This document provides summaries of different research study designs by briefly describing examples of each design type. The designs included are: experimental, correlational, survey, grounded theory, ethnographic, narrative research, mixed methods, and action research. For each example a few key details are given such as the research topic, methodology used, and findings or purpose of the study to illustrate how it fits the particular design classification.
An investigation of_factors_influencing_student_use_of_technology_in_k-12_cla...Cathy Cavanaugh
The purpose of this research was to examine the effects of teachers’ characteristics,
school characteristics, and contextual characteristics on classroom
technology integration and teacher use of technology as mediators of student
use of technology. A research-based path model was designed and tested
based on data gathered from 732 teachers from 17 school districts and 107
different schools in the state of Florida. Results show that a teacher’s level
of education and experience teaching with technology positively and significantly
influence his/her use of technology. Teacher use of technology
strongly and positively explains classroom technology integration and
student use of technology. Further, how a teacher integrates technology
into the classroom explains how frequently students use technology in a
school setting. The findings provided significant evidence that the path
model is useful in explaining factors affecting student use of technology
and the relationships among the factors.
In the discovery with models method identification relationships among students behaviors and characteristics or contextual variables are key applications.
Teaching models, concept attainment model, four phases of this model, social system, Principles of reactions, support system, application, Inquiry training model, 3 phases, social system, support system, classroom application
EFFECTIVENESS OF CO-OPERATIVE LEARNING METHOD IN LEARNING OF MATHEMATICS AMON...Thiyagu K
Co-operative learning is defined as students working together to “attain groups goals that cannot be obtained by working alone or competitively”. The main purpose of co-operative learning is to actively involve students in the learning process, a level of student empowerment which is not possible in a lecture format. The present study found out the effectiveness of co-operative learning in mathematics learning among the eighth standard students of Tirunelveli district. Two equivalent group experimental-designs are employed for this study. The investigator has selected 40 students studying VIII standard in High School, Tirunelveli Educational District. According to the scoring of pre-test, 20 students were chosen as control group and 20 students were chosen as experimental group in a cluster sampling techniques. Finally the investigator concludes that; (a) There was significant difference between control and experimental group students in their gain scores. That is the experimental group student is better than control group students in their gain scores. (b)There was significant difference between control and experimental group students in their gain scores for attainment of the knowledge, understanding, and application objectives.
An investigation of_factors_influencing_student_use_of_technology_in_k-12_cla...Cathy Cavanaugh
The purpose of this research was to examine the effects of teachers’ characteristics,
school characteristics, and contextual characteristics on classroom
technology integration and teacher use of technology as mediators of student
use of technology. A research-based path model was designed and tested
based on data gathered from 732 teachers from 17 school districts and 107
different schools in the state of Florida. Results show that a teacher’s level
of education and experience teaching with technology positively and significantly
influence his/her use of technology. Teacher use of technology
strongly and positively explains classroom technology integration and
student use of technology. Further, how a teacher integrates technology
into the classroom explains how frequently students use technology in a
school setting. The findings provided significant evidence that the path
model is useful in explaining factors affecting student use of technology
and the relationships among the factors.
In the discovery with models method identification relationships among students behaviors and characteristics or contextual variables are key applications.
Teaching models, concept attainment model, four phases of this model, social system, Principles of reactions, support system, application, Inquiry training model, 3 phases, social system, support system, classroom application
EFFECTIVENESS OF CO-OPERATIVE LEARNING METHOD IN LEARNING OF MATHEMATICS AMON...Thiyagu K
Co-operative learning is defined as students working together to “attain groups goals that cannot be obtained by working alone or competitively”. The main purpose of co-operative learning is to actively involve students in the learning process, a level of student empowerment which is not possible in a lecture format. The present study found out the effectiveness of co-operative learning in mathematics learning among the eighth standard students of Tirunelveli district. Two equivalent group experimental-designs are employed for this study. The investigator has selected 40 students studying VIII standard in High School, Tirunelveli Educational District. According to the scoring of pre-test, 20 students were chosen as control group and 20 students were chosen as experimental group in a cluster sampling techniques. Finally the investigator concludes that; (a) There was significant difference between control and experimental group students in their gain scores. That is the experimental group student is better than control group students in their gain scores. (b)There was significant difference between control and experimental group students in their gain scores for attainment of the knowledge, understanding, and application objectives.
