SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics
Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020, pp. 588~593
ISSN: 2302-9285, DOI: 10.11591/eei.v9i2.2089  588
Journal homepage: http://beei.org
Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic
ovarian syndrome
A. A. Nazarudin1, Noraishikin Zulkarnain2, A. Hussain3, S. S. Mokri4, I. N. A. M. Nordin5
1,2,3,4
Centre for Integrated Systems Engineering and Advanced Technologies (INTEGRA), Faculty of Built
and Environment, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia
1,2,3,4
Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering, Faculty of Built and Environment, Universiti
Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia
5
Cybernetics Research Group, Faculty of Engineering Technology, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia
Article Info ABSTRACT
Article history:
Received Sep 18, 2019
Revised Nov 21, 2019
Accepted Dec 28, 2019
Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS), is a condition of the ovary consisting
numerous follicles. Accurate size and number of follicles detected are crucial
for treatment. Hence the diagnosis of this condition is by measuring
and calculating the size and number of follicles existed in the ovary.
To diagnosis, ultrasound imaging has become an effective tool as it is non
invasive, inexpensive and portable. However, the presence of speckle noise
in ultrasound imaging has caused an obstruction for manual diagnosis which
are high time consumption and often produce errors. Thus, image
segmentation for ultrasound imaging is critical to identify follicles for PCOS
diagnosis and proper health treatment. This paper presents different methods
proposed and applied in automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis
by previous researchers. In this paper, the methods and performance
evaluation are identified and compared. Finally, this paper also provided
suggestions in developing methods for future research.
Keywords:
Automated segmentation
Follicle identification
Image segmentation
PCOS
Polycystic ovarian syndrome
This is an open access article under the CC BY-SA license.
Corresponding Author:
Noraishikin Zulkarnain,
Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering,
Centre for Integrated Systems Engineering and Advanced Technologies (INTEGRA),
Faculty of Built and Environment, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia,
43200 UKM, Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia.
Email: shikinzulkarnain@ukm.edu.my
1. INTRODUCTION
Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome, -or commonly known as PCOS is described as a condition
of numerous primordial follicles in the ovary. This disorder is diagnosed by ultrasound imaging which gives
important information on the ovarian follicle quantity and size. Ovarian follicles are spherical, fluid-filled
structures in which oocytes (eggs) develop. In two dimensional ultrasound imaging, ovarian follicles
appeared as dark, roughly circular regions. In PCOS, the condition is characterized as having 12 or more
follicles in the ovary with the size of 2-9 mm and/or the volume of 10 cm3 [1]. The number and size
of follicles in the ovary is vital in a healthy women’s reproductive system, especially those who are trying to
conceive. Ultrasound imaging are non-invasive, portable and inexpensive. Therefore ovarian ultrasound
imaging has become an effective tool in PCOS diagnosis and ovarian follicle identification. However,
ultrasound imaging has poor quality of images which disturbed by speckle noise [2]. This disturbance are
causing difficulties to recognize the ovarian follicles especially by medical practitioners with manual
diagnosis. Manual diagnosis and identification is laborious, time consuming and often produce errors [3].
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin)
589
Thus, many researchers have been working on developing an automated algorithm to identify ovarian
follicles for PCOS diagnosis.
In developing an automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis system, the follicles
are the regions of interest (ROIs) in an ovarian ultrasound image, which need to be detected using image
processing techniques. The basic image processing steps consist of pre-processing, segmentation, feature
extraction and classification [4]. One of the crucial steps is segmentation, where this is to help identifying
region of interest, namely the follicles. Hence the automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis
systemis to identify the number and size of ovarian follicles using image segmentation.
Among the earliest study of automated follicle identification using image processing are led by
Krivanek et al. [5] in 1998 and Potocnik et al. [6] in 2002. In their research, Potocnik [6] highlighted
the difficulties of recognising smaller follicles and distingushing adjacent follicles which has no expressive
boundaries to each other. Later on, in 2017, Faghih et al. [7] raised the same issues while reviewing
the literature for their studies. Based on previous studies, the smaller follicles or follicles that are adjacent to
each other were neglected or unnoticed and some methods have the tendency of over-segmenting which will
effect the treatment given.
Based on previous comparative studies in automated follicle identification for PCOS
diagnosis [2-3, 8], researchers concluded it is needed to develop algorithm in removing the speckle noise in
the ultrasound image effectively and to investigate features extraction for classification of the ovary.
Thus, this paper objective is to review previous methods of image segmentation in ultrasound image
for automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis; the methods applied and the parameter for
evaluation. To study the image segmentation methods applied by previous researchers, this paper applied
snowball method. This method had focused on the literature regarding automated follicles identification
in ovarian ultrasound images. Therefore, the review on different methods and performance evaluation will be
presented. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: in section 2 describes the methods suggested
by previous researchers. Later in section 3 is shown the table review for the methods of automated follicle
identification with performance evaluation. In section 4 is the conclusion and future work suggestions.
2. IMAGE SEGMENTATION METHODS
Medical practitioners have been using ovarian ultrasound images to diagnose PCOS condition.
This is due to ultrasound is non-invasive and less time consuming. In ultrasound, the image of follicles in
the ovaries will appear as roughly dark circles. The images of normal and polycystic ovary as shown in
the Figures 1 and 2.
From these images, medical practitioners will manually calculate the size and number of follicles
existed. However, this approach is time consuming and often produce errors. Therefore, researchers have
been developing and exploring an automated image segmentation for follicle identification to diagnose
PCOS condition. Various research groups have devised different automated image segmentation techniques
for follicle identification. Among the foremost groups are led by Krivanek et al. [5] in 1998 and Potocnik et
al. in 2002 [6]. In image segmentation for automated follicle identification, researchers applied various
methods with improvisations namely watershed transform, thresholding, region based growing, edge based,
clustering, artificial neural network and mathematical morphology. This section presents an overview
of researches on automated follicle identification techniques.
Figure 1. Normal ovary [8] Figure 2. Polycystic ovary [8]
2.1. Watershed transform
Krivanek and Sonka [5] introduced a multistep automated segmentation employing watershed
segmentation and graph search method to determine the inner border of the follicles. In the application of this
 ISSN: 2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020 : 588 – 593
590
method, minimal manual segmentation by medical practitioner was involved. The evaluation of this
technique was by comparing the maximum and root mean square (RMS) borders positioning between
computer-determined and observer-defined. It was shown that the RMS for computer-determined is more
accurate. In 2011, Deng et al. [9] proposed an enhanced watershed algorithm, namely labeled watershed
algortihm for local minima extraction because the classic watershed algorithm often leads to excessive
segmentation and needs minimal medical practitioner interaction. The labeled watershed algoritm was
applied after adaptive morphological filtering of image.
In the research for a novel real-time follicle identification, [7] Faghih et al. applied watershed
algorithm for the condition if there is a possibility of multiple follicles existed in the region of interest of
a very dark image with high percentage of dark pixels. This algorithm was introduced to minimize the faulty
in ignoring the follicles which are adjacent to each other or too small for segmentation. Some researchers
applied watershed segmentation method as image enhancement, in the pre-processing stage of image
processing,for ultrasound image [10-11].
2.2. Region growing method
Potocnik et al. in 2002 [6], proposed region growing method by making the homogenous region
of interest grow until they clash with the object’s boundary. The recognition rate of this method was
around 78%. However, they concluded this method had the difficulties in detecting smaller follicles due to
