Semantic Technology
for Provider-Payor-Pharma
Data Collaboration
Building Intelligent Health Data Integration

©2013, Cognizant
Healthcare Expenditure as a % of GDP

th
United States ranked 1st in st in Expenditure,in Life Expectancy
United States ranked 1 Expenditure, 27 27th in Life Expectancy

Health expenditure as a share of GDP, OECD countries, 2012
Strong need to drive down the cost of Healthcare while improving Outcomes
Source: OECD Health data, June 2012

1

| ©2013, Cognizant
Shift to Personalized Medicine and Targeted Therapies

The emerging patient-centric healthcare services will need to be outcomes-driven,
service oriented, and adaptive to respond to human behaviors

Patient Wellness & Quality of
Life Personalized Healthcare
and improved Disease
Management

2

| ©2013, Cognizant

02

Compliance

Connected Personal
Health

Engaging Customers
Interactive & game-based
activity to connect and engage
better with patients to drive
adherence and compliance

01

03

Patient
Centric

Improved Patient
Outcomes

Connected Health
Using Technology to provide
Healthcare remotely
(Care Management)

Cost Containment

04
Remote Health Monitoring is a Key Element of Connected Health
Collect

Transmit

Evaluate

Patients
+
Data

Insight

3

| ©2013, Cognizant

Engage

Intervene
Patient-Centric Integrated Health Data

4

| ©2013, Cognizant
Big Data in Healthcare
Four distinct big data pools exist in the U.S. health care domain today with little
overlap in ownership and low levels of integration.
Owner

Owner

Pharmaceutical companies;
Academia

Example datasets

Various, including
stakeholders outside of
healthcare

Pharmaceutical
R&D Data

Clinical Trials; Compound
Libraries

Patient
Behavior
Data

Integration of
Data Pools
Required for
Major
Opportunities

Example datasets

Utilization of Care; Costs
Estimates

Claims
and Costs
Data

Patient behaviors &
preferences; Exercise data
captured in running shoes
and wearable health monitors

Owner

Owner
Payers, Providers

Example datasets

Clinical
Data

Providers

Example datasets
Electronic Medical Records;
Medical Images; Prescription
Data

Source: Big Data: The Next Frontier for Innovation, Competition and Productivity; McKinsey Global Institute, May 2011

5

| ©2013, Cognizant
Semantic Technology “Super Charging” Health Data Integration
Intelligent Health Data Integration Technology Stack
Health Data Exchange Technology Stack
Semantic Technology
CDISC
Expert Knowledge

PRM

Entity Resolution

CDASH
Patient
Behavior
Data

ODM
SDTM

ADaM

SHARE

SEND

Patient
Privacy

Data Virtualization

Data Federation

Claims EDI
Eligibility

Linked Data

Claim
Submission
Claim Status
Services Review

6

| ©2013, Cognizant

CDA
CCD
RIM
CCOW

HL7
QRDA
GELLO
ICSR
SPL

Provenance
Type 2 Diabetes Research using Semantic Technology
Mayo Clinic used Semantic Web technologies to develop a framework for high
throughput phenotyping using EHRs to analyze multifactorial phenotypes

1

4
Diseasome
Mapped Clinical
Database
to Ontology Model

DBPedia

ChemBL

Find Genes or Biomarkers associated
with T2D, as Published in the Literature

2

5
RxNorm

DailyMed

Clinical DB

Find All FDA-approved T2D Drugs;
Find All Patients Administered these Drugs

Diseasome

RxNorm

ChemBL

DrugBank

Clinical DB

Selected Genes have Strong Correlation to T2D. Find All Patients
Administered Drugs that Target those Genes.

3

6
RxNorm

SIDER

Clinical DB

Find Which of these Patients are having a
Side Effect of Prandin

Diseasome

RxNorm

ChemBL

| ©2013, Cognizant

Clinical DB

Find All Patients that are on Sulfonylureas, Metformin,
Metglitinides, and Thiazolinediones, or combinations of them

Reprinted with permission from Jyotishman Pathak, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic

7

DrugBank
Semantic Technology Components
User interface and applications
Trust
Proof
Unifying logic