Project Opera (Operation Rational): A Tool In Bridging The Learning GAPS In F...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT : The study was conducted to determine the Mathematical performance of the students. The
study aimed to evaluate the effect of project opera in the mathematical performance of the students during pretest and post-test performance in fractions. The study employed the quasi -experimental one group-pre-test-posttest research design. The paired t-test was employed to establish the existence of significant difference between
pre-and post-test scores in fractions.
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...oircjournals
School examination results the world over are arguably the most important measure of perceived success or failure
of a candidate. It has been pointed out by the Nyanza Provincial Education Board that the province’s performance in
examinations and the quality of education in general is unsatisfactory and inadequate. The paper sought to determine
the contribution of teacher qualification to students’ scores. The study adopted the Theory of Organisational Climate
which defines organisational climate as the human environment within which an organization’s employees do their
work. A case study and survey design was used. Purposive sampling was used to identify the four schools under study
and form three students. Simple random sampling was used to select the respondents of the study. Data was analyzed
using both qualitative and quantitative using descriptive statistics in particular percentages and means. The study
found that teachers’ qualifications affect teaching ability while knowledge of teachers’ subject was among the major
teacher factors contributing to students’ academic achievements.
Practicality and Effectiveness of Student’ Worksheets Based on Ethno science ...IJAEMSJORNAL
Generally, the learning process in classes still used worksheets that does not link the matter and instructional topics with local knowledge of local area. Though it is able to increase the students' conceptual understanding of the specific physics topics. This study aimed to analyze the practicality and effectiveness student’ worksheet based on Ethno science in improving student understanding of rigid body’ concept. The study used a quasi-experimental with pretest-post test control group design. The sample was students’ senior high school in Lampung’ province, Indonesia. The sampling technique used simple random sampling technique. Data were obtain through the questionnaire, responses of teachers and students, and test of learning outcome in multiple choice questions reasoned type. Data were analyzed by percentage, N-gain, and effect size. The results showed that student worksheet based on Ethno science was practically using in learning and effective in improving conceptual understanding which is indicated by the differences in test results between the control and the experimental class.
Running Header PROJECT BASED LEARNING PROJECT BASED LEARNING .docxagnesdcarey33086
Running Header: PROJECT BASED LEARNING
PROJECT BASED LEARNING 6
Effects of project based learning on education
Marcus Coleman
Ashford University
Effects of in cooperating Project based Learning in the school curriculum
Introduction
Learning is determined by a number of factors, some of which are environmental related while others are not. The approach of teaching is one of the major determinants of learning as far classroom learning is concerned, however there has been a concern that the current approaches to learning are a little too abstract. Lack of real life scenarios and too much theory has been responsible for the growing apathy towards learning. It is for this reason that studies are being contacted to see if the change in tact can improve learning. One of the suggested ways is the project based learning approach which uses non fictional concepts for teaching.
Purpose of the study
The purpose of this study is to find out the effects of in cooperating project based learning in the school curriculum. The study seeks to ascertain if there is any relationship between projects based learning and the improvement in scores for students (Daniel 2012). Previous studies have shown that students are likely to improve in cases where some form of simulation or use of no fictional material. According to these, the use of non fictional approaches stimulates the students to look at issues from the reality perspective hence making it easy to internalize whatever they are learning for the sake of being able to remember, however these studies have not clearly explained the actual relationships that exist between the performance and the project based learning. There are other factors which could have in for the findings to be so, for those studies, this study would critically examine the direct impact that project based learning has on students.
Research questions
1. Will the incorporation of project based learning improve students state assessment scores as it relates to the common core state standards in comprehending non fiction text?
2. Will the inclusion of project based learning improve student application of comprehending non fictional text at a high depth of learning level?
3. How does project based learning integrate clear expectations and essential criteria and remain successful
In research, data is an important factor because it is the one which determines the findings and recommendations for the, decisions to be made (Peter 2011). The main data collection methods will be observation, interviews and artifacts, questionnaires will also be used to collect data concerning the stakeholders. Observation will be effective tools for confirming how students behave in classes, when the various approaches are used. Students will be observed in a classroom setting and comparisons be made between those classes that imp.