their brightness and poorly perceivable. This method was modified with two additional criteria to merge with
region of interest [12]. Lawrence [12] highlighted, although the modified method is known as a better follicle
recognition rate, it is lacking in robustness. They suggested for deploying a more robust automated follicle
identification in the future.
In 2011, Deng et al. [9] constructed a cost map for the region growing method and assigned a cost
function to the cost map for follicle identification. This method is more effective than the two mentioned
above and achieved higher rate of follicle identification. By utilizing spatial connectivity of follicles
and the contour of ovary, Sitheswaran et al. [10] constructed cost map depending one the pixel’s relative
location for region growing algorithm. The recognition rate was the same as Deng et al. In 2015, Adiwijaya
applied region growing method where aims to compare both the identified seed and homogeneous region to
enlarge its region for reaching the real follicle limits [13]. However this method limited to ultrasound image
with homogeneity, where as most ovarian ultrasound images are inhomogeneous.
2.3. Edge based method
Edge based method for image segmentation falls into two categories: gradient based method and soft
computing approach [2]. In this section, the category of edge based method widely found on literature is
the gradient based method. Researchers applied the gradient based method with Canny operator [14-17].
There are few others operators for edge based method in segmentation such as Sobel, Prewitt but based on
the review, it is found that most researcher applied Canny operator for edge based method as Canny operator
gave the most satisfying result [14]. Hiremath et al. [14] compared edge based method segmentation with
manual segmentation done by medical practitioner. It was shown that the increase of false acceptance rate
and false rejection rate of the proposed method is lower than the manual segmentation. Thus the proposed
method was more efficient. Considering follicles are in circular shape with areas about 4-80 mm2 for PCOS
ovarian follicle and about 314 mm2 for normal ovarian follicle, threshold values for area of each region of
interest is calculated and number of important follicles identified is found out [15].
2.4. Active contour method
Among the commonly applied method for image segmentation for ovarian ultrasound image is
active contour without edge based. In segmentation stage, Hiremath and Tegnoor [18] applied this method
for ovarian ultrasound image segmentation to detect the follicles existed. The average of the proposed
method was 96.66% with 3.33% false rejection rate. Later they applied this method while introducing fuzzy
logic inference for ovary classification [19].
In 2015, Kumar and Srinivasan [20] improved this method by improvising the Chan-Vase method
and combining with Split Bregman optimization to help with identifying small follicles of less than 2mm
diameter. The average computational time for the proposed method is 24.15 seconds. In 2017, Lestari [21]
applied morphological operation to the Chan-Vase model to remove imperfections that appeared during
segmentation and achieved a better result. Meanwhile, Faghih [8] applied active contour method for
the condition where the percentage of the very dark pixels in a compressed image is very low to create a new
binary mask before morphological processing.
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin)
591
2.5. Thresholding method
In this method, it attempts to determine an intensity value, called the threshold, of the image by
creating binary partitioning of the image intensities. The segmentation is achieved by grouping the pixels
with greater intensities of the threshold into one class[22]. The pixels darker than their surrounding were
scanned row wise (horizontal scanning) and column wise (vertical scanning) [23]. Then the resulted image
is fused to get the dark follicle in the white background. Mehrotra [23] applied this method and in their
research the difference in the error rate is less compared to manual segmentation. Meanwhile Rihana [24]
achieved a promising result of 90% accurancy for this method.
2.6. Clustering method
Clustering method to group the pixels based on similarity. In image segmentation of ovarian
ultrasound for PCOS, two different clustering algorithms were applied by researchers. Fuzzy c-means
clustering was applied for the segmentation of follicles from the ovarian ultrasound images. This method’s
performance was calculated using means square error (MSE). The lesser the MSE, the better the efficiency
of the method [25]. Park [26] proposed fuzzy c-means clustering as an alternative for image segmentation
of brachial ultrasound image. Another clustering algorithm is K-Means clustering algorithm [27]. For this
algorithm, authors evaluated structural similarity, false acceptance rate and false rejection rate to show its
efficiency. In 2016, Lee applied K-Means clustering algorithm to detect cervical vertebrae with ultrasound
image and achieved a success percentage of96% accurancy [28].
3. REVIEW TABLE
In this section, the table for image segmentation techniques applied for follicle identification in
PCOS diagnosis by previous researchers and the performance evaluation for each research based on section 2
is presented. Table 1 shows the list of papers which studied the automated follicle identification for PCOS
diagnosis. In the table, the techniques applied and performance evaluation were explained briefly. Each
of the method applied required different parameters of evaluation. From the table, it shows that recognition
rate and acceptance rate are among the significantly used parameter for accurancy evaluation of automated
follicle identification. The higher the recognition rate and acceptance rate indicates the higher the accurancy
of the algorithm applied. By far, the highest recognition rate in automated follicle identification is done by
Padmapriya [13] in 2016 with recognition rate of 87.5% using morphological operation with edge based
method using Canny operator. However, in their study, the size of the ovarian follicles was not involved.
Based on PCOS definition, the number and size of ovarian follicles existed are one of the determining factors
of the syndrome. Hence, the method proposed by Padmapriya is only applicable for cystic ovarian case and
further study needed to be done for this method on PCOS condition.
Table 1. Technique and performance evaluation of image segmentation in ultrasound images
Ref. Author, Year Paper Title Technique Performance Evaluation
[6]
Krivanek,Sonka,
1998
Ovarian ultrasoundimage
analysis: follicle segmentation
Watershed
transform
Root-mean-square borderpositioningerror
andmaximum value decrease indicates the
proposedmethodis more accurate.
[7]
Potocnik, Zazula,
2002
Automatedanalysis of a
sequencingof ovarian
ultrasoundimages. Part I:
segmentationofsingle 2D
images
Region growing
method
Recognitionrate (RR) offollicles is 78%
andmisidentificationrate (MR)is 29%.
[12] Lawrence, 2007
Computer assisted detectionof
polycystic ovary morphology in
ultrasoundimages
Modifiedregion
growingmethod
Recognitionrate offollicles (RR) is 83.1%
andmisidentificationrate (MR)is 31.1%.
[9] Deng, 2011
An automateddiagnostic system
of polycysticovarysyndrome
based on object background
Cost map, region
growingmethod,
cost function
Increase value of tuningparameterbeta
indicates high recognitionrate,
misidentificationrate.
[10]
Sitheswaran,
Malarkhodi, 2014
An effective automatedsystem
in follicle identification for
polycystic ovary syndrome
using ultrasoundimages
Cost map
dependingon
pixel’s relative
location, region
growingmethod
Tuningparameterbeta (β) value increase
showedincrease in recognitionrate (RR)
andmisidentificationrate (MR). F1 score
is desireable when tuningparameteris 6
with RR 84.04%andMR 5.9%
[13] Adiwijaya, 2015
Follicle detectionon theUSG
images to support determination
of polycysticovarysyndrome
Region growing
(region basedand
seed based)
Average success of recognition rate80%
when the empirical value for region based
is 1 while for seedbased the recognition
rate is 79.86% when thresval value is
0.005.
 ISSN: 2302-9285
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020 : 588 – 593
592
Ref. Author, Year Paper Title Technique Performance Evaluation
[14]
Hiremath,
Tegnoor, 2010
Automatic detection offollicles
in ultrasoundimages of ovaries
using edge based method
Edge based
method(Canny
operator)
False acceptance rate (FAR)andfalse
rejectionrate (FRR) showincrease in
efficiency theaccurancyof the proposed
method.
[18] Padmapriya, 2016
Detectionof follicles in poly
cystic ovariansyndrome in
ultrasoundimages
usingmorphological operations
Morphological
operationwith
edge based
method(Canny
operator)
The average recognitionrate for all the
images processedby the proposedmethod
is87.5%
[16]
Hiremath,
Tegnoor2010
Follicle detectionin ultrasound
images of ovaries usingactive
contour method
Active contour
without edge
based
Lesser false rejection rateandfalse
acceptance ratein proposedmethod
indicates the accurancy offollicle
identificationincreased.
[17]
Kumar,
Srinivasan 2015
Fast automatic segmentationof
polycystic ovary in ultrasound
images using improvisedchan-
vase methodwith split-bregman
optimization
ImprovisedChan-
Vase with Split
Bregman
optimization
Average computational timeis 24.15
seconds. Dice coefficient is 0.8772.
