
.1'0>
.1011
.""
.'IU
......IHI
..,,'
.1111
..,,,
.'1"
:~l
to •••., ••
_" •. '011"'''U~ • .ou, ••,
OCll"l'
'n.• OIlIU.
Uu,·"lIO. .oil''''
nt. OOLIO",
10. ::~::~
lI•• :~:::::
II! I~!:i
~m~h1~lli
n~jm~~mm~
!g1!~mh~l
OOL''''.ou.,"
oc,~ •• u
In. ,ou••,.
110. 'OU.I",'
'0", •••
n••• OU ••••
'''.00,••••,
::::l~ilr~
n~~::ml:~:
m: mi::i:
.m: m!u:!
~lm~~gffi;
jll~:j!~~~::::: m:::;;
m~~ib~~~
Annex UO 3
.....Ir.H.
II.Ht
..us
•••It
u .•••
II.r"
' •• ot
".IH
11."1
'.fU
U."I
...".."'."".II.'"
..,,,
' •• ro
......It.'"
il~
il!11
'.'"".'10
II.HI
11•• 1'
I.'"......11.nl
......".no
n.M'
'.'n'1.71'
.,.u.'.UI
•••• 0
H.'"
".1)1
II.)"
".'1)
".HI
tm
~.~~f~
~:8n t T A 3 L Z r U n B E R 1 An nex n 0
4
.",,,- 'J.'""
: ,./ ... ,IIn 1I'.)·tI 01"" 111. '~I" , ,.." '''r,'' .....111.1' .".. ".11/ "'."
"." .. .... 'UIT''''
...... ... ...... ,,... IJ."" 111, '."10" II,It'
,n.•,
.""
11 •••• :",," ,11'· ,,"·11
m~
'.11011'
:i:jlj" ","" OIT& 'H, '~I ,.,.,
U,'" '" "'." .1'" '"" '"(11"'101 ••• ..nl '1. I~I"" I,l,.
'''.''/',.'" .10' III.
'·u"": I,••, .U.
10,1116
,..... ... ,,,... 'I'"~
I
I'UII"
" "',.11
.""
I
".....".,.... .....,
: "','" ,.. .... .....,
'" 101."
,.",ul
'".1'
".01.
.~",.": .~".... ".1"
,.. )'1,"
."M
.n.'••••
11_.'· ,,,,, 'nil '"
...... UHI'"
" : .,... nUl ••• 11.0"
101"'" ......
'"
......
:
II
,I.".
'" ''',II .I~'"
:
-.11'
H •••• ,.. "<-," ,ft.,,.,,
:
".111
'MotU!
I"." .''''
_.111
'"
...... ...,, .~ll",)'
.. t •••• HI." ..."...j".-}
.'n, 01.'" ,n '''.11 ./1" •••.1."
."" I',h'
'",,'...• ..... .,... .....'ITH
.....,
'" In.I' .U·1
UH""".'U '"
'/1.11
:
·'10.
".". m •••• 1' • .'H/
00", •••
,,~... ."'0
~I
~,,,'
~,.. /11."
'111,
,;
II.U'
"H" tlUI ••f
: ,"I.P .UH 'if"
".611
'" ~"..' .11/'
lto; ••
••.•u
'" II •• " ·~H]OU
: ".HI
'"
le.'.I' .I'~' .,'" .ft'Il~.'
11'." .u,~ ./011
I.'": .,..,
;m~m
11••••
m I'~.'· .Hl. .,,,, IOU I"'
iI~m" '''.01
~I
Ufl'
'" .",t" .,..,
: H'.IO .,.., 1<.'"
'" 1".11 ./'1'
1.ln
'" ."" o·U"'·
."., -.'01 ,,' I"." ."H .,..,
Ii
t~ll""
!~
" •• 1.11
.,...
~mm
11.1"
". .n.1I .11'0
"
11.'"
~H" In,.,,_
"6." .,... ".0"
'" ·."IOU
: 1100.
'''.11 .1''' .~u,••,
"I."
".l ••
'" '0"."
: UOO.
110.01 .11" oou ••••
'''.'' ./11'
'0" ••"
.I10f
'~II''"'"tI.
.'HI
.. '·."11
"'.
'~I" • I.'" :.. 1'<."
'0" ••• ••ru
.,." '.'".,... '" "....
'" III." .n •• ..""
"0. ".'"o, .n •• 'J.1I11 lIe . ."...... ".'HIn •. o~U'"<1
II.'" ."'. '.HH
"'. .lIt.t"" 11.1>1
.19" n••
IOU •••• HI.I' .110/
n.' ••.•• ••••• r
: lto.
'OU'" Il.HI ".'''' .. IH. IOU IOU
'.'"
"I." ...," III.
".  ..../
'.'''' llO. ".'It
'10.
'" 1."" .Il"
.....,
.,." 110.
6.• 'H
...".101.1) .10", ".J/19
'"
UI." .IH' ""e ".. •••• 10
.,,,~ ".. U,II·.f ,.. ".''''.. .""
_."/1
11. '~UI"" ...e •• ". J"." .111'
I."" ,,>le 1'.
","'" 11.'"
.. '"."
'.1'" ". "'.ll .1'" •• ~·II
HI • H.'"II.,
.0 •••• "
....."
'o.,,,, rn. 1.11'
no 'i"" .'''0 ~.IUI 11••
.. .~" I. 0
.... _.1"....,..• n. ,,~... • 1.1
: 11.1/" .,.., .... ..""". 11.·••
".1."
.... 01", ••, 11.111
"
tn.1I 'oe. In"••" l.UI
.. "'.PI .,... 1I.llI' .... .~n"" ".!PI H' '''.'1 ,... U.tH
11'''1 '00.
: ".1 •• , rn. '~llI'U H.'U
'"
'''.n .lIll II.I'U
"''''
lit. Ultl'~1 11.1"
07 ••• 1' .IOQ' 10.'''. 'lfit .. '0 e , H ••••
'"~. 10 .,.,. II ••• ,. IUH .n,,",•• n.ul ..,." .411
".1'" I •••
: Il.U" '1"
un"·' II.U.
..' 1".)< .1ltl n.!!tI .,'" .. , ee , onlllU' ....,UUIIU ".IO,.u, ••••• In. .,.."
').10/0
"'" 'O"UU
1T.lU
"'." ,'/"
1'1
Ir'" .. 100. uu .~" II."a
'"
U.II' .... •••• IU.
...".
: ·o",u· " •• 11 ..' •••• 1•. •1'"
,... 1.100
... .'1." .llH ".l1ot
,...0
~I
"..,.
u."" .~...... ,.. '1)." Uot. .~...,..1'" ~ e , 1'11
'''A, '~IL ,I<
'.'" '" ))'.~,
....,"' '.11<
",'H' '011.<10
tou ••• 1
"."" : ,.... •~u'"" ......
".... '0",,,, '.111
'" 'Ut.
.....
'0,,1'1 .. ."., 0111.110"
..,...
'H.'· II ••••
UOI. 11.HI
.0110,"
........"."., .0 •• , ••• '....,,..... , ••1<" un. 01.11'
'"....~.,..,
'~I'''' 11.1"
..... .011"" ·1••••
."" ".,"' .'''~
I'''G ,~o e , ..".". ...".·' •• tlO .nu·,," ,~.,., •• ,40
: 1/,.,' .'11) 10.',,, ,~ ,."
'" '1'"
" IUO. UlllI" l1.all
'OIL ,.~. II.CH " .•,1
". ,.. ..... '"".... 1T.'1t
: 'hlllUl "./n
". "".). .,,'1 •••• )J
: '01''''
:
'"
.JII) 'I ••U' .,..,
'" ••••• t .lIn ....,., .,.., III. OOU'" t.HI
: .,,,. '."," "'" no.
l!ll!~~!
: IlO. nuuu II,HI .'1' In.01 .1'"
tll~
""' " no.
m U'.h .• 1_" 1."11 Ut. uu, ••, n.II'
: II ••••
".. '.1I1 ,n 11••
ll.n UIt'O" I.M'
'"
.,011
" ..'n : ,n.11 .II!· ,..... III •
....,.., ".... <1.11 ..... no.
m III." './U, •0" •••• n.'"
'"
.••n n•.
... .'101 '.UII n•. II •• "
10••• '
.., '/f.1I .11 It 1.1111 'IU, HO.
II.'"
'"
lol.U
~~!
~ri
"'H JII.
IOHIOIt 11.'" .110., ••••·.1,.·.. II.'"n•• :
.., ..., :
........... '."" ,,,. n•••• ".
..,,, lO.'''' .... l.tI'
'"...... I ••• .~" •• I
••,.u n •••n .... .0"•.,. OI.tal
:
i~!
'00 •
H'UHI"0. 10'.
• )1" >0 •• "UU,. '.11t ....., '00 • 'DUIU'
... • It 1 ,t •. 'OUU"
'.N' 1" :..". .... ..",... 10 •• • ~Lt,.u
: ".1." r••• UtI'''' h,'G/ ,.. •••• 11 .,,,. .... •0" ••••,.. tJl.11 •It •• II.'", otU'l&l 10.'" ." :
,..... '0 •. .n",•••... : HI.II
."" "..:" ........ .},,,. ,..."t} 110. to~ II••' II ••••
:
'" ~::~;U",." 100. '0"0,,.
.I'" II •.,,, no. Lt.'"
,..
." "1.)0
,ou, •.••
". HI,le
:!!i: ~!:):::
jilll
" !~~:
~i
'~:::~
:mt
Imm
::::: :::: :~~::::11•• 11
... I"." 11••10
'"
,...))
:;::: :!::H: "
i~
::::H... : ""." ."H :;;;; ,m:
![~~
:UH
'"
~!:~t:~i~
"
:i~
'" ••I.U .1111
~~~i
~'''' Uto. , •.,1
: •• U. 'I.OIe
01/ ••• • 1'01 -r", 1106. 11.111 ,..:IUI.H .11"
: ">1' 1100. ...., ... .,..,••• 11
: •• 0 ••••
.l'" .,.., Uot.
'I ••••
'''... • 11'
U.lll
,..
... ,ue. ".1"
'" ;;;;:;; ::;;; ;UH! 'P"
" H::HIU'."
."" :U;;: 'IT" flU.
.,..~: ..... UH.
'01'"'' II.U'
'"
:lmi ~~m~wm""' "
:~ll'
u, •••••
il~llm ,:,;::;:
:iW ~nm
•••u IOU.
". :: 10". 'OlI'U 11.'10
".U •• U, ••• 101 ,.. ,....., .ntl'HI
:
-216-
11J-i"J
;:;:~
.':j
'jii
"j
:~
T A B L " Ii U H 13 E R 1 An nex N
0
1c.
:
"....•. h',
..... ,.,
.....
'".'''
, ..,,'
. .I'~' ",. 'u, .ft",.,.
t,'"
::::~: ,.~,.., .ftlll"
'.'",.., d"IU' ",HC •...•.. ''', t!Ol.t •• , II.UI
" "'.~O ,II', I,.n, 1111 ,. .... I~LlUll
"',n, ,'" ",H,
10.'" ~'I •" .H·' s , ",. IJlt lit. ,nUI"" U,'.I
.".. oa",<), r,". " ..,. I,'"• il.~ .111' '..~.,"" ".'"r ,.. ."'. ',.'" "", 'PUI"~ H.H'
"'." .",0, '.11" '"HI,,, ".10' ,., ,,,,. I."" '"HI,,, ......"'." 1',0., ''','" '....,,." ..- 1.,"
"" .nn'·" '.,011
'" "'." .".. 1,'111 'U • ,nUl'"
:U!i•••• J<
.,.,., I'"~ ,nll'"
".'" ,.. :;::::. .".,. .,,",.u.1>•• I •• ,n "10 .~ ••• LO'
".1" I."" '''. •••.••UU. tI.lI.