THE IMPACT OF SIMULATION ON TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS AND STUDENT LEARNING PERFO...IJITE
Simulation Strategy Is Increasingly Becoming A Popular Educational Tool In The Production Of Highly Qualified Professionals In The Field Of Education, Health, And Applied Sciences. Particularly, The Strategy Helps Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. This Research Paper Aimed At Investigating The Effectiveness Of Simulation In Teaching And Student Learning Performance In The University Context. The Study Was Important Since It Highlighted How Different Kinds Of Simulation Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. The Explanatory Research Design Was Used In This Research Where Data Was Collected Using Close-Ended Questionnaires Designed To Utilize Likert Scale Described In The Methodology Section. The Study Targeted 150 Student Participants. However, Only 134 Students Filled And Returned Their Questionnaires. Both Descriptive And Statistical Analysis Techniques Were Applied In This Research. Descriptive Statistics, Particularly Percentages Were Used In Describing Participant Information. Also, Statistical Analysis Was Used In Determining Reliability Of The Questionnaire As Well As For Hypothesis Testing. The Study Indicated That Social Process Simulation, Diagnostic Simulation, And Data Management Simulation Have A Statistically Significant Positive Relationship With Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. Based On The Findings, It Was Concluded And Recommended That Teachers And Students Should Accept The Use Of Simulation In Their Classroom To Enhance Their Classroom Outcomes.
THE IMPACT OF SIMULATION ON TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS AND STUDENT LEARNING PERFO...IJITE
Simulation Strategy Is Increasingly Becoming A Popular Educational Tool In The Production Of Highly
Qualified Professionals In The Field Of Education, Health, And Applied Sciences. Particularly, The
Strategy Helps Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. This
Research Paper Aimed At Investigating The Effectiveness Of Simulation In Teaching And Student Learning
Performance In The University Context. The Study Was Important Since It Highlighted How Different
Kinds Of Simulation Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. The
Explanatory Research Design Was Used In This Research Where Data Was Collected Using Close-Ended
Questionnaires Designed To Utilize Likert Scale Described In The Methodology Section. The Study
Targeted 150 Student Participants. However, Only 134 Students Filled And Returned Their Questionnaires.
Both Descriptive And Statistical Analysis Techniques Were Applied In This Research. Descriptive
Statistics, Particularly Percentages Were Used In Describing Participant Information. Also, Statistical
Analysis Was Used In Determining Reliability Of The Questionnaire As Well As For Hypothesis Testing.
The Study Indicated That Social Process Simulation, Diagnostic Simulation, And Data Management
Simulation Have A Statistically Significant Positive Relationship With Teaching Practice Effectiveness And
Student Learning Performance. Based On The Findings, It Was Concluded And Recommended That
Teachers And Students Should Accept The Use Of Simulation In Their Classroom To Enhance Their
Classroom Outcomes.
This research aimed to find out the difference of cognitive learning achievement between students taught with Concept Attainment Model and those taught with Discovery Learning model. This study was a quasiexperimental research. The population of research was the 12th Science graders of SMAN 1 Karas of Magetan Regency in school year of 2016/2017. The sample was taken using cluster random sampling technique, consisting of two grades: the 12th Science 4 grade as the first experiment class using Concept Attainment Model and the 12th Science 3 grade as the second experiment class using Discovery Learning model. Technique of collecting data used was t-test technique for data of students’ cognitive learning outcome. Data analysis was carried out using unpaired two-sample variance analysis. The result of research showed there was a difference of cognitive learning outcome between the students treated with learning using Concept Attainment Model and those treated with learning using Discovery Learning. The cognitive learning achievement of students taught with Concept Attainment Model was higher than that of those taught with Discovery Learning.
Author One
Author Two
Author Three
Author Four
Author Five
Type and purpose
of study
Type means qualitative, quantitative, or mixed methods research.
Hypothesis or Research Questions
Both quantitative and qualitative research can have research questions, but only quantitative can have hypotheses.
Population
and
Sample
Methodology
Examples are case study, grounded theory, ethnography, quasi-experimental design etc.
Findings
We call it findings in qualitative research and results in quantitative research.
Evaluation
notes
Look for the limitations to the study. Small sample size, not generalizable, bias of researcher etc.
How will the study help your research or why are you rejecting it?
Stern’s (2015) Note Taking Table
Article One
Enabling school structures, collegial trust and academic emphasis: Antecedents of professionals learning
Article Two
Enhancing self-efficacy in elementary science teaching with Professional Learning Communities
Article Three
Teacher's perceptions and implementation of professional learning communities in a large Suburban School
Type and purpose
of study
Type means qualitative, quantitative, or mixed methods research.