[23] Mehrotra,2011
Automatedovarianfollicle
recognition for polycysticovary
syndrome
Scanline
thresholding
Difference in theerrorrate is lesser
indicates the effectiveness of theproposed
method.
[24] Rihana, 2013
Automatedalgortihm for
ovarian cysts detection in
ultrasonogram
Scanline
thresholding
Foundaccurancy of 90% as a promising
result with 88.33% sensitivityand95%
specificity.
[25] Raj, 2013
Detectionof cysts in ultrasonic
images of ovary
C-Means
Clustering
Lesser mean square error (MSE) in peak
signal to noise radio (PSNR).
[27]
Kiruthika, Ramya
2014
Automatic segmentation of
ovarian follicle usingk-means
clustering
K-Means
Clustering
Structural similarity (SSIM) increase
indicates the propose methodis more
efficient andaccurate.
4. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK
Polycystic ovarian syndrome most commonly diagnosed by ultrasound by medical practitioners as it
is inexpensive and non-invasive. In PCOS diagnosis it is important to know the size and number of ovarian
follicles that portray the characteristic of this syndrome for medical practitioner to administrate the correct
treatment. Manual follicle identification in ultrasound image have the flaws of time consuming and often
produce errors. Due to that reason, automated follicle identification methods have been explored by many
researchers and still being develop for better diagnosis in the future. This review paper has surveyed image
segmentation techniques and algorithmproposed by many researches. Automated follicle identification eases
the laborious work faced by medical practitioners. Various forms of image processing techniques have been
applied for automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis.
While reviewing the literature, some researchers highlighted the condition of small follicles or
adjacent follicles were neglected or unnoticed. This condition can seriously affects the treatment given and
health condition of the patient. Other than that, each of the method applied does not apply the same
pre-processing filtering algorithm to remove the speckle noise. This has led to different parameter of
evaluation. Thus, in the future, further research is needed to develop the method to remove the speckle noise
in the ultrasound images effectively and explore available methods for ovarian ultrasound images in
identifying follicles, including the smaller follicles and that are adjacent to each other.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to sincerely thank to Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia for the support
and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) for the facilities and equipment provided for this research.
This work is fully supported by Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia under FRGS research Grant
(Vote no. FRGS/1/2018/TK04/UKM/02/15) and research university Grant (Vote no. GGPM-2017-087).
REFERENCES
[1] S. Jonard et al., “Ultrasound examination of polycystic ovaries: is it worth counting the follicles?,” Human
Reproduction, vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 598-603, 2003.
[2] R. Saranya and S. U. Maheswari, “A Literature Review on Computer Assisted Detection of Follicles in Ultrasound
Images of Ovary,” International Journal of Computer Applications, vol. 48, no. 12, pp. 39-40, June 2012.
Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285 
Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin)
593
[3] I. O. Rabiu, A. D. Usman, A. M. S. Tekanyi, “A Review on Computer Assisted Follicle Detection Techniques and
Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS) Diagnostic System,” International Journal of Computer Trends and
Technology (IJCTT), vol. 28, no. 1, October 2015.
[4] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Follicle detection and ovarian classification in digital ultrasound images of
ovaries,” Advancement and Breakthroughs in Ultrasound Imaging, chapter 7, pp. 168-199,June2013
[5] A. Krivanek and M. Sonka, “Ovarian ultrasound image analysis: follicle segmentation,” in IEEE Transactions on
Medical Imaging, vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 935-944, Dec. 1998.
[6] B. Potocnik and D. Zazula, “Automated analysis of a sequence of ovarian ultrasound images part I: segmentation of
single 2D image,” Image and Vision Computing, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 217-225, March 2002.
[7] R. T. Faghih, K. S. Aaron and E. N. Brown, “Automated ovarian follicular monitoring: a novel real-time
approach,” 2017 39th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society
(EMBC), Seogwipo, pp. 632-635, 2017.
[8] M. P. Aarti and B. S. Nidhi, “Comparative study on ovarian follicle detection using segmentation techniques,”
International Journal of Innovative Research in Computer and Communication Engineering, vol. 4, no. 9,
pp. 16683-16689, September 2016.
[9] Y. Deng, Y. Wang and Y. Shen, “An automated diagnostic system of polycystic ovary syndrome based on object
growing,” Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 199-209, November 2010.
[10] R. Sitheswaran and S. Malakhodi, “An effective automated system in follicle identification for polycystic ovary
syndrome using ultrasound image,” 2014 International Conference on Electronics and Communication Systems
(ICECS), Coimbatore, pp. 1-5, 2014.
[11] N. H. Mahmood, N. Zulkarnain, N. S. A. Zulkifli, “Ultrasound Liver Image Enhancement Using Watershed
Segmentation Method,” International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications (IJERA), vol. 2, no. 3,
pp. 691-694, 2012.
[12] M. J. Lawrence et al., “Computer assisted detection of polycysticovary morphology in ultrasound images,” Fourth
Canadian Conference on Computer and Robot Vision (CRV '07), Montreal, Que., pp. 105-112, 2007.
[13] Adiwijaya et al., “Follicle detection on the USG images to support determination of polycystic ovary syndrome,”
Journal of Physics: Conference Series, vol. 622, pp. 255-262, 2015.
[14] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Automatic detection of follicles in ultrasound images of ovaries using edge
based method,” in International Journal of Computer Applications, pp. 120 - 125, January 2010.
[15] S. S. Deshpande and A. Wakankar, “Automated detection of polycystic ovarian syndrome using follicle
recognition,” 2014 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Communications, Control and Computing
Technologies, Ramanathapuram, pp. 1341-1346, 2014.
[16] B. Purnama, U. N. Wisesty, Adiwijaya, F. Nhita, A. Gayatri and T. Mutiah, “A classification of polycystic ovary
syndrome based on follicle detection of ultrasound image,” 2015 3rd International Conference on Information and
Communication Technology (ICoICT), Nusa Dua, pp. 396-401, 2015.
[17] B. Padmapriya and T. Kesavamurthy, “Detection of follicles in polycystic ovarian syndromne in ultrasound images
using morphological operations,” Journal of Medical Imaging Health Informatics, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 240,
February 2016.
[18] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Automatic detection of follicles in ultrasound images of ovaries using active
contours method,” 2010 IEEE International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Computing Research,
pp. 286-291, 2010.
[19] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Fuzzy inference system for follicle detection in ultrasound images of ovaries,”
in Soft Computing, vol. 18, no. 7, pp. 1353-1362, July 2014.
[20] H. P. Kumar and S. Srinivasan, “Fast automatic segmentation of polycystic ovary in ultrasound images using
improved Chan-Vase with Split-Bregman optimization,” Journal of Medical Imaging and Health Informatics,
vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 57-62, February 2015.
[21] D. P. Lestari et al,. “Comparison of Three Segmentation Methods for Breast Ultrasound Images Based on Level Set
and Morphological Operations,” International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol.7,
no. 1, pp. 383-391, February 2017.
[22] D. L. Pham, C. Xu and J. L Prince, “Current Methods in Medical Image Segmentation,” Annual Reviews of
Biomedical Engineering, vol. 2, pp. 315-337, August 2000.
[23] P. Mehrotra et al., “Automated ovarian follicle recognition for polycystic ovary syndrome,” 2011 International
Conference on Image Information Processing, Shimla, pp. 1-4, 2011.
[24] S. Rihana, H. Mousallem, C. Skaf and C. Yaacoub, “Automated algorithm for ovarian cysts detection in
ultrasonogram,” 2013 2nd International Conference on Advances in Biomedical Engineering, Tripoli, 2013,
pp. 219-222, 2013.
[25] A. Raj, “Detection of cysts in ultrasonic images of ovary,” International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR),
vol. 2, no. 8, pp. 185-189, August 2013.
[26] J. Park et al., “Automatic Segmentation of Brachial Artery based on Fuzzy C-Means Pixel Clustering from
Ultrasound Images,” International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 8, no. 2,
pp. 638-643, April2017.
[27] V. Kiruthika and M.M. Ramya, “Automatic segmentation of ovarian follicle using K-means clustering,” 2014 Fifth
International Conference on Signal and Image Processing, Bangalore, India, pp. 137-141, 2014.
[28] H. Lee, D. H, Song and K. B. Kim, “Effective Computers-Assisted Automatic Cervical Vertebrae Extraction with
Rehabilitative Ultrasound Imaging by using K-Means Clustering,” International Journal of Electrical and
Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 6, no.6, pp. 2810-2817, December 2016.