,..... ...... I •••• '
on" •••• 1> •• "
•nll""" /0'," ..,,' •••• 00
....'~'.'; ...., '.n1l 0111 .. U.IU
....., .....,
'~"'" ,., ••.1 ."It -.111'
.". 10"U~'
".'H'."" '0""" •••• 1/
..... ......, "If H ••••
'~'." • 1'"
.... 11.' ••
""." .,,,. ".'H! If" .~".<,. 11.1' '.11." .,.., ,~..." 'OJ. .~,,",,. ".'"
II ••• " .... ,ft" •• " '''.'' ...... '.'''' I ••• leUI.n
....." •• U' ,... ."".",.. .".U .1<:, ••••• 1
'''' 'nuu" ...... '"
.~.... ./1" ".0'" 100. I~"..,.• It.'"H •.••
.""
·."If
.". '"''''''
II ••••
"'." .11" '."" '40 • •~u •••..• "....,
" H'.tl .. ••..0, ".'".1&;, ~.nt I'U 101I1'~' U.611
'"
~~j
.,,/
j~
1111
mnm'''.'' • '00' 1.,"11
I, •
""''"". ".10'IOU .nl·
'''.'' .10"
'."" I'"~
.10.'
.. ......, ."'~ ".nl
.. "'..'
.1011
.. '~'IOI"' ".IU
./111
.''''
l~:m~
illl ,I
'" .11" .." 10"HP'
0'.11 .... '~<I'••' ".H' .11" "'lu~r
.. HI.II .ICO' .. Innl" t .•n
'" .II~' I~nl"" .... .•u' nUl,,,
".11' ,., .'P' .~nl'U
"
~.~
.HII
!~j
,. ,n'll·n 14.1"
'"
~~,
~~U
1111
;m;n:.,..:
I •• ,.
.. .11" lOnl'" ".," oanl",'
.IH'
IOU""
1t.1II1
'OUIl'-
...,. ...... .ou •••.•
.~t.I·U
OO'l~'" ".1"
,~,..."
.. . •• 0. .MII'CoO U.UI
mm
1111 '~UI"C
.n", ••• 11 •• n
.. .IlH
.0 ••••••
.0 ••• , ••
.. U··.III
'" ""'.'.I:.
."... L"n s". IH. onu,.U 11.100 ,.. '''.'' ,..... 110. U••t!
.1'" '''.'' •.• tI~
ll!:l~" 11•• " I.IIlt ,,,. :10.
'n,,'H' ".1"
,,, '1.11,
.11" 110. .., )1'." .h~·
""" "0 . •••• 01
."to
"" 11 •
1.111 ... ....,. .,,~, ...... , ve , '.U,
"
,<1 •••
• 101:
"'" oouuu '1.'.' "..." ..." 11.1".'11'
'" ''''.'" 11.
.". '''.'',..... .11" .", n•.,. .".. 1."" ,... ..",..,
I.l'" )l'. ...,.. '"
...... .1111
1."" H ••
".1"
.. on." .It"
'.H" "10 no. 11.111
'"
....... .,," I."" ,II'
" IH. " ..",,,.., .n" '.1111 1110
" .. .n ••• ,", ",
~I'
.11" I.'!I'
" 10. tO~I"'" ".111
",." .1'" 1."11 .." no. .I1U I."" ".. ,o~uu. ....,.
" 'll.H .,.., l.tHI III' 1I0. ,nI ••H It.HO m •Utl 1.110 .11. 110 • ,nll'Hl U.,"
".... •/1"1
'."" 51" 'u . ... .).n 1.110'
".. '.'".u.UI.II .,," ••••• 0. "10 •U. 100 • '~"1'" II.'"
.. .11,,)
..'''' UIO I••• ...,10 ..." '.1111 .... .ou,." ".,"
to." •• '.U.· .11.' .... ,n,,"10
0".'• .1./
'.'.06 ,,,, .to. lO'l'''' ".'60 ,.. .,.,. '0.0'"
100.
'OU1.~' OJ.H~It6.
.'''' Ito •
.11"
I."" ".... IU.
.~"/."
'0 ••• ' • /111
I."" '10 •
'.'"
••).n
• 100' '.)111 Sll' I ee , ••• U. ,.. .10'•
'.'''' 100. 'OllIO" 11.1' •
.'"1 e , tI ••
"" '00. 'Oll1.~t
·t·... •JlI' '"D .
'" HI.1l .1110
:mm
UF' •..IOIUU
:::m
.., ./ •• 1, .lOt ~ ".1101 1111 .. ,~o. Inll'~" U.IH
'''.10 .11" If" '.0.
'''.'. ...,, '.""
100. .•".CI. '.1'1.U.
,It. '0 •• '''.'' '.11"
100.
,nlllU'
).111
.n" •• " ".,1<
,..... ,,". 1.'"
",... .n •• ,... 'ot. .., .0 •. " .1"·1 ....", III • .. 101• 'PIlO~" 1f.11t
.)01 ,... ,... H'"oU' II.lIt .., 1'." .11' '6.111< 'ot. 101lOC01 10•• 11
H).I< .!l1I ".01" .... ,..... ,..... .H'· '~.1'" I••••
'"
"'..... ••• 11 1/ ••••• ,II' OIee • •nll'H·
1O~'."
."" /0.1111
"". 'lPUU~ 1).'"''''.11 .'1" ".,"'. II" l.111
'" 'O/l.H
'" "H.t1 .<111 11.01" II" UOO. '0","'1 U.H' ,.. IOIO.H .',011 ,..UIl ,II' ..... .Gu.on H.I"
1'." •. 0.•••
In.''
.01, 1/.1'" .... ..... '" '''.'' ".,,"
.". 111." "...., "... 'OHI·" ".'"t.'"
....,.. •• to 01 •••• '"." II .•••• ....,.'''.'' 01."" hot • • ~lIUU
H.It,
.......
ill!. '111111
:H:: U.'"....... ,,,.".'H·" •• 11'
.... UII'''' II ••U
'" ".""
..... tOil'''' 11.'"
,n ".1-11 It!,
'" I ••• /t .,,,. .~.,," Itl. '"UH", ".1"
'"
...,. ....." '100. u,,_nr ".'11,.. ".0."110. '.111 '" '/0.1'
."" 1.011 lt. ,ou.n .....
'" "'.11 .']D' I.t'" UU
"
110. '!IlU.1I ".000
'" H'." .-'" 1.110' JIll ••  .. IOU"" ').,"I."," Itl. ne , 11.11)
'" 111.'0 .1111 ",'U '". '~U'UI •••• to
.". .)00.
'.""
'" .11·' '.111
""
)~O • '1.",. '.11' .., '''.'' ."" '."" n•. _.M'
"'. '" ""." .uu II.'"
••••• 1 ).,... "II •u. ...... .""•• 11' '.)01. UfO ·It. II •••• ,..
1111
••• 00 1.10611
".. 'GlI''&' It.""
'''.11 .10'. •••• 17 IF" 110. u••••" .....,
'"
...., I •••• ) n••
n••••u .....II.'"'.Ill! ,... 1 •• '~UI'" ".01.
'"
....~I."" I". ·H.ItU ".011
1 ••••.
• , •• 1
,.,... 110 • •ou ••••
11.110 '"
•• ,10 ,,.. to,I"'" ..."."'.11 1.1711 110. ,Q"••" ,.. . 11" 1.1101
Ho. .01' •••• 11 ••••
1 • .,11 $1(0 1U.
'" lI •.
I."" 11 •• "",,,10." .HU 1.10" till
" 110. ,nu,,, 11•• 1
l~! .IOtl
:i~
II •• U nl. ,ou.·" .,...,
!:::::
~~
m:
~I~
:::!::
mm
r~i
'" '1-.11 .1'"
jl~
"
ij~j
!~ii Ii I!~I,
'".
l!~i
'0 •.
."'" ,...'.11." • IIH
i .Ill:!l
'et . UIUH
"..,. • 1111 It,.
...."..h ••
.,.., ...."".~' ....,....., 'H." .'1"
,... '~11""
h •. IOH•••••
..,., $100
....o., •••• 1• ..,)
:um Wf
..
:m~
ll~!l~~i:!-il! ~lm~!t ~~wil'llli !ililj i1!!:
l!ll~i:j
.., ',lI." .'~..•••• 11
'" 1I11.IA
::W ;um :::; ..
".
:H:::: :EH111'."
'II.'·.
m~~
~,~
III'
~~i~ii"~ III
~:~:;;
:!ll!
~li'
III' IV
l~I~,:~
'" ." ... It(,
''''.'' "..'J".'~ It" "'1."
'" ,"I.n
::;;~ ""
•••. A.
'"
:m:il :tj!
11" .II'.'A
'"
,,,. "".u ."" "", .
'"
III' ..
l~~~~~'" ~lt.1I .111
"""
'" "If
'" 10"." ....,
'OtfUU$I"
'"
t.O,.I1
.''''..,
-217-
"c.0 n t T A B L E N U 11 B E R 1 An n ex N
0
5
'"
:
'.' "'." >."" ,OIU e •• 001
•• ,.to ....., ••• U • ,...
." ...... .111." ,,.,,,, ""I ,,~. '0",0/'
'10.
 ...." ,UM ••••• ·1 _1'01 "., ,nlll'"I" .•, • to,..
"',11 .:,M,
......, "., or", ••,... / ...., 11,"11 j'O • .n,( "r.~• 1' •• , ,!Ill. )H. ,~""",
... "'."' .. ..'
'."11 'IOU ,,~.,eu.tU
: ".. ·.",.U
'" ",," .,." -.'''. " ... 'H. UHI""
'"t.,,,
"'.,< ."" "."" ....:
'''.'' .r •••
".""
w«,
Ion,·"
'''.'. .1'1' /','101 "",
,..,
." "",II .1111 /',1'.'
'u. Inlll'~'
"'.-- .'''. 11.1'1' ,~ e • 'OUI'"
: ..". :' •• 110 ."., >00.
." ...... ,10,.
~"II " 'H.
'D,,",,,
: ,,,.,, ,1" 1,'." '00, lUlU'.' ".'10...... .'"'. ".,'''' >•• , '0"0401 11,0"
"~.l' .11" ••.•nl 10".0
1<,." "."" 'Ou,.,/ ",/11
'" ....'. ,'I" ' •. 1'" "1.10110 '1.11'
"'.1'
,II.,
I ••• n uu. '.H''''
'"
'OIL'i" 1.111
/, .... .",&
".'.0'
••'/0
.I·..~},10.11 ,1,.1 ".',111 "fO' H&e • IUUI'U It.III
• <1, ••• • 'Ilt
U.""."0' "."10 .n •• " ••
no •• ,
.,"' I'.'HI lUG • •nu, ••' 11.11
.H" OI.n"
f/.n •• IU e • '01101" 11.111
'.1"'" 11.0'
: 11.'"
,.1.•· .1611 '1.1'"
: 'I"U .:1" t.,,,, ~I'" HU. ou,'".) If .e t<
I"." ./<,. '0."11' '11" !'», •n".,. ..,..•10" n •••,• JIO. I~",.,
1.>1,.
·''''·U
.1"0
...... ....~ J'o • IUU"," ".u.
'.'011
." .. ·!It.'101l
• •• 11
'II." .,'n ....... .~.."(" P.OI'
: .,," I.'''' '0",,,, • ••• ,to
... •·••. 11 •,1'1
'.'''. 110. ...."
: .1>.'
·'.lO'.,.... • 111 ......: "'.'0
•••• 11
,"",It • 17.",
."" ,qUI"O
: 110 •
.,." ,.)'0' )l'. ".11'
...... •It" ....... ',H' I •••
'.H'."0' 11.'"' ..,...., IIA.V •• ,ol 11.'''' .,.., IU. ,n,IU" II."•.., .no. ,... ..uoG!>
'"."
.,," !I.IU'
I•••
- •• 11.111> lot. •• ",,1'
II."" ".1"
... .. .. >I."" I•••
: '.11'''' 'I. )O~
." '''.Il
."" ....... '0''''''
."