Querying:
SPARQL

Ontologies:
Predicate
QWL

Rules:
Object
RIF/SWRL

Taxonomies: RDFS
Data interchange: RDF

Syntax: XML
Identifiers: URI

8

| ©2013, Cognizant

Character set: UNICODE

Cryptography

Subject
Semantic Technology Components
SNOMED Clinical Terms Ontology
Integrating Expertise: Selecting for Hypothyroidism
User interface and applications
Case Medications
Levothyroxine, synthroid,
levoxyl unithroid, armour
thyroid, desicated thyroid,
cytomel, triostat,
liothyronine, synthetic
trilodothyronine, liotrix,
thyrolar

ICD-9 Codes for Hypothyroidism
244, 244.8, 244.9, 245, 245.2, 245.8, 245.9

Abnormal Lab Values
TSH > 5 OR FT4 < 0.5

Trust

ICD-9 Codes for Secondary
Causes of Hypothyroidism
244.0, 244.1, 244.2, 244.3

}

Cryptography

ICD-9 Codes for Post
Surgical or Post Radiation
Case Definition
Hypothyroidism
All three conditions required:
Proof 40930008
sno:40930008for hypothyroidism OR abnormal TSH/FT4
ID
193*, 242.0, 242.1, 242.2,
1. ICD-9 code
sno:40930008 Preferred Name use
Hypothyroidism
242.3, 242.9, 244.0, 244.1,
2. Thyroid replacement medication
244.2, 244.3, 258*
3. Require at least 2 instances of either medication or lab
Pregnancy Exclusion
SPARQL queryID between the first244 last
(abbreviated)
with at least 3 months
and
ICD-9 Codes
icd9:244
CPT Codes for Post
Unifying lab
instance of medication andlogic
Any pregnancy billing code
icd9:244
Preferred Name Acquired hypothyroidism
Radiation Hypothyroidism
or lab test if all Case
77261, 77262, 77263, 77280,
icd9:244.8
ID
244.8
Definition codes, labs, or
77285, 77290, 77295, 77299,
Ontologies:
Rules: acquired
icd9:244.8 DISTINCT ?patientID, ?patientName
medications fall within 6
{Case Exclusions Preferred Name Other specified
SELECT
77300, 77301, 77305, 77310,
QWL
RIF/SWRL
months before pregnancy
Exclude
at any time in
etc.
Querying: if the following information occurshypothyroidism
to one year after
the record:
SPARQL
WHERE
pregnancy
ind:4093008 causes of hypothyroidism
ID
40930008
• Secondary
Exclusion Keywords
V22.1, V22.2, 631, 633,
Taxonomies: RDFS
{
• Post surgical or post radiation hypothyroidism
Multiple endocrine neoplasia,
ind:4093008
Defined By
sno:40930008
633.0, 633.00, 633.1,
• Other thyroid diseases ICD “HYPOTHYROIDISM”
MEN I, MENII, thyroid cancer,
?patient Inclusion
?indication icd9:244
ind:4093008
633.10, 633.20, 633.8,
• Thyroid altering medication
thyroid carcinoma
icd9:244.8
633.80, 633.9, 633.90,
}
645.1, 645.2, 646.8, etc.
DataExclusion ICD RDF
interchange: icd9:631
ind:4093008

icd9:633
Thyroid-Altering Medications
Case Exclusions
Exclusion Keywords
Phenytoin, Dilantin, Infatabs,
Time dependent case exclusions:
Optiray, radiocontrast,
Dilantin Kapseals, Dilantin-125,
Syntax: XML
• Recent pregnancy TSH/FT4
iodine, omnipaque,
Phenytek, Amiocarone
• Recent contrast exposure
visipaque, hypaque,
Pacerone, Cordarone, Lithium,
Conway et al.; Denny et al.
ioversol, diatrizoate,
Eskalith, Lithobid,
iodixanol, isovue,
Methimazole, Tapazole,
Identifiers: URI
Character set: UNICODE
iopamidol, conray,
Northyx, Propylthiouracil, PTU
iothalamate, renografin,
sinografin, cystografin,
Source: SNOMED-CT Ontology, IHTSDOpermission from Jyotishman Pathak, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic
conray, iodipamide
Reprinted with
9

| ©2013, Cognizant
Semantic Technology Components
User interface and applications
Linked Open Drug Data
(LODD) Cloud

Trust
Proof

Unifying logic

Rules:
RIF/SWRL

Taxonomies: RDFS
Data interchange: RDF

Cryptography

Querying:
SPARQL

Ontologies:
QWL

Source: SemanticSyntax: XML
Web for Health Care and Life Sciences Interest Group

Identifiers: URI

10

| ©2013, Cognizant

Character set: UNICODE
Linked Data Case Study Highlights

Detecting off label
prescribing based on
adverse events

11

| ©2013, Cognizant

Monitoring emerging
therapies for
growing disorder
populations
Adding Semantic Technology to Health Data Integration
Gets Us Closer to Solving Connected Health
Semantic Technology
Connected Health
Collaboration