More Related Content

What's hot

USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASE
USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASEUSING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASE
USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASEIJCSEIT Journal
 
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methods
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and MethodsPathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methods
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methodsimgcommcall
 
IRJET- Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET-  	  Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET-  	  Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET Journal
 
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...Wookjin Choi
 
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of Data
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of DataMachine Learning and Deep Contemplation of Data
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of DataJoel Saltz
 
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...IRJET Journal
 
University of Toronto - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017
University of Toronto  - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017University of Toronto  - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017
University of Toronto - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017Andre Dekker
 
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET Journal
 
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...ijcsit
 
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendation
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and RecommendationThyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendation
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendationijtsrd
 
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTION
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTIONAN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTION
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTIONijcsit
 
IRJET- Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...
IRJET-  	  Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...IRJET-  	  Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...
IRJET- Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...IRJET Journal
 
Artificial Intelligence in pathology
Artificial Intelligence in pathologyArtificial Intelligence in pathology
Artificial Intelligence in pathologynehaSingh1543
 
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumor
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain TumorAn Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumor
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumorijtsrd
 
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision Medicine
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision MedicineDigital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision Medicine
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision MedicineJoel Saltz
 
E-book Thesis Sara Carvalho
E-book Thesis  Sara CarvalhoE-book Thesis  Sara Carvalho
E-book Thesis Sara CarvalhoSara Carvalho
 
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detection
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detectionApplication of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detection
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detectioneSAT Publishing House
 
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classification
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor ClassificationDescription of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classification
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classificationasclepiuspdfs
 
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...IRJET Journal
 
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics Muhammad Alli
 

What's hot (20)

USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASE
USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASEUSING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASE
USING DATA MINING TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSIS AND PROGNOSIS OF CANCER DISEASE
 
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methods
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and MethodsPathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methods
Pathomics Based Biomarkers, Tools, and Methods
 
IRJET- Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET-  	  Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET-  	  Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Survey Paper on Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
 
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...
Radiomics: Novel Paradigm of Deep Learning for Clinical Decision Support towa...
 
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of Data
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of DataMachine Learning and Deep Contemplation of Data
Machine Learning and Deep Contemplation of Data
 
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...
IRJET- Comparison of Feature Selection Methods for Chronic Kidney Data Set us...
 
University of Toronto - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017
University of Toronto  - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017University of Toronto  - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017
University of Toronto - Radiomics for Oncology - 2017
 
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine LearningIRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
IRJET- Oral Cancer Detection using Machine Learning
 
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...
A MODIFIED BINARY PSO BASED FEATURE SELECTION FOR AUTOMATIC LESION DETECTION ...
 
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendation
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and RecommendationThyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendation
Thyroid Cancer Detection for Myanmar Review and Recommendation
 
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTION
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTIONAN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTION
AN EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT FEATURE SELECTION METHOD FOR LUNG CANCER DETECTION
 
IRJET- Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...
IRJET-  	  Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...IRJET-  	  Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...
IRJET- Effect of Principal Component Analysis in Lung Cancer Detection us...
 
Artificial Intelligence in pathology
Artificial Intelligence in pathologyArtificial Intelligence in pathology
Artificial Intelligence in pathology
 
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumor
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain TumorAn Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumor
An Enhanced Feature Selection Method to Predict the Severity in Brain Tumor
 
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision Medicine
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision MedicineDigital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision Medicine
Digital Pathology, FDA Approval and Precision Medicine
 
E-book Thesis Sara Carvalho
E-book Thesis  Sara CarvalhoE-book Thesis  Sara Carvalho
E-book Thesis Sara Carvalho
 
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detection
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detectionApplication of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detection
Application of genetic algorithm for liver cancer detection
 
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classification
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor ClassificationDescription of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classification
Description of Different Phases of Brain Tumor Classification
 
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...
A Review of Various Retinal Microaneurysm Detection Methods For Grading Of Di...
 
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics
Intra Report- St. James' Hospital Medical Physics
 

Similar to Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome

Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based improvised U-Net
Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based  improvised U-NetUltrasound image segmentation through deep learning based  improvised U-Net
Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based improvised U-Netnooriasukmaningtyas
 
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcare
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing HealthcareThe Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcare
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcaresana473753
 
journals on medical
journals on medicaljournals on medical
journals on medicalsana473753
 
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...TELKOMNIKA JOURNAL
 
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...theijes
 
IRJET - Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN Algorithm
IRJET -  	  Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN AlgorithmIRJET -  	  Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN Algorithm
IRJET - Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN AlgorithmIRJET Journal
 
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learning
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learningDiabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learning
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learningIRJET Journal
 
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network Classifier
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network ClassifierDetection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network Classifier
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network ClassifierIRJET Journal
 
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and optimized classifi...
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and  optimized classifi...Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and  optimized classifi...
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and optimized classifi...IJECEIAES
 
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...IRJET Journal
 
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep Learning
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep LearningSurvey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep Learning
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep LearningIRJET Journal
 
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...IJECEIAES
 
IRJET- Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...
IRJET-  	  Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...IRJET-  	  Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...
IRJET- Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...IRJET Journal
 
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A Review
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A ReviewBreast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A Review
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A ReviewIRJET Journal
 
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUE
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUEDIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUE
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUEIRJET Journal
 
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...IRJET Journal
 
Breast Cancer Prediction
Breast Cancer PredictionBreast Cancer Prediction
Breast Cancer PredictionIRJET Journal
 
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptx
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptxCancer tissue evaluation.pptx
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptxKerenEvangelineI
 
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...IRJET Journal
 

Similar to Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (20)

Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based improvised U-Net
Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based  improvised U-NetUltrasound image segmentation through deep learning based  improvised U-Net
Ultrasound image segmentation through deep learning based improvised U-Net
 
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcare
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing HealthcareThe Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcare
The Evolution and Impact of Medical Science Journals in Advancing Healthcare
 
journals on medical
journals on medicaljournals on medical
journals on medical
 
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...
Early detection of breast cancer using mammography images and software engine...
 
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...
Detection of Glaucoma using Optic Disk and Incremental Cup Segmentation from ...
 
IRJET - Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN Algorithm
IRJET -  	  Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN AlgorithmIRJET -  	  Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN Algorithm
IRJET - Lung Disease Prediction using Image Processing and CNN Algorithm
 
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learning
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learningDiabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learning
Diabetic Retinopathy detection using Machine learning
 
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network Classifier
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network ClassifierDetection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network Classifier
Detection of Kidney Stone using Neural Network Classifier
 
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and optimized classifi...
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and  optimized classifi...Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and  optimized classifi...
Breast cancer histological images nuclei segmentation and optimized classifi...
 