.,." Itl. ".01
'I~ .11
• <11' II .••••
.,.., ".JlU
•••• I~ .1/11 ".11" '1'" 10O • •nlll",~ 1'.101
1I.1OU
'.0.
,o,,, ••1
".'"
1.1/ .HU
1J •••• l
"I'"
'01.,,1 n,,"
41.UU IOU. 1011"0 e , 101
11'.11 •••• 1
".".0
'0"'.1' ".'"1'.··•• "./10
: 10'.1' .1"" " ..."
: ."~8 "."".""
'00. ~.
.40" 10 •••• 1 .".,."U ••• lIH
.nu,·"••••• 11
'01"'" 1/.111
'"
"./'
.1IH ~.a"o '1
1
"
..... .01 ,.~o 10.111
'1.••
.o".~"
".IH
'" .11" "./1" ".t'
: ...,.
1l_.ll ."" .1 ••••• 1<.,"
.1'" ".0.,
,...."
'" HO./' ..." H.'III "1"6 J' e • IOU]",
,.'"
'" 'It.I' '.IOU
III. Ull'I/' II.IIt
" .. '"n,'U
'" .1" • ...... _.t/t
.Ut' '.~H .p., II~. Utl"" 11.1)1
:
.'''' , .••n II •• '~"I'" '/.10.
II; H'''~ ."'~ 1.11/1 .,." !IO. IOUI.,1 It.'"
'."" II •. ,..,.,
>.1>"
.''''
,"".~., ".110
: .",. ".1'" '.HI
'" ".... ."~, !'.""
"'.'" .0111 "."1/
'1'"
,U. .au.~" 11./1'
." 10'.11 ...., 11.1'" '0,,1'" n .•It
'" : ,.,." .)'10 .......
.1.1- ./., II."" '00. .nll'·" 11.0"
~"." ."1' 'O.~UI In.
'"""" n.llt
'" .,,.. 11.'1'. .n", ••,
.',n '1.>111
".1"••n· 11••••• I ee •
'0" ••" 1I.1tl
... 0/-.1> .HH 11."" '11" ,... 'DUfUr
'."'
,.. .h.... .....' •I.~I/. ·,..~ ,... •nll'''' 11.11'... ''I.,,' • AI 0 ~ ' •• HII ·,..~ 100. •n, ••.~"I
..:...
'" ...•" lO.nOO' IOU.
'0'"'' », 1t0
.,.t ••
"."11
1'00.
'~"H/J II.".
m ;~~:;;.~I ~° I. ~10! '1111
:w~m ';:!~:
."" H.01I' .,.., IHO •
:::;:;W
1••• 1' •••• 1 1/.0<01
• I"~
UU. '0111'"
•• 'Ot
III." .1'" 1l.""U 'l'U ,.H. .oll""
llllll
.711
..."" "... 'Ou, •••
'"
,".11 .1<1' 11•.,11
"'''' 101""
'.' •• ',> .~"...."'..' .'''' ·.·.1<11 '1'" .n"'I1·
.'1" '1'./'" "00. lnUl'G'
,.. "01." ."'" 1."" .nll ••"
'"
'Otl .)~
.'''' ".'HI .,.., InO, U,UItI 11.0"
--
-218-
Annex N° 6
EXAMPLE OF THE TYPICAL GRAPHS OBTAINED
~ "lfoUI Ullt n. "IOlUI( 01'''-''''~
..-
::~ ::~ ~;oo
=•.oot I.". ~_•• , .••• 1.1 ••.•• :.J~=-••~.~.,,~ •.,.,-.~.~,,~.,.--'-'-'._ •.
H!YAG Ew
~_ [lit rUlJ(wt. u, II•• O"hUUIO.
,j !
;' ;J ,/. /.
l~~a
~J'''' I·:l 11.11 1'.lO '''/0 u;,
~_ <'0< r'IC~[M<, n. ~Ml'" ~IIHICI'.~ ~ ".e IUV[II" " ••••• "'((U"'''''
"
-•.••• ,.:, ".ro " •.., ,•.•• , •. /0 "'.to
2.
700.0
fLCEN,NS
Figure
:J ~1I,"(e; UHa '1, '''' •• C~'H!I"
.1
'1 r: .
:j ~~
'.1 /;/
'I A •
. 1","v :
,;1
,
Sf[ k t W
; no' """"" ••_••••A. ur""lIo"
,., ,
/;/"j"
'~ 11H~HLuno ., .• s,~.~rl ""lln'
:i
, ,
;.~
: ~ ~:oo.o·
:1~'ii... .." •.•• ..,. 0-.' •. _
ELCEN N5
7
-219-

More Related Content

What's hot

D04124025029
D04124025029D04124025029
D04124025029IOSR-JEN
 
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...IAEME Publication
 
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building using Flat Slab and Gri...
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building  using Flat Slab and Gri...Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building  using Flat Slab and Gri...
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building using Flat Slab and Gri...IRJET Journal
 
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...IOSR Journals
 
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOILIAEME Publication
 
Iisrt z mahantaesh tr
Iisrt z mahantaesh trIisrt z mahantaesh tr
Iisrt z mahantaesh trIISRT
 
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTURE
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTUREEVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTURE
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTUREJournal For Research
 
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildings
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildingsEffect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildings
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildingseSAT Journals
 
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pile
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pileNumerical simulation of laterally loaded pile
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pileDr. Naveen BP
 
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat Slab
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat SlabIRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat Slab
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat SlabIRJET Journal
 
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...IAEME Publication
 
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...IRJESJOURNAL
 
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...eSAT Journals
 

What's hot (18)

D04124025029
D04124025029D04124025029
D04124025029
 
P01254123131
P01254123131P01254123131
P01254123131
 
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF CONCRETE GIRDER BRIDGES UNDER STRONG EARTHQUAKES: THE EFF...
 
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building using Flat Slab and Gri...
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building  using Flat Slab and Gri...Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building  using Flat Slab and Gri...
Seismic Analysis of Multi Storied Irregular Building using Flat Slab and Gri...
 
Ijciet 10 01_094
Ijciet 10 01_094Ijciet 10 01_094
Ijciet 10 01_094
 
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...
Effect of Planar Solid Shear Wall - Frame Arrangement on the Deformation Beha...
 
infilled frame
infilled frame infilled frame
infilled frame
 
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL  DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
DYNAMIC RESPONSE OF CONCRETE GRAVITY DAM ON RANDOM SOIL
 
Iisrt z mahantaesh tr
Iisrt z mahantaesh trIisrt z mahantaesh tr
Iisrt z mahantaesh tr
 
K012256874
K012256874K012256874
K012256874
 
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTURE
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTUREEVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTURE
EVALUATION OF RESPONSE OF INELASTIC RCC FRAME STRUCTURE
 
Bearing capacity of piles
Bearing capacity of pilesBearing capacity of piles
Bearing capacity of piles
 
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildings
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildingsEffect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildings
Effect of infill walls on the seismic performance of the multistoried buildings
 
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pile
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pileNumerical simulation of laterally loaded pile
Numerical simulation of laterally loaded pile
 
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat Slab
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat SlabIRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat Slab
IRJET- Analytical Design for Optimization of Shear Wall for Flat Slab
 
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...
NONLINEAR BEHAVIOR AND FRAGILITY ASSESSMENT OF MULTI-STORY CONFINED MASONRY W...
 
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...
Crash Analysis And Design of Multi-Cell Octagonal S-Shape Members Under Axial...
 
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...
The optimum location of shear wall in high rise r.c bulidings under lateral l...
 

Viewers also liked

Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốn
Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốnGiảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốn
Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốnyasmin367
 
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?Libdesign
 
Designing a slideshare technical presentation
Designing a slideshare technical presentationDesigning a slideshare technical presentation
Designing a slideshare technical presentationTa No
 
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015Bekki Tagg
 
а.гитлер (приложение)
а.гитлер (приложение)а.гитлер (приложение)
а.гитлер (приложение)Tretyakova
 
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting Ltd
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting LtdFlourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting Ltd
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting LtdScott Talbot
 
Deeply Inspired Designs Porfolio
Deeply Inspired Designs PorfolioDeeply Inspired Designs Porfolio
Deeply Inspired Designs PorfolioNatalie Acevedo
 
государство2
государство2государство2
государство2Tretyakova
 
1031241117作業
1031241117作業1031241117作業
1031241117作業丞偉 林
 
партиии и партийные системы
партиии и партийные системыпартиии и партийные системы
партиии и партийные системыTretyakova
 
Holiday inn pacote_turistico
Holiday inn pacote_turisticoHoliday inn pacote_turistico
Holiday inn pacote_turistico100002529091970
 

Viewers also liked (18)

Serveurs
ServeursServeurs
Serveurs
 
Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốn
Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốnGiảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốn
Giảm cân nhanh chóng không mang lại kết quả mong muốn
 
Six Sigma
Six Sigma Six Sigma
Six Sigma
 
HTS-Corporate Profile
HTS-Corporate ProfileHTS-Corporate Profile
HTS-Corporate Profile
 
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?
Jindřich Fialka: K čemu všemu je dobrý design?
 
Designing a slideshare technical presentation
Designing a slideshare technical presentationDesigning a slideshare technical presentation
Designing a slideshare technical presentation
 
Farmacia
Farmacia Farmacia
Farmacia
 
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015
Meaningful EMR Use - A Survey of Family Practice Clinics - TAGG_BEKKI_MSC_2015
 
а.гитлер (приложение)
а.гитлер (приложение)а.гитлер (приложение)
а.гитлер (приложение)
 
profile -1
profile -1profile -1
profile -1
 
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting Ltd
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting LtdFlourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting Ltd
Flourish Apartment For Sale - UCHK Consulting Ltd
 
Deeply Inspired Designs Porfolio
Deeply Inspired Designs PorfolioDeeply Inspired Designs Porfolio
Deeply Inspired Designs Porfolio
 
Eveanna's Portfolio
Eveanna's PortfolioEveanna's Portfolio
Eveanna's Portfolio
 
государство2
государство2государство2
государство2
 
Kia Green
Kia GreenKia Green
Kia Green
 
1031241117作業
1031241117作業1031241117作業
1031241117作業
 
партиии и партийные системы
партиии и партийные системыпартиии и партийные системы
партиии и партийные системы
 
Holiday inn pacote_turistico
Holiday inn pacote_turisticoHoliday inn pacote_turistico
Holiday inn pacote_turistico
 

Similar to Individual Studies on Elasto-Plastic Foundations

A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...
A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...
A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...nhandoan10
 
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdfcesarrodriguez782237
 
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET Journal
 
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET Journal
 
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...paperpublications3
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...eSAT Journals
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...eSAT Journals
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with differentEarthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with differenteSAT Publishing House
 
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...IRJET Journal
 
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...IRJET Journal
 
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...Ijripublishers Ijri
 
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Device
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing DeviceDissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Device
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Deviceidescitation
 
Mba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaMba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaEdhole.com
 
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...ijtsrd
 

Similar to Individual Studies on Elasto-Plastic Foundations (20)

A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...
A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...
A THEORETICAL STUDY ON COLLAPSE MECHANISM AND STRUCTURAL BEHAVIOR OF MULTI-ST...
 
Inocuchi[3]
Inocuchi[3]Inocuchi[3]
Inocuchi[3]
 
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf
3-Soil_Structure_Interaction_of_Cylindrica.pdf
 
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
 
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic DamperIRJET-  	  Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
IRJET- Seismic Performance of Building using Accordion Metallic Damper
 
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...
Out of Plane Behavior of Contained Masonry Infilled Frames Subjected to Seism...
 
n-p-p Silicon solar Cells.PDF
n-p-p Silicon solar Cells.PDFn-p-p Silicon solar Cells.PDF
n-p-p Silicon solar Cells.PDF
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different aspect ratios of masonry ...