• Population Registry
• Care Management
• Dynamic Care Plan

• Medical Management
• Productivity Management
• Workflow Automation

• Alerts
• Providers, Members
• Community Organizations

Analysis

• Risk Stratification
• Care Engine Rules
• Utilization Trends

• Population Management
• Care Gaps (Trigger)
• Episode Grouper

• Predictive Analysis
• Patient Adherence

• EMPI (Master Person
Record
• Relationships across
data
• Claims
• Lab
• Pharmacy

• Unstructured to structured
usable data
• Extended EMRs
• Member Messaging Engine
• External EHR
• Self-Reported
• Next Gen

• Creation of Cleanest Record
• Identify Opportunities for Action
• Identify Clinical Concepts

Integration

Data

Expert Knowledge

Linked Data

Data Virtualization
HL7
12

| ©2013, Cognizant

• Cerner
• Internal EHR

Provenance

Entity Resolution
CDISC

Data Federation
Claims EDI
Call for Action

1

2

3

4

Assess

Identify

Define

Execute

how the patientcentric model affects
your programs

the relevant patient
behavior data that
you can use

use cases that drive
from the disease
state perspective

projects that rapidly
achieve capabilities,
but don’t try to boil
the ocean




13

| ©2013, Cognizant

Pilots
Proofs of Concept
Agile, Incremental
Development
Q&A

©2013, Cognizant
Speakers

Nagaraja Srivatsan, Senior Vice President, Cognizant
Srivatsan has more than two decades of experience in the Information
Technology industry and deep knowledge of the Healthcare & Life Sciences
domain. Srivatsan drives Cognizant’s strategy in Healthcare and Life
Sciences.
Srivatsan was recognized as one of the top 100 most inspiring people in the
life sciences industry award by PharmaVOICE publication and has been
regularly quoted in national and global magazines like CIO, PharmaVoice,
and CNNFn.

Thomas (Tom) Kelly – Practice Director, EIM Life Sciences
Thomas is a Practice Leader in Cognizant’s Enterprise Information
Management (EIM) Practice, with over 30 years of experience, focusing on
leading Data Warehousing, Business Intelligence, and Big Data projects that
deliver value to Life Sciences and related health industries clients.