The study examines the roles of ESS, trust and academic significance in the enlargement of PLC
The main aim of the study was to find out if there existed a relationship between the application of CL by elementary schools and the implementation of PLCs and other blocks that prevented the use of CL.
The main aim of this article was to understand the teachers’ take before and after the implementation of PLCs in the school. It was to provide more information on majorly three areas that is retention and success of students, retaining of teachers and lastly, teachers’ perception on leadership.
Hypothesis or Research Questions
Both quantitative and qualitative research can have research questions, but only quantitative can have hypotheses.
How is enabling structure of importance in the development of PLCs?
What is the role of collegial trust ?
How did self-efficacy of the teachers change during the period when the professional program was developed?
How did teacher instructional practice altered over time?
How did the results of expectancy change during that time?
What was the teachers’ perception before the implementation of PLCs?
How did the teachers react to the implementation of PLCs?
How teachers perceived leadership?
Population
and
Sample
General group being studied, size of sample or number of participants, age(s), gender, etc.
A survey was collected from 67 schools.
The concerned group was elementary school teacher. Different schools were picked and the research carried out in the sample of the concerned teams.
The study conducted with a population of 190 teachers from a district school and three more schools were included. The sample contained at least two teachers in each subject except in mathematics which had t.
THE IMPACT OF SIMULATION ON TEACHING EFFECTIVENESS AND STUDENT LEARNING PERFO...IJITE
Simulation Strategy Is Increasingly Becoming A Popular Educational Tool In The Production Of Highly Qualified Professionals In The Field Of Education, Health, And Applied Sciences. Particularly, The Strategy Helps Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. This Research Paper Aimed At Investigating The Effectiveness Of Simulation In Teaching And Student Learning Performance In The University Context. The Study Was Important Since It Highlighted How Different Kinds Of Simulation Improve Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. The Explanatory Research Design Was Used In This Research Where Data Was Collected Using Close-Ended Questionnaires Designed To Utilize Likert Scale Described In The Methodology Section. The Study Targeted 150 Student Participants. However, Only 134 Students Filled And Returned Their Questionnaires. Both Descriptive And Statistical Analysis Techniques Were Applied In This Research. Descriptive Statistics, Particularly Percentages Were Used In Describing Participant Information. Also, Statistical Analysis Was Used In Determining Reliability Of The Questionnaire As Well As For Hypothesis Testing. The Study Indicated That Social Process Simulation, Diagnostic Simulation, And Data Management Simulation Have A Statistically Significant Positive Relationship With Teaching Practice Effectiveness And Student Learning Performance. Based On The Findings, It Was Concluded And Recommended That Teachers And Students Should Accept The Use Of Simulation In Their Classroom To Enhance Their Classroom Outcomes.
1. Experimental Design:
Ysseldyke, J., Spicuzza, R., Kosciolek, S., Teelucksingh, E., Boys, C., & Lemkuil, A.
(2003). Using a curriculum-based instructional management system to enhance math
achievement in urban schools. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk, 8(2),
247-265. Retrieved July 10, 2009, Academic Search Complete database.
The authors of this article conducted their research based on a computerized curriculum-
based instructional management system called Accelerated Math (AM). The students in
the AM group showed significant increase in math tests scores when suggested
intervention strategies were fully implemented. This research identifies positive effects
of a computer software package that accelerated the math achievement of at risk students
when used properly and fully. This research is a good example of an experimental design
due to the inclusion of a controlled experiment. There was a group of students who used
to AM, while a similar group did not use the strategies of the AM program. Therefore,
this experiment included a dependent variable and an independent variable making it an
experimental design.
Correlational Design:
Passolunghi, M., Mammarella, I., & Altoè, G. (2008). Cognitive abilities as precursors of
the early acquisition of mathematical skills during first through second grades.
Developmental Neuropsychology, 33(3), 229-250. doi:10.1080/87565640801982320.
The researchers in this study wanted to determine precursors of mathematical
2. achievement in young children. They used path analysis and a longitudinal model to test
72 children in first grade and then followed them to second grade to be tested again. The
students were tested on phonology, short-term memory, counting competence, and
working memory. In first grade the students were also tested on verbal and performance
IQ as well. The researchers discovered with the longitudinal model that the students’
working memory in both grades predicted the students’ achievement in mathematics. The
final results showed that working memory can be a mediator in predicting mathematics
achievement in young school age children. This is an example of a correlational design
because there are two or more variables being tested to see if they influence each other.