 
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with differentEarthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different
Earthquake analysis on 2 d rc frames with different
 
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
 
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
“THE SEISMIC RESISTANCE OF THE DIFFERENT INFILL MATERIALS USED IN THE CONSTRU...
 
Ijmet 09 11_017
Ijmet 09 11_017Ijmet 09 11_017
Ijmet 09 11_017
 
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF EARTH-QUAKE RESISTANT FOR MULTI-STORIED BUILDING ON A ...
 
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Device
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing DeviceDissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Device
Dissipative Capacity Analysis of Steel Buildings using Viscous Bracing Device
 
Bd4102397403
Bd4102397403Bd4102397403
Bd4102397403
 
A04520105
A04520105A04520105
A04520105
 
Final Ppt (18MTSE005 ).pptx
Final Ppt (18MTSE005 ).pptxFinal Ppt (18MTSE005 ).pptx
Final Ppt (18MTSE005 ).pptx
 
Mba admission in india
Mba admission in indiaMba admission in india
Mba admission in india
 
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...
Structural Behaviors of Reinforced Concrete Dome with Shell System under Vari...
 

Recently uploaded

(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...ranjana rawat
 
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IV
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IVHARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IV
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IVRajaP95
 
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptx
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptxCoefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptx
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptxAsutosh Ranjan
 
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCollege Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptx
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptxMicroscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptx
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptxpurnimasatapathy1234
 
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLS
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLSMANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLS
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLSSIVASHANKAR N
 
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptx
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptxIntroduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptx
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptxupamatechverse
 
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130Suhani Kapoor
 
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptx
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptxthe ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptx
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptxhumanexperienceaaa
 
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...srsj9000
 
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...Christo Ananth
 
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...ranjana rawat
 
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escortsranjana rawat
 
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxIntroduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxupamatechverse
 

Recently uploaded (20)

(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
(SHREYA) Chakan Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Esc...
 
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANVI) Koregaon Park Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Profile Call Girls Nagpur Meera Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IV
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IVHARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IV
HARMONY IN THE NATURE AND EXISTENCE - Unit-IV
 
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptx
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptxCoefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptx
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion and their Importance.pptx
 
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCollege Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
College Call Girls Nashik Nehal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptx
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptxMicroscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptx
Microscopic Analysis of Ceramic Materials.pptx
 
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLS
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLSMANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLS
MANUFACTURING PROCESS-II UNIT-5 NC MACHINE TOOLS
 
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptx
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptxIntroduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptx
Introduction to Multiple Access Protocol.pptx
 
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Kondapur Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
 
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and RoutesRoadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
 
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptx
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptxthe ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptx
the ladakh protest in leh ladakh 2024 sonam wangchuk.pptx
 
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
Gfe Mayur Vihar Call Girls Service WhatsApp -> 9999965857 Available 24x7 ^ De...
 
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...
Call for Papers - African Journal of Biological Sciences, E-ISSN: 2663-2187, ...
 
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(PRIYA) Rajgurunagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANJALI) Dange Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth 8250192130 Will You Miss Thi...
 
Exploring_Network_Security_with_JA3_by_Rakesh Seal.pptx
Exploring_Network_Security_with_JA3_by_Rakesh Seal.pptxExploring_Network_Security_with_JA3_by_Rakesh Seal.pptx
Exploring_Network_Security_with_JA3_by_Rakesh Seal.pptx
 
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(MEERA) Dapodi Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
 
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptxIntroduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
Introduction to IEEE STANDARDS and its different types.pptx
 

Individual Studies on Elasto-Plastic Foundations

  • 1. INDIVIDUAL STUDIES BY PARTICIPANTS AT THE . INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF SEISMOLOGY AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING Vol. 16 October 1980 Interna tional Institute of Seismology and Earthquake Engineering Building Research Institute, Ministry of Construction 1 To t eho ro , Oha-machi. Tsukuba-gun, IBARAlO PREFECTURE, J APAN
  • 2. ELASTO - PLASTIC FOUNDATION by Fabian Ed. CEVALLOS larco (For the Earthquake Engineering Course, 1979-1980) ABSTRACT This paper is an effort in analyzing the response of s mall buildings having an elasto-plastic behavior. It's founded that a relationship between the ratio building-stiffness/founda tion-stiffness and the maximum shear force acting on the build ing exists. Some devices for obtaining the elasto-plastic behavior are proposed and it suggests the possibility of designing the appropriate device for the kind of earthquake expected. 1.- INTRODUCTION Since the begining of the earthquake engineering subje ct, the attitude of the researchers was pointed out in two ways; the first one, how to design a building strong enough to resist the earthquake shock and the second one, how to avoid or decre ase the earthquake imput. Nowdays, the first field got a huge development, but the second is still growing up. This study is involved in the second area, where one of the solutions is an elasto-plastic foundation. In 1960ths. Dr Matsushita and Dr. Izumi presented so me devices for decreasing the earthquake imput, all of them sho wn a non-linear relationship between a restoring force and the displacement (f). In 1974 they presented to the Fifth World Can ference on Earthquake Engineering some devices for tall buildi ngs Private Consultant, calle Alemania 0381 Quito - ECUADOR ** Tokyo University Professor and Research Engineer of Inter national Institute of Seismology and Earth. Eng. (Japan/74) -205-
