Scanning GELP’s Horizon
Exploring the transforming
education, global marketplace
What and who we excluded and why
Networks and forums                                                                               Research organisations


             WEF             EWF                    EFF
        World Economic
         Forum Global      The Education      Education                                                              ICSEI
                            World Forum                                                                              International
            Agenda                           Fast Forward                 ATC21S                                     Congress of
            Council                                                        Assessment                                   School
                                                                          and Teaching                             Effectiveness &
                                                                          of C21st Skills                           Improvement
                                                                                                   OECD ILE
   TES
                    Global            WISE                                                          Innovative
                    cities              World                                                        Learning
 Transforming                       Innovation for                                                 Environment
  Education
                  Education
                   Network            Education
    Summit                             Summit




Tech companies & foundations                                                     Non governmental organisations


 Pearson           Google                                 CISCO
  Affordable     In education &    Microsoft                Global
   Learning        the Google         Partners in
                                                           Education
     Fund           Academy            learning                                       World
                                                                                    Bank Group               Association
                                                                                        Learning                for the
                                                                                         for All             development
                                                                                                             of education
                   Intel                                   Apple
                                                                                                               in Africa
Promethean        Education        Amplify
 Education                                                Distinguished
                Transformation
  Strategy                                                 educators
Networks and forums                                                                               Research organisations


             WEF             EWF                    EFF
        World Economic
         Forum Global      The Education      Education                                                              ICSEI
                            World Forum                                                                              International
            Agenda                           Fast Forward                 ATC21S                                     Congress of
            Council                                                        Assessment                                   School
                                                                          and Teaching                             Effectiveness &
                                                                          of C21st Skills                           Improvement
                                                                                                   OECD ILE
   TES
                    Global            WISE                                                          Innovative
                    cities              World                                                        Learning
 Transforming                       Innovation for                                                 Environment
  Education
                  Education
                   Network            Education
    Summit                             Summit
                                                            GELP




Tech companies & foundations                                                     Non governmental organisations


 Pearson           Google                                 CISCO
  Affordable     In education &    Microsoft                Global
   Learning        the Google         Partners in
                                                           Education
     Fund           Academy            learning                                       World
                                                                                    Bank Group               Association
                                                                                        Learning                for the
                                                                                         for All             development
                                                                                                             of education
                   Intel                                   Apple
                                                                                                               in Africa
Promethean        Education        Amplify
 Education                                                Distinguished
                Transformation
  Strategy                                                 educators
WEF             EWF                    EFF
       World Economic
        Forum Global       The Education      Education                                                              ICSEI
                            World Forum                                                                              International
           Agenda                            Fast Forward                 ATC21S                                     Congress of
           Council                                                         Assessment                                   School
                                                                          and Teaching                             Effectiveness &
                                                                          of C21st Skills                           Improvement
                                                                                                   OECD ILE
   TES
                    Global            WISE                                                          Innovative
                    cities              World                                                        Learning
 Transforming                       Innovation for                                                 Environment
  Education
                  Education
                   Network            Education
    Summit                             Summit




                   Google                                 CISCO
                 In education &    Microsoft                Global
                   the Google         Partners in
                                                           Education
                    Academy            learning                                       World
                                                                                    Bank Group               Association
                                                                                        Learning                for the
                                                                                         for All             development
                                                                                                             of education
                   Intel                                   Apple
                                                                                                               in Africa
Promethean        Education        Amplify
 Education                                                Distinguished
                Transformation
  Strategy                                                 educators
SYSTEM FOCUS                                                                                      PEDAGOGY FOCUS

             WEF             EWF                    EFF
       World Economic
        Forum Global       The Education      Education                                                              ICSEI
                            World Forum                                                                              International
           Agenda                            Fast Forward                 ATC21S                                     Congress of
           Council                                                         Assessment                                   School
                                                                          and Teaching                             Effectiveness &
                                                                          of C21st Skills                           Improvement
                                                                                                   OECD ILE
   TES
                    Global            WISE                                                          Innovative
                    cities              World                                                        Learning
 Transforming                       Innovation for                                                 Environment
  Education
                  Education
                   Network            Education
    Summit                             Summit




TECHNOLOGY FOCUS                                                                             DEVELOPMENT FOCUS

                   Google                                 CISCO
                 In education &    Microsoft                Global
                   the Google         Partners in
                                                           Education
                    Academy            learning                                       World
                                                                                    Bank Group               Association
                                                                                        Learning                for the
                                                                                         for All             development
                                                                                                             of education
                   Intel                                   Apple
                                                                                                               in Africa
Promethean        Education        Amplify
 Education                                                Distinguished
                Transformation
  Strategy                                                 educators
SYSTEM FOCUS                                                                                                  PEDAGOGY FOCUS