There is also the opportunity to predict outcomes of the relationship between the
variables.
Survey Design:
Penuel, W. R., Boscardin, C. K., Masyn, K., & Crawford, V. M. (2007). Teaching with
student response systems in elementary and secondary education settings: survey study.
Educational Technology Research & Development, 55(4), 315-346.
doi:10.1007/s11423-006-9023-4. Retrieved July 8, 2009, Academic Search Complete
database.
In this article, an online survey was given to 498 elementary and secondary educators
about how they use student response systems in their classrooms. The authors studied the
teachers’ goals for the response systems, their instructional strategies and the effects of
the response systems they have seen within each of their classrooms. Based on the
3. comments made by several of the teachers, it was evident that the response systems can
be used in multiple content areas and for teaching and/or assessing. This research would
be classified as a survey design because the researchers are evaluating whether or not a
strategy or program tool is effective in the classroom and they seek their answers from
the teachers themselves through an online questionnaire. More specifically, this research
can be considered a cross-sectional survey design due to it taking place at one single
time.
Grounded Theory Design:
Skeat, J., & Perry, A. (2008). Grounded theory as a method for research in speech and
language therapy. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 43(2),
95-109. Retrieved from E-Journals database.
The authors of this article seek to explain the importance of qualitative research in the
field of speech and language therapy and its usefulness to the profession. According to
the article, not much qualitative research exists in this area and the researchers seek to
create a theory that grounded theory design does in fact have a lot to offer to the speech
and language therapy field. This article reflects a grounded theory design in that the
authors are seeking to generate their own theory that grounded theory design is beneficial
to speech and language therapists and qualitative research.
4. Ethnographic Design:
Siegel, C. (2005). An ethnographic inquiry of cooperative learning implementation.
Journal of School Psychology, 43(3), 219-239. doi:10.1016/j.jsp.2005.04.005.
This study included five middle school science and math teachers who were trained in a
certain program and their variations in implementing cooperative learning. The author
was seeking to determine if cooperative learning experiences are the answer to the
socialization and achievement crisis. The author used the ethnographic design to study
this problem by persistent observations and interpretation of the actual act of cooperative
learning taking place. By studying the smaller group so closely and persistently, some of
the findings can be applied to the larger group, thus explaining the ethnographic
approach.
Narrative Research Design:
Russell, C., & Timmons, S. (2009). Life story work and nursing home residents with
dementia. Nursing Older People, 21(4), 28-32. Retrieved from Academic Search
Complete database.
The researchers in this study used a narrative research design to gain insights into the
lives of people suffering from dementia. The authors listened to five different individuals
with dementia talk about their lives and what they remember about themselves. The
authors learned that people with dementia are unique individuals and not a homogeneous
group. Narrative research seeks to report the stories of individual people who wish to
5. share the stories and this article does just that of these five people.
Mixed Methods Design:
Wright, R., Guadagno, B., & Powell, M. (2009). An evaluation of a self-initiated practice
exercise for investigative interviewers of children. International Journal of Police Science
& Management, 11(3), 366-376. doi:10.1350/ijps.2009.11.3.141.
For this study, there were 40 investigative interviewers who were recruited to take part in
a distance education class about practicing proper techniques in interviewing. The
participants were required to do pre-post measure of performance (a quantitative
approach) and create and maintain a practice diary (a qualitative approach). The results
showed the need for careful monitoring and evaluation of all of the practices that the
interviewers should adhere to. The authors of the study used both qualitative and
quantitative analyses making this a prime example of a mixed methods research design.
Action Research Design:
Sullivan, M. (2005). Teaching mathematics to college students with mathematics-related
learning disabilities: report from the classroom. Learning Disability Quarterly, 28(3),
205-220. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete database.
The author of this study had a very specific educational problem that needed solving,
6. “How would college students who have mathematics-related LD perform in a course
where making sense of mathematics is a critical component, where explaining one’s work
is expected, and where discourse among member s if common practice?” Therefore, this
study is an example of an action research design. The author designed her class around
helping the three LD students make sense of the mathematics she was teaching.