  • 3. ructed with foundation devices able to decrease the imput acc~ lerations caused by earthquakes, and a few years ago a nuclear power plant is projected by Koeberg S.A. in Africa with an el as to-plastic foundation system composed by rubber and sleek s ;, teel (3). 2.- MODEL USED In order to pointed out the possible relationship bet ween the variables involved in the problem, a two degree of freedom system model was used (figure 1). In the model; the mass number one, m l , represents the first story and the foundation device; the stiffness number 0 ne, k l , is the stiffness of the device which transmit the gro und movement to the structure and has an elasto-plastic behav ior; the mass number two, m 2 , is the building's mass and the stiffness number two, k2' is the stiffness of the building. The ground motion exitation was imput to the model by the accelerograms of three earthquakes: San Fernando earthqua ke (recorded in Pacoima dam, S - 74W component), El Centro (N- S component) and Miyagi-oki earthquake (recorded in the basem ent number two of the Sumitomo Bank Building, E - W component). The analysis was carried out in a digital computer, b~ sically using a program already performed by Dr. Yamazaki for a non-linear systems. 3.- DAMPING FOUNDATION DEVICES Some systems were analyzed before one was chosen as th e most appropriate, but they could be divided in the following groups: 3.1.- Hanging type: Fundamentally, this one consists of hanging the struc_ ture so that it could work as a pendulum (figure 2), from the physical pOint of view, the stiffness (k l ) of the device is gi ven by the formula: • Research Engineer of I.I.S.E.E. (1980) -206-
  • 4. r k1 = _-=-P_...:.x'--_E=---__ s Ln «, r x L t Where: k = stiffness value of the device; other words, restoring force 1 divided by deformation. P = weight of the structure ~= angle between the cable and the horizontal plane E = Young's modulus ~ = allowable stress in the cable t L = length of the cable where, In the practical field if steel is used, for example, 2 r.- 2 E= 2100000 kg/ cm, U = 1400 kg/ cm , 0< = 900 (in the mo t st favorable case) and L= 100 cm.; kl becomes 15 x P, this is a high value for kl because instead of decrease the imput it will work as an amplifier. 3.2.- Sledding type: Mainly this type consists of defining one level of imp ut force by the friction angle between the building and the ear th (figure 3). Nevertheless the behavior of this model is inte resting, the analysis by computer is difficult. 3.3.- Floating type: The idea in this type is floating the building in a me dium where some frequencies could be missed and a medium with big values of damping ratio will decrease the imput values hig~ ly. From the practical point of view, the floating medium to be used could be soft soil and some researchers had pointed out th ,', is fact (4). Therefore the problem to be analized in this type belongs to the soil-structure interaction. 3.4.- Rolling type: Basically this type involves rolls, balls or lenses 10 cated between the earth and the foundation (figure 4), with the characteristic that the shape and the size of the lenses or ba lIs gave different behavior to the whole structure by providing the wished foundation's stiffness. -207-
  • 5. Some devices and the kl value formula are listed below: W k l =----- Z(R-r) Where: W= weight of the building R,r,e,a showed in graphs above. 3.5.- Mixed type: The combination of two of the types mentioned before generates the mixed type and this one seems to be the most sui table to solve the problem. The nuclear power plant projected in Africa includes a floating-sledding type (figure 5). And t~ is study is related to this type, where the foundation behavi or is elasto-plastic. 4.- VARIABLES CHOSEN A floating-sledding type was selected because it is po ssible for construction. For that purpose a slab foundation mu st. be done, and over that the lenses will be located and over the lenses a steell plate with lubricant, then the foundation of the building will be placed (figure 6). Since the variables involved in the problem are eight: stiffness of the device (k l ), stiffness of the building (k 2 ), mass of the foundation (m l ), mass of the building (m Z )' damping ratio of the foundation (hI)' damping ratio of the building (h 2 ), sledding level of the foundation or yeilding point of th e foundation (Q ) and imput accelerations (x); some of them m u y st be fixed for the analysis. Therefore a three stories build ing was considered, in order to avoid the influence of the roc ,I~ king problem (5), with a hundred square meter per floor. The foundation weight was included in the first floor. In this ma nner the upper stories weight was rounded in 300 tons. By keeping the period of the building between 0.2 to -208-
  • 6. 0.3 seconds the stiffness of the building is in the range betwe en 150 to 300 tn/ern. The damping ratio of the building was fix ed in 0.02, considered as the worse case, and fa r the foundati on it was fixed in 0.001 to assure tha t the only way where the energy will dissipate in the foundation is throught the pla~ tic deformation beyond the sleeding level. Due to this cons ide rations, the variables m 2 ' k2' hI and h2 were fixed. The varia bles k l , m l , Q y and x were the values used as parameters. The stiffness of the foundation, k l , w a s varying from the 10% to 80% of the building's stiffness in the following ran ge: Name k2 kl ratio Name k2 kl ratio ROLING 0 150 20 0.13 ROLLING7 2S0 40 0.16 ROLLING 150 40 0.26 ROLLINGS 250 SO 0.32 ROLLING2 150 SO 0.53 ROLLING9 250 120 0.4S ROLING2A 150 100 0.66 ROLING9A 250 160 0.64 ROLLING3 150 120 0.80 ROLING9B 250 200 0.80 ROLING3A 200 20 0.10 ROLLINGO 300 40 0.13 ROLLING4 200 40 0.20 ROLLINGA 300 80 0.26 ROLLINGS 200 80 0.40 ROLLINGB 300 120 0.40 ROLLING6 200 120 0.60 ROLINGBI 300 180 0.60 ROLING6A 200 160 0.80 ROLINGB2 300 240 0.80 The stiffness of the foundation, k , 1 are varying mean while the stiffness of the building is fixed due to the fact there is more uncertainties about the behavior of the device than the behavior of the building. The weight of the foundation was defined by three valu e s : 50, 100 and 150 tons, in other words, one sixth, one third and one half of the building weight. The yeilding point of the foundation (where the plastic range start) was defined by three values: 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 of the whole weight over the damping devices. The maximum imput acceleration given by the three eart~ quakes mentioned before, was adjusted to reach three levels 350 -209-
  • 7. 700 and 1400 gals. Therefore, the total number, N, of cases analyzed is gi ven by: N= earthquakes x imput levels x building stiffness x foun dation stiffness x building's damping ratio x foundati on's damping ratio x yeilding point values x building 's masses x foundation's masses. N= 3 x 3 x 4 x 5 x I x 1 x 3 x 1 x 3 1620 cases The output requested to the computer was the following values: maximum shear coefficient for the building (SCMAX), ma~ imum absolute displacement of the foundation (with respect to the earth, ABMAX), frequency for the first mode (OME) and the maximum acceleration imput to the first story (ACMAX). 5.- RESULTS The results of the computation are shown in the Table 1 and they are listed in the annex number 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. Where the first column is the value of ACHAX, the second column is SCMAX, the third column is ABMAX, the fourth is the earthquake name, the fifth is the maximum acceleration of the earthquake, the sixth is the type of the building structure and the seventh is OME's value. To visualize the relationship between the variables, a computer program was performed to draw the following graphs: Ordinate (Y) vs. Abscissa (X) - maximum shear coefficient vs. stiffness ratio - maximum .absolute displacement vs. stiffness ratio - maximum shear coefficient vs. frequency - maximum acceleration of the first story vs. frequency The typical graphs obtained are shown in the figure 7 in the annex number 6, where each line represents the same bui! ding (fixed the stiffness, k2' of the building) with different kinds of foundation devices (varying the stiffness, k l , of the foundation). Therefore, each cartesian coordinates contains 20 points and 324 graphs were plotted for the analysis. -210-
  • 8. 6.- CONCLUSIONS The analysis of the graphs pointec out the following fdctS: - the shear coefficient to be applied to the building keeps a relationship with foundation's stiffness/building's stiffness ratio, in other form: if the ratio increases, the shear coeffi cient increases. - the maximum absolute displacement increases for stiffness ra tio values below some level. - for the same conditions, the shear coefficient increases when the mass ratio ml/m Z (foundation's mass/ buildine's mass) also increases. - for big earthquakes, the maximum absolute displacement of the foundation is almost directly proportional to the yeilding poi nt Q of the elasto-plastic device; then, it is proportional to y the frictional angle between the structure and the earth. - in the case of big earthquakes analyzed (1400 gals) the maxi mum shear coefficient obtained is independent of the earthquake imput, but depend on the yeilding point Q of the elasto-plas y tic foundation device. - there is some value of the stiffness ratio where the absolute displacement and the shear coefficient are in a reasonable valu es for each kind of earthquake analyzed. 7.- ADVANTAGES Special buildings, for example, for computer systems or military purposes, could be constructed with a great safety fa~ tor using an elasto-plastic foundation; even near to the faults where the accelerations got unexpected values. After the structural design of the building, the stiff ness value of the structure must be computed, with this value the appropriate stiffness of the foundation could be defined and designed using the formula (a) of the section three. 8.- LIMITATIONS - the small earthquakes amplified by a factor do not show the -211-