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...
An Innovative Deep Learning Framework Integrating Transfer- Learning And Extr...
 
Puplication-Assesssment of Vitritis On OCT-Journel TVST
Puplication-Assesssment of Vitritis On OCT-Journel TVSTPuplication-Assesssment of Vitritis On OCT-Journel TVST
Puplication-Assesssment of Vitritis On OCT-Journel TVST
 
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep Learning
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep LearningSurvey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep Learning
Survey on Automatic Kidney Lesion Detection using Deep Learning
 
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...
Optic Disc and Macula Localization from Retinal Optical Coherence Tomography ...
 
IRJET- Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...
IRJET-  	  Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...IRJET-  	  Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...
IRJET- Lung Cancer Detection using Digital Image Processing and Artificia...
 
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A Review
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A ReviewBreast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A Review
Breast Cancer Detection through Deep Learning: A Review
 
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUE
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUEDIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUE
DIABETIC RETINOPATHY DETECTION USING MACHINE LEARNING TECHNIQUE
 
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...
A Comprehensive Study on the Phases and Techniques of Breast Cancer Classific...
 
Breast Cancer Prediction
Breast Cancer PredictionBreast Cancer Prediction
Breast Cancer Prediction
 
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptx
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptxCancer tissue evaluation.pptx
Cancer tissue evaluation.pptx
 
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...
IRJET - Deep Multiple Instance Learning for Automatic Detection of Diabetic R...
 

More from journalBEEI

Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherSquare transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherjournalBEEI
 
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...journalBEEI
 
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...journalBEEI
 
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksA secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksjournalBEEI
 
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkPlant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkjournalBEEI
 
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...journalBEEI
 
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...journalBEEI
 
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...journalBEEI
 
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmWireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmjournalBEEI
 
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennaImplementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennajournalBEEI
 
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headThe calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headjournalBEEI
 
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...journalBEEI
 
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationDesign of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationjournalBEEI
 
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...journalBEEI
 
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)journalBEEI
 
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...journalBEEI
 
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...journalBEEI
 
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...journalBEEI
 
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationParking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationjournalBEEI
 
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...journalBEEI
 

More from journalBEEI (20)

Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipherSquare transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
Square transposition: an approach to the transposition process in block cipher
 
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
Hyper-parameter optimization of convolutional neural network based on particl...
 
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
Supervised machine learning based liver disease prediction approach with LASS...
 
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networksA secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
A secure and energy saving protocol for wireless sensor networks
 
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural networkPlant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
Plant leaf identification system using convolutional neural network
 
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
Customized moodle-based learning management system for socially disadvantaged...
 
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
Understanding the role of individual learner in adaptive and personalized e-l...
 
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
Prototype mobile contactless transaction system in traditional markets to sup...
 
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithmWireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
Wireless HART stack using multiprocessor technique with laxity algorithm
 
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antennaImplementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
Implementation of double-layer loaded on octagon microstrip yagi antenna
 
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human headThe calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
The calculation of the field of an antenna located near the human head
 
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
Exact secure outage probability performance of uplinkdownlink multiple access...
 
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting applicationDesign of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
Design of a dual-band antenna for energy harvesting application
 
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
Transforming data-centric eXtensible markup language into relational database...
 
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
Key performance requirement of future next wireless networks (6G)
 
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
Noise resistance territorial intensity-based optical flow using inverse confi...
 
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
Modeling climate phenomenon with software grids analysis and display system i...
 
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
An approach of re-organizing input dataset to enhance the quality of emotion ...
 
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentationParking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
Parking detection system using background subtraction and HSV color segmentation
 
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
Quality of service performances of video and voice transmission in universal ...
 

Recently uploaded

Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdf
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdfdata_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdf
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdfJiananWang21
 
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 BookingVIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Bookingdharasingh5698
 
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.ppt
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.pptnotes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.ppt
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.pptMsecMca
 
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Bookingroncy bisnoi
 
Intze Overhead Water Tank Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdf
Intze Overhead Water Tank  Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdfIntze Overhead Water Tank  Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdf
Intze Overhead Water Tank Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdfSuman Jyoti
 
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineering
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineeringchapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineering
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineeringmulugeta48
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)simmis5
 
AKTU Computer Networks notes --- Unit 3.pdf
AKTU Computer Networks notes ---  Unit 3.pdfAKTU Computer Networks notes ---  Unit 3.pdf
AKTU Computer Networks notes --- Unit 3.pdfankushspencer015
 
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01KreezheaRecto
 
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlyKubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlysanyuktamishra911
 
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.ppt
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.pptThermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.ppt
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.pptDineshKumar4165
 
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Bookingroncy bisnoi
 
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 BookingVIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Bookingdharasingh5698
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Budhwar Peth ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
 
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdf
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdfdata_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdf
data_management_and _data_science_cheat_sheet.pdf
 
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and RoutesRoadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
Roadmap to Membership of RICS - Pathways and Routes
 
Call Girls in Ramesh Nagar Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝9953056974 🔝 Escort Service
Call Girls in Ramesh Nagar Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝9953056974 🔝 Escort ServiceCall Girls in Ramesh Nagar Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝9953056974 🔝 Escort Service
Call Girls in Ramesh Nagar Delhi 💯 Call Us 🔝9953056974 🔝 Escort Service
 
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 BookingVIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Palanpur 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
 
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.ppt
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.pptnotes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.ppt
notes on Evolution Of Analytic Scalability.ppt
 
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Walvekar Nagar Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
Intze Overhead Water Tank Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdf
Intze Overhead Water Tank  Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdfIntze Overhead Water Tank  Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdf
Intze Overhead Water Tank Design by Working Stress - IS Method.pdf
 
Call Now ≽ 9953056974 ≼🔝 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar ≼🔝 Delhi door step de...
Call Now ≽ 9953056974 ≼🔝 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar  ≼🔝 Delhi door step de...Call Now ≽ 9953056974 ≼🔝 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar  ≼🔝 Delhi door step de...
Call Now ≽ 9953056974 ≼🔝 Call Girls In New Ashok Nagar ≼🔝 Delhi door step de...
 
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineering
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineeringchapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineering
chapter 5.pptx: drainage and irrigation engineering
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)
Java Programming :Event Handling(Types of Events)
 
AKTU Computer Networks notes --- Unit 3.pdf
AKTU Computer Networks notes ---  Unit 3.pdfAKTU Computer Networks notes ---  Unit 3.pdf
AKTU Computer Networks notes --- Unit 3.pdf
 
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01
Double rodded leveling 1 pdf activity 01
 
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghlyKubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
KubeKraft presentation @CloudNativeHooghly
 
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.ppt
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.pptThermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.ppt
Thermal Engineering -unit - III & IV.ppt
 
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Wakad Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
(INDIRA) Call Girl Bhosari Call Now 8617697112 Bhosari Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Bhosari Call Now 8617697112 Bhosari Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Bhosari Call Now 8617697112 Bhosari Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Bhosari Call Now 8617697112 Bhosari Escorts 24x7
 
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 BookingVIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
VIP Call Girls Ankleshwar 7001035870 Whatsapp Number, 24/07 Booking
 
NFPA 5000 2024 standard .
NFPA 5000 2024 standard                                  .NFPA 5000 2024 standard                                  .
NFPA 5000 2024 standard .
 

Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome

  • 1. Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020, pp. 588~593 ISSN: 2302-9285, DOI: 10.11591/eei.v9i2.2089  588 Journal homepage: http://beei.org Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome A. A. Nazarudin1, Noraishikin Zulkarnain2, A. Hussain3, S. S. Mokri4, I. N. A. M. Nordin5 1,2,3,4 Centre for Integrated Systems Engineering and Advanced Technologies (INTEGRA), Faculty of Built and Environment, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia 1,2,3,4 Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering, Faculty of Built and Environment, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia 5 Cybernetics Research Group, Faculty of Engineering Technology, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia, Malaysia Article Info ABSTRACT Article history: Received Sep 18, 2019 Revised Nov 21, 2019 Accepted Dec 28, 2019 Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS), is a condition of the ovary consisting numerous follicles. Accurate size and number of follicles detected are crucial for treatment. Hence the diagnosis of this condition is by measuring and calculating the size and number of follicles existed in the ovary. To diagnosis, ultrasound imaging has become an effective tool as it is non invasive, inexpensive and portable. However, the presence of speckle noise in ultrasound imaging has caused an obstruction for manual diagnosis which are high time consumption and often produce errors. Thus, image segmentation for ultrasound imaging is critical to identify follicles for PCOS diagnosis and proper health treatment. This paper presents different methods proposed and applied in automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis by previous researchers. In this paper, the methods and performance evaluation are identified and compared. Finally, this paper also provided suggestions in developing methods for future research. Keywords: Automated segmentation Follicle identification Image segmentation PCOS Polycystic ovarian syndrome This is an open access article under the CC BY-SA license. Corresponding Author: Noraishikin Zulkarnain, Department of Electrical, Electronic and Systems Engineering, Centre for Integrated Systems Engineering and Advanced Technologies (INTEGRA), Faculty of Built and Environment, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43200 UKM, Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. Email: shikinzulkarnain@ukm.edu.my 1. INTRODUCTION Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome, -or commonly known as PCOS is described as a condition of numerous primordial follicles in the ovary. This disorder is diagnosed by ultrasound imaging which gives important information on the ovarian follicle quantity and size. Ovarian follicles are spherical, fluid-filled structures in which oocytes (eggs) develop. In two dimensional ultrasound imaging, ovarian follicles appeared as dark, roughly circular regions. In PCOS, the condition is characterized as having 12 or more follicles in the ovary with the size of 2-9 mm and/or the volume of 10 cm3 [1]. The number and size of follicles in the ovary is vital in a healthy women’s reproductive system, especially those who are trying to conceive. Ultrasound imaging are non-invasive, portable and inexpensive. Therefore ovarian ultrasound imaging has become an effective tool in PCOS diagnosis and ovarian follicle identification. However, ultrasound imaging has poor quality of images which disturbed by speckle noise [2]. This disturbance are causing difficulties to recognize the ovarian follicles especially by medical practitioners with manual diagnosis. Manual diagnosis and identification is laborious, time consuming and often produce errors [3].
  • 2. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin) 589 Thus, many researchers have been working on developing an automated algorithm to identify ovarian follicles for PCOS diagnosis. In developing an automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis system, the follicles are the regions of interest (ROIs) in an ovarian ultrasound image, which need to be detected using image processing techniques. The basic image processing steps consist of pre-processing, segmentation, feature extraction and classification [4]. One of the crucial steps is segmentation, where this is to help identifying region of interest, namely the follicles. Hence the automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis systemis to identify the number and size of ovarian follicles using image segmentation. Among the earliest study of automated follicle identification using image processing are led by Krivanek et al. [5] in 1998 and Potocnik et al. [6] in 2002. In their research, Potocnik [6] highlighted the difficulties of recognising smaller follicles and distingushing adjacent follicles which has no expressive boundaries to each other. Later on, in 2017, Faghih et al. [7] raised the same issues while reviewing the literature for their studies. Based on previous studies, the smaller follicles or follicles that are adjacent to each other were neglected or unnoticed and some methods have the tendency of over-segmenting which will effect the treatment given. Based on previous comparative studies in automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis [2-3, 8], researchers concluded it is needed to develop algorithm in removing the speckle noise in the ultrasound image effectively and to investigate features extraction for classification of the ovary. Thus, this paper objective is to review previous methods of image segmentation in ultrasound image for automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis; the methods applied and the parameter for evaluation. To study the image segmentation methods applied by previous researchers, this paper applied snowball method. This method had focused on the literature regarding automated follicles identification in ovarian ultrasound images. Therefore, the review on different methods and performance evaluation will be presented. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: in section 2 describes the methods suggested by previous researchers. Later in section 3 is shown the table review for the methods of automated follicle identification with performance evaluation. In section 4 is the conclusion and future work suggestions. 2. IMAGE SEGMENTATION METHODS Medical practitioners have been using ovarian ultrasound images to diagnose PCOS condition. This is due to ultrasound is non-invasive and less time consuming. In ultrasound, the image of follicles in the ovaries will appear as roughly dark circles. The images of normal and polycystic ovary as shown in the Figures 1 and 2. From these images, medical practitioners will manually calculate the size and number of follicles existed. However, this approach is time consuming and often produce errors. Therefore, researchers have been developing and exploring an automated image segmentation for follicle identification to diagnose PCOS condition. Various research groups have devised different automated image segmentation techniques for follicle identification. Among the foremost groups are led by Krivanek et al. [5] in 1998 and Potocnik et al. in 2002 [6]. In image segmentation for automated follicle identification, researchers applied various methods with improvisations namely watershed transform, thresholding, region based growing, edge based, clustering, artificial neural network and mathematical morphology. This section presents an overview of researches on automated follicle identification techniques. Figure 1. Normal ovary [8] Figure 2. Polycystic ovary [8] 2.1. Watershed transform Krivanek and Sonka [5] introduced a multistep automated segmentation employing watershed segmentation and graph search method to determine the inner border of the follicles. In the application of this
  • 3.  ISSN: 2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020 : 588 – 593 590 method, minimal manual segmentation by medical practitioner was involved. The evaluation of this technique was by comparing the maximum and root mean square (RMS) borders positioning between computer-determined and observer-defined. It was shown that the RMS for computer-determined is more accurate. In 2011, Deng et al. [9] proposed an enhanced watershed algorithm, namely labeled watershed algortihm for local minima extraction because the classic watershed algorithm often leads to excessive segmentation and needs minimal medical practitioner interaction. The labeled watershed algoritm was applied after adaptive morphological filtering of image. In the research for a novel real-time follicle identification, [7] Faghih et al. applied watershed algorithm for the condition if there is a possibility of multiple follicles existed in the region of interest of a very dark image with high percentage of dark pixels. This algorithm was introduced to minimize the faulty in ignoring the follicles which are adjacent to each other or too small for segmentation. Some researchers applied watershed segmentation method as image enhancement, in the pre-processing stage of image processing,for ultrasound image [10-11]. 