Concept of state security service and the system
                      of public order protection
                                    Levan Izoria
Problem

• Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA) – the basis of countries political
  system (“law enforcement body”)
• Low on police adopted in 1993
• Politicizing police (president’s order)
• MIA system is only identified with the functions of police and
  security (service agency)
• Departments implementing security functions are still under the
  ministry subordination
• Extra expenditures
• There are 16 departments under MIA control
• There are no mechanisms for public control of the MIA (transparent
  buildings – non transparent system)
Half measure reforms implemented in the
             police system

• Political system and the selection of reform
  components
• Not implementing MIA system reform
  strategy prepared by OSCE mission in 2005
Goals

• Change of the basics of political system
• Establishing of the Ministry of Internal Affairs
  (civil services)
• Depolitization of police: protected citizen –
  protected policeman
• Separating of state security service from the
  MIA system
• Independent court
How to achieve the goals

• Adopting law on police and the bodies for
  protecting public order
• Structural reorganization
• Establishing municipal police
• Providing civic control
• Introducing principle of career
• Introducing and implementing the advanced
  practice
Ministry of Internal Affairs and police


• 3 levels of administration or management
• Strategic assignments; Minister’s political
  responsibility
• Police department (patrol and criminal police)
• Appointing of heads of departments; their
  accountability
• System of police bodies
Civic control of the police


• Public council – 9 members (nominated by
  public defender, supreme court and bar
  association)
• Functions
• Annual report to the parliament
Serving in police (principal of career)



•   6 months preliminary training course
•   Certification once in 2 years
•   Central certification commission
•   Discharging from police service by the head of
    the department according to the grounds
    determined by law
Advanced practice

•   Prevention and repression
•   Society oriented police
•   Ethics code for the police
•   Instructions for the patrol police conduct
    (example of using mobile phones etc)
State security service
• Establishing of state security service
• Acquiring confidential/secret
  information, systematization, analysis and
  application
• Main directions
• Structure of the service
  (intelligence, counterintelligence and anti
  terroristic)
Ministry of Internal Affairs



                            Administration




                                                 Border police
     Police departments
                                                  department




                                           Professional
   Civil          Youth and                    and               Rescue
governance          sport                   vocational           service
                                            education
State security service




                       Head




Intelligence   Counterintelligence        Anti terroristic
department        department               department

Skema1[1]

  • 1.
    Concept of statesecurity service and the system of public order protection Levan Izoria
  • 2.
    Problem • Ministry ofInternal Affairs (MIA) – the basis of countries political system (“law enforcement body”) • Low on police adopted in 1993 • Politicizing police (president’s order) • MIA system is only identified with the functions of police and security (service agency) • Departments implementing security functions are still under the ministry subordination • Extra expenditures • There are 16 departments under MIA control • There are no mechanisms for public control of the MIA (transparent buildings – non transparent system)
  • 3.
    Half measure reformsimplemented in the police system • Political system and the selection of reform components • Not implementing MIA system reform strategy prepared by OSCE mission in 2005
  • 4.
    Goals • Change ofthe basics of political system • Establishing of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (civil services) • Depolitization of police: protected citizen – protected policeman • Separating of state security service from the MIA system • Independent court
  • 5.
    How to achievethe goals • Adopting law on police and the bodies for protecting public order • Structural reorganization • Establishing municipal police • Providing civic control • Introducing principle of career • Introducing and implementing the advanced practice
  • 6.
    Ministry of InternalAffairs and police • 3 levels of administration or management • Strategic assignments; Minister’s political responsibility • Police department (patrol and criminal police) • Appointing of heads of departments; their accountability • System of police bodies
  • 7.
    Civic control ofthe police • Public council – 9 members (nominated by public defender, supreme court and bar association) • Functions • Annual report to the parliament
  • 8.
    Serving in police(principal of career) • 6 months preliminary training course • Certification once in 2 years • Central certification commission • Discharging from police service by the head of the department according to the grounds determined by law
  • 9.
    Advanced practice • Prevention and repression • Society oriented police • Ethics code for the police • Instructions for the patrol police conduct (example of using mobile phones etc)
  • 10.
    State security service •Establishing of state security service • Acquiring confidential/secret information, systematization, analysis and application • Main directions • Structure of the service (intelligence, counterintelligence and anti terroristic)
  • 11.
    Ministry of InternalAffairs Administration Border police Police departments department Professional Civil Youth and and Rescue governance sport vocational service education
  • 12.
    State security service Head Intelligence Counterintelligence Anti terroristic department department department