  • 9. same characteristics as the big ones. For that analysis another kind of simulated earthquakes must be applied, for instance, th e synthetic earthquakes obtained by the multiple source method. - after the earthquake jacks will be used to return the struc ture to the original po~ition. - water, sanitary and gas installations must be provided with a flexible joint to out-side of the building. 9.- SUGGESTIONS - a floating-sledding type using clay and sand could be develo ped, for that purpose some tests will be carried out to analyze the real behavior of this system. - a computer program must be developed to analyze the pure sled ding type. - using the results showed in the table 1, a formula could be ob tained to establish the relationship between the variables. REF ERE N C E S (£) MATSUSHITA and IZUMI et al. "Study about the process to red!:!. ce the seismic force on the buildings"; Transaction of the Architectural Institute of Japan, Vol. N° 122, April-1966 pp. 15-22 ,', (2) MATSUSHITA and IZUHI. "Application of input controlling me_. chanism to the structural design of a tall building"; Proce edings of the Fifth W.C.E.E. Rome-1974, Vol. N° 2 pp. 2948- 2955. (~) KOEBERG S.A. Mr. Marc Richli, Spie-Batignolle Paris (4) BYCROFT "Soil-structure interaction at higher frequency fac tor"; Abstract journal in earthquake engineering, Vol. N° 7 Dec-1978. Section soil-structure interaction 0.8 - 9 pp.l69 1, (5) OSAWA, KITAGAhlA and IRIE. "Evaluation of various parameters on response analysis of earthquake motions, including soil- building system"; Proceedings of the Sixth W.C.E.E., Vol. 2 New Delhi - 1977, pp. 1461 - 1466 -212-
  • 10. MODEL USED W/.@IW$W/~ Figure 1 SLEDDING TYPE Figure 3 FLOATING SLEDDING Figure 5 HANGING TYPE slab Figure 2 ROLLING TYPE '~~<> slab foundation PB~I!@W~_$A_ Figure 4 ROLLING - SLEDDING steel plate wi th lubricant lenses foundation slab Figure 6 -213-
  • 11. 1 An nex N 0 2 Co n t T A B L E N U 1f B E R : "..... ""'i' ',IU : .".' .. ,!I" 11.'.. IU'" :!i: 1~ii111 :I.~l '" .,..., '.'" .''''. -.11" ,,0'" .:," "'.nfl' ",," .11.'" .1'"'>I." 11,7., 1.>." 'u,.· .., : .hP ...." ,. "', ,n",n. ,.'" " '''.'' .h" >."1' flU ••• 1".11 HII' "....., "'. .OH'." ...../ ."'~,.. :"." .11" '.'h}', 'I'. ".u, · .•• Ufl qUI" n~u .••, ."'~' .< •••• ."" • •OOI~ .,., '"n',,' ".'" '''.11 HI," ./":' I,M" " 'Ib • '~I "~1 ".1" .,'0, '{"." .',,, ., e , ,nll.·t, 1/' .~.' ,"" ~.Hf' 'UI'" ..' " e , ,...., ,I'" '.'1 ."'1 '."" I".'" 'lel'OI ),., '~l 10" ""..,: ...... ."'.' >."" ,....".1'" m~,~mm;:.1'" .... ,I". ".'''1 .,,,.,, .'''' II.UU 100, .. •.••.n 'H'•..• 'U. 1011.1, ." '•..... ,1.1< 1••••• " HI" 01 [~:~~:!;~j'.n" UII " "0. : ."U 'I,Hn 111' " ,.,. Inlf'" ""." .,.., 11."'" "(I',, I~". ••••. 11 .,,., " .• ,t> >U. ,ou'"" ".,n ."u '1.'/1.'~I ,.~/O " 'II"" 'h .• n" ••~. ,,,.... !l!:l~!ij~ll '·.'.H ,II" .",......." " '" '''.'' .UH ',.OH III .. It~• '~l1UU I' •.•~ ....' Il, •• 1/ 1".0< : ..,,~ .... : .'" ".., '0" ••• " "'.~' ."" I!."" 111111!iiil!j ,.n, H •• " "" ./:.,·1 .1O~ ."..- .1,/ • ....." '.U' '.' ,).ue '''.'' .,'," "."U : ."." /.,'" ".111 '" "."' ' .II~ : : .1'" ~,.""1 "'G. " ,,, .•• t .1'" <1."1/ "0" !ll.l: l~l;~l~ 11.'",,,.,, .101> ..... "".1', .H.· "0'" .HI' I.,,·•• "10 IU •• 'GIll'" "1." .1: •• ".)001 : ".'"HI.H .180, ".·'H "0'. In, ,.~.~ II •• ., ".1'" 11f"" I·~.I .!.~' II.'''' ..... ., ".UIj H{I' 'I ::~:::~~U;;~ , ••• 1 : .1'" ...... "'..,./ .1»' ",10<1 '" IHo. 'QII'ill ",11' .. """./ . ". ",.,', .1"/ 1"',00 " '10. ,Oll'.O t.'.' JI •••• •)'1 I."~, HI" tve , 1.111 : .n" I."'" '.'"n.", "'." .10" ,,(,. II •• .nll,.., "'." ."M 11•••• I."" "0..,... 'G • .,·u 'ClI'''' ,"" " I •••.•~ .,.tI '.lIot 'IU' II e , 'G".u. 1.11' I.'" UQ. : "'." .'''' II,. '.IH' '((f' II". lI.ln ... ~..... II e , .It") 11.'1 n•. '."" 0.100 '''.'' '(fl' ".. ".01'I'''. , .•. ,0 .101' ,.,not .. no, • n••• ~•• n.19' "...•,.ltl' 11 •• '""....1".11 .,.10 I."H .~""., ' ••• 1 " .. '...., ... •••• 11 .It•• 1.'11. 10. '~ll1'~' ...... ",." .) ... ,.,'11 .011'" 10 •••• .l/" I'to 110. .nl:'''' II.,,, "'." ./011 I.Itol 111/· aD ••••• , .H" ...., .. .nll", : 'I.u'... ~II .• '~ •• HI 1.11t. " '60 • !,; II.". •••.1. ,,<1, .., : .'''' ....,. .1,., 11'." ,1'1' 1.110/ .. /0'. ','/0 ": .n"' 'OUI'.' n.I" ,"L' ...., t.>I" III. " " e , II.IH "' ..'. .!lot "(,. " •.01 : ."'.' ,... ".1" 11.1'1 .OUI·" 1),'10 HI." ....... ".'"".111 "". 01.1" ... '11.'" .n' I1.H" '.~. H.lt! "'." .H" ".1'" ".'"... .IH· ..... .11" : ..,.~~ "./. In. 10.101 Ill." .11 ".UIO : II •••• ,.. '".''' .IM· /'."'. " "... '.'e/ 11." .1" ... '''.1' .101' / ...." " "... .nLlI'U 11,11' 1011.", ..,,, 10./)01 1100 '01'''1 II.U' .00 "00. OO.u,l. 11,110 1I."" '1.111 .., U'." .1'" 'o."" ,0'1'<)' , •• 11 "'.1< .I~" ...,.., .n •••••• >.111 .! t , II ..." .I~<I ••.uu 'OIlIlU ...,.. "".11 ..", flO' 'Ou/." It.I" : ",." .q,. I1.Uro ".." ""." ...., :Hl,.. n'.I' ..", n.I'D6 .. ", e . 'Oltto,. :ll!!! ,.. 'U.'~ .JlI' n.'14 H(n !!m 'CUlOtt "I." .111.' Sf"." .<111 11.'"1 .".. 'CIIUH ".111 .1'" ,,. 1/'.',0 .1/" U.!lH " "". 1011.1' .IHI 19,1)1 1111' ;m: '01"" 11.0011 '" • 11.1' ". "".n It." •• ......., ...,.. : .Il" •• 00' oJ'." .HI< I.UU lH" lb • ,ol, •• e '.11' '" "I.~I .1'0/ 1.11" 1IU ,. lO. .nll"~ '.'" '" ,,,..' .lIlt '.1111 HII. 10. Oft", •• •••n '" HI.I) .•• r- 1.'"' " 10. '01101/1 ".lID '" "~.!' .,1/, •.nu fill' )0 • .nllo". 11.111 ~"." 1.11" .ou,," ').11' '''.'' 'lIfO 110. In. '.IIt '" II'." .11" , .1~J1 " ISO. 'OU'''' '.'" IU.·' .11'/ q(l' i!~ 'O'lIU' f.U' '" "'.!' ,I'" I.IIU ".11' ••0" : .h:· 11.100 ". 11I.'~ • •• 1. I.'''' Heh ~:::.ftlU" ".111 ", 1'9." .IIf' I •.,,, II., '011"" '.011 -.Q'" 'H(' ~. "111'10 1•• ", : ."-' ."" ".11' • '1" ..... ,,,.,, ...:. '" '!'.II '''.'',0"', '.011, ,.,. II.IID "01./1 ,tlH LI111 flO' '~ll"H 11.1 : .1'" ".U' "".11 .t'" H(II .0.".0 '.11. : .",' '.01' .GU, ••• ".11. .'''' '1 .e 1t ""." ........ '" "".~ .on • 'Ol~ , ••• II.HI I~U"u ".11' • '011 .. ~I'.·· .1'" ' •• IIIt u." •.•• 'e.'n•I·~' '.U· .ft ••••• ' ,,, "'.1. .UU "."/9 .. In. Inlll'" 11.)" ... ISI.I • . oj" '.11" IUfO In. IftU ••• ' ",01' '" ,~I " ~.o.,. III' '00. 'Olll'" 1t.11I '''.1' ."" ".UU HU' im tftll"" II •••• ,.. "'." ,'II '.'''' ".. t.OI! ." .I~ ."O! II.IHI ,,(I' '~'I"" ".nl ,.. ."" .""".. .,1' 101.11" 11.1" .'''', .n<l"" 'OlllOU ,.. ,,,.',. ••.•• It 1.11" P.1U '" "'.11 .01., 7.0·/1 1(1' .m: 1010111 II.'" ."') ',.",., ,~ e , 10., .,~, II .~" 01." .11" ...... ,,{I' .c,'Utl ..", '" "1,.' ,"·1" "."" 1(' UIO • • nuo< 0 ..... ... "'.Il .,.,, 11."11 ""' .ou •.•• I. II! ..... •••• ,0 '.101 '00.>1 .'HI 11.1'11 "n. :!::: 101'" •• 11 "".~' .>01' H •••••• "n. ,DIUI/' OI.n. ... "I.~I ,UI1 Jr."'1 '(1' ...., .~t,.<1' >1.'" '.~ ''''.1' ,'~'~ 11,/.11 III' " UU. Ull' •• ' '::::: '" ;mm .,." 1t.9119 HI," :!::: un,'" It. II! • I·t> '0" •• 1• I'd •·.nI· ••• 1111 III' " lO" • U",~" :tm ... ."" ;;~!:~;Ill" :;;:~.ftlll"" :::;::.'", 1t."" I." 1~;~:;~ :i!~1ilillli IfIl .. iil! 'Ol'IIAI lilll! '" !iillli It!t! ~:I!!!II!!! Ino, l~!!ll!li~1 '" ::::: ... .nlll'" ;m:,~~, .1 '''.AI III .nlll"" ::~~: '" "" '~Ill",' :::t... ..-.~' ."" 'L'''I .".,. t •• e • .0 •••••• .111 n.I'" .~,..., '" -214-