2.2. Region growing method Potocnik et al. in 2002 [6], proposed region growing method by making the homogenous region of interest grow until they clash with the object’s boundary. The recognition rate of this method was around 78%. However, they concluded this method had the difficulties in detecting smaller follicles due to their brightness and poorly perceivable. This method was modified with two additional criteria to merge with region of interest [12]. Lawrence [12] highlighted, although the modified method is known as a better follicle recognition rate, it is lacking in robustness. They suggested for deploying a more robust automated follicle identification in the future. In 2011, Deng et al. [9] constructed a cost map for the region growing method and assigned a cost function to the cost map for follicle identification. This method is more effective than the two mentioned above and achieved higher rate of follicle identification. By utilizing spatial connectivity of follicles and the contour of ovary, Sitheswaran et al. [10] constructed cost map depending one the pixel’s relative location for region growing algorithm. The recognition rate was the same as Deng et al. In 2015, Adiwijaya applied region growing method where aims to compare both the identified seed and homogeneous region to enlarge its region for reaching the real follicle limits [13]. However this method limited to ultrasound image with homogeneity, where as most ovarian ultrasound images are inhomogeneous. 2.3. Edge based method Edge based method for image segmentation falls into two categories: gradient based method and soft computing approach [2]. In this section, the category of edge based method widely found on literature is the gradient based method. Researchers applied the gradient based method with Canny operator [14-17]. There are few others operators for edge based method in segmentation such as Sobel, Prewitt but based on the review, it is found that most researcher applied Canny operator for edge based method as Canny operator gave the most satisfying result [14]. Hiremath et al. [14] compared edge based method segmentation with manual segmentation done by medical practitioner. It was shown that the increase of false acceptance rate and false rejection rate of the proposed method is lower than the manual segmentation. Thus the proposed method was more efficient. Considering follicles are in circular shape with areas about 4-80 mm2 for PCOS ovarian follicle and about 314 mm2 for normal ovarian follicle, threshold values for area of each region of interest is calculated and number of important follicles identified is found out [15]. 2.4. Active contour method Among the commonly applied method for image segmentation for ovarian ultrasound image is active contour without edge based. In segmentation stage, Hiremath and Tegnoor [18] applied this method for ovarian ultrasound image segmentation to detect the follicles existed. The average of the proposed method was 96.66% with 3.33% false rejection rate. Later they applied this method while introducing fuzzy logic inference for ovary classification [19]. In 2015, Kumar and Srinivasan [20] improved this method by improvising the Chan-Vase method and combining with Split Bregman optimization to help with identifying small follicles of less than 2mm diameter. The average computational time for the proposed method is 24.15 seconds. In 2017, Lestari [21] applied morphological operation to the Chan-Vase model to remove imperfections that appeared during segmentation and achieved a better result. Meanwhile, Faghih [8] applied active contour method for the condition where the percentage of the very dark pixels in a compressed image is very low to create a new binary mask before morphological processing.
  • 4. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin) 591 2.5. Thresholding method In this method, it attempts to determine an intensity value, called the threshold, of the image by creating binary partitioning of the image intensities. The segmentation is achieved by grouping the pixels with greater intensities of the threshold into one class[22]. The pixels darker than their surrounding were scanned row wise (horizontal scanning) and column wise (vertical scanning) [23]. Then the resulted image is fused to get the dark follicle in the white background. Mehrotra [23] applied this method and in their research the difference in the error rate is less compared to manual segmentation. Meanwhile Rihana [24] achieved a promising result of 90% accurancy for this method. 2.6. Clustering method Clustering method to group the pixels based on similarity. In image segmentation of ovarian ultrasound for PCOS, two different clustering algorithms were applied by researchers. Fuzzy c-means clustering was applied for the segmentation of follicles from the ovarian ultrasound images. This method’s performance was calculated using means square error (MSE). The lesser the MSE, the better the efficiency of the method [25]. Park [26] proposed fuzzy c-means clustering as an alternative for image segmentation of brachial ultrasound image. Another clustering algorithm is K-Means clustering algorithm [27]. For this algorithm, authors evaluated structural similarity, false acceptance rate and false rejection rate to show its efficiency. In 2016, Lee applied K-Means clustering algorithm to detect cervical vertebrae with ultrasound image and achieved a success percentage of96% accurancy [28]. 3. REVIEW TABLE In this section, the table for image segmentation techniques applied for follicle identification in PCOS diagnosis by previous researchers and the performance evaluation for each research based on section 2 is presented. Table 1 shows the list of papers which studied the automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis. In the table, the techniques applied and performance evaluation were explained briefly. Each of the method applied required different parameters of evaluation. From the table, it shows that recognition rate and acceptance rate are among the significantly used parameter for accurancy evaluation of automated follicle identification. The higher the recognition rate and acceptance rate indicates the higher the accurancy of the algorithm applied. By far, the highest recognition rate in automated follicle identification is done by Padmapriya [13] in 2016 with recognition rate of 87.5% using morphological operation with edge based method using Canny operator. However, in their study, the size of the ovarian follicles was not involved. Based on PCOS definition, the number and size of ovarian follicles existed are one of the determining factors of the syndrome. Hence, the method proposed by Padmapriya is only applicable for cystic ovarian case and further study needed to be done for this method on PCOS condition. Table 1. Technique and performance evaluation of image segmentation in ultrasound images Ref. Author, Year Paper Title Technique Performance Evaluation [6] Krivanek,Sonka, 1998 Ovarian ultrasoundimage analysis: follicle segmentation Watershed transform Root-mean-square borderpositioningerror andmaximum value decrease indicates the proposedmethodis more accurate. [7] Potocnik, Zazula, 2002 Automatedanalysis of a sequencingof ovarian ultrasoundimages. Part I: segmentationofsingle 2D images Region growing method Recognitionrate (RR) offollicles is 78% andmisidentificationrate (MR)is 29%. [12] Lawrence, 2007 Computer assisted detectionof polycystic ovary morphology in ultrasoundimages Modifiedregion growingmethod Recognitionrate offollicles (RR) is 83.1% andmisidentificationrate (MR)is 31.1%. [9] Deng, 2011 An automateddiagnostic system of polycysticovarysyndrome based on object background Cost map, region growingmethod, cost function Increase value of tuningparameterbeta indicates high recognitionrate, misidentificationrate. [10] Sitheswaran, Malarkhodi, 2014 An effective automatedsystem in follicle identification for polycystic ovary syndrome using ultrasoundimages Cost map dependingon pixel’s relative location, region growingmethod Tuningparameterbeta (β) value increase showedincrease in recognitionrate (RR) andmisidentificationrate (MR). F1 score is desireable when tuningparameteris 6 with RR 84.04%andMR 5.9% [13] Adiwijaya, 2015 Follicle detectionon theUSG images to support determination of polycysticovarysyndrome Region growing (region basedand seed based) Average success of recognition rate80% when the empirical value for region based is 1 while for seedbased the recognition rate is 79.86% when thresval value is 0.005.