             WEF             EWF                    EFF
       World Economic
        Forum Global       The Education      Education                                                                          ICSEI
                            World Forum                                                                                          International
           Agenda                            Fast Forward                            ATC21S                                      Congress of
           Council                                                                     Assessment                                   School
                                                                                      and Teaching                             Effectiveness &
                                                                                      of C21st Skills                           Improvement
                                                                                                               OECD ILE
   TES
                    Global            WISE                                                                      Innovative
                    cities              World                                                                    Learning
 Transforming                       Innovation for                                                             Environment
  Education
                  Education
                   Network            Education
    Summit                             Summit




TECHNOLOGY FOCUS                                                          GELP                           DEVELOPMENT FOCUS

                   Google                                 CISCO
                 In education &    Microsoft                Global
                   the Google         Partners in
                                                           Education
                    Academy            learning                                                   World
                                                                                                Bank Group               Association
                                                                                                    Learning                for the
                                                                                                     for All             development
                                                                                 Pearson                                 of education
                   Intel                                   Apple
                                                                                 Affordable                                in Africa
Promethean        Education        Amplify                                        Learning
 Education                                                Distinguished             Fund
                Transformation
  Strategy                                                 educators
In the real world, foci overlap



                 SYSTEM



                                   PEDAGOGY




                              DEVELOPMENT
          TECHNOLOGY
PEDAGOGY




TECHNOLOGY
PEDAGOGY


             GELP




TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM




         TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM

         GELP




          TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM

                      PEDAGOGY


            GELP




         TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM

                       PEDAGOGY


            GELP




         DEVELOPMENT



         TECHNOLOGY
EFF
                              Education                   Promethean        ICSEI                        WISE
                             Fast Forward                  Education        International
                                                                                                        World
                                                            Strategy        Congress of             Innovation for
                                                                               School                 Education
                                                                          Effectiveness &              Summit
                                                                           Improvement




                      CISCO                   EWF
                       Global                   The                                                               TES
                      Education              Education
                                                                                                              Transforming
                                            World Forum
                                                                                                               Education
         WEF                                                                                                     Summit
     World Economic
      Forum Global
         Agenda
         Council

                            Intel                    ATC21S                                              OECD ILE
                           Education                  Assessment                                          Innovative
                         Transformation              and Teaching                                          Learning
                                                     of C21st Skills   Microsoft                         Environment
                                                                        Partners in
                                                                         learning




Google                                    Apple             Global     Pearson                                   Association
In education &    Amplify                                                                     World                 for the
                                     Distinguished          cities     Affordable
  the Google                                                                                Bank Group           development
                                      educators           Education     Learning              Learning
   Academy                                                                                                       of education
                                                           Network        Fund                 for All             in Africa
EFF
                              Education                   Promethean        ICSEI                        WISE
                             Fast Forward                  Education        International
                                                                                                        World
                                                            Strategy        Congress of             Innovation for
                                                                               School                 Education
                                                                          Effectiveness &              Summit
                                                                           Improvement




                      CISCO                   EWF
                       Global                   The                                                               TES
                      Education              Education
                                                                                                              Transforming
                                            World Forum
                                                                                                               Education
         WEF                                                                                                     Summit
     World Economic                                                               GELP
      Forum Global
         Agenda
         Council

                            Intel                    ATC21S                                              OECD ILE
                           Education                  Assessment                                          Innovative
                         Transformation              and Teaching                                          Learning
                                                     of C21st Skills   Microsoft                         Environment
                                                                        Partners in
                                                                         learning




Google                                    Apple             Global     Pearson                                   Association
In education &    Amplify                                                                     World                 for the
                                     Distinguished          cities     Affordable
  the Google                                                                                Bank Group           development
                                      educators           Education     Learning              Learning
   Academy                                                                                                       of education
                                                           Network        Fund                 for All             in Africa
Some questions that the scan suggests
• How important is it that GELP is able to identify with
  and distinguish itself from other opportunities?

• How important is it that GELP develops a strong and
  coherent narrative around technology in education?
  Do we already have one that we could use better?

• What are the strategic partnerships that will enable
  GELP to deliver on its aims now and grow and stay
  relevant in the future?