  • 12. Con t n. ,.. .,,., ..m ,.. "" '" '"'"'"no ". '" '" '"'"... ."'" '"nr n. '"n, '" "' ... ., M' M' '" '"... ,..,n '"'" '" '" '" III ., '"..'" '" ". '"...,., TAB L E 6>,," " •• H &lO.·~ 'U,'. •,•.u •••• 0 1J1." "',11 •~,.1' ....~.10.1' 11I.1t ''',It IU." IH.·'•u ••• 116.06 UO.l1 ......",.., In••• ''',>I "'.)1,•••n ,,,.,, 111.U n"u •••• '1 " •. t, ".',.t "".1' " ••tI 'o6.lI ,m:lln e , ll ......,." ." .•• ••• J. III.t· ......101.11 '1'.'1 ''',11 ...,., "',1 • •H.t. l~~ ·m:H ~~:!~ m:~~ :~ii ;lli:j! .Ion •HU .1U' .HU ,.]116 ,llU .,,,. •)1" ,Ion ,Hll .1111 ..,.. "". .11" ,'''! .1001 ,.,10 ,I'" .I"~• 11>- ;01 •• .110' .1'10 lun HIU '."n He •• 1.""'.Ull Ile•• HU • ".'fl, .UII 1._. ,UI• !:~!:~:t::: ~:!!:::~:~ loUU HII • II,Utl Hlto ....,.. HIn n.uu "CI' lUll Hel' IUU U,U IUU He •• Heu I~U' Hel' ne •• IU.· ntl. HII. HI" .UI. HU' IU" H, •• ,,,to ,Ut, .101 ,1111 • 1901 .1'",.tol ,lilt ,19.' ."1& ,IU' ,I'" :m~ .tUf ......>0" .llIJ .ilh ."1', •• 11 .".,,tl/f ,'." ."".".1 I.'''' HIU 1•• '" HIIO '.UU IUIO ~.tl •• lun I."" lUll '.HI! HIU ••••n '.nu 1."11 rUI • I.n" Hlto 1111" he •• ".6111 IHII HI" "..."'"H'" I,Mn HCIO HCOt •••• " HIIO H.'''' H'"1.UII ILIII 1.1111 ,un ,un; nm.!:!m :w: ,um Hi!: !~I!II~)f,IIH IIln n~~mmn 1,.. .~~,0, I ~iJ;~ ~!'l~ill~~::::g~1::~ m~~m~m'~Q. 'O~UIII .~, 10101 IUQ, 10LI0I 0 un. 1401, .ouu" U", un'It'" '.0e , nUI_ 1001. uu,o" H ••• n"u" un. 101"" ".. n•• IH. oou,on 1>0, •••• , ••• 0.101..1.,01' aGLI"" 111. tOu,'" III1;;;;;;;: ~1:~~~~;, ',UoCo, 10 ••• 101. ,.., oOo"ltu '0 •• ,0lllUl n,.u,lOU, "",.IOI'UIO lUO • .au,,,,, .~••••u 1£00, IDUIU' uu, ,onlO •• 'O,,'U' 0'"""1'00•• 011"" '0«'''' IOU. '011 •• 01 no, UH'" .0',.••.110, Inu.l'" 30.0.""" HI, UILUU IOU •••• "0, toLU'" "U.·"we, 1ft", ••• 00" •••• 0."•••, In•• 'CI'U ..",." 'O~'0I1' ..",..•• ii~~lmtm, •••• Olll'" m: mmU ,m~mm;i l~l:l!~jlll mr mgm::::; ::~::::~ jm~~~mm HUH n E R •. 1" '.IIt ".UI ........,.. " .•n '.'".,.".It •• " n.". ".,"•••• )1 t ••u t.'" 11.", '.UI ',.H, lim[ II'.It. t ••, • H.I" '.H' 11.011 ...". ~i ".U, '.H'1l •• U H.n. ..,.. '.1" ".1" II.IH ".0')U.t1O 11.01' -215- " '" .•.... '" ." '" '" ".." ." .. .,. ... ... '"'" '"on ... '" '",,, ,.. '",.. '" ,,, '" '"'" l~no '" ......."'."/, ..., 1'1.0 ,.,.•.. "'.'", ., ,- , .III." '10." 'N." ,.....,,,.,' '''.H.11." I~·.• I I 1"." "'." ~U1 'U.U III." ", .." ..N.H '...., '''.'',...., 110 •• ' .' •• H "'.11,,,.1. 1/,.1> ""." /I •••• "~.,,.n." u~."",./01".)1 '''.'' UO ••• ......"<.11 •••• 11 • ••• 11 UI.H .11 •• 1 '00.1' "'." '1<.11 H'.II "'.11 l·'." 109.11 tlo •• , U ••• , '10.It fI~." ,~../.11 '''.''no.tI 1!1~ 1 .17' .,.;', • "Y' .10" ..... .1'''' . "1' ."" ."" ."".,n, ."...IIU ."1'.1"..,,,, .r •• , .lln .IIH .,"'• 1110 •/1" .,,,. .,," .n•• ."...101' .IIH .1'11 II."lI Illl' l.lO.' /lil. '."" +~m::::: ..1'"...."..11" '.'/0" ILCI' '.01" ..-'"•••• 11 ,.1011 HCI' ..,,"....., jj:ru1 ::::: :::HH ::::: H:;m :~::: :::!~~:~::: ::::::: ;m; ~IIII .n" .111' .1111 .1'" .11" .HII .J"I .111' "I1~ .0<1 .'01. .01" .111 .1111 .IOH ".0111 'LCI'" ••••• 1 HCU U !."" He •• 01 ".11" ,.110 '" •• lI'" <.1'" II.oOl'H'"'' '.HII 1._'" ILl •••• Hili U HO' 01 HIli" lUll 11 11(11 U I UfO 11 'U" 01 111~11 ~~;:~~ .HO' ."" ".10" I.""' ••• to •••••• Ill"" ,."U IHU'I ".lIP 1.""...... ~t:;!:m: :H~:!1 II.)HI III II " ::;:r, ILl"" .~:m:nm:: ~mmm~;~i ~uml~mg :::;::: :t::::: :::J;H :~::::; mm!m~~2 .<1'1 .611 ••• 10 .]111 .,.,..... .PII .•ou .1111 .UI' .1'0> .1011 ."" .'IU ......IHI ..,,' .1111 ..,,, .'1" :~l to •••., •• _" •. '011"'''U~ • .ou, ••, OCll"l' 'n.• OIlIU. Uu,·"lIO. .oil'''' nt. OOLIO", 10. ::~::~ lI•• :~::::: II! I~!:i ~m~h1~lli n~jm~~mm~ !g1!~mh~l OOL''''.ou.," oc,~ •• u In. ,ou••,. 110. 'OU.I",' '0", ••• n••• OU •••• '''.00,••••, ::::l~ilr~ n~~::ml:~: m: mi::i: .m: m!u:! ~lm~~gffi; jll~:j!~~~::::: m:::;; m~~ib~~~ Annex UO 3 .....Ir.H. II.Ht ..us •••It u .••• II.r" ' •• ot ".IH 11."1 '.fU U."I ...".."'."".II.'" ..,,, ' •• ro ......It.'" il~ il!11 '.'"".'10 II.HI 11•• 1' I.'"......11.nl ......".no n.M' '.'n'1.71' .,.u.'.UI •••• 0 H.'" ".1)1 II.)" ".'1) ".HI tm ~.~~f~
  • 13. ~:8n t T A 3 L Z r U n B E R 1 An nex n 0 4 .",,,- 'J.'"" : ,./ ... ,IIn 1I'.)·tI 01"" 111. '~I" , ,.." '''r,'' .....111.1' .".. ".11/ "'." "." .. .... 'UIT'''' ...... ... ...... ,,... IJ."" 111, '."10" II,It' ,n.•, ."" 11 •••• :",," ,11'· ,,"·11 m~ '.11011' :i:jlj" ","" OIT& 'H, '~I ,.,., U,'" '" "'." .1'" '"" '"(11"'101 ••• ..nl '1. I~I"" I,l,. '''.''/',.'" .10' III. '·u"": I,••, .U. 10,1116 ,..... ... ,,,... 'I'"~ I I'UII" " "',.11 ."" I ".....".,.... ....., : "','" ,.. .... ....., '" 101." ,.",ul '".1' ".01. .~",.": .~".... ".1" ,.. )'1," ."M .n.'•••• 11_.'· ,,,,, 'nil '" ...... UHI'" " : .,... nUl ••• 11.0" 101"'" ...... '" ...... : II ,I.". '" ''',II .I~'" : -.11' H •••• ,.. "<-," ,ft.,,.,, : ".111 'MotU! I"." .'''' _.111 '" ...... ...,, .~ll",)' .. t •••• HI." ..."...j".-} .'n, 01.'" ,n '''.11 ./1" •••.1." ."" I',h' '",,'...• ..... .,... .....'ITH ....., '" In.I' .U·1 UH""".'U '" '/1.11 : ·'10. ".". m •••• 1' • .'H/ 00", ••• ,,~... ."'0 ~I ~,,,' ~,.. /11." '111, ,; II.U' "H" tlUI ••f : ,"I.P .UH 'if" ".611 '" ~"..' .11/' lto; •• ••.•u '" II •• " ·~H]OU : ".HI '" le.'.I' .I'~' .,'" .ft'Il~.' 11'." .u,~ ./011 I.'": .,.., ;m~m 11•••• m I'~.'· .Hl. .,,,, IOU I"' iI~m" '''.01 ~I Ufl' '" .",t" .,.., : H'.IO .,.., 1<.'" '" 1".11 ./'1' 1.ln '" ."" o·U"'· ."., -.'01 ,,' I"." ."H .,.., Ii t~ll"" !~ " •• 1.11 .,... ~mm 11.1" ". .n.1I .11'0 " 11.'" ~H" In,.,,_ "6." .,... ".0" '" ·."IOU : 1100. '''.11 .1''' .~u,••, "I." ".l •• '" '0"." : UOO. 110.01 .11" oou •••• '''.'' ./11' '0" ••" .I10f '~II''"'"tI. .'HI .. '·."11 "'. '~I" • I.'" :.. 1'<." '0" ••• ••ru .,." '.'".,... '" ".... '" III." .n •• .."" "0. ".'"o, .n •• 'J.1I11 lIe . ."...... ".'HIn •. o~U'"<1 II.'" ."'. '.HH "'. .lIt.t"" 11.1>1 .19" n•• IOU •••• HI.I' .110/ n.' ••.•• ••••• r : lto. 'OU'" Il.HI ".'''' .. IH. IOU IOU '.'" "I." ...," III. ". ..../ '.'''' llO. ".'It '10. '" 1."" .Il" ....., .,." 110. 6.• 'H ...".101.1) .10", ".J/19 '" UI." .IH' ""e ".. •••• 10 .,,,~ ".. U,II·.f ,.. ".''''.. ."" _."/1 11. '~UI"" ...e •• ". J"." .111' I."" ,,>le 1'. ","'" 11.'" .. '"." '.1'" ". "'.ll .1'" •• ~·II HI • H.'"II., .0 •••• " ....." 'o.,,,, rn. 1.11' no 'i"" .'''0 ~.IUI 11•• .. .~" I. 0 .... _.1"....,..• n. ,,~... • 1.1 : 11.1/" .,.., .... ..""". 11.·•• ".1." .... 01", ••, 11.111 " tn.1I 'oe. In"••" l.UI .. "'.PI .,... 1I.llI' .... .~n"" ".!PI H' '''.'1 ,... U.tH 11'''1 '00. : ".1 •• , rn. '~llI'U H.'U '" '''.n .lIll II.I'U "'''' lit. Ultl'~1 11.1" 07 ••• 1' .IOQ' 10.'''. 'lfit .. '0 e , H •••• '"~. 10 .,.,. II ••• ,. IUH .n,,",•• n.ul ..,." .411 ".1'" I ••• : Il.U" '1" un"·' II.U. ..' 1".)< .1ltl n.!!tI .,'" .. , ee , onlllU' ....,UUIIU ".IO,.u, ••••• In. .,.." ').10/0 "'" 'O"UU 1T.lU "'." ,'/" 1'1 Ir'" .. 100. uu .~" II."a '" U.II' .... •••• IU. ...". : ·o",u· " •• 11 ..' •••• 1•. •1'" ,... 1.100 ... .'1." .llH ".l1ot ,...0 ~I "..,. u."" .~...... ,.. '1)." Uot. .~...,..1'" ~ e , 1'11 '''A, '~IL ,I< '.'" '" ))'.~, ....,"' '.11< ",'H' '011.<10 tou ••• 1 "."" : ,.... •~u'"" ...... ".... '0",,,, '.111 '" 'Ut. ..... '0,,1'1 .. ."., 0111.110" ..,... 'H.'· II •••• UOI. 11.HI .0110," ........"."., .0 •• , ••• '....,,..... , ••1<" un. 01.11' '"....~.,.., '~I'''' 11.1" ..... .011"" ·1•••• ."" ".,"' .'''~ I'''G ,~o e , ..".". ...".·' •• tlO .nu·,," ,~.,., •• ,40 : 1/,.,' .'11) 10.',,, ,~ ,." '" '1'" " IUO. UlllI" l1.all 'OIL ,.~. II.CH " .•,1 ". ,.. ..... '"".... 1T.'1t : 'hlllUl "./n ". "".). .,,'1 •••• )J : '01'''' : '" .JII) 'I ••U' .,.., '" ••••• t .lIn ....,., .,.., III. OOU'" t.HI : .,,,. '."," "'" no. l!ll!~~! : IlO. nuuu II,HI .'1' In.01 .1'" tll~ ""' " no. m U'.h .• 1_" 1."11 Ut. uu, ••, n.II' : II •••• ".. '.1I1 ,n 11•• ll.n UIt'O" I.M' '" .,011 " ..'n : ,n.11 .II!· ,..... III • ....,.., ".... <1.11 ..... no. m III." './U, •0" •••• n.'" '" .••n n•. ... .'101 '.UII n•. II •• " 10••• ' .., '/f.1I .11 It 1.1111 'IU, HO. II.'" '" lol.U ~~! ~ri "'H JII. IOHIOIt 11.'" .110., ••••·.1,.·.. II.'"n•• : .., ..., : ........... '."" ,,,. n•••• ". ..,,, lO.'''' .... l.tI' '"...... I ••• .~" •• I ••,.u n •••n .... .0"•.,. OI.tal : i~! '00 • H'UHI"0. 10'. • )1" >0 •• "UU,. '.11t ....., '00 • 'DUIU' ... • It 1 ,t •. 'OUU" '.N' 1" :..". .... ..",... 10 •• • ~Lt,.u : ".1." r••• UtI'''' h,'G/ ,.. •••• 11 .,,,. .... •0" ••••,.. tJl.11 •It •• II.'", otU'l&l 10.'" ." : ,..... '0 •. .n",•••... : HI.II ."" "..:" ........ .},,,. ,..."t} 110. to~ II••' II •••• : '" ~::~;U",." 100. '0"0,,. .I'" II •.,,, no. Lt.'" ,.. ." "1.)0 ,ou, •.•• ". HI,le :!!i: ~!:)::: jilll " !~~: ~i '~:::~ :mt Imm ::::: :::: :~~::::11•• 11 ... I"." 11••10 '" ,...)) :;::: :!::H: " i~ ::::H... : ""." ."H :;;;; ,m: ![~~ :UH '" ~!:~t:~i~ " :i~ '" ••I.U .1111 ~~~i ~'''' Uto. , •.,1 : •• U. 'I.OIe 01/ ••• • 1'01 -r", 1106. 11.111 ,..:IUI.H .11" : ">1' 1100. ...., ... .,..,••• 11 : •• 0 •••• .l'" .,.., Uot. 'I •••• '''... • 11' U.lll ,.. ... ,ue. ".1" '" ;;;;:;; ::;;; ;UH! 'P" " H::HIU'." ."" :U;;: 'IT" flU. .,..~: ..... UH. '01'"'' II.U' '" :lmi ~~m~wm""' " :~ll' u, ••••• il~llm ,:,;::;: :iW ~nm •••u IOU. ". :: 10". 'OlI'U 11.'10 ".U •• U, ••• 101 ,.. ,....., .ntl'HI : -216-