15

| ©2013, Cognizant
Thank you

©2013, Cognizant

Semantic Technology for Provider-Payer-Pharma Data Collaboration

  • 1.
    Semantic Technology for Provider-Payor-Pharma DataCollaboration Building Intelligent Health Data Integration ©2013, Cognizant
  • 2.
    Healthcare Expenditure asa % of GDP th United States ranked 1st in st in Expenditure,in Life Expectancy United States ranked 1 Expenditure, 27 27th in Life Expectancy Health expenditure as a share of GDP, OECD countries, 2012 Strong need to drive down the cost of Healthcare while improving Outcomes Source: OECD Health data, June 2012 1 | ©2013, Cognizant
  • 3.
    Shift to PersonalizedMedicine and Targeted Therapies The emerging patient-centric healthcare services will need to be outcomes-driven, service oriented, and adaptive to respond to human behaviors Patient Wellness & Quality of Life Personalized Healthcare and improved Disease Management 2 | ©2013, Cognizant 02 Compliance Connected Personal Health Engaging Customers Interactive & game-based activity to connect and engage better with patients to drive adherence and compliance 01 03 Patient Centric Improved Patient Outcomes Connected Health Using Technology to provide Healthcare remotely (Care Management) Cost Containment 04
  • 4.
    Remote Health Monitoringis a Key Element of Connected Health Collect Transmit Evaluate Patients + Data Insight 3 | ©2013, Cognizant Engage Intervene
  • 5.
    Patient-Centric Integrated HealthData 4 | ©2013, Cognizant
  • 6.
    Big Data inHealthcare Four distinct big data pools exist in the U.S. health care domain today with little overlap in ownership and low levels of integration. Owner Owner Pharmaceutical companies; Academia Example datasets Various, including stakeholders outside of healthcare Pharmaceutical R&D Data Clinical Trials; Compound Libraries Patient Behavior Data Integration of Data Pools Required for Major Opportunities Example datasets Utilization of Care; Costs Estimates Claims and Costs Data Patient behaviors & preferences; Exercise data captured in running shoes and wearable health monitors Owner Owner Payers, Providers Example datasets Clinical Data Providers Example datasets Electronic Medical Records; Medical Images; Prescription Data Source: Big Data: The Next Frontier for Innovation, Competition and Productivity; McKinsey Global Institute, May 2011 5 | ©2013, Cognizant
  • 7.
    Semantic Technology “SuperCharging” Health Data Integration Intelligent Health Data Integration Technology Stack Health Data Exchange Technology Stack Semantic Technology CDISC Expert Knowledge PRM Entity Resolution CDASH Patient Behavior Data ODM SDTM ADaM SHARE SEND Patient Privacy Data Virtualization Data Federation Claims EDI Eligibility Linked Data Claim Submission Claim Status Services Review 6 | ©2013, Cognizant CDA CCD RIM CCOW HL7 QRDA GELLO ICSR SPL Provenance
  • 8.
    Type 2 DiabetesResearch using Semantic Technology Mayo Clinic used Semantic Web technologies to develop a framework for high throughput phenotyping using EHRs to analyze multifactorial phenotypes 1 4 Diseasome Mapped Clinical Database to Ontology Model DBPedia ChemBL Find Genes or Biomarkers associated with T2D, as Published in the Literature 2 5 RxNorm DailyMed Clinical DB Find All FDA-approved T2D Drugs; Find All Patients Administered these Drugs Diseasome RxNorm ChemBL DrugBank Clinical DB Selected Genes have Strong Correlation to T2D. Find All Patients Administered Drugs that Target those Genes. 3 6 RxNorm SIDER Clinical DB Find Which of these Patients are having a Side Effect of Prandin Diseasome RxNorm ChemBL | ©2013, Cognizant Clinical DB Find All Patients that are on Sulfonylureas, Metformin, Metglitinides, and Thiazolinediones, or combinations of them Reprinted with permission from Jyotishman Pathak, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic 7 DrugBank
  • 9.
    Semantic Technology Components Userinterface and applications Trust Proof Unifying logic Querying: SPARQL Ontologies: Predicate QWL Rules: Object RIF/SWRL Taxonomies: RDFS Data interchange: RDF Syntax: XML Identifiers: URI 8 | ©2013, Cognizant Character set: UNICODE Cryptography Subject
  • 10.
    Semantic Technology Components SNOMEDClinical Terms Ontology Integrating Expertise: Selecting for Hypothyroidism User interface and applications Case Medications Levothyroxine, synthroid, levoxyl unithroid, armour thyroid, desicated thyroid, cytomel, triostat, liothyronine, synthetic trilodothyronine, liotrix, thyrolar ICD-9 Codes for Hypothyroidism 244, 244.8, 244.9, 245, 245.2, 245.8, 245.9 Abnormal Lab Values TSH > 5 OR FT4 < 0.5 Trust ICD-9 Codes for Secondary Causes of Hypothyroidism 244.0, 244.1, 244.2, 244.3 } Cryptography ICD-9 Codes for Post Surgical or Post Radiation Case Definition Hypothyroidism All three conditions required: Proof 40930008 sno:40930008for hypothyroidism OR abnormal TSH/FT4 ID 193*, 242.0, 242.1, 242.2, 1. ICD-9 code sno:40930008 Preferred Name use Hypothyroidism 242.3, 242.9, 244.0, 244.1, 2. Thyroid replacement medication 244.2, 244.3, 258* 