D-Mart’s Competitive Advantage
Wafer thin margins & intense competition characterize the F & G business, but…
Mr. Radhakishan Damani (renowned
value investor) wanted to…
…build a low priced retailer in
it’s area of operation
…focus on fundamentals
…emphasize on profitability and
sustainable scalability approach
…create everyday low-price
offering (EDLP)
Break-even in first year of
it’s operations
Industry best
revenue/sq.feet
Consistent profitability
Progressively enhancing
return ratios
Living up to the promise of
high discount offering
The pillars of the resilient business model…
Location benefits; frugal in store infra
Sustainable scaling
Customer centricity
Profitability
High discounting
Progressive return metrics
Rightpricing
Costefficiency
Ops.&
Infrastructure
Expansionmoves
Cluster based expansion strategy
Deepening penetration in areas where they already have footprints instead of expanding in newer regions.
[Source: ICICI Securities]
Cluster based expansion strategy
Ownership model rather than a
lease model
Regional/local clustering
Protection from unreasonable renewal
hikes that could affect profitability
negatively
Cost benefits on fixed expenses pass
on to consumers
Superior industry specific parameters
(RoCE 23%, Gross fixed asset
turnover of 4.1x)
Conservative new store addition
Opening new stores within radius of
few kms of its operating stores
Higher cost efficiency and visibility due
to concentrated marketing activities &
efficient SCM
On an average, ASL added 21 stores/yr during FY
16 to FY 19
Even faster growth of total
carpet area
Healthy asset turnover ratio Return ratio
[Source: ICICI Securities]
Cracking the consumers’ buying psyche
Targeting value conscious market
Customer loyalty using EDLP
strategy
Product categories: Food, FMCG,
General merchandise & apparel
Location: Sub-urban areas of major
cities; residential places; densely
populated
Target: Lower middle, middle and
aspiring upper middle class (inc. <Rs.
50000 per month)
Cost effective procurement policy
High levels of discounts compared to
peers
27% CAGR in terms of bills issued Improving average bill size
ASL’s revenue break up (Food category contributing to 50%+ revenue)
[Source: ICICI Securities]
Razor sharp product assortments
Stocking
Vendor relations
Limited SKUs of popular brands due to
their high recalls
Local preference orientation and bulk
buying to achieve better neotiation
Conservative approach towards private
labels
Faster credit cycle results in higher
cash discounts from vendors
Accelerated inventory churning
Controlled working capital cycle & low
creditor days
One of the best inventory turnover in the industry
Sustained record of low payable days
[Source: ICICI Securities]
The impact of strategies on the KPIs
[Source: Annual Report 2019, ASL]
The impact of strategies on the KPIs
The strategy of cost efficiencies while
offering best customer value has witnessed
stable performance across financial and
operational parameters.
[Source: Annual Report 2019, ASL]
The move for the future
D-Mart Ready
Concept of providing paid home
delivery/convenience of pick up
from nearby store
Low distribution cost
Conservative city based
approach where real estate
costs are high
Long term planning
Close proximity to main
stores
Compete against hyper
local services
For unserviceable pincodes
around key areas
Focus on sustainability as
the management considers
it a long term concept
Thank you
Contributors: Durbar Dasgupta | Krishna Prasad | Kuldeep | Praveen Kumar | Rahul Mishra | Shivam Sharma, PGDM SRCC

Strategy analysis of D-Mart

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Wafer thin margins& intense competition characterize the F & G business, but… Mr. Radhakishan Damani (renowned value investor) wanted to… …build a low priced retailer in it’s area of operation …focus on fundamentals …emphasize on profitability and sustainable scalability approach …create everyday low-price offering (EDLP) Break-even in first year of it’s operations Industry best revenue/sq.feet Consistent profitability Progressively enhancing return ratios Living up to the promise of high discount offering
  • 3.
    The pillars ofthe resilient business model… Location benefits; frugal in store infra Sustainable scaling Customer centricity Profitability High discounting Progressive return metrics Rightpricing Costefficiency Ops.& Infrastructure Expansionmoves
  • 4.
    Cluster based expansionstrategy Deepening penetration in areas where they already have footprints instead of expanding in newer regions. [Source: ICICI Securities]
  • 5.
    Cluster based expansionstrategy Ownership model rather than a lease model Regional/local clustering Protection from unreasonable renewal hikes that could affect profitability negatively Cost benefits on fixed expenses pass on to consumers Superior industry specific parameters (RoCE 23%, Gross fixed asset turnover of 4.1x) Conservative new store addition Opening new stores within radius of few kms of its operating stores Higher cost efficiency and visibility due to concentrated marketing activities & efficient SCM On an average, ASL added 21 stores/yr during FY 16 to FY 19 Even faster growth of total carpet area Healthy asset turnover ratio Return ratio [Source: ICICI Securities]
  • 6.
    Cracking the consumers’buying psyche Targeting value conscious market Customer loyalty using EDLP strategy Product categories: Food, FMCG, General merchandise & apparel Location: Sub-urban areas of major cities; residential places; densely populated Target: Lower middle, middle and aspiring upper middle class (inc. <Rs. 50000 per month) Cost effective procurement policy High levels of discounts compared to peers 27% CAGR in terms of bills issued Improving average bill size ASL’s revenue break up (Food category contributing to 50%+ revenue) [Source: ICICI Securities]
  • 7.
    Razor sharp productassortments Stocking Vendor relations Limited SKUs of popular brands due to their high recalls Local preference orientation and bulk buying to achieve better neotiation Conservative approach towards private labels Faster credit cycle results in higher cash discounts from vendors Accelerated inventory churning Controlled working capital cycle & low creditor days One of the best inventory turnover in the industry Sustained record of low payable days [Source: ICICI Securities]
  • 8.
    The impact ofstrategies on the KPIs [Source: Annual Report 2019, ASL]
  • 9.
    The impact ofstrategies on the KPIs The strategy of cost efficiencies while offering best customer value has witnessed stable performance across financial and operational parameters. [Source: Annual Report 2019, ASL]
  • 10.
    The move forthe future D-Mart Ready Concept of providing paid home delivery/convenience of pick up from nearby store Low distribution cost Conservative city based approach where real estate costs are high Long term planning Close proximity to main stores Compete against hyper local services For unserviceable pincodes around key areas Focus on sustainability as the management considers it a long term concept
  • 11.
    Thank you Contributors: DurbarDasgupta | Krishna Prasad | Kuldeep | Praveen Kumar | Rahul Mishra | Shivam Sharma, PGDM SRCC