Scanning GELP's Horizons

  • 1.
    Scanning GELP’s Horizon Exploringthe transforming education, global marketplace
  • 2.
    What and whowe excluded and why
  • 3.
    Networks and forums Research organisations WEF EWF EFF World Economic Forum Global The Education Education ICSEI World Forum International Agenda Fast Forward ATC21S Congress of Council Assessment School and Teaching Effectiveness & of C21st Skills Improvement OECD ILE TES Global WISE Innovative cities World Learning Transforming Innovation for Environment Education Education Network Education Summit Summit Tech companies & foundations Non governmental organisations Pearson Google CISCO Affordable In education & Microsoft Global Learning the Google Partners in Education Fund Academy learning World Bank Group Association Learning for the for All development of education Intel Apple in Africa Promethean Education Amplify Education Distinguished Transformation Strategy educators
  • 4.
    Networks and forums Research organisations WEF EWF EFF World Economic Forum Global The Education Education ICSEI World Forum International Agenda Fast Forward ATC21S Congress of Council Assessment School and Teaching Effectiveness & of C21st Skills Improvement OECD ILE TES Global WISE Innovative cities World Learning Transforming Innovation for Environment Education Education Network Education Summit Summit GELP Tech companies & foundations Non governmental organisations Pearson Google CISCO Affordable In education & Microsoft Global Learning the Google Partners in Education Fund Academy learning World Bank Group Association Learning for the for All development of education Intel Apple in Africa Promethean Education Amplify Education Distinguished Transformation Strategy educators
  • 5.
    WEF EWF EFF World Economic Forum Global The Education Education ICSEI World Forum International Agenda Fast Forward ATC21S Congress of Council Assessment School and Teaching Effectiveness & of C21st Skills Improvement OECD ILE TES Global WISE Innovative cities World Learning Transforming Innovation for Environment Education Education Network Education Summit Summit Google CISCO In education & Microsoft Global the Google Partners in Education Academy learning World Bank Group Association Learning for the for All development of education Intel Apple in Africa Promethean Education Amplify Education Distinguished Transformation Strategy educators
  • 6.
    SYSTEM FOCUS PEDAGOGY FOCUS WEF EWF EFF World Economic Forum Global The Education Education ICSEI World Forum International Agenda Fast Forward ATC21S Congress of Council Assessment School and Teaching Effectiveness & of C21st Skills Improvement OECD ILE TES Global WISE Innovative cities World Learning Transforming Innovation for Environment Education Education Network Education Summit Summit TECHNOLOGY FOCUS DEVELOPMENT FOCUS Google CISCO In education & Microsoft Global the Google Partners in Education Academy learning World Bank Group Association Learning for the for All development of education Intel Apple in Africa Promethean Education Amplify Education Distinguished Transformation Strategy educators
  • 7.
    SYSTEM FOCUS PEDAGOGY FOCUS WEF EWF EFF World Economic Forum Global The Education Education ICSEI World Forum International Agenda Fast Forward ATC21S Congress of Council Assessment School and Teaching Effectiveness & of C21st Skills Improvement OECD ILE TES Global WISE Innovative cities World Learning Transforming Innovation for Environment Education Education Network Education Summit Summit TECHNOLOGY FOCUS GELP DEVELOPMENT FOCUS Google CISCO In education & Microsoft Global the Google Partners in Education Academy learning World Bank Group Association Learning for the for All development Pearson of education Intel Apple Affordable in Africa Promethean Education Amplify Learning Education Distinguished Fund Transformation Strategy educators
  • 8.
    In the realworld, foci overlap SYSTEM PEDAGOGY DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY
  • 9.
  • 10.
    PEDAGOGY GELP TECHNOLOGY
  • 11.
    SYSTEM TECHNOLOGY
  • 12.
    SYSTEM GELP TECHNOLOGY
  • 13.
    SYSTEM PEDAGOGY GELP TECHNOLOGY
  • 14.
    SYSTEM PEDAGOGY GELP DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY
  • 15.
    EFF Education Promethean ICSEI WISE Fast Forward Education International World Strategy Congress of Innovation for School Education Effectiveness & Summit Improvement CISCO EWF Global The TES Education Education Transforming World Forum Education WEF Summit World Economic Forum Global Agenda Council Intel ATC21S OECD ILE Education Assessment Innovative Transformation and Teaching Learning of C21st Skills Microsoft Environment Partners in learning Google Apple Global Pearson Association In education & Amplify World for the Distinguished cities Affordable the Google Bank Group development educators Education Learning Learning Academy of education Network Fund for All in Africa
  • 16.
    EFF Education Promethean ICSEI WISE Fast Forward Education International World Strategy Congress of Innovation for School Education Effectiveness & Summit Improvement CISCO EWF Global The TES Education Education Transforming World Forum Education WEF Summit World Economic GELP Forum Global Agenda Council Intel ATC21S OECD ILE Education Assessment Innovative Transformation and Teaching Learning of C21st Skills Microsoft Environment Partners in learning Google Apple Global Pearson Association In education & Amplify World for the Distinguished cities Affordable the Google Bank Group development educators Education Learning Learning Academy of education Network Fund for All in Africa
  • 17.
    Some questions thatthe scan suggests • How important is it that GELP is able to identify with and distinguish itself from other opportunities? • How important is it that GELP develops a strong and coherent narrative around technology in education? Do we already have one that we could use better? • What are the strategic partnerships that will enable GELP to deliver on its aims now and grow and stay relevant in the future?