3. Require at least 2 instances of either medication or lab Pregnancy Exclusion SPARQL queryID between the first244 last (abbreviated) with at least 3 months and ICD-9 Codes icd9:244 CPT Codes for Post Unifying lab instance of medication andlogic Any pregnancy billing code icd9:244 Preferred Name Acquired hypothyroidism Radiation Hypothyroidism or lab test if all Case 77261, 77262, 77263, 77280, icd9:244.8 ID 244.8 Definition codes, labs, or 77285, 77290, 77295, 77299, Ontologies: Rules: acquired icd9:244.8 DISTINCT ?patientID, ?patientName medications fall within 6 {Case Exclusions Preferred Name Other specified SELECT 77300, 77301, 77305, 77310, QWL RIF/SWRL months before pregnancy Exclude at any time in etc. Querying: if the following information occurshypothyroidism to one year after the record: SPARQL WHERE pregnancy ind:4093008 causes of hypothyroidism ID 40930008 • Secondary Exclusion Keywords V22.1, V22.2, 631, 633, Taxonomies: RDFS { • Post surgical or post radiation hypothyroidism Multiple endocrine neoplasia, ind:4093008 Defined By sno:40930008 633.0, 633.00, 633.1, • Other thyroid diseases ICD “HYPOTHYROIDISM” MEN I, MENII, thyroid cancer, ?patient Inclusion ?indication icd9:244 ind:4093008 633.10, 633.20, 633.8, • Thyroid altering medication thyroid carcinoma icd9:244.8 633.80, 633.9, 633.90, } 645.1, 645.2, 646.8, etc. DataExclusion ICD RDF interchange: icd9:631 ind:4093008 icd9:633 Thyroid-Altering Medications Case Exclusions Exclusion Keywords Phenytoin, Dilantin, Infatabs, Time dependent case exclusions: Optiray, radiocontrast, Dilantin Kapseals, Dilantin-125, Syntax: XML • Recent pregnancy TSH/FT4 iodine, omnipaque, Phenytek, Amiocarone • Recent contrast exposure visipaque, hypaque, Pacerone, Cordarone, Lithium, Conway et al.; Denny et al. ioversol, diatrizoate, Eskalith, Lithobid, iodixanol, isovue, Methimazole, Tapazole, Identifiers: URI Character set: UNICODE iopamidol, conray, Northyx, Propylthiouracil, PTU iothalamate, renografin, sinografin, cystografin, Source: SNOMED-CT Ontology, IHTSDOpermission from Jyotishman Pathak, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic conray, iodipamide Reprinted with 9 | ©2013, Cognizant
  • 11.
    Semantic Technology Components Userinterface and applications Linked Open Drug Data (LODD) Cloud Trust Proof Unifying logic Rules: RIF/SWRL Taxonomies: RDFS Data interchange: RDF Cryptography Querying: SPARQL Ontologies: QWL Source: SemanticSyntax: XML Web for Health Care and Life Sciences Interest Group Identifiers: URI 10 | ©2013, Cognizant Character set: UNICODE
  • 12.
    Linked Data CaseStudy Highlights Detecting off label prescribing based on adverse events 11 | ©2013, Cognizant Monitoring emerging therapies for growing disorder populations
  • 13.
    Adding Semantic Technologyto Health Data Integration Gets Us Closer to Solving Connected Health Semantic Technology Connected Health Collaboration • Population Registry • Care Management • Dynamic Care Plan • Medical Management • Productivity Management • Workflow Automation • Alerts • Providers, Members • Community Organizations Analysis • Risk Stratification • Care Engine Rules • Utilization Trends • Population Management • Care Gaps (Trigger) • Episode Grouper • Predictive Analysis • Patient Adherence • EMPI (Master Person Record • Relationships across data • Claims • Lab • Pharmacy • Unstructured to structured usable data • Extended EMRs • Member Messaging Engine • External EHR • Self-Reported • Next Gen • Creation of Cleanest Record • Identify Opportunities for Action • Identify Clinical Concepts Integration Data Expert Knowledge Linked Data Data Virtualization HL7 12 | ©2013, Cognizant • Cerner • Internal EHR Provenance Entity Resolution CDISC Data Federation Claims EDI
  • 14.
    Call for Action 1 2 3 4 Assess Identify Define Execute howthe patientcentric model affects your programs the relevant patient behavior data that you can use use cases that drive from the disease state perspective projects that rapidly achieve capabilities, but don’t try to boil the ocean    13 | ©2013, Cognizant Pilots Proofs of Concept Agile, Incremental Development
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Speakers Nagaraja Srivatsan, SeniorVice President, Cognizant Srivatsan has more than two decades of experience in the Information Technology industry and deep knowledge of the Healthcare & Life Sciences domain. Srivatsan drives Cognizant’s strategy in Healthcare and Life Sciences. Srivatsan was recognized as one of the top 100 most inspiring people in the life sciences industry award by PharmaVOICE publication and has been regularly quoted in national and global magazines like CIO, PharmaVoice, and CNNFn. Thomas (Tom) Kelly – Practice Director, EIM Life Sciences Thomas is a Practice Leader in Cognizant’s Enterprise Information Management (EIM) Practice, with over 30 years of experience, focusing on leading Data Warehousing, Business Intelligence, and Big Data projects that deliver value to Life Sciences and related health industries clients. 15 | ©2013, Cognizant
  • 17.