  • 5.  ISSN: 2302-9285 Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf, Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2020 : 588 – 593 592 Ref. Author, Year Paper Title Technique Performance Evaluation [14] Hiremath, Tegnoor, 2010 Automatic detection offollicles in ultrasoundimages of ovaries using edge based method Edge based method(Canny operator) False acceptance rate (FAR)andfalse rejectionrate (FRR) showincrease in efficiency theaccurancyof the proposed method. [18] Padmapriya, 2016 Detectionof follicles in poly cystic ovariansyndrome in ultrasoundimages usingmorphological operations Morphological operationwith edge based method(Canny operator) The average recognitionrate for all the images processedby the proposedmethod is87.5% [16] Hiremath, Tegnoor2010 Follicle detectionin ultrasound images of ovaries usingactive contour method Active contour without edge based Lesser false rejection rateandfalse acceptance ratein proposedmethod indicates the accurancy offollicle identificationincreased. [17] Kumar, Srinivasan 2015 Fast automatic segmentationof polycystic ovary in ultrasound images using improvisedchan- vase methodwith split-bregman optimization ImprovisedChan- Vase with Split Bregman optimization Average computational timeis 24.15 seconds. Dice coefficient is 0.8772. [23] Mehrotra,2011 Automatedovarianfollicle recognition for polycysticovary syndrome Scanline thresholding Difference in theerrorrate is lesser indicates the effectiveness of theproposed method. [24] Rihana, 2013 Automatedalgortihm for ovarian cysts detection in ultrasonogram Scanline thresholding Foundaccurancy of 90% as a promising result with 88.33% sensitivityand95% specificity. [25] Raj, 2013 Detectionof cysts in ultrasonic images of ovary C-Means Clustering Lesser mean square error (MSE) in peak signal to noise radio (PSNR). [27] Kiruthika, Ramya 2014 Automatic segmentation of ovarian follicle usingk-means clustering K-Means Clustering Structural similarity (SSIM) increase indicates the propose methodis more efficient andaccurate. 4. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK Polycystic ovarian syndrome most commonly diagnosed by ultrasound by medical practitioners as it is inexpensive and non-invasive. In PCOS diagnosis it is important to know the size and number of ovarian follicles that portray the characteristic of this syndrome for medical practitioner to administrate the correct treatment. Manual follicle identification in ultrasound image have the flaws of time consuming and often produce errors. Due to that reason, automated follicle identification methods have been explored by many researchers and still being develop for better diagnosis in the future. This review paper has surveyed image segmentation techniques and algorithmproposed by many researches. Automated follicle identification eases the laborious work faced by medical practitioners. Various forms of image processing techniques have been applied for automated follicle identification for PCOS diagnosis. While reviewing the literature, some researchers highlighted the condition of small follicles or adjacent follicles were neglected or unnoticed. This condition can seriously affects the treatment given and health condition of the patient. Other than that, each of the method applied does not apply the same pre-processing filtering algorithm to remove the speckle noise. This has led to different parameter of evaluation. Thus, in the future, further research is needed to develop the method to remove the speckle noise in the ultrasound images effectively and explore available methods for ovarian ultrasound images in identifying follicles, including the smaller follicles and that are adjacent to each other. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to sincerely thank to Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia for the support and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) for the facilities and equipment provided for this research. This work is fully supported by Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia under FRGS research Grant (Vote no. FRGS/1/2018/TK04/UKM/02/15) and research university Grant (Vote no. GGPM-2017-087). REFERENCES [1] S. Jonard et al., “Ultrasound examination of polycystic ovaries: is it worth counting the follicles?,” Human Reproduction, vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 598-603, 2003. [2] R. Saranya and S. U. Maheswari, “A Literature Review on Computer Assisted Detection of Follicles in Ultrasound Images of Ovary,” International Journal of Computer Applications, vol. 48, no. 12, pp. 39-40, June 2012.
  • 6. Bulletin of Electr Eng & Inf ISSN: 2302-9285  Review on automated follicle identification for polycystic ovarian syndrome (A. A. Nazarudin) 593 [3] I. O. Rabiu, A. D. Usman, A. M. S. Tekanyi, “A Review on Computer Assisted Follicle Detection Techniques and Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS) Diagnostic System,” International Journal of Computer Trends and Technology (IJCTT), vol. 28, no. 1, October 2015. [4] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Follicle detection and ovarian classification in digital ultrasound images of ovaries,” Advancement and Breakthroughs in Ultrasound Imaging, chapter 7, pp. 168-199,June2013 [5] A. Krivanek and M. Sonka, “Ovarian ultrasound image analysis: follicle segmentation,” in IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 935-944, Dec. 1998. [6] B. Potocnik and D. Zazula, “Automated analysis of a sequence of ovarian ultrasound images part I: segmentation of single 2D image,” Image and Vision Computing, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 217-225, March 2002. [7] R. T. Faghih, K. S. Aaron and E. N. Brown, “Automated ovarian follicular monitoring: a novel real-time approach,” 2017 39th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC), Seogwipo, pp. 632-635, 2017. [8] M. P. Aarti and B. S. Nidhi, “Comparative study on ovarian follicle detection using segmentation techniques,” International Journal of Innovative Research in Computer and Communication Engineering, vol. 4, no. 9, pp. 16683-16689, September 2016. [9] Y. Deng, Y. Wang and Y. Shen, “An automated diagnostic system of polycystic ovary syndrome based on object growing,” Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 199-209, November 2010. [10] R. Sitheswaran and S. Malakhodi, “An effective automated system in follicle identification for polycystic ovary syndrome using ultrasound image,” 2014 International Conference on Electronics and Communication Systems (ICECS), Coimbatore, pp. 1-5, 2014. [11] N. H. Mahmood, N. Zulkarnain, N. S. A. Zulkifli, “Ultrasound Liver Image Enhancement Using Watershed Segmentation Method,” International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications (IJERA), vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 691-694, 2012. [12] M. J. Lawrence et al., “Computer assisted detection of polycysticovary morphology in ultrasound images,” Fourth Canadian Conference on Computer and Robot Vision (CRV '07), Montreal, Que., pp. 105-112, 2007. [13] Adiwijaya et al., “Follicle detection on the USG images to support determination of polycystic ovary syndrome,” Journal of Physics: Conference Series, vol. 622, pp. 255-262, 2015. [14] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Automatic detection of follicles in ultrasound images of ovaries using edge based method,” in International Journal of Computer Applications, pp. 120 - 125, January 2010. [15] S. S. Deshpande and A. Wakankar, “Automated detection of polycystic ovarian syndrome using follicle recognition,” 2014 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Communications, Control and Computing Technologies, Ramanathapuram, pp. 1341-1346, 2014. [16] B. Purnama, U. N. Wisesty, Adiwijaya, F. Nhita, A. Gayatri and T. Mutiah, “A classification of polycystic ovary syndrome based on follicle detection of ultrasound image,” 2015 3rd International Conference on Information and Communication Technology (ICoICT), Nusa Dua, pp. 396-401, 2015. [17] B. Padmapriya and T. Kesavamurthy, “Detection of follicles in polycystic ovarian syndromne in ultrasound images using morphological operations,” Journal of Medical Imaging Health Informatics, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 240, February 2016. [18] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Automatic detection of follicles in ultrasound images of ovaries using active contours method,” 2010 IEEE International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Computing Research, pp. 286-291, 2010. [19] P. S. Hiremath and J. R. Tegnoor, “Fuzzy inference system for follicle detection in ultrasound images of ovaries,” in Soft Computing, vol. 18, no. 7, pp. 1353-1362, July 2014. [20] H. P. Kumar and S. Srinivasan, “Fast automatic segmentation of polycystic ovary in ultrasound images using improved Chan-Vase with Split-Bregman optimization,” Journal of Medical Imaging and Health Informatics, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 57-62, February 2015. [21] D. P. Lestari et al,. “Comparison of Three Segmentation Methods for Breast Ultrasound Images Based on Level Set and Morphological Operations,” International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol.7, no. 1, pp. 383-391, February 2017. [22] D. L. Pham, C. Xu and J. L Prince, “Current Methods in Medical Image Segmentation,” Annual Reviews of Biomedical Engineering, vol. 2, pp. 315-337, August 2000. [23] P. Mehrotra et al., “Automated ovarian follicle recognition for polycystic ovary syndrome,” 2011 International Conference on Image Information Processing, Shimla, pp. 1-4, 2011. [24] S. Rihana, H. Mousallem, C. Skaf and C. Yaacoub, “Automated algorithm for ovarian cysts detection in ultrasonogram,” 2013 2nd International Conference on Advances in Biomedical Engineering, Tripoli, 2013, pp. 219-222, 2013. [25] A. Raj, “Detection of cysts in ultrasonic images of ovary,” International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), vol. 2, no. 8, pp. 185-189, August 2013. [26] J. Park et al., “Automatic Segmentation of Brachial Artery based on Fuzzy C-Means Pixel Clustering from Ultrasound Images,” International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 638-643, April2017. [27] V. Kiruthika and M.M. Ramya, “Automatic segmentation of ovarian follicle using K-means clustering,” 2014 Fifth International Conference on Signal and Image Processing, Bangalore, India, pp. 137-141, 2014. [28] H. Lee, D. H, Song and K. B. Kim, “Effective Computers-Assisted Automatic Cervical Vertebrae Extraction with Rehabilitative Ultrasound Imaging by using K-Means Clustering,” International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), vol. 6, no.6, pp. 2810-2817, December 2016.