Editor's Notes

  • #2 During autumn 2012, the GELP learning team completed a horizon scan to try to discover as much of the global education transformation market place as possible. Our aim was to provide good intelligence to inform conversations about the future of GELP. The short presentation that follows summarises the findings. The full, detailed output from the scan (a large excel spread sheet) is available on request.Our scan discovered 67 opportunities to take part in activities relating to transforming education – opportunities included books and papers to read, networks or forums to join, organisations to subscribe to or buy products and services from. Our criteria were that opportunities should be: about and for education; of international relevance, and preferably global – based in or referring to more than one country; futures oriented i.e. concerned with transforming education to meet the changing needs of the C21st
  • #3 From amongst the 67, we have selected a ‘Top 20’ to explore in more depth. We have excluded – individual researchers and thought leaders; and organisations who are principally active in just one country. Mostly this was the USA. These criteria rule out some important players and some close to our hearts and practice. So its important to acknowledge them here and recognise how significantly they are shaping the transforming education agenda.
  • #4 (I plan to animate this slide so the different sections fall in in sequence with the categories appearing post hoc)So in our Top 20 (there are only 19 here – see if you can guess what #20 is) there are four categories of organisations active in the transforming education global space. We think these organisations are the most active, and most engaged and most visible on the global stage. Its important to note that they are all at different points on an improvement-to-transformation continuum. We are not offering an evaluation of their place on that continuum for the simple reason that many would be on all points on it. Because they are so active and there is diversity within individual opportunities and across the range. For the tech companies and foundations, example and qualifying (for the scan) programmes are shown. But most have more than one.
  • #5 (I plan to animate this slide so the different sections fall in in sequence with the categories appearing post hoc)So in our Top 20 (there are only 19 here – see if you can guess what #20 is) there are four categories of organisations active in the transforming education global space. We think these organisations are the most active, and most engaged and most visible on the global stage. Its important to note that they are all at different points on an improvement-to-transformation continuum. We are not offering an evaluation of their place on that continuum for the simple reason that many would be on all points on it. Because they are so active and there is diversity within individual opportunities and across the range. For the tech companies and foundations, example and qualifying (for the scan) programmes are shown. But most have more than one.
  • #6 (I plan to animate this slide so the different sections fall in in sequence with the categories appearing post hoc)So in our Top 20 (there are only 19 here – see if you can guess what #20 is) there are four categories of organisations active in the transforming education global space. We think these organisations are the most active, and most engaged and most visible on the global stage. Its important to note that they are all at different points on an improvement-to-transformation continuum. We are not offering an evaluation of their place on that continuum for the simple reason that many would be on all points on it. Because they are so active and there is diversity within individual opportunities and across the range. For the tech companies and foundations, example and qualifying (for the scan) programmes are shown. But most have more than one.
  • #7 A more interesting way to analyse the Top 20 is terms of their focus. In every case, the focus offered in this analysis is the principal, web presences, are focused on system change.
  • #8 A more interesting way to analyse the Top 20 is terms of their focus. In every case, the focus offered in this analysis is the principal, web presences, are focused on system change.
  • #9 Actually the world is not so nearly well organised. Agenda, funders and networks overlap considerably. One way to look at this is as mostly a good thing, creating opportunities for efficiencies and value add as the organisations and foci intersect. But there are costs.
  • #10 Although the market is crowded it is still relatively immature with limited demand from early adopter and high leverage participants. If we look just at the intersection between the tech and ped foci, how would a jurisdiction choose between these opportunities to participate. And what is being crowded out?
  • #11 If we plot GELP onto this analysis we’d have to be honest and say that we are stronger and more confident in the pedagogy focus that in the use of technology. In our own (programme) practice and in our refocused discussions about technology in education we are doing better. But given the expertise of jurisdictions and the opportunities available we could be in further into the intersection that we probably are. IS that the right way to think about this? Or should we notice how crowded the space is and differentiate ourselves?
  • #12 There’s a similar problem in the technology v system intersection. Not all of the tech companies are interested in system change, preferring to focus instead on recruiting individual teachers, schools and districts – and in some cases learners. What’s interesting about these opportunities is the scale at which they operate. MS partners in learning currently boasts over 4 million educators in 107 countries amongst its subscribers.
  • #13 There’s a similar problem in the technology v system intersection. Not all of the tech companies are interested in system change, preferring to focus instead on recruiting individual teachers, schools and districts – and in some cases learners. What’s interesting about these opportunities is the scale at which they operate. MS partners in learning currently boasts over 4 million educators in 107 countries amongst its subscribers.
  • #14 This summarises both positions
  • #15 This summarises both positions
  • #16 One final cut of these Top 20. It turns out that more than half are already in a relationship with one another.
  • #17 One final cut of these Top 20. It turns out that more than half are already in a relationship with one another.
  • #18 These are almost certainly wrong – just a first punt…