3. Why this book?
Brookfield’s experience
Focus on adults
Consummate readability of his books
Thoughtfulness
Brookfield: http://www.stephenbrookfield.com/
UAA Title III Robust Online Learning Grant
4. #1: Skillful teaching is whatever helps students
learn
Not all students have same needs; we also can’t dive into a sea of relativism
We are a bundle of habits, attitudes, insecurities, etc and that really has an
impact on the teaching and learning experience
Example: Insecurity
Example: Habit
Example: Attitude
5. #2: Skillful teachers adopt a critically reflective
stance toward their practice
Key point! Contextually informed - the assumptions we operate under
actually fit our context. See above about discussion and the problems it can
create.
Checks we can use to help with our assumptions and context
Students' eyes: checking in with students. (This why I do the pulse-taking surveys
with students in online courses.)
Colleagues' perceptions (debriefing, teaching and learning)
Literature
Autobiography
6. #2: Skillful teachers adopt a critically reflective stance
toward their practice
Why?
Informed action
Modeling critical thinking
Example: Consider that I stopped this class in the middle of the semester for a
whole week to change things around - a lot harder to do in an online course
where a lot of the planning and packaging of content is done well in advance.
Re-energize our teaching
Example: Using videos from people who know more than I do about the heavy-
duty epistemology and psychological learning theory seemed wise. However, I
find it necessary now to step back… our energy is lagging, and we need to
renew our learning experience
Fall 2016 NS A640
7. #3: Teachers need a constant awareness of how
students are experiencing their learning and perceiving
teachers' actions
Challenging to do in an honest way
Anonymous survey techniques - safe environment
Eliminate possible bias on our parts
8. #4: College students are adults. Period.
Not such an issue in CPE
That is what STUDENTS want - consider that if you teach undergraduates
Appearance of disinterest is not always disinterest
Transformation is often incremental
Collaborative learning
10. Learning Environment vs Classroom
Note difference in title from Brookfield
The learning environment is broader than just a classroom
CPE – in a very practical way, the learning environment can be a
classroom, webinar, online course, apprenticeship, or any of a variety of
things
Move away from thinking about a room and more about the features of
the learning space, no matter what it looks like
See M,C, & B Chapter 2 for a discussion of various learning
environments or settings (p. 29-42)
UAA FA16 NS A640
12. Brookfield's techniques for understanding the
classroom
One-minute paper (p. 28) - sort of a written pop quiz
The muddiest point - identifying points of confusion (28-29)
Best-known and quite useful - Critical Incident Questionnaire (p. 34)
Learning audit (29)
Clickers (30)
Social media feedback
TodaysMeet - anonymous twitter, instant and delayed feedback (31)
Texting as clicker (31-32)
Word clouds (31-32)
Fall 2016 NS A640
13. More about the learning environment
It's important to be acutely aware of the learning environment
Factors might manifest different in virtual and face to face environments, so be
prepared to adjust
Physical
Comfort/too comfortable
Distractions
People
Virtual
Easy to ignore
Distractions
Frustration with design, technology, people
People
Fall 2016 NS A640
15. Who are the Adult Learners
This is where the Merriam book shows its age – all the adult learner
info is out of date
Better info here at NCES about who adult learners are and their
characteristics
Fall 2016 NS A640
16. Motivations of Adult Learners
Boshier’s Education Participation Scale (EPS) for motivations of adult
learners. Not by any means definitive, but helpful in looking at the landscape
Communication improvement
Social contact
Educational preparation
Professional advancement
Family togetherness
Social stimulation
Cognitive interest
Fall 2016 NS A640
Editor's Notes
Up to now, a lot of what we’ve been doing is laying groundwork for thinking about teaching and learning, trying to wrap our minds around the basics of epistemology, traditional psychological and adult learning theories. In so doing, it has been my hope to prepare you ultimately to think about teaching in a comprehensive fashion. That is, I want you to think about your teaching from what you think of as knowledge- and how one gains knowledge – clear through the experience of being a teacher in a professional context, aligning your perspectives, goals, theories, techniques, and so on to come away with the most effective teaching or learning experiences possible.
This section is mostly straight from Brookfield’s The Skillful Teacher, with a dollop of experience thrown in for good measure.
At one point I talked over my research with Stephen Brookfield at the Adult Education Research Conference. That was some15 years ago, mind you, but he made an impression then as being very much a pragmatist – he researches, thinks, writes, is creative, but he always comes back to where the rubber meets the road, and that is teaching.
The need to be sensitvie to all our students without driving ourselves insane is a recurring topic in adult education. Brookfield answers this by saying, essentially, that we should have a game plan and then be willing to adapt on the fly by being aware of our environments and aware of ourselves, then applying some critical thinking skills to try to navigate the scenario.
Example: I'm acutely conscious that this is a class about teaching and learning. Every time I'm late with something, something doesn't make sense, or students think that what I've offered is "meh", I die a little death. Insecure - what in the world were they thinking hiring me to teach this??
Example: In graduate school education, there is a lot of discussion. In adult education, as brookfield notes, we have a lot of discussion. In online learning, guess what… there’s a lot of discussion. But even with all winds blowing in one direction, discussion doesn't always work well and isn't necessarily the best option.
Example: fostering self-directedness. In adult ed, we have a tendency to try to do this. Sometimes it works… sometimes not so much. Barriers include work, home life, inexperience, or taking a structured course BECAUSE you don't have the time/energy to be self-directed. Many of these things are magnified in online learning.
This idea of being contextually informed is important – we make assumptions and they are necessary; we just need to make sure that they are the correct ones for the context. Here there are some common ways that we can take different perspectives on our practice and context – checking in with students is a big one; checking in with colleagues; rifling through our experience, and then going to the library to see what we can find.
When we teach we are navigating a scenario to try to achieve specific goals – there are many variables in any given scenario. By taking informed action, rather than just taking action, we can improve the possibilities of achieving our goals.
Also… if you take a critically reflective stance on practice, it liberates us to take a step back and change things if we need to without feeling shamed or failure
This has to do with informed action vs action. Stay in touch with the students in such a way that they can give you honest feedback safely and help make a better class
This assumption is a little less relevant to our class than some others, excpet that some of us are college professors. In my classes full of adults, I have a tendency to treat my adult students as peers with different areas of expertise. I’m not sure I could do that with undergraduates, but I can treat them as adults. In either case, very little will alienate your students faster than condescension.
One of my goals here this semester is to get you to determine what IS- and look at why. Then think about what could be, or what could be better – and ask your self why it is not that. And if possible, is that an area for improvement?
I’m going to differ from brookfield a little here, suggesting that we should be looking at the learning environment or learning space, no matter what form it takes.
Their settings are a little odd, as they are closer to a typology except for the online learning piece. Online learning is not a reasonable part of this typology, as any of these types of learning could happen online.
I like this typology because it lets us take several lenses to the learning opportunities that we see in our professional context. We have a tendency to think of using a single strategy when we approach learning, and that may not be in our best interest
Here are several of Brookfield’s techniques for understanding the classroom. I’ll employ one or two of these over the next several weeks so we can see them in action.
We’ve talked at length of the learning environment and the need to be aware of it, so I won’t belabor that further.
This section provides a quick update to some of our textbook content on characteristics of adult learners, and then a brief conversation about motivations of adult learners.
I’ve highlighted the one most likely to apply in our context – although it is not necessarily advancement that we see. Sometimes it is, and sometimes it is about prevention of stagnation, as you all have noted