  • 14. 11J-i"J ;:;:~ .':j 'jii "j :~ T A B L " Ii U H 13 E R 1 An nex N 0 1c. : "....•. h', ..... ,., ..... '".''' , ..,,' . .I'~' ",. 'u, .ft",.,. t,'" ::::~: ,.~,.., .ftlll" '.'",.., d"IU' ",HC •...•.. ''', t!Ol.t •• , II.UI " "'.~O ,II', I,.n, 1111 ,. .... I~LlUll "',n, ,'" ",H, 10.'" ~'I •" .H·' s , ",. IJlt lit. ,nUI"" U,'.I .".. oa",<), r,". " ..,. I,'"• il.~ .111' '..~.,"" ".'"r ,.. ."'. ',.'" "", 'PUI"~ H.H' "'." .",0, '.11" '"HI,,, ".10' ,., ,,,,. I."" '"HI,,, ......"'." 1',0., ''','" '....,,." ..- 1.," "" .nn'·" '.,011 '" "'." .".. 1,'111 'U • ,nUl'" :U!i•••• J< .,.,., I'"~ ,nll'" ".'" ,.. :;::::. .".,. .,,",.u.1>•• I •• ,n "10 .~ ••• LO' ".1" I."" '''. •••.••UU. tI.lI. ,..... ...... I •••• ' on" •••• 1> •• " •nll""" /0'," ..,,' •••• 00 ....'~'.'; ...., '.n1l 0111 .. U.IU ....., ....., '~"'" ,., ••.1 ."It -.111' .". 10"U~' ".'H'."" '0""" •••• 1/ ..... ......, "If H •••• '~'." • 1'" .... 11.' •• ""." .,,,. ".'H! If" .~".<,. 11.1' '.11." .,.., ,~..." 'OJ. .~,,",,. ".'" II ••• " .... ,ft" •• " '''.'' ...... '.'''' I ••• leUI.n ....." •• U' ,... ."".",.. .".U .1<:, ••••• 1 '''' 'nuu" ...... '" .~.... ./1" ".0'" 100. I~"..,.• It.'"H •.•• ."" ·."If .". '"'''''' II •••• "'." .11" '."" '40 • •~u •••..• "...., " H'.tl .. ••..0, ".'".1&;, ~.nt I'U 101I1'~' U.611 '" ~~j .,,/ j~ 1111 mnm'''.'' • '00' 1.,"11 I, • ""''"". ".10'IOU .nl· '''.'' .10" '."" I'"~ .10.' .. ......, ."'~ ".nl .. "'..' .1011 .. '~'IOI"' ".IU ./111 .'''' l~:m~ illl ,I '" .11" .." 10"HP' 0'.11 .... '~<I'••' ".H' .11" "'lu~r .. HI.II .ICO' .. Innl" t .•n '" .II~' I~nl"" .... .•u' nUl,,, ".11' ,., .'P' .~nl'U " ~.~ .HII !~j ,. ,n'll·n 14.1" '" ~~, ~~U 1111 ;m;n:.,..: I •• ,. .. .11" lOnl'" ".," oanl",' .IH' IOU"" 1t.1II1 'OUIl'- ...,. ...... .ou •••.• .~t.I·U OO'l~'" ".1" ,~,..." .. . •• 0. .MII'CoO U.UI mm 1111 '~UI"C .n", ••• 11 •• n .. .IlH .0 •••••• .0 ••• , •• .. U··.III '" ""'.'.I:. ."... L"n s". IH. onu,.U 11.100 ,.. '''.'' ,..... 110. U••t! .1'" '''.'' •.• tI~ ll!:l~" 11•• " I.IIlt ,,,. :10. 'n,,'H' ".1" ,,, '1.11, .11" 110. .., )1'." .h~· """ "0 . •••• 01 ."to "" 11 • 1.111 ... ....,. .,,~, ...... , ve , '.U, " ,<1 ••• • 101: "'" oouuu '1.'.' "..." ..." 11.1".'11' '" ''''.'" 11. .". '''.'',..... .11" .", n•.,. .".. 1."" ,... ..",.., I.l'" )l'. ...,.. '" ...... .1111 1."" H •• ".1" .. on." .It" '.H" "10 no. 11.111 '" ....... .,," I."" ,II' " IH. " ..",,,.., .n" '.1111 1110 " .. .n ••• ,", ", ~I' .11" I.'!I' " 10. tO~I"'" ".111 ",." .1'" 1."11 .." no. .I1U I."" ".. ,o~uu. ....,. " 'll.H .,.., l.tHI III' 1I0. ,nI ••H It.HO m •Utl 1.110 .11. 110 • ,nll'Hl U.," ".... •/1"1 '."" 51" 'u . ... .).n 1.110' ".. '.'".u.UI.II .,," ••••• 0. "10 •U. 100 • '~"1'" II.'" .. .11,,) ..'''' UIO I••• ...,10 ..." '.1111 .... .ou,." ".," to." •• '.U.· .11.' .... ,n,,"10 0".'• .1./ '.'.06 ,,,, .to. lO'l'''' ".'60 ,.. .,.,. '0.0'" 100. 'OU1.~' OJ.H~It6. .'''' Ito • .11" I."" ".... IU. .~"/." '0 ••• ' • /111 I."" '10 • '.'" ••).n • 100' '.)111 Sll' I ee , ••• U. ,.. .10'• '.'''' 100. 'OllIO" 11.1' • .'"1 e , tI •• "" '00. 'Oll1.~t ·t·... •JlI' '"D . '" HI.1l .1110 :mm UF' •..IOIUU :::m .., ./ •• 1, .lOt ~ ".1101 1111 .. ,~o. Inll'~" U.IH '''.10 .11" If" '.0. '''.'. ...,, '."" 100. .•".CI. '.1'1.U. ,It. '0 •• '''.'' '.11" 100. ,nlllU' ).111 .n" •• " ".,1< ,..... ,,". 1.'" ",... .n •• ,... 'ot. .., .0 •. " .1"·1 ....", III • .. 101• 'PIlO~" 1f.11t .)01 ,... ,... H'"oU' II.lIt .., 1'." .11' '6.111< 'ot. 101lOC01 10•• 11 H).I< .!l1I ".01" .... ,..... ,..... .H'· '~.1'" I•••• '" "'..... ••• 11 1/ ••••• ,II' OIee • •nll'H· 1O~'." ."" /0.1111 "". 'lPUU~ 1).'"''''.11 .'1" ".,"'. II" l.111 '" 'O/l.H '" "H.t1 .<111 11.01" II" UOO. '0","'1 U.H' ,.. IOIO.H .',011 ,..UIl ,II' ..... .Gu.on H.I" 1'." •. 0.••• In.'' .01, 1/.1'" .... ..... '" '''.'' ".,," .". 111." "...., "... 'OHI·" ".'"t.'" ....,.. •• to 01 •••• '"." II .•••• ....,.'''.'' 01."" hot • • ~lIUU H.It, ....... ill!. '111111 :H:: U.'"....... ,,,.".'H·" •• 11' .... UII'''' II ••U '" "."" ..... tOil'''' 11.'" ,n ".1-11 It!, '" I ••• /t .,,,. .~.,," Itl. '"UH", ".1" '" ...,. ....." '100. u,,_nr ".'11,.. ".0."110. '.111 '" '/0.1' ."" 1.011 lt. ,ou.n ..... '" "'.11 .']D' I.t'" UU " 110. '!IlU.1I ".000 '" H'." .-'" 1.110' JIll •• .. IOU"" ').,"I."," Itl. ne , 11.11) '" 111.'0 .1111 ",'U '". '~U'UI •••• to .". .)00. '."" '" .11·' '.111 "" )~O • '1.",. '.11' .., '''.'' ."" '."" n•. _.M' "'. '" ""." .uu II.'" ••••• 1 ).,... "II •u. ...... .""•• 11' '.)01. UfO ·It. II •••• ,.. 1111 ••• 00 1.10611 ".. 'GlI''&' It."" '''.11 .10'. •••• 17 IF" 110. u••••" ....., '" ...., I •••• ) n•• n••••u .....II.'"'.Ill! ,... 1 •• '~UI'" ".01. '" ....~I."" I". ·H.ItU ".011 1 ••••. • , •• 1 ,.,... 110 • •ou •••• 11.110 '" •• ,10 ,,.. to,I"'" ..."."'.11 1.1711 110. ,Q"••" ,.. . 11" 1.1101 Ho. .01' •••• 11 •••• 1 • .,11 $1(0 1U. '" lI •. I."" 11 •• "",,,10." .HU 1.10" till " 110. ,nu,,, 11•• 1 l~! .IOtl :i~ II •• U nl. ,ou.·" .,..., !::::: ~~ m: ~I~ :::!:: mm r~i '" '1-.11 .1'" jl~ " ij~j !~ii Ii I!~I, '". l!~i '0 •. ."'" ,...'.11." • IIH i .Ill:!l 'et . UIUH "..,. • 1111 It,. ...."..h •• .,.., ...."".~' ....,....., 'H." .'1" ,... '~11"" h •. IOH••••• ..,., $100 ....o., •••• 1• ..,) :um Wf .. :m~ ll~!l~~i:!-il! ~lm~!t ~~wil'llli !ililj i1!!: l!ll~i:j .., ',lI." .'~..•••• 11 '" 1I11.IA ::W ;um :::; .. ". :H:::: :EH111'." 'II.'·. m~~ ~,~ III' ~~i~ii"~ III ~:~:;; :!ll! ~li' III' IV l~I~,:~ '" ." ... It(, ''''.'' "..'J".'~ It" "'1." '" ,"I.n ::;;~ "" •••. A. '" :m:il :tj! 11" .II'.'A '" ,,,. "".u ."" "", . '" III' .. l~~~~~'" ~lt.1I .111 """ '" "If '" 10"." ...., 'OtfUU$I" '" t.O,.I1 .''''.., -217-
  • 15. "c.0 n t T A B L E N U 11 B E R 1 An n ex N 0 5 '" : '.' "'." >."" ,OIU e •• 001 •• ,.to ....., ••• U • ,... ." ...... .111." ,,.,,,, ""I ,,~. '0",0/' '10. ...." ,UM ••••• ·1 _1'01 "., ,nlll'"I" .•, • to,.. "',11 .:,M, ......, "., or", ••,... / ...., 11,"11 j'O • .n,( "r.~• 1' •• , ,!Ill. )H. ,~""", ... "'."' .. ..' '."11 'IOU ,,~.,eu.tU : ".. ·.",.U '" ",," .,." -.'''. " ... 'H. UHI"" '"t.,,, "'.,< ."" "."" ....: '''.'' .r ••• "."" w«, Ion,·" '''.'. .1'1' /','101 "", ,.., ." "",II .1111 /',1'.' 'u. Inlll'~' "'.-- .'''. 11.1'1' ,~ e • 'OUI'" : ..". :' •• 110 ."., >00. ." ...... ,10,. ~"II " 'H. 'D,,",,, : ,,,.,, ,1" 1,'." '00, lUlU'.' ".'10...... .'"'. ".,'''' >•• , '0"0401 11,0" "~.l' .11" ••.•nl 10".0 1<,." "."" 'Ou,.,/ ",/11 '" ....'. ,'I" ' •. 1'" "1.10110 '1.11' "'.1' ,II., I ••• n uu. '.H'''' '" 'OIL'i" 1.111 /, .... .",& ".'.0' ••'/0 .I·..~},10.11 ,1,.1 ".',111 "fO' H&e • IUUI'U It.III • <1, ••• • 'Ilt U.""."0' "."10 .n •• " •• no •• , .,"' I'.'HI lUG • •nu, ••' 11.11 .H" OI.n" f/.n •• IU e • '01101" 11.111 '.1"'" 11.0' : 11.'" ,.1.•· .1611 '1.1'" : 'I"U .:1" t.,,,, ~I'" HU. ou,'".) If .e t< I"." ./<,. '0."11' '11" !'», •n".,. ..,..•10" n •••,• JIO. I~",., 1.>1,. ·''''·U .1"0 ...... ....~ J'o • IUU"," ".u. '.'011 ." .. ·!It.'101l • •• 11 'II." .,'n ....... .~.."(" P.OI' : .,," I.'''' '0",,,, • ••• ,to ... •·••. 11 •,1'1 '.'''. 110. ...." : .1>.' ·'.lO'.,.... • 111 ......: "'.'0 •••• 11 ,"",It • 17.", ."" ,qUI"O : 110 • .,." ,.)'0' )l'. ".11' ...... •It" ....... ',H' I ••• '.H'."0' 11.'"' ..,...., IIA.V •• ,ol 11.'''' .,.., IU. ,n,IU" II."•.., .no. ,... ..uoG!> '"." .,," !I.IU' I••• - •• 11.111> lot. •• ",,1' II."" ".1" ... .. .. >I."" I••• : '.11'''' 'I. )O~ ." '''.Il ."" ....... '0'''''' ." .,." Itl. ".01 'I~ .11 • <11' II .•••• .,.., ".JlU •••• I~ .1/11 ".11" '1'" 10O • •nlll",~ 1'.101 1I.1OU '.0. ,o,,, ••1 ".'" 1.1/ .HU 1J •••• l "I'" '01.,,1 n,," 41.UU IOU. 1011"0 e , 101 11'.11 •••• 1 ".".0 '0"'.1' ".'"1'.··•• "./10 : 10'.1' .1"" " ..." : ."~8 ".""."" '00. ~. .40" 10 •••• 1 .".,."U ••• lIH .nu,·"••••• 11 '01"'" 1/.111 '" "./' .1IH ~.a"o '1 1 " ..... .01 ,.~o 10.111 '1.•• .o".~" ".IH '" .11" "./1" ".t' : ...,. 1l_.ll ."" .1 ••••• 1<.," .1'" ".0., ,...." '" HO./' ..." H.'III "1"6 J' e • IOU]", ,.'" '" 'It.I' '.IOU III. Ull'I/' II.IIt " .. '"n,'U '" .1" • ...... _.t/t .Ut' '.~H .p., II~. Utl"" 11.1)1 : .'''' , .••n II •• '~"I'" '/.10. II; H'''~ ."'~ 1.11/1 .,." !IO. IOUI.,1 It.'" '."" II •. ,..,., >.1>" .'''' ,"".~., ".110 : .",. ".1'" '.HI '" ".... ."~, !'."" "'.'" .0111 "."1/ '1'" ,U. .au.~" 11./1' ." 10'.11 ...., 11.1'" '0,,1'" n .•It '" : ,.,." .)'10 ....... .1.1- ./., II."" '00. .nll'·" 11.0" ~"." ."1' 'O.~UI In. '"""" n.llt '" .,,.. 11.'1'. .n", ••, .',n '1.>111 ".1"••n· 11••••• I ee • '0" ••" 1I.1tl ... 0/-.1> .HH 11."" '11" ,... 'DUfUr '."' ,.. .h.... .....' •I.~I/. ·,..~ ,... •nll'''' 11.11'... ''I.,,' • AI 0 ~ ' •• HII ·,..~ 100. •n, ••.~"I ..:... '" ...•" lO.nOO' IOU. '0'"'' », 1t0 .,.t •• "."11 1'00. '~"H/J II.". m ;~~:;;.~I ~° I. ~10! '1111 :w~m ';:!~: ."" H.01I' .,.., IHO • :::;:;W 1••• 1' •••• 1 1/.0<01 • I"~ UU. '0111'" •• 'Ot III." .1'" 1l.""U 'l'U ,.H. .oll"" llllll .711 ..."" "... 'Ou, ••• '" ,".11 .1<1' 11•.,11 "'''' 101"" '.' •• ',> .~"...."'..' .'''' ·.·.1<11 '1'" .n"'I1· .'1" '1'./'" "00. lnUl'G' ,.. "01." ."'" 1."" .nll ••" '" 'Otl .)~ .'''' ".'HI .,.., InO, U,UItI 11.0" -- -218-
  • 16. Annex N° 6 EXAMPLE OF THE TYPICAL GRAPHS OBTAINED ~ "lfoUI Ullt n. "IOlUI( 01'''-''''~ ..- ::~ ::~ ~;oo =•.oot I.". ~_•• , .••• 1.1 ••.•• :.J~=-••~.~.,,~ •.,.,-.~.~,,~.,.--'-'-'._ •. H!YAG Ew ~_ [lit rUlJ(wt. u, II•• O"hUUIO. ,j ! ;' ;J ,/. /. l~~a ~J'''' I·:l 11.11 1'.lO '''/0 u;, ~_ <'0< r'IC~[M<, n. ~Ml'" ~IIHICI'.~ ~ ".e IUV[II" " ••••• "'((U"''''' " -•.••• ,.:, ".ro " •.., ,•.•• , •. /0 "'.to 2. 700.0 fLCEN,NS Figure :J ~1I,"(e; UHa '1, '''' •• C~'H!I" .1 '1 r: . :j ~~ '.1 /;/ 'I A • . 1","v : ,;1 , Sf[ k t W ; no' """"" ••_••••A. ur""lIo" ,., , /;/"j" '~ 11H~HLuno ., .• s,~.~rl ""lln' :i , , ;.~ : ~ ~:oo.o· :1~'ii... .." •.•• ..,. 0-.' •. _ ELCEN N5